Sunday Homilies with Fr. Mike Schmitz Episode: May 25, 2025 – Pillar and Foundation: Says Who?
Release Date: May 24, 2025
Host/Author: Ascension
Duration: 20-30 minutes

Introduction

In the May 25th episode of Sunday Homilies with Fr. Mike Schmitz, Fr. Schmitz delves into a profound exploration of the foundational pillars of Christian truth, specifically addressing the relationship between the Bible and the Church. Titled "Pillar and Foundation: Says Who?", the homily challenges listeners to consider whether the Bible alone serves as the sole authority in Christian faith or if the Church also holds an indispensable role.

The Central Question: Scripture or the Church?

Fr. Schmitz begins by presenting a common inquiry he encounters:

"Is that in the Bible or is that just from the church?"
[00:25]

This question serves as the catalyst for his discussion, prompting an examination of whether the Church's teachings stand independently of Scripture or are intrinsically linked.

The Role of the Church in Christian Doctrine

Fr. Schmitz emphasizes the importance of recognizing the Church as more than an optional entity in Christian life. He poses critical questions to the congregation:

"Is the church optional? Is the Bible enough?"
[01:10]

He argues that both Scripture and the Church are essential, stating:

"Both the Bible and the church, both Scripture and tradition are essential."
[05:45]

Historical Context: The Council of Jerusalem

To substantiate his argument, Fr. Schmitz references Acts Chapter 15, detailing the Council of Jerusalem. This early Church council confronted whether Gentile converts needed to adhere to Jewish customs, such as circumcision, before fully embracing Christianity.

He explains:

"What does the Bible say about the role of the church? ... The first apostles are Jewish, and when Gentiles convert, do they need to follow the old covenant first?"
[03:30]

The council's decision, guided by the Holy Spirit, concluded that Gentiles did not need to undergo circumcision to be part of the Christian community. This historical precedent underscores the Church's authority in interpreting and applying Scripture.

Sola Scriptura and Its Limitations

Addressing the Protestant Reformation's principle of sola scriptura (Scripture alone), Fr. Schmitz critiques the notion that tradition and the Church are unnecessary:

"Look through the entire book from Genesis to Revelation. You will not find one moment when the Bible teaches Bible alone."
[10:20]

He highlights that key biblical passages, such as 2 Thessalonians 2:15, advocate for adherence to both written Scripture and oral tradition:

"Hold fast to the traditions that you were taught, either by word of mouth or by written letter to you."
[12:50]

The Necessity of the Church Today

Fr. Schmitz asserts that the Church remains the pillar and foundation of Christian truth, essential for salvation:

"God's plan for all of us is the Catholic Church."
[18:10]

He reinforces this by referencing Revelation, illustrating the Church's enduring presence and foundational role:

"The city of God, Heaven itself is built upon the foundation of the twelve apostles... the kingdom, the church, the bride of Christ, the body of Christ."
[20:45]

Conclusion: Embracing Both Scripture and the Church

In closing, Fr. Schmitz urges listeners to reject the false dichotomy of Scripture versus the Church. Instead, he advocates for embracing both as essential components of Christian faith and practice:

"The Church is not optional, but is the pillar and the foundation."
[25:30]

He calls upon believers to recognize the integral role of the Church in living out the Gospel, ensuring a faith that is both grounded in Scripture and nourished by the traditions upheld by the Church.

Key Takeaways:

• Integration of Scripture and Tradition: The Bible alone does not encapsulate the entirety of Christian truth; the Church's teachings and traditions are equally vital.

• Historical Precedent: Early Church councils, like the Council of Jerusalem, exemplify the necessity of Church authority in interpreting Scripture.

• Critique of Sola Scriptura: The principle of sola scriptura lacks explicit biblical support and undermines the foundational role of the Church.

• Enduring Role of the Church: The Church remains God's intended pillar and foundation for believers, essential for salvation and spiritual growth.

By addressing these themes, Fr. Mike Schmitz provides a compelling argument for the indispensable role of the Church alongside Scripture, urging listeners to embrace a holistic approach to their faith that honors both the Holy Bible and the traditions of the Catholic Church.