Podcast Summary

Sunday Sitdown with Willie Geist

Episode: STAND-UP GREATS: Nate Bargatze on His Rise, Hosting 'SNL,' and Building the Nateland Empire
Date: November 22, 2025
Live at: City Winery, New York City

Episode Overview

In this special live episode, Willie Geist interviews one of stand-up comedy’s biggest current stars, Nate Bargatze. With a sold-out crowd in attendance at City Winery, Nate opens up about his journey from humble beginnings in Tennessee to selling out arenas, hosting Saturday Night Live twice, building his Nateland entertainment empire, and sticking to his roots—clean, self-deprecating humor and strong family values. The conversation is authentic and full of laughs, as Nate shares stories about failure, fame, and the vision he has for the future of comedy and family-friendly entertainment.

Key Discussion Points & Insights

Nate’s Journey: From Old Hickory to Arenas

Vanderbilt Fandom and Early Ties (07:14 – 10:47)
- Both Nate and Willie bond over years of supporting Vanderbilt sports — before it was “cool” to do so.
- Nate’s mother worked in the Vanderbilt ticket office; his uncle coached and commentated.
- “[Being a Vanderbilt fan]…you’re rooting for that team that’s not always gonna win. And then when they get on these runs…it’s fun. Greatest times of my life.” – Nate Bargatze (10:47)
Making It to the Top (11:26 – 13:19)
- Nate reflects on 20+ years of grinding in comedy before his “overnight” ascent; how the sudden fame almost doesn’t feel real.
- “All takes very long, but then it happens very quick… you just try to stay as good as you can possibly be.” – Nate (13:19)
Flight Trouble & Road-Heroes (04:47 – 06:10)
- A missed flight almost jeopardized Nate’s attendance at the live show; he rented a van and drove from Pennsylvania with his team, proving comedian road-warrior spirit is alive and well.
- Humorous reflections on gas station snacks: “A gas station on the road… there’s nothing in there that’s not gonna give you diabetes.” – Nate (05:52)

SNL, Breakthroughs & Viral Moments

Hosting SNL Twice & the “George Washington Dream” Sketch (13:19 – 17:45)
- Hosting Saturday Night Live in October 2023, then again in October 2024—an unusual honor for any host.
- Nate fought for the now-famous “George Washington” sketch despite lukewarm table read reception. The sketch later “destroyed” during rehearsal and was moved up in the running order.
- “I knew it'd be funny… once I get in front of a crowd, it's gonna be great. That blew up and…became what it all became.” – Nate (14:01–15:37)
- The sketch’s mainstream reach introduced Nate to millions and directly impacted ticket sales and tour size.
Word-of-Mouth Career (16:23 – 18:08)
- Nate’s growth is described as organic—his audience comes from people bringing friends to shows rather than viral fame or a single breakout hit.
- Post-SNL, he had to reschedule and add arena shows to meet demand.

Roots, Influences, and Style

Family & Magic Roots (19:25 – 24:40)
- Grew up outside Nashville; his father is a magician who incorporates comedy—Nate credits his sense of timing and showmanship to these roots.
- Childhood jokes, magic, and supportive parents set Nate on a creative path.
Working Clean & Making Parents Proud (30:18 – 31:38)
- Nate made a conscious decision to work clean out of respect for his family and their values.
- “I write everything I write... for them. I just want… them to see it and be proud.” – Nate (30:33)
Influences and Comedy Heroes (33:05 – 35:06)
- Major inspirations include Seinfeld, Brian Regan (whose CD made him “pull the car over from laughing so hard”), and Jim Gaffigan, now a friend and fellow clean comic.
Self-Deprecation & Not Being Mean (36:21 – 38:25)
- Nate avoids mean-spirited humor; the joke is almost always on himself.
- “I don’t want anybody to think I’m ever better than them… I’ll make fun of me. You can laugh with me or at me; it doesn’t matter.” – Nate (37:20)

The Nuts and Bolts of Comedy

Bombing and The Grind (56:06 – 58:13)
- Nate shares early stories of bombing, including performing for one audience member and being haunted by the memory of a tucked-in shirt set.
- “You bomb a lot at the beginning… once, one guy was the only one in the crowd… it was pleasant, but…” – Nate (56:06)
Breakthrough Moments: Fallon and Conan (40:10 – 41:32)
- Conan and Jimmy Fallon provided early national television exposure; Fallon personally invited him on after seeing him perform, which helped open major industry doors and led to developing a show together.
Process and Memorization (66:35 – 69:17)
- Building an hour-long act is like “learning a song”: things flow in a sequence.
- Old jokes are hard to recall once he’s moved on.
- “Sometimes you have to just bail on a bit mid-set—you just say, ‘I don’t remember how that goes.’” – Nate (67:39)
Ripening with Age (57:18 – 57:35)
- On comedic success: “You either make it at 20 or 40… you gotta grind it out otherwise.” – Nate (57:27)

The Nateland Vision & Nashville

Building Nateland—A Family Entertainment Empire (47:59 – 54:24)
- Nate’s goal is to create family-friendly, trustworthy content under his Nateland umbrella, driven by what he feels Hollywood neglects.
- He envisions Nateland as a sort of “alternative Disney,” with movies and projects that families can trust.
- “If you see Nateland, you might not like it, but you can at least trust that I’m not going to… make you uncomfortable… I want you all to watch it as a family.” – Nate (48:29)
- He discusses the need for Hollywood to better nurture young talent and create “the next Star Wars,” not just sequels.
- Plan to step back from stand-up after one or two more big tours and focus on producing.
Nashville & Hometown Roots (43:49 – 45:29, 69:28 – 71:14)
- He opened a new gym and athletic center at his old high school.
- Favorite Nashville spots? Nate: “San Antonio Taco Company (SatCo) on 21st;” Willie: “Station Inn in the Gulch.”
- “My high school – Donaldson Christian Academy. Graduated with 56 people and still didn’t make the basketball team. Half were girls!” – Nate (45:00)

Family, Success, and Life Balance

Support System: His Wife (59:00 – 59:58)
- Nate and his wife met working at Applebee’s: she was a server, he a host.
- “She’s been much more important than I probably realized… The only way I would even have success.” – Nate (59:18)
Using Family & Real Life in Material (64:49 – 66:08)
- With his daughter growing up, Nate is even more careful to ensure nothing from his act would embarrass her.
- “I just want to get old enough so she can understand why I’d be saying [a joke about her] and that it’s not anything.” – Nate (64:56)

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

On SNL and confidence:
“I knew once I got in front of a crowd, it’s gonna be great. Not everybody has my confidence; they thought I was out of my mind!” – Nate (14:01)
On touring & overnight success:
“It all takes very long, but then it happens very quick… you just try to stay as good as you can possibly be.” – Nate (13:19)
On working clean:
“I have Catholic guilt without any of the fun, and the strictness of Baptist… I walk a pretty tight line.” – Nate (31:03)
On self-awareness:
“You can laugh with me or at me, and it doesn’t matter.” – Nate (37:20)
On stand-up’s process:
“It’s like a song… an hour-long kind of song.” – Nate (66:35)

Audience Q&A Highlights

First realization he was funny:
“High school party, telling a story, people start laughing… first kind of standup set I felt like I did.” (55:35)
First time bombing:
“Bombed for a crowd of one; another time, bombed in front of a sold-out crowd, blamed my tucked-in shirt.” (56:06)
What keeps him going:
“I kind of felt I was supposed to be doing this… As long as every year got a little better…” (57:46)
Man crushes:
Nate: Kiefer Sutherland (“He told me ‘I love you, buddy’—I don’t think he knows who I am!”) (61:38)
Willie: Paul Rudd

Timestamps of Major Segments

03:58 – Arrival of Nate, audience welcomes
07:14 – Vanderbilt fandom shared history
13:19 – Reflections on career arc, SNL host stories
16:23 – The “George Washington” SNL sketch
19:25 – Growing up with a magician father
22:16 – Early comedy influences, family support
28:19 – Getting serious about comedy; move to Chicago
30:18 – Decision to work clean
33:05 – Seinfeld, Regan, and Gaffigan as heroes
36:21 – Not being mean on stage, self-deprecation
40:10 – Career breaks: Conan and Fallon
47:59 – The Nateland vision: family-friendly entertainment and building the next empire
53:48 – Need for new young entertainment talent in Hollywood
59:00 – Wife’s central role in his journey
69:28 – Favorite Nashville places

Tone & Atmosphere

The entire episode is casual, upbeat, and deeply funny—true to both Bargatze and Geist’s playful, self-mocking sensibilities. The live audience lends energy, while the personal stories and reflective tone offer unexpected substance behind the laughs.

Summary prepared for listeners who want the wisdom, laughs, and warmth of Nate Bargatze and Willie Geist—without missing a beat.

Podcast Summary

Sunday Sitdown with Willie Geist

Episode: STAND-UP GREATS: Nate Bargatze on His Rise, Hosting 'SNL,' and Building the Nateland Empire
Date: November 22, 2025
Live at: City Winery, New York City

Episode Overview

Key Discussion Points & Insights

Nate’s Journey: From Old Hickory to Arenas

Vanderbilt Fandom and Early Ties (07:14 – 10:47)
- Both Nate and Willie bond over years of supporting Vanderbilt sports — before it was “cool” to do so.
- Nate’s mother worked in the Vanderbilt ticket office; his uncle coached and commentated.
- “[Being a Vanderbilt fan]…you’re rooting for that team that’s not always gonna win. And then when they get on these runs…it’s fun. Greatest times of my life.” – Nate Bargatze (10:47)
Making It to the Top (11:26 – 13:19)
- Nate reflects on 20+ years of grinding in comedy before his “overnight” ascent; how the sudden fame almost doesn’t feel real.
- “All takes very long, but then it happens very quick… you just try to stay as good as you can possibly be.” – Nate (13:19)
Flight Trouble & Road-Heroes (04:47 – 06:10)
- A missed flight almost jeopardized Nate’s attendance at the live show; he rented a van and drove from Pennsylvania with his team, proving comedian road-warrior spirit is alive and well.
- Humorous reflections on gas station snacks: “A gas station on the road… there’s nothing in there that’s not gonna give you diabetes.” – Nate (05:52)

SNL, Breakthroughs & Viral Moments

Hosting SNL Twice & the “George Washington Dream” Sketch (13:19 – 17:45)
- Hosting Saturday Night Live in October 2023, then again in October 2024—an unusual honor for any host.
- Nate fought for the now-famous “George Washington” sketch despite lukewarm table read reception. The sketch later “destroyed” during rehearsal and was moved up in the running order.
- “I knew it'd be funny… once I get in front of a crowd, it's gonna be great. That blew up and…became what it all became.” – Nate (14:01–15:37)
- The sketch’s mainstream reach introduced Nate to millions and directly impacted ticket sales and tour size.
Word-of-Mouth Career (16:23 – 18:08)
- Nate’s growth is described as organic—his audience comes from people bringing friends to shows rather than viral fame or a single breakout hit.
- Post-SNL, he had to reschedule and add arena shows to meet demand.

Roots, Influences, and Style

Family & Magic Roots (19:25 – 24:40)
- Grew up outside Nashville; his father is a magician who incorporates comedy—Nate credits his sense of timing and showmanship to these roots.
- Childhood jokes, magic, and supportive parents set Nate on a creative path.
Working Clean & Making Parents Proud (30:18 – 31:38)
- Nate made a conscious decision to work clean out of respect for his family and their values.
- “I write everything I write... for them. I just want… them to see it and be proud.” – Nate (30:33)
Influences and Comedy Heroes (33:05 – 35:06)
- Major inspirations include Seinfeld, Brian Regan (whose CD made him “pull the car over from laughing so hard”), and Jim Gaffigan, now a friend and fellow clean comic.
Self-Deprecation & Not Being Mean (36:21 – 38:25)
- Nate avoids mean-spirited humor; the joke is almost always on himself.
- “I don’t want anybody to think I’m ever better than them… I’ll make fun of me. You can laugh with me or at me; it doesn’t matter.” – Nate (37:20)

The Nuts and Bolts of Comedy

Bombing and The Grind (56:06 – 58:13)
- Nate shares early stories of bombing, including performing for one audience member and being haunted by the memory of a tucked-in shirt set.
- “You bomb a lot at the beginning… once, one guy was the only one in the crowd… it was pleasant, but…” – Nate (56:06)
Breakthrough Moments: Fallon and Conan (40:10 – 41:32)
- Conan and Jimmy Fallon provided early national television exposure; Fallon personally invited him on after seeing him perform, which helped open major industry doors and led to developing a show together.
Process and Memorization (66:35 – 69:17)
- Building an hour-long act is like “learning a song”: things flow in a sequence.
- Old jokes are hard to recall once he’s moved on.
- “Sometimes you have to just bail on a bit mid-set—you just say, ‘I don’t remember how that goes.’” – Nate (67:39)
Ripening with Age (57:18 – 57:35)
- On comedic success: “You either make it at 20 or 40… you gotta grind it out otherwise.” – Nate (57:27)

The Nateland Vision & Nashville

Building Nateland—A Family Entertainment Empire (47:59 – 54:24)
- Nate’s goal is to create family-friendly, trustworthy content under his Nateland umbrella, driven by what he feels Hollywood neglects.
- He envisions Nateland as a sort of “alternative Disney,” with movies and projects that families can trust.
- “If you see Nateland, you might not like it, but you can at least trust that I’m not going to… make you uncomfortable… I want you all to watch it as a family.” – Nate (48:29)
- He discusses the need for Hollywood to better nurture young talent and create “the next Star Wars,” not just sequels.
- Plan to step back from stand-up after one or two more big tours and focus on producing.
Nashville & Hometown Roots (43:49 – 45:29, 69:28 – 71:14)
- He opened a new gym and athletic center at his old high school.
- Favorite Nashville spots? Nate: “San Antonio Taco Company (SatCo) on 21st;” Willie: “Station Inn in the Gulch.”
- “My high school – Donaldson Christian Academy. Graduated with 56 people and still didn’t make the basketball team. Half were girls!” – Nate (45:00)

Family, Success, and Life Balance

Support System: His Wife (59:00 – 59:58)
- Nate and his wife met working at Applebee’s: she was a server, he a host.
- “She’s been much more important than I probably realized… The only way I would even have success.” – Nate (59:18)
Using Family & Real Life in Material (64:49 – 66:08)
- With his daughter growing up, Nate is even more careful to ensure nothing from his act would embarrass her.
- “I just want to get old enough so she can understand why I’d be saying [a joke about her] and that it’s not anything.” – Nate (64:56)

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

On SNL and confidence:
“I knew once I got in front of a crowd, it’s gonna be great. Not everybody has my confidence; they thought I was out of my mind!” – Nate (14:01)
On touring & overnight success:
“It all takes very long, but then it happens very quick… you just try to stay as good as you can possibly be.” – Nate (13:19)
On working clean:
“I have Catholic guilt without any of the fun, and the strictness of Baptist… I walk a pretty tight line.” – Nate (31:03)
On self-awareness:
“You can laugh with me or at me, and it doesn’t matter.” – Nate (37:20)
On stand-up’s process:
“It’s like a song… an hour-long kind of song.” – Nate (66:35)

Audience Q&A Highlights

First realization he was funny:
“High school party, telling a story, people start laughing… first kind of standup set I felt like I did.” (55:35)
First time bombing:
“Bombed for a crowd of one; another time, bombed in front of a sold-out crowd, blamed my tucked-in shirt.” (56:06)
What keeps him going:
“I kind of felt I was supposed to be doing this… As long as every year got a little better…” (57:46)
Man crushes:
Nate: Kiefer Sutherland (“He told me ‘I love you, buddy’—I don’t think he knows who I am!”) (61:38)
Willie: Paul Rudd

Timestamps of Major Segments

03:58 – Arrival of Nate, audience welcomes
07:14 – Vanderbilt fandom shared history
13:19 – Reflections on career arc, SNL host stories
16:23 – The “George Washington” SNL sketch
19:25 – Growing up with a magician father
22:16 – Early comedy influences, family support
28:19 – Getting serious about comedy; move to Chicago
30:18 – Decision to work clean
33:05 – Seinfeld, Regan, and Gaffigan as heroes
36:21 – Not being mean on stage, self-deprecation
40:10 – Career breaks: Conan and Fallon
47:59 – The Nateland vision: family-friendly entertainment and building the next empire
53:48 – Need for new young entertainment talent in Hollywood
59:00 – Wife’s central role in his journey
69:28 – Favorite Nashville places

Tone & Atmosphere

Summary prepared for listeners who want the wisdom, laughs, and warmth of Nate Bargatze and Willie Geist—without missing a beat.

wavePod

STAND-UP GREATS: Nate Bargatze on His Rise, Hosting 'SNL,' and Building the Nateland Empire

Powered by Wave AI

Summary

Podcast Summary

Sunday Sitdown with Willie Geist

Episode Overview

Key Discussion Points & Insights

Nate’s Journey: From Old Hickory to Arenas

SNL, Breakthroughs & Viral Moments

Roots, Influences, and Style

The Nuts and Bolts of Comedy

The Nateland Vision & Nashville

Family, Success, and Life Balance

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

Audience Q&A Highlights

Timestamps of Major Segments

Tone & Atmosphere

Summary

Podcast Summary

Sunday Sitdown with Willie Geist

Episode Overview

Key Discussion Points & Insights

Nate’s Journey: From Old Hickory to Arenas

SNL, Breakthroughs & Viral Moments

Roots, Influences, and Style

The Nuts and Bolts of Comedy

The Nateland Vision & Nashville

Family, Success, and Life Balance

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

Audience Q&A Highlights

Timestamps of Major Segments

Tone & Atmosphere