Podcast Summary
The Amazing Authorities Podcast
Host: Mitch Carson
Guest: Dustin Domaresse (Author, Consultant, Founder of Dynamic Consultants Group)
Episode: "Why Most ERP & CRM Projects Fail — And How to Avoid a Business Disaster"
Published: May 7, 2026
Episode Overview
This episode dives into the surprisingly high failure rates of ERP (Enterprise Resource Planning) and CRM (Customer Relationship Management) implementation projects. With expert guest Dustin Domaresse, the conversation explores why these vital business systems so often fail, the costly consequences, and practical frameworks leaders can use to avoid a business disaster. Dustin draws from two decades of front-line consulting experience and his book, Last Chance to Launch, to offer actionable insights for C-suite executives, managers, IT professionals, and anyone considering a major business software change.
Key Discussion Points & Insights
1. What Are ERP and CRM? (03:10 - 04:56)
- ERP: More than just accounting software (e.g., QuickBooks); includes supply chain, shipping, inventory, warehouse management—essentially handles all back office operations for growing businesses.
- CRM: Customer Relationship Management tracks customers, sales, marketing, service cases, and more. It's typical for organizations moving beyond basic spreadsheets to consider both systems.
"Where most organizations start getting it wrong is actually whenever they think of ERP as only an accounting system."
— Dustin Domaresse [03:13]
2. Separate or Integrated Systems? (05:04 - 06:33)
- Some enterprise suites offer combined ERP and CRM (e.g., Microsoft, SAP).
- Dustin warns against defaulting to a combined suite simply for vendor convenience: often, it leads to mismatched functionality.
"It ends up always being a strength on one and weakness on another."
— Dustin Domaresse [05:24]
3. Why Do So Many Projects Fail? (06:33 - 09:59)
- Failure Statistics:
- 66% of these projects fail (Standish Group)
- 17% threaten organizational survival (McKinsey)
- 70% that do launch fail to deliver expected outcomes (BCG)
- Core Reasons:
- Wrong Decision-Makers: IT or Procurement often run projects with minimal input from end-users, resulting in poor fits for daily business needs.
- Missing the "Secret Sauce": Adopting generic, off-the-shelf processes often erases the unique elements that set a business apart.
"They're making these decisions based on purely IT decisions rather than a business process decision."
— Dustin Domaresse [08:34]
4. The Importance of Frontline Workers (09:59 - 13:20)
- Real-life example: A failed warehouse tech rollout due to barcode mislabeling—rooted in inadequate user-level testing and communication with those who actually use the system.
- "Shadow IT" emerges when workers create their own unofficial solutions to cope with system gaps.
"Unless you're involving those frontline workers and pulling them in to the decision early, it's just going to be a complete failure."
— Dustin Domaresse [13:10]
- Psychological Safety: Teams must feel safe to report workarounds, process issues, and mistakes; otherwise, systems are built on flawed assumptions.
5. The Role of Documentation and Truth-Telling (14:37 - 17:33)
- Dustin advocates for mapping "as is" workflows—word-for-word, click-by-click—by talking directly with people performing the jobs.
- Identifies disconnects between management perception and ground reality.
"It's shocking sometimes for us to bring that document out to a CFO or CEO and say, here's what your process actually is."
— Dustin Domaresse [15:13]
- Leadership must foster environments where it's safe for staff to speak honestly about what really happens in operations.
6. Dustin’s Consulting Approach: The SPEAR Method (18:03 - 19:42)
- SPEAR:
- Surveillance: Gather, centralize accurate data
- Performance: Measure outcomes against KPIs
- Excellence: Drive consistent, standardized processes
- Automation: Only after prior steps are strong
- Roadmap: Guide digital transformation in a logical sequence
"We've seen so many organizations that are trying to get to automation, especially in the day of AI. Everybody wants to move to automation, but yet they don't have surveillance. They don't have performance and they don't yet have organizational excellence."
— Dustin Domaresse [18:50]
7. Who Should (and Shouldn’t) Pursue Complex Systems? (19:54 - 21:26)
- Dustin's ideal clients are mid-market to large enterprises—typically those reaching ceilings in growth with existing systems like QuickBooks and Excel.
- Not suited to solopreneurs or very small firms; many businesses can reach $10–30M in revenue before needing more advanced tools.
8. Memorable Quotes & Moments
- On Consultants:
"There's nobody better at giving us puzzle pieces to put together than the tech companies. Right? I mean, they know how to create the pieces. They don't always know how to put them together."
— Dustin Domaresse [21:39]
- On the real cost of neglecting ground-level insight:
Host Mitch shares how an employee sabotage cost his agency $7,000 due to unchecked manual processes—emphasizing why checks and communication are vital. [13:20]
Notable Quotes with Timestamps
-
"You can make that jump you into that kind of software so early that you end up crippling your organization because it requires a level of sophistication that many SMB...just don't have today."
— Dustin Domaresse [03:53]
-
"Unless you're involving those frontline workers and pulling them in to the decision early, it's just going to be a complete failure..."
— Dustin Domaresse [13:10]
-
"We fundamentally believe that the first thing you should do is what's called an as is."
— Dustin Domaresse [14:39]
-
"We've seen so many organizations that are trying to get to automation...but yet they don't have surveillance. They don't have performance and they don't yet have organizational excellence."
— Dustin Domaresse [18:50]
Resource Links & How to Connect
- Dynamic Consultants Group Website: dynamicconsultantsgroup.com — Includes a free ERP/CRM assessment tool.
- Dustin Domaresse on LinkedIn: LinkedIn profile
- Book: Last Chance to Launch: How Leaders Rescue ERP, CRM and Digital Transformation Projects from the Edge of Failure — Available on Amazon.
Takeaways
- ERP and CRM transformation projects must be driven by comprehensive understanding of current processes and involve all stakeholders, especially frontline workers.
- Frameworks like SPEAR provide a practical roadmap for organizations ready to transition beyond basic tools and scale effectively.
- Psychological safety and honest process documentation are foundational to success.
- The real risk in digital transformation is not just wasted investment, but potentially existential damage to a business.
Recommended Actions for Listeners
- Evaluate your company’s current readiness for a technology overhaul before committing to new software.
- Involve end users and frontline employees early (and often) in technology selection and implementation projects.
- Consider frameworks (like SPEAR) and experienced consultants to guide ERP/CRM transformation.
For more insights on leadership, technology, and transformation from world-class authorities, subscribe to The Amazing Authorities Podcast.