Table Read: Caravaggio – Act 3

Date: February 24, 2026
Podcast: TABLE READ by Manifest Media

Episode Overview

This episode of Table Read is an immersive audio drama, bringing to life the final, dramatic act in the story of Michelangelo Merisi da Caravaggio—one of history’s most notorious, brilliant, and tormented painters. Act 3 traces Caravaggio’s desperate flight across the Mediterranean, his final great works painted in exile, his violent encounters with the Knights of Malta, and ultimately, his tragic and enigmatic death. Hollywood’s top actors deliver performances rich in emotion and complexity, supported by cinematic sound and music, enveloping listeners in a world of intrigue, faith, betrayal, and brutal beauty.

Key Discussion Points & Narrative Highlights

Caravaggio’s Exile and Pursuit

• [00:54–03:05] Caravaggio, escaping punishment, arrives in Syracuse, Sicily, after fleeing from Malta with the help of a young boy.

  • “Where are we?” — Caravaggio [02:23]
  • “Syracuse.” — Fisherman [03:03]

• [03:07–03:57] In Rome, Cardinal Del Monte negotiates with Pope Paul V to secure Caravaggio’s safety, hinting at complex Vatican politics and financial debts.

• [05:42–06:55] In Malta, the Grandmaster holds a trial, denouncing Caravaggio and casting him out of the Knights, tightening the net around him.

Artistic Life in Exile

• [07:38–08:30] In Syracuse, Caravaggio chooses models for a new commission, demonstrating his distinctive approach:

  • “Close your eyes, please… Your complexion evokes so much.” — Caravaggio to Margarita [08:03]

• [08:30–10:34] Flashbacks to Rome reveal intimate moments with his muse Lena, and the tensions between sensuality, art, and survival:

  • “He once said he saw all life in my face.” — Lina [10:04]
  • “But we need you, our muse.” — Caravaggio [10:30]

Rising Danger and Flight

• [12:26–12:47] Receiving warnings that the Knights are closing in, Caravaggio prepares yet another escape, this time from Syracuse.

• [14:19–15:16] In Messina, he secures temporary sanctuary and continues to create, but danger looms as he is forced to move again with the Knights in pursuit.

Naples: Brief Refuge and Violent Attack

• [18:51–19:50] The Marchese di Caravaggio offers him protection and a haven in Naples—a respite filled with creative output and reflection.

  • “Paint, sleep, live. Whatever you need is here. My gardens are a refuge for the mind, the spirit, and the heart.” — Marchese di Caravaggio [19:14]

• [21:28–24:49] Caravaggio's enemies close in; disguised knights surveil him. At a raucous Neapolitan tavern, he's ambushed and almost killed:

  • “Despite the bleeding, Caravaggio grabs his rapier and slashes the first swordsman… There is pandemonium in the tavern…” [22:50–24:00]

• [24:49–26:41] In desperate flight, wounded, Caravaggio seeks sanctuary in a church, protected by a courageous friar:

  • “In the name of Christ, I grant it [sanctuary].” — Friar [26:27]
  • “Sanctuary.” — Caravaggio, repeatedly as he collapses [26:10, 26:39]

Art as Redemption and Plea

• [27:09–28:31] Recuperating, Caravaggio paints “David with the Head of Goliath,” using his bloodied features as Goliath—a gift to the Pope and a plea for pardon.

  • “He sends it as a gift… That is his face, Goliath, though now pained and wounded from his current ordeal.” — Cardinal Del Monte [27:46–27:54]

• [28:31–29:29] The Pope issues a pardon, finally offering Caravaggio hope for return to Rome.

Final Escape & Betrayal

• [32:04–34:17] At the Naples dock, he's betrayed due to the Knights’ warrant; his safe passage is disregarded, and Caravaggio is arrested and separated from his paintings.

Imprisonment and Existential Reckoning

• [35:01–37:29] In the hellish Fossa di San Elmo prison, Caravaggio faces disease, violence, and existential terror. Here, he is both victim and fighter.

• [39:31–41:08] Aloff Stefano, the Grandmaster, visits him in his cell—posing questions about faith, love, and artistic purpose:

  • “Does faith guide your hand?” — Aloff Stefano [40:13]
  • “My questions guide me.” — Caravaggio [40:23]
  • “Who is your God?” — Aloff Stefano [40:28]
  • “The faces I paint.” — Caravaggio [40:34]
  • “But my painting saved your soul.” — Caravaggio [40:55]
  • “Was not my love dear to you?” — Aloff Stefano [41:04]
  • “How could I love what I fear?” — Caravaggio [41:11]

Final Days and Death

• [42:24–45:54] Freed but gravely ill, Caravaggio struggles through swamp and heat, pursued by fever, hallucinations, and guilt.

  • “I tried to find that harmony between what I saw and how I lived and failed.” — Caravaggio [45:35]
  • “There is a life going on beyond this life. A life that separates us from all our mistakes, from accidents and pain.” — Caravaggio [45:54]

• [46:40–47:03] Two nuns and a young boy attempt to comfort him on a sun-bleached beach.

  • “That is how God has been to me all my life. Just out of reach.” — Caravaggio [46:40]
  • “The light tells me to love the mystery and then let go.” — Caravaggio [46:48]

• [47:03–47:44] Word of Caravaggio's death reaches Cardinal Del Monte and Pope Paul V in Rome; his paintings are gathered, his legend set.

• [48:40–48:59] Aloff Stefano finds Caravaggio dying and offers a final, fraught moment of forgiveness.

  • “Forgive me.” — Aloff Stefano [48:40]
  • “What you see in the art, you will find in the artist. And what you see in the artist, you will find in the man.” — Caravaggio [48:59]

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

• “A man with a gentle soul painted it… a wretched soul, yes, but not a murderer.” — Cardinal Del Monte discussing Caravaggio's painting [05:07]
• “Without a pardon from the Pontiff, I will never be safe.” — Caravaggio [12:43]
• “All my sins are mortal.” — Caravaggio, refusing holy water [16:37]
• “They would need an army to pry you from me.” — Marchese di Caravaggio, on Caravaggio’s protection [19:35]
• The tavern fight sequence: Caravaggio wounded, fighting for his life, barely escapes with the help of a courtesan’s warning [23:00–24:49]
• The sanctuary scene: A friar, risking his own life, defies the Knights to shield Caravaggio inside the church [25:31–26:49]
• “The faces I paint.” — Caravaggio, when asked what guides him [40:34]
• “But my painting saved your soul.” — Caravaggio to Aloff Stefano [40:55]
• “How could I love what I fear?” — Caravaggio, in a moving final encounter [41:11]
• “I tried to find that harmony between what I saw and how I lived and failed.” — Caravaggio [45:35]
• “What you see in the art, you will find in the artist. And what you see in the artist, you will find in the man.” — Caravaggio’s final words [48:59]

Timestamps for Key Segments

• [00:54] Caravaggio’s arrival in Syracuse, Sicily
• [03:07] Political maneuvering in Rome about Caravaggio's fate
• [05:42] Caravaggio is formally expelled from the Knights of Malta
• [08:30] Studio scenes with Lena—insight into Caravaggio’s artistic mind
• [12:26] Caravaggio flees once more as knights approach
• [19:09] Sanctuary in Naples—Marchese offers protection
• [22:50–24:49] Violent ambush at the tavern and flight through the night
• [26:31] Dramatic sanctuary in the church; tension with the friar and knights
• [27:09] Painting of “David with the Head of Goliath”—art mirrors life
• [28:31] The Pope’s pardon arrives
• [34:12] Betrayal at the dock; Caravaggio arrested
• [35:01–37:29] Prison brutality in Fossa di San Elmo
• [39:31–41:15] Confrontation with Grandmaster; meditations on faith, art, love, and fear
• [45:35–46:55] Final moments on the beach—Caravaggio’s last existential reflection
• [48:40–48:59] Final forgiveness and Caravaggio’s death

Episode's Tone & Style

The episode’s tone is somber, intense, and richly evocative of both Baroque drama and existential struggle, with moments of tenderness, menace, and philosophical depth. The script fuses historical grandeur with emotional rawness—mirroring Caravaggio’s own paintings. Dialogues are delivered with period-appropriate formality, yet pulse with humanity and urgency.

Conclusion

Caravaggio – Act 3 is a powerful audio journey through the artist’s final days—full of political intrigue, artistic revelation, violent peril, and existential searching. It also stands as a meditation on creative genius in a world that can both destroy and immortalize its visionaries. The script, performances, and immersive audio surround listeners in every brush stroke, shadow, and emotion of Caravaggio’s tempestuous life and legacy.

For more episodes: TableReadPodcast.com