The Athletic FC Podcast Summary Episode: Arsenal's New Sporting Director: Who Is in the Frame?
Release Date: March 3, 2025

Introduction

In this episode of The Athletic FC Podcast, host Phil Hay, alongside football correspondent David Ornstein and guest Ayo Akimolere, delves into Arsenal Football Club's pursuit of a new sporting director. The discussion explores the role's significance, the potential candidates under consideration, and the implications for Arsenal's ambitions to secure their first Premier League title.

Arsenal's Search for a Sporting Director

Phil Hay opens the conversation by highlighting the urgency of Arsenal finalizing their search for a sporting director within March. David Ornstein underscores the timing's critical nature, especially as Arsenal's performance this season hasn't met expectations in domestic competitions, though there remains optimism in the Champions League.

• Key Points:

  • Arsenal aims to conclude their sporting director search by the end of March.
  • The current season has underperformed in the Premier League and domestic cups.
  • The sporting director role encompasses transfer market activities, first team management, academy development, and oversight of the women's team.

• Notable Quote:

  Phil Hay ([02:38]): “...this is a massive appointment for Arsenal. It's huge in the context of their day-to-day operations, the immediate term, the medium term, and they'd like to think the longer term as well.”

The Role and Importance of a Sporting Director

Ayo Akimolere elaborates on the extensive responsibilities of a sporting director, emphasizing that the role extends far beyond player transfers to include succession planning, contractual negotiations, and overall managerial duties within the club.

• Key Points:

  • The sporting director is integral to both short-term and long-term club strategies.
  • Responsibilities include managing transfers, overseeing academy pathways, and integrating women's team operations.
  • The role is essential for maintaining the club's competitive edge and operational efficiency.

• Notable Quote:

  Ayo Akimolere ([06:23]): "It's succession planning for managers, for coaches, contractual matters. It's basically a managerial role in its own right these days, for sure."

Key Candidates Under Consideration

David Ornstein identifies several potential candidates Arsenal may be considering for the sporting director role, including current interim director Jason Ato, and external prospects like Dan Ashworth, Andrea Berta, Roberto Alabe, and Thiago Scuro.

a. Jason Ato

As the interim sporting director, Jason Ato has been managing the role following Edu's departure. His tenure has been under scrutiny, with discussions about his authority and impact.

• Notable Quote:

  David Ornstein ([33:13]): “...it's a little bit harsh to pin the lack of a striker signing on Jason Ato. He has been there for a long time and he's been influential and you could say it doesn't matter as soon as you get the opportunity and your feet under the table.”

b. Dan Ashworth

Formerly Manchester United's sporting director, Dan Ashworth's stint was met with mixed reviews. His experience spans roles at Brighton and Newcastle, making him a notable candidate despite previous challenges.

• Insights:
  • Ayo Akimolere expresses skepticism regarding Ashworth’s fit for Arsenal, citing his mixed track record.
  • Ashworth's time at Manchester United under Ineos was viewed as unsuccessful, raising questions about his suitability.

c. Andrea Berta

Andrea Berta, currently Atletico Madrid's sporting director, is recognized for his successful tenure in managing transfers and club structures. His relationship with manager Diego Simeone and experience in a top-tier Spanish club make him a strong contender.

• Insights:
  • Berta's competence and proven track record at Atletico Madrid position him as a favorable candidate.
  • His ability to adapt and lead within a competitive environment aligns with Arsenal's aspirations.

d. Roberto Alabe

Roberto Alabe from Real Sociedad brings valuable experience in managing transfers and academy operations. His existing connections with Arsenal, including facilitating player trades like Xabi Alonso's transfer to Zubamendi, enhance his suitability.

• Insights:

  • Alabe is considering stepping down in the summer, which may affect his availability.
  • His established rapport with Mikel Arteta could be advantageous for seamless integration.

• Notable Quote:

  David Ornstein ([38:54]): “...he's not looking to take anything until the summer at the very earliest...”

Impact on Arsenal's Strategy and Mikel Arteta

The prospective appointment of a new sporting director is pivotal to Mikel Arteta's strategic vision for Arsenal. The alignment between Arteta and the sporting director is essential for executing transfer strategies and maintaining club cohesion.

• Key Points:

  • The sporting director will be a key partner to Arteta, influencing transfer decisions and long-term planning.
  • Effective collaboration is necessary to enhance Arsenal's competitiveness in both domestic and European arenas.

• Notable Quote:

  David Ornstein ([18:15]): “...the sporting director may hold a key to your success as a manager, your career, your legacy.”

Challenges and Considerations

The podcast highlights several challenges Arsenal faces in appointing a sporting director, including ensuring the right fit within the club’s hierarchical structure and managing existing dynamics between ownership, the board, and managerial staff.

• Key Points:

  • The appointment process involves multiple stakeholders, including KSE Kroenke Sports Entertainment and key club directors.
  • Past examples, such as Leeds United’s sporting director challenges, serve as cautionary tales for Arsenal.
  • Balancing authority between the new sporting director and Mikel Arteta is crucial to avoid conflicts.

• Notable Quote:

  Ayo Akimolere ([25:31]): “...the sporting directors can no longer hover in the background... scrutiny on them was extremely intense.”

Conclusions and Future Outlook

As Arsenal navigates the appointment of a new sporting director, the club remains committed to enhancing its operational structure and competitive performance. The podcast concludes with reflections on the importance of selecting a candidate who aligns with Arsenal's values and long-term goals, emphasizing that the right choice will significantly influence the club's future success.

• Key Points:

  • Arsenal's commitment to finding a suitable sporting director reflects its ambition to reclaim Premier League glory.
  • The final decision will hinge on the candidate’s ability to integrate with the existing management and drive strategic initiatives.
  • Fans and analysts alike will be keenly watching the appointment to assess its impact on the club's trajectory.

• Notable Quote:

  David Ornstein ([28:04]): “...Arsenal will ultimately be doing a huge amount of work on just finding the right fit for them and their ambitions.”

Final Thoughts

The Athletic FC Podcast offers a comprehensive analysis of Arsenal's pursuit of a new sporting director, highlighting the role's critical importance, evaluating potential candidates, and considering the broader implications for the club's strategic direction. As Arsenal strives to enhance its operations and achieve top-tier success, the selection of a sporting director stands out as a pivotal element in realizing these ambitions.

For more insightful discussions and analyses, subscribe to The Athletic FC Podcast on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or your preferred podcast platform.