John Strand (8:37)
I do. And this is going to monologue and I apologize, but no one here is not used to that, so. Cory Doctorow presentation. The coming war on general purpose computing is absolute reading for anybody to understand where we're at. This is not about security, even though security is part of it. It's predominantly about how you can lock people into an ecosystem to where the only way that they can load apps is through your store, that they get a percentage in the cut from the sales on that. So an example would be I have an app. Let's say. I want to say, let's. Oh, Kindle. All right, so if I have a Kindle app on my iPhone, right? If I want to buy a book on my Kindle app, it has to take me to my browser, which is logged into Amazon, and then I can purchase the book. And the reason why Kindle is doing that is because iOS and Apple have made it that if you have any in app purchases, then they want their percentage and they want their cut of every single one of those purchases. So it's not about security for a lot of this stuff. It's all about making money on these particular things, right? So if you're looking at this, Google wants to do the same thing. Because with Google, you can enable third party applications. I remember Fortnite, you used to have to install Fortnite using third party applications and enabling it and then downloading it. It was a pain in the ass. But the reason why is inside of Fortnite you could have in game purchases and they wanted to do that outside of the Google Play ecosystem. So what's happening now is you have Microsoft, Google and of course Apple that are forcing everything to go through their ecosystems, right? You have to go through their stores, you have to go through their verification for absolutely everything that you do. And this bothers me for a couple of reason. One, it does somewhat help security, I think, but we see lots of examples of malicious apps making it through. The other reason why this bothers me is it does actually make security testing more difficult. With a general purpose computer, you can download software, you can install it, you can evaluate that software relatively easily. With these particular ecosystems it's not very easy. Like getting root level access on your device, while possible, is not a given in these particular fields. So that means that there's wide areas of places that are not going to get the level of scrutiny and research that we talk about all the time on this show. Dealing with privacy, right? How much are apps giving data away about you that you don't feel comfortable them giving away? The problem with that is in these types of ecosystems it becomes more and more difficult for us to identify how much of our privacy is being lost. So this is bad for a number of reasons. It's just one more notch that's turning and honestly we need a full true open source Linux phone. I know people talk about Libre phones and I can't remember the graphene. Yeah, graphene OS and all of that. We need these things. But they're making it more and more difficult to install these third parties onto existing hardware platforms. With like even now you used to be able to get a pixel and you could install a bunch of these third party operating systems onto existing pixels and they're discontinuing that pixel line and making it more difficult. So there's a lot wrong with this. Difficult to test the security, it's difficult to validate the privacy and issues. Especially as we're moving into the age of AI, it's getting more and more locked in to where you're spending more and more money just trying to get third party apps to work. And they're taking a bigger and bigger cut out of it. We're getting higher and higher into the oligarchy scale. And I'll leave one thing, if you want to look up something terrifying, look up the GENIE index. Geni index has to do with the number of economic dispersion. A1 would be everyone makes the same amount of money. A100 means that only one person makes the money. And no one makes any other money. No one makes anything else. Right. The French Revolution happened at a Genie index of 82 and we are currently at 83. So there's more and more consolidation into these oligarchs, into these people running these apps. We need diversity, we need competition, we need open source platforms, but they keep getting cut back. So that's my rant on that and I'm going to step back.