John Lowell (3:58)

Thank you Isaac and welcome everybody. I just wanted to say quickly that as a recently former Los Angeles resident, that my heart is breaking for everyone, friends, loved ones and all those affected by the fires happening in Los Angeles right now, and I'm just praying that the fires are contained and extinguished soon and that support and relief are abundant and available to everyone who needs it. Here are your quick hits for today. First up, multiple wildfires continue to burn across Los Angeles county, with at least 130,000 residents under evacuation orders. The largest of the fires, the Palisades Fire, has burned 17,234 acres and is 0% contained as of Thursday morning. At least five people are dead and 2,000 structures have burned as a result of the fires. Separately, all water storage tanks in the Palisades area went dry on Wednesday morning, leaving fire hydrants with little to no water. City officials blamed the tremendous demand for water. Number two, union dock workers and port employers announced a tentative agreement on a new six year contract averting a potential strike at east coast and Gulf ports. Number three Attorney General Merrick Garland said he plans to release special counsel Jack Smith's report on President elect Donald Trump's 2020 election interference case, but not his report on Trump's classified documents case, citing the ongoing cases of the president elect's co defendants. Number four Amid ongoing ceasefire negotiations, Israel announced it had recovered the body of a hostage taken during Hamas October 7th attacks. Israel believes as many as half of the 100 remaining hostages in Gaza could be dead. And number five, Fulton County District Attorney Fani Willis petitioned the Georgia Supreme Court to review an appeals court's decision disqualifying her from prosecuting President Elect Trump in his Georgia election interference case.

Isaac Saul (6:20)

My name is Jimmy Carter and I'm running for President.

John Lowell (6:24)

He went from being Jimmy who to winning the White House itself, then struggled with crises overseas and a troubled economy at home. A one term president whose time as ex president was the longest thank you all. Among the most active in American history, becoming the first American president to celebrate his 100th birthday on December 29th. Jimmy Carter, the 39th president of the United States, passed away at the age of 100. Carter served one term after defeating Gerald Ford in the 1976 election, then lost his re election bid to Ronald Reagan. Carter's administration faced several distinct challenges including double digit inflation, energy shortages and the Iran hostage crisis. His post presidency was associated with humanitarian works and efforts to address global conflicts. On Tuesday, Carter's body arrived at the U.S. capitol to lie in state. President Joe Biden declared Thursday a national day of mourning to honor Carter, whose state funeral will be later that day. Carter, who lived longer than any president in U.S. history, was a Georgia native and devout Baptist who served in the Navy early in his life. He went on to become a successful peanut farmer and community leader, then won Georgia's gubernatorial election in 1970. He rose to national prominence for his public stance against segregation as Georgia's governor and his speech at the 1972 Democratic National Convention. His 1976 campaign against Ford was buoyed by a lackluster economy and the Watergate scandal, which had led to President Richard Nixon's resignation in 1972. As president, Carter faced a litany of domestic and international predicaments at home. Societal rifts grew over racism and women's rights, while an Arab oil embargo drove up the price of gasoline and contributed to rapid inflation. Abroad, he faced a protracted hostage crisis in Iran when a group of Iranian students invaded the US embassy in Tehran, taking 66American citizens hostage. The crisis lasted 444 days and eight US service members were killed in a failed rescue mission. Separately, Carter brokered a peace treaty between Israel and Egypt, signed a strategic arms limitation agreement with the Soviet Union, and formalized diplomatic relations with China. Carter's approval rating had cratered by the end of his term and he lost in a landslide to Ronald Reagan in 1980. However, he remained active in public life after leaving office, establishing the Carter center to pursue philanthropic goals in 1982, helping volunteer efforts with Habitat for Humanity starting in 1984 and taking an active role in advising on international conflicts, sometimes to the chagrin of his successors. In 2002, he was awarded a Nobel Peace Prize for his decades of untiring effort to find peaceful solutions to international conflicts, to advance democracy and human rights, and to promote economic and social development. While Democrats and Republicans have praised Carter for his humanitarian efforts, the impact of both his presidency and post presidency remains an open debate. Today we'll explore arguments about his legacy from the left and the right, and then Isaac's take.

Isaac Saul (9:59)

We'll be right back after this quick break.

Warby Parker Ad (10:05)

Every idea starts with a problem. Warby Parker's was simple. Glasses are too expensive, so they set out to change that. By designing glasses in house and selling directly to customers, they're able to offer prescription eyewear that's expertly crafted and unexpectedly affordable. Warby Parker glasses are made from premium materials like impact resistant polycarbonate and custom acetate, and they start at just $95, including prescription lenses. Get glasses made from the good stuff. Stop by a Warby Parker store near you.

Podcast Advertising Voice (10:35)

You can trust podcasts to deliver results for your business. 80% of podcast listeners say they'll consider a brand recommendation by their favorite host. Even more impressive, 88% have taken action because of a podcast ad. If you're looking to connect with highly engaged audiences, now's the time to dive in. Download podcast Pulse 2024 for all the latest insights and see how podcast ads can drive real results for you.

John Lowell (11:08)

All right, first up, let's start with what the left is saying. The left mostly praises Carter's legacy, with many emphasizing his character and commitment to service. Some say his policies worsened the problems he sought to solve. Others say his record is unfairly maligned. In the Guardian, Representative Ro Khanna, the Democrat from California, wrote, president Jimmy Carter was an antidote to politics as spectacle. Jimmy Carter represented politics at its highest calling. He reminded me of my grandfather, Amarnath Vidyalankar, an Indian freedom fighter who served in jail as part of Gandhi's independence movement. They both shared a commitment to standing up for principle, khanna said. American politics is different these days. Colleagues on both sides scream at each other in hearings and cling to power long past their mental and physical primes. In frivolous political times like ours, Carter is a refreshing reminder that it is possible to have a politics of dignity and statesmanship. It is no wonder that he won, running on, cutting the defense budget and investing in our infrastructure and our people. Instead, when he took office, he brought a new approach to foreign policy centered on universal human rights. He brokered the historic peace agreement between Egypt and Israel, signed the Panama Canal Treaty, normalized relations with China and negotiated the SALT II arms control agreement between the United States and the Soviet Union, Khanna wrote. I remember visiting his elementary school classroom in Plains where they pointed out his desk and marveling that America had produced none. Only just a young man with such steely ambition, but one who put it in service of our highest ideals. In Jacobin, Nick French said Jimmy Carter worsened the American malaise he decried. In July 1979, Jimmy Carter described a spiritual crisis of confidence that could destroy the social and political fabric of America. But the neoliberal policies of his administration helped make the US a more atomized and mean spirited society, French wrote. These trends that Carter described seem mostly to have gotten worse. Compared to our hyper individualistic, consumption obsessed era, the United States in 1979 must have looked like a beacon of civic mindedness and self restraint. Trust in key institutionsgovernment, churches, public schools and even the news media has continued to plummet. If you wanted the malaise Carter so eloquently bemoaned to metastasize, you could do worse than enacting the very policies his own administration implemented. Cutting taxes, shrinking the welfare state, deregulating the economy and turning away from the increasingly besieged labor movement. These measures paved the way for a few at the top to grow fabulously wealthy while the majority of Americans saw their wages stagnate and their unions destroyed while suffering the consequences of the ultra rich's reckless self serving decisions. Our second Gilded Age of obscene inequality and atomization is the predictable result of such policies. In the Washington Post, Stuart Eisenstot argued history views Carter's legacy and his many accomplishments all wrong. Conventional wisdom holds that Jimmy Carter was a failure as a president, redeemed only by his philanthropy and efforts to promote democracy. In his post presidential years, Carter's accomplishments at home and abroad were more extensive and longer lasting than those of almost all modern presidents. Eisenstadt said Carter helped restore trust in the presidency through ethics reforms more relevant today than ever before. He established the Senior Executive Service and insulated civil service workers against political pressure. He slowed the revolving door for departing officials and placed independent inspectors general in every department. Carter dramatically expanded all major education policies, established the departments of Education and Energy, put the United States on the path to greater energy security from opec, the Organization of the Petroleum Exporting Countries, deregulated and transformed our entire air and ground transportation system and communications industries, placed consumer advocates in major regulatory agencies and added more land to the national park system than all presidents together since Teddy Roosevelt. Eisenstadt wrote Carter's signature achievement, reached over 13 agonizing days and nights, was the Camp David accords between Israel and Egypt. They led to a peace treaty he personally negotiated which provided security to Israel after five wars with Egypt. Alright, that is it for what the left is saying. Which brings us to what the right is saying. The right mostly criticizes Carter's legacy, suggesting that his presidency was of little historical significance. Some say Carter's greatest contribution to American politics may have been unintentional. Others push back on the praise for Carter's post presidency. In the New York Post, Philip Terzian said Jimmy Carter brought the end of an era in presidential politics. Carter turned out to be very much a transitional figure, his discordant foreign policy and modest domestic agenda more closely resembling a prolonged sunset than a glorious dawn. And he might have seen the twilight coming two years after Watergate and Richard Nixon's resignation in his surprisingly narrow victory over Nixon's appointed successor, Gerald Ford, Terzian said, for by the 1970s the New Deal and Great Society had at long last run out of steam and the Vietnam War had wounded the domestic Cold War consensus. Even the longtime Democratic monopoly on Congress was broken with the Democrats loss of the Senate along with the presidency after Carter's single term. Of course, Carter's presidency had its periodic, even ironic achievements. The Camp David accords, airline deregulation, a path breaking emphasis on human rights and US Diplomacy, Terzian said. Our chronic energy crises, Carter declared, required not just practical measures that could be negotiated with Congress but but the moral equivalent of war. Our foreign entanglements, he said, were needlessly aggravated by an inordinate fear of communism. Carter seemed genuinely surprised to learn on the job that successful governance requires a certain cynicism and horse trading skill. In the Daily Signal, Connie Marschner wrote about Carter's little known role in political history. President Jimmy Carter's personal service to the poor after he left the White House in 1981 is remembered as Christian charity in action. What is not so remembered in his role, albeit unwittingly, in bringing evangelical Christians into the political process, Marschner said. In his first days in his candidacy, Carter threw the mainstream media into a tizzy by proclaiming himself a born again Christian. As reporters scrambled to find out what that meant, Carter's self revelation gave heart to born again Christians. Finally, years after being isolated from the political process, here was somebody they could identify with, one of themselves running for president. Once elected, however, instead of dancing with the folks who brought him, Carter ignored or disavowed his Christian base and instead followed the lead of his appointees who were on the left. First came the attack on parents rights. Then came the attack on traditional family itself. In between was silence on the life issues which evangelicals had come to embrace and the steady advancement of the feminist agenda, marschner wrote. Christian leaders watched in hope that the born again president would hear their concerns and send some signal of support for traditional marriage and family, but he never did. In National Review, Philip Klein argued Carter was an even worse former President than President A popular narrative surrounding the legacy of Jimmy Carter is that as president he was a victim of unlucky timing that impeded him politically, but that he excelled during his long post presidential career. The reality is that he was a terrible president, but an even worse former president, klein said. After being booted out of office in landslide fashion, the self described citizen of the world spent the rest of his life meddling in US Foreign policy and working against the United States and its allies in a manner that could fairly be described as treasonous. His obsessive hatred of Israel and pompous belief that only he could forge Middle east peace led him to befriend terrorists and lash out at American Jews who criticized him. Carter, who performatively carried his own luggage as president, tried to present himself as humble, but somebody actually humble would have taken the hint. By the magnitude of his defeat, the real Jimmy Carter was stubborn and arrogant. He had plans for a second term and he wanted to see them through despite the overwhelming rejection by the American people. So instead of stepping away, he spent the rest of his life simply pretending that he was still president and pursuing foreign policy goals even when it meant undermining the actual president. Alright, let's head over to Isaac for his take.

Isaac Saul (20:31)

All right, that is it for what the left and the right are saying. Which brings us to my take. It is genuinely impossible to encapsulate someone like Jimmy Carter, a US President who lived to be a hundred years old, with a single through line take. So instead, here's an assortment of just 16 thoughts I have about his presidency. Number one, my most unoriginal take is one you'll see a lot of people share. He may not have had a great presidency, but he was the best ex president we ever had. Number two, Carter was one of the first truly outsider presidents in the modern era of mass media, born four years after women got the right to vote in a home that had no plumbing, electricity or insulation. It's rather difficult to articulate all he saw and overcame as a person headlining that list was overcoming Washington D.C. which he never truly seemed to like. And the feeling was mutual. Number three, you can't talk about Carter's presidency without discussing the genuinely ruinous moments that forever tarnish his legacy. He soured many of his relationships with the members of Congress he needed most early on in his presidency. In particular, he made enemies with many members of his own party, including Senator Edward Kennedy from Massachusetts, who opted to run against him in the 1980 primary. Carter prevailed before being romped by Reagan in one of the biggest landslides in US History. Number four, for context, since it's hard to really articulate how perilous the economy was in the 1970s, consider this. Inflation was rising at 1% month over month. The stock market lost 50% of its value over a 20 month period, and the Fed chairman, who came in to save the day, more on him in a little bit, raised interest rates to over 17%. This inflationary period was not Carter's fault alone, but he took the brunt of the blame from the public. Number five, Carter's presidency was ultimately defined by his most famous failure, the Iran Hostage Crisis. Carter allowed the Shah of Iran to come to the United States for medical treatment and was rewarded with a group of Iranian students invading the US embassy in Tehran and taking 66 diplomats and workers hostage. On the tail of a failed rescue attempt, a helicopter leaving Iran crashed into a transport plane and killed eight US service 52 of the hostages were held until Ronald Reagan was sworn in. Number six. Conversely, Carter ushered in a lasting peace deal between Egypt and Israel. There was a time when peace between those two nations seemed as hopeless as peace between Israelis and Palestinians. And while Carter would later be criticized for being anti Israel or even anti Semitic, his contribution to stability in the region is indisputable. Number seven. Carter governed through an era of social upheaval over the civil rights movement, high inflation, Cold War tensions, and the worst, worst hostage crisis in American history. He admitted much later that his resistance to and disdain for the Washington insiders and lobbyists damaged his presidency, though of course it was his outsider status that got him there in the first place. Number eight. All that being accounted for, I have to say the quagmire of learning about Carter is that his presidency was a time of great turbulence. But in retrospect, so much of what he said and did has actually aged pretty well. I did not live through his presidency, so I have much less of the association of him as a failed president. But learning about him, with the benefit of hindsight, I will say there is much to like. Number nine. One of the most remarkable things Carter ever did was his 10 day summit at Camp David where he literally isolated himself from the world and just took advice and listened to people over the course of a week and a half. He then turned back to the world and shared all the criticisms of his presidency he'd received during those 10 days. Genuine harsh criticism, and then tried to address it. It's truly hard to imagine any president in our era doing anything remotely like that these days, but man, I yearn for it. The speech that came out of it became infamous for how poorly it went over, ironically. But it's startling now for good reasons too. In the midst of high inflation, he had the gusto to tell Americans to conserve more fuel and warned of the threats of consumerism. He actually asked us to take control of our lives rather than rely on the government to fix it. Number 10 the crisis of confidence speech I'm referring to above is truly worth reading now. If you have a few minutes for how applicable it is to many of today's issues, here's an excerpt that still hits for me. In a nation that was proud of hard work, strong families, close knit communities, and our faith in God, too many of us now tend to worship self indulgence and consumption. Human identity is no longer defined by what one does, but by what one owns. But we've discovered that owning things and consuming things does not satisfy our longing for meaning. We've learned that piling up material goods cannot fill the emptiness of lives which have no confidence or purpose. End quote number 11 one of the most controversial things Carter ever did was pardon the Americans who dodged the Vietnam draft. It's a moment in history I wish I could dedicate an entire Tangle podcast to. And maybe we will, as the debates over whether it was the right or wrong thing to do are robust and salient. But at the very least, given all we learned about the horrors of Vietnam in the decades since, Carter's decision looks better now than it did then. Number 12 another thing Carter deserves more credit for in retrospect, is that he sacrificed his own administration's approval for the long term success and stability of the US Economy. Hiring Paul Volcker to help end US Inflation knowing full well he would raise interest rates and invite a recession was part of what doomed his presidency, but it's also part of what unlocked a prosperous future and preserved the independence of the Fed. Number 13 no reflection on Carter's legacy is complete without mention of his wife Rosalynn, who goes down as one of the most influential and notable first ladies in American history number 14 the thing I admired most about President Carter was his genuine love for the American people. Little things like exiting his motorcade and walking Pennsylvania Ave. After being inaugurated or wearing casual clothes during fireside chats are what a lot of older Americans will remember about him. But he also did the hard and challenging things very few presidents do now, like telling Americans things they don't want to hear. He ran on a campaign promise to never lie, and he upheld that promise better than most politicians have. Number 15 Ultimately, Carter's strongest legacy is what he did after he left the White House. Among other things, Carter and the Carter center have monitored hundreds of elections in dozens of countries, helped eradicate diseases, treated millions of sick people in remote countries, worked on diplomatic missions for both Republicans and Democrats, and helped negotiate a peace deal between North Korea and the United States. Carter ultimately won a Nobel Peace Prize in 2002 for his work to resolve international conflicts and promote democracy. Amidst all of this, he also took the time to do the small things like teaching Sunday School. Number 16 One way to interpret Carter's post presidency actions was that he was motivated by the failures of his presidency to make the most of his life as a private citizen. I think that is a fair read and one the man himself would probably have accepted. But like most things, Carter's legacy is not black and white. He wasn't simply a failed president and he wasn't simply a model citizen. He was both and more than either of those simple descriptions can capture. We can learn a lot from his mistakes, his successes, and most of all, his vision of what a great country and great citizen really is. We'll be right back after this quick break.

Warby Parker Ad (28:28)

What makes a great pair of glasses? At Warby Parker? It's all the invisible extras without the extra cost. Their designer quality frames start at $95 including prescription lenses plus scratch resistant, smudge resistant and anti reflective coatings and UV protection and free adjustments for life to find your next pair of glasses, sunglasses or contact lenses, or to find the Warby Parker store nearest you, head over to warbyparker.com that's warbyparker.com hey marketers, are.

Podcast Advertising Voice (28:59)

You ready to discover the latest trends in podcast advertising? The podcast Pulse Report by Acast is out now, packed with fresh audience insights into why podcasts are a must have marketing strategy. Learn how podcast audiences are more engaged than ever, why hosts are trusted voices for brands, and how niche shows are delivering massive impact. Download the report today at podcastpulse2024.acast.com foreign.

Isaac Saul (29:34)

That is it for my take? Which brings us to your questions answered. This one is from an anonymous listener in Washington, D.C. who said, why did you choose not to mention the January 6th insurrection in your January 6th, 2025 newsletter, especially in the context of the US House certifying President elect Donald Trump's Electoral College ballot count? I was at work on January 6th, 2021 with my boss, a US Congressman, and the terror of that day still looms large in my memory. So my short answer is the same thing I tell everyone who asks why we didn't include one story or another in our daily coverage. We thought other things were more relevant and worth focusing on that day. When we came back from break, we knew that we had a pressing story to cover with the attack in New Orleans and a big story on the back burner with the H1B visa debate. An event that occurred over four years ago or the uneventful certifying of the election results just wasn't going to be something we gave priority to. That said, I know there are good rebuttals to that point. If it wasn't the main story, why not at least mention it was part of our coverage somewhere? Why wasn't it an under the radar piece or a quick hit? It's the first certification of an election since the capitol riots in 2021. Isn't that a newsworthy event? To be really blunt, no, not really. After every election except one, January 6th has come and gone is little more than a formality. The same was true in 2025. The one year was different. We covered it a lot, and we've written about it a lot since then, including covering the anniversary of January 6th a couple times. Even as a retrospective now, we just didn't have anything new or interesting to say about it, so we didn't say anything about it. That isn't to say that the January 6 riot wasn't a major event, and I get that anniversaries are significant, but our role in the media landscape is to cover debates and break through the partisan bias to give A full, reliable 360 degree view of the news of the day. In that role, we didn't really have a news event related to January 6th to cover in depth. And as an extra feature, we didn't think we'd have anything valuable to say about January 6th that we haven't already said before. So that's the answer. Quick reminder, you can ask questions that you want answered in the podcast by filling out a form that is linked to in our episode description or writing in to staffeadtangle.com with the subject line Listener question. I'm going to send it back to John for the rest of the pod and we'll see you guys tomorrow for the end of year 2024 grading of our work. We'll see you then.

John Lowell (32:07)

Thanks Isaac. Here's your under the radar story for today fol On Tuesday, US Secretary of State Antony Blinken accused the Sudanese paramilitary Rapid Support Forces of committing genocide and said that the United States would impose sanctions on the group's leader, Mohammad Hamdan de Galo, also known as Hemedti, and associated businesses. Blinken outlined an extensive set of allegations against the RSF and allied militias, including systematic murder of civilians and sexual violence against women. The group has been fighting the Sudanese military since April of 2023, during which an estimated 150,000 people have been killed. The new sanctions bar Hamadti from traveling to the United states and target 7 RSF owned companies based in the United Arab Emirates in an attempt to curb the group's weapons procurement. The BBC has this story and there's a link in today's episode Description alright, next up is our numbers Sect the number of electoral votes won by Jimmy Carter in the 1976 election is 297. The number of electoral votes won by Jimmy Carter in the 1980 election was 49. Carter's approval rating in February 1977 was 66%, according to Gallup. Carter's approval rating in December of 1980 was 34%. Carter's average approval rating during his presidency, the third lowest of any U.S. president since World War II, not including President Joe Biden, was 45.5%. The percentage of Americans who said they approved of Carter's job performance as president when asked in June of 2023 was 57%, according to Gallup. The number of seats lost by Democrats in the House of representatives in the 1978 midterm elections was 11, the slimmest seat loss of a party whose president was below 50% approval. And the number of times Carter finished In the top 10 in Gallup's annual Most Admired Man Polluted was 29, third most of any public figure since the poll began. And last but not least, our have a nice day story. Jason Stalter is part of an inmate club in the Penitentiary of New Mexico in Santa Fe. Clubs span a variety of topics, including religion, fitness and gardening. Each year, the groups raise money to give back to the community. This year, incarcerated individuals across New Mexico donated $15,000 to charities like the Ronald McDonald House and the Children's Cancer Fund and to pay for the school lunch debt of all local students. Stalter commented about the clubs and donations, saying, we've made a mistake and now we want to rejoin our community in a positive way. Koat has this story and there's a link in today's episode description all right everybody, that is it for today's episode. As always, if you'd like to support our work, Please go to retangle.com and sign up for a membership. You can also go to tanglemedia.supercast.com and sign up for a premium podcast membership that gets you ad free daily podcasts, Friday editions, Sunday editions, interviews, bonus content and so much more. As Isaac mentioned at the top, we'll be releasing a Friday edition newsletter and podcast that is grading our work from 2024. A preview version of the podcast will be released for free, but if you want the podcast in its entirety, you need to go to tanglemedia.supercast.com to sign up for a membership. Isaac and Ari will be here for the Sunday podcast and I will return on Monday. For Isaac and the rest of the crew, this is John Lowell signing off. Have a fantastic weekend, y'all. Peace.

Isaac Saul (36:03)

Our podcast is written by me, Isaac Saul, and edited and engineered by John Wall. The script is edited by our Managing editor, Ari Weitzman, Will Kdack, Bailey Saul and Sean Brady. The logo for our podcast was designed by Magdalena Bokova, who is also our social media manager. Music for the podcast podcast was produced by Diet75. If you're looking for more from Tangle, Please go to readtangle.com and check out our website.

Warby Parker Ad (36:43)

Every idea starts with a problem. Warby Parker's was simple. Glasses are too expensive, so they set out to change that. By designing glasses in house and selling directly to customers, they're able to offer prescription eyewear that's expertly crafted and unexpectedly affordable. Warby Parker glasses are made from premium materials like impact resistant polycarbonate and custom acetate, and they start at just $95, including prescription lenses. Get glasses made from the good stuff Stop by a Warby Parker store near.