Lessons - The Hidden Psychology Behind Persuasive Communication | Charles Duhigg - Bestselling Author of "The Power of Habit"

Summary

Success Story Podcast: Lessons - The Hidden Psychology Behind Persuasive Communication with Scott D. Clary

Host: Scott D. Clary
Guest: [Unnamed Guest Speakers]
Release Date: May 28, 2025

---

Introduction

In the episode titled "Lessons - The Hidden Psychology Behind Persuasive Communication," host Scott D. Clary delves into the intricacies of effective communication. Through insightful discussions with expert guest speakers, the episode explores the different types of conversations, the underlying psychology that makes communication persuasive, and practical strategies to enhance interpersonal interactions both in personal and professional settings.

Understanding the Three Types of Conversations

At the core of the episode is the exploration of three distinct types of conversations: practical, emotional, and social. Guest Speaker 1 introduces these categories, emphasizing their unique characteristics and impacts on relationships.

• Practical Conversations: These are grounded in logic and reasoning, often involving decision-making and problem-solving. They engage the prefrontal cortex, focusing on cost-benefit analyses and structured planning. For instance, planning a vacation or setting a budget falls under this category.

  "A practical conversation is one where we're thinking about logical systems in any respect... we're using the prefrontal cortex."
  — Guest Speaker 3 [03:22]

• Emotional Conversations: These dialogues revolve around feelings and emotional states. Unlike practical conversations, emotional ones engage the brain's deeper structures, such as the basal ganglia and amygdala. The emphasis here is on empathy and the "logic of similarities" rather than logical reasoning.

  "The logic of costs and benefits tends not to be as persuasive as what's known as the logic of similarities."
  — Guest Speaker 3 [03:22]

• Social Conversations: These interactions focus on identity and social acknowledgment. They don't rely on logic or emotions per se but on the recognition and validation of one's social identity. This type fosters a sense of being heard and understood within a social context.

  "A social conversation happens when I come to you and I say, like, look, you know, as a... as someone who grew up in New Mexico... without even realizing it, is not empathy like in emotions."
  — Guest Speaker 3 [03:22]

The Science of Neural Entrainment

A significant portion of the discussion centers on neural entrainment, a concept from neuroscience that explains how effective communication leads to synchronized brain activity between individuals. Guest Speaker 3 elaborates on how conversations can cause physiological and neurological changes that foster trust and connection, even amidst disagreements.

"If we could see inside your brain and my brain, what we would see is that our thought patterns are becoming more and more alike... This is known in neuroscience as neural entrainment."
— Guest Speaker 3 [03:22]

Neural entrainment not only enhances mutual understanding but also increases the persuasiveness of the communicator. When minds align, trust and likability naturally follow, making communication more effective.

Practical Implications in Daily Interactions

The episode highlights how recognizing the type of conversation at hand can vastly improve interactions across various aspects of life, including:

• Professional Settings: Understanding whether a discussion is practical, emotional, or social can help in tailoring responses that resonate appropriately, leading to more productive meetings and collaborations.

  "When you recognize the type of conversation, you can tailor your responses to better align with the other person's mindset."
  — Guest Speaker 1 [10:44]

• Personal Relationships: Whether negotiating with a spouse, interacting with colleagues, or engaging with friends, identifying the conversation type aids in fostering deeper connections and resolving conflicts more amicably.

Mastering the Art of Deep Questions

A pivotal strategy discussed is the use of deep questions to initiate meaningful conversations. Unlike superficial inquiries, deep questions probe into values, beliefs, and personal experiences, facilitating a more profound exchange of ideas and emotions.

"When we ask those kinds of questions, we're inviting them to tell us what kind of mindset they're in."
— Guest Speaker 3 [12:19]

Examples of deep questions include:

• Instead of: "What law firm do you work at?"
• Ask: "What made you decide to go to law school?"

Such questions not only reveal the underlying motivations and feelings but also pave the way for mutual understanding and neural entrainment.

Overcoming Subconscious Agendas

Another key insight is the recognition of subconscious agendas that individuals may carry into conversations. Often, people enter discussions with predetermined outcomes, which can hinder genuine communication.

"We have our own agenda going into that conversation and we want our own outcomes... That's almost like a subconscious entrainment."
— Guest Speaker 1 [10:55]

To mitigate this, the episode suggests:

• Self-awareness: Acknowledge personal biases and objectives before entering a conversation.
• Active Listening: Focus on truly understanding the other person's perspective rather than steering the conversation towards a personal agenda.
• Asking Open-Ended Questions: Encourage dialogue that allows both parties to share and connect on a deeper level.

Techniques for Enhancing Conversational Skills

The guest speakers provide actionable techniques to improve persuasive communication:

1. Identify the Conversation Type: Quickly assess whether the interaction is practical, emotional, or social to tailor your approach accordingly.

   "The first and most important thing we can do is to ask a question."
   — Guest Speaker 3 [12:19]

2. Ask Deep Questions: Use inquiries that delve into personal values and experiences to foster a more meaningful exchange.

   "A deep question is something that asks about your values or your beliefs or your experiences."
   — Guest Speaker 3 [12:19]

3. Engage in Neural Entrainment: Strive for synchronized thinking by finding common ground and shared experiences, enhancing mutual trust and connection.

   "When we entrain with someone, we like them more, we trust them more, we're more persuaded by them."
   — Guest Speaker 3 [17:36]

4. Avoid Monologues: Ensure that conversations are two-way streets by balancing speaking and listening, thereby transforming potential monologues into genuine dialogues.

Conclusion

Scott D. Clary's episode on the hidden psychology behind persuasive communication offers valuable insights into the mechanics of effective conversations. By understanding the types of conversations, leveraging neural entrainment, and mastering the art of deep questioning, listeners can enhance their interpersonal skills, leading to more meaningful and persuasive interactions in all areas of life.

---

Notable Quotes:

• "Our thought patterns are becoming more and more alike... neural entrainment is at the core of communication."
  — Guest Speaker 3 [03:22]

• "When we entrain with someone, we like them more, we trust them more, we're more persuaded by them."
  — Guest Speaker 3 [17:36]

• "Asking a deep question allows us to not only figure out what's happening in the other person's head, but it interrupts that subconscious thing."
  — Guest Speaker 3 [13:15]

Additional Resources

For listeners interested in further exploring the topics discussed, check out the full episode available on Success Story Podcast and explore related content on persuasive communication and neural psychology.

Transcript

[Scott Clary]

Lingoda is a partner of success story. Look, I'll be real with you. My French used to be solid. I learned it in school. I even had decent pronunciation. But when I booked a trip to France last year, it was a total blank. I could barely order a croissant without sounding like a tourist. So I jumped into the Lingoda Sprint challenge and man, it changed everything. I'd take live classes late at night after podcasting. Only five students max. Real teachers, real, real conversations. And in just two months, I went from Bonjour to holding full conversations at a Paris cafe. Confidence unlocked. Now here's the play 30 or 60 classes in 60 days and if you finish them all, you get 50% cash back. That's basically €4 or $5 per class. That's insane value. Go to try.lingoda.com successsprint and then my code Scott sprint for an extra €20 off on top of their current deal. Registration closes May 5th. Classes start May 12th. Let's get fluent. I have to take a second and thank Northwest Registered Agent for supporting today's episode. Now listen. I know a lot of entrepreneurs listen to this show. If you're an entrepreneur, if you're building a business, you have to listen if you want to get more when you're launching your next big idea, Northwest Registered Agent lets you establish your entire business identity in in just 10 clicks and 10 minutes. For nearly 30 years, they've been the secret weapon for entrepreneurs who want to move fast while getting expert guidance. For just $39 plus state fees, they'll handle your formation, create a custom website and establish your local presence wherever your business takes you. As an entrepreneur myself, what I value most is their one stop business solution. You get everything from formation paperwork to custom domains to trademark registration all in one easy to use account. No more juggling all these multiple services or wasting time figuring out the legal stuff. So don't wait for protect your privacy, build your brand and set up your business in just 10 clicks and 10 minutes. Visit northwestregisteredagent.com success and start building something amazing. Get more with Northwest registered [e-mail] success in this lessons episode, discover how every.

[Guest Speaker 1]

Conversation fits into one of three types practical, emotional or social.

[Scott Clary]

And how recognizing the difference can improve your relationships.

[Guest Speaker 2]

Learn how asking deep questions reveals the mindset behind someone someone's words. Learn how neural entrainment helps build trust and connection even across disagreements. And learn how to stop talking at.

[Scott Clary]

People and start truly engaging with them.

[Guest Speaker 1]

Walk me through how this even impacted Your work. So when you. So now at this point, this is sort of like the first phrase. I know you go through a couple different frameworks in the book, but this is the first framework. So three types of conversations. You have the practical decision making, you have the emotional, you have the social identity. Maybe first explain them a little bit more so that people can wrap their minds around them. But then talk to me about how this impacted your day to day when you, I mean, you've interviewed more people than me. So when you're interviewing people, when you're doing investigations, when you're talking to your wife, when you're talking to your boss.

[Guest Speaker 3]

Yeah, and it's worth noting, an interview isn't necessarily a conversation. Right. Like. Like in this. What. In this interview that we're doing right now, you're going to ask me a lot more questions than I'm going to ask you. And so it's not necessarily back and forth, but when we're having a conversation, oftentimes, what. What happens? Well, let me explain what happens when we're having a conversation that works. When we are, when we connect with someone through conversation or through any type of communication, our bodies and our brains actually change without us realizing it. Like, even in this conversation, even though we're separated by a continent, our breath patterns are starting to match each other, our heart rates are starting to match each other, the dilation of our eyes is starting to become similar. And more importantly, if we could see inside your brain and my brain, what we would see is that our thought patterns are becoming more and more alike. And that actually makes sense when you think about it, because if I tell you about an emotion I'm feeling, you actually experience that emotion a little bit. Or if I tell you about an idea I had, you experience that idea. And so it would make sense that our brains would become more similar. But it turns out that similarity, what's known in neuroscience as neural entrainment, is at the core of communication. When we communicate and we feel like we've actually heard and understood the other person and they've understood us, and we feel connected to them, we trust them more, we like them more, even if we disagree with them, it's because we achieved that neural entrainment, because our thoughts became very similar, entrained with each other. And so what's interesting is that these three kinds of conversations, the practical, the emotional, and the social, they use different parts of our brains. So a practical conversation is one where we're thinking about logical. When we're thinking about logical systems in Any respect, right? We're using the prefrontal cortex. So we're making plans for a vacation, we're setting a budget, we're deciding where to go to dinner tonight by sort of saying like, oh, I like Chinese, but I had it last week. Anything where there's what's known as a logic of costs and benefits is using your prefrontal cortex. An emotional conversation uses a very different structure in our brain. It uses the deep interior structures in our brain, the basal ganglia, the amygdala. And in those cases, the logic of costs and benefits tends not to be as persuasive as what's known as the logic of similarities. Oftentimes when I'm confronted with a situation where it's, I'm feeling an emotion, someone's discussing an emotion, it's clearly an emotional conversation. I try and figure out what to do next, not by asking myself costs and benefits, not by comparing alternative paths, but by looking for something similar, like, oh, you just stubbed your toe. When I stubbed my toe, what I really needed was someone to say, it's okay. Or, I have a friend, as I was mentioning, that just lost his house in the fires in Los Angeles, right? And he doesn't need me coming in and being like, okay, here's what you should do about insurance and X and Y and Z. What he needs is someone who's like, oh, my, I'm so sorry, man, that sounds so hard. And in order to figure out what to say, I'm going to think about those moments in my life when I've had some tragedy and what I needed and what people did for me. So that's the logic of similarities. And then the social conversation is kind of different because it doesn't rely on a logic as much as it relies on evidence that the other person is acknowledging who I am. So a social conversation happens when I come to you and I say, like, look, you know, as a. As someone who grew up in New Mexico, or as a journalist or as a man or as a father, and I tell you something about myself based on how I see myself and how I believe society sees me at that moment. What I'm looking for from you, without even realizing it, is not empathy like in emotions. It's not logic, like in the language of the practical conversation. It's simply acknowledging that you've heard me. If I come and I say, you know, I see this differently as you, and here's why. The best thing that you can say in response is to say, oh, I totally. Like, I totally hear what you're saying. You see this differently than I do, and that's legitimate.

[Scott Clary]

HubSpot is a success Story Partner now if you're an entrepreneur, listen up, because HubSpot makes impossible growth impossibly easy for their customers. If you are building a business, you need to get HubSpot.

[Guest Speaker 2]

Why?

[Scott Clary]

Here's the perfect example. Morehouse College needed to reach new students with fresh, engaging content, a problem that every single business in the world has. But with a 900 page website, even the tiniest update took 30 minutes to publish. Now Breeze, which is HubSpot's collection of AI tools, helped them write and optimize their content in a fraction of the time. And the results? 30% more page views and visitors now spend 27% more time on their site. If you are ready for impossible growth like this, visit HubSpot. Com.

[Guest Speaker 2]

Indeed is a Success Story Partner. Now say you just realized your business needed to hire someone fast. How can you find amazing candidates fast? It's easy. Just use Indeed. When it comes to hiring, Indeed is all you need. Stop struggling to get your job post seen on other job sites. Indeed sponsored Jobs help you stand out and hire fast. And with Sponsored Jobs, your post jumps to the top of the page for your relevant candidates so you can reach the people you want faster and it makes a huge difference. According to Indeed data, Sponsored jobs posted directly on Indeed have 45% more applications than non sponsored jobs. Plus with Indeed sponsored jobs, there's no monthly subscription, no long term contracts. You only pay for results. There's no need to wait any longer. Speed up your hiring right now with Indeed and listeners of this show will get a $75 sponsored job credit. To get your jobs more [e-mail] Clary just go to indeed.com Clary right now and support our show by saying you heard about Indeed on this podcast. Indeed.com Clary terms and conditions apply. Hiring Indeed is all you need. NetSuite is a success story partner. Now what does the future hold for business? If you ask nine experts, you're going to get 10 answers. Bull market. Bear market. Rates will rise. Rates will fall. Honestly, I just wish somebody could invent a crystal ball. But until then, over 41,000 businesses have future proof their business with NetSuite by Oracle, the number one Cloud ERP. Bringing accounting, financial management, inventory and HR into one fluid platform. With real time insights and forecasting, you're peering into the future with actionable data. And when you're closing the books in days, not weeks, you're spending less time looking backwards and More time on what's next. If I had needed this product, this is what I'd use. Whether your company is earning millions or even hundreds of millions, NetSuite helps you respond to immediate challenges and seize your biggest opportunities. And speaking of opportunity, download the CFO's guide to AI and machine learning at netsuite.com ScottClary the guide is free to you at netsuite.com Scottclary netsuite.com Scottclay so when you.

[Guest Speaker 1]

I'm just thinking through now. You have me thinking about all the conversations I have in my life. And now I'm mapping out when some things just seem to not click. And now it makes a lot of sense as to why.

[Scott Clary]

The, the three.

[Guest Speaker 2]

Kinds.

[Guest Speaker 1]

The three kinds of conversations that you just mentioned. I feel like. I feel like when we go into a conversation, the reason why we could not pick up on the type of conversation that the other person is trying to have could be because we have our own agenda going into that conversation and we want our own outcomes. And I don't even know if that's a conscious thought. I feel like in my case, if I'm going into a conversation, I've had this conversation so many different times. I have this subconscious outcome that I'm looking for, and I'm not even. I'm not. It sounds cliche, but I'm not stepping into other people's shoes, right? I'm just saying I'm having this conversation. I'm feeling this emotion. This is what I want out of it. If I don't get that, I'm not happy with the interaction, but I'm not consciously doing that. That's almost like a subconscious, entrained.

[Guest Speaker 3]

Well, and there's a way, there's a way to sidestep this, right? So this is one of the first big skills, is how do we figure out what kind of conversation we're in and how do we get ourselves out of our head? Because oftentimes before we have a conversation, we might think about it. Like, if it's an important conversation or something we're kind of uptight about, we'll think about it. And what we think about is what I want to say. Like, here's what I want the other person to know. Here's what I want to say. That's not really a conversation, right? That's a monologue. That's.

[Guest Speaker 1]

That's what most people.

[Guest Speaker 3]

That's, that's totally. It's totally natural. So what do we do when we start that conversation to make it an actual Conversation. The first and most important thing we can do is to ask a question. But not all questions are created equal. Some questions are much more powerful than others. And within psychology, these are known as deep questions. And a deep question is something that asks about your values or your beliefs or your experiences. And that can sound a little bit intimidating, but it's as simple. Like if you met someone who's a lawyer, you know, instead of asking them, oh, what law firm do you work at? Asking them, oh, what made you decide to go to law school?

[Scott Clary]

Right?

[Guest Speaker 3]

Do you like being a lawyer? Like, what do you love about it? When we ask those kinds of questions, when we ask people not about the facts of their life, but how they feel about their life, what we're doing is we're inviting them to tell us what kind of mindset they're in. Because that person who's a lawyer, at one party, he might say, oh, I wanted a steady job and I knew that there's always going to be demand for lawyers. So he's in a practical mindset. At another party, the exact same person might say, oh, I actually saw my uncle get arrested when I was a kid. And I felt like it was really unjust and I wanted to help fight against that. Okay, so that's much more of an emotional, maybe even a social conversation. Asking a deep question allows us to not only figure out what's happening in the other person's head, but it interrupts that subconscious thing that you're talking about. Because instead of just barreling in and being like, here's what I want you to know about me, I'm asking you a question, we're starting a dialogue. And the great thing about deep questions is that as soon as you ask that question and they answer it, it's very natural for you to answer your own question, right? Oh, you became a lawyer because you saw your uncle get arrested. That's really interesting. I'm a doctor and I became a doctor because I saw my dad get sick when I was a kid. So that's the, that's the first and most important step is, or skill is learn to ask the right questions and then ask them.

[Guest Speaker 1]

When you ask these. First of all, it's sort of a two pronged question to this. The first part is when you ask these or how, how practical is it to ask these deep questions before every interaction that you have? Because that's what you're alluding to. This is what you, this is what you're teaching. Before you have any kind of conversation, you have to get almost a barometer reading of where that person is at to a degree. You can add.

[Guest Speaker 3]

Well, sometimes, sometimes, like, like, I mean, sometimes you, you walk up and like, you're in Jim's, your, your coworkers. Like, we got to discuss the budget. And you're like, okay, let's discuss the budget. Like, you know that he's in a practical mindset, right? He's announced it. Sometimes people, what mindset they're in. I think it's those situations when you're not, when it's not announced and those moments that's when asking this deep question. And I think what you're really asking is like, man, that seems like so much work. But actually asking a deep question usually takes a couple of seconds, and the reply usually takes no more than 20 or 25 seconds. Right. Like, you mentioned that you lived in Miami. So like a deep question I would ask you would be like, oh, you know, what made you guys decide to move to Miami? Like what, like, what was going on? That, like, and you're going to answer that question and you're going to tell me something about yourself. You're sick of the cold or you wanted to get away from your in laws or whatever it is. Something, something was going on that gives me some insight into who you are and what kind of mindset you're in right now. But it's not going to be a big, like, cry on each other's shoulder moment. No. In fact, in schools, they teach teachers to do this by saying, look, if a student comes up and they want to have a conversation with you, start the conversation by asking them, do you want to be helped? Do you want to be hugged? Or do you want to be heard? Which are the three kinds of conversations? The practical, the emotional, and the social. And if anyone listening has kids at home, try this with your kids. They will tell you exactly what they want. Immediately. They will say like, no, I don't need your help. I just want you to hear what's going on. Or, I need a hug.

[Guest Speaker 1]

When you add the second part to that, that question that I was just asking was, when you have, when you ask these deep questions, is there a greater degree of connection made with that person? Is there some sort of deeper level of understanding or empathy? Like some bond that's formed?

[Guest Speaker 3]

Well, so you're starting to entrain, right? Like if I, if I, if I say to you, you know, why'd you become a lawyer? I saw my uncle get arrested and they say, oh, I became a doctor because I saw my dad get sick. Now we're both having the same kind of conversation, right? We're finding something that we have in common. We are starting to entrain with each other. And the thing that's interesting about entrainment is you can't help but feel closer to the person when you entrain with them. Like, literally, like, even if you dislike each other, even if you disagree about everything on earth, entrainment doesn't mean you're going to change your mind. It doesn't mean you're going to walk away saying, I agree with you. Entrainment is something that we achieve with another person that makes us feel connected. And when we are entrained with someone, we like them more, we trust them more, we're more persuaded by them. And that doesn't mean that we really like them or that we really trust them, but it does mean that we feel connected to them in some way.

[Guest Speaker 1]

Thanks for tuning in. If you found this valuable, don't forget to hit that subscribe button so you never miss an episode. And if you want to dive deeper into this conversation, check out the links in the description to watch the full episode. See you in the next one.

[Scott Clary]

The HubSpot Podcast Network is a Success Story Partner now if you like Success Story, you're going to love other podcasts in the HubSpot podcast network. One of my personal favorites is I Digress. Hosted by my boy Troy Sandich. With shows under 30 minutes, I digress helps eliminate complexity, complications, and confusion in your business with frameworks and strategies to achieve true, scalable and sustainable success. If you are an entrepreneur building anything you need to listen to I Digress. This is one of the most useful business podcasts you're ever going to subscribe to. Listen to I Digress. Wherever you get your podcasts.