Podcast Summary: "How AI Porn Isolates Us"

The 404 Media Podcast – December 5, 2025
Guests: Host (404 Media) and Noelle Perdue
Theme: Exploring the intersection of pornography, AI-generated content, loneliness, and shifting sexual cultures

Episode Overview

This episode delves into the ways in which AI-generated pornography and companion chatbots are reshaping sexual consumption, social interaction, and personal connection. With guest Noelle Perdue — a writer, producer, and internet porn historian — the discussion weaves through the history of porn, obscenity laws, parody culture, and how emergent technologies like AI may be deepening isolation, rather than offering connection.

Key Discussion Points and Insights

1. Noelle Perdue: Background in the Porn Industry

• Early Career: Wrote for major studios (Brazzers, Babes, Trans Angels) and indie studios (Afterglow) ([02:17-03:18])

• Parody Porn Expertise: Encyclopedic knowledge of porn parodies; highlights the artistry and humor in titling and production ([03:32-06:45])

  Quote:
  “I think that a lot of people that are watching parody porn, it's a genre of comedy. Like, it's not even necessarily a genre of erotica. It's much closer aligned to comedy than it is to traditional eroticism.” (Noelle Perdue, 06:15)

2. The Lost Art of Porn Parody & Fun in Porn

• Changing Legal Landscape: Parody law now only requires adding “A Porn Parody” to the title—diminishing creativity.

• Social Significance: Discusses how pornography and sex have lost their public sense of fun amid increasingly political and legislative debates ([06:45-08:40]).

  Quote:
  “I feel like people are forgetting that porn is supposed to be fun and that porn is fun. Yeah, people forget... It shouldn't be that serious.” (Noelle Perdue, 07:16)

3. Obscenity Laws, Politics, and Marginalized Communities

• Historical Weaponization: Reviews how obscenity laws have long served to marginalize interracial, queer, and now trans relationships ([11:00-14:05])

• Modern Parallels: Project 2025 and other legislative pushes are intentionally linking LGBTQ+ identities to pornography to justify bans.

  Quote:
  “Obscenity is ultimately kind of like a respectability politics question. So anything that is seen as not respectable can be argued to be obscene.” (Noelle Perdue, 14:43)

• Recent Examples: Texas drag bans, federal and state bills redefining obscenity to criminalize everyday sexual content ([16:20-19:12]).

4. The Boundaries of Porn – What’s Actually “Obscene”?

• Slippery Definitions: Definition of porn is so broad, bans could affect almost anything designed to arouse—including innocuous content ([19:12-20:39]).

  • Example: Social media food videos (e.g., slow egg yolk pops) as accidental fetish content.

  Quote:
  “The surest way to get people to develop really, really weird kinks and fetishes is to ban the normal stuff.” (Noelle Perdue, 20:39)

5. AI Porn on Social Media and Beyond

• AI vs. Human-Made: Current feed algorithms heavily favor AI-generated models while human sex workers get banned ([24:00-24:43])

• Dual Evolution: Proliferation of both AI visual content and chatbot companions are fundamentally altering sexual experiences ([24:43-25:54]).

  Quote:
  “Now we are completely locked into our own minds and we don't see that, oh, other people are consuming this too... There's no element of communication anymore.” (Noelle Perdue, 33:14)

6. AI and the Male Loneliness Epidemic

• Historic Shifts in Privacy:

  • Past required human connection for access—now increasingly private and isolated, especially via AI chatbots ([32:02-35:36]).

• AI Companions Worsening Isolation:

  • No social feedback, no community, no sharing of the “weirdness” that normalizes personal fetishes and sexualities ([36:34-38:52]).

  Observation:

  • The move to private AI-driven sexual experiences deepens shame and disconnect; used to be “you had to interact with somebody to get porn” ([33:14]).

7. The Dangers of AI-Generated Sexual Companions

• Loss of Human Reciprocity:

  • AI chatbots only “spit your own beliefs back out at you” ([38:52-41:42])
  • Without human signals or agency, empathy and concern for others' pleasure disappear—leading to stunted social development.

  Quote:
  “When we're interacting with something that we don't have to care about whatsoever, that we don't have to factor in how they're going to respond to us... that’s a dangerous world to exist in.” (Noelle Perdue, 41:18)

• Community & Parasociality:

  • Even in parasocial online porn communities, there is an exchange of care and realness—lost in AI-only interaction ([36:45-38:52])

8. Age Verification and Surveillance Concerns

• ChatGPT Erotica Announcement:

  • Real goal is widespread age-verification (identity/data harvesting), not “erotica for verified adults” ([47:45-48:24])
  • AI companies frame themselves as serving the user, but they are fundamentally extracting value (data) for themselves ([48:24-49:19]).

  Quote:
  “People are referring to [AI] as their tool, and it's not their tool. This is the company's tool that it is using to harvest your data.” (Noelle Perdue, 48:34)

9. Pushing Back Against AI & Disconnection

• Techno-Luddite Shift:

  • Many, like Noelle, have moved from tech enthusiasm to deliberate resistance as AI’s harms (isolation, data extraction) become clear ([45:38-46:58])

• Hope in Real-World Connection:

  • The “grand experiment” of the Internet may be ending; optimism now turns to offline community, real-world events, and physical creativity ([50:59-53:56]).

  Quote:
  “What is exciting me is what is happening offline... Just as like going out and buying a book. That's real and that's tangible. They can't take that away from you.” (Noelle Perdue, 51:49)

• Future of 'Human-Made' Label:

  • Human-crafted artwork and personal interaction may become the valued “premium” of the future ([53:17-54:31]).

Memorable Quotes and Moments (with Timestamps)

• On the Art of Parody Porn:
  “I did a parody of Cutthroat Kitchen that I called Come Throat Kitchen. I did another one. I did Diners Drive Ins and Dick... There is a real art to it because you want. It has to be recognizable and it has to be as stupid as possible.”
  — Noelle Perdue, [05:35]

• On Societal Shifts and Porn Laws:
  “I would pinpoint 2007. Even feel like when people ask me why I like porn, it's hilarious to me because I'm like, what do you mean why do I like porn? Porn rocks. Porn is awesome. Porn is so fun. Why would I not like porn?”
  — Noelle Perdue, [07:45]

• On AI Fantasy and Isolation:
  “Now we are completely locked into our own minds and we don't see that, oh, other people are consuming this too... There’s no element of communication anymore.”
  — Noelle Perdue, [33:14]

• On the Shortcomings of AI Companionship:
  “When we're interacting with something that we don't have to care about whatsoever... I think that that's a dangerous world to exist in.”
  — Noelle Perdue, [41:18]

• On Who Benefits from AI:
  “People are referring to [AI] as their tool, and it's not their tool. This is the company's tool that it is using to harvest your data.”
  — Noelle Perdue, [48:34]

Notable Segments by Timestamp

• [02:17-03:32] — Noelle’s porn industry career & writing background
• [03:32-06:45] — Parody porn discussion and cultural loss of fun
• [11:00-14:05] — Obscenity laws, culture wars, and marginalized identities
• [16:20-19:12] — Expansive legal definitions of “pornography” and chilling effects
• [24:00-25:54] — The evolution and social impact of AI porn and chatbots
• [32:02-35:36] — AI companions, privacy, and deepening loneliness
• [36:45-38:52] — Community, OnlyFans, and the shift away from shared experience
• [41:18-41:42] — AI, human empathy, and isolation
• [47:45-48:24] — ChatGPT, erotica, and age verification/data extraction
• [50:59-54:31] — Hope in offline community and valuing of human-made art

Takeaways and Final Reflections

• Cultural Shifts: Pornography has transitioned from fun, communal, and creative to a fraught political battleground.
• Legislation: Current obscenity laws (and proposals like Project 2025) leverage “pornography” as a blunt tool for marginalization.
• AI Impacts: Generative AI porn offers extreme privacy but also deepens loneliness and self-judgment, eliminating healthy community reflection and reducing empathy.
• Hope for the Future: Despite commercialization and algorithmic takeover, there’s a hopeful movement toward valuing physical, communal, and human-made experiences in both sexuality and creativity.

Final Note

Noelle Perdue:
“Ultimately, I will say that to my last breath, what everybody is ultimately looking for is some type of connection. And the Internet is giving us that less and less.”
[53:26]

Host:
“I do think that like made by humans or human made is going to be the new organic... and if we value that, then that's what's important.”
[54:31]

For the full conversation and to support independent tech journalism, subscribe to The 404 Media Podcast at 404media.co.