
Today we’re sharing an episode of The Hustle Daily Show — a daily dose of irreverent, offbeat, and informative takes on business & tech news. In this episode, they take a look at how getting stuff for “free” affects consumer behavior.
Loading summary
Ryan Reynolds
Ryan Reynolds here from Mint Mobile. I don't know if you knew this, but anyone can get the same Premium Wireless for $15 a month plan that I've been enjoying. It's not just for celebrities. So do like I did and have one of your assistant's assistants switch you to Mint Mobile today. I'm told it's super easy to do@mintmobile.com.
Podcast Announcer
Switch upfront payment of $45 for 3 month plan equivalent to $15 per month Required intro rate first 3 months only, then full price plan options available, taxes and fees extra. See full terms@mintmobile.com hey listeners, in this episode, we're doing something a bit different. We're featuring an episode from another podcast called the Hustle Daily show. More than 2 1/2 million young professionals read the Hustle's daily email for its irreverent and informative takes on business and tech news. Now they have a daily podcast called the Hustle Daily show where their team of writers break down the biggest business headlines in 10 minutes or less and explain why you should care about them. They'll also do deep dives on topics like the story of a man who won the lottery 14 times and why it's nearly impossible to buy an original Bob Ross painting. I checked out a few episodes of the Hustle Daily show and boy is it interesting. What I love about it is that it's really well researched, it's entertaining, and frankly, it's really thought provoking. In the episode I'm about to play for you, you'll learn why people go absolutely crazy for free stuff, from free grocery store samples to free shipping to those crummy T shirts that get shut out of cannons at sporting events. Let's jump in and I'll catch you on the other side to tie things up.
Zachary Crockett
So let me paint a scene for you here. It's 2015. We're at a Costco in Southern California, the epicenter of chill vibes. It's just before 11am and the free samples are out in full swing. You've got the tables with people hocking crackers and nuts and smoked meats and all of a sudden this brawl breaks.
Mark Dent
Yeah, this 78 year old guy is there at the table helping himself to quite a few free samples of Nutella waffles, which sound absolutely delightful by the way. And someone who's quite a bit younger, in his 20s is not having it and he tells the guy to stop hoarding so many samples and they get into a little bit of an argument and then all of a sudden, the 20 something guy punches the 78 year old in the face.
Zachary Crockett
Is there bloodshed?
Mark Dent
Oh, yes, there's bloodshed. There's a hospital visit, there's an arrest. There's a lot of news stories on the local TV stations in California.
Zachary Crockett
This is all over a free sample.
Mark Dent
Yeah, it was just those Nutella waffles.
Zachary Crockett
Okay, so this may seem odd, right, that a few small free samples on toothpicks can do something like incite violence. But this conduct is really rooted in behavioral psychology. And as it turns out, free stuff makes us do very strange things. I'm Zachary Crockett.
Mark Dent
And I'm Mark Dent. This is the Hustle Daily Show.
Zachary Crockett
And today we are taking a look at how getting stuff for free, free affects consumer behavior. And to really get at the heart of the story here, we're gonna focus on three wildly different areas. Free grocery store samples, free shipping, and online content. And really free affects all of these arenas in very different ways. But I guess to start, I'll ask you a question, Mark. What is it about the word free that drives us nuts and makes us do this stuff? You talked to a couple influential behavioral psychologists and economists about this?
Mark Dent
Yeah. Kind of like you were saying, when something becomes free, it's like all bets are off. Any sort of normal type of consumer behavior changes. It just goes completely off the charts to where something that might seem totally irrational in kind of any other situation now feels. It feels normal and you're going to start doing it. And obviously that fight was like a pretty crazy example. But like, there's this one study that is seen as the sort of like ultimate gauge of what your behavior is like when you see something that's free. And this happened at like a really prestigious university in their cafeteria. And Dan Ariely, Dan Ariely is a pretty well known behavioral economist and a couple of other researchers, they started having some chocolates in this cafeteria. And for one study, they had Hershey's kisses that cost one penny and they had Lindt truffles for 14 cents.
Zachary Crockett
A far superior chocolate.
Mark Dent
Yeah, like people pay a lot of money for those things. So 14 cents is like a really good deal.
Zachary Crockett
Right?
Mark Dent
And one cent for a Hershey's kiss is, you know, maybe kind of a good deal, but pretty average, I would say. And so not surprisingly, the Lindt truffle wins out big time. Roughly three times, almost four times as many people choose to pay 14 cents for that. Over one cent for the Hershey's kiss. But here is there we get this crazy irrational thing about free Stuff, they decide to make the Hershey's Kiss free when they do the experiment again because they dropped that price by $0.01. They also dropped the Lindt truffle price by $0.01, so it's now $0.13. And this time, the Hershey's Kiss for free is way more popular. More than twice as many people pick the Hershey's Kiss as they do the Lindt truffle, even though it's not as good, but it's free. That's what matters.
Zachary Crockett
Wow. So first study. The Hershey's kiss is $0.01. Overwhelmingly, people go with the lint truffle. And then essentially the same pricing, except the Hershey Kiss is free. And overwhelmingly, people pick the kiss. Just a $0.01 difference.
Mark Dent
There's no difference in the price at all. And it's not like it was one of those special dark Hershey's Kisses or, you know, the one that has, like, white chocolate mixed with it and it's somehow a little bit nicer. Right?
Zachary Crockett
Right.
Mark Dent
Yeah. It's the same thing, the same Hershey's Kiss. There's no.
Zachary Crockett
No extra utility derived from that. Hershey's Kiss. It's the same piece of crappy chocolate.
Mark Dent
Yeah. And they even set up the experiment so that like, like, at first they worried if there was some sort of, like, bias that would creep in. Because when something is free, you don't have to reach for your wallet. Right. Which is kind of like, you know, it saves you a little bit of effort if something is free. But they even had it set out so that that was not an effect. Right. They were sitting there at the end of the counter for people who were already buying things, you know, so, like, they were already buying some sort of item from the cafeteria, so they already had their wallet out. Right.
Zachary Crockett
Sure. So what does Ariely conclude here?
Mark Dent
So they came up with something called the zero price effect. They kind of coined that term. And what it really means is that people overvalue things that are free and they make irrational decisions when something free is involved. And one of the other co authors of that study, Christina Champenier, was telling me that the behavior is irrational because the participants who picked that free Hershey's Kiss, they gave up something that was better, something that they would almost certainly prefer in a traditional cost benefit analysis.
Zachary Crockett
Sure.
Mark Dent
So, like, in life, we're making these cost benefit analyses every day, and when you throw in this extra variable of something that's free, they just go haywire.
Zachary Crockett
So tell me if I have this right, an example of this playing out in the real world would be like, let's say you see, you know, a crappy, low quality T shirt at a store for 20 bucks. Most people are just going to walk by and, you know, feel the fabric and say, eh, I don't know, that's not worth 20 bucks. They just continue on with their day. But if that same exact T shirt is like, you know, launched out of a cannon at a baseball game into the crowd, you're going to have like 20 dudes fighting over it, spilling beer all over each other and causing mayhem just to get their hands on that T shirt.
Mark Dent
And potentially maybe hundreds of people, not even just 20.
Zachary Crockett
Right.
Mark Dent
They're always wondering, like, why don't you aim the cannon at me? Why not the upper deck?
Zachary Crockett
Right, right.
Mark Dent
That's like exactly what it is. There's something that is of not necessarily that much value, but just, you know, smack the word free on it. Christina Champonier, one of these co authors, was saying that there's like this glow that we attach to it. That was like the word that she used, like this positive glow. That's almost like a high. Like your mind is just not clear in some sort of way, you know, just like kind of it is with a traditional high, I suppose.
Zachary Crockett
So we're under kind of a trance, a spell, like a free stuff spell. And when we're in this kind of trance, we don't really see the downsides of what we're getting for free.
Mark Dent
Yeah. The downside in the Hershey's Kiss case would be like you're actually passing up something of value. Right. You know, they were passing up the opportunity to have a lint truffle that is more delicious, more expensive, typically because of that free thing. And they're giving that up. Right. And the T shirt is maybe a little bit different. Maybe you're kind of giving up your dignity, I guess. Like when you're just like jostling for that thing, you essentially don't realize that what you're doing has some sort of probably cost to it, you know, because you just think it's free.
Zachary Crockett
You know, there's. There's like free stuff all around us every day, especially in E commerce. You looked at free shipping as one arena where the word free is used very liberally. But what you're finding here is free shipping is kind of a good example of not really being able to see those downsides. Is that right?
Mark Dent
Yeah, people, they are obsessed with free shipping. There was like a 2019 survey that showed 77% of over a thousand participants Said that free shipping was what made them more likely to buy an item online, more so than free returns. Same day shipping. So fast shipping even wasn't all that important. It was just like getting this sort of free thing was the thing that drove people to actually buy something online more than almost any other factor. It obviously makes some sense, right? Like, hey, it's free shipping that helps you out. But the problem is that people oftentimes don't realize that whether it's, like, different companies or, you know, people who are just kind of selling things online individually will often jack up the price of the product because they are offering free shipping. And so the free thing obscures the fact that you're paying a premium price. I know you've kind of looked into this, Zach. Free shipping, to me seems like this really dodgy, maybe halfway version of like a buy one, get one free, you know, Totally is.
Zachary Crockett
Yeah, the free shipping thing totally reminds me of buy one, get one free deal. So we've all gone to the store and, you know, let's say it's a pair of jeans or something at Levi's, and you buy one, you get one free seems like a great deal. But what's often happening behind the scenes in those kind of promotions is that you're really just getting 50% off of the MSRP, the rack price. An example that an economist gave me a few years ago was, let's say a retailer has a surplus of jeans. It costs them $20 per pair to acquire them and to make them, and they sell them for $100 each. Right. So $20 cost, they sell them for 100 bucks. Now, if they run a standard 50% off sale, just one pair of jeans, 50% off, so they buy it for 20 to sell it for 50 bucks, they make $30 on that one pair of jeans. But with a bogo, what often happens is they'll just sell that first pair of jeans for $100. They'll keep that price up at MSRP and you'll get one free. But the retailer is actually making $60. They're making a $30 profit on each pair of jeans. In that case, they're passing it off as if they're giving you this crazy deal. But it's not really a crazy deal. They're still winning. And now you have two pairs of pants when you only really needed one. So there's a social waste element to it as well. But the point being, you're right. There are all these hidden costs when things are free.
Mark Dent
Yeah. And it's like in that kind of example you're giving people, they feel like they're saving though, you know what I mean?
Zachary Crockett
Sure.
Mark Dent
And so it becomes worth it for them, which again is not necessarily rational, but it is something that feels good. You know, for instance, to go back to the shipping thing, there was a study done over at Wharton University of Pennsylvania where consumers preferred to save $7 and get free shipping versus saving $10 off the purchase price and still pay for shipping. So they're really like flat out saying, I would rather pay a little bit more as long as something feels free. We'll maybe get into some good buy one, get one examples that you have here. I think there's definitely like this sort of positive glow we've been talking about, but I think there's also a practical element to it as well where I think people do also sometimes not really understand what these extra costs should be and what they maybe should be paying for and not paying for. So, like with shipping, for instance, they know it's normal to pay for this tangible product, but they don't necessarily see the cost that goes into shipping. Right. Like there's a whole bunch of costs associated. You have to have someone drive it to your door, you have to have it probably be flown on an airplane somewhere, etc. And it's really hard to think of those as costs that you want to pay for. And you're just like, screw all that, like, why would I need to pay for free shipping? And that also, I think, gets into it.
Zachary Crockett
Yeah, that's totally true. There's like this fallacy that we have as consumers that the price we're paying is just for the good itself. But even long before E Commerce, long before you went online and bought that pair of jeans on Amazon or whatever, if you go to a brick and mortar store and you buy, let's say, a pair of pants, part of what you're paying for is the trucking and the shipping to get that there. And you know, it goes beyond the, obviously the cost of the good itself. But like you said, those prices just aren't a transparent part of the pricing model and we don't often see them.
Mark Dent
Yeah, and it's like you wouldn't really know unless you actually are someone who has like their own E commerce store or something like that. If you were to ask me, like, how much does it cost to ship a pair of jeans across the country, I'd be like, I have no idea. I wouldn't know if it was like five bucks or if it was like 15. I really wouldn't. Yeah, I think it's probably closer to five or seven maybe, but I don't know. I do know it's very expensive if you ship it overseas, basically no matter what. But, yeah, it's just something that's so far outside of most people's minds what that thing should cost. So you're just like, it better be free.
Zachary Crockett
Right. I think that lack of knowledge really plays into why we fall prey to the word free. I remember one economist with buy one, get one free deals just telling me, buy one, get one free deals are kind of like quasi legitimate, maybe not so legitimate deals, and they really rely on consumers not paying a lot of attention to what they're doing. It just rests on the assumption that we don't know those costs and we don't know what goes into commerce, and we just wander in and we are suddenly under the spell of this one word.
Mark Dent
Right? And you can totally be taken advantage of. You wrote about how there were, like, 150 lawsuits just over the last few years over free promotions. And some of these are just, like, pretty awful, frankly. Very scammy.
Zachary Crockett
Right? So, yeah, I'll give you a few examples here. Burger King, years ago, they offered a buy one, get one free croissanwich deal. Never knew that was a thing. But anyway, in this deal, they charged a higher price for the sandwich than it regularly cost. So the sandwich regularly cost about $2.16. They charged $3.15. They charged an entire dollar more for the sandwich, for the buy one, get one free. So, yes, you got one for free, but you paid significantly more for the first one. Mypillow, this infamous pillow company that's now, you know, obviously under a lot of scrutiny for its affiliations in recent years. They offered a buy one, get one free deal on their pillows, but they jacked up the price on the first pillow by 2x. So you paid double the price for the first pillow.
Mark Dent
So that one was literally not a deal at all.
Zachary Crockett
It's literally just like buying two pillows from them. It's the same thing. Vision works. They offered a buy one, get one free deal on eyeglasses, but it turned out they'd increased the price of the first pair of glasses by 40%. So, you know, a lot of companies have been caught. This is actually considered deceptive marketing for inflating the price of the first good that you get to basically cover the cost of the second, quote unquote free item. You know, in short, in some of these more nefarious situations, you're not getting Anything for free, you're paying for it. It's baked into the price.
Mark Dent
It's like what you exactly were saying. No one has any clue, frankly, what a pillow probably normally costs. So they're just like, oh, buy one, get one free. They're like, oh, yeah, all right, yeah, 12 bucks. That makes sense. And also like, go. God bless the people who filed these lawsuits because it means that they did such great homework to Burger King. They were like, you know what, I swear to God, I knew it said $2.16 on this menu like a month ago and somehow went up and looked that up. And I love that.
Zachary Crockett
When I think of free shipping, I immediately think Amazon, they completely revolutionized the game with free shipping. They normalized free shipping. They made it an expectation rather than just an extra perk.
Mark Dent
Yeah, absolutely. They have, of course, their prime program, which makes most free shipping wise. And they've been like experimenting with it going back to the time when Jeff Bezos was like appearing in Taco Bell commercials, you know what I mean? Like in the, in like the late 90s and such.
Zachary Crockett
Yeah.
Mark Dent
At that time they were trying out free shipping in different countries and in France they reduced it, you know, at least at the study I saw, to one franc. This was like during that really weird time when the euro had not quite been switched over for currency yet for France. So this really cheap amount for shipping, but not quite free. And so what they saw in France was that sales didn't rise all that dramatically compared to some other countries where they did offer free shipping. It was such a hook, it led to people buying those things. And you know, we're talking about not being able to see what things actually cost. So therefore you think free is a good deal or like even something necessary to have. I really just think Amazon prime is like a perfect instance of that too. You pay this flat fee every year and it's unclear if it's really going to be worth it for you. Right. Because again, we really don't know how much shipping actually costs on a given item. And so you just think, oh, well, I'll pay this. And I'm sure it'll make sense for me in the long run because everything says free on it when you go to check out.
Zachary Crockett
So, you know, in short, here with free shipping, most of the time the cost is just baked in to what you're paying anyway. They're using free shipping. They're touting it as this big benefit that you're getting, but it's really just baked into the price at the End of the day in most cases. Now, you looked into a different area here. Let's take it back to free samples. We talked about the brawl that emerged in that Costco at the beginning of this podcast. But a lot of stores like Costco that have these free sample models, I think one question everybody has is, you know, there's got to be some catch here. What are the stores getting out of giving all this stuff away for free?
Mark Dent
Right. Like, we've been kind of talking so far about how free it gives you this glow. It kind of, you know, makes you act a little bit irrational. It kind of, like, obscures certain costs that may actually be involved to the point where you actually may not get that good of a deal on something that's free. Throw all those ingredients in there. And then on top of that, as Dan Ariely told me, something that's free usually makes you want to, like, do something nice in return.
Zachary Crockett
Oh, really?
Mark Dent
Because someone essentially did something for you, so you want to do something for them. And what that means for stores like Costco is that when those Nutella waffles there are, you know, on a toothpick for. And, you know, A, they taste delicious, so you might want to buy them. But B, you got them for free, so you might want to buy them. It kind of catalyzes you into going that extra step and, you know, paying five bucks for them or whatever, because you got it for free.
Zachary Crockett
So there is a monetary payoff here.
Mark Dent
Yeah. And there's, like, pretty good data about this, actually. I mean, what we've seen is that on frozen pizza, there's a 600% average annual percentage increase in sales after you have that in free sample demonstrations.
Zachary Crockett
Wow.
Mark Dent
I mean, that's easily the craziest one. But with lipstick, I mean, think Sephora, right, Where there's a ton of free makeup samples there. 540%, 310%. For wine and cheese, it's 103% beer, 71% gain. I would love to know why wine. It's 310% and only 71% for beer.
Zachary Crockett
I don't know, maybe more economists drink beer or something.
Mark Dent
That is a study there.
Zachary Crockett
Yeah. So this kind of explained, you know, wineries giving out free wine flights or something, and, you know, you feel indebted to them. And actually, in a lot of these free sample cases, leads to massive increases in sales for what ultimately amounts to a pretty minimal input cost. I think you, you. You dug up some 2011 data that showed that the average demonstration company for one day at a grocery Store might be something like 150, 400 bucks. Something in there.
Mark Dent
Yeah, it's definitely not cheap, but usually it returns. It's a good investment. Otherwise people wouldn't do it. Of course. And like we were just saying, this is an old stat from a few years ago, but add up every company that wants to, like, hire someone to do their free samples and has them at the different stores and whatnot, and it's a $2 billion a year industry. $2 billion is spent to give people free stuff in hopes that they will reciprocate back. And they do. And, you know, we've been talking about irrationality and whatnot, but I think, like, this part of the equation, to me at least, is like, a little bit less rational to some degree. Right. If you get something for free, you want to do something back. I think it's more of, like, a nice side of human nature to some extent, even though we're still talking about spending and money and business.
Zachary Crockett
All right, so free shipping comes with ancillary costs that are baked in that you don't see free samples. You have this feeling that you need to reciprocate. And maybe, yes, you get that Nutella sample for free, but you end up spending, I don't know, 20 bucks on, like, three jars of Nutella or something in return for that. There's a third arena, and this is dramatically different. But how do we think about free in the digital ecosystem with content where everything is just expected to be free and we have this overwhelming pit of free content everywhere we look?
Mark Dent
I wanted to look into this because a. Like you said, stuff online is free. Right. There's a lot of free news sites, free social media sites, et cetera. And on top of that, usually the different types of services that do charge you for, like, content on the Internet, they'll typically give you a freebie, right? They'll give you maybe three or four free articles per month on, like, the New York Times or if you subscribe to somebody's substack newsletter, even those that are premium, they generally, they'll give you, like, one free article a week or something like that. So they are more or less doing what Costco is. They're giving you something free, free, hoping to entice you to buy something. And I know, Zach, you and I have talked about different news subscriptions and how expensive they are, but, you know, the New York Times is roughly, I don't know, I think 10 bucks a month or 8 bucks a month or something like that. So that's what they're hoping you'll shell out. Right. If you get a couple of things for free. I asked Dan Ariely about this and he said no. Like, that whole feeling of reciprocation, it does not apply.
Zachary Crockett
That doesn't carry over to content on the Internet.
Mark Dent
No. If you just look at the numbers, like, you can kind of see why. According to the RO Reuters Institute's Digital News Report for 2020, only about 20% of Americans pay for online news. And, I mean, that's really not that much. Obviously, some subscription publications are doing very well, but only a couple, you know, you know, the New York Times being one Washington Post, some more niche kind of websites as well. And you can just tell it, people don't want to pay for it. You know, whenever I see, like, some journalist post something on Twitter, like this huge investigative report, usually, like, the first replies are like, I can't read this. It's a paywall.
Zachary Crockett
Yeah, yeah.
Mark Dent
And so why is this, though? It's unlike the food, where we've been conditioned to knowing that we must pay for food for, like, centuries, at least, maybe even eons. You know, if you think of, like, bartering and whatnot, that's not really the case with the Internet. When the Internet really came of age over the last 25, 30 years, there's been more of an expectation that things are free. Right. So you don't feel like you have to reciprocate because you expect that it is going to be free. Facebook, it's free. Twitter is free.
Zachary Crockett
Yeah. And something like 4 in 10Americans say that they would never pay for news.
Mark Dent
Yeah, exactly.
Zachary Crockett
So that one in five sliver may stay pretty small for a while. Of the people who aren't paying, 40% of them have no interest in starting.
Mark Dent
Yeah. And to, like, bring this all full circle. What's most fascinating, I think, about people not wanting to pay for news or social media or something like that is that free content isn't necessarily a good deal. It takes us back to, like, the irrationality of free stuff because, say, you're on Facebook, we all know you get bombarded with ads, targeted ads, for that matter. And because it is dependent on this one sort of revenue model, as they say, you know, sometimes when something is free, you're the customer. Right. And that's certainly the case with social media. So people who have this free service that they're like, yes, yes, it's free. I would never pay for this. They might be clicking on one of those targeted ads and they might be buying something that they don't really want and spending money that way. And the same is true with news sites where there's a lot of ads on a lot of those. And for some kind of news websites, they're not very high quality websites, so your experience isn't very good. So there's all these kind of costs again that people are overlooking because something is free and they just are like, yeah, free, free, give me free. And they don't think about the other costs that they're paying in the long run.
Zachary Crockett
Yeah. And you know, you could even make the case that the costs of free content are higher than the costs of hidden costs of something like free shipping. The things we are giving away on the Internet are actually very highly valued.
Mark Dent
Right.
Zachary Crockett
We're often giving away vast swaths of our personal data just to access a website. You know, you should enter your personal information or something to get access to a free site. That's not free. People are behind the scenes brokering your data on data brokering websites. Your data enters this kind of intractable stream of where it gets disseminated to all different types of parties. You get signed up for newsletters, you get junk mail, you get phone calls. I guess the adage that nothing is free really is true in this case.
Mark Dent
Like you said, you're giving up your information. And in some ways I think that you're also perhaps giving up your time. In some ways, right, It's a free service. You're just going to be on it all the time. Perhaps like how some people are with social media. There's just so many different costs.
Zachary Crockett
And I'm sure, you know, if everything is free and available at any given time, we're going to have less reservations about interacting and spending more time on those platforms. That's a huge waste of time. It kind of gets at this other concept of diminishing marginal utility too. You know, the easiest way to think about this is if you buy a whole pizza and you're really hungry, the first slice is going to be incredible. You're gonna bite into it and say, this is the best damn pizza I've ever had in my life. Second piece, pretty damn good.
Mark Dent
Yeah.
Zachary Crockett
Third piece, maybe still pretty good. Fourth piece, fifth piece, whatever, you know, by the fifth, sixth piece, depending on your appetite, it's gonna start not tasting as good. By the seventh and eighth piece, you're gonna be very full. You're gonna start wishing you didn't have any pizza left. If you get it to like now, you know, 9, 10, 11, 12 range, whatever, you're probably gonna throw up. The further you go, the less utility, the less value you're getting out of each slice. And I often think about how this plays into content on the Internet. You know, the first 20 minutes browsing Twitter might yield some funny or interesting things.
Mark Dent
Oh, yes.
Zachary Crockett
But the longer you stay on, the more toxic it is.
Mark Dent
Yeah. When I am like logging on Twitter for the first time in the day, I'm kind of like, okay, now I kind of remember why I'm addicted to this. But, you know, then by 3:00 in the afternoon, you feel like you are ready to just go into a corner and just look at like a blank wall for an. Basically because it would feel better than looking at Twitter for even two more minutes. It is truly all around us. And there obviously is content that we do pay for, right? Netflix, Hulu, et cetera. So it's so malleable in a way. Right. Some content we see as having value worth paying for, some we don't. And these extra costs that you incur, I think because you don't really realize that there is actually value in that. And so someone else has. Has figured out a way to make value off of that content and they're making it off of you, even though you're not paying them five bucks or whatever.
Zachary Crockett
One other thing it reminds me of, this is a little bit of a tangent, but have you ever seen, like, those free cars at the mall?
Mark Dent
Oh, yeah. When I was a child, I. I loved seeing those.
Zachary Crockett
Yeah. So you walk into the middle of a mall, there's this, like, cordoned off section, and there's this shiny new Acura or whatever, and it's. It's this beautiful car parked in the middle of the mall. A huge sign above it that says, free car. All you have to do is enter to win. I did an investigation a few years ago on those promotions, and it turns out that in many cases, at least the one that I entered, you basically enter this competition, you put your name, your email, your address, your phone number, all of your data into this digital form, and you basically get entered into a timeshare competition. You get invited to all these timeshare presentations, and your data goes into this database. In the fine print of the contract, it says they can sell it and resell it and resell it, resell it to data brokers. You never get out of it. And the kicker is that there's no free car at all. In the fine print of the contract, it says the car is for display purposes only. It's not actually a part of the Giveaway.
Mark Dent
So basically, they were giving away the opportunity to be wooed by someone who has, like, a condo in the Virgin Islands or something like that.
Zachary Crockett
Yeah. And the real prize was, like, a $200 gift card or something to that effect. But the only way to qualify for it was to attend all these timeshare presentations and waste, like, six hours of.
Mark Dent
Your day, all your time.
Zachary Crockett
So basically, the costs outweighed the benefits. But, you know, I feel like that's the perfect antidote to kind of summarize everything that you found in your story. It's just maybe I'm overly cynical, but maybe, truly, there is nothing for free in the world. Maybe it's just not worth it when you see that word.
Mark Dent
Yeah, I know. Although I still get suckered in by free stuff. Here's like, a kind of a fun example. So I got married a few months ago, and we would have hired this photographer no matter what. Right. But, like, as part of the package that we paid a few thousand dollars for, they also gave us a free T shirt. And it's just like a regular white T shirt that has, like, their company logo on it. But I just. I wear it all the time. I'm like, I really like this shirt. You know, it's a cool shirt, and probably because it's free, like, I wear it all the time now.
Zachary Crockett
And when you wear it, do you think, damn, I got this shirt for free?
Mark Dent
Yeah, I mean, I totally do.
Zachary Crockett
Even though you paid 2,000 bucks, basically to get this shirt?
Mark Dent
Yes. Yeah, it was very expensive shirt, all things considered.
Zachary Crockett
Oh, man, that's funny. All right, that's going to do it for us today, folks. Thanks for tuning into the Hustle Daily Show. We're a proud part of the Huzbot podcast network. Our editor today is Robert Hartwig, and our executive producer is Darren Clark. We've got a lot more tech and business coverage for you in our newsletter. And if you're not subscribed to that, you can go over to the Hustle Co. And get yourself subscribed. That's the Hustle Co. Catch you all tomorrow.
Mark Dent
Tomorrow.
Podcast Announcer
That was an episode of the podcast the Hustle Daily Show. There are more episodes available where you'll hear daily business and tech news in 10 minutes or less. To hear those episodes, just search the Hustle Daily show in your podcast app. That's the Hustle Daily Show.
The $100 MBA Show: MBA2269 Bonus Episode Summary
Episode Title: MBA2269 Bonus Episode: You're Going to Love The Hustle Daily Show
Release Date: March 20, 2023
Host/Author: Omar Zenhom
In this bonus episode of The $100 MBA Show, host Omar Zenhom presents an insightful feature from The Hustle Daily Show. This episode delves deep into the intriguing psychology behind why people are irresistibly drawn to free items. Through engaging discussions between Zachary Crockett and Mark Dent, listeners gain a comprehensive understanding of how the allure of "free" influences consumer behavior across various domains.
Omar Zenhom introduces the episode by highlighting The Hustle Daily Show—a podcast extension of The Hustle's popular daily business and tech news email. With over 2.5 million young professionals as readers, the podcast promises well-researched, entertaining, and thought-provoking content. The featured episode explores the compelling reasons behind humanity's obsession with free stuff, ranging from grocery samples to online content.
The episode kicks off with a dramatic real-life example:
Mark Dent [02:08]: "Yeah, this 78-year-old guy is there at the table helping himself to quite a few free samples of Nutella waffles, which sound absolutely delightful by the way. And someone who's quite a bit younger, in his 20s, is not having it and he tells the guy to stop hoarding so many samples and they get into a little bit of an argument and then all of a sudden, the 20-something guy punches the 78-year-old in the face."
This incident underscores the extreme reactions that "free" items can provoke, highlighting the potent psychological triggers at play.
Zachary Crockett and Mark Dent delve into the concept of the zero price effect, coined by behavioral economist Dan Ariely. This phenomenon explains how the introduction of something for free can drastically alter consumer decisions, often leading to irrational choices.
Mark Dent [06:04]: "Any sort of normal type of consumer behavior changes. It just goes completely off the charts to where something that might seem totally irrational in kind of any other situation now feels... it feels normal and you're going to start doing it."
A pivotal study is discussed where participants overwhelmingly chose free Hershey's Kisses over discounted Lindt truffles, despite the latter being superior:
Mark Dent [05:50]: "More than twice as many people pick the Hershey's Kiss as they do the Lindt truffle, even though it's not as good, but it's free. That's what matters."
This illustrates how the word "free" can overshadow rational assessments of value.
Free shipping has become a cornerstone of e-commerce, often touted as a major incentive for online purchases. However, Crockett and Dent reveal the concealed costs embedded within:
Mark Dent [09:49]: "People are obsessed with free shipping. There was like a 2019 survey that showed 77% of over a thousand participants said that free shipping was what made them more likely to buy an item online, more so than free returns. Same day shipping even wasn't all that important."
While consumers perceive free shipping as a significant benefit, retailers frequently offset this by inflating product prices. For instance, a "buy one, get one free" (BOGO) deal might actually result in higher overall profits for the retailer:
Zachary Crockett [10:56]: "They're still winning. And now you have two pairs of pants when you only really needed one. So there's a social waste element to it as well."
This dynamic illustrates the deceptive nature of some "free" promotions, where the financial burden shifts subtly onto the consumer.
The digital realm is saturated with content labeled as "free," from news articles to social media platforms. However, Crockett and Dent argue that this "free" often comes at a hidden price—primarily in the form of personal data:
Zachary Crockett [26:31]: "We're often giving away vast swaths of our personal data just to access a website... You get signed up for newsletters, you get junk mail, you get phone calls."
Unlike physical goods, where costs are more tangible, the cost of free digital content is less apparent but equally significant. This leads to a pervasive expectation that online content should always be free, diminishing the willingness to pay for quality journalism or premium services.
Crockett and Dent provide several real-world instances where "free" promotions have been misleading:
Burger King: Offered a "buy one, get one free" croissanwich deal but increased the sandwich price from $2.16 to $3.15, negating the perceived savings.
Zachary Crockett [15:23]: "Burger King... they charged an entire dollar more for the sandwich, for the buy one, get one free. So, yes, you got one for free, but you paid significantly more for the first one."
MyPillow: Promoted a BOGO deal by doubling the price of the first pillow, effectively not offering anything for free.
Zachary Crockett [16:08]: "They jacked up the price on the first pillow by 2x. So you paid double the price for the first pillow."
These examples highlight how companies exploit the allure of "free" to mask actual costs, leading to consumer deception and eventual legal repercussions.
Mark Dent explains that offering free samples triggers a sense of reciprocity, compelling consumers to make purchases they might otherwise avoid:
Mark Dent [19:43]: "Because someone essentially did something for you, so you want to do something for them."
This innate desire to reciprocate benefits businesses by increasing sales post-sample distribution. For instance, free samples can lead to substantial sales spikes:
Mark Dent [20:29]: "On frozen pizza, there's a 600% average annual percentage increase in sales after you have that in free sample demonstrations."
However, while this strategy is effective, it also taps into the irrational aspects of consumer behavior.
The episode culminates with a poignant reflection on the true cost of "free":
Zachary Crockett [30:15]: "There's just a whole bunch of costs associated. You have to have someone drive it to your door, you have to have it probably be flown on an airplane somewhere... It's really hard to think of those as costs that you want to pay for. And you're just like, screw all that, like why would I need to pay for free shipping?"
Mark Dent shares a personal anecdote to illustrate the lingering impact of free items:
Mark Dent [31:22]: "We would have hired this photographer no matter what... they also gave us a free T-shirt... I wear it all the time now. I'm like, I really like this shirt. Probably because it's free, like, I wear it all the time now."
Despite paying for an expensive service, the perception of receiving something "free" can leave a lasting, positive impression, further cementing the psychological hold of free offerings.
The episode effectively unpacks the multifaceted nature of "free" in consumer behavior. While free items can drive sales and foster goodwill, they often come with hidden costs—both tangible and intangible. Whether it's inflated product prices, compromised personal data, or wasted time, the allure of free can mask underlying economic realities. As Crockett and Dent illustrate, understanding these dynamics is crucial for both consumers and entrepreneurs aiming to navigate the intricate landscape of modern commerce.
Mark Dent [06:04]: "When something becomes free, it's like all bets are off. Any sort of normal type of consumer behavior changes. It just goes completely off the charts."
Zachary Crockett [08:12]: "That's like exactly what it is. There's something that is of not necessarily that much value, but just, you know, smack the word free on it."
Mark Dent [15:23]: "Some of these are just, like, pretty awful, frankly. Very scammy."
Zachary Crockett [26:31]: "We're often giving away vast swaths of our personal data just to access a website."
Mark Dent [19:43]: "Because someone essentially did something for you, so you want to do something for them."
This comprehensive exploration by The Hustle Daily Show, presented on The $100 MBA Show, serves as a crucial reminder: while "free" may seem enticing, it's imperative to discern the true costs behind the allure. Empowering oneself with this knowledge leads to more informed and rational consumer decisions.