Podcast Summary: Tangle - "Elon Musk Wants to Start a Party"
Released on July 10, 2025
Host: Isaac Saul

Introduction

In this episode of Tangle, host Isaac Saul delves into Elon Musk's ambitious move to establish a new political entity, the America Party. The discussion explores Musk's motivations, the potential impact on the U.S. political landscape, and the varied reactions from both the right and the left wings of the political spectrum. Additionally, Saul provides his personal analysis of Musk's prospects and addresses listener questions regarding the implications of artificial intelligence on the workforce.

Elon Musk's America Party: An Overview

Elon Musk's announcement to form the America Party marks a significant attempt to disrupt the longstanding two-party system in the United States. According to Saul, Musk aims to represent the "80% in the middle of the United States" and seeks to address issues such as reducing the federal debt, modernizing the military with artificial intelligence, and decreasing energy regulations. However, formal recognition of the party faces hurdles due to the Federal Election Commission's (FEC) current lack of quorum, preventing the approval of new parties.

Notable Quote:
Musk expressed his intentions on social media, stating, "I hope to crack the uniparty system and represent the 80% in the middle of the United States." ([05:21])

Reactions from the Right

The conservative response to Musk's America Party has been largely dismissive. Critics argue that Musk's foray into politics is premature and ill-conceived, drawing parallels to historical third-party failures.

Key Points:

• The New York Post editorial board criticized Musk's understanding of the political system, stating, "Governments just don't run like private companies." ([08:05])
• Cynical Publius highlighted the potential disconnect between Musk's business acumen and political strategy, suggesting his efforts might lead to "similar ignominy" as past third-party attempts.
• National Review's John R. Puri pointed out the structural challenges, emphasizing that Musk's focus on fiscal responsibility might alienate both GOP and Democrat voters ([08:05]).

Notable Quote:
Puri noted, "What drives the nation's gargantuan deficits is a structural mismatch between tax revenue and spending, which is primarily the result of popular demand." ([05:21])

Reactions from the Left

Progressive voices have also expressed skepticism about the viability of the America Party, often viewing it as a repackaged version of Republican ideologies without substantive differentiation.

Key Points:

• The Washington Post's Philip Bump questioned the institutional support needed for a new party, stating, "Who’s going to donate to a party created by the richest man in the world?" ([10:19])
• Ed Kilgore from New York Magazine suggested that Musk's platform closely mirrors GOP positions, making it unclear why voters would shift allegiance ([10:19]).
• Nate Cohen of The New York Times discussed the "wasted vote" problem but acknowledged that third parties could overcome it through strategic polling and leveraging competitive districts ([10:19]).

Notable Quote:
Kilgore remarked, "Musk isn't offering anything voters can't find in the right wing of the Republican Party or, barring that, in the Libertarian Party." ([10:19])

Isaac Saul’s Take

Isaac Saul offers a nuanced perspective on Musk's political ambitions. He acknowledges Musk's substantial resources and influence as advantageous for launching a third party but remains skeptical about its success due to Musk's polarizing public image and the inherent challenges of altering the entrenched two-party system.

Key Points:

• Strategic Focus: Musk’s strategy to target specific Senate and House seats could provide short-term gains without the immediate pressure of a presidential bid.
• Public Sentiment: With high numbers of self-identified independents and low approval rates for Congress, there is a fertile ground for political disruption ([19:10]).
• Economic Concerns: While Musk correctly identifies the national debt as a pressing issue, Saul believes that fiscal responsibility alone may not be sufficient to rally a broad voter base.

Notable Quote:
Saul concludes, "If you are one of those opponents of the uniparty who see Musk's third party efforts as supporting your longing for fundamental changes, consider that his central issue of minimizing the debt will serve only to draw away GOP voters." ([19:10])

Listener Question: AI and the Future of Work

A listener named David from Stanford, Connecticut, posed a question about whether increased AI productivity will lead to a shorter workweek or job reductions. The Tangle editorial team provided diverse perspectives:

• Isaac Saul: Predicts job reductions are more likely, emphasizing that while AI could theoretically enable shorter workweeks, the immediate impact is expected to be workforce reductions.
• Lindsay Knuth: Agrees with job reductions, citing current trends in layoffs across various industries due to AI integration.
• Ari Weitzman: Offers a short-term view of increased productivity without reduced hours but foresees job losses in the long term as AI continues to evolve.
• Audrey Moorhead: Highlights the impact on white-collar jobs, noting that companies are more inclined to reduce headcounts than reform work hours.
• Will Kbach: Supports the likelihood of job reductions, suggesting that companies will prefer redistributing work to fewer employees to maintain productivity.

Notable Quote:
Isaac Saul reflects, "Job reductions will almost certainly come first or are already here and will have a much broader impact." ([28:46])

Under-the-Radar Story: AI in Education

The American Federation of Teachers (AFT) announced the launch of the National Academy for AI Instruction, aiming to provide free virtual training to its 1.8 million members. Funded by AI companies like Anthropic, Microsoft, and OpenAI, the initiative seeks to integrate AI tools in classrooms while ensuring that teachers remain central to education.

Notable Quote:
CBS News reported, "The Academy aims to ensure that teachers remain at the head of the classroom as AI adoption scales." ([31:18])

Numbers Section

• Elon Musk’s Favorability: 35% favorable, 56% unfavorable as of July 9, according to the Silver Bulletin.
• Political Parties: 55 distinct ballot-qualified parties in the U.S. as of January 2025, with 238 state-level parties.
• 2024 Presidential Election: Louisiana saw the highest number of candidates on the ballot with 11.
• Public Opinion on Third Parties:
  • 58% believe a third major party is needed when combined with dissatisfaction with the Republican Party.
  • 37% hold the same view when combined with dissatisfaction with the Democratic Party (September 2024 Gallup poll).
  • Breakdown by affiliation:
    • 53% of Democrats
    • 69% of Independents
    • 48% of Republicans

Closing Remarks

Isaac Saul wraps up the episode by inviting listeners to support Tangle through memberships and previews upcoming content, including a special edition focusing on his reflections on predictions about Donald Trump's second term.

Notable Quote:
Saul hints at future content, stating, "I'm going to focus the lens a little bit. I'm going to be taking personal stock and answering the question, what have I gotten wrong about Trump's second term so far." ([31:18])

Conclusion

This episode of Tangle provides a comprehensive examination of Elon Musk's attempt to reshape the American political landscape through the formation of the America Party. By analyzing reactions from both ends of the political spectrum and offering insightful commentary, Isaac Saul presents a balanced view of the challenges and potential hurdles Musk faces. Additionally, the episode addresses broader societal concerns such as the impact of AI on employment, offering listeners diverse perspectives on these pressing issues.

For more insights and detailed discussions, subscribe to Tangle and join the conversation on transforming political discourse.