Sunday Sports Club with Allison Kuch Episode: The JUICIEST Sports Relationship Drama with Isaac Rochell Date: September 28, 2025
Overview
In this lively, laugh-filled episode, host Allison Kuch is joined by her husband and former NFL player Isaac Rochell for a candid deep dive into the wildest romantic dramas inside the world of sports. They read and react to anonymous, listener-submitted stories—most involving athletes behaving badly, wild DMs, secret girlfriends, side chicks, and the intricate dance of dating in sports. Throughout, Allison and Isaac debate red flags, boundaries, and the social codes surrounding public relationships in sports, all with their signature playful banter.
Key Discussion Points & Insights
1. Life Updates & Podcast Setup
- Allison and Isaac open with a spirited back-and-forth, poking fun at each other’s quirks.
- Brief life updates (03:07): Daughter is almost 2 years old—a fun, “spunky” age; Isaac is starting a TV sports gig with KCAL in SoCal and training for marathons.
- Allison highlights the struggle of work/life balance as parents and the relief a new office space has brought them.
- Tease for next episode: Details on Isaac’s new career moves.
2. Intro to “Juicy” Relationship Stories
- Allison explains she asked her mostly-female sports community for their messiest dating and relationship drama involving athletes (06:54).
- Stories are read anonymous—Isaac is hearing them live for authentic reactions.
Relationship Drama Stories & Takeaways
1. Hidden Girlfriend & Social Media Red Flags
Tale: College basketball player refuses to be public about his girlfriend. Hides her on a private Insta, ensures she sits apart from other girlfriends. When another teammate hits on her, the player breaks up, accusing her of “cheating.”
Key Debate: Is refusing to post your partner a red flag?
- Allison: “If he’s active on social media and he’s not posting you—red flag! If it’s only close friends, red flag.” (09:46)
- Isaac: Pushes back: For highly public careers, privacy has business reasons (10:07).
- Allison: “If I am dating an NFL player and we’ve been boyfriend and girlfriend for a year and he still won’t post me, then I think that’s a red flag.” (13:04)
2. The Jersey Chaser’s Dilemma
Tale: Friend hooks up with athlete who keeps her a secret (“sneaks her in and out”); when friendship ends, the guy starts flirting with the narrator and they hook up too.
- Isaac: “We don’t have enough info…but the 12am thing and ignoring on campus is crazy. That’s shame.” (16:49)
- Allison: “If a guy is ignoring you on campus, he probably doesn’t have feelings for you.” (16:57)
- Discussion: Why is it viewed worse when women hook up casually than when men do?
3. Cheating DMs & Calling Out the Player
Tale: Third-string college football player with a girlfriend DM’s the listener, tries for a hookup via Snapchat. She screenshots and sends to his girlfriend.
- Allison: “Oh, my God, I love you for that.” (25:57)
- Allison and Isaac agree: Most long-distance “hometown” relationships don’t survive in college or pro sports.
- Allison (re: their daughter): “Would you tell Scotty to break up with her boy in college?” Isaac: “Absolutely.” (27:47–27:55)
4. Sugar Daddy Eye Surgeon & Perks of the Box Seats
Tale: Friend dates unattractive doctor met on “sugardaddies.com” for NFL game perks; gets heartbroken when she finds she isn’t the only “sugar baby.”
- Isaac expresses disbelief people sign up for sugar daddy arrangements, wonders about the nature of these transactions (30:44).
- Banter about selling feet pics, generational side hustles, and the ethics of sugar dating.
5. NFL Cheater Flies Out Side Piece—Wife Surprises Them in Miami
Tale: Woman hooks up with NFL player at a Vegas club. He lavishes gifts, flies her to Miami, but only books a one-way ticket; she's stranded when his wife finds out.
- Allison: “If you’re cheating on your wife, you’re a shitty dad.” (33:01)
- Isaac: “This guy’s a loser. Having three kids and doing that, you’re willing to throw your whole life away.” (33:48)
- Both discuss if the “side chick” shares blame upon learning about the wife/kids.
6. The Ring Camera Nightmare
Tale: Listener has a situationship with an NFL player, visits him, gets “caught” by a woman who appears on his Ring camera, screaming. Months later, another woman calls the listener at work, revealing herself as the player’s girlfriend of a year—separate from Ring camera woman.
- Allison: “I just don’t understand why a woman would stay with a professional athlete after finding out he cheated. They’ll never change.” (45:25)
- Isaac: “Maybe she just wanted closure, though.” (45:38)
- Debate on why women stay in these situations—money? Fame? Sunk costs?
7. Player Juggling Wife & Multiple Side Pieces
Tale: Player has wife, girlfriend, side chick all at training camp; eventually leaves wife for the girlfriend.
- Isaac: “Do you know how delusional you have to be to have three women… and bring them together?” (48:34)
- Allison: “I think you’re addicted to sex if that’s the case.” (48:58)
8. The Double Flown-In, Ghosted in Denver Story
Tale: Listener is flown in by an NFL player, left alone in his apartment (fake “MRI” excuse); finds out later he had another woman in town and stayed with her the first night.
- Isaac: “That’s crazy work, bro… you can’t look at women like they’re actual humans if that’s how you act.” (50:18)
- Allison: “If you get flown out by a guy and he is not picking you up from the airport with fucking flowers… get the fuck back on a plane.” (51:12)
- Both discuss the bare-minimum expectations for being flown out.
--
Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments
- Allison: “Do you get icks even with your husband of how many years? Four years? Yeah, I do.” (00:11)
- Isaac: “My boy is living in 2030. That’s actually a crazy play on his part. Ew.” (09:28) — reacting to the non-starter player’s breakup tactic.
- Allison: “I think in college you're allowed to be a little messy. Is that toxic of me?” (15:05)
- Isaac: “A lot of great guys… Our friend groups were always like, stand up. Really, really good guys.” (54:21)
- Isaac: “That’s crazy work, bro… you’re just looking at women like objects.” (50:18)
- Allison: "If a guy is flying you out to see you, he should make it an experience...vice versa. Let’s not gender stereotype." (51:36)
- On professional athletes and cheating:
- Isaac: “What’s the number that makes their behavior more or less acceptable? There’s a chart—the more money you make, the more lenient.” (47:30)
- Allison: “Take the professional sport out of it. Is he a good person? It sounds like he’s not. Do you want to raise a child with that person?” (46:23)
Timestamps for Important Segments
- Life updates & new office / work balance: 02:54–06:42
- Introduction to the “juicy” relationship stories: 06:54–08:15
- Red flags in posting a significant other (social media): 09:38–13:04
- First messy dating story, group chat admissions: 13:16–16:14
- Cheating DMs and relationship longevity in college/athletics: 25:19–27:55
- NFL player/sugar daddy stories: 29:05–31:43
- Cheating NFL player, stranded side chick, wife appears: 31:51–34:52
- The “Ring camera” girlfriend investigation: 43:44–45:38
- Why women stay with cheaters (debate): 45:25–47:55
- Three-woman training camp saga: 48:06–48:58
- Double-flown-in, ghosted in Denver: 49:18–52:33
- Wrap-up and reflection: 52:49–55:08
Tone and Final Thoughts
- This episode is full of energetic, sometimes savage banter but always self-aware ("we disagree a lot, but that's fun").
- Isaac is the skeptical, logical counterweight to Allison’s passionate, outspoken take on female solidarity and standards.
- Both express genuine disgust at cheaters, disappointment at the lack of respect shown by many male athletes, and empathy for women caught in these dramas.
- They finish by reaffirming: yes, there are great, faithful athletes, but drama can be rampant, and women should have higher expectations.
Allison: "If you have a story you want to write in, head over to the Sunday Sports Club podcast Instagram…we’ll have one of the little bubbles." (55:08)
Summary prepared for listeners who missed the episode, complete with major story beats, quotes, and the unique flavor that Allison and Isaac bring to 'Sunday Sports Club.'