Tangle Announcer (3:50)

Thanks Isaac and welcome everybody. Here are your quick hits for today. First, a shooter killed two people and wounded six others at a school in Madison, Wisconsin. The suspect, identified as a teenage girl, died of a self inflicted gunshot wound and authorities have not announced a motive. Number two, German Chancellor Olaf Scholz lost a vote of confidence in the German Parliament, prompting the dissolution of Parliament and triggering early elections, which will be held in February. Scholz will remain in office until Parliament elects a new chancellor. Separately, Canada's finance Minister, Chrystia Freeland, resigned abruptly over policy disagreements with Prime Minister Justin Trudeau, including a dispute on handling potential tariffs on Canadian imports by President Donald Trump's administration. Elsewhere, Ukraine said it had killed a senior Russian general in a targeted assassination in Moscow. Number three, Alexander Smirnov, a former FBI informant, pleaded guilty to making false statements that the head of the Ukrainian energy company Burisma had paid both President Biden and his son Hunter $5 million. These claims led to a House GOP investigation into the Biden family's business activities. Number four, Judge Juan Merchand ruled that President Elect Trump's conviction in his New York hush money case was valid, rejecting Trump's team's efforts to dismiss the conviction after the Supreme Court's ruling on presidential immunity. And number five, the Justice Department charged two men with conspiring to export sensitive technology used in a drone attack in Jordan that killed American troops earlier this year to Iran.

John Mull (5:35)

In one of the final major acts of his administration. President Biden commuted the sentences of roughly 1500 people Thursday and pardoned another 39. The White House called it the largest single day act of clemency in modern history. It comes just over a week after Biden's highly criticized decision to grant his son Hunter Biden a broad pardon for any crimes he has or may have committed over the past decade.

Tangle Announcer (6:01)

On Thursday, President elect Joe Biden announced the largest single day act of clemency in modern American history, commuting the sentences of roughly 1,500 people who were moved from prison to serve home confinement sentences during the pandemic. Additionally, Biden pardoned 39Americans convicted of nonviolent crimes. The pardons and commutations exceeded the previous single day record set by Barack Obama, who commuted the sentences of 330 people on his final day in office in 2017. Biden said he would continue to review clemency petitions through the end of his term. As a reminder, a pardon completely absolves someone of guilt, while a commutation reduces the sentence of a crime without forgiving the person who was convicted. Both pardons and commutations are forms of clemency. Article 2, Section 2 of the Constitution gives presidents the power to grant reprieves and pardons for federal crimes. Presidential pardon power is expansive but not limitless. Presidents can only pardon offenses against the United States, meaning state criminal offenses and civil penalties cannot be pardoned by a President. The Supreme Court has said that pardon power is intended to be a tool to offer mercy and grace to the convicted and that the power should be used to further public welfare. Earlier this month, President Biden came under fire for issuing a far reaching pardon for his son Hunter, who was facing prison time for tax and gun crimes. The pardon covered a nearly decade long period of behavior. We covered that story and there's a link in today's episode. Description Many of Biden's commutations and pardons did not garner attention, but the commutations of two former elected officials drew harsh criticism. One was Pennsylvania Judge Michael Conahan, who was convicted in 2011 in the cash for Kids scandal, taking kickbacks for profit detention centers in exchange for wrongly sending juveniles to prison. More than 4,000 juvenile convictions were thrown out due to the scheme. Conahan's house arrest was set to end in 2026. Biden's second controversial commutation was for Rita Crundwell, a former comptroller in Dixon, Illinois who pleaded guilty to a $54 million embezzlement scheme in 2012, now considered the largest municipality fraud in U.S. history. Crundwell was slated to be released from house arrest in 2028. Of the 39 pardoned individuals, many committed non violent drug offenses in their youth and had served in the US Military. Today we're going to examine the reactions from the right and the left of Biden's clemency and then Isaac's take.

Isaac Saul (8:43)

We'll be right back after this quick break.

Ryan Reynolds (8:49)

Ryan Reynolds here from Mint Mobile. With the price of just about everything going up during inflation, we thought we'd bring our prices down. So to help us, we brought in a reverse auctioneer, which is apparently a.

Isaac Saul (8:59)

Thing Mint Mobile Unlimited Premium wireless everybody get 30, 30 better get 30 better.

Tangle Announcer (9:04)

Get 20, 2020 better get 20, 20 better get 15, 151515 just 15 bucks.

Ryan Reynolds (9:08)

A month so give it a try@mintmobile.com.

Mint Mobile Announcer (9:11)

Switch $45 upfront payment equivalent to $15 per month new customers on first three month plan only taxes and fees Extra speed slower above 40gb detail holiday magic is in the air and DSW's got all the shoes to make your season extra merry. Believe you've got parties to attend and lists to check twice, so DSW is taking care of the details like gifts to make their eyes all aglow. Styles that bring joy to your world. Brands everyone wants like Ugg, Nike, Birkenstock and more and deals to make your budget bright. Find the perfect shoes for you and yours at a DSW store near you or dsw.com.

Tangle Announcer (9:56)

All right, first up, let's start with what the right is saying. The right is mostly critical of the commutations and pardons, arguing Biden's blanket approach was rife with flaws. Some frame the move as an abuse of power in a presidency filled with them. Others defend the practice of clemency while questioning Biden's use of it. In the Washington Examiner, Quinn Hillier said Biden's mass pardons are unpardonable. Presidential pardons and commutations can be good policy if judiciously awarded to deserving recipients. However, Biden is handing out blanket pardons for entire classes of crimes. Not only does this practice significantly violate the intent of pardoned power, but in practice it means that wholly undeserving convicts, some of whom committed crimes that should not be forgiven, will have their records unjustly cleansed, hillier wrote. The one attracting the most criticism, deservedly so, is the judge who took bribes to send children to for profit juvenile prisons with sentences disproportionate to their crimes and one of the children killed himself. These aren't people who committed victimless crimes or ones whose sentences were disproportionate to the offense. These aren't people who particularly distinguished themselves with unusually good deeds after serving time and who just need their records cleansed so they can regain their right to vote and the ability to get jobs and bank loans, hillier said. These people received sentences commensurate with the major crimes but were already getting a break from prison because of a pandemic that is no longer existent. Now Biden is giving them for no good reason, the added benefit of a full release. In PJ Media, Rick Moran wrote, biden abuses his power of clemency as he has abused all his other powers. The urge to create the illusion that the President is a good and just man is just too much to resist. Joe Biden is no different as far as the urge to be seen as doing good is concerned. Where he separates himself from normal run of the mill presidents is in the scale of his do gooderism, moran said. Biden's recent pardon of his own son Hunter complicates his moves to grant clemency to anyone. Hunter would have been convicted of a gun crime, tax fraud and several other crimes for which Americans are rotting in jail. I'm sure the families of many nonviolent criminals who remain locked up wonder about the President's compassion for his son and not their loved ones. The commutations are an abuse of the President's clemency power. Historically, clemency for the most part has been granted selectively and carefully. But Biden's mania for being the first president to name someone of this race or gender to an important job, or to be the first President to visit this or that country, or be the first President to do the most, the largest, the most spectacular, the most awe inspiring feat in history knows no bounds. In Fox News, Brett L. Tolman argued clemency is good policy. The one day record breaking commutations of 1,500Americans in home confinement by President Joe Biden is good policy. Despite being an unabashedly transparent political salve for the wound caused by his nepotistic blanket pardon of his son, Hunter Tolman wrote, the commutation of the individuals on the CARES act home confinement is warranted. It's one of the most successful criminal justice initiatives in this country with a 3.7% recidivism rate, a fraction of the national average. These individuals were held accountable for their crimes and through changed behavior and abiding the law a majority are succeeding outside a carceral setting. Clemency is not an act of leniency. Sentencing laws must be applied consistently to every American, and clemency should never be shrouded in secrecy or offered as favors to family or financially well connected individuals. While Biden's apparent misuse of his presidential clemency powers overshadows the likely January 6th pardons from President Elect Donald Trump, we cannot afford to forget the thousands of deserving Americans in our federal prisons already serving disproportionately long sentences, often longer than they would receive if sentenced today. Alright, that is it for what the right is saying. Which brings us to what the left is saying. The left is mixed on Biden's acts, with many suggesting they are a more defensible use of presidential power than Hunter's partner pardon. Some say Biden's criteria for clemency was overly broad and offensive to some crime victims. Others argued Biden should pursue more commutations before leaving office, the New York Daily News editorial board wrote. Unlike Hunter's pardon, Biden's clemency grants are just as President Joe Biden heads to the end of his time in the Oval Office, he is leaving with an act of compassion for those serving unnecessarily long federal prison sentences and who have perhaps been targeted by punitive laws that no longer fit in with our contemporary understandings of fairness and proportionality, the board said. These grants of clemency were done the right way through the Department of Justice Office of the Pardon Attorney under regular procedures. Unlike how he broke his word and conferred on his legitimately convicted but not sentenced son, Hunter, a full and unconditional pardon. Many of the sentences commuted would have been initially lower if they had been handed down. Plus, a chunk of these pardons have been for crimes that no longer exist in their current form or that we don't consider very serious, the board wrote. In some important ways, the commutations are a recognition that some laws and sentencing guidelines were disproportionate and contrary to what should be the ultimate goal of criminal to issue some punishment, yes, but also to be dissuasive and to at least allow for the prospect of people returning to their lives with the ability and resolve to live better lives. In the Washington Post, Heather Long criticized the broken presidential pardon process. My jaw dropped when I saw Michael Konahan, a former judge involved in a notorious Kids for Cash scandal in Pennsylvania among the nearly 1,500 people President Joe Biden granted clemency to last week. The White House portrayed the mass clemency as an historic moment for justice. But Conahan's commutation only underscores how broken the presidential pardon and clemency process is, Long said. An administration official said this wasn't a case by case decision. The Biden team set broad criteria and Conahan matched them. That explanation isn't going down well with many. In Pennsylvania, Democratic governor Josh Shapiro called the clemency absolutely wrong. Some victims are speaking out in shock. For Biden, this is another unforced error. More broadly, it raises fresh questions about presidential clemency going too far and whether it should exist at all. There was outrage when former President Donald Trump pardoned allies as Stephen K. Bannon, Paul Manafort and Charles Kushner Long wrote. Such dubious grants of presidential mercy reinforce a belief that America has a two tiered justice system where the wealthy and connected fare much better than everyone else and certainly better than the young people who came before Judges Conahan and Ciavarella in Luzerne county for the Brennan Center, Lauren Brook Eisen called Biden's move a good start. President Biden's historic clemency announcement Thursday is welcome news. It's a major step in the right direction and a recognition of the excessively punitive nature of our criminal justice system. But there are thousands of additional people who still deserve clemency. Encouragingly, the White House added that the president is continuing to review more clemency options. Eisen said Biden campaigned on a pledge to strengthen America's commitment to justice and reform our criminal justice system. One way for him to ensure that his justice policies have a lasting legacy is by more fully using the clemency power. Starting on January 20, Donald Trump will have the power to reverse many of the current administration's policies. He has already promised as much, vowing to reinstitute the federal death penalty, but he cannot reverse acts of clemency, eisen wrote. We are still hopeful that Biden will grant clemency to the more than 40 people on federal death row whose sentences can be commuted to life without parole and more than 6,000 serving racially disparate drug sentences. All right, let's head over to Isaac for his take.

Isaac Saul (18:26)

All right, that is it for what the left and the right are saying. Which brings us to my take. So I'm going to be honest here. I was shocked by a few of Biden's decisions. In particular, the commutation of Michael Conahan's sentence just left me staring at my computer in disbelief. The Kids for Cash scheme is as horrific as the name sounds, it is notorious in my home state of Pennsylvania. Conahan was literally, literally destroying children's lives for money, sending them to privately owned juvenile detention centers for crimes like making fun of a principal on MySpace, often maximizing his kickbacks by imposing the harshest sentences possible. One of the children Conahan sentenced killed himself after being put behind bars. That child's mom, Sandy Fonzo, became famous for confronting the other judge involved in this kickback scheme outside a courthouse after the commutation was announced, she was interviewed. I'm shocked and I am hurt, she said. Conahan's actions destroyed families, including mine, and my son's death is a tragic reminder of the consequences of his abuse of power. This pardon feels like an injustice for all of us who still suffer. Right now, I'm processing and doing the best I can to cope with the pain that this has brought back. How could anyone not agree? It's hard to imagine an act less deserving of clemency than putting children in prison for trumped up crimes or extending sentences they already had in exchange for money. If anything, Conahan's sentence of 17 years felt inadequate to many in Pennsylvania, especially given he's been serving the last few outside of prison. Rita Cronwell, the other commutation we cited in the introduction, was similarly gobsmacking. At a time of populist resentment and distrust of institutions, Crunwell is the poster child for corruption. She committed the largest municipal fraud in U.S. history, stealing over $50 million from a town of 16,000 people in the span of 20 years. Crunwell spent the money on four dozen cars, a horse breeding operation and real estate purchases. As with Conahan, Biden has made no attempt to justify Cronwell's commutation. I also want to highlight one more case of clemency. Jim Carlson. I hadn't heard Carlson's story before Biden commuted his sentence, but he was sentenced for running a synthetic drug ring in Minnesota that sold enough synthetic drugs to cause a public health crisis in Duluth. Carlson reportedly used his own employees as guinea pigs to test how the unregulated drugs worked on customers and misbranded the drugs as incense, bath salts and glass cleaner to sell them out of his shop. Given the impact these people had on their communities, I think it's worth considering how those communities actually reacted to Biden's acts. Pennsylvania governor Josh Shapiro, a Democrat speaking about the Conahan clemency, said Biden got it absolutely wrong and created a lot of pain here in Northeastern Pennsylvania. Minnesota Senator Amy Klobuchar, also a Democrat, said that while some of the pardons were probably worthy, there were a number that I think make no sense at all, seemingly referring to Carlson. And Danny Landgloss, the current city manager of Dixon, Illinois, where Cronwell stole over $50 million, said the city is, quote, shocked and outraged with the announcement that President Biden has given Rita Cronwell clemency for the largest municipal embezzlement in the history of our country. This is a complete travesty of justice and a slap in the face for our entire community. The 39 pardons that Biden granted, as well as many hundreds of commutations, appear to be fair or even just. Many were nonviolent crimes involving people who had served lengthy sentences and worked to rehabilitate themselves. Clemency petitions often come with powerful details of what convicted criminals have been doing since they were put behind bars. And many of these people have spent years helping others and trying to repair the damage they've done. Others were simply serving extended sentences for crimes that are no longer punished with long sentences, and it makes sense to allow those people to go back to their lives. Granting clemency to the trio of Conahan, Cromwell and Carlson doesn't fit at all with those ideals. The administration has framed the clemency as an act of mercy before the holidays, justifying the decisions by saying the cases they commuted fit a broad set of criteria and didn't get into the specifics of these cases. But an anonymous administration official told Politico the White House had not considered any of the troubling details around cases like Conahan's a jarring revelation, considering what he was convicted of. Granting commutations in masks based on broad criteria is a dangerous and insufficient way to handle pardons. And commuting their sentences completely overshadows the rest of what Biden was trying to do, and rightfully so. We are living in a time where diseases of despair like addiction and suicide are everywhere. We're living in a time where mistrust of the judicial system is at an all time high and vigilante justice is being celebrated. We're living in a time where the government is viewed as incompetent and corrupt. And in this moment, Biden gives reprieve to a corrupt judge who destroyed children's lives, a corrupt government official who stole millions from a small town, and a shop owner who used his place in the community to poison people with synthetic drugs. It's just hard to understand, and it's impossible to support. We'll be right back after this quick break.

Ryan Reynolds (23:57)

Ryan Reynolds here for Mint Mobile. One of the perks about having four kids that you know about is actually getting a direct line to the big man up north. And this year he wants you to know the best gift that you can give someone is the gift of Mint Mobile's Unlimited Wireless for $15 a month. Now you don't even need to wrap it. Give it a try@mintmobile.com Switch $45 upfront.

Mint Mobile Announcer (24:19)

Payment required equivalent to $15 per month New customers on first three month plan only taxes and fees Extra Speed slower above 40 GB on unlimited. See mintmobile.com for details.

Progressive Announcer (24:28)

This episode is brought to you by Progressive Insurance. Do you ever find yourself playing the budgeting game? Well, with the name your price tool from Progressive, you can find options that fit your budget and potentially lower your bills. Try it@progressive.com Progressive Casualty Insurance Company and affiliates Price and coverage match limited by state law not available in all states.

Isaac Saul (25:00)

All right, that is it for my take today, which brings us to your questions answered. This one is from Jim in Ashland, Oregon. Jim wrote Elon Musk recently said that the F35, the combat aircraft design was broken at the requirements level because it was required to be too many things to too many people. This made it an expensive and complex jack of all trades, master of none. Success was never in the set of possible outcomes. And manned fighter jets are obsolete in the age of drones anyway. They will just get pilots killed. End quote. I totally agree with Mr. Musk, especially his fourth sentence I've said for a few years now. Why are we still building manned fighters like the F35 instead of unmanned fighter drones? With fighter drones you don't need to spend millions of dollars to train pilots, risk their lives, and suffer all of the human foibles such as fatigue. If we are serious about reining in our huge deficits, which I doubt, we could reduce the defense budget without adversely impacting our defenses by ending the F35 program right now. What do you think? Okay, so this is a repeated mantra around the virtual tangle water cooler. If you are serious about cutting federal spending, then you have to look at the biggest areas where the federal government spends money right now. That's healthcare 13%, defense 14%, Medicare 16% and Social Security 20% in line items that big, I'm sure you'll find some significant excessive spending somewhere. And Musk comments about the F35, they sound right to me. Now I'll add a couple important caveats to this. First of all all of the largest spending categories are probably not that big primarily because of waste, but because they serve a vital and far reaching need. What could be more important to our country than our national security and the health and welfare of our citizens? And I also know what many of you will say about Social Security that it's our money, we paid into it ourselves and we deserve the benefits that come from that. That's a bit oversimplified, but still the program is so popular that it's very difficult to curtail. Then there's the issue of things like scapegoating. When we read about healthcare inefficiencies, we often hear about PBMs Pharmacy benefit managers as big drivers of costs. However, they're also talked about like the big bad boogeyman in healthcare. And they aren't. The issues in our healthcare system are complex, deep rooted and many. The same is true for military spending. I can't tell you how many articles I've read about the F35's $2 trillion price tag. I'm not going to sit here and tell you those articles are wrong and that the jet is worth the cost. In fact, I think the jet is probably overpriced and that Musk is probably right. I just want to be cautious not to say let's scrap the F35 and call the problem solved. In my most optimistic read, I think finding inefficiencies like this are exactly what Musk and the Doge Committee could do best, and I hope he keeps doing it. All right with that, I'm going to send it back to John for the rest of the podcast and I'll see you guys tomorrow. Have a good one.

Tangle Announcer (27:58)

Thanks, Isaac. Here's your under the radar story for today, folks. On Friday, the consulting firm McKinsey & Co. Agreed to pay $650 million to resolve criminal and civil investigations into its work advising opioids manufacturer Purdue Pharma. Federal prosecutors charged McKinsey's U.S. branch with conspiring to misbrand a drug, an obstruction of justice for its efforts to help Purdue boost sales of OxyContin, a painkiller widely viewed as the catalyst of the opioid crisis. As part of the agreement, McKinsey admitted that it chose to continue working with Purdue despite knowing the risks of OxyContin, and that it had advised the company to turbocharge sales of the drug. USA Today has this story and there's a link in today's episode description alright, next up is our numbers sect the number of people granted clemency by President Biden prior to last week's announcement was 161. The number of men and women, respectively, whose sentences were commuted by President Biden is 1,217 and 282. The median age of those granted clemency by Biden is 51. The number of people who were granted clemency who had less than a year left in their sentence was 769. The percentage of US adults who approve of presidents having the power to pardon or commute prison sentences of people convicted of federal crimes is 51%, according to an August 2024 YouGov poll. The approximate percentage of Biden's total acts of clemency that have been granted during his final fiscal year in office, though his term is ongoing, is 90%, according to Pew Research. The percentage of President Trump's total acts of clemency that came during his final fiscal year in office was 84%, and the percentage of President Obama's total acts of clemency that came during his final fiscal year in office was 61%. And last but not least, our have a nice day story. Max Goldberg, a Philadelphia resident and DIY project enthusiast, had an old sports display clock and an idea using publicly available data about the bus system. Goldberg Gold set out to link the clock to the bus system so that the clock would show the number of minutes until the next bus arrived. The successfully created clock now sits in his front window, where individuals waiting for the bus can clearly view it. If I can do anything to make public transit a little less annoying for people, goldberg said, I feel like it's my duty. The Philadelphia Inquirer has this story and there's a link in today's episode description. All right everybody, that is it for today's episode. As always, if you'd like to support our work, Please go to readtangle.com and sign up for a membership. You can also go to tanglemedia.supercast.com to sign up for a premium podcast membership, which gets you ad free daily podcasts, Friday editions, Sunday editions, interviews, bonus content and so much more. We'll be right back here tomorrow. For Isaac and the rest of the crew, this is John Mull signing off. Have a great day, y'all. Peace.

Isaac Saul (31:14)

Our podcast is written by me, Isaac Saul, and edited and engineered by John Wall. The script is edited by our Managing editor, Ari Weitzman, Will K Back, Bailey Saul and Sean Brady. The logo for our podcast was designed by Magdalena Bokova, who is also our social Media manager. Music for the podcast was produced by Diet 7 years. If you're looking for more from Tangle, Please go to readtangle.com and check out our website.

US Cellular Announcer (31:54)

Gifting is hard, but here's a hint. Give the gift of connection from US Cellular. Not sure what that means. Well, here's a slightly more specific hint. You can choose four free phones and get four lines for $90 a month from US Cellular. Your family wants new phones? How do we know? Well, they told us. The good news is that compared to wrapping presents, you're great at getting hints. So take the hint and get them four free phones in four lines for $90 a month. US Cellular built for us.

Progressive Announcer (32:24)

This episode is brought to you by Progressive Insurance. Do you ever find yourself playing the budgeting game? Well, with the name your price tool from Progressive, you can find options that fit your budget and potentially lower your bills. Try it@progressive.com Progressive Casualty Insurance Company and affiliates Price and coverage match limited by state law. Not available in all states.

Thumbtack Announcer (32:48)

What makes a great pair of glasses? At Warby Parker, it's all the invisible extras without the extra cost. Their designer quality frames start at $95 including prescription lenses plus scratch resistant, smudge resistant and anti reflective coatings and UV protection and free adjustments for life. To find your next pair of glasses, sunglasses or contact lenses, or to find the Warby Parker store nearest you, head over to warbyparker.com that's warbyparker.com.