The Republican texting scandals.

Summary

---

Tangle Podcast Episode Summary

Podcast: Tangle
Host: Isaac Saul
Episode: The Republican Texting Scandals
Date: October 22, 2025

---

Overview

In this episode, Isaac Saul and senior editor Will Kaback break down two major scandals rocking Republican circles: leaks of racist and extremist group chats between Young Republican leaders and a separate, incriminating text chain involving Paul Ingrazia, the White House liaison to the Department of Homeland Security and Trump’s nominee to head the Office of Special Counsel. The discussion covers reactions from across the political spectrum, examines the deeper cultural and political implications for the GOP, and shares personal reflections on accountability, "cancel culture", and the right way for political parties to handle internal scandals.

---

Key Discussion Points & Insights

1. Background: The Scandals

• Young Republicans Group Chat Leak: Thousands of offensive and racist messages were exchanged among young GOP leaders, including hate speech and jokes about planting fake stories to smear rivals. Chapters in NY, KS, AZ, and VT implicated ([07:38]).
• Paul Ingrazia Controversy: Leaked messages show Ingrazia making racist and Nazi-referencing remarks, including, “the Martin Luther King Jr. Holiday should be tossed into the seventh circle of hell,” and admitting he has “a Nazi streak in me from time to time” ([06:46], [07:38]).

2. Immediate Fallout

• Repercussions: The Young Republican National Federation called the conduct “disgraceful” and suspended several members; organizational fallout led to New York’s chapter suspending operations. Paul Ingrazia withdrew his nomination after Republican Senate leaders withdrew support ([07:38], [09:20]).
• Divided GOP Response: Vice President J.D. Vance called for leniency, opposing “ruined lives for saying something stupid in a private group chat.”

3. Political Reaction: Right & Left

What the Right Is Saying ([12:40])

• Condemnation and Critique of "Vice Signaling":
  • Ricky Schlott (New York Post): Called the group chat part of “vice signaling” – a backlash to “virtue signaling” on the left, but says, “Tasteless and rude isn’t a flex, and performatively standing against something isn’t a coherent ideology.” ([13:12])
• Skepticism of Outrage:
  • Jeffrey Ingersoll (Daily Caller): Downplays significance, calls the messages “cringe… LARPing as edgy 4chan racists,” and points to lack of comparable Democratic disavowal for other scandals.
• Importance of Accountability:
  • Wall Street Journal Editorial Board: “It would be useful if President Trump made clear that this kind of garbage isn't wanted in his MAGA political movement”; notes that the party’s rejection of Ingrazia shows some institutional standards remain.
  • “Mr. Ingrazia’s nomination is dead, a sign that the GOP won’t tolerate his brand of extremist political behavior and rhetoric.” ([14:00])

What the Left Is Saying ([16:10])

• Appalled by Content & GOP Inaction:
  • Jonathan Chait (The Atlantic) criticizes Vance’s refusal to condemn, calling it an example of how “the hateful troll-like way in which these people communicate has found its way into the mainstream GOP.”
• Praise for Senate Stand—But Warns It’s Not Enough:
  • Washington Post Editorial Board: “It took Senate Republicans five months to say as much. Presidents deserve significant deference… but the Senate plays an important role enforcing certain boundaries.” ([17:35])
• Normalization of Toxic Culture:
  • Kim & McHugh (Politico): Warn how online culture is seeping into real-world politics, with “chronically online young people on the right aging into higher positions of power” and the White House adopting provocative, troll-like online messaging.

4. Isaac Saul’s Take ([20:33])

• Clear Standards Needed:
  • “Somebody with a self-described Nazi streak who uses slurs to describe Black people… apparently crosses the line.” ([20:59])
• Room for Grace, but Repercussions Essential:
  • “Extending grace is not the same as withholding consequences… [they] shouldn’t get to say the things they said in that chat without any blowback. There should be repercussions. Even assuming the best… it should still be taboo to say overtly racist things to be edgy, or joke about gas chambering your political opponents, or make light of embracing Hitler, especially in a context where you’re supposedly modeling leadership behavior.” ([22:05])
• Critique of J.D. Vance:
  • “Vice President J.D. Vance handled the situation about as poorly as one could have imagined.”
  • Notes hypocrisy: “This wasn’t just some group of teenagers who didn’t know any better… Most of these young men are in their 20s, and some are in their 30s and even 40s.”
• Appropriate Repercussions, Not Punitive Exile:
  • “Appropriate consequences don’t have to ruin lives… But they also shouldn’t get to say the things they said without any blowback.”
• Praise for Party Response:
  • “For the most part, Republicans have actually handled these two scandals precisely how they should have… almost every Republican at the state and national level has rejected this language outright and called for clear repercussions. This is an encouraging signal about the norms we’re all still willing to enforce and live by.” ([26:40])

5. Will Kaback’s Dissent ([27:15])

• Online Right Still Defends:
  • Cites Matt Walsh and other conservative influencers who argue, “the right should never disavow its own in order to maintain a united front against the left.”
  • Warns this "no enemies to the right" attitude remains significant and will shape future GOP controversies.
• Calls Out Democratic Failures, Too:
  • Notes lackluster Democratic responses to their own scandals, suggesting failure to uphold standards is a bipartisan problem.

---

Notable Quotes & Moments

• Young Republicans Board Statement:

  “Such behavior is disgraceful, unbecoming of any Republican, and stands in direct opposition to the values our movement represents.” — Board of Directors, Young Republican National Federation ([07:38])

• Paul Ingrazia’s Post:

  "I will be withdrawing myself... because unfortunately I do not have enough Republican votes at this time." — Paul Ingrazia ([09:13])

• Isaac Saul:

  “Extending grace is not the same as withholding consequences.” ([22:05])
  “Vice President J.D. Vance handled the situation about as poorly as one could have imagined.” ([23:20])
  “Republicans should keep it up, and Democrats should remember it the next time they have an opportunity to draw lines on what’s acceptable and what’s not.” ([26:53])

• Will Kaback:

  “…the notion of 'no enemies to the right' remains salient and will recur when future controversies arise.” ([27:33])

---

Timestamps for Key Segments

• [01:50] — Episode topic intro by Isaac Saul
• [05:08] — “Quick hits” news rundown
• [06:46] — Political commentator summarizes the Politico leaks and fallout
• [07:38] — Will Kaback details both scandals and contextualizes their impact
• [12:40] — What the right is saying: media and commentator reactions
• [16:10] — What the left is saying: criticism and analysis
• [20:33] — Isaac Saul’s personal analysis and take
• [27:15] — Will Kaback’s dissent responding to Isaac’s take
• [30:10] — Questions from listeners (not directly related to main topic)
• [33:01] — “Under the Radar” story and segment wrap-up

---

Tone & Language

The discussion maintains Tangle’s signature non-partisan, thoughtful, and at times self-critical tone. Isaac Saul is introspective, drawing from personal experience to advocate for balanced accountability rather than knee-jerk condemnation. Commentary from the right ranges from skepticism of “cancel culture” to explicit acknowledgment that bigotry has no place in political leadership. The left is forceful in its alarm over normalization of racially charged rhetoric and the potential for these attitudes to move into mainstream Republican spaces.

---

Conclusion

This episode tackles the messy reality of modern political discourse and accountability within parties. While both left and right recognize the gravity of the offending messages, there is a genuine split over the appropriate degree of punishment, the danger of normalization, and the risk of overreaching in the name of moral policing. The show’s hosts ultimately conclude that Republicans, for the most part, handled the latest scandals appropriately—with clear lines drawn by official party bodies and the Senate. Listeners are encouraged to consider the standards their own political communities uphold and to value consequences over permanent exile for those who err.

---

Transcript

[Ryan Reynolds]

Mint is still $15 a month for premium wireless. And if you haven't made the switch yet, here are 15 reasons why you should. One, it's $15 a month.

[BetterHelp Advertiser]

Two.

[Ryan Reynolds]

Seriously, it's $15 a month. Three, no big contracts.

[BetterHelp Advertiser]

Four.

[Momentous Advertiser]

I use it.

[Ryan Reynolds]

Five, my mom uses it.

[Will Kaback]

Are you.

[Ryan Reynolds]

Are you playing me off? That's what's happening, right? Okay, give it a try.

[Mint Mobile / Monday.com Advertiser]

@Mintmobile.Com Switch upfront payment of $45 per three month plan. $15 per month equivalent required. New customer offer first three months only. Then full price plan options available, taxes and fees extra.

[Isaac Saul]

See mintmobile.com Did I talk too much?

[American Red Cross Advertiser]

Can't I just let it go?

[BetterHelp Advertiser]

Take a breath. You're not alone. Let's talk about what's going on. Counseling helps you sort through the noise with qualified professionals. And online therapy makes it convenient. See if it's for you. Visit betterhelp.com randompodcast for 10% off your first month of online therapy and let life feel free. Better A I.

[Will Kaback]

Had the time of my life.

[American Red Cross Advertiser]

Hey, I never felt this way before.

[Mint Mobile / Monday.com Advertiser]

From building timelines to assigning the right people and even spotting risks across dozens of projects, Monday Sidekick knows your business, thinks ahead and takes action. One click on the star and consider it done.

[Will Kaback]

And I owe it all to you.

[Mint Mobile / Monday.com Advertiser]

Try Monday Sidekick AI you'll love to use on Monday.com.

[Will Kaback]

From executive producer Isaac.

[Mint Mobile / Monday.com Advertiser]

Saul, this is Tangle.

[Isaac Saul]

Good morning, good afternoon, and good evening, and welcome to the Tangle podcast, a place where we get views from across the political spectrum, some independent thinking, and a little bit of my take. I'm your host, Isaac Saul, and on today's episode, we're going to be talking about the Young Republicans group chat as well as the Paul and Gracia controversy. Two, oddly, two chats that got leaked to Politico that I think have had a really big newsy impact. Yeah, I mean, it's. It's very interesting. So I hope you guys can get something out of this newsletter today because I think there's been a lot of noise on both these stories. I actually have a little bit of an optimistic take though. There's some dissent from our staff, so we'll get into that. Before we jump in, though, I have a quick note, a really fun announcement. The media industry, as many of you guys know, is changing and that change is happening fast. The future is uncertain. Every day we are thinking of new ways to do two things. One, ensure we can always reach our audience and two, deliver content that meets your needs as news consumers. To that end, we are launching a new Future Proof product. We think our audience will love a free text message service. We tested this out with about 700 readers and listeners sending breaking news, analysis, behind the scenes updates and giving you opportunities to help shape our coverage. It got rave reviews so we are opening it up for free to the entire Tangle audience. We'll never send you ads or share your phone number with any third party of any kind of and we'll make sure we only text you with valuable information, rarely more than once a day depending on the alerts you sign up for. So far, things are off to an incredible start. It took me 11 months to get 5,000 people to sign up for the Tangle newsletter, but 5,000 people have already signed up for our texting service in just under two hours. If you are interested and want to join this new offering, you can sign up with a link in today's episode description or you can text Tango Tangle in all caps to 850-338-9163. That's tangle in all caps to 850338, 9163. Or you can sign up with the link in today's episode description. Again, this is a free text messaging service where we're going to give some breaking news analysis, behind the scenes stuff. Generally try and provide some really interesting short form content for you guys. All right, with that I'm going to send it over to Will who's tagging in for John today as we all travel to our event in la, which is the second thing I want to remind you of. I should say Irvine, California. Somebody said calling it Los Angeles is Orange county erasure, which is fair. We are going to be in Irvine, California on Friday. There are still some tickets left. A link to that's also in an episode description or you can go to readtangle.com forward/live. You guys should come out if you're interested in seeing what this looks like in person. But yes, that event's happening. We're all traveling today. It's crazy day for the Tangle team, so Will's jumping in on the pod and I'll be back for my take.

[Will Kaback]

Thanks, Isaac. All right, let's get into today's quick hits. Number one, President Donald Trump is reportedly requesting that the Justice Department pay him approximately $230 million as compensation for federal investigations into him following the end of his first term. Trump submitted complaints through an administrative claim process in 2023 and 2024 seeking damages for the investigations. And on Tuesday, Trump said he would give any money he receives to charity number two. A White House official said that President Trump and Russian President Vladimir Putin would not meet in the immediate future after Trump had said on Thursday that the two planned to meet in Hungary in the coming weeks. Number three a deputy U.S. marshal and a TikTok streamer were injured when an Immigration and Customs Enforcement agent fired shots at a suspect who was allegedly trying to run from agents and used his car to ram the agent's vehicle. Number four the North Carolina Senate approved a new congressional map expected to help Republicans gain an additional House seat in the 2026 midterm elections. The North Carolina House is expected to approve the map in a vote on Wednesday. And finally, number five, Peru's President Jose Harry declared a 30 day state of emergency in the country's capital, Lima, and the Providence of Callao to address crime. The declaration authorizes the deployment of the armed forces alongside the police to maintain public.

[Political Commentator]

Politico published an explosive new report revealing thousands of vile, racist text messages exchanged among some Young Republican leaders. It's so bad that some of them are losing their jobs. President Trump's pick to lead the Office of Special Counsel appears to be on thin ice, and that, quite honestly, maybe a generous take. You now have the top Republican in the Senate, John Thune, saying this about Paul in he's not going to pass. It comes after Politico reported on racist text messages in Grassi allegedly sent in a group chat with Republican operatives. In one message in Grazia allegedly texted that the Martin Luther King Jr. Holiday should be tossed into the seventh circle of hell where it belongs. In another, in Gracia, in a back and forth, allegedly wrote, I do have a Nazi streak in me, in me from time to time. I will admit it.

[Will Kaback]

On Thursday, Politico published screenshots of text messages sent by members of Young Republicans, an organization for Republican party members between 18 and 40 years old that featured offensive jokes and racist language in the messages. Various leaders of Young Republican chapters across the country joked about planting fake stories to smear rival GOP candidates, used racial epithets to refer to black people and expressed admiration for Hitler. The texts also showed group members discussing a potential error in the number of delegates at the Republican National Convention. Those implicated in the texts reportedly represent chapters in New York, Kansas, Arizona and Vermont. Many GOP leaders have called on the Young Republicans to take accountability, as has the group's board of directors. Quote, such behavior is disgraceful, unbecoming of any Republican, and stands in direct opposition to the values our movement represents, the Young Republican National Federation's board of directors said in A post on Instagram. As part of the fallout for the report, New York's Young Republicans chapter voted to suspend its operations on Friday. Other national leaders have called for leniency and understanding. Most notably, Vice President J.D. vance said he did not want those exposed by the reports to have their lives, quote, ruined because they're saying something stupid in a private group chat, end quote. Then on Monday, Politico published another leaked chain of incriminating private messages, this time from Paul Ingrazia, White House liaison to the Department of Homeland Security and President Donald Trump's nominee to lead the Office of Special Counsel. The messages between Ingracia and a group of fellow Republicans show the 30 year old attorney saying that the Martin Luther King Jr. Holiday should be, quote, tossed into the seventh circle of hell, end quote. And admitting to having a, quote, nazi streak. Ingrazia's nomination was already embattled as recent reports revealed he was the subject of an internal investigation at the Department of Homeland Security after a sexual harassment complaint was filed against him. The woman who initially filed the complaint later withdrew it and Ingracia's attorney denied the allegation. Separately, in July, Senator Thom Tillis, a Republican from North Carolina, said that Ingrazia was, quote, not ready for prime time. After a meeting with the Senate Homeland Security Committee staff on Tuesday evening, Ingrazia withdrew his nomination, quote, I will be withdrawing myself from Thursday's Committee on Homeland Security and Government affairs hearing to lead the Office of Special Counsel because unfortunately I do not have enough Republican votes at this time in Gracia said in a post on X. Senate Majority Leader John Thune, a Republican from South Dakota and Senators Ron Johnson of Wisconsin, Rick Scott from Florida and James Lankford from Oklahoma were among the Republican senators who had publicly expressed doubts about Ingrazias nomination. Today we'll break down the young Republicans and Paul and Gracia scandals with views from the right and left. Then executive editor Isaac Saul gives his take.

[Isaac Saul]

We'll be right back after this quick break.

[Ryan Reynolds]

Hey, Ryan Reynolds here from Mint Mobile. Now I don't know if you've heard, but Mint's Premium Wireless is $15 a month. But I'd like to offer one other perk. We have no stores. That means no small talk.

[Isaac Saul]

Crazy weather we're having.

[Ryan Reynolds]

No it's not. It's just weather. It is an introvert's dream. Give it a [e-mail] switch upfront came.

[Mint Mobile / Monday.com Advertiser]

In a $45 for 3 month plan. $15 per month equivalent required. New customer offer first 3 months only, then full price plan options available, taxes and fees extra 6 a lot of.

[Momentous Advertiser]

Supplement brands chase trends, but if you're serious about your health, we know research backed science is what actually moves the needle. Momentous works with the best brains in human science to create every formula and every batch is made of pure ingredients tested for safety and does not contain fillers so you get the best long term results possible. Creatine isn't just for muscle gains, it's essential daily fuel for your brain, body and long term performance. Momentous Creapure Creatine is backed by leading performance experts like Dr. Andrew Huberman and Dr. Stacey Sims. Sourced exclusively in Germany, Creapure sets the gold standard for creatine, delivering the purest form creatine monohydrate that's rigorously washed and never cut with fillers. With over 2,000 five star reviews, over 112,000 customers have seen the results firsthand. With Momentous, the fundamentals are done right. Right now, Momentous is offering our listeners up to 35% off your first subscription order with promo code and Acast. Go to livemomentous.com and use promo code Acast for up to 35% off your first Subscription Order. That's livemomentous.com promo code Acast.

[Will Kaback]

Here's what the right is Most on the right condemn the messages in the leaked chats. Some argue that the messages are not meaningfully worse than what elected Democrats have said, and others say the Ingrazia leaks are a lesson for other young Republicans. In the New York Post, Ricky Schlott said the Young Republican group chat is part of the right's new vice signaling bonding ritual. It's apparently supposed to be funny. You guys are in on the joke, right? And meant to prove loyalty. If you're one of us, they're implying you'd never rat. But it's abhorrent and fits right into a concerning mounting trend on the right, Schlott wrote. Vice signaling is a backlash response to the left's smug virtue signaling a performative and exclusionary trend of going to fashionable protests, using overly genuflecting lingo and shaming anyone to the right of the far left. It's not just a matter of rejecting political correctness. It's about being actively and aggressively politically incorrect. Yes, it's all free speech, but there's also an expectation of civility and basic respect for others, especially from up and coming political leaders. There's humor and there's taking a joke so far that it's vile, schlott said. The right has to rethink whether being anti PC is really the best glue to hold together a community. Tasteless and rude isn't a flex, and performatively standing against something isn't a coherent ideology. In the Daily Caller, Jeffrey Ingersoll wrote, these leaked chats won't get a rise out of me. The leaked chat from a group of young Republican leaders mostly came off like a bunch of cringe prepubescent idiots who recently discovered curse words. Except it was 20 somethings LARPing as edgy 4chan racists, Ingersoll said. Do I think all this is bad? Yes. Condemning it is easy. I don't even need to hit the brakes. I can do a drive by condemnation. But do I believe they need to be rapidly unpersoned? Absolutely not. Jay Jones, the potential top law enforcement officer of the most historic state in the Union, fantasized about shooting a former state House speaker in the head. He said he'd love to do it not once but twice, ingersoll wrote. As far as I can tell, not a single sitting Democrat has called for him to drop out. Abigail Spanberger is running for governor to actually work with the man, and she hasn't either. Until a higher percentage of the fiery but mostly peaceful crowd stops thinking it's totally justified to assault and kill us a, I won't be getting mad about these leaked chats. The Wall Street Journal editorial board called the Ingrazia scandal a lesson for young MAGA beyond the failure of vetting. It would be useful if President Trump made clear that this kind of garbage isn't wanted in his MAGA political movement, the board said. A lawyer for Mr. Ingrazia told the news outlet Politico he didn't concede the veracity of the leaked messages. Quote, even if the texts are authentic, they clearly read as self deprecating and satirical humor, making fun of the fact that liberals outlandishly and routine call MAGA supporters Nazis, end quote. It's impossible to know what's in Mr. Ingrazia's heart, but if his explanation is that he acted like an Internet troll, it isn't much of a defense. Other participants in the chat offered warnings, quote, paul, you are coming across as a white nationalist, one reportedly said, quote, you're going to be in private practice one day and this shit will be around forever, end quote. The same advice could have been given to all of those Young Republican leaders whose chat threads were leaked recently, the board wrote. Mr. Ingrazia's nomination is dead, a sign that the GOP won't tolerate his brand of extremist political behavior and rhetoric. It is also a potent lesson for mega youth in what not to do. All right, here's what the left is saying. The left is appalled by the messages and alarmed by some prominent Republicans refusal to condemn them. Some commend Senate Republicans for pulling their support for Ingracia. Others say the attitude shown in the group chats has already spread to mainstream Republican circles in the Atlantic. Jonathan Chait asked, why is Vance defending that racist group chat? When a political ally does something controversial, there are three ways to respond defend it, repudiate it, or deflect attention away from it. Defense is the obvious option if you think the action is acceptable enough to the public. Repudiation makes sense if the matter is so toxic that you can't afford to keep the guilty party in your coalition, chait wrote. Deflection is the response of choice only when the behavior of an ally is too toxic to defend but so widespread within your coalition that you cannot afford to criticize it. That a group of ambitious, professional Republicans can spread nakedly racist messages without rebuke signifies the transformation of conservative political norms in the Trump era, chait said. The vice president apparently grasps that openly defending references to black people as, quote, watermelon eaters and quips about sending political rivals to the gas chamber would hurt his political standing. But he also clearly needs these young Republican leaders if he hopes to consolidate the Trump base behind him. Deflection is a calculated response. The Washington Post editorial board wrote about Republicans drawing a line on Paul and Gracia. One of the differences between President Donald Trump's first and second terms is the meekness of Senate Republicans. But it's good to know that there's still a limit somewhere. After Senate Majority Leader John Thune warned Monday night that his conference would reject the nomination of Paul in Grazia, the board said it was always clear that Ingrazia was a puerile troll with no business serving as an officer of the United States. But it took Senate Republicans five months to say as much. Presidents deserve significant deference in filling most executive branch posts, but the Senate plays an important role enforcing certain boundaries. Thune's majority mostly abdicated that responsibility by approving figures such as Robert F. Kennedy Jr. As health and Human services secretary and Kash Patel as FBI director, the board wrote. Republican and Democratic senators are too enthralled to presidents of their parties, and it's damaging the constitutional system. In Politico, Katherine Kim and Caulder McHugh called the leaked chat a sign of where we could be headed. As the leaked Young Republicans chat reveals, the hateful troll like way in which these people communicate has also found its way into the mainstream gop. It's a trend that could become more visible as a generation of chronically online young people on the right age into higher positions of power and are embraced by the party, Kim and McHugh said. What begins in far right corners of the Internet seeps into right leaning spaces offline, even within Republican politics. Several members of the Young Republicans group Chat are in official positions in the party. One works for the Trump administration. Government agencies under the Trump administration have also demonstrated their fluency in this kind of radical online humor and provocation. The Public X accounts of the White House and the Department of Homeland Security are now sharing content that would be at home on groiper message boards, though without explicit Nazi reference, Kim and McHugh wrote. The transgressive nature of these kinds of posts is likely the point. It's supposed to make the poster's enemies mad and push the boundaries of acceptable discourse. All right, that is it for what the right and left are saying, so I will pass it back over to Isaac for his take. Isaac, over to you.

[Isaac Saul]

All right, that is it for the left and the right are saying. Which brings us to my take. I'll start with the easy one before moving on to the issue that I think has slightly more nuance. Paul and Gracia's nomination getting pulled is obviously a good thing. It also serves as a reminder that Senate Republicans who have displayed an incredible amount of deference to President Trump still have lines that they are not willing to cross. Someone with a self described Nazi streak who uses slurs to describe black people and thinks all federal holidays honoring minorities should be tossed into the seventh circle of hell apparently crosses the line. A lot of this stuff was already known about in Gracia, so it's alarming it took this long for him to be rejected by the party, but good riddance. The discussion about the Young Republicans text message scandal offers a few more layers of nuance. If you have been reading this newsletter or listening to this podcast for a little while, you probably know that my position here is typically one of extending grace. In 2021 I wrote a piece called Confessing My Sins which addressed the way Cancel Culture was derailing the lives of people who have made embarrassing mistakes when they were younger, and how it could also have derailed mine had I not been given grace and room to grow. As a teenager I used homophobic slurs and rapped along to lyrics using the N word. I did this mostly because the people I grew up around did it, and I broke out of these habits because better adjusted older kids made me feel stupid and uncool for using this language without exiling me altogether. On occasion, I'll still make or laugh at an offensive or edgy joke, which describes a lot of humor. And I generally try not to judge young people by the worst things they say, especially in the context of them trying to be funny or win social approval. In sum, I don't think I'm particularly sensitive to this stuff, and I'm inclined against destroying people's lives when you can instead help them evolve. At the same time, extending grace is not the same as withholding consequences. Nobody is going to jail or being publicly tarred and feather. Neither should these young leaders be permanently blacklisted from working in politics. But they also shouldn't get to say the things they said in that chat without any blowback. There should be repercussions. Even assuming the best of the participants, it should still be taboo to say overtly racist things to be edgy, or joke about gas chambering your political opponents, or make light of embracing Hitler, especially in a context where you're supposedly modeling leadership behavior. The board of directors of the Young Republicans set the right tone in response to the leaked chats. They called the behavior disgraceful and unbecoming of Republicans and helped force out several members from the political jobs they were holding. This is good. This is what appropriate repercussions look like. Vice President J.D. vance, on the other hand, handled the situation about as poorly as one could have imagined. Vance dismissed the vile language as kids doing stupid things and that young boys make edgy and offensive jokes before repeating the mantra that we shouldn't ruin their lives for it. But this wasn't just some group of teenagers who didn't know any better. First off, these aren't kids. Most of these young men are in their 20s, and some are in their 30s and even 40s, just a few years younger than the vice president. Secondly, they are supposed to be the next generation of political leaders for the Republican Party. A few were in important government jobs or leadership positions. One was a state senator from Vermont who has since resigned. Second, the entire premise is laced with hypocrisy. Rumesa ozturk is a 30 year old graduate student who is snatched up on the street by ICE and detained for writing a milquetoast, a pro Palestine op ed. Is she a kid? She's younger than some participants in the group chat, and she was arrested and detained for a run of the mill political opinion piece. Third, and finally, appropriate consequences don't have to ruin lives. The Vice President, of all people, should be able to hold these Young Republicans to the same standard the board of directors of their own organization does. But alas, he was incapable of doing even that. Just this month I wrote about the J. Jones text messages in which the Democratic candidate for Virginia Attorney General entertained the value of his opponent's children dying in order to change his political views, and I called on him to drop out of his race. My argument in that case was simple. Let's make calls for political violence, even if they can be excused as jokes so taboo that both sides start to weed this behavior out of their own ranks. We have to police our own groups and communities. And my appeal to Democrats was to take the high road, sacrifice Jones and then try to hold Republicans to the same standards. Now it's the GOP's turn to exercise those standards. Republican senators just showed how easy it was with In Gracia. A few said that they would vote no, and now his nomination is dead. There wasn't some uprising from the base, and there was no downside to setting the standard. It just made them look like decent and reasonable people. The board of directors of the National Young Republicans also did a good job with the participants of the group chat. They condemned the text in plain language, and then they called on every member of the group chat to immediately resign, whatever positions they held. And many of them have this is good. This is how it's done. Which all brings me to my final point. For the most part, Republicans have actually handled these two scandals precisely how they should have. With the prominent exception of the Vice President and the small selection of members of Congress, most of the party condemn these behaviors for what they were. Plenty of news outlets, including Politico, have framed the story as the GOP being split on these text messages and how to navigate them. But I'm not really buying that Politico came up with exactly two Republican members of Congress who tried to defend or distract from the messages. I'm sure there were a few more, but I think the party generally condemned these actions for what they were. So framing this as a division is a gross overstatement. Sure, you can find plenty of people on X defending the Young Republicans, though nobody really came to in Gracia's defense. But that reaction isn't representative of the Republican Party as a whole. Repercussions are being delivered across the country. The Young Republicans organization itself has staked out a hardline condemnation, and almost every Republican at the state and national level has rejected this language outright and called for clear repercussions. This is an encouraging signal about the norms we're all still willing to enforce and live by. Republicans should keep it up, and Democrats should remember it the next time they have an opportunity to draw lines on what's acceptable and what's not. All right, that is it for my take. Senior editor Will Kbach has a dissent, so I'm gonna pass it over to him for that.

[Will Kaback]

Hey, this is Senior Editor Will Kaback jumping back in here to share my dissent to a portion of Isaac's take today. I agree with Isaac that the Republican Party writ large has responded appropriately to the Young Republican group chat leaks, but I think he's downplaying the importance of the dissent among the online right. Most notably, conservative podcaster Matt Walsh, who has nearly 4 million followers on X, suggested that the right should never disavow its own in order to maintain a united front against the left. The post has sparked a massive debate with some of the most influential conservative figures weighing in, many of whom have a direct line to the White House and President Trump. While I admire elected Republicans response to this controversy, I think this notion of no enemies to the right remains salient and will recur when future controversies arise. With all that said, it's also worth noting that elected Democrats approach to the recent scandals involving Jay Jones and Maine Senate candidate Graham Platner have been just as disappointing. All right, I'm going to send it back over to Isaac for today's reader question.

[Isaac Saul]

Foreign we'll be right back after this quick break.

[Boost Mobile Advertiser]

The longer you stay alive, the longer you can enjoy Boost Mobile's unlimited plan with a price that never goes up. So here are some tips. Do not parallel park on a cliff if you want to enjoy an unlimited plan with a price that never goes up, do not mistake a wasp nest for a pinata. If you want to enjoy an unlimited plan with a price that never goes up, do not Microsoft of a hard boiled egg if you want to enjoy an unlimited plan with the price that never goes up, stay alive and enjoy Unlimited Wireless for $25 a month forever. With Boost Mobile, after 30 gigs, customers may experience slower speeds. Customers will pay $25 a month as long as they remain active on the Boost Mobile Unlimited Plan.

[BetterHelp Advertiser]

If you're navigating anxiety, depression, relationship challenges, postpartum struggles, or something else, you deserve care that meets you where you are. GrowTherapy is designed to help you find a therapist who fits your needs and supports the way you want to feel. They connect you with thousands of independent licensed therapists across the US offering both virtual and in person sessions. You can search by insurance provider, specialty treatment methods and more to find a therapist who works for you. Whatever challenges you're facing, GrowTherapy is here to help. Sessions average about $21 with insurance and some pay as little as $0 depending on their plan. Visit growththerapy.com acast today to get started. That's growththerapy.growtherapy.com acast availability and coverage vary by state and insurance plan.

[Isaac Saul]

All right, next up is your questions answered. This one's from Jody in Seattle, Washington. Jody said, Would it make any difference if Congress stopped getting paid during a shutdown? And why, when the government shuts down, do I still pay taxes? Okay, this is a great question. Actually divided our staff a little bit, so we've got some version of this a lot this week. Some readers have wondered if members of Congress get paid during the shutdown. They do. If any have publicly declined their salaries. Some have pledged to. And if congressional staffs are getting paid, they are, but they are subject to furlough. Those are questions with straightforward, factual answers, as is your second question. Congress is getting paid because Article 1, Section 6 of the Constitution defines the pay of federal legislators, stating in part that Senators and Representatives shall receive a compensation for their services to be ascertained by law and paid out of the treasury of the United States. Your first question is more of an opinion question, one that strongly divided our editorial team. Would it make any difference if Congress stopped getting paid during a shutdown? We should start by saying that several bills have actually been proposed that would achieve this goal. The Make America Govern Again act, introduced yesterday, ironically during the shutdown, would bar members from collecting salaries during a shutdown. And the no Budget, no Pay act, introduced in January, goes a step further and would forbid members from collecting a salary until Congress approves a budget. Those all sound like good motivators, so why wouldn't they make a difference? Some of us, like managing editor Ari Weitzman and social media and marketing strategist Russell Nystrom, think such laws wouldn't make a difference. Russell and Ari believe the salary cost would likely be less than the benefit gained by any politician who would vote in favor of such a measure. Wealthier members of Congress make plenty of side money from book deals and speaking fees and have for years and now make so much in stock deals that it's become almost a joke. Without pairing this measure with other reforms like requiring members to place investments in a blind trust. This kind of reform will likely serve to give more leverage to wealthier representatives to push their agendas to knowing others are less able to survive shutdowns. Others of us, like me and Associate Editor Audrey Moorhead, strongly disagree. We think that very few members of Congress actually make a lot of money off book deals or trading stocks. Remember, Congress is over 500 members. For the vast majority, losing their pay would be a huge deal. And we think the consequences would increase the pressure on the majority of Congress to find a deal in a way that could actually be pretty productive. All right. That is it for your questions answered. I'm going to send it back to Will for the rest of the pod and I'll see you guys tomorrow. And I hope some of you out in LA on Friday have a good one. Don't forget to sign up for subtext. Peace.

[Will Kaback]

Thanks, Isaac. All right, jumping back in now with our under the Radar story. On Monday, Colombia recalled its ambassador to the United States, Daniel Garcia Pena, amid rising tensions between the countries over US Strikes on alleged truck boats in the Caribbean. Colombian President Gustavo Petro accused the United States of, quote, murder for a strike in September that he claims killed a fisherman whose boat was adrift due to engine failure. Trump responded by alleging that Petro was encouraging drug production in Colombia and announcing that he would cut off U.S. aid to the country. The Hill has this story, and we'll put the link to it in today's episode notes. Now onto today's numbers. 2,900. That's the number of pages of chats among young Republicans leaked to Politico. And the number of text messages in the leak was approximately 28,000. The year that the association of New York State Young Republican Clubs was established was 1932, and the age range of those eligible to join the club was 18 to 40. Finally, the number of days between Paul and Gracia being nominated to lead the Office of Special Counsel and his withdrawal for the position was 145 days. Finally, here's today's have a nice day story. Jeff Robertson became a local celebrity for his house's Halloween decorations in 2020, and he decided to use some of that attention to help others. Robertson launched skeletons for St Jude, a national campaign that encourages families to decorate their homes for Halloween and raise awareness and funds for children's cancer research. Roughly 600 homes are already participating this year, and Robertson says the number could reach 1,000 by Halloween. The effort has raised approximately 978,000 for St. Jude since 2020. Good Good Good has this story and we'll put the link to it in the show notes as well as the link to check out the Skeletons for St. Jude website. All right, that is it for today's edition. Thanks as always for being with us. We'll be back tomorrow. Have a great day.

[Isaac Saul]

Our Executive Editor and founder is me, Isaac Sowell and our Executive Producer is John Wall. Today's episode was as edited and engineered by Dewey Thomas. Our editorial staff is led by Managing Editor Ari Weitzman with Senior Editor Will K. Back and Associate Editors Hunter Casperson, Audrey Moorhead Bailey, Saul, Lindsey Knuth and Kendall White. Music for the podcast was produced by Diet75. To learn more about Tangle and to sign up for a membership, please visit our [e-mail].

[Mint Mobile / Monday.com Advertiser]

You know what's faster than your paycheck? Literally everything. It's time to get your pay up to speed with Earn In. You can access your pay as you work instead of waiting days and weeks for a paycheck. Get up to $150 a day with max of $750 between paydays. No interest, no credit checks and no mandatory fees because hey, it's your money. Download the earnin app now to get it and join millions of people making any day payday. That's earnin. Earnin is not a bank. Access limits are your earnings and risk factors available in select states. Expedited transfers available for a fee. Terms and restrictions apply. Visit Earnin.com for full details.

[American Red Cross Advertiser]

Blood Donation is now more Inclusive More people are able to donate blood with the American Red Cross through FDA guidelines that eliminate eligibility questions based on sexual orientation. The Red Cross celebrates this historic change and welcomes those who may be newly eligible to donate blood. There's a place for everyone in the mission of the Red Cross Cross. The Red Cross is committed to achieving an inclusive blood donation process that treats all potential donors with equality and respect while maintaining the safety of the blood supply. Join us and help save lives. To learn more and make your appointment to donate blood, visit redcrossblood.org LGBTQ that's redcrossblood.org LGBTQ if your dog could talk.

[BetterHelp Advertiser]

They'D beg for Ollie. The full body tail wag, the excited little hops, the big goofy grin. That's the oll. Ollie delivers clean, fresh nutrition in five drool worthy flavors even for the pickiest eaters. Made in US kitchens with high quality human grade ingredients, Ollie's food contains no fillers, no preservatives, just real food. Just fill out Ollie's 32nd quiz and they'll create a customized meal plan based on your pup's weight, activity level, and other health info. Dogs deserve the best, and that means fresh, healthy food. Head to ollie.com healthypup tell them about your dog and use code healthypup to get 60% off your welcome subscribe today. Plus, they offer a happiness guarantee on the first box, so if you're not completely satisfied, you'll get your money back. That's O L L I E.com HealthyPup and enter code HealthyPup to get 60% off your first box.