Podcast Summary: The Ancients – Episode on Atlantis

Title: Atlantis
Host: Tristan Hughes
Guest: Professor Edith Hall, Durham University
Release Date: January 5, 2025
Podcast: The Ancients by History Hit

Introduction

In the January 5, 2025 episode of The Ancients, host Tristan Hughes delves into the enigmatic tale of Atlantis, exploring its origins, cultural significance, and enduring legacy. Joining him is Professor Edith Hall from Durham University, an esteemed scholar in classical studies, who unpacks the historical and philosophical underpinnings of the Atlantis narrative as presented by Plato.

Origins of the Atlantis Story

Professor Hall elucidates that the story of Atlantis originates from Plato's dialogues, specifically the Timaeus and Critias, written in the early 4th century BCE. Contrary to popular belief, Atlantis is not a historical account but rather the first known work of historical fiction.

Edith Hall (07:02): “The story of Atlantis is incredibly important culturally... it’s the first ever work of historical fiction.”

Hall emphasizes that while Atlantis draws inspiration from real events like tsunamis and the apocalyptic destruction of civilizations, the narrative itself is a fictional construct designed to convey philosophical ideals.

Plato's Philosophical Motives

Plato introduced Atlantis in the aftermath of the Peloponnesian War, a time when Athens was grappling with its imperial decline. By crafting a tale of a utopian society that succumbed to decadence, Plato aimed to critique the very elements he believed led to Athens' downfall—particularly its naval supremacy and imperial overreach.

Edith Hall (24:16): “Plato is writing at a time when he’s very worried that Athens might become a thalassocracy again.”

Hall discusses how Plato juxtaposes the idealized ancient Athens (Kallipolis) with the decadent Atlantis to highlight the dangers of imperialism and moral decay.

Depiction of Atlantis

Atlantis, as described by Plato, is an opulent and advanced civilization founded by the god Poseidon. The city is characterized by its architectural grandeur, including concentric canals and elaborate temples adorned with jewels and murals.

Edith Hall (14:46): “Atlantis is run by despotic monarchs with full power... their moral downfall.”

Despite its initial prosperity, Atlantis's obsession with sea power and materialism leads to internal strife and eventual destruction by cataclysmic forces, rendering the city submerged beneath the waves.

Historical Context and Inspirations

Professor Hall draws parallels between Atlantis and contemporary civilizations like the Phoenicians and Persians, noting that Plato amalgamated various elements from these cultures to craft a composite image of decadence and imperial ambition.

Edith Hall (21:47): “The Atlanteans are a conglomerate of lots of different earlier civilizations.”

She underscores that Atlantis serves as a cautionary tale against the hubris of empires, reflecting Plato's apprehensions about Athenian naval dominance and its ethical implications.

Atlantis in Later Cultures

The narrative of Atlantis has transcended its original context, influencing Renaissance thinkers and becoming a staple in modern popular culture. Professor Hall highlights how the story was co-opted during European explorations and continues to inspire myths and media to this day.

Edith Hall (35:07): “Atlantis sort of underlies far more stories than those just about Atlantis.”

She notes the persistent allure of Atlantis in contemporary imagination, likening it to mythical creatures like Bigfoot or the Loch Ness Monster, symbolizing humanity's fascination with lost civilizations and apocalyptic destruction.

Critical Analysis and Modern Interpretations

Professor Hall critiques the literalist interpretations that emerged, especially during the Renaissance, where scholars and explorers sought to locate Atlantis geographically. She emphasizes that understanding Atlantis as a fictional narrative offers deeper insights into Plato's philosophical critiques rather than a quest for a historical utopia.

Edith Hall (39:22): “Most people want to believe it and they want to have the mystery just like they want to find Bigfoot or the Loch Ness Monster.”

Hall advocates for appreciating Atlantis within its intended allegorical framework, cautioning against conflating myth with historical fact.

Conclusion

The episode concludes with Tristan Hughes and Professor Edith Hall reflecting on the enduring legacy of Atlantis. They underscore its role as a foundational myth that continues to provoke thought about civilization, morality, and the consequences of imperial ambition.

Tristan Hughes (39:42): “Edith, you have explained brilliantly... thank you so much for taking the time to come the podcast today.”

Professor Hall reiterates the importance of critical scholarship in unraveling myths like Atlantis, encouraging listeners to view such stories through the lens of their philosophical and cultural contexts.

Notable Quotes

• Edith Hall (07:02): “The story of Atlantis is incredibly important culturally... it’s the first ever work of historical fiction.”

• Edith Hall (14:46): “Atlantis is run by despotic monarchs with full power... their moral downfall.”

• Edith Hall (21:47): “The Atlanteans are a conglomerate of lots of different earlier civilizations.”

• Edith Hall (35:07): “Atlantis sort of underlies far more stories than those just about Atlantis.”

• Edith Hall (39:22): “Most people want to believe it and they want to have the mystery just like they want to find Bigfoot or the Loch Ness Monster.”

Final Thoughts

This episode of The Ancients offers a comprehensive exploration of the Atlantis myth, debunking misconceptions and highlighting its significance as a philosophical allegory. Professor Edith Hall's expert analysis provides listeners with a nuanced understanding of how ancient narratives continue to shape contemporary thought and culture.

Subscribe to The Ancients on History Hit
For an ad-free experience and access to bonus episodes, subscribe at historyhit.com/subscribe.