Loading summary
Advertiser 1
Stop over in Qatar and enjoy pristine beaches and vibrant souks. Relax in a five star hotel from just $48 per night. Go to visit qatar.comstopover Terms apply Every.
Advertiser 2
Idea starts with a problem. Warby Parker's was simple. Glasses are too expensive, so they set out to change that. By designing glasses in house and selling directly to customers, they're able to offer prescription eyewear that's expertly crafted and unexpectedly affordable. Warby Parker glasses are made from premium materials like impact resistant polycarbonate and custom acetate and they start at just $95 including prescription lenses. Get glasses made from the good stuff. Stop by a Warby Parker store near you.
Kandi Burruss
Holiday shopping is here and Amazon Live has got you covered. Shop for the perfect gift from the comfort of your home with Amazon Live's shoppable video Experience. Discover the hottest products from influencers and shop while you watch this season. Join Kandi Burruss from Real Housewives in her holiday Amazon Live series Generation Face off, where Kandi, her mom, Mama Joyce and daughter Riley share their favorite stocking stuffers and go to gifts across fashion, beauty and more. Watch and shop new episodes of Kandi's series Generation Face off now by going to Amazon.com candylive that's Amazon.com candylive for a limited time use promo code candylive for $5 off an eligible product featured on the first episode of the series. That's K A N D I L I V E promotion expires on December 25, 2024. Limited supply of goods Terms and conditions apply. For full promotion terms and conditions go to Amazon.com candyterms.
Advertiser 2
From executive producer Isaac Saul.
John Law
This is Tangle.
Isaac Saul
Good morning, good afternoon and good evening and welcome to the Tangle Podcast, the place where you get views from across the political spectrum, some independent thinking and a little bit of my take. I'm your host Isaac Saul and on today's episode we're going to be talking about the healthcare CEO shooting. You know the story of UnitedHealthcare CEO Brian Thompson being killed in New York City. For those of you who listened to the Sunday podcast, you got a preview of my thoughts and feelings here yesterday as Ari and I recorded. But today we're going to give it the standard Tangle treatment with the breakdown of what happened and some opinions from across the political spectrum. Before we jump into that though, I do want to give you a quick heads up on a very special note about this holiday season. For those of you who don't know, you can actually give the gift of Tangle as we like to say we have Tangle gift subscriptions for the newsletter and the website, but the way it works is pretty simple. You can basically just buy a family member, friend or coworker a subscription to the Tangle newsletter and our website by using the link that is in today's episode description or in today's newsletter if you want to go check that out. You can also just do this on our website by going to readtangle.com gift subscription. That'll take you to a page where you can enter anyone's email you want and their name and then gift them a subscription to Tangle. Also, for those of you who know family or friends who you want to give a gift that are already Tangle fans, we have a merch store. We don't really talk about it much, but we have T shirts, hoodies, hats, mugs, stickers, phone cases, and more. I'm not super keen on just trying to sell you stuff all the time. I know how annoying that can be. But yeah, we should tell you regularly that we do have a merchandise store. I love our logo and I think the swag is really awesome. There's a link to that as well in today's episode description. So it's holiday season. I know some people out there might be looking for final gifts or stocking stuffers and consider some Tangle stuff as a potential way to solve your gifting problems. All right, with that, I'm going to send it over to John for today's main story and I'll be back back for my take.
John Law
Thanks Isaac and welcome everybody. Here are your quick hits for today. First up, Syrian President Bashar Al Assad and his family fled to Russia after Syrian rebel forces seized control of the capital of Damascus. The fall of Assad's government comes after a 13 year civil war and widespread reports of human rights violations overseen by Assad. On Sunday, Israel said it had taken control of territory on the Syrian side of the border of the Golan Heights, its first captured Syrian territory since 1973. Number two South Korean lawmakers failed to hold a planned vote on impeaching President Yoon Suk Yeol after members of Yoon's People Power Party party boycotted the vote, which followed his decision to declare martial law last week. However, party leader Han Dong Hoon said Yoon would no longer be involved in state affairs for the remainder of his term. Separately, the Romanian Constitutional Court canceled the results of the country's first round presidential elections in November, setting an alleged Russian interference campaign to boost their preferred candidate. Romania must now restart the electoral process. Number three in his first broadcast interview since winning the election, President Elect Donald Trump laid out his plans for his first months in office, telling Meet the Press's Kristen Welker that he would pursue an extension of the tax cuts passed in his first term, not raise the age for government programs like Social Security and Medicare, not seek to restrict access to abortion pills, issue pardons for those convicted in the January 6th Capitol riot and seek to end birthright citizenship. Number four. The judge in Daniel Penney's trial dismissed the manslaughter charge against him after the jury failed to reach a unanimous decision on the count. The jury will continue to debate a lesser charge of criminal negligent homicide on Monday. And number five, a federal appeals court ruled that a law requiring the social media app TikTok to sell its U.S. operations or be banned in the United States is constitutional, rejecting the challenger's argument that that the ban infringes on free speech.
Marc Maron
The expanding manhunt for the suspect in the murder of United Healthcare CEO Brian.
Advertiser 1
Thompson Police continue to search Central park.
John Law
For clues, both on land and in water.
Marc Maron
Yesterday, a police scuba team searched the waters of Central park looking for evidence including the gun used in the murder of Brian Thompson. Police released two new photos of a person of interest.
John Law
On Wednesday, a gunman shot and killed United Healthcare CEO Brian Thompson outside a hotel in New York City. Police have yet to publicly identify the shooter or determine a motive, though they believe the attack was targeted. Despite these limited details, the incident has reignited debates about the United States healthcare system and incited controversy on social media, where many have expressed support for the shooter. Thompson became chief executive officer of UnitedHealthcare in 2021 after more than two decades at the company. UnitedHealthcare offers health insurance to individuals and employers and generated approximately $281 billion in revenue in 2023. That year, Thompson received a total compensation package of $10.2 million. Earlier this year, Bloomberg reported that Thompson was one of several United Health executives who sold millions of dollars worth of company stock prior to the announcement of a federal antitrust investigation. The shooting took place at approximately 6:45am Eastern Time in midtown Manhattan. Surveillance footage shows the assailant firing multiple shots at Thompson from close range before fleeing towards Central park on a bicycle. Thompson was transported in critical condition to Mount Sinai West Hospital, where he was pronounced dead. Police shared photos of the suspect, who appeared to be a young white man from the hostel where he had been staying prior to the attack, but they have yet to release further details about his identity. On Saturday, New York City Mayor Eric Adams said law enforcement was making progress toward making an arrest, though police also believe that the suspect is no longer in New York City. On Friday, New York City Chief of Detectives Joseph Kenney said investigators were exploring whether this shooter could have been an employee or client of UnitedHealthcare. Additionally, police are investigating several pieces of evidence from the immediate aftermath of the attack, including a backpack found in Central park believed to have been worn by the shooter. They've also tested a discarded water bottle and a protein bar wrapper for DNA and obtained a search warrant to search a cell phone found along the gunmen's escape route. While the attack caused shock over the nature of the shooting and the gunman's ability to evade capture so far it has also generated intense debate about the motive, in particular the discovery of shell casings at the crime scene with the words Delay, Deny and Depose written on them, suggesting that the shooting could have been motivated by insurance company policies. Delay, Deny Defend is the title of a 2010 book on tactics used by insurance companies to avoid reimbursing patient claims on social media. Scores of users have linked the incident to broader complaints about purported exploitative practices of insurers like UnitedHealthcare, with some even praising the shooter. The network Contagion Research Institute released a report that found that six of the top 10 most engaged posts on X about the shooting on Wednesday either expressed explicit or implicit support for the killer or denigrated the victim. Furthermore, public acts of solidarity with the shooter have taken place around New York City, many of which referenced the Delay, Deny Depose messaging. In the days since the attack, large corporations have adopted heightened security measures for their executives, particularly those in pharmaceutical and insurance industries. Today we'll explore the reactions to the shooting from the left and the right, and then Isaac's take.
Isaac Saul
We'll be right back after this quick break.
John Law
What a difference a day makes.
Advertiser 1
Swap your airport transit weight for an exciting stopover in Qatar where idyllic beaches and vibrant souks are all just moments away. Enjoy a 24 hour Qatar stopover with 5 star hotels from only $48 per night. Go to visit qatar.comstopover Terms apply every.
Advertiser 2
Idea starts with a problem. Warby Parker's was simple. Glasses are too expensive, so they set out to change that. By designing glasses in house and selling directly to customers, they're able to offer prescription eyewear that's expertly crafted and unexpectedly affordable. Warby Parker glasses are made from premium materials like impact resistant polycarbonate and custom acetate, and they start at just $95, including prescription lenses. Get glasses made from the good stuff. Stop by a Warby Parker store near you.
John Law
All right, first up, let's start with a bit of agreement. Both sides agree that if indeed motivated by health insurance grievances, the shooting was not the right way to address the issue. The left and right are both dismayed by displays of acceptance and praise for the shooter on social media. All right, let's move on to what the left is saying. The left is concerned by the celebratory response by some to Thompson's death, arguing the attack won't encourage necessary reforms. Some say the anger that followed the shooting is a sign of societal fraying. Others say the response shouldn't come as a surprise against the backdrop of the US Healthcare system. In Bloomberg, Lisa Jarvis said, the health insurance industry is broken. Don't let it break us. I found myself wincing at the tone of the messages rolling in on my various group threads and social media sites, including from people whose opinion I usually deeply respect. My compass on these things is always how I'd want my daughter to hear me react in such a moment. Would I want her to think it's okay to dance on the grave of someone whose sons are now fatherless? Jarvis wrote. And yet we can't ignore the ferocity of the responses or the fact that no one's gut told them to check it. It lays bare a ground truth. If there's anything our fractured country seems to agree on, it's that the healthcare system is tragically broken and the companies profiting from it are morally bankrupt. I desperately want this rage to be channeled into something productive. My worry is that it will not and by design cannot under the US current healthcare infrastructure that instead of prompting healthcare companies to introspection about their most egregious profit driven behaviors, that they will simply go quiet and hope we move on, jarvis said. I also worry that the rage is causing more people to gravitate toward ideas that ultimately are dangerous. There seems to be a growing attitude that real change can only come by burning it all down, or that we need to be open to extreme approaches to fixing our system. In the New York Times, Zeynep Tufekce suggested the rage and glee that followed a CEO's killing should ring all alarms. Even before any details were available, the Internet was awash in speculation that the company had refused to cover the alleged killer's medical bills. And in debates about whether murder would be a reasonable response, Tufekje wrote. It's true that any news with shock value would get some of this response online. After all, trolling, engagement bait and performative provocation are part of everyday life on digital platforms. But this was something different. The rage that people felt at the healthcare industry and the elation that they expressed at seeing it injured was widespread and organic. The conditions that gave rise to this outpouring of anger are in some ways specific to this moment. Today's business culture enshrines the maximization of executive wealth and shareholder fortunes and has succeeded in leveraging personal riches into untold political influence. But the currents we are seeing are expressions of something more fundamental, tufekje said. The fraying of the social contract is getting worse. Americans express less and less trust in many institutions. Substantial majorities of people say that government, business leaders and the media are purposely misleading them. In striking contrast to older generations, majorities of younger people say they do not believe that the American dream is achievable anymore. And the Guardian Arwal Madawi wrote about why Brian Thompson's Death has Elicited Little sympathy I don't need to spell out why Thompson's death has elicited so little sympathy. It doesn't matter how great a guy he might have been to his friends and family, he was a top executive at a company that has treated millions of people very poorly. Health insurance in the US Is a racket that is more focused on increasing profits than providing care, and United Healthcare is particularly egregious when it comes to getting its customers to pay enormous premiums, then turning around and denying them care when they desperately need it. In short, Thompson was the face of an unfair system that has screwed millions of people over. Whatever the motive, many people seem to think Thompson got what he deserved. The glee we're seeing doesn't stem from animosity towards insurance companies, but anger towards an unfair system in which the elite rarely seem to face any consequences for their actions, madawi said. Murdering anyone is quite clearly wrong. But please spare me the pearl clutching from people, many politicians and billionaires who are shocked by the satisfaction Thompson's murder has inspired. All right, that is it for what the left is saying. Which brings us to what the right is saying. The right is dismayed by the shooting and the response that followed. Some suggest the progressive left's response has laid bare the hypocrisy of their politics. Others worry that American society is embracing violence as a solution for anger. In National Review, Dominic Pino said, Murdering CEOs is evil. The natural human reaction to all of this is to first be horrified that a husband and father of two children was murdered. The second reaction to this is to wonder who planned this and whether they have also planned more hits against other United Health executives or leaders of other companies, pineau wrote. This is not the time to offer your criticisms of the health insurance industry. There is never a time to believe that corporate executives are by their very nature evil people who deserve to be killed. Yet that's what you'll see if you go on social media right now and look at the comments on news stories about this assassination. I had never heard of Brian Thompson before today, and it's entirely possible that he made some bad decisions. It's not possible that he deserved to be murdered because nobody deserves to be murdered, and the level of seething resentment some people seem to have of wealthy people is deeply unhealthy, pino said. Socialism is always motivated by envy and often brought about by violence. If there is some kind of organized effort to target CEOs with violence to win applause from the public, that ought to fail because the American public would be repulsed by it. All of us need to be repulsed by this murder. Basic human decency and a commitment to a free society demand it. In the free Press, kat Rosenfield wrote, A CEO was shot dead. These people cheered. The shooting was captured on video. The killer, masked and dressed in black, steps out from behind a parked car as Thompson passes. A moment later, Thompson stumbles, falls and doesn't get up. It's terrible to watch. And yet this literal snuff film is less disturbing than the various critics and commentators. Many of them self describe progressive empaths who preach compassion for the marginalized and hashtag their posts with be kind who are treating this real murder of a real person as though it were the emotionally cathartic climax of a John Wick movie. This practice of celebrating the destruction of one individual person as a scapegoat for whether a systemic injustice, racism or sexism, or in this case corporate greed has been a recurring cultural phenomenon since roughly the first Trump administration, Rosenfeel said. It has always been human nature to hunt for witches, particularly in moments when everything seems to either be broken or falling apart, when people feel scared and out of control, as anyone who has ever had the displeasure of tangling with a health insurance conglomerate in the midst of a medical crisis surely has. It's strangely soothing to imagine that every harm, every injustice can be traced back to the depravity of a single mustache twirling villain who feasts while decent people starve. The only problem is, it's not true. In the Deseret news Cliff Smith argued the decoupling of ends and means is leading to disaster. Something has taken a hold in America that is particularly toxic. Namely, too many people seem to believe that any grievance justifies any response to rectify it. And this past week we've seen a particularly dangerous example of this playing out on the Internet and in the media, smith wrote. The people that were justifying a premeditated killing need to have a good hard think and undertake an examination of their own consciences and of reality. Their usual take amounted to this. Since the healthcare industry is flawed, it leads to people dying, ostensibly due to corporate greed. It is therefore okay to justify and even celebrate Thompson's cold blooded murder. You can see similar flawed logic playing out in big or small ways in those who justify Hamas attacks on innocent Israelis, justify the pardoning of the plainly guilty Hunter Biden because his dad is president, and account for delegitimizing elections and attacking the Capitol, smith said. Anger itself is not wrong, but it can lead us to doing wrong things. There has to be a direct comparable connection between the means and ends, and whatever means taken cannot be more destructive than the ends gained. No amount of anger, justified or not, changes that. All right, let's head over to Isaac for his take.
Isaac Saul
All right, that is it for what the left and the right are saying. Which brings us to my take. So before Brian Thompson was killed last week, I had never heard of him. I'm a politics reporter and I pay pretty good attention to the general societal upset over the state of health insurance in America. So I suspect that if I had never heard Brian Thompson's name, then probably 99% of other Americans at least, also had not heard of him until he was murdered in cold blood. That reality makes the general tenor of the reaction to his death all the more startling, at least for me. When Donald Trump was nearly assassinated and many on the left joked about how they wished the shooter didn't miss, I was morally shocked. I thought it was disgusting, but predictable. Americans live in a deeply polarized world where they are effectively being brainwashed to hate people whose politics they don't agree with, a reality that informs the very work we do here at Tangle. So the reaction to an attempt to kill our most famous politician didn't take me by surprise. But this. This was a little different. On Tuesday night, nobody knew who Brian Thompson was. By Wednesday at lunch, people were celebrating his death with little regard for the wife or kids he left behind and little care about what he actually did as a CEO. The fact that he led United Healthcare was enough for him to be deserving of death or unworthy of sympathy. Even if you believe Thompson was all the evil things so many people online say he was a corrupt CEO, guilty of insider trading and working as the face of a company that denies life saving coverage to tens of thousand Americans a year in the name of profit. He was a corporate cog. He was responsible to a board and to shareholders, and in short order he'll be replaced by another CEO. Nothing will have changed except that killing someone in the middle of Manhattan whom you deem evil is now going to be more normal I know how a lot of people might react to me writing this because I've encountered the refrains already. It's good these people are scared is one common through line of the response. In other words, no, I don't necessarily support killing corporate CEOs in cold blood on the streets. But if CEOs scale back their predatory behavior because they're scared of reprisal, that's a net good. Or of course, the suggestion that I'm more worried about the killing of one CEO than a system that kills tens of thousands or hundreds of thousands of people a year. I suppose there's something appealing about these kinds of arguments. They're not entirely unlike arguments I've made in the past, like that we should be prosecuting more corrupt presidents and members of Congress, not fewer. Stability of the system be damned. The obvious difference, though, is that when I made those arguments, they came from a place of demanding accountability, insisting that the system do a better job rooting out corruption and evil, not cheering extrajudicial violence on the streets. To put it differently, if you are hoping for our rich corporate overlords to live in fear of expedited, unanswerable and unexpected punishment, then you are necessarily hoping for us common folk to start delivering that punishment that requires us to be the arbiters of who is good and who is evil. The left might consider how long it'll be until abortion providing doctors or trans activists or Democratic politicians start being mowed down in the street in the name of striking fear into evildoers. If that's the world you want to live in, I strongly suggest signing off the Internet and going to spend some time outside. I want to be clear that I am consciously not joining the chorus celebrating the purported message sent to major corporate health insurers. I say purported here because, crucially, we still don't know the motive of the shooter, even though I've had plenty of reason to do so. My own frustrating health issues have in the past sent me down the rabbit hole of insanity that is our healthcare infrastructure, full of denials and never ending phone calls and exorbitant price and inexplicably inhumane treatment from insurers. I've seen it happen to the people I love too. During my mother's second bout of breast cancer, her doctors informed her that her body was likely to reject the chemotherapy treatment. She had gotten a similar treatment two decades before, and it was common for patients bodies to reject the treatment the second time. The oncologists had a backup plan, but my mom's insurance wouldn't cover it unless they tried the chemotherapy first. This process, we were told, might be unpleasant. I was with her at the appointment, playing cards while the chemo began. A few minutes into the treatment, things seemed to be going well and for a brief moment we thought she might be one of the lucky ones. Then I noticed her chest turning bright red with a flush running up toward her throat. Suddenly her mouth was open, but she couldn't speak, only choking out and I can't breathe. I yelled for help and stood back out of my chair as she was swarmed by nurses. Like in some kind of horror movie. They ripped out her IVs, started injecting her with steroids, and held her head back so she couldn't choke to death. It took minutes for the situation to resolve and my mom and I were fully traumatized by the whole experience. Thankfully, the attentive medical staff was able to save her, but she easily could have had a blood pressure spike or stroked out right there in the chair. Our system, in effect, had to torture her so she could get coverage. And we were lucky. My mom is in good health even after beating breast cancer a third time, and has, thank God, gotten incredible care throughout her life. Despite the sometimes exorbitant and infuriating cause, many other people aren't so lucky. I can only imagine the pain, frustration or anger I might have felt if my mom's story ended differently. I tried to hold that perspective as I watched the alarming response to Thompson's death last week. Shockingly, there's a lot we still don't know about this entire story. While a scary number of people seem to be celebrating or gleefully cheering on the shooter's escape, we know next to nothing about who he is or his motivation. Was he or a family member? A patient with United Healthcare Insurance? Did he work at United Healthcare? Did he know Thompson personally? Did he even kill the right person or intend to target Thompson intentionally? He was, after all waiting outside a healthcare conference? Could there be another explanation altogether? None of this is known to us, yet we're all seemingly comfortable to jump to conclusions. Whatever details emerge, one thing will remain true. Improving our healthcare system and our society more broadly is not going to start by shooting corporate leaders in the back. It's going to take fastidious work from consumer advocates, legislators, and corporations. It will require grassroots movement and political pressure. It will happen slowly, deliberately, with a checkered history of wins and losses. That is always how this goes, and anyone convincing you otherwise is selling snake oil. Even less discussed these days is that a majority of Americans are actually satisfied with their own personal healthcare's quality and coverage, which majorities rate positively. In other words, people seem to simultaneously hate the system, perhaps due in part to the narrative building around things like Thompson's death, while being satisfied with their own care. I'm not sure how to connect those dots, but I do know it's a sign. There are plenty of things working well that we can build off of, so long as we choose a path better than the one we appear to be on now. All right, that is it for my take. Today's pod is a little bit longer than usual, so we're going to skip our listener question and I'm going to send it back to John for the rest of the podcast. I'll see you guys tomorrow. Have a good one. Peace. We'll be right back after this quick break.
Advertiser 3
Hey, it's Marc Maron from WTF here to let you know that this podcast is brought to you by Progressive Insurance. And I'm sure the reason you're listening to this podcast right now is because you chose it well. Choose Progressive's name your price tool and you could find insurance options that fit your budget. So you can pick the best one for your situation. Who doesn't like choice? Try it@progressive.com and now some legal info. Progressive Casualty Insurance Company and affiliates. Price and coverage match limited by state law. Not available in all states.
Marc Maron
Gifting is hard, but here's a hint. Give the gift of connection from US Cellular. Not sure what that means. Well, here's a slightly more specific hint. You can choose four free phones and get four lines for $90 a month from US Cellular. Your family wants new phones? How do we know? Well, they told us. The good news is that compared to wrapping presents, you're great at getting hints. So take the hint and get them four free phones in four lines for $90 a month. US Cellular built for us.
John Law
Thanks, Isaac. Here's your under the radar story for today, folks. Last week, North Carolina's Republican controlled state Senate voted to override Democratic governor Roy Cooper's veto of a bill would strip power from several prominent Democrats who will take statewide office in 2025. The bill passed during a lame duck session after the election, which was marketed primarily as an aid package for Hurricane Helene victims, but Governor Cooper accused lawmakers of disguising its true intent. The bill includes provisions that would shift appointment power for the State Board of Elections from the governor, who will be a Democrat in 2025, to the state auditor, who will be a Republican. Additionally, it will bar the attorney General, who will be a Democrat, from taking legal positions opposed by the General assembly in litigation challenging a given law's validity. The state's incoming Democratic Superintendent of Public Instruction would also lose power to appeal decisions by a state board that reviews charter school applications. The bill now returns to the state House, where Republicans have a slim veto proof majority. The Associated Press has this story and there's a link in today's episode Description all right, next up is our numbers section. The approximate number of United healthcare customers in 2023 is 52 million. United Healthcare's revenues in 2023 was 281 billion. The percentage of insured US adults who describe themselves as in good health who rate their insurance provider positively is 84%, according to a 2023 KFF survey. The percentage of insured U.S. adults who describe themselves as in fair or poor health who rate their insurance provider positively is 68%. The percentage of all insured adults who reported a problem with their health care insurance in the past 12 months is 58%. The percentage of insured adults who say their health insurance denied or delayed prior approval for needed care in the past 12 months is 16%. The total number of in network claims denied by Affordable Care Act Marketplace insurers in 2021 was 48.3 million, and the percentage of those denied claims that consumers appealed through their insurer's internal Appeals process is 0.2%. All right, and last but not least, our have a nice day Story. Lynn Story's car frequently broke down, but that didn't prevent her from using it to serve others. The neighborhood app next door connected Story to community members who needed rides like April Goodwin, who needed help getting to medical appointments, and Kevin Horrigan, who needed assistance getting to work. After hearing about the service Story had been rendering in her community car, dealer David Kelleher stepped in, arranging for Story to receive a new car. CBS News has this story and there's a link in today's episode description all right everybody, that is it for today's episode. As always, if you'd like to support our work, Please go to retangle.com and sign up for a membership. You can also go to tanglemedia.supercast.com to sign up for a premium podcast membership which gets you ad free daily podcasts, Friday editions, Sunday editions, interviews, bonus content and so much more. We'll be right back here tomorrow. For Isaac and the rest of the crew, this is John Law signing off. Have a great day, y'all. Peace.
Isaac Saul
Our podcast is written by me, Isaac Saul and edited and engineered by Duke Thomas. Our script is edited by Ari Weitzman, Will Kabak, Eric Saul and Sean Brady. The logo for our podcast was made by Magdalena Bokova, who was also our social media manager. The music for the podcast was produced by Diet75. And if you're looking for more from Tangle, please go check out our website@readtangle.com that's readtangle.com.
Advertiser 1
Stop over in Qatar and enjoy pristine beaches and vibrant souks. Relax in a 5 star hotel from just $48 per night. Go to visit qatar.comstopover terms apply. This episode is brought to you by Progressive Insurance. Do you ever find yourself playing the budgeting game? Well, with the Name youe Price tool from Progressive, you can find options that fit your budget and potentially lower your bills. Try it@progressive.com Progressive Casualty Insurance Company and affiliates Price and coverage match Limited by state law not available in all states.
Advertiser 2
What makes a great pair of glasses? At Warby Parker, it's all the invisible extras without the extra cost. Their designer quality frames start at $95 including prescription lenses plus scratch resistant, smudge resistant and anti reflective coatings and UV protection and free adjustments for life. To find your next pair of glasses, sunglasses or contact lenses or to find the Warby Parker store nearest you, head over to warbyparker.com that's warbyparker.com.
Podcast Summary: Tangle – "The Healthcare CEO Shooting"
Release Date: December 9, 2024
Host: Isaac Saul
In this compelling episode of Tangle, host Isaac Saul delves into the tragic assassination of Brian Thompson, the CEO of UnitedHealthcare, exploring the multifaceted reactions and underlying societal issues that have surfaced in the wake of this event. Isaac sets the stage by outlining the episode's structure, promising an in-depth analysis that includes perspectives from across the political spectrum.
At 06:33, host John Law provides a detailed account of the incident:
Incident Overview: On Wednesday morning, around 6:45 AM ET, Brian Thompson was fatally shot outside a Midtown Manhattan hotel. Surveillance footage captured the assailant firing multiple shots before fleeing towards Central Park on a bicycle.
Police Investigation: A comprehensive manhunt is underway, with police searching both land and water areas of Central Park. Two new photos of a person of interest were released, depicting a young white male from a nearby hostel (06:38-06:51).
Public and Social Media Reaction: The assassination has sparked intense debate about the U.S. healthcare system. Shockingly, some social media users have expressed support for the shooter, linking the attack to broader grievances against insurance companies like UnitedHealthcare.
Evidence and Motive Theories: Shell casings found at the scene bore the words "Delay, Deny, and Depose," echoing themes from a 2010 book critical of insurance company practices. This has fueled speculation that the motive may be tied to frustrations with healthcare policies (06:51-10:16).
The left expresses a mix of sorrow over the loss of life and anger towards the healthcare industry's practices:
Lisa Jarvis (Bloomberg): Highlights the deep-seated frustrations with the broken health insurance industry, stating, "If there's anything our fractured country seems to agree on, it's that the healthcare system is tragically broken and the companies profiting from it are morally bankrupt." (07:45)
Zeynep Tufekce (New York Times): Emphasizes the societal discontent that the shooting reveals, noting, "The rage that people felt at the healthcare industry and the elation that they expressed at seeing it injured was widespread and organic." (09:15)
Arwal Madawi (The Guardian): Points out the lack of sympathy for Thompson, attributing it to his role as the face of an unfair system. She asserts, "Murdering anyone is quite clearly wrong. But please spare me the pearl clutching... It was the face of an unfair system that has screwed millions of people over." (11:00)
These perspectives collectively argue that while the punishment of an individual is unjustifiable, the underlying systemic issues within the healthcare industry warrant serious attention and reform.
Conversely, the right voices outrage over both the act and the reaction it has provoked:
Dominic Pino (National Review): Condemns the glorification of violence against corporate executives, stating, "Nobody deserves to be murdered... The level of seething resentment some people seem to have of wealthy people is deeply unhealthy." (15:30)
Kat Rosenfield (Free Press): Criticizes the progressive response, comparing the reaction to a "John Wick movie" and warning against scapegoating individuals for systemic issues. She remarks, "It's strangely soothing to imagine that every harm, every injustice can be traced back to the depravity of a single mustache twirling villain." (17:00)
Cliff Smith (Deseret News): Discusses the dangerous mindset that justifies extreme actions based on grievances, urging for moral introspection. He warns, "Anger itself is not wrong, but it can lead us to doing wrong things... No amount of anger, justified or not, changes that." (18:45)
These viewpoints stress that endorsing or celebrating violence undermines societal stability and ethical standards, regardless of systemic frustrations.
At 20:21, Isaac Saul shares a personal and reflective perspective on the incident:
Personal Connection: Isaac recounts his mother's harrowing experience with the healthcare system, highlighting the intense emotional and physical toll it exacted on his family. He states, "Our system, in effect, had to torture her so she could get coverage."
Critique of Public Reaction: He expresses shock at the rapid and widespread celebration of Thompson's death, emphasizing that most people, including himself, were unfamiliar with Thompson prior to the assassination. Isaac observes, "The fact that he led United Healthcare was enough for him to be deserving of death or unworthy of sympathy."
Call for Constructive Change: Isaac argues that systemic reform is necessary and achievable through persistent advocacy and legislative action, rather than through violence. He warns against the normalization of extrajudicial actions, suggesting that such behavior could lead to further societal decay.
Balanced Perspective: While acknowledging the legitimate grievances against the healthcare system, Isaac firmly rejects the notion that violence is an acceptable means of effecting change. He concludes, "Improving our healthcare system and our society more broadly is not going to start by shooting corporate leaders in the back."
John Law presents key statistics related to UnitedHealthcare and the broader healthcare landscape (25:00):
John Law covers a significant political maneuver in North Carolina politics (27:00):
A heartwarming tale is shared (28:00):
In this thought-provoking episode, Tangle navigates the complex emotions and political tensions ignited by the assassination of a major healthcare executive. By presenting diverse viewpoints and a deeply personal perspective, Isaac Saul encourages listeners to reflect on the broader implications for society and the healthcare system. The episode underscores the necessity for constructive dialogue and systematic reform over destructive reactions, advocating for a more empathetic and rational approach to addressing deep-rooted issues.
Notable Quotes:
Lisa Jarvis (Bloomberg) – [07:45]: "If there's anything our fractured country seems to agree on, it's that the healthcare system is tragically broken and the companies profiting from it are morally bankrupt."
Zeynep Tufekce (New York Times) – [09:15]: "The rage that people felt at the healthcare industry and the elation that they expressed at seeing it injured was widespread and organic."
Dominic Pino (National Review) – [15:30]: "Nobody deserves to be murdered... The level of seething resentment some people seem to have of wealthy people is deeply unhealthy."
Kat Rosenfield (Free Press) – [17:00]: "It's strangely soothing to imagine that every harm, every injustice can be traced back to the depravity of a single mustache twirling villain."
Cliff Smith (Deseret News) – [18:45]: "Anger itself is not wrong, but it can lead us to doing wrong things... No amount of anger, justified or not, changes that."
Isaac Saul – [20:21]: "Improving our healthcare system and our society more broadly is not going to start by shooting corporate leaders in the back."
This summary encapsulates the key elements of the episode, providing a comprehensive overview for those who haven't listened while maintaining the depth and engagement of the original content.