Loading summary
Transcript128 lines
- [00:00]
Tristan Hughes
Ever wondered why the Romans were defeated in the Teutoburg Forest? What secrets lie buried in prehistoric Ireland? Or what made Alexander truly great? With a subscription to History Hit, you can explore our ancient past alongside the world's leading historians and archaeologists. You'll also unlock hundreds of hours of original documentaries with a brand new release every single week covering everything from the ancient world to World War II. Just visit historyhit.com subscribe
- [00:33]
Nissan Pathfinder Advertiser
there's an SUV that turns the unthinkable into the unforgettable. The new Nissan Pathfinder. Built for big adventures and all that family chaos. It's powered by a strong V6 engine with a nine speed automatic transmission. Inside, it's rugged and capable, but still premium and tech forward with room for up to eight passengers. It's also available with seven passenger seating and second row captain's chairs with massive hauling capability. Now you can bring all the gear you and your family need for unforgettable adventures. The new V6 Nissan Pathfinder power your adventure.
- [01:02]
Commercial Announcer
Your new home is now ready Dr. Horton, America's builder has new homes that are ready today with new construction communities in Ellensburg and throughout the Greater Seattle area. Dr. Horton has the right home for you. At Dr. Horton we're still building with flexible living spaces, smart home technology and two and three car garages. More communities and more homes available every day. For find your new home in Ellensburg now ready@drhorton.com Dr. Horton, America's builder and equal Housing opportunity Builder.
- [01:50]
Tristan Hughes
329 BC the ancient land of Bactria, modern day Afghanistan and Uzbekistan. An incredibly affluent area of the ancient Middle East. A real crossroads of Asia that connects east, west, north and south. Home to verdant river valleys full of fertile lands surrounded by towering mountain ranges full of precious minerals, gold, silver. Not to mention the precious bluestone that Egyptian pharaohs, Indian elites and Chinese emperors alike have all sought for millennia. Lapis Lazuli Bactria has a long and prestigious history. Flowing through its heart was the mighty Oxus river, the Nile of Central Asia. Dozens of prosperous centuries old cities line the river and its many tributaries. Their formidable walls are made of thick unbaked mud bricks towering several meters high. Their houses within are also made of this abundant mud brick material. These cities are home to large populations sustained by the nearby nutrient rich farmlands irrigated by the Oxus along both of its banks. No wonder Bactria became known as the Land of a Thousand Cities. The Oxus river has already witnessed many great armies crossing its waters. Now a new formidable force reaches its Banks tens of thousands strong. Most of these soldiers are tired and veteran, serving thousands of kilometers away from their homelands for years on end. They haven't seen their loved ones back home. Instead, they have followed their king into countless battles and sieges, fighting their way through great plains, overcoming coastal strongholds and crushing fortified mountain defences. They have won numerous victories to conquer the ancient superpower of the time, the Persian Empire. But their fight isn't over. King Alexander, their revered leader, wants to go even further. So now they cross this mighty life giving river north towards the lands of Sogdia, modern Uzbekistan, and the great steppe that lies beyond. For now, these lands prove welcoming to Alexander and his men. The locals offer food, knowledge and hospitality. They expect Alexander's army to move on pretty quickly. And indeed this commander has every intention of moving on. Alexander's eyes are already fixed southeast on India. But before he leaves, Alexander wants to found a city permanently leaving his mark on this northeastern fringe of his new expanding empire. Does he have any idea that his actions were about to upset the status quo and spark some of the most vicious fighting of his entire career? Episode 4 the Final Part of this series about the life and legend of Alexander the Great, one of history's most formidable commanders. Last week we followed Alexander's journey from Syria to Afghanistan. His final great victory against the Persian king of kings, Darius III and his takeover of the Persian Empire. But alongside this remarkable conquest, we started to see cracks in the emerging in Alexander's retinue, culminating in the executions of two high ranking generals, Philotas and his father, the esteemed Parmenion. Today we continue the story. In this episode we will track the last few years of Alexander's life. From the most intense battles of his entire career in Afghanistan and Uzbekistan, to his campaigning in India against armies that include mighty elephants, to ultimately his return to Babylon and the early demise of this legendary conqueror. We're going to see how Alexander's condition deteriorated over these years leading to his death aged just 32. Joining me in this episode once again is Dr. Adrian Goldsworthy, the author of Philip and Kings and Conquerors. I'm Tristan Hughes, your host and this is the fourth and final episode. Alexander, Lord of Asia.
- [06:40]
Adrian, welcome back.
- [06:42]
Dr. Adrian Goldsworthy
Thank you for having me.
- [06:43]
Tristan Hughes
Again for the fourth and final time, episode four of Alexander the Great. We've covered quite a lot already, so we've gone from 356bc Alexander's birth to now when he's entering Afghanistan. This is 3, 33, 29, around that time. So he is 26, 27 at this time, what were you doing? Were you 26, 27?
- [07:08]
Dr. Adrian Goldsworthy
Yeah, having finished my thesis, I was starting to try and write another book. So being a research fellow at university, but I wasn't conquering the world, far too lazy for that sort of thing.
- [07:20]
Tristan Hughes
And now he is in Afghanistan, he's just captured the regicides Bessus and so it very much feels like by this time he's Lord of Asia. And things are also looking quite good in Afghanistan because he hasn't faced too much resistance here either.
- [07:35]
Dr. Adrian Goldsworthy
It's the basic problem though, you can conquer all of this. But Philip had found this in, you know, Alexander's father. He'd taken, he'd won lots of wars, people had submitted, they'd said, we'll be your ally with your subject. But very often you then face rebellions. You have to create a regime that works. You have to create, consolidate your power and set things up. Alexander hasn't really done that, he's just kept on going and he's kept on going because the war has been there all the time and there's been the threat of Darius. The Persian Empire is so big recovering, coming back to hit you and lead you and it comes back to that first thing from the time when Alexander landed in Asia, he only needed to lose once and that would be it. In any sort of major encounter he has to win and keep on winning and he has to keep on going. But you've absorbed all of this now. You have the advantage to some extent that this had been the Achaemenid Persian Empire for several centuries. So it's used to operating as a unit. There is an administration there. Very often you've tried to take over as much as you can and you've also, particularly locally, so we talked last time about being in Babylon and how you would expect the city and the areas around it to run their own affairs, to do their own thing with. Often local leaders stay in power or new men, but their locals are appointed to take over. And the number of Greeks and Macedonians actually running things early on is very small. You've tried to basically say I'm now the equivalent of the great king, whatever I call myself, I am now your ruler, I am your friend, I'm going to rule well, I will respect you, I will treat you well, you deal with the day to day stuff and I won't trouble you. But I will need a few things. I'll need some money, I'll need some food for my army, I'll need supplies, I'll need some troops. Sort of thing, but you're not demanding too much. But it's very hard to make that sort of transition so quickly. You may have locked the head off the empire, but the Persians had their problems in controlling areas. They'd have problems on the western fringes. Egypt kept rebelling. Sometimes the SAT traps, the Asia Minor coast of Asia Minor, rebels in the east in this area, Bactria, Sogdiana, all these areas. This was a volatile population that the Persians, generally speaking, kept within what they saw as their empire. But there were often rebellions, there were local disputes, it was hard to control. The people were fiercely independent, fiercely competitive with each other, and willing at times to resist. So Alexander has done the dramatic stuff you're now getting into, the consolidation, the confirming the fact that you're in control. And you're dealing now with leaders and with communities who are not controlling big areas, so that you have to make sure every single one of them is convinced that they should be loyal to you. It's not like defeating Darius is hard. Fighting a battle like Issus or Gaugamela is hard, but when you've done it in a day, you've half conquered the Persian Empire, you've taken. You've done a major blow against the great king. Whereas if you've got some local warlord in a city in what these days would be Afghanistan, you fight him, you defeat him. His neighbor, five miles away, 10 miles away, even closer, doesn't necessarily think, well, he's been beaten, therefore I should give in. So you're dealing with a far more complicated environment and one you don't know at all. You've had some perception of the Persian Empire. You've had a lot more of what Egypt's like and particularly what Asia Minor is like. But this is now really alien. And apart from in a few places, you're not the first Greek to get there. There have been a few others, but they are very few. And it's the part of Persia that is less familiar to you. So everything is a new challenge, a great struggle to develop. And it's unsurprising that it proves complicated that Alexander can't win so easily and so quickly as before.
- [11:25]
Tristan Hughes
Well, Shari mentioned first of all that kind of bizarre Greek presence that they encounter when they get that far into, well, what is now Afghanistan and Uzbekistan. So Samarkand today, in the capital of Uzbekistan, there was actually a Samarkand in ancient times called Maracanda. So that's. There is a place called Samarkand there at the time, which is interesting, but as Alexander is marching through this area, you know, early on, post Basus, there doesn't seem to be big opposition to him, that the local people are still in place. Maybe they're still thinking the army is just passing through. And as Alexander's trying to march to like the fringes of what was the Persian Empire in that area, they encounter this, this Greek population in one of our sources, the Branchidae. But this idea that they are Greeks who had been relocated there centuries earlier from Miletus, which is like on the Aegean coast, and this idea that Alexander sees this, this Greek descendant population and then I think he kills them all or something like that is quite.
- [12:23]
Dr. Adrian Goldsworthy
I mean, the tradition isn't a clear one and it's not in our most reliable sources. It's this perception, it's part of the weird and wonderful. We mentioned last time an encounter that some people claimed with an Amazon queen of the Amazons that famously one of Alexander's commanders then later said, well, where was I when this happened? Because I don't remember that. I think I would have noticed that. So you're never quite sure how much is embellishment. On the other hand, the idea of transplanting most of the population or sometimes just the elite of a city from one end of the empire to another is something that the Persians and some of the other big powers that their predecessors have done and will continue to be the case. The Persians in the 3rd, 4th centuries AD are doing it with captured Roman population. So the idea is that Alexander comes to consider these people as traitors to Greece and then massacres them for that reason. It's a sort of last flash really of this great war of revenge of the Greeks against the Persians. Because by this time it's very hard to maintain that that's what you're doing anymore because the Persian Empire isn't there. And you've also, you've sent home your Greek troops, your allied troops. You then send home some of them, like the salient, stay for a bit, then you send them home as well. And you've still got your Macedonians and you've got lots and lots of mercenaries and you've got lots and lots of Asian troops now. So your army is numerically bigger than it's ever been, but it's changed fundamentally. You're no longer really there as the leader of the League of Corinth that Philip had created, modern term, but that's the idea of this alliance of Greek states to come under Macedonian leadership and avenge themselves on the Persians for this ancient wrong done to them.
- [14:06]
Tristan Hughes
So let's get on to which seems to the next big episode in Alexander's story. We mentioned in the last episode. One of the greatest legacies of Alexander is the founding of Alexandria in Egypt, still a city today. And then we get here when Alexander the Great is in ancient Sokdia, roughly approaching, I think it's Tajikistan as well by this time in this area. And a river which is known in ancient times as the Jaxartes River. Modern day it's a river called the Syr or the Sirdaria, which ends up in the Aral Sea. The Aral Sea, but there is seen as like kind of the, the, the end of what was the Persian empire of Persian control. And Alexander decides to found a new city here, a new Alexandria, which he calls Alexandria, quite fittingly, Alexandria the furthest.
- [14:58]
Dan Snow
Yes.
- [15:00]
Tristan Hughes
And it seems to have been near Monde cogende. I mean, like the Fergano Valley. I won't go too many to names because it's, it's not, you know, they're not well known names in the western
- [15:12]
Dr. Adrian Goldsworthy
hemisphere matter too much. Precisely.
- [15:14]
Tristan Hughes
But what this seems to be is almost a trigger because from then on, at least to me, it seems that both the local populations, the Sogdians, the Bactrians further south, and the Scythians or the Saka, the people who live north of the Jaxartes river, they now start realizing that Alexander is not just passing through, he's here to establish this as part of his territory. It feels, at least to me, Adrian, this is a big moment in the shift of opinion towards Alexander in this area.
- [15:43]
Dr. Adrian Goldsworthy
And it's often the way with other empires that when they first arrive, they're actually welcomed and they're seen as a protector against some other enemy. But it's that when they settle down, it's what do they want in turn for this? And then they go to stay. Then you start thinking, actually, no, I don't want that. And I didn't invite them, so let's change our mind. And there may be some disruption to trade. It may just be the sense that someone is marking out farmland and saying, this is now mine, in areas where you've grazed your flocks. And it is that permanence, it's that I wouldn't mind you as a friend. I wouldn't mind occasionally if I'm in trouble, you come and send some troops and help me. But why are you here? Why are you on my doorstep? Why are you staying? So it's a big deal and it's something the Persians hadn't done. There are colonies of Persian troops settled out here. They had tried to run their empire in a different way by again winning over the local aristocracy, controlling by a mixture of bribery and force. And Alexander's doing something different. And again, Alexandria the furthest. It must have seemed a pretty bleak, distant place to the settlers, but those settlers would seem all the more weird and strange and alien and intruders to the local population, as well as the inevitable disruption of the power balance between the local nobility. And add in the sense that these people who are settling there are acting as the conquerors of the world, because they are the conquerors of the world as far as they're concerned. So they're not likely to be too respectful of your customs either, Very much so.
- [17:17]
Tristan Hughes
And it seems to all kind of go downhill there, for Alexander, at least. Chaos erupts again across the region, and I think he tries to summon lots of the local nobility for a meeting, and then they get worried that actually they're going to become killed off. So that seeds more mistrust. You get the emergence of this new kind of figurehead, a man called Spitermenes, who becomes a thorn in Alexander's side. And it's not just the Sogdians who are largely the people overseeing this revolt, The Sogdian revolt. You also get, I mentioned earlier, those people north of the river, the eastern Sidians, the Saka, these horse riders famous for their horse archery and so on. It's much like the Sogdians and the Scythians. They become aligned in their resistance to Alexander and these tumultuous events that follow.
- [18:03]
Dr. Adrian Goldsworthy
It's the convenience factor. It's not that they're necessarily always going to be united, it's just that they feel they have a common. So it would be better for both of them if the Macedonians go away. So therefore, let's combine to fight them. It doesn't need to be a permanent political revolution, though. Obviously Sparmenes leader wants something. He thinks he's building up permanent power, but he can rally them enough against a common enemy.
- [18:27]
Tristan Hughes
So what are some of the big events from the early stages of this revolt, Adrian? I can remember there's a siege of Cyropolis with Alexander, so there's a town named after Cyrus that very quickly, Alexander, when he realizes the local area, the cities are turning against him, he takes them one by one, and then the Cyropolis is the big city that's resisting him. And it's quite a difficult one to take. So once again we have another big kind of city siege. That he has to deal with, which
- [18:52]
Dr. Adrian Goldsworthy
is something the Macedonians are good at, They've done before. In this case, they're going through the normal preparations. Alexander is supposed to spot this watercourse, basically, that goes underneath the fortifications that has dried up. So sneaks in the head of some of his men, under cover of darkness, they open the gates, let more in. But remember, I mean, you can see this in some ancient city sites you go to in this part of the world. And it was all the more true in areas like this, there's not lots of wide open space. Once you're inside, what you've got are very narrow alleyways rather than streets. This is not built for wheeled transport. This is built for a donkey with panniers on. It's that sort of width. Lots of houses closed together. So although Macedonian troops getting in and inside the fortifications, the people don't think, oh, well, we've got to give up. This is their home, after all. They keep fighting for it. So you end up with very brutal fighting inside. Alexander gets hit on the head with a rock of some sort, possibly just dropped or thrown from a roof. You know, that's the risk. You're in this very crowded urban environment and it seems to concuss him quite badly. He passes out, can't see for a while. Again, in modern terms, you'd be quickly doing X rays of the skull, all this, but it's that sort of injury. So there's. There's a real danger that, again, Alexander could die. And, yes, it's not quite the same as the position at Granicus all the way back at the beginning. But if Alexander died, there is no heir. What do the Macedonians do? And there's also. The only reason they're here in the first place is because of Alexander. He wants them to do this, but they've gone way beyond their cause of seeking vengeance from the Persians. So it comes down to how much of this whole campaigning in this whole expedition is focused on him and what he wants. In fact, enough men get inside, they fight their way, they get control of the city and sack the place. But it's a danger and it shows how this is not a famous battle, and it's not even a famous siege like Tyre. And yet it could have been the end of Alexander and could have been the end of his campaign. And it's a reflection of the fighting in these later years that he fights a lot. He spends much of his time. If he's not marching from one place to another, he's besieging A city they're assaulting one of these little and they're called cities. They're often very small settlements, mostly of mud brick, but nevertheless they've got walls, they're not easy to get into. The Macedonians tend to win all the time, but it takes them time. It means losses, it means risks. In all the fights of Alexander's campaigns, right from the beginning through, it is striking how there's always a very high proportion of wounded to the number of dead, which does suggest that quite a high proportion of his men like Alexander are taking hits and they are recovering. So they're going on with wounds to the arms, the legs, the head, the memory of it. And there will probably tend to be more and more wounded and killed amongst the men who go first, the first up the ladder, the first through the open gateway. So your most aggressive, your sort of real cutting edge of the army just gets ground down.
- [22:02]
Tristan Hughes
And also the lieutenants like the key commanders, so we think of Alexander the Great swallows, but actually many of those generals who outlive Alexander, you also hear either through the accounts of Alexander or what happens afterwards, because they have that similar mindset, they suffer wound after wound if they're leading their contingents up the ladders or wherever.
- [22:19]
Dr. Adrian Goldsworthy
It's an interesting thing because when you think they're basically wearing a cuirass of some sort, a helmet perhaps, grieves, it does seem very successfully to protect the vital organs against the weaponry that's deployed against it, whether arrows, spears, bows. So there are at some of the times where it's mentioned there are 10 times as many wounded as there are fatalities. So a lot of people are getting hurt, they are recovering and coming back eventually, but they've got their scars and there may well be mental ones as well as the physical ones. So it's wearing everybody down and it's hard, it's arduous, it isn't pretty, it's ugly fighting. But they keep doing it and they keep winning, but at a cost.
- [23:01]
Tristan Hughes
This revolt endures for two years or so and it's almost that Alexander will plug the gap one place and then another falkspool appear somewhere else or threaten them elsewhere in Battery or Sogdia, or attack a garrison somewhere and deal a lot of damage from the earlier stages. I just wanted to bring up quickly two other big events that happen. So after the siege of Cyropolis, Alexander taking those towns, there is actually, I guess, a kind of large scale pitched battle against the Scythians at the Jaxartes River. I don't know how large we can
- [23:33]
Dr. Adrian Goldsworthy
say it is not on the scale of Issus or Gaugamela. It's difficult and it doesn't, you know, it's not really. When modern scholars look at the history of warfare and the history of battle, it doesn't tend to get, get listed. But it is this river crossing and where it's. Because he's fighting mainly against cavalry, you have to be quite careful about keeping together, not being broken up by them and then driving them off and killing their leaders. So there's a lot of fighting and it involves large parts of the Macedonian army. But it is that classic thing winning one of these battles doesn't gain you as much as winning an Issus or a Gaugamima. In that far fewer communities are inclined to say, all right gov, it's a fair copy, I'm giving in because you've done that. A people happily run away and think that's no reflection on their manhood. They will fight again another day because that's just common sense as far as they're concerned. But also it's this fragmented society, all these different communities, they don't feel obliged. Alexander can sack one mud walled city after another, but the next one he comes to doesn't feel that it has to give in. As far as it's concerned, it's always defended itself. Why shouldn't it against these people?
- [24:38]
Tristan Hughes
And you also have in this region which is, you know, this is the first of many that we'll get to this, these great rock fortresses, you know, these very impregnate, not impregnable as we'll find out but you know, they are still formidable defensive locations almost. Think of it like, like, you know, the traditional view of a hill fort in, in Iron Age Bristol, wherever that you know, somewhere strong that you could retreat to and really difficult for someone to attack. So those kind of safe havens that these little bands, guerrilla bands will venture back to. And over the course I also want to mention the fact that Alexander the Great does arguably suffer the worst loss of his entire career here. It's not him himself, but he like a detachment of 2 to 3,000 men are lured out near Samarkand and annihilated by a Sogdian Scythian army. And that's unprecedented fact that he's able to lose so many men and there is no like wounded or barely anyone escaped. They're all killed.
- [25:33]
Dr. Adrian Goldsworthy
Yes, it's gone and it's not. We lose a lot of casualties as we're gradually taking Tyre. It's we're defeated as well.
- [25:39]
Tristan Hughes
We are defeated, absolutely. Smashed a river crossing Polytunnettis river. It's terrible for Alexander. And the revolt will continue like hit and run tactics across Sogdia. Alexander kind of, you know, different detachments of his army trying to face them off for two years or so. Morale, inevitably, it must have plummeted around that time.
- [26:01]
Dr. Adrian Goldsworthy
Well, they've all been away from home a very long time. You know, we go back to the second episode, I think we talked about, the men who were allowed so winter's leave, the men recently married, to go home to Macedonia. But in contrast to Philip's campaigns, where generally speaking, every year you've got to go home for at least a bit of time, that's no longer the case. You have become. Your home is now mobile, you're moving around. We'll learn from later on that many of the soldiers have taken local women as their companions. They've got children, they're building up because they've been away from so long, they've been cut off for so long. But clearly a lot of them still think of themselves as Macedonian. That's still home that they think of this as well. We go to war, okay, it's bigger scale than Philip stuff, but basically it's the same idea. We go off, we win victories, we get loot, we get glory, then we go home to enjoy those things. But you're not going home. And the fighting continues. And you've already won more spectacular victories than anyone's ever heard of. And yet it's still not enough. And now you're fighting as well. Smaller scale, but as brutal, if not more so. People are dying. You have this defeat that's embarrassing, that's costly, and it doesn't seem to get you anywhere. You take one of these places and the one across the other side of the valley now rebels against you, or the one in the next valley over and people keep raiding you. You can't relax, you can't see any path that's clear and simple because there's no one leader. There isn't a Darius or Abessus even to take out.
- [27:29]
Tristan Hughes
Well, exactly. You get the name Spitermenes, but then Spitermenes is actually killed, supposedly by his wife.
- [27:35]
Dr. Adrian Goldsworthy
And it doesn't matter.
- [27:35]
Tristan Hughes
It does matter because others take up the mantle. Yeah.
- [27:38]
Dr. Adrian Goldsworthy
And it's again, it's why so many powers and empires in history have had trouble in the same region, because of this very fragmented political system with a strong, strongly independently minded people. But also the landscapes that make campaigning difficult, that give Plenty of strongholds and you need a lot more soldiers if you're going to garrison all of this and hold everything down and you just don't have the numbers. So even with the army that's bigger, he can't put a garrison every can't be strong everywhere. And the reason for the defeat was that he wasn't strong enough in that one place at the time because he's busy with most of the army off elsewhere and by the time they come up to aid them, the columns been wiped out.
- [28:28]
Nissan Pathfinder Advertiser
There's an SUV that turns the unthinkable into the unforgettable. The new Nissan Pathfinder. Built for big adventures and all that family chaos. It's powered by a strong V6 engine with a nine speed automatic transmission. Inside it's rugged and capable, but still premium and tech forward with room for up to eight passengers. It's also available with seven passenger seating and second row captain's chairs with massive hauling capabilities. Now you can bring all the gear you and your family need for unforgettable Adventures. The new V6 Nissan Pathfinder. Power your adventure.
- [29:00]
Don Wildman
What started the Civil War? What ended the conflict in Vietnam? Who was Paul Revere and did the Vikings ever reach America? I'm Don Wildman and on American History, my expert guests and I are journeying across the nation and through the years to uncover the stories that have made America. We'll visit the battlefields and debate floors where the nation was formed, meet the characters who have altered it with their touch and count the votes that have changed the direction of our laws and leadership. Find American History hit twice a week, every week, wherever you get your podcasts. American History hit a popular podcast from History Hip.
- [30:00]
Tristan Hughes
We need to move on from the Sogdian revolt. But before we get to the ending, we do also have to mention one of the big infamous events of Alexander's life. Hits him, you know, psychologically for six. And this is around a figure that we've already mentioned a couple of times in our series, the important general, the veteran general of Clitus the Black. So I think this is 327bc. Now we're in Samarkand and for context, Clitus, this key adjutant of Alexander, one of the Alexander's father's generals. I think Alexander has just appointed him to be like the new governor of this region as well, which doesn't really seem like a great, great posting quite frankly. But what happens, it's this infamous drinking party.
- [30:48]
Dr. Adrian Goldsworthy
It's one of the lulls, you know, it's not 12 months of a Year, every year they're campaigning. It's very intensive, but it's one of the quieter periods and it's partly why he's appointing Blaclitus, as he's called to this, boasting basically as governor. So there's a brief pause and you often find you get trouble. It seems you get mutinies in armies when they get some rest period, because while they're busy fighting, they're just too busy and too preoccupied and then too exhausted. But when you get a bit of time to stop and think, things tend to get fractures. Grievances have time to grow a little bit, and in this case, you've got some feasting, they're celebrating. When they do stop, on those rare occasions they do have big parties, they celebrate. All of this has got more lavish because Alexander is now fabulously wealthy in a way that he wasn't ever as king of Macedonia. You've got the Persian luxuries, you've got trappings of the Persian court. You've got all of this coming in and the celebration, the ceremony surrounding the king. And you've also got the changing of the guard to some extent, in terms of the people around Alexander are more of his contemporaries and younger men who've proven themselves in recent years. The men like Clitus the Black are fewer in number. Philip's old hold hands, the real veterans. And that clearly Alexander likes being flattered. And that's reflected in the histories that are written by his court historians, that ridiculously exaggerated events that have occurred when he didn't need to. It is rather childish almost, that this man delighted in being said he's even more wonderful than he really was because he didn't. If they just stuck to the bare facts, it's spectacular. So you get a group that are praising Alexander and denigrating Philip and Clitus, who is or all of them quite highly inebriated at this point because again, you've still got this very strong drinking culture of the clansmen, of the king and his warriors basically celebrating together. So he starts mocking this. Some of his friends realize that it's going a bit too far. He's starting to criticize Alexander and reminding him about, you'd be dead if it wasn't for my right arm. This sort of thing. We're the people who fought this. Some of his friends managed to sort of usher him out. And then, as is sometimes the way with drunks, he somehow gets free and thinks it's a great idea to come back in and start insulting Alexander again. Alexander flies off the handle completely grabs a spear from one of the guards that's there and runs Cleitus through and kills him at this point is shocked by what he's done. He takes the spear and is then trying to kill himself with it. So he has to be stopped and restrained from that and then goes into this depression mourning period where he has just killed a man who saved his life. He has killed a man who's the brother of his nurse as a child, who's been loyal to him at every stage all the way through this long journey. And he's done it because an argument's got out of hand. And while you can think back to Alexander himself was a youth going into exile when his father's marrying Cleopatra, his last wife, and mocking Philip when Philip falls over when he's coming across the couch to get at him. Shouldn't end in blows and weapons. It's going too far. And Alexander can see that. He knows he's done something wrong. He knows he's done something with black and his reputation. Nobody's going to protest against this. Clitus is dead. What's the point now you can't bring him back. But it's scaring everybody, I think, including Alexander, that that control isn't there anymore and that you can't. It's shown there is always a struggle. There has been for quite a while. What is he now? What is the relationship between not just him, but you have alongside the Macedonians and Greeks because he's got all these Asians that he's brought in from the aristocracy to try and make sure the regions are happy. They're starting to figure in the army more, they're figuring in the court more. How do they react to. And it'll lead on to the whole proscanasis, the idea of prostrating yourself before the great king as you would do, which if you don't do it, is a mark of disrespect and shameful from the point of view of the cultures, the Persians in particular. But if you do, it is absolutely disgusting from a Macedonian Greek point of view. So how can you please everybody? And how can. Alexander's trying to steer a path through the middle and is often too tired, too drunk, too vain perhaps to do it well. So it's. All of this is getting more. At a time when the war is arduous, unpleasant and apparently unending. Whenever there's a lull, these tensions break to the surface because nobody knows what this is anymore and nobody knows what they're doing and what's going to happen.
- [35:44]
Tristan Hughes
It's kind of scary times indeed. And following in the footsteps of the killing of Parmenion as well. It's like the old guard, as you say, is very much disappearing. And the infamous end of Clitus, the fact it also happens at a point where it is really, really difficult for the Macedonians and in Bactria and Sogdia, and, you know, the Clitus the Black's murder just makes it even worse for Alexander and his companions. Of course, they do manage to quash the revolt ultimately after this. And something that we see is, as I mentioned earlier, you have these prominent rock fortresses of several key nobles in the region. There's a man called Oxyatis, I think Coryones is another one. I think one of them is called the Sogdian rock, literally just called the Sogdian rock. And there was this idea that it was impregnable, that Alexander couldn't take it. But as you've also already mentioned, Adrian, he's got people in his army who are, you know, no strangers to mountainous warfare, to climbing difficult terrain. And he does, one by one with his special troops, manages to climb up these rock fortresses and take them to the complete surprise of the local Sogdians anyway, as well. But interestingly, following that, what seems to be the kicker in finally ending the revolt, yes, probably taking the fortress is part of it, but the other half is he decides to get married, his first marriage, and it's to the daughter of one of these Sogdian noblemen who had been in charge of one of these rock fortresses, who had been leading one of the figureheads of the revolt. He decides to marry his daughter. I think that's very, very revealing.
- [37:30]
Dr. Adrian Goldsworthy
It's straight out of Philip's playbook. I mean, it's what he'd been doing throughout his campaigns. Obviously, this is someone more alien than marrying, even, but, you know, an Illyrian, a Thracian, you know, these are unusual brides, even for a Macedonian. But it's the same idea. It's odd in a way that it's taken Alexander so long to do this. An odd then that he chooses someone who is the daughter of a local nobleman, a local prince, not somebody with really widespread influence. So it's a strange choice and the whole story of it that will later become part of the embellishment, the Alexander romance and all this sort of thing. It makes political sense up to a point, but it's odd in terms of. Until he adds a few more other wives when it starts to look More like Philip just doing this thing. It's a very odd first choice. He's had a mistress for a long time who's Greek and has had a child with her. So he hasn't been on his own all these long winter nights. But it's still odd in many respects. But it does seem to be part of giving at least this temporary peace, this stability, bringing this conflict to an end. And it's perhaps, as I say, it's almost a throwback to how Philip would do things.
- [38:42]
Tristan Hughes
And the nobleman Oxyaates, he remains in charge. Effectively. Alexander's like, right, I'm done with this. Do the marriage, get peace in this area finally. And then we and the trucer can leave this godforsaken land. In their idea, that's. They're certainly in their mindset, it's one
- [38:59]
Dr. Adrian Goldsworthy
of the problems that the army simply being there causes resistance and when it moves on, well, there's no one to resist for a start. But also they're. They're less inclined because of the army being that a. It's a visible presence, it's a challenge, it's humiliating. But also it wants stuff. It keeps on eating lots of fodder, forage, it needs meat, it needs all of these things. It needs leather to replace its harness, it needs new weapons, new clothing, it devours material in areas that are not that wealthy. So it is starting to. It's a burden. So moving away, and if you can move away while saving face, which is what he does, you've got enough of a success that you can say, all right, that's fair enough, we're going, we've won. Does help to calm the situation as well in a strange way, which leads
- [39:46]
Tristan Hughes
Alexander to his, where he has eyes on next, which is across the Hindu Kush into the Indian subcontinent. Now, he doesn't take all of his army with him because another really interesting thing is he leaves some 13 to 15,000 troops in Bactria, Sogdia, once again hinting at the instability there. I always find this interesting because a lot of those troops are Greek mercenaries who had recently come from mainland Greece. Those Greek mercenaries had fought alongside a Spartan king against the Macedonians who were still in Europe a few years earlier. The Macedonians had won and the Macedonian in charge back in Europe had sent these defeated Greek mercenaries all the way across Asia to join up with Alexander in Bactris, Sogdia, so Afghanistan, Uzbekistan, they don't seem to have enjoyed it. And Alexander decides, I can't take them into India. I don't. I Think he doesn't trust them at all. So he leaves them in Afghanistan, Uzbekistan, where they just have to settle down. And it's a funny story, that one.
- [40:49]
Dr. Adrian Goldsworthy
I find it's odd because in. In some sense you can see if you go back quite a bit further into Greek history, the whole idea of, well, if you. Things haven't been going well in your home city, you go off and you form a colony somewhere else or you join one there, is that, you know, the Greeks had been great travellers on a smaller scale. It's not quite the same as this. It had tended to be seaborne. You'd gone around the Mediterranean, but you'd also gone around the Black Sea. You know, you had Greek cities in the Crimea, in southern Ukraine, that area from centuries, as well as in Spain, in southern France, you know, Massilia, Marseille today. So in one sense, taking a load of Greeks and say, well, settle down here, make your own city, make your own laws, be Greek, probably take local women as wives and all this sort of thing, but it remains a Greek community. Isn't so unusual, but it is more, as you say, it seems to be a problem. These people have fought on the losing side, so their experience of warfare is being beaten by the Macedonians. They then come all this vast way to try and tack them on to your victorious army probably is more effort than it's worth, whereas what can they do that will cause you trouble? If you dump them in this place, they might not be happy about it, but what are they going to do about it? And you are, in a sense, doing something honorable for them. You are saying, here's a city, become citizens here, act here. So I think it is, yeah, they're not worth the effort. Probably doesn't trust them, perhaps not simply in terms of their loyalty, but just how good they are. So why feed them? Why pay for them when he can take away? Because the other thing he's doing is taking troops, another way of calming the situation, taking men from the regions that have been rebelling against you and giving them the opportunity to go off and fight on your behalf and win gold and glory against other people. And that's again another way that powers have tended to work throughout the centuries, where you take away the sort of wilder young men who've got nothing else to do and send them up and go and get them to fight somebody else on your behalf. And they do it very well.
- [42:44]
Tristan Hughes
Everybody's happy, well, let's move on now into India. So Alexander's path into India is through. I think he takes more than one route, he divides the army. But there's like the Khyber Passed, there's the Swat Valley, and to get towards the Indus river valley and to get there, it's almost. We've talked about rock fortresses already. There's like another few. There's more, there's more difficult rock fortresses. One called the Aornis Rock isn't there. And a Massaga, not Masada Massaga, but it's a similar story. He is able to overcome those formidable defenses. There are some romantic stories. There's a particular queen called Cleophas in one story attached to one of the cities. Whatever the truth, whatever the facts, whatever the fiction, Alexander does ultimately get his army into the Indus river valley. And, and this is the beginning of that, that great most exotic part of Alexander's story. I feel, at least in the eyes of the Greeks that they've, they've emerged into this land that was really the furthest eastern edge of the Persian Empire.
- [43:47]
Dr. Adrian Goldsworthy
It's, it's an. Areas where the Persians have now and again being able to assert themselves and claim power. But that was only really when the local powers were too busy fighting each other and left weak as a result. They never really established. And there is a. There are fanciful elements within the traditions about what happens in India that you don't quite get anywhere else. You feel it is more you're moving into the borders of legend rather than.
- [44:10]
Tristan Hughes
Well, you mentioned earlier how you know this idea that there are intellectuals in Alexander the Great's army and when they're in India, whether you're a geographer, a botanist, a historian or whatever, these are a philosopher, all this kind of new world that's opened up to you when
- [44:29]
Dr. Adrian Goldsworthy
you get there, it is staggering because it's again a place where civilization is more ancient than Greece. So there are routes back, although it's not necessarily any technologically more sophisticated when you get there. This is a very, very ancient culture with its own way of doing things, but more than one, because it is not united. There are different areas. So there is a sense of wonder and strangeness about it all. Whether there's partly in the stories as well, the sense that it's even more exotic to explain why they don't in the long run stay there quite so long, you have to wonder. But again, in other respects it's the same pattern. As you come across, you approach people and you want them either to submit to you, or if they won't submit to you, you'll fight them.
- [45:21]
Tristan Hughes
And which he does isn't he so this is when we get the last big pitched battle of Alexander's career. So how do we get to this legendary name of the Battle of the Hydaspes River?
- [45:31]
Dr. Adrian Goldsworthy
It's an interesting thing. You've got King Porus who's got a large army that includes not just men on foot and horseback, but lots of elephants. And that's something. There have been a few of these at Gaugamela, but they're not really mentioned. He's got lots. And this is an army that you know, is used to fighting and using more elephants. They know how to use them. So it's very different. It's also Alexander's crossed rivers before. He's done it at the Axartes, not too long before. He's done it at Agranicus in a sense. But this is a much bigger river to get across so that you're in a position to face the enemy is harder. They're doing it at night. They end up landing on an island rather than actually on the shore. There's a lot of confusion. There's again some nice detail you get in the likes of Arrian that suggest just a, the capability of the Macedonian army, how experienced it is, but also how difficult many of these operations are so that even when you're experienced things go wrong. And the deception plan that they've arranged to conceal the fact that they are doing this crossing. So they get across without being opposed, but then advance to encounter Porus and his army. And this is a much more fluid battle than the others. There aren't the straightforward battle lines. Both sides are caught a little bit by surprise and you end up with heavy fighting, quite costly fighting. Prominent role is played by some of the horse archers and others that he's got in his more recent campaigns in Central Asia. So people who've been fighting against him not too long before. And again Alexander wins, but it's a hard fought battle and it's his last really big pitch battle in a sense. As I say, whether there are organized battle lines is a different thing. And Porus is captured, brought before him at the end. And again you get the famous stories because this will be celebrated. There's an awful lot of art that emphasizes elephants, men on elephants and fighting against them. So it does capture the imagination. People can't imagine this massed army of elephants, Taurus is brought before Alexander. He's described as very handsome, very, very tall, exceptionally so, almost superhumanly so. And when asked by Alexander, how would you be treated? The answer is supposed to be like a king and Alexander reconfirms him not only in his own kingdom, but gives him extra lands. And it's another one of those Alexander myth moments where you see the man who is generous to the defeated, generous to someone he respects, willing to trust them, willing to expand their power on the basis that they will then be loyal to him. So it's a great moment, and it's one of the last great military moments of Alexander and great diplomatic moments as well, in many respects.
- [48:17]
Commercial Announcer
For delicious meals, you could go out to eat, or you could just make a Marie Callender's meal. Marie Callender's classic chicken parmigiano bowl is so good. It has marinara sauce that's made from scratch and creamy mozzarella cheese over pasta. It's delicious with no artificial flavors, colors, or preservatives and 30 grams of protein. You can find it in the frozen aisle. Marie Callender's what having it all tastes like.
- [48:41]
Dan Snow
Hi there, I'm Dan, host of Dan Snow's history podcast. I can imagine on these dark winter nights, all you want to do is curl up with a cup of tea and get lost in an amazing story. Well, I can help you with that. Twice a week, I tell you the most dramatic and extraordinary stories from history, with details I can guarantee you never heard before. Feel the frostbite of that grisly failed American invasion of Canada in the dead of winter. Imagine every clash and blow at the Battle of Bosworth. Follow Eleanor of Aquitaine rather than most powerful women in the medieval world as she goes on crusade to the holy land. With 300 handmaidens in tow, she leads her own army.
- [49:21]
Tristan Hughes
Everyone goes gaga for Eleanor.
- [49:22]
Dan Snow
And trace the voyage of the first Vikings as they arrive on Iceland's lonely shores. For the best historical stories to get lost in, check out Dan Snow's history.
- [49:52]
Tristan Hughes
You can see it means a lot to him because archaeologically, one of my favorite sets of artifacts is you have these medallions surviving. There's one in the British Museum. I think there are a few others have been found, but it's believed to be they're almost army medals for the soldiers that had served at that battle. And it shows an elephant with either one or two riders. And the elephant is kind of going away. It looks like it's kind of fleeing away. And chasing the elephant is a cavalryman with a long zist on lance looking to spear. Yeah, I think the rear man on the back of that elephant. And it's kind of a triumph of like the companion cavalryman against the porous Elephant. But it's amazing to have that sort of artifact surviving. But what I also love about the Battle of the Hydaspes, yes, Alexander wins it and yes, Alexander takes a lot of pride in it. It'd be great, you know, defeating this army of elephants. But when you look at the bigger picture, Porus's kingdom is a small kingdom, probably the size of Macedonia, at most in a little bit of the Indus river valley between two particular rivers, river branches. Alexander's got an army of a hundred thousand. Maybe that's exaggeration, but you know, all
- [50:59]
Dr. Adrian Goldsworthy
to win this, to win it.
- [51:01]
Tristan Hughes
And he does.
- [51:02]
Dr. Adrian Goldsworthy
Yes.
- [51:02]
Tristan Hughes
But he still takes a lot of pride around it. And he said Porus becomes an ally.
- [51:06]
Dr. Adrian Goldsworthy
He's got not fighting Chandragupta or anyone like this with a big united army.
- [51:11]
Tristan Hughes
There's a myth, isn't he, that he actually meets a young.
- [51:14]
Dr. Adrian Goldsworthy
Yes. Because it's. Again, his main power will occur later. It's post Alexander and it's. But it's again, it's a reflection of India is quite fragmented politically just at that moment. Yeah. And then you will get the strong leader to emerge who is a sort of Alexander in his own right.
- [51:28]
Tristan Hughes
Yeah.
- [51:29]
Dr. Adrian Goldsworthy
But on that other scale. And they don't meet. And it was interesting. I remember talking to someone who wrote a book about a great contest between generals in history and said he couldn't really fit Alexander in because Alexander doesn't fight an equal in the sense of a great commander with a great army. He fights one or the other, but not both at the same time. He's not a Scipio and Hannibal. It's not Caesar and a Pompey or whoever you might see. So he's there at the right moment. But it is, I think as well, they probably don't realize just how big and how populous India is when they arrive there. So that particularly because they've so recently been fighting after the big wars against the main united Persians, they've been fighting all these local campaigns. They don't really have enough information. They have gone beyond where they've got
- [52:17]
Tristan Hughes
detailed what's over the next river, what's over the next branch. Right. You know, that kind of. It's very interesting. You've also got the local Indian kingdoms around that time. They weren't all like Porous. They don't all fight Alexander. There's the king of Taxilla, Abmi or Taxiles. He's quite known, isn't he? But then there are others that also try to resist. There's a siege of a place called Sangala and the Cathayans. And Alexander is slowly advancing eastwards past each kind of different branch of the Indus river, this far up it. But then they get to the Hyphasis River. Sorry.
- [52:54]
Dr. Adrian Goldsworthy
Yeah. And they're into the monsoon and it's just hellish again. It's moved to a world they don't recognize. It's like going into the desert in Egypt. This is just strange. And there's no end to it. There's just one. And why are they there? Other than the fact that Alexander quite fancies the idea of conquering as far as he can keep conquering. And in a sense, you know, you even have to wonder sometimes, does he keep doing this a because he just loves it, or does he not want to settle down and do the boring stuff of running this empire he's just conquered? But the men are finally get to the point where they are just fed up. They don't keep going because these are people who've been at this now for so many years, come so far. And most of them had fought under Philip as well before that. And there's only so much you could take out of someone. They must be exhausted. And it's your boldest men have suffered wound after wound or they've watched others die because they've kept on leading the way. Yes, you've had promotion, yes, you've had loads of plunder, you've got lots of glory, but what's the point of it if you can't spend it and if you can't go back to have people admire you? So it's the point where Alexander's inability to read his men sometimes just comes to a head because he thinks he can bluster first of all and make them go on and do this. Oh, yeah, you'll back down and it's cross the Hyphasis river that you will just go, we'll cross this one and then we'll keep going. But they simply refuse and you have this mutiny. That is not a rejection of him. They're not saying, we don't want you as king anymore. They don't try and kill him. There's no plot against him. It's not that sort of thing at all. It's not what's happened to plenty of Macedonian kings in the past, that somebody is getting rid of you. It's. It's simply we can't do it anymore. We are fed up. We just can't go on. There's no end to this. Give us some rest. Let us at least take a break for A bit. Let's have a few campaigning seasons off. Let's rest. Whether they're already thinking of, let's go back home. Some of them, surely, yes, but it's so far away and it's that element of utter exhaustion and they will not be moved. Even when he tries to bribe them, then frighten them and then bully them, it doesn't work. So eventually he gives in and retreats. But you have this story of him building these camps with sort of oversized armor left behind, and this is suggested the Indians, that some race of giants had come to their aid. And you better be frightened of the Macedonians because we might come back one day. But it is space saving. It's no more than that. And I don't think anybody local is that impressed by this. It's a. But that's the point where there have been these situations where he hasn't read the mood of the men at all well, even though he can inspire them when the fighting. He's great, he can do all of that. But the why this is happening and why this is going on, he can't seem to sympathize with them.
- [55:45]
Tristan Hughes
We mentioned in the first episode the taming of Bucephalus. And now we get to the end of Bucephalus story as well, because this is when Alexander's trusted steed dies around this time. Yeah, that was a city.
- [55:57]
Dr. Adrian Goldsworthy
Yes. I mean, most of the city gets swept away by flooding before too long. But it's nevertheless, it's a remarkable thing to. You know, Hadrian wrote a poem and left a grand tomb at Tivoli for his. One of his famous hunting horses. But to found a city and name it after your horses is a big, big deal. And it's clearly again, though, in that culture where, you know, they have been companions in so many wars, Alexander would feel that his life has been saved and has relied upon being able to trust Bucephalus to do what he wanted. So it is a big thing, but it's also a sign of exhaustion. Even that link with home has died. A lot of people aren't there anymore and the ones that are just tired and worn out. So Alexander leaves a bit of a mark on India. He found some cities, he makes alliances, he imposes his rule, forces people to. But it's not really a deep, deep thing because he isn't there long enough. And it's. He has reached the limit of his power.
- [56:57]
Tristan Hughes
Because we are getting near the end of Alexander's story now. I mean, because the next part in Alexander's story. Once his army has said, we're not going any further, Bucephalus has died. It just gets quite, dare I say, repetitive and brutal. Because Alexander now marches his army down the Indus river valley. He's basically like, okay, we'll go home, but we're going to go down the
- [57:17]
Dr. Adrian Goldsworthy
valley, we're going to go the long way round. I want the scenic route.
- [57:19]
Commercial Announcer
Yeah.
- [57:19]
Tristan Hughes
And so he goes down and like, there's city after city, like some submit but lots of them resist. And then what he gets is brutal capturing of city after city again and again and again. And it's repetitive and. But that is kind of. This is more of the clearly murderous, clearly, dare say, like psychotic Alexander at this time, I'd say.
- [57:43]
Dr. Adrian Goldsworthy
I mean, again, what is the purpose of it all now? And it's been fuzzy for a long time. But you come to each of these communities, they're proud, independent communities. He tells them to surrender, they say, no, why should we? So he storms them and he massacres everybody and then he comes to the next one and the same thing happens again and again and it's brutal. And you have the case where he's quite badly wounded, he's shot by an arrow in the chest during one of the assaults on these things where he's again got impatient with his own men. He felt they were hanging back when they were just. They were short of ladders. So runs up the only ladder there is, followed by a couple of his sort of close bodyguards and companions who are thinking, oh dear, you know, we really got to be there because it'll be. We don't want to be blamed for the king getting killed. But the ladder collapses because. Not enough to get up. So they're isolated for a while. They jump down into the city and sort of lay about them with swords. He's shot, they stand over him. It's very Homeric. I mean, it's cookie straight from the Iliad till eventually the rest of the army breaks in. But it's where he's getting angry and impatient. There's a sign they've all done too much, they're all exhausted, they're all really touchy. And Alexander in particular, because again, it's perhaps that sense of even he doesn't quite know what he wants to do and what he should be doing and how to do it. So it's even your return is by a new conquest, new exploration. So it's, in a sense, the same old thing is going on and they are just more and more brutal. It is very grim in this, this last phase.
- [59:07]
Tristan Hughes
Absolutely it is. And finally they get down to the delta, like the, the mouth of the Indus river. Patala, I think it's called. No, it is called Patala. And I think there's some archaeological evidence of Alexander's army being there. I'm not going to delve into that. And this is where, you know, Alexander, a much weaker Alexander because they thought he was. There was a time where they didn't know whether he was going to survive or not. And there were rumors that then got to people further aboard that Alexander had died in India. And then there's a. Remember those disgruntled Greek mercenaries I mentioned that were left in Baksha in Afghanistan. Some of them think, oh goody, this is the time to go back to Greece. Then they find out Alexander's alive and it all goes to pot for them. That's another story. But Alexander does survive. Gets down to the mouth of the Indus river valley and then it's, it's the westward journey home. And it's a big splitting up of the army. There's the navy, which has gone down the Indus river, you know, sail down and that will hug the coast. And then Alexander divides his army and he's gonna go. I think the plan is to be near the fleets, that's the plan. But they're gonna go westwards through this arid, difficult terrain west of the Indus river valley towards, well, southern Iran today, towards back towards Babylon. And this is the Kadrosian desert. And it seems because of the monsoons, the navy and the army do not coordinate. And all of a sudden the navy contingent, commanded by a guy called Nearchus, loses track of the army. And Alexander's troops, they really suffer. Marching. This is the worst logistical disaster of Alexander's career.
- [60:49]
Dr. Adrian Goldsworthy
It's very hard to know the scale of losses, but it is clearly a traumatic experience for all of them going through the Gedrosian desert as they run low on water. But it gives. And you half wonder, is this Alexander punishing them? Is it just his longing? You know, this whole Pothos thing that you get, there's this sense of doing something that nobody else has done. I will succeed where everyone else has failed. If that fortress is, you know, impossible to capture, I will capture it. You know, so you have this and you have this odd mixture. There are clearly some mistakes. You know, at one point they camp in dried up watercourse which floods when it rains. And this, it's fairly obvious stuff you probably should work out, but they don't. But you have the classic moment as well, as they start to lose stragglers, people are left behind, but they're running short of water. They have none left. And somebody finds enough to fill a helmet, brings it to Alexander, presents it to him, and he makes a big display of pouring it out onto the sand. I mean, he could have perhaps given it to the man who brought it to him. But nevertheless, the message is, if you're not drinking, I'm not drinking either. So you get Alexander the Incredible Leader along with Alexander the Unfocused. What's he doing here? What's this going on? So it's probably not the losses that are reported. The numbers of casualties are probably greatly exaggerated. But it's still a nasty moment for an army that's already tired. And the fact that it is tired means that some of them are reaching the end of their tether and more vulnerable to collapse before they get there. So it's a very odd thing where you have another epic, you have this golden Alexander moment, but then the whole setting for it all is why this is happening in the first place. Because there's nothing there worth conquering in this area. And as you say, if there had been any attempt to keep in touch with the fleet, that's long since failed. But again, once Alexander's committed to something, Alexander doesn't quit. He keeps going. And of course, he does get away with it in the end. They do get through, but it's after suffering an awful lot, after losing quite a lot of people.
- [62:49]
Tristan Hughes
Absolutely. And one of my favorite books on Alexander the Great is one logistics. Very nerdy.
- [62:55]
Dr. Adrian Goldsworthy
Engels.
- [62:56]
Tristan Hughes
Engels, yeah. Points out that, yes, like, the high numbers, the people that you don't hear about that are probably the majority of those casualties was the baggage train people. They're the people who would have, like, been the first to die or be the stragglers and the women and children by this time. You know, most of those soldiers have their own wives, and they're the ones who would have lost the most life. You know, the highest casualties. Not the soldiers, probably. But yes, as we get to the end of. Of Alexander's story, because when he finally meets up with Nearchus and the team again, I think Nearchus recounts how they go to see Alexander and his withered army, and they've all got beards and stuff, and they just look bedraggled and exhausted, but they've made it.
- [63:38]
Dr. Adrian Goldsworthy
But there's also the Nearchus. They. They've given him up for dead. They think the fleet's gone. Yeah. So he appears and they don't believe who he is at first, first. So it's this because by this time the army's recovered so it's the other way around where he's gone and it's just they've not heard anything. They don't really have that much sense of how far it is and they just think they've gone and there have been problems, it's been a difficult journey but nevertheless. But through that they've learned, they've then from then on know there is a sense of okay this is India, how does it connect to the heartland of the Persian empire? So they have learned things. I mean there is some positive I suppose from this but it's all been expensive, sort of overly costly.
- [64:18]
Tristan Hughes
So Alexander gets back to, well, Persia I guess so what is now kind of the central area of his empire. One of the first things he does which is very interesting is he hears that some of his governors have been like in the nicest way possible, misbehaving or misappropriating funds or not respecting local cultures and he goes down hard on them. He has quite a few of them executed. One of his boyhood friends, a man called Harpalus who had been left in Babylon sees the writing on the wall which is fitting for Babylon and flees westwards with a lot of the money and he will try to rise, incur a revolt against Alexander, his whole boyhood friend back in Athens. That's a story for another day. But Alexander encounters that difficult situation and then what follows that I guess it's the big wedding ceremony, isn't it?
- [65:09]
Dr. Adrian Goldsworthy
There's a move altogether in that a lot of the people he executes are Asians and they're local people that he's kept in power. So as well as some of the Greeks and others who've gone off the rails as far as he's concerned. There's an emphasis more you get more Greeks and particularly Macedonians appointed subsequently and then you get this big ceremony where he marries off particularly prominent Macedonians but also some others more generally to aristocratic or Persian and Asian women. Now this used to be, you know, you've got the old stuff from Tan and people like that. This was all to do with this idea of brotherhood of mankind. You would bring the different races together and all mingle together. The significant thing is that you don't marry any Persian men to a Macedonian wife. It's all one sided. It is purely Alexander's officers get pretty and wealthy, well connected local women as their wives. So it might be a sense of, well I'd like you all to settle in Asia and think of these as your main estates, significantly, all but one, the exception being Seleucus will as soon as Alexander's dead, they get rid of these wives, divorce them very quickly or just dispose of them so it doesn't prove to be happy families. So he's unusual in that he keeps her. But it's a grand gesture. But it's again, it's this whole who are we now? That raises questions, raises difficulties. Nobody quite knows what's going on and it builds towards. You're marrying some of your soldiers to Persians and then you present the youngsters, some of them orphans, some of the mothers that you've raised that are Persians, and you've raised and educated and trained as Macedonians and trained as a new phalanx. And you present them to your old veterans who are really fed up by this time as your replacements. And unsurprisingly, it doesn't go down terribly well the sense that, well, we beat these, you know, this, this people really easily. We've walked through this, we've conquered everything. And now he wants to get rid of us and just rely on the Asian soldiers we've beaten.
- [67:05]
Tristan Hughes
No, exactly. That's what's happening at the same time, isn't it? You can see there's clear incorporation now of Persian, of Asian units into even the Macedonian phalanxes. There's talk of a mixed Falan Persian and Macedonians together there. Alexander is clearly giving a lot of favor to this new. I guess he calls them the epigony of a particular group, which basically means the successors.
- [67:29]
Dr. Adrian Goldsworthy
I know it's as tactless as you can get slap in the face, isn't it? Particularly as they've been complaining and saying they want to go home. You've had the mutiny at office. You've had all of this where they've just, you know, we're fed up and it's, oh, well, I don't need. You know, by the way, meet your.
- [67:43]
Tristan Hughes
These are the next brainstems. This is the new phallics.
- [67:46]
Dr. Adrian Goldsworthy
Incredibly tactless in one sense. You could see it, it's still doing a Philip. It's how as he had conquered other areas and incorporated them into a greater Macedonia, but they were culturally much more similar and longer connections, whereas this is something very, very different. On the one hand, what else are you going to do with this empire? And if he wants to go on and fight more wars, then he needs an army to do it. He wants a big army to do it. So where Are you going to get recruits? But it's tactless, it's not popular and it doesn't even, to a vast extent, win over the wider Asian community. The people involved seem to be fairly loyal.
- [68:30]
Tristan Hughes
Very much so. You mentioned there the OPIS mutiny. So this is this. As a consequence, the Macedonian soldiers are just fed up and you get that amazing speech preserved in Arrian. I won't say it all now, but Alexander scaves. I've got all these wounds on my body. I've got none on my back, by the way, because I never turn my back to the enemy kind of idea. And I've suffered them all for you and this is how you repay me kind of thing.
- [68:52]
Dr. Adrian Goldsworthy
Philip found you in skins, living in caves sort of thing. I know we've made you civilized men the lords of the world.
- [68:56]
Tristan Hughes
It's an amazing speech. How much we can believe.
- [68:58]
Dr. Adrian Goldsworthy
Yeah.
- [68:59]
Tristan Hughes
But, you know, it's still. I can imagine Alexander saying that, as
- [69:03]
Dr. Adrian Goldsworthy
the ancient authors would say, it's what he, you know, meant to say. It's the essence of what he said. That was his argument.
- [69:09]
Tristan Hughes
Absolutely. And so. But then you see some 10,000 of the veteran Macedonians are sent home and Alexander's expecting more recruits to come up to come out to him for future campaigns. But we're getting near the end now. They're not going to happen. Shall I just wrestle through a couple of other events that should mention before we get to Babylon? So this is now 324bc, so we're very near the end. A big event that happens around this time is Alexander's kind of moving around this central area. I think he's in Ecbatana, that his closest friend and almost certainly his lover Hephaestion, dies, falls ill and dies. And this just sends Alexander, if you thought him mourning Cleitus the Black was bad, this is another level. He is grieving and that grief just keeps gnawing at him forever. If it was for the rest of his life, so much so then I think partly in consequence, he hears of. Well, he kind of goes on a punitive campaign against nearby mountain people. Well, hill tribe, people in the mountains, the Cosseians. And it's brutal. It's another. This is murderous, vengeful, besotted by grief. Alexander, the last kind of military campaign before he dies, and it is just one of just massacre.
- [70:31]
Dr. Adrian Goldsworthy
They really chose their timing badly to upset him because he was just in an angry mood. So it's. They pay the price for that. And it's that with Hephaestion, you Have this spectacular funeral and celebrate even the tactful things he's done before. He wants all the flames, but it's all the fire temples of the local. All the cults are supposed to stop and mourn and everything. It's suddenly, I am the center of the world. I am feeling bad. Everybody else needs to feel bad. And I've got a big army. So you've got to do this. You haven't got any choice. But it is not very good. But again, sometimes people forget. Although Alexander has kept some sort of level of control over the empire, he's mostly been too busy throughout his reign to run the area he's conquered. So apart from the initial contact where he tends to be nice to people and tactful, he's not practiced in dealing all the time with other people's feelings, placating people, keeping them happy. He's not had to do the fillet stuff and keep everybody as happy in a Macedonian court as he's had to. He's always been able to distract with, this is the war. That's what we've got to focus on. Let's just go and fight and win, and then we can forget about things till afterwards. But this is the afterwards, and dealing with that is hard for him. It is.
- [71:44]
Tristan Hughes
And he will ultimately venture back to Babylon, which it looks like he might be eyeing up as a new capital. Well, clearly, I think there's story of him inviting his mother to Babylon as well, isn't there? But there's a famous story that as he enters Babylon, the local priests, or like, there's an omen or there's a prophecy that Alexander, if you enter Babylon, you'll never leave. And that will prove to be the case. He's got future plans. I think it's around Arabia he may have an idea of.
- [72:12]
Dr. Adrian Goldsworthy
Well, it's more than an idea. They've actually sent the initial. The fleet has gone down the rivers to reconnoiter. So it's. Yes, they've built up. They've done the sort of preliminaries for a campaign that's going to happen the next.
- [72:22]
Tristan Hughes
Which makes sense.
- [72:23]
Dr. Adrian Goldsworthy
And it's ready to go.
- [72:24]
Tristan Hughes
Which makes sense because of those rich trading cities along the Arabian coastline between Egypt and India. And I think he'll go back to. I've said this several times before on record that I do think that he sees he's got advisors whispering to him about Athens and there is some trouble further west. So I do think he probably had eyes on campaigning further west, but that never happens. And that's all we can only theorize as to what would have happened next. But we get to late May, early June 323 BC and the ill fated dinner party of one of his companions, of Medius of Larissa, where he's drinking
- [73:01]
Dr. Adrian Goldsworthy
too much and falls ill. And then it's. There are all sorts of rumors at the time and subsequently of poison and various theories as to how it could be delivered. You do get a sense that many people are really unhappy with how things are but don't really know what they want. But there is no alternative to Alexander. Roxanne is pregnant this time, but they don't know whether she'll carry to term. Would it be a boy? It turns out to be and we
- [73:27]
Tristan Hughes
should clarify because I don't think we actually ever mentioned her name but Roxanne. Oh sorry, no, no, that's quite. I should have said earlier. So she is that Sogdian princess or Sogdian daughter of the nobleman to end that revolt.
- [73:37]
Dr. Adrian Goldsworthy
Yes, but there isn't anybody, there isn't an adult, you know, even an adolescent. You could have a guardian for a while and you could think of as a viable alternative. So they, they are faced with a problem, so on. It's a bit like Philip's murder you think with Alexander. Well, he might have been murdered because some people might just have felt we really. I can't cope with this anymore, we've got to move on. On the other hand, nobody has that clear a plan of what they're going to do afterwards and he's, you know, he's led a fairly wild lifestyle and people fall ill in the age world, particularly people who've moved through so many different environments, become exposed to so many different sorts of germs along the way. Yes, they're tough in many respects but there's still that one thing that can just prove fatal. And I. So I'm still, I think probably it is just disease and it is just chance that he dies then but it's impossible to say. And there were, there are plenty of people who clearly fed up with him. Whether they were that fed up and able to do it, I don't know.
- [74:37]
Tristan Hughes
I'm on completely the same wavelength. I don't believe he was poisoned partly because the poison myth, you can clearly see its origins in the years that follow because it's specifically targeted against one faction that rises to prominence, the family of Cassander and Antipater. And it seems to being curated by the faction that were opposing them for power in Macedonia. Following that. Secondly, as you mentioned. It seems to be a combination of factors. We've mentioned all of his war wounds he suffered, the heavy drinking throughout his career, the illness, the weaker immune system that he would have had, the grief, the excessive grief fighting, all of those things would have weakened him and made him more susceptible for whatever disease. Malaria, typhoid. Lots of different ideas being put forwards for him succumbing to that particular illness. So I'm completely on the same wavelength there. And what I love about the death of Alexander the Great is morbid, as I say, is that you have basically almost, word for word, the same account of his last week and a half in two of our different sources, which suggests. And they actually say it in the source.
- [75:48]
Dr. Adrian Goldsworthy
Yeah.
- [75:49]
Tristan Hughes
That they took it from the royal journals, which were written down by his personal secretary, a man who will become fascinating in the following years, Eumenes of Cardia. Yes, I'm sure we could talk about him a lot. But it's almost like the account we have in both these accounts, which is the same, almost certainly originates from the pen or the stylus of Eumenes writing it down and how Alexander's condition deteriorates every week and a half. You know, at first he doesn't seem
- [76:15]
Dr. Adrian Goldsworthy
to be too affected.
- [76:16]
Tristan Hughes
He's still giving his orders and the like and planning his campaigns. But then he becomes mute. Then the soldiers know that he's going to die, so they all file past his bedside to say their last. The Macedonian soldiers, at least. And he's. He's. He can't. He only acknowledges them with a mute kind of acknowledgment. And then a few days later, he dies. Of course, you get the legendary last words to the strongest. Yeah. If he's mute, he can't say that. But it's like in hindsight, isn't it? They know.
- [76:48]
Dr. Adrian Goldsworthy
It's what they feel he should have
- [76:49]
Tristan Hughes
said because of the absolute chaos that follows.
- [76:52]
Dr. Adrian Goldsworthy
Yeah.
- [76:53]
Tristan Hughes
Within 48 hours of his death, there's a fight in the room where he dies in the palace in Babylon.
- [76:59]
Dr. Adrian Goldsworthy
Yeah.
- [76:59]
Tristan Hughes
You know, it doesn't stop. It's a symbol for the next. Well, you could say 20 years. If you want to go down to this titanic battle of Ipsus. You could say 40 years. If you want to go down to the last of these wars of the successors and the Basle of Coropedium, where, remember you mentioned earlier how at the start you have, like, people into their 70s and 80s leading armies. We have a general, two generals in their late 70s or early 80s leading their cavalry against each other, like these last two generals who'd fought with Alexander, you know, fighting it off on this last battle. But it shows, doesn't it? You know, Alexander's life ends. His afterlife just hangs around.
- [77:40]
Dr. Adrian Goldsworthy
Yeah.
- [77:41]
Tristan Hughes
For decades, for centuries, Forever, you could say.
- [77:44]
Dr. Adrian Goldsworthy
And it's. It's, as I say, we serve right back at the start. That's why it's so hard to pin him down. It's so hard to free ourselves when we're looking at these events, from the knowledge that he's going to achieve all this, he's going to do so much and that others haven't done it. It is still spectacular by any standards when you look at it.
- [78:02]
Tristan Hughes
Gosh. And of course, the afterlife of Alexander himself, his physical body is also fascinating. Where is it now, how it ends up in Egypt, this amazing heist, and then ultimately, you know, disappearing several centuries later with early Christians in Alexandria. There's so much to his story, isn't there, Adrian? This has been so much fun. In four episodes, we've gone from the beginning to. To the end of Alexander's story, his narrative. How do you feel about it all now that we've done this, now that we talked through his life? I mean, what thoughts immediately come to mind when you say Alexander the Great? Now we talk through his whole story.
- [78:38]
Dr. Adrian Goldsworthy
It's hard, I mean, it's still hard to pin him down, to know who he really was. You could see what he did, but why he did it is harder and it's the frustration and you can understand why. I don't think there'll ever be a. A great film about Alexander the Great. The story is too big, the canvas is so vast and it's complicated. He packed an awful lot into that short time. You know, there's no, there's no surprise that you have the stories about Julius Caesar weeping when he sees a bust of Alexander the Great, because at his age, Alexander had conquered the world. Caesar's just a minor Roman magistrate at this point, but on the other hand, there's also smeny respects he's a hard man to like. You can admire aspects of him, you can deplore aspects of him, but he wouldn't have been easy to be around very much.
- [79:23]
Tristan Hughes
So, Adrian, I think we'll wrap it up there because you've given us so much of your time to be our guest for this entire series. Last but certainly not least, you have a book which covers the entirety of Alexander's story and of his father Philip,
- [79:38]
Dr. Adrian Goldsworthy
which is called Philip and Alexander, Kings and Conquerors in America. And I think it's something else in Britain, but Philip and Alexander is the main thing.
- [79:45]
Tristan Hughes
It just goes to me to say well done and thank you so much for coming on the podcast.
- [79:50]
Dr. Adrian Goldsworthy
Thanks. It's been lots of fun.
- [79:55]
Tristan Hughes
Well, there you go. There was Dr. Adrian Goldsworthy and I finishing off this special series on the life and legend of Alexander the Great. Thank you so much for listening. It was such a pleasure to record this series over four episodes and I really do hope you enjoyed. We may well do another series in the future. Maybe the follow up what happened after Alexander's death, the wars of the Successors, or perhaps something slightly different like Julius Caesar's invasion of Gaul or something else. Let us know your thoughts in the comments. Now, if you did enjoy this series, if you're enjoying the Ancients, please make sure that you are following the show on Spotify or wherever you get your podcasts. That does really help us and you'd be doing us a big favor. You'd be doing us an even bigger favor if you'd also be kind enough to leave us a rating as well. We'd really appreciate that. Don't forget, you can also sign up to History Hit for hundreds of hours of original documentaries, including quite a few ancient history documentaries hosted by myself with a new release on History Hit every week. Sign up at History Hit. Subscribe.
- [81:14]
Dr. Adrian Goldsworthy
Oh no.
- [81:14]
Tristan Hughes
My coffee.
- [81:16]
Dr. Adrian Goldsworthy
Bronnie here.
- [81:19]
Nissan Pathfinder Advertiser
New brawny 3 ply is now more absorbent.
- [81:21]
Dr. Adrian Goldsworthy
Wow. Got a clean shirt.
- [81:23]
Nissan Pathfinder Advertiser
Do you wear plaid? Some of the strongest. There's an SUV that turns the unthinkable into the unforgettable. The new Nissan Pathfinder. Built for big adventures and all that family chaos. It's powered by a strong V6 engine with a nine speed automatic transmission. Inside. It's rugged and capable, but still premium and tech forward with room for up to eight passengers. It's also available with seven passenger seating and second row captain's chairs with massive hauling capability. Now you can bring all the gear you and your family need for unforgettable Adventures. The new V6 Nissan Pathfinder. Power your adventure.