Short Stuff: Third Man Syndrome

Summary

Stuff You Should Know: Short Stuff – Third Man Syndrome

Podcast: Stuff You Should Know (iHeartPodcasts)
Episode Date: November 12, 2025
Hosts: Josh & Chuck

---

Episode Overview

This “Short Stuff” episode dives into Third Man Syndrome—an eerie yet often comforting phenomenon reported in life-or-death situations, where individuals perceive the presence of someone guiding or urging them onward. Through historical accounts, literature, and personal anecdotes, Josh and Chuck explore the roots, possible explanations, and recurring patterns of this mysterious survival experience.

---

Key Discussion Points & Insights

1. Defining Third Man Syndrome

• [01:26] Josh: Introduces Third Man Syndrome as a “weird phenomenon,” popularized by author John Geiger (who prefers the term “Third Man Factor”).
• [01:51] Chuck: Clarifies that it’s not related to the movie The Third Man and suggests it should more accurately be called “third person syndrome,” as the perceived presence is not always male or a literal third.
• Typically occurs “when someone is in dire straits”—often mountaineers or those in isolation and extreme stress—who suddenly sense a presence urging them on.
• Tangible feeling: Not just a fleeting thought, but an “absolutely real” sense of someone alongside them, sometimes even as vivid as actually seeing or hearing another person.

---

2. Historical Foundation: Ernest Shackleton’s Account

• [02:51] Josh: Credits Ernest Shackleton as the first to document experiencing the phenomenon during his 1914-15 Antarctic expedition.
• [03:24–05:40] Chuck & Josh:
  • Recounts Shackleton’s harrowing ordeal—ship crushed by ice, stranded for months, and then epic escape attempts via boat and foot.
  • During the “last push” over land to the South Georgia whaling station, Shackleton and his two companions all felt a mysterious fourth presence guiding and comforting them.
• [05:40] Josh: All three agreed they sensed “another person, in this case a fourth,” with them.

---

3. Cultural Impact: T.S. Eliot and The Wasteland

• [06:38] Josh & Chuck: T.S. Eliot’s 1922 poem The Wasteland draws from Shackleton’s story, contributing the iconic “third man” wording—despite the original being a fourth person.
  • Quote [07:00] Josh (reading Eliot):

    “Who is the third who walks always beside you? When I count, there are only you and I together. But when I look ahead up the white road, there is always another one walking beside you… I do not know whether a man or a woman, but who is that on the other side of you? Answer me.”

• T.S. Eliot admitted not remembering which expedition inspired him, nor the exact count of people involved.

---

4. Famous Modern Cases

Compiled by John Geiger in The Third Man Factor (2008)

• [09:53] Josh:

  • Frank Smythe (1933, Everest): So convinced of an unseen companion, he attempted to share a piece of cake with his “second man.”
  • Joe Simpson (1985, Peruvian Andes): After breaking his leg, wrote in Touching the Void that a voice instructed and guided him to safety.
  • Not just mountaineers—Third Man Syndrome also appears in non-cold, urban situations.
  • 9/11 Survivors:
    • Ron DeFrancesco: Last person out of the South Tower, attributed his escape to being guided by a presence through flames to safety.
    • Janelle Guzman McMillan: Trapped in rubble, felt a companion named “Paul” with her.

• Chuck [12:13]: Sometimes the presence is familiar—like a geologist who, lost during a cave dive, was guided back by the felt presence of her recently deceased husband.

---

5. Nature of the Presence

• [10:29] Josh: The “third man” is generally supportive, not frightening—in contrast to horror tropes.
• [11:21] Josh & Chuck: The sense is often specific—sometimes giving directions or instructions critical to survival.
  • Chuck: “After reading all this stuff, I would be wise to go in whatever direction your invisible person is telling you to go.”
  • Josh: “Obey the voice, I think is the upshot of all this.”

---

6. Who (or What) Is the Third Man?

• “Guardian angels,” lost loved ones, or unnamed entities—interpretations vary by victim.
• [12:57] Chuck & Josh: Some even assign names; Josh suggests “Tim” if you need one on the spot.

---

7. Scientific Theories & The Bicameral Mind

• [13:00–14:46] Chuck & Josh:
  • No definitive explanation; perhaps an innate, hardwired survival mechanism activated in extreme duress.
  • Reference to Julian Jaynes’ “bicameral mind” theory: ancient people interpreted their own inner dialogue as gods’ voices—a possible root for Third Man experiences.
  • Josh: The syndrome may be a “vestigial, bicameral experience” where a part of our mind, under stress, operates as a separate guiding voice.

---

8. Final Thoughts

• [14:59] Chuck: Hopes the urge to survive with support is “within all of us.”
• [15:05] Josh: “Hopefully no one listening ever has to experience it because it sounds like it’s pretty rough to get there.”
• [15:11] Chuck: Agreed.

---

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

• Chuck [02:06]: “When they’re at their sort of worst, low point, they get a sense that someone else is there... urging them on. But it’s not just like, ‘Oh, I got this weird feeling.’ Like, it’s a real serious, tangible thing.”
• Josh [03:59]: “They rode for six days before they reached Elephant Island... the closest place where there’s other people... is a whaling station on South Georgia Island, and that’s 800 miles away.”
• Josh [07:00]:

  “Who is the third who walks always beside you? ...there is always another one walking beside you... I do not know whether a man or a woman, but who is that on the other side of you? Answer me.”

• Chuck [10:51]: “...in a comforting way. Not like, well, I was going to spoil that Nicole Kidman movie, but I guess I won’t do that, right? Not in a horror movie kind of way.”
• Josh [11:21]: “Obey the voice, I think is the upshot of all this.”
• Josh [14:46]: “This idea is the Third Man Syndrome is kind of this vestigial, bicameral experience... where what seems like something outside of your mind is helping you, urging you on, guiding you. But really it’s just another part of your mind that gets kicked in.”
• Chuck [14:59]: “Hopefully this instinct is within all of us, because I wouldn’t mind a pal urging me on in the end.”
• Josh [15:05]: “But hopefully no one listening ever has to experience it because it sounds like it’s pretty rough to get there.”

---

Important Timestamps

• 01:26: Defining Third Man Syndrome; how the feeling manifests.
• 02:51–05:40: Ernest Shackleton’s Antarctic ordeal and the original account.
• 06:38–07:40: T.S. Eliot’s The Wasteland and the phrase’s cultural impact.
• 09:53–12:45: Other famous cases, including mountaineers and 9/11 survivors.
• 13:00–14:46: Speculation about psychological and evolutionary explanations.
• 14:59–15:12: Reflective close and final thoughts.

---

Takeaway

Third Man Syndrome is a rare, poorly understood, and oddly comforting human experience at the extreme limits of survival. Drawing on both history and science, Josh and Chuck invite listeners to ponder both the mysterious resilience of the mind and the (hopefully never needed) possibility of finding help from within when all hope seems lost.

Transcript

[Chuck]

This is an iHeart podcast.

[Josh]

And now Superhuman Shack.

[Superhuman Shack]

I keep telling them not to say that. I'm no superhuman. Believe it or not, I struggle with moderate obstructive sleep apnea, or osa in adults with obesity. Moderate to severe OSA is a condition where breathing is interrupted during sleep with loud snoring, choking, gasping for air, and even daytime fatigue. Let's just say it can sound a lot like this. Sound familiar? Learn more at don't sleep on OSA.com.

[Josh]

This information is provided by Lilly, a medicine company.

[Chuck]

Want Black Friday prices without the crowds? Lowes gets it. Shop their early Black Friday deals and beat the rush. $99 is all you need to grab a select 7 foot pre lit artificial Christmas tree for the holidays. And don't sweat what gifts to get dad. They have up to 40% off select tools and accessories going on now that. That's how Lowe's celebrates Black Friday. Early selection varies by location, while supplies last.

[Josh]

Hey, and welcome to the shortstop. I'm Josh and there's Chuck. And it's just us right now, but that's okay because we have a third and fourth man with us today in the form of Jerry and Dave.

[Chuck]

That's right. I feel. I sense their presence.

[Josh]

I do, too. And they're guiding us on. They're saying, come on, you guys, you can finish the short stuff. It's going to be a good one. I can feel it.

[Chuck]

Chuck, I think we're going to be okay.

[Josh]

We just demonstrated a really weird phenomenon pretty well, if you ask me. I think we did a great job just now, everyone saying so. But we, we just demonstrated this weird phenomenon called the third man syndrome. There's an author named John Geiger who for some reason changed syndrome to factor. But that's typically what it's called as third man syndrome. And like I said, it's weird. Chuck, take it away.

[Chuck]

Yeah, it has nothing to do with the movie the Third man, which was good, great movie. And immediately when you sent this along and I saw the title, I thought it might have something to do with that. And it doesn't have to be a man. It really should be the third person syndrome.

[Josh]

Sure.

[Chuck]

But it is this phenomenon that has been talked about by many people over hundreds of years where someone is in dire straits. Oftentimes it's like somebody sort of like a mountaineer or somebody in the wilderness that's lost and struggling to survive, but not always as we'll see. And when they're at their sort of worst moment, maybe worst low point, they get a Third, a sense that someone else is there. And again, it's not always the third person if they're alone. It's just technically the second person.

[Josh]

Sure.

[Chuck]

But it's just somebody there kind of urging them on. But it's not just like, oh, I got this weird feeling. Like it's a real serious, tangible thing.

[Josh]

Yeah. Like whatever sense you have when there's somebody sitting next to you and they actually are, there is a person sitting next to you. It seems to be the exact same type of feeling and level of feeling and all that. Yeah. It's not like this weird kind of, like, thought a little bit here there. It's like sensing another presence. And the first person to ever really kind of document this was Ernest Shackleton. Surely he was not the first person to experience this, but he was the first person to write about it. And his experience is just nuts in and of itself.

[Chuck]

Yeah, we talked about this guy before. It was a British expedition to Antarctica in 1914. Fifteen, trying to get to the South Pole. It was his third try, and he's trying to establish a base there. And his ship got trapped in sea ice. They tried to kind of ride it out, but eventually the ice kind of came together. And, I mean, this just shows how forceful, like, creeping ice can be. It kind of crushed the boat. And they abandoned ship, set up camp on other ice and stayed there, initially for four months. On this ice.

[Josh]

Yeah. Waiting for the ice to break up enough to try to make an attempt by whaling boat over to Elephant island, which is the closest island. And they made it. They rode for six days before they reached Elephant island, which was great. They weren't on the ice anymore, but they were on a deserted island. And again, probably cold. Yeah, I'm thinking it's pretty cold, too. Yeah. And again, this is 1914. They're not, like, you know, picking up the sat phone and saying, like, hey, can somebody come get us? Like, they've got a real problem here. So they're stranded on this deserted island, and the closest place where there's other people, where they actually can get in touch and say, hey, somebody come get us. Is a whaling station on South Georgia island, and that's 800 miles away. So Ernest Shackleton says, gotta keep going. Whittles down to a few men, I think six, five or six other people. And they actually rode 800 miles from Antarctica to South Georgia Island.

[Chuck]

Yeah. So they get there 16 days later. It turns out they landed on the wrong side of the island because the winds blew them off course. And so this Guy was undaunted. Still, he took two guys. I think you see where this is headed, even though the math is still wrong. And they made the rest of the way on foot. It's about 18 miles or 30 kilometers, and through some pretty treacherous conditions. Took about 36 hours. They finally get there, and everyone ends up being rescued. Like, that's the good news. But this is. That last push is when Shackleton feels the presence of this additional person urging them on.

[Josh]

Yeah. Cause this is like they've reached the limit of their endurance and they're still going on. And so Shackleton sensed it, but he never said anything about it until he wrote his book, South. It was published in 1919. But he did say something to the other two people who were with him. One was Captain Worsley. And Worsley said, yeah, I had the same feeling, actually. And so did Crean, the other guy on this expedition. They all sensed another person, in this case a fourth person, with them, kind of basically comforting them to some. To some degree. So that seemed, in and of itself, pretty cool. And I guess the word of this got out because T.S. eliot, he's frequently cited as the person who coined the term Third Man Syndrome. As far as I can tell, no one knows who actually took this T.S. eliot poem and turned it into Third Man Syndrome, but it actually did come indisputably from this T.S. eliot poem from 1922.

[Chuck]

Yeah. So. Well, the Wasteland was the poem. And again, he was wrong on the math. He should have called it the Fourth Man. But this is kind of the funniest part. T.S. eliot said that he couldn't remember who. Who inspired this, like, which expedition it was. When asked, you know, why the number of people was four and not three or three and not four, rather.

[Josh]

Exactly. And I'm feeling a little poetic today, Chuck, do you mind if I read this little excerpt? This is from T.S. eliot's the Wasteland. Three words. Who is the third? Who walks always beside you? When I count, there are only you and I together. But when I look ahead up the white road, there is always another one walking beside you, gliding, wrapped in a brown mantle, hooded. I do not know whether a man or a woman, but who is that on the other side of you? Answer me. Thank you. Thank you. I say we take a break and let everybody in stunned silence. Absorb all that.

[Chuck]

All right, we'll be right back.

[Superhuman Shack]

Foreign.

[Chuck]

Support for the show Today comes from public.com. you're thoughtful about where your money goes. You've got core holdings, some recurring crypto buys, maybe even a few strategic options plays on the side. The point is you're engaged with your investments and Public gets that.

[Josh]

Yeah, that's why they built an investing platform for those who take it seriously. On public you can put together a multi asset portfolio for the long haul. Stocks, bonds, options, crypto. It's all there plus an industry leading 3.6% APY high yield cash account.

[Chuck]

Switch to the platform built for those who take investing seriously. Go to public.comsysk and earn an uncapped 1% bonus when you transfer your portfolio. That's public.comsysk paid for by Public Investing. All investing involves risk of loss, including loss of principal. Brokerage services for U.S. listed registered securities options and bonds in a self directed account are offered by Public Investing Inc. Member FINRA and SIPC. Crypto trading provided by Zerohash Complete disclosures [e-mail] Disclosures.

[Josh]

And now superhuman Shack I.

[Superhuman Shack]

Keep telling them not to say that. I'm no superhuman. Believe it or not, I struggle with moderate obstructive sleep apnea or OSA in adults with obesity. Moderate to severe OSA is a condition where breathing is interrupted during sleep, with loud snoring, choking, gasping for air, and even daytime fatigue. Let's just say it can sound a lot like this. Sound familiar? Learn more@don'tsleeponosa.com this information is provided by.

[Josh]

Lilly, a medicine company.

[Chuck]

All right, so that's the third man syndrome, Shackleton's version. But it's happened a bunch. Like we said, there was a collection by John Geiger called the third man factor that you mentioned earlier from 2008 where he dug up a bunch of these stories and we're gonna go through some of them right now.

[Josh]

Yeah, I mean, it's quite a feat that he got all these together because they were definitely few and far between. One of the first ones that he mentions is a guy named Frank Smythe who made a solo attempt at his summit Everest. He would have been the first back in 1933, and he got close, but he didn't make it and he realized he had to turn back. And his second man during this attempt was so real to him that at one point he actually turned to offer them food before he realized that there was no one there. So, like, this can be a pretty tangible presence. A tangible intangible presence, essentially.

[Chuck]

Yeah. I mean, I've seen this in movies, you know, and they don't call it out as, you know, third man syndrome, but I've definitely seen these scenes, you know, where there's an unseen person, and they look and then they're not there, you know? Yeah, it's pretty good, but in a comforting way. Not like, well, I was going to spoil that Nicole Kidman movie, but I guess I won't do that, right? Not in a horror movie kind of way.

[Josh]

No.

[Chuck]

For sure. But there was another guy, a climber again, named Joe Simpson. This is 1985. He was climbing in the Peruvian Andes, and he broke his leg. So he was in really bad shape. And he wrote a book called Touching the Void where he talked about obeying this voice, like, guiding him. And a lot of times that's what happens. It's not just like, you can do it, you can do it, but, like, go this way kind of thing. And if you're in this situation, after reading all this stuff, I would be wise to go in whatever direction your invisible person is telling you to go.

[Josh]

Yeah. Obey the voice, I think is the upshot of all this. Yeah. He was guided to safety by his voice. And enough of these are mountaineers that I started to think, maybe the cold has something to do with this. But this has also happened to other people who were not in the cult, who were in totally different situations. Very famously, out of the 911 attacks, two people who survived reported experiencing third man syndrome. One was Ron DeFrancesco, who was the last person out of the South Tower before it collapsed. He was led down while everybody else was going up and actually went through flames, fire, like three stories of fire, to get to safety. And it was because he was being urged on. And then there was another woman, Janelle Guzman McMillan, who was actually trapped in the rubble of the North Tower, and she had a similar experience, too.

[Chuck]

Yeah. And, you know, again, it's. It feels like it might be like in the movie, like a family member or something. And sometimes it seems like that can happen. Like, I know. Wasn't there one of these where. Yeah, it was a geologist who was on a cave dive and lost her guideline with 20 minutes left in her air tank. And she felt her husband, Rob, who had died. So her dead husband had died in a diving accident a few weeks prior. So he appears. So sometimes it's like a known individual.

[Josh]

Yeah. And Janelle Guzman McMillan. I read she didn't think hers was a family member, but she considered it a guardian angel, and its name was Paul. So they do get names sometimes, even if you don't know them.

[Chuck]

I would name mine.

[Josh]

What would you name yours?

[Chuck]

I don't know. It depends. I think it would hit me in the moment but it seems like the respectful thing to do and not just say, hey, you, thanks for all that.

[Josh]

Right? Yeah. And just a little word of advice. If you can't come up with a name, just go with Tim.

[Chuck]

Tim. That's pretty good scientifically. I mean, you might be wondering, like, well, what's happening here? And no one really knows. It's kind of one of those things where they think it may be some hardwired innate instinct that just kind of kicks in. You know, obviously you can't study something like this, and if it is hardwired, we may all have it. But you're just. Luckily, most of us aren't ever in that situation, you know?

[Josh]

Right. Like, you not only have to be in this limit of your endurance life or death situation, you also have to survive it to come back and tell everybody about it, too. So you would imagine, like, this is a pretty small population of people. Right. I mean, clearly, just from the few stories that John Geiger was able to collect. Did you see the thing about the bicameral mind theory? So remember our episode on the bicameral mind from Julian Janes? And basically, just for people who aren't familiar, this is a hypothesis that all the way up until, like, the Bronze Age, people hadn't fully become conscious. Like, we think of consciousness today. And so the voices in their head that we call an inner dialogue, where we know we're talking to ourselves, to them, this was the gods speaking to them, guiding them, instructing them. So this idea is the Third man syndrome is kind of this vestigial, bicameral experience that people used to have where what seems like something outside of your mind is helping you, urging you on, guiding you. But really it's just another part of your mind that gets kicked in.

[Chuck]

Yeah, I love it. Which kind of jives with the first theory anyway. You know, it's not like that doesn't cancel it out, right?

[Josh]

No, there's no canceling going on here.

[Chuck]

Yeah. Good.

[Josh]

You got anything else?

[Chuck]

Nothing else. Hopefully this instinct is within all of us, because I wouldn't mind a pal urging me on in the end.

[Josh]

For sure. Yes. But hopefully no one listening ever has to experience it because it sounds like it's pretty rough to get there.

[Chuck]

Agreed.

[Josh]

Short stuff is out.

[Chuck]

Stuff you should know is a production of iHeartRadio. For more podcasts My Heart Radio, visit the iHeartRadio app. Apple Podcasts are wherever you listen to your favorite shows.