Summary of "Why can't Arsenal get over the line?" – The Athletic FC Podcast

Release Date: May 8, 2025
Host: Ayo Akimwaleere
Guests: Artur Rocher (Arsenal Writer), Liam Tharman (Tactics Writer), Phil Hay (Athletic FC Newsletter), Amy Lawrence (Arsenal Correspondent)

1. Introduction

In this episode of The Athletic FC Podcast, host Ayo Akimwaleere delves into Arsenal's persistent struggles to secure major trophies, particularly focusing on their recent exit from the UEFA Champions League semifinals. The discussion centers around identifying the underlying issues that prevent Arsenal from translating their potential and progress into tangible successes.

2. Arsenal's Exit from the Champions League

The podcast opens with a vivid recount of Arsenal's defeat against Paris Saint-Germain (PSG) at the Parc des Princes, marking the end of their European campaign. Reported by Jordan Campbell (03:11), the loss is characterized as another "bitter blow" adding to Arsenal's string of near-misses over the past two years.

Jordan Campbell (03:11):

"It's another very, very disappointing defeat to add to the semifinal against Newcastle in the EFL Cup and the close calls that they've had in the Premier League the last two years."

3. Missed Opportunities and Defensive Weaknesses

Phil Hay highlights specific moments in the PSG match where Arsenal squandered key chances, leading to their downfall. Notably, a crucial save by PSG's Gianluigi Donnarumma stifled Arsenal's momentum.

Phil Hay (04:14):

"Martinelli cross arc firing across the face and Donnarumma comes up big again."

The recurring theme of missed opportunities is emphasized as a symptom of broader performance issues throughout the season.

4. Impact of Injuries and Squad Depth

Liam Tharman discusses the significant impact injuries have had on Arsenal's season, citing key players like Odegaard, Saka, Jesus, Havertz, and Gabriel Martinelli. These setbacks have not only disrupted the team's chemistry but also strained their tactical flexibility.

Liam Tharman (05:27):

"It's been about the injuries that they've suffered throughout the campaign... I think it just seems like someone who is playing while they're not really in their groove and you're hoping that the summer's kind of a natural reset button for him."

5. Tactical Analysis: Arsenal vs. PSG

The panel compares Arsenal's tactical approach under Mikel Arteta with PSG's under Luis Enrique. Amy Lawrence provides insights into PSG's high-pressing and versatile gameplay, which contrasts with Arsenal's more rigid tactics.

Amy Lawrence (09:09):

"Luis Enrique's coached them into one of the best high pressing teams in Europe this season... They can play through teams, carve them apart."

Phil Hay adds that PSG's balanced midfield and clinical finishing have made them a formidable opponent, often overshadowing Arsenal's efforts.

6. The Quest for a Prolific Number Nine

A significant portion of the discussion revolves around Arsenal's desperate need for a reliable striker. Currently, Bukayo Saka shoulders much of the attacking responsibility, but his contracts are nearing their end, raising concerns about the club's ability to retain star talent.

Phil Hay (37:42):

"If you add a top class number nine to your squad, then you have someone who digs you out on nights where you need somebody to dig you out and sometimes that, that is necessary."

The absence of a dedicated goal-scorer has hindered Arsenal's ability to convert chances into goals, a critical factor in their recent performances.

7. Player Performance and Individual Issues

Owen Odegaard's form is scrutinized, with Phil Hay and Liam Tharman observing a decline in his on-field creativity and fluidity. Despite his high potential, Odegaard appears out of sync during crucial moments.

Liam Tharman (39:43):

"He ends up playing out wide to the left... someone who is playing while they're not really in their groove and you're hoping that the summer's kind of a natural reset button for him."

8. Comparison with PSG's Coaching Philosophy

The contrast between Mikel Arteta's methodical approach and Luis Enrique's dynamic strategies is a focal point. Phil Hay notes that while Enrique's PSG exudes creativity and risk-taking, Arteta's Arsenal remains more conservative, potentially limiting their adaptability in high-stakes matches.

Phil Hay (43:25):

"This is it though. If you add a top class number nine to your squad... it's not as if PSG have been flawless all season."

9. Future Prospects and Recommendations

The panel suggests that Arsenal must address their tactical rigidity, enhance squad depth, and secure a proven striker to elevate their chances in future competitions. Liam Tharman emphasizes the need for creativity in midfield and attacking positions to foster goal-scoring opportunities.

Liam Tharman (38:11):

"Creativity because that's what I was getting at before the break. Basically players who can create something out of nothing, that's not what Arsenal have enough of."

10. Conclusion

The episode concludes with a consensus that while Arsenal has made commendable progress under Arteta, translating that into silverware remains elusive. The forthcoming summer transfer window is pivotal for the club to reinforce their squad and finally "get over the line."

Phil Hay (43:39):

"Doesn’t mean he's doing a bad job. And the longer it goes on, the more, more contentious it's going to get."

Notable Quotes:

• Jordan Campbell (03:11)

  "Leaving Paris tonight wondering how many more times these players can pick themselves up off the ground."

• Phil Hay (04:14)

  "Martinelli cross arc firing across the face and Donnarumma comes up big again."

• Liam Tharman (05:27)

  "He's not really in flow as he was last season."

• Amy Lawrence (09:09)

  "Their first three shots... Fabian Maurice had the shot that went in with a slight deflection."

• Phil Hay (37:42)

  "They're structured in a different way, PSG, aren't they?"

This comprehensive discussion sheds light on the multifaceted challenges Arsenal faces in clinching major titles. From tactical shortcomings and injury woes to the dire need for a prolific striker, The Athletic FC Podcast provides an in-depth analysis of why Arsenal struggles to "get over the line." The insights offered by the panel underscore the critical areas that Arteta and the club must address to achieve sustained success.