Podcast Summary: "Why Are We Obsessed With Aliens?"

The 404 Media Podcast | Date: December 15, 2025
Host: Emmanuel for 404 Media | Guest: Becky Ferreira (science journalist & author)

Episode Overview

This episode dives deep into our collective fascination with aliens, using the lens of Becky Ferreira’s new book, First: The Story of Our Obsession With Aliens. Instead of just cataloging sightings or analyzing the science of the search for extraterrestrial life, Becky explores what our obsession with aliens reveals about humanity itself—touching on history, anthropology, psychology, science, religion, and media. The discussion is both skeptical and imaginative, blending scholarship with pop culture and even some personal takes.

Key Discussion Points & Insights

1. The Book’s Unique Approach: Anthropology of Aliens

• Becky’s angle differs from typical alien books by focusing on human obsession:
  • “It's really a work of anthropology… just as much about our obsession with aliens and what that says about humanity than it is about theories and potential of alien life itself.” – Emmanuel ([01:15])
  • Becky was initially skeptical about writing another alien book, but realized the universal cultural pull and diversity of perspectives made it “an inexhaustible subject.” ([02:07])

2. Personal Roots of Fascination

• Becky links her interest to growing up in the time of Star Trek: The Next Generation, The X-Files, and Carl Sagan's Cosmos, reflecting how culture shapes our sense of wonder:
  • “As an elder millennial… you can't escape it. Every generation has a lot of aliens.” ([04:06])
  • Notes a pivotal shift for her as a science reporter: the launch and discoveries of the Kepler telescope, which exponentially expanded the known number of exoplanets and thus credible targets for life. ([04:30])

3. Alien Stories Reflect Their Times

• Pop culture depictions of aliens mutate with society’s anxieties and hopes:
  • 1950s sci-fi was about invasion and paranoia (“Body Snatchers”/communism).
  • 1990s movies like Independence Day were “very negative… they're just gonna come and obliterate us,” reflecting anxieties that the era’s optimism (the “end of history”) was fragile. ([07:10-09:20])
  • Becky adds that even amid disaster paranoia, the ‘90s were diverse—Men in Black, Starship Troopers, Contact all offered different readings. ([07:22])
  • “Aliens are as ubiquitous as human characters now in pop culture, really, for the last 30 years.” – Becky ([08:57])

4. Ancient Myths and the Roots of Alien Thought

• Emmanuel asks how Becky separates alien lore from creation myths.
  • “Symbolically, the fact that they clearly used these stories about the personification of the skies, all cultures do it… It's bizarre to me, that it's this premonition that we all have.” ([11:16])
  • Many ancient accounts blend myth, religion, and cosmic speculation.

Memorable Example:

• The first “alien story:” Lucian’s True History, a 2nd-century satire where “a bunch of horny dudes want to have sex with the aliens”—a trope “as old as alien lore itself.” ([15:24])
• Becky also references humanity's experience meeting Neanderthals and Denisovans, suggesting our search for “the other” is deeply rooted in prehistory. ([15:24])

5. Religion vs. Alien Life: Evolution of Thought

• The emergence of alien belief was a profound challenge to religious doctrine, particularly in Catholicism.
  • “It was not only that Earth was central, it was also that humans were supposed to be the big creation of God.” ([22:22])
  • Debates centered on whether aliens, if they existed, could be “children of God.”
• Some thinkers bridged the gap:
  • Jewish philosopher Maimonides: “It is of great power advantage that man should know his station and not erroneously imagine that the whole universe exists only for him.” ([25:27])
  • Giordano Bruno (burned at the stake for heresy) argued the immensity of the universe magnified God, and was an early scientific optimist about aliens. ([27:44])
  • “He just thought that makes God so much more immense. Like, why would you not worship the God of the universe with all of the stars and all of the life forms and… limits yourself to Earth?” ([28:29])

6. Scientific Camps & The Fermi Paradox

• In the Enlightenment and following, two main schools emerged:
  • Alien Optimists: Universe is vast, life should be everywhere. “It would be so much stranger to be the only inhabited planet…” ([30:14])
  • Alien Pessimists (precursors to the Fermi Paradox): Where is everyone, then? “If you look at all these… planets around these stars, that would be a really, really small zone where you would be able to have life like Earth.” ([31:02])
• Modern theories:
  • “Dark Forest” theory—civilizations hide for self-preservation.
  • Becky personally leans to “rare Earth” hypothesis: complex life may be possible, but rare. ([34:13])

7. Media, Hoaxes, and Information Culture

• Aliens as a media phenomenon is longstanding:
  • War of the Worlds panic.
  • The 1830s “Great Moon Hoax”: penny press claims astronomer John Herschel found life on the Moon—"man bats and cities." ([35:34])
  • “Alien stories have always been blockbusters.” – Becky ([38:13])
• Edgar Allan Poe famously tried to sue over his story being plagiarized for the hoax. ([39:04])
• Becky’s experience as a reporter: much contemporary science and alien reporting risks sensationalism. She focuses on staying within peer-reviewed research and contextualizing ambiguous results.
  • “What is the bar for a biosignature?... scientists totally disagree about that.” ([41:33])
  • The real story is often the publication of provocative claims, not the claims themselves.

8. The Pentagon UFO Videos—A Modern Key Text

• The release of military UFO footage in 2017 (and ensuing government openness) marks a shift: “We have more information than ever… and despite, or even because of having more information, it feels like we know less.” – Emmanuel ([47:19])
  • The phenomenon reflects both increased information and decreased trust in institutions.
  • “Those are so concrete… the fact that you can, as a couple of those videos have, have the pilots reacting as well... everyone should want to know what that is.” – Becky ([44:53])
  • Overindulgence (endless hearings, grifters) is as confusing as secrecy. “The first time... you were like, oh my God, we're really living through a moment. And then like the fourth time, you're like, who is this guy?” ([49:54])

9. Current & Future Science: The Search in Practice

• Highlights promising missions:
  • Mars Sample Return: Perseverance Rover is cacheing samples, including one “recognized to have a potential biosignature.” Budget and political threats (notably Trump-era NASA cuts) endanger the mission ([50:38-53:10])
  • Becky’s “most excited” about this: “If life can emerge, it apparently does, even in microbial form. Then you know that it must be common, right?” ([53:10])
  • Discusses further missions to Europa, Enceladus—moons with subsurface oceans—and the frustration that there isn’t more urgency or funding given the opportunities. ([53:32-54:08])
  • “Our own solar system has so many interesting sites.” ([55:02])

10. Is There a Plan for Alien Contact?

• International researchers have developed the Declaration of Principles Concerning Activities following the Detection of Extraterrestrial Intelligence ("the plan")—a set of guidelines to ensure transparency, peer review, and responsible release of information. ([55:20])
  • Emmanuel and Becky discuss its naivety given realpolitik, but emphasize we must begin somewhere.

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

• [09:20] Emmanuel: “There's an undercurrent in the culture that knows that's bullshit… the intuition that this can't last was True. Eventually the worm turns.”
• [15:24] Becky: “…the best example is like the earliest alien story… a bunch of horny dudes wanting to have sex with the aliens, which I think is like the trope… as old as alien lore itself.”
• [27:19] Emmanuel (on Maimonides): “…the only way to understand God is to constantly question and confuse yourself. And in the trying to answer… is sort of like the trying to approach the divine.”
• [28:48] Becky (on Bruno): “He had a lot of heretical beliefs beyond the Copernican stuff. He was, you know, a debate guy, like, debate, but in a time where that's not a very safe thing.”
• [38:13] Becky: “Alien stories have always been blockbusters.”
• [41:33] Becky: “What is the bar for a biosignature? And they're like surprised when it's like scientists totally disagree about that.”
• [47:19] Emmanuel: “We have more information than ever… and despite, or even because of having more information, it feels like we know less.”
• [53:10] Becky (on Mars samples): “…if life can emerge, it apparently does, even in microbial form. Then you know that it must be common, right?”
• [58:53] Becky (on no-microbe intelligent aliens in our Solar System): “…I love microbes. I'm just a microbe person. Okay, so no, in that case. No, I doubt it. Yeah.”
• [62:35] Becky (Favorite depiction): “My favorite is A Story of Your Life by Ted Chiang, which is the book that Arrival’s based on…”

Timestamps: Important Segments

• Opening & premise of the book: [00:59]-[02:07]
• Personal roots of alien obsession: [03:37]-[05:48]
• Aliens as reflection of the era (pop culture): [07:10]-[09:55]
• Ancient myths & creation stories: [11:16]-[17:11]
• Aliens and religion: [21:37]-[29:50]
• Scientific split: optimists vs. pessimists: [29:50]-[34:39]
• Media hoax history – The Great Hoax: [35:34]-[39:26]
• Reporting on aliens & science comms: [40:16]-[43:23]
• Pentagon UFO videos & our era: [44:53]-[50:17]
• Most exciting missions for finding life: [50:38]-[55:17]
• International plan for alien contact: [55:20]-[58:15]
• Lightning round (lighthearted conclusions): [58:53]-[62:54]
• Favorite depictions in media: [62:21]-[63:54]

Tone and Style

The podcast is conversational and intellectual, mixing skeptical journalism with genuine wonder. Humor and cultural references abound, keeping the discussion grounded and relatable. Both host and guest maintain a respectful openness to the unknown, honoring science while keeping distance from fringe speculation.

Concluding Note

This episode explains not just the perennial pull of aliens, but how the subject forms a funhouse mirror reflecting every era’s anxieties, hopes, and technological booms. It makes clear our obsession is as much about us as any possible others “out there.” Becky Ferreira’s book and this conversation remind us: searching for aliens is a way of searching for ourselves.

Recommended for anyone:

• Curious about the science, history, and cultural impact of aliens
• Interested in how science journalism works
• Looking for deep-yet-fun conversations about humanity’s cosmic place

Further reading/listening:

• Becky Ferreira’s First: The Story of Our Obsession With Aliens
• Daniel Oberhaus, Extraterrestrial Languages
• Ted Chiang, Story of Your Life (basis for Arrival)
• Arketti Martine, A Memory Called Empire (as recommended by Emmanuel)

For full access to 404 Media’s work and ad-free podcast:
Subscribe at 404media.co