Loading summary
Transcript189 lines
- [00:00]
Jennifer
Thy ticket lady Jennifer of Coolidge. Well, many thanks good sir. Here is my Discover card. They accept Discover at Renaissance fairs? Yeah, they do here. Discover is accepted at the places I love to shop. Get it with the times. With the times. You're playing the loot. Yeah, and it sounds pretty good, right?
- [00:23]
Dave
Discover is accepted at 99% of places that take credit cards nationwide. Based on the February 2025 Nielsen report.
- [00:30]
Boost Mobile Rep
Big news. Boost Mobile is now experts nationwide to deliver and set up customers new phones at home or work.
- [00:35]
Derek
Wait, we're going on tour?
- [00:37]
Boost Mobile Rep
Not a tour. We're delivering and setting up customers phones so it's easier to upgrade.
- [00:41]
Michael Beller
Let's get in the tour bus and hit the road.
- [00:43]
Boost Mobile Rep
No, not a tour bus. It's a regular car we use to deliver and set up customers phones at home or work.
- [00:47]
Robert Mayes
Are you a groupie on this tour?
- [00:49]
Boost Mobile Rep
We deliver and set up phones. It's not a tour.
- [00:51]
Derek
Oh, you're definitely a groupie.
- [00:53]
Boost Mobile Rep
Introducing store to door switch and get a new device with expert setup and delivery wherever you're at.
- [00:58]
Dave
Delivery available for select devices purchased@boostmobile.com if.
- [01:01]
Jennifer
Your skincare isn't working, you're probably skipping one essential gentle daily exfoliation Bare faced toning pads Remove dry dead skin cells so the rest of your routine can actually work. They help reduce clogged pores, improve tone and texture and leave skin looking smoother and clearer without irritation. One of These sells every three minutes. They have over 653,000 five star reviews and the results speak for themselves. If you want real results and a routine you'll actually stick to, start here, visit barefaced.com and use code SKIN15 for 15% off plus free shipping. Barefaced less steps, Better skin.
- [01:51]
Robert Mayes
Welcome to the Athletic Football Show. I'm Robert Mayes. It's the first mailbag of the off season. Always enjoy doing these. Sincerely appreciate everyone who took the time to send questions in. We will be doing them regularly. We may not have one next week because of the combine, but after that I plan on having them essentially weekly throughout the entire off season. We do that in part because you guys do such a great job with the questions. Today was no exception. Dave and Derek joined me to answer the questions like we did last year. Bell is going to be the one teeing them up. So we got a little four man weave going today. Really enjoyed this discussion. Hope you guys do as well. Let's get to it right now. We are back with the off season mailbags here on the Athletic Football Show. We did mailbag Monday last year. I'm not tying us to that because the off season schedule is a little bit in flux, but we will be doing regular mailbags. The plan is to have them weekly outside of certain exceptions, free agency week, combine next week, all of that kind of stuff. But we're going to be doing these throughout the entire off season as this is is the first one. As always, sincerely appreciate everyone who spent the time to send in questions. We got a bunch of them. A reminder, I said this on the Friday show. Just worth throwing out Again, we are going to be pulling questions from Discord the entire off season and we're going to be pulling at least half of them from the Discord. So if you have not signed up for the Discord, now is the time to do that. The link is in the show description below. Encourage you guys to get in there. It is going at all times. I mean we've got people talking about off season stuff, trades, coaching cycle. There are channels now for food and restaurants and movies and we're bouncing around in there. It's been a great community in season one of doing it. And so now if you have not signed up or not dug into that, now would be a good time because we will be pulling a decent amount of the questions from the Discord throughout the entire off season. Reprising his role as the reader of the mailbag questions because he did such a fantastic job last year. It is our old buddy and super producer Michael Beller. Beller, thank you for doing this.
- [04:03]
Michael Beller
I am great at reading. You know, I learned how to do it. I never forgot how to do it. And so I'm.
- [04:10]
Dave
You got the baritone for it too. Like you've just got a great like omniscient narrator voice.
- [04:16]
Michael Beller
Well, thank you, Dave. I'm happy to be able to do this with you. Now last year it was just Robert and Derek. Now we've got you in the fold. So four voices on the athletic football show Mailbags. And let's get into it right now with one of those questions from from Discord. This comes to us from K. Liang, Seattle. So I assume congratulations are in order for K. Liang. K says, among the league's worst teams, who has the best chance for a one year turnaround to be the next Patriots? Robert, get us started on this one.
- [04:44]
Robert Mayes
I mean the easy answer is the Titans, right? Even if I don't really believe it, I think the easy answer is probably the Titans. We have a year two quarterback next year that at least showed some flashes in year one. Even if the Overall numbers were terrible. I do think they have some pieces along the offensive line. Obviously last year started off pretty rocky with J.C. latham being hurt. Dan Moore played terrible at the start of the season. I think things did gel a little bit better in the second half. This is a team that has a ton of money to spend. Like the idea of dropping Alec Pierce onto this team. They're drafting in the top five. There are edge rushers available in the top five. That's exactly what they need. Like you could talk me into the Titans being a wild card team next year. Even though I want to just put on the record right now there is a 0% chance I'm picking the Titans to make the playoffs next year. Zero.
- [05:32]
Derek
Do that again.
- [05:33]
Robert Mayes
Zero percent. But I do think they are the best among all of these teams to potentially do something like that.
- [05:39]
Derek
Yeah. Cause obviously the easy like pick is like okay, which of the young quarterbacks on these terrible teams do do I believe in? And I do believe in Cam Warden. I do think that he could have a turnaround like that where you know, maybe MVP level is a stretch but he could play like he could suddenly jump up into the top third of the league. And I don't think that they would be that crazy. I think the other one is like there's a world where you could have got me there on the Giants before they assembled the offensive staff. Now that it is what it is, I'm not sure I can get quite as excited to that level even if I do have some excitement about the defensive staff and Harbaugh's overall like push over that organization. And then the other one, like I think they ended the season too well to really count for this. But like the Saints are mildly interesting to me.
- [06:25]
Robert Mayes
They still count. They still count. They were a last place in their.
- [06:29]
Derek
Division and because that's the thing, like if we're going again, I don't think shucks ceiling is even as high as Cam Ward's but it's like he could play like a top half quarterback next year. I think the offensive line has some pieces and the defense even if old and losing a piece potentially in like a Longe Taylor, they were pretty good last year, especially down the stretch. Like there's a world that like one or two additions maybe shuck takes a step like they could win 10 games and be like a reasonably interesting team.
- [06:56]
Dave
I think those are all of the most obvious answers and I like how Robert is going the exact opposite direction of me. Whereas I'll just triple down and I am tripling down on the Titans because when they did the Will Levis thing I was like ah, surround your quarterback with talent. Figure out if he's any good. Okay. That didn't work. So you get the number one pick. Oh they he's Cam Ward. He's awesome. And they've added players around him. They thanks to Ran Carthon he's got a better supporting cast and it did not look like that freaking at all. And I'm here to tell you that I'll sign up one more time. I will sign up one more time with the Tennessee Titans. I love Cam. I don't care what the stats say. I'm sky high on what he could be not he is not yet. I know he's got a long way to go, but this team has $93 million in effective cap space for the amount of dumb things that they've done. They're not like beholden to all of these terrible contracts like the Dan Moore contract they're kind of stuck with. But you could get away from Calvin Ridley and Legerious Snead if you want to. Like you're not stuck with all these albatrosses around your neck. And you add that with the draft capital that they have. We just watched Robert Salah make a beautiful chicken salad sandwich out of some bad parts in San Francisco by the end of that season. So the play caller on defense, whatever you think of Brian D. I think it's fair to say he can at least raise the floor there. And yeah, give him $100 million to spend in free agency. I'm absolutely in on the Titans. I do like the Saints shout though. Derek. I think that's, that's worth bringing up the.
- [08:34]
Robert Mayes
A hundred million dollars is important because without looking combined, how much cap space do you think the Giants and the Saints have?
- [08:43]
Dave
Shockingly little. The giants have like $10 million in.
- [08:46]
Robert Mayes
Cap space between them. It's zero because the Saints are probably over and The Giants are $6 million under. And so you were looking at negative 6, 6 and 100 million for the Titans. And I know that spending $100 million in free agency typically is not good. It's not a good practice. But we just saw the Patriots spend hundreds of millions of dollars in free agency and then go to the Super Bowl. We don't have to relitigate all of the reasons that they went to the super bowl. But to figure out the team that can have that one year boost. I think all the money that the Titans have to throw around probably makes them the best candidate.
- [09:23]
Derek
Yeah. Cause Saint Sign might be a year early because I think in 2027 they have a lot more cap space and.
- [09:28]
Robert Mayes
Are like, they have a blank team. It's in 2027 is they have no players this year.
- [09:34]
Derek
They're still over somehow.
- [09:35]
Dave
Can I, can I paint a picture for y'?
- [09:37]
Jennifer
All?
- [09:38]
Dave
It's, it's, it's April 27th or whatever night, day one of the draft is and the New Orleans Saints draft Jeremiah Love and they just get killed by all of us nerds.
- [09:53]
Robert Mayes
Like, what are you doing?
- [09:54]
Dave
You're in the top 10. There's so many other things you could do. You don't need a running back. And then Jeremiah Love turns their offense into a juggernaut behind a very underrated offensive line. And Tyler Schuck in year two. I like, I can picture this and get pretty excited about it.
- [10:12]
Robert Mayes
I think the argument for against the Raiders doing it is that they needed offensive lineman. The Saints need interior offensive lineman, but they have two tackles. I mean, so. And that's what you would typically draft in the top 10. And so we're projecting this out way further than we need to right now. I don't need to already be deciding whether Jeremiah Love is a good pick for the Saints at 8. I'm just saying it is slightly different than what the Raiders did last year. I'm.
- [10:34]
Dave
I'm just getting reckless. And yeah, I mean, Eric McCoy struggled with injury the last couple years, but if he's healthy and part of this thing, you could really, you could be cooking with some gas, which I don't think most people think of the Saints that way right now.
- [10:48]
Robert Mayes
All right, Bo, let's get to the next one.
- [10:49]
Michael Beller
All right. Well, Dave, you take us to a question from Tom. Ski hill. Appropriate name with the Olympics going on. Tom says Big nickel is like what you guys said about elite running backs last year. They can be gasoline, but the fire already has to be lit using this framework. Which teams do you think are ready for that kind of player? I think everyone agrees the Raiders weren't ready for genty and the jets don't have much use for a breeze hall in their current state. Obviously this is a bit scheme dependent, but which defenses are a big nickel away from catching fire? Derek, we're going to go to you first on this one.
- [11:19]
Derek
I think this is an extremely overplayed talking point. I don't really think that there are hardly any defenses where I think that this matters. The only one I could really look at because it's partly a structural thing.
- [11:29]
Robert Mayes
Right?
- [11:29]
Derek
Like not every defense even wants this. And so I was trying to look at defenses are like, okay, who tries to play this way and who doesn't have one? It's kind of just Jacksonville, I think that really like wants to play this way, already had a pretty good defense and might be able to supercharge it. If they had something akin to Derwin James, Emin Worre, Kyle Hamilton, like a player of that mold, I think that they could do it. I also think the reason this is like a little bit overplayed is like, listen, the Emin worry stuff is cool, but he was like the 9th most useful player on the defense. And so I just, it feels like an easy talking point that I feel like is a little bit missing the point of why the Seahawks were even good.
- [12:08]
Robert Mayes
I don't disagree with that in terms of how important he was. And overall, like what having a player like this does. I still think that there are a couple defenses out there where it's like, all right, if they had a guy where they could just play a nickel all the time and then you look at the rest of their defense like the team that immediately comes to mind because I really like their outside corners already and I actually do think they have a couple pieces at safety. And I mean, I guess he does play a little bit closer to the box, but if you wanted to make him a more traditional safety, like if the Panthers had a player like this, I'd be like, okay, you could get.
- [12:41]
Derek
Me on the Panthers. Yeah, that's good.
- [12:42]
Robert Mayes
The defense suddenly becomes like, because you know right now you've got Smith, Chow, Wade in there and it's like if they had like a big nickel player where. All right, maybe this mitigates some of the questions you have at linebacker. Like it's a very like thin needle to thread here. But looking at just the depth charts at that position, that was the first team that came to mind again. Cause I already like the outside corners.
- [13:04]
Dave
You can tell I'm draft pilled because I do building the beast. But I, I think about a lot of this in terms of who coming out in this draft and I'm already seeing the existential battle of wills that's going on among several fan bases about Caleb Downs. And let's, let's be really clear, like Caleb Downs and Nick Iman worry are not like that similar of players. It's Certainly not a one to one comp like Caleb Downs gives up two or three inches and like 25 pounds to nick him and worry. So I think you're making a mistake just Thinking of them as the same guy, but in terms of a safety who can just be on the field at all times and strengthen the spine of your defense and be useful in a variety of ways. You look at the teams picking at the top of the draft, and I do think Caleb Downs could make a hell of a lot of difference for the New York Giants, who, like, don't look like this, you know, like, even with all the talent that they have, the defensive results have been lacking. But you have all the talent you could possibly want on the front. You have maybe not like the best corners in the league, but I'm encouraged by what the Giants have at cornerback. Between Paulson Adibo, what you saw from Drew Phillips this year, I would even throw in Cordell Flot and then obviously Javon Holland. So I don't think they're that far away from being a much better defense. We all love Denard Wilson and all the fun shit that he loves to do. I just think a player like that at who is good at everything. I mean, he's a plus run defender. He is good in coverage. You can move him around. He's not Nick and worry, but he is such a versatile player. I think there are going to be a lot of people saying, oh, you want to take a safety in the top five? And my reaction to that would be, yes, yes, I do. I think Caleb Downs would unlock a lot of cool shit for the Giants and several other teams, but they were one of the first teams that came to my mind.
- [15:09]
Robert Mayes
I want to say this about the Nicki Minwari thing. It he doesn't have to look like Nika Nick, Iman Warri for this to work, right? Like the idea that the inches and the pounds, like the two guys who were doing this last year before we even know who Nick amanwari was, were J1 Petrie and Cooper de Jean, both of whom are like 6 foot or shorter and 200 pounds. Like, you don't need to be 6, 3, 2, 20 to allow your team to play nickel to everything. There are other body types as long as you clear certain bars and play a certain way that allows your team to play like this. And so I don't think we have to necessarily pin it to somebody with an Emanwari type physical profile to fit this role within your defense. Even though him and Kyle Hamilton are probably the two most visible examples of this and the best possible version of it, but it doesn't have to be the best possible version to be viable. All right, Bella, let's get to the Next one.
- [16:02]
Michael Beller
All right, Reagan comes to us with this one. Reagan says, in back to back years, the Seahawks and the Eagles have shown a team that has an elite defense, stud wide receiver and good offensive line can win a Super bowl despite having a less than elite quarterback. Are these the exceptions that prove the rule or is this a signal of a shifting paradigm as schemes evolve and preferred body types. Body types, excuse me, change. If so, what does this mean for teams that have sold everything to obtain or retain the services of an elite quarterback? Dave, you take this one first.
- [16:31]
Dave
I mean, I think this is an example of not wanting to completely overreact to what we've seen most recently. Like, yes, I think it's. It's really great that Philly and. And even less so Philly, Seattle in particular. Like, you can build a really great team around a good quarterback, like a top 15 quarterback. And I say less so Philly just because Philly had such a ridiculous roster. I mean, they had all pros at like eight different positions. And while Seattle's roster was really, really deep, I don't think it had quite as much star power. Having said all of that nice stuff about those two teams, we still went through a stretch where Patrick Mahomes dragged the Chiefs to three consecutive Super Bowls. The Josh Allen Bills and the Baltimore Ravens, with the exception of this year, have been in the mix every single season and have been a handful of plays away reaching the Super Bowl. So I'm not ready to throw that aside. Like, at the end of the day, I'd still rather have it. I like, I'd rather have a top five quarterback than the alternative because I just think it gives you. There's less variables, there's less things that can go wrong. As long as you have the quarterback available, you will probably be a viable team. I think ideally that's the way you want to do it. It's just, it is a breath of fresh air from somebody who loves the league and talks about the league that we are seeing examples that you can do this another way. Because for so long we were fixated on like, good is the enemy of great. Throw out your 12th overall quarterback because he's not good enough to get you to a championship. It's nice to get away from that viewpoint and understand that there are different ways to do this. But all things being equal, I'd still rather have that elite quarterback if I had the choice.
- [18:28]
Robert Mayes
I'm going the other way on this.
- [18:30]
Dave
Really.
- [18:30]
Robert Mayes
We were. I don't think that that's wrong. I just think this is like the astronaut meme. Like it's always been like this, like the quarterbacks winning the Super Bowls that you've paid all this money for. That was the outlier over the last 20 years. Remember all the conversations that we were having in the last three or four years about how you can only spend a certain percentage of your cap at quarterback and build the championship worthy team? Like if you look back on it, I think the number was like 12 and a half percent, where if you spent more than 12 and a half percent of the cap on a quarterback, it was going to be really hard to win a championship. And then Mahomes won two in a row, way above that number. But he was the one that wasn't like the others. I mean, there was a stretch for a very long time where a lot of teams were winning these championships with relatively cheap kind of top 12ish quarterbacks. And that was actually the norm. And so I think a return to that line of thinking actually brings us into what the league looked like for most of the last 15 years.
- [19:28]
Derek
I think I kind of agree with that actually. Like the Mahomes stuff is like, that is the aberration. And then even within that relative time period you got like the end of Brady winning it with like not really an offensive centric team anyway. Like it was kind of just like Tom Brady being able to beat the Rams and obviously their defense played really well. And then Brady goes and lands on a Bucks team that was already really good and had a really good defense. And so I do kind of think that it is like having a full team, having guys at the other 21 positions is really important. It's like, I think to me, the teams that have the elite quarterbacks, those are the rule breakers. We just have to understand that like there will always be three or four teams in the NFL that always have one of those guys and will always be in the discussion, but those teams winning it is the rule breaker.
- [20:17]
Dave
Don't you? Do you think this is an example of the end result coloring perception? Because I mean, and I tend to.
- [20:25]
Robert Mayes
Agree with what Dave is saying.
- [20:26]
Dave
Yes, the goal is to win the championship, but if I were to go back and look at the bracket every year, you can count on and look, I know like the packers famously fell short so many times after 2010, but when Rogers was available, they were the shit. Like you could just pencil them into the bracket every single year. You could say the same thing about New England. Obviously you've been able to say that about the Chiefs up until this year. With Mahomes, the Bills haven't gotten it done. But there's a certain level of comfort in just knowing that you can write them into the bracket. And so I understand that the goal is to win the championship, but goofy stuff happens in the playoffs. And like I said, I just think I have. I think having the quarterback lessens the number of other variables. And maybe you get six bites at the apple and you don't ever come away with a trophy. And that really sucks. But I'll take my chances with that stabilizer at quarterback again if, if I have the choice. And that's the cool thing though is like teams like Philly and Seattle don't get hung up on the fact that you don't have that guy. You can build a champion without him. But if I had the choice between the two, it just feels easier to team build if you can count on that.
- [21:40]
Robert Mayes
I think that's right. If I were, if I, if I could choose having a top, whatever number it is, the numbers of the quarterbacks is already trying not to leave somebody. It's February 12th. If I have one of like the MVP caliber quarterbacks, a top four to five guy, whatever the club you want to include, all that shit. But if I had one of those guys, right, I think that is the way I would typically go. Cause I think that's your best chance to be like in the Final Four every single year. And I think that the end result of all of this skews it in a couple of different ways. One, if you look back at the last 10 Super Bowls, how many of them were Tom Brady and Patrick Mahomes? And two, the cap percentage thing is completely skewed by the fact that Tom Brady never made as much as Tom Brady could. These teams were still driven by elite quarterback play. And so I agree with you, Dave. I do think the end result is skewing this a little bit. But I think the point you made is exactly right. You can do it another way. That's exactly what this is a lesson of. You can get there in another way. It doesn't have to be the elite quarterback path that takes you to this moment.
- [22:43]
Dave
It's very nice to put to bed that talking point because there are people every year that's like. And again, it doesn't have to be a specific quarterback. There are a dozen of them where it's like, he's not the guy, he can't do it. Like, you just got to start over. You got to draft somebody new. And it's like, no, with all Due respect to Jalen Hurts and Sam Darnold, like, you can build a champion around those guys and they are not elite quarterbacks. They never have been. Regardless of however we want to talk about this. And like, I think that's very encouraging. It's like you're not, you're not dreaming big enough if you think swapping out the quarterback is the only way to fix this thing.
- [23:22]
Robert Mayes
I have a hot take that I want to follow that up with. It is very funny to me that we spent all of last off season and when I say we, I mean a lot of other people debating about whether Jalen Hurts was a top five quarterback because he won the Super Bowl. Sam Darnold was better than Jalen Hurts in this playoff run that the Seahawks just had. That conversation isn't even going to begin about Sam Darnold. And I think that's correct. But I just think it's so funny that Sam Darnold was better in these playoffs than Jalen Hurts was last year. And I don't think anybody's gonna be beaten down the door to try to argue that Sam Darnold is a top five quarter.
- [23:59]
Derek
Which like is funny too because I feel like that is obviously that is some element of like Sam Darnold had been cast away entirely early in his career. But I think also another part of that is like people saw what the Vikings, how the Vikings thing ended and how he just got blown up in the playoffs and all that stuff. We had seen Jalen Hurts get blown up in the playoffs by Todd Bowles multiple times before he ended up winning this Super Bowl. So like, it's just funny that we're doing it this way.
- [24:22]
Dave
I mean, Jalen Hurts played two mid to bad games in last year's playoffs. He just, he played his. I will give him the credit of saying he was better as the games got bigger. He was excellent against the commanders and obviously he was fantastic in the Super Bowl. So I think that factors into it. But I will say this, Robert, this is just the nature of things. If Darnold hits JSN on that, on that deep ball out of his own end zone early in the game and it's like an 86 yard touchdown, we might be having a very different conversation, even if it's just like a one throw difference.
- [24:57]
Robert Mayes
That's what's so funny to me though is that for Hertz last year, the Rams game ceased to matter by the time we got to the Super Bowl. And for Darnold, the NFC championship game ceases to matter because it happened two weeks earlier. It just never happened.
- [25:12]
Dave
They're, they're both good football players and maybe we can just leave it at that.
- [25:17]
Robert Mayes
We can't though. I pro. I promise you, we can't just leave it at that. All right, let's take our first quick break and then come back and hit some more of these.
- [25:26]
Michael Beller
Dinner time, huh? It's an eternal struggle. On the one hand, you don't want to sacrifice flavor and health. On the other hand, you don't want to necessarily give up all your time preparing a perfect meal for you and your family. As for Butcherbox can really help you. ButcherBox delivers over 100 premium protein options straight to your door, including 100% grass fed beef, free range, organic chicken, crate free pork and wild caught seafood. For more than a decade, Butcherbox has led the industry with meat and seafood that's antibiotic free, hormone free and independently verified. It's the clean, trustworthy protein you want to be eating, especially at the start of a new year. Every product meets the same rigorous standards. Whether you're cooking a filet mignon or popping chicken nuggets into the air fryer. It's all quality across the board. Look for me, I've got two kids, so it's pretty easy to pick the chicken nuggets. It makes things easy and makes dinner time very simple to prepare for. Simple to get on the table if we maybe forget that we need to get dinner on the table until it's a little bit later than we would like it to be. And you know what? Pretty good for me and my wife too. Not gonna lie about that. Those chicken nuggets really satisfy the entire family. As a certified B Corp. Butcherbox is committed to doing things right from how the animals are raised to how their team supports workers and reduces environmental impact. Plus, every box ships free always and members get access to recipe inspo tips, tips and exclusive deals that make every meal easier, healthier and more enjoyable. As an exclusive offer, new listeners can get their choice between organic ground beef, chicken breast or ground turkey in every box for a year, plus $20 off when you go to butcherbox.com athleticfootball that's right, your choice of organic ground beef, chicken breast or ground turkey in every box for an entire year plus $20 off your first box and free shipping always. That's ButcherBox.com AthleticFootball don't forget to use our link so they know we sent you. A well built wardrobe is about pieces that work together and hold up over time. That's what Quince does best premium materials, thoughtful design, and everyday staples that feel easy to wear, easy to rely on even as the weather shifts. Quince has the everyday essentials I love with quality that lasts. I've talked about this a few times. If you've been listening to our show all season long, you've heard me talk about it. The shacket, the jeans, they're both great in cold weather. In warm weather too, it's coming for us. But in cold weather, they're both great. They've also got organic cotton sweaters, polos for every occasion, and lighter jackets that will keep you warm in changing seasons. Quince works directly with top factories and cuts out the middlemen. So you're not paying for brand markup, just quality clothing. Everything is built to hold up to daily wear and still look good season after season. Plus, they only partner with factories and they meet rigorous standards for craftsmanship and ethical production. Refresh your wardrobe with quince. Go to quince.com athleticfootball for free shipping on your order and 365 day returns. Now available in Canada too. That's Q U-N-C-E.com Athletic Football free shipping and 365 day returns. Quince.com Athletic Football.
- [28:24]
Robert Mayes
Oh, could this vintage store be any cuter?
- [28:26]
Jennifer
Right. And the best part? They accept Discover.
- [28:29]
Robert Mayes
Except Discover in a little place like this?
- [28:32]
Jennifer
I don't think so.
- [28:33]
Robert Mayes
Jennifer.
- [28:33]
Jennifer
Oh yeah, huh? Discover's accepted where I like to shop. Come on, baby, get with the times.
- [28:39]
Robert Mayes
Right.
- [28:40]
Derek
So we shouldn't get the parachute pants.
- [28:42]
Jennifer
These are making a comeback, I think.
- [28:46]
Dave
Discover is accepted at 99% of places that take credit cards nationwide. Based on the February 2025 Nielsen report.
- [28:58]
Robert Mayes
All right, Ballard, what's the next one?
- [29:01]
Michael Beller
Okay, the next one comes to us from Brent. Brent says if the new defensive meta is the Seahawks and Mike McDonald's scheme, what offensive conse and player types are best suited to attack it? Let's go to you, Robert.
- [29:14]
Robert Mayes
There are multiple layers to this answer. The first layer is the Seahawks is the defensive meta is not something that you should try to replicate. It's not replicable like the amount of talent that they have and that talent allowing them to play a certain way. You can take the playbook from Seattle and drop it wherever you want. I don't think you're going to have the same type of results. So that that's the first step of this and I think we should start getting ahead of that as often as possible. Like playing with the structures they do on early downs and being the best run Defense in the NFL, while playing that way should be impossible. It's a product of the players. And so I do think that is going to be really, really hard to take from one stop to the other. That being said, let's just say hypothetically here we do get to a place where there are other teams that can play nickel to everything, still be a good run defense, be this really zone based team, not have to blitz a lot to get home. What are the ways that you can beat this? The first thing I would say, this is a team that wants to play with light bodies. So can you be. And essentially the answer here in as many words is just do all the stuff that Rams do. Okay, so can team that can put a ton of heavy bodies on the field. They're going to match you with light bodies and you can run the ball efficiently because you have a size advantage. If you look at what the Rams are able to do on some of those 13 personnel runs, they're not ripping off huge gains, but they were able to move the ball efficiently on the ground, especially in the NFC Championship Game in ways a lot of other teams weren't this season because they were willing to play in personnel groupings that other teams can't access. So I think that's part of it. And the other part of it goes back to something that Derek did a great job of pointing out this year, about how Stafford is kind of uniquely positioned to go after the Seahawks as a quarterback. And it's that clip from all the stuff that came out after the game where Julian Love is talking about Drake May and how Drake May as a young quarterback. This isn't even like a ding on Drake May. He needs to see stuff and get back to stuff and see it before he's willing to make some of these throws. Stafford creates his own windows within the defense, especially against zone heavy teams because of the way he plays the position. And so trying to steal as many aspects of what the Rams are when it comes to how they run the ball, the outside receiver talent that they have, because ultimately you're always going to be able to create one on ones on the outside, just no matter what coverage is other teams are playing against. And so if you can really dominate those matchups in the way the Rams are able to, combined with having a quarterback who is able to create his own windows within the defense because of how he plays the Latin. The last point I'll make about this, this to me actually I'm like workshopping this, but I think it's right. The Seahawks and the way that they play and how well coached that they are and the fact that you really. Those windows can't. You have to create those windows against them. One of the reasons I think they're so dominant and we're so dominant this year is that we live and exist in a league with only young quarterbacks now. So as quarterbacks get a little bit more advanced and get to a level that Matthew Stafford exists at in their mid-30s, where you have that mental side of it down to the degree that he has, not all of them are going to have his physical tools. But I do think that the league right now with the makeup of the quarterback position is at a unique disadvantage for taking advantage of some of these defenses because some of these guys and most of these guys are so young.
- [32:37]
Derek
And this is also why I listen the Patriots deserved to have gotten to the super bowl, all that stuff. I really wish we could have seen the Bills against this Seahawks defense because I think that they were actually kind of uniquely set up to potentially beat them. One, because you have a veteran quarterback who is insanely talented. The way that like just in terms of pure arm talent, the way that Matthew Stafford is. I think Matthew Stafford is even a little bit more cerebral than Josh Allen is. And that's no knock on Allen. He's obviously incredibly smart. 10 years older.
- [33:05]
Robert Mayes
He's been in league for 10 more years.
- [33:07]
Derek
Exactly. He's been doing. He's been running this show for a long also. He gets to see them multiple times a year in a way that Josh Allen obviously does not. So there's even that element of it. But like the Bills run game, both in terms of like the offensive line talent, them getting two and three tight ends on the field, they have a fullback. Like their run game in theory would have actually been set up to do all the stuff that you were talking about. And then yeah, again, like Josh Allen was talented enough to go do all that stuff. And also the other small element of, to me of this, to me is part of the question was what are the types of players. And I actually do thinking having like a very dynamic running back and a guy who can potentially make people miss underneath could be like a small way to deal with this because like they are a defense that is not really going to give you those windows intermediate. And even if you're trying to throw deep and I do think that you can scheme up their coverage deep, like a lot of double post concepts, scissors stuff where you're getting those, you know, the half or the quarter safety in the corner to kind of, you know, ruin their coverage a little bit. You can get them that way. The problem with that stuff is like it often requires drop back and you're probably not going to be able to protect against this front. And so that's the issue. And so I do think that like checking down is like kind of a way to deal with this team. It's just that there are very few running backs who I think can consistently make this particular set of players miss that many tackles.
- [34:24]
Dave
You just gave me the worst visions of half of Josh's drop backs in a hypothetical super bowl just being 8 second fire drills because the Seahawks are stuffing his receivers in lockers and he's got to try to make something happen. My, the way I looked at this, I'm curious for Yalls thoughts because y' all are, y' all are scheme heads on another level from me, but like if the question was if you're like if you're trying to build an offense to give the Seahawks fits and I know, I think that's overstated in today's NFL, but I think the place that I would start is just being big and efficient in the run game. Do you agree with that? Like Robert, you kind of alluded to that. I like it. I think that's where I would start is like we need big bodies on the field, we need multiple tight ends that are plus blockers and we need to be able to run effectively against these guys no matter what.
- [35:20]
Robert Mayes
I think that's right. And the Rams. Matthew Stafford was the mvp. The Rams had the most efficient running back ground game by success rate in the last like decade in the NFL. Like, that was a huge part of what made the Rams the Rams. And they did a lot of it with one of the heaviest personnel groupings you can throw on the field.
- [35:38]
Derek
Yeah, I think that that is absolutely the way that you want to do it. Like if their whole thing is going to be we're going to stay in nickel and we're going to dictate to you. You don't get to do this. You kind of have to get big and say you and run the ball all over them. And it's hard to do obviously, but I do think that has to be the way to do it. Exactly. Most teams cannot do it and you.
- [35:57]
Robert Mayes
Look at the numbers. I was kind of shocked by this, looking at some of the next gen numbers by the end of the season because I don't know the exact percentages on it, but we saw more jumbo this year than at any point Since I started covering the leak, a lot, a lot of teams went to it. The Patriots were an example of that. The Patriots used it like 19% of the times in the playoffs. But if you look at the run game efficiency out of a lot of those jumbo looks, it's actually pretty bad. And I think some of the reason for that might be that most teams are matching that with base personnel and so throwing out of those looks is actually more efficient. But there are not a lot of teams this year, I think in part because of how defense has matched it, that when they went jumbo they were just grinding teams to dust on the ground. That that just didn't happen.
- [36:40]
Derek
Them or, or in some of them were just like not good run games and offensive lines to begin with. And it was a band like I think the Texans, the Jaguars were like this where they were, you know, when they had their offensive line and they were putting Cole Van Landen out there as a six guy and it's like, well, they're doing that because like Brenton Strange was hurt and they didn't have any other way to run the ball at all.
- [36:58]
Robert Mayes
Yes, I think that's, that's. And I also think that the tight ends part of it, the teams that have the tight ends to do this are the teams that went away from jumbo. The Rams didn't use any jumbo. The Bills didn't use a lot of jumbo this year. And so I'll be curious what that looks like. How many teams seek out that, that honestly that to me where we say like the Nick Gaming worry thing is a fool's errand because there are only so many Nick Emen worries. I think there are more Jackson Hawses in the world than there are Nicki Min worries. And I think that seeking out that skill set and what that can give your offense, like do we see a half around bump for guys that are specifically blocking tight ends because of where the league is going? I actually think that's more interesting.
- [37:40]
Dave
Dane had a good bit on Building the Beast last week about how pretty much every tight end drafted this year should kick a percentage to Jackson Hawes for bumping his draft stock.
- [37:50]
Derek
I love that on we're recording this on February 12th and Robert is like we need more Josh Olivers and Tip Ryman's and Jackson Hawes is. And he's completely correct. I think that is the way the teams need to think about it.
- [38:02]
Robert Mayes
Let's go.
- [38:04]
Dave
If you ever talk to football coaches, it's hilarious. Like that's the type of shit they key on. Like you want to talk about all the sexy players and they're like, no. Who allows me to like run the personnel packages I want to without exposing myself? Like that's, that's everything.
- [38:20]
Robert Mayes
You I with zero irony. When I left Cowboys training camp last year, one of my first thoughts is we should see more Brevin span forward snaps this year for Dallas and we what's the next one?
- [38:35]
Michael Beller
Brent Craswell asked us a question. What are the wrong lessons that bad teams are going to take from the 2025 Seahawks? I think with what we just talked here in the first question that we've hit that a little bit. So great question, Brent, but we're going to move on to our next one. This one comes to us.
- [38:49]
Robert Mayes
I'll answer this very quickly. I'll answer this very quickly because I have a sustain. I have a succinct and specific example. There are going to be too many teams that become the 2022 Chargers version of the 2025 Seahawks where it's like, all right, all of these structural ideas are really good and then they're going to put the wrong players in there and the whole thing is going to collapse like a house of cards. That's it. That's my answer.
- [39:13]
Derek
They're going to do it with the 24th best D line instead of whatever the Seahawks had.
- [39:17]
Robert Mayes
The first buy a mile and the best one I've seen in a really long time. All right, we can get.
- [39:25]
Michael Beller
Let's do it. Here's the next one. This one is from Gaming Antler, so you can see we're taking plenty of questions from Discord. Gaming Antler says what's the deal? Seinfeld voice with centers being paid less than guards, centers handle a lot but seem undervalued. I think of Tyler Linderbaum not getting his option picked up and spot track valuing valuable him at less than 18 million in average annual value. Derek, what do you got on this one?
- [39:49]
Derek
So I think there are a couple different directions to go and I would say I would start with right or wrong. The positions that are harder to find in the draft also tend to get paid less outside of quarterback, obviously, because the value is just insane for having a very good quarterback. But like I'm thinking of like linebackers typically get paid in less than other positions. Safeties are paid less than their their counterparts at cornerback and stuff like that. Like these positions that can be a little bit more cerebral, like center can be harder to find in the draft, end up being paid a little Bit less. And so I think that.
- [40:18]
Robert Mayes
Easier to find in the draft. Easier to find in the draft.
- [40:21]
Derek
Right? Yeah, sorry.
- [40:22]
Robert Mayes
Yeah, yeah.
- [40:22]
Derek
And I, I think the other element of this to me would be that like centers, they're obviously incredibly talented players, they are less physically gifted than guards and tackles. Like there is an element of like there are just more guards and tackles who can really be force of nature type of like moving people in the run game, really holding one on ones in pass pro and stuff like that. There's really just not that many centers who have that kind of value. And then I think like going beyond that like because the value so much of a really good center is mental. That can be a little bit contingent on like how well is the coaching setting them up for success, how well are the guards next to them helping them, what is their connection like with the quarterback that they have? Like, it's just there are so many other factors. Whereas like with the guard it's kind of just like does he fit okay enough in the system and can he kick ass? Like it's just a little bit simpler to me.
- [41:18]
Dave
I think that's pretty perfectly put, Derek. And to be more concise traits get you drafted. I mean let's, you know there are, there are only so many guys who can line up on an island on the edge and handle the Miles Garrett's of the world and deal with that. And there are just more guys with the physical archetype to play center. And like you just you like as far as obviously you gotta be a great athlete to play in the NFL but by NFL standards there's more guys that fit the bill to play center which is, it is really unfair though. I think it's a very good point by the by Gaming Antler for asking the question that the difference that a top notch safety can make is unbelievable. I mean Jason Kelsey is obviously one of the first names that's going to come to mind. But I had a front row seat of Travis Frederick career in Dallas and the stuff that a center of that caliber can do from your offense, from setting the protection, making life easier on the quarterback. Also just I picked this up somewhere along the line from one of the many people who's taught me about football. Cutting the defense in half all the time. Like the way that a center can handle his assignment at the line, climb to the second level and just wipe the, the backside pursuit out of a play. It's unbelievable. And it's such a ace up your sleeve if you have one. So like, I mean like if you could guarantee me I was drafting Creed Humphrey, then you would draft that guy highly every time and pay him very handsomely. But those guys are easier or it's easier said than done to find those guys.
- [42:57]
Robert Mayes
Yeah, I think there's. Everything you guys said is right. I think the availability of players at every level of the draft is part of this. Like, you just don't have to draft a center in the first round for the center to be good. And there are some positions where that just is the case. Like pass rushers are like this. Offensive tackles are like this. Obviously there are exceptions, but if you look at the makeup of the players who are good at that position, it is drastically in favor of highly drafted players. Center doesn't have to be like that. And what you're asking of them physically, I was looking at the numbers while you guys were talking. So centers looking at like the percentage of plays where they're in one on one situations as pass blockers. There was no center in the league this year who was above 50%. No one. If you look at tackles, there are a lot of guys up in like the 80% range. Like, just what's being asked of you physically is different. The Seahawks just won the super bowl with an undrafted center. Like, you can just get by with different kinds of players in a wider range of guys that you can pull from more different places. That doesn't mean that the value of a really good one is any less.
- [44:02]
Derek
And so that's actually what I meant when I meant they're harder to find in the draft in the sense of like, when a pass rusher is really good in college, it is incredibly evident by his physical skill set and that he's like, like you take him third overall and you don't even think about it. Whereas like, with centers, it's like, man, they're kind of tricky to evaluate. Linebackers can be tricky. Safety, it's the cerebral positions are just trickier to evaluate so they fall a little bit.
- [44:25]
Robert Mayes
So that I went harder and easier is interesting because. Because they're the. The best pass rushers are more scarce, but they're easier to identify.
- [44:32]
Derek
To identify.
- [44:33]
Robert Mayes
Centers are less scarce, but they're harder to identify because it's not an apparent skill set the same way safeties and linebackers are.
- [44:41]
Dave
It does suck that like, like Creed Humphrey makes $6 million less a year than the best guard. And I don't know if I think that's fair, like, if you are of that caliber or like whatever deal Tyler Linderbaum gets here in a little Bit like if you are of a certain caliber, I do think you're probably worth more. But it speaks to what Robert just said, that if, if you were going to have a late day three pick starting for you on your offensive line, you would probably prefer it to be your center. So you're probably, you're contending with that aspect of it when you're talking about paying a guy.
- [45:16]
Robert Mayes
I mean, that's just the nature of markets, right? I mean, it doesn't really matter if you're the best player at your position and if the value you give to that position outshines how we typically think of it with positional designations. Travis Kelsey was the most important pass catcher on multiple super bowl teams. He was still making drastically less than wide receivers because he happened to be a tight end. Like that's just how it works. All right, Bella, what's the next one?
- [45:43]
Michael Beller
Okay. Boogie asks us. He says you guys have a tight turnaround when watching prime time games before discussing them as a casual. I'm trying to understand what I should be looking at before and after a game when reviewing what's the first thing you guys go to to get the feel it is it vibes based is the stat you look at first. What do you got on this one, Dave?
- [46:02]
Dave
Oh, I love that you threw it to me. Because sorting out my thoughts in the 12 minutes between the end of a game and when we start talking about it is the most frantic part of my week. I'm just constantly, I'm, I'm trying to get it all into a good place and feeling like it's never going to happen. So I appreciate the insinuation that maybe we do a good job at it. It's interesting. So a couple things come to mind. Number one, I do think it's very vibes based. I mean just the more familiarity you get with the game of football, the more you can just watch a game play out and notice the trends like who would. Which team is struggling in pass protection, which team is running the ball well, which, which you know, is. Is the defensive line constantly on the other side of the line of scrimmage or is it the other way around? So just tracking that Stu. Probably where it starts for me. Other than that, like as far as stats that I'm looking at, I mean I, I have, you know, I have the live stats up during any given game to see how the other team is affecting the quarterback, how efficiently the, you know, each team is running the football. And I'd say I look at that to confirm what I think. But after enough years doing it, I. I tend to just trust what I'm watching. And I would say the other thing is I noticed this. Have you guys ever noticed? Noticed? Like, when I watch a game and I know that I'm not working, it is so vastly different than when I'm watching a game for the show. Oh, my God.
- [47:36]
Robert Mayes
Yeah.
- [47:37]
Dave
Like, you know, I'll be responding to texts or checking my social media or seeing what y' all are saying about the game. And, like, it is a very cushy job. I'm not trying to make it sound hard, but, like, when I'm watching a game for the show, I'm, like, glued to the tv. I'm typically taking notes about every single snap and color coding it so I can find it later. So a big part of it is just I watch every single snap with a level of attention that I would never do if I didn't have to talk about it afterward.
- [48:10]
Derek
I. I think it dep. I'm kind of with Dave. Like, it depends on the game a little bit. Like, you kind of know what you need to go back and look for, depending on how the game went. Like, there are going to be some games where if it really feels like a strong back and forth and teams really weren't making mistakes, then I'm going back and I'm trying to look at, like, like, success rates and trying to square that with, like, how the game, how the flow of the game went. Like, who was really controlling the pace of the game. And then I kind of just look at, like, the easiest spot is just I scour over my notes and, like, what were the pivotal moments? There's going to be turnovers, missed opportunities, whether that's like, dropped interceptions or maybe a team missed a sack, or maybe somebody put a ball on the ground, something like that. Or chances where, like, seven points turned into three because somebody messed up in the red zone. Just stuff like that. Like, I think. Think you kind of understand I'm kind of with Dave. Like, you do this enough that you start to feel like, what are the things that matter in a game? Like, there are going to be games. Like, this is the best example I can give. There are going to be some games where you watch both teams, and blitz rate never even crosses into your mind. Like, it's just like both teams were doing what they do. It wasn't weird. You didn't think about it, not even once. Then there's going to be times where, like, we. I think it was Week 1, the Bills and the Ravens played, and Sean McDermott was blitzing these shit out of the Ravens. And it, like, you track it, you're like, oh, that seems really weird. And then you look it up and it's like the Bill's, like, sixth highest blitz rate in his entire era. And it's just little stuff like that. You start to feel. What feels weird about this game relative to who I know this team is.
- [49:38]
Dave
You could take it back to last week. I remember we were sitting together at Levi's stadium, and Mike McDonald blitzed on his first two third downs of the game. And I was like, whoa, that's. That's different. Like, I don't typically see that many people going after the quarterback from Seattle, and that just comes with time on task, I guess.
- [49:57]
Robert Mayes
I think that. I mean, the. One of the tricks and one of, like, the little things I've leaned on, when we know we're doing those in real time, is that in some capacity. For the last, like, four or five years, when I've been watching games on tv, I see every play twice. And I used to do that by having a second TV on, and I would just put it, like 15 seconds or 10 seconds slower. And so I'd watch the play, and then if I wanted to rewatch it, I could just look at the other tv. Now with Next Gen, I can see the dots on every play immediately after it happens. And so that allows you to see what happened on every me. It allows me to see what happens on every play twice. And so I think that without that, it would be vastly different. Like, I would just catch so many, so fewer things. And the story I actually told this. I did a book event with Chuck Klosterman a couple weeks ago, and he was talking about the way we see football on television and how it kind of wires our brains in a certain way. And I don't know if I've actually told you guys this. I might have, but when I went to see the Bears game in week one, it was the first time that I had seen a game live without my computer or without, like, a second TV in the press box in a decade, probably. And so I'm watching the game and I'm getting, like, antsy because I'm only watching the play once, and I'm like, there's not nearly enough information hitting my brain right now. And so I took out my phone and I started watching the play. And then I would look down and watch the play again on my phone.
- [51:25]
Dave
Because, like, that was broken, buddy.
- [51:26]
Robert Mayes
That was the only way I could do it. It was just like, I can't. I can't only watch the play one time. I have to be able to see what actually happened.
- [51:34]
Derek
Watch. Watching a September NFL game and being like, why didn't that second. Why did that second quarter blitz happen? And being like, I need to figure it out. It's like that's. That's what's wrong with them, all of. Of us here.
- [51:46]
Dave
That's really funny because the, the super bowl was the first game I've gone to live in at least a couple years. And I was a beat writer for 10 years, so I used to. I watched. I was at every cowboy game with a bird's eye view and a pair of binoculars for like 10 years. And getting back into a stadium and being able to see the whole picture live, I was like, ah, this. This feels nice. I don't have to consult next gen. Like I can just see where the safeties are right here.
- [52:16]
Robert Mayes
Here.
- [52:16]
Dave
I don't have to do any extra work.
- [52:18]
Robert Mayes
I'm always gonna miss something. Watching the play live though. You can only watch so much as it unfolds live. And so there's always gonna be something I need to be answering.
- [52:26]
Dave
No.
- [52:26]
Derek
Even then I gotta do some rewinding every now and then.
- [52:28]
Dave
Sitting next to Derek for a live game was crazy. He's just like, oh yeah, like that guy, you know, he was a robber right there. He bounced backward and they dropped him out and like he's just pulling it all live. I. It blew my mind.
- [52:40]
Robert Mayes
All right, we're gonna take one more quick break and then come back and hit a couple more of these.
- [52:48]
Jennifer
Thy ticket lady Jennifer of Coolidge. Well, many thanks, good sir. Here is my Discover card. They accept Discover at Renaissance fairs? Yeah, they do here. Discover is accepted at the places I love to shop. Geth with the times.
- [53:04]
Robert Mayes
With the times.
- [53:06]
Jennifer
You're playing the loot. Yeah. And it sounds pretty good, right? Right.
- [53:11]
Dave
Discover is accepted at 99% of places that take credit cards nationwide, based on the February 2025 Nielsen report. Dreaming of getting the all new iPhone 17 Pro designed to be the most powerful iPhone ever.
- [53:22]
Boost Mobile Rep
Then stay in bed and let a Boost Mobile expert deliver and set it up for you.
- [53:26]
Michael Beller
Oh, actually they will have to get.
- [53:27]
Dave
Up and open the door.
- [53:28]
Jennifer
Oh, right.
- [53:29]
Dave
Delivery available for select devices purchased@boostmobile.com terms apply.
- [53:32]
Boost Mobile Rep
Big news. Boost mobile is now sending experts nationwide to deliver and set up customers new phones at home or work.
- [53:38]
Derek
Wait, we're going on tour?
- [53:39]
Boost Mobile Rep
Not a tour. We're delivering and setting up customers phones so It's EAS to upgrade.
- [53:43]
Michael Beller
Let's get in the tour bus and hit the road.
- [53:45]
Boost Mobile Rep
No, not a tour bus. It's a regular car we use to deliver and set up customers phones at home or work.
- [53:49]
Robert Mayes
Are you a groupie on this tour?
- [53:51]
Boost Mobile Rep
We deliver and set up phones. It's not a tour.
- [53:53]
Derek
Oh, you're definitely a groupie.
- [53:55]
Boost Mobile Rep
Introducing store to door switch and get a new device with expert setup and delivery wherever you're at.
- [54:00]
Dave
Delivery available for select devices purchased@boostmobile.com.
- [54:07]
Robert Mayes
All right, Bauer, what's the next one?
- [54:09]
Michael Beller
Okay, our next question is from Nick W. Nick says every year there's a unit that takes a huge jump due predominantly to a coaching change. Which coordinator, play calling, head coach changes do you have your eye on that could elevate a unit based on the coach alone. Derek, this one's for you. What do you got?
- [54:26]
Derek
So I think I had two pretty easy ones and then one that like, I have to squint a little bit, but I, I can still get excited about. I think Jesse Mentor and like Anthony Weaver, that staff in Baltimore, like, they could go back from average to being like a top five defense. And I don't think it would be crazy. The other easy one is obviously Mike McDaniel in Los Angeles. Like if they can fix the offensive line a little bit, I think obviously that's another one. The one where you do have to actually squint to see it. And they do need to make some changes to actually get there. Denard Wilson with the New York Giants. Again, we've talked about it a number of times. I love what he did with Tennessee. This front, especially the edges are a lot more talented than he ever had in Tennessee, so I'm interested to see how that goes. The secondary needs some work. Linebacker might need some work, but like one or two decent additions. I could totally see this thing swinging around to them being like the eighth or ninth best defense, something like that.
- [55:19]
Robert Mayes
I like all those. The other one, I would say just being a caricature of myself, I'll be curious what Dallas's defense looks like with Christian Parker and not Maddie Berflus. That's. That's one where I'm I'll at least be curious about it. I don't think there'll be like a great defense because the talent still isn't good enough. But will they go from being the worst defense in the league to like the 17th best defense in the league? And is that enough to make them scary? Like, I think that's what I'll be looking for.
- [55:42]
Derek
Can they do what Patrick Graham did with the Raiders for like three years like that? That is honestly the goal for them.
- [55:50]
Dave
Was an Patrick Graham was another one on my list where what he's done with lesser talent. You throw him into Pittsburgh with the amount of talent that they have. I'll be interested to watch that. I think Baltimore and the Chargers are boring answers, but the right answers. And I guess I would throw out Zach Robinson in Tampa Bay too.
- [56:13]
Derek
That's a good one. Actually. That is a really good one because I think he was a little bit scapegoated. I mean obviously like most of the staff got fired entirely but like I don't think he was nearly as bad as it seemed that second year. I do think Robinson can probably be be better and get the bucks back on track. I think that's a good one.
- [56:29]
Robert Mayes
I'll throw out one more. And we talked about it a little bit last week when we were discussing the coaching carousel going from what the Raiders offensive infrastructure was last year to like this sort of Kubiak Shanahan world that lifts the floor of the offensive line. I would not be surprised if that. Oh they're kind of feisty and fun version of the Raiders we thought we were going to get this year. We actually get next year year with Kubiak and Fernando Mendoza. I don't know how good they'll be cause they do need better talent across the board. But I also wouldn't be surprised if like oh shit man. Brock Bowers, Ashton Jensen, like this thing's actually pretty enjoyable two years in a.
- [57:06]
Derek
Row where the sell for Kubiak is he's replacing a college guy and they're just going to run a normal stable NFL offense.
- [57:13]
Robert Mayes
That's it. That, that, that's truly one of the most important improvements you can make.
- [57:18]
Dave
I'm not giving up on the Raiders and I'm not giving up on the Titans. I'm just pretending like nothing, nothing ever happened. We're back to optimism.
- [57:25]
Robert Mayes
You are so. You are such a braver man than me.
- [57:29]
Dave
We'll see if I stick to any of that when we have to put the wind spool together.
- [57:35]
Robert Mayes
All right, Bell, we got one more here.
- [57:37]
Michael Beller
Here we go. Last one. Evans Cronus writes in Evan says what big picture football inevitability is more intriguing to you? Patrick Mahomes next head coach or Sean McVeigh's next quarterback both feel like league altering opportunities that could be realized sooner rather than later. Robert, take us away on this one.
- [57:55]
Robert Mayes
I think it's McVeigh's next quarterback simply because I. I don't. It just feels. Not that inevitable, maybe the wrong word, but, like, we know it's going to happen. Like, I'm not clamoring for Patrick Mahomes to have a different coach than Andy Reid. Like, I don't spend my time sitting and thinking about what that will look like. The Chiefs offense has been frustrating over the last couple years, and I think that they could do with a new injection of ideas. But Andy Reid is one of the best offensive coaches in the history of the NFL. Like, I. I don't. I'm not sitting here looking at my watch, waiting for the day that Patrick Mahomes no longer has to play with Andy Reid. But with a quarterback, it's like, it's hard not to do little experiments in your mind about what McVeigh could do with this type of quarterback and that type of quarterback. And the fact that we know Stafford is probably in the last two to three years of his career, I think it's pretty easy to bring yourself to that place. And so that's the answer for me.
- [58:49]
Derek
I think, to me, too, the Mahomes thing, like, one Mahomes is Mahomes. Like, he's going to play at an incredibly high and cool level almost regardless. And then I think the other thing with the Andy Reid and all of that is, like, moving Andy Reid would obviously change this and affect this, but to me, it's like, I just want to see what the roster would look like with a new guy, and that. That would take so many different iterations. It would take years to build all that stuff.
- [59:12]
Robert Mayes
Yeah, there are more moving parts with the Andy Reid one than there is with the mahomes. With the McVeigh one. Yeah.
- [59:17]
Derek
Yes. So many more. Whereas, like, if we tomorrow figured out who the new quarterback for Sean McVay was going to be, we could start doing so many calculations of, like, okay, this is what the offense is going to look like and this is how they want to build it, and this is what he might do. Like, it just. It, to me, is a more fun thought experiment. And I think we just also have proof over the last basically decade that Sean McVeigh can do so many different adaptations to his offense and be so many different things that I'm just.
- [59:43]
Jennifer
Just.
- [59:44]
Derek
I'm kind of curious what he even seeks out at quarterback. Like, that is really more interesting to me.
- [59:50]
Dave
I spend a lot of my free time. I shouldn't admit this. I spend a lot of my free time daydreaming about who The Rams next quarterback might be like, my, was, was there a world before he signed where Dak Prescott plays for the Rams? Is there a world, even though he did sign that Dak Prescott winds up on the Rams? Rams. Do the Rams draft Ty Simpson or Garrett Nussmeier this year? Like, are they that interested in either of those guys? Are there any other veterans that might come available in the next few years that Sean McVay would identify? Like, I think that is so fascinating and I respect the hell out of Andy Reid. He's one of the best coaches ever. He's going to be in the hall of fame one day. LeBron James has had a shitload of great coaches and he's had bad coaches too. And he was still LeBron James. Like Patrick Mahomes. Mahomes with a lesser coach I would imagine will still be Patrick Mahomes. Like, I'm not going to go as far as to say that's not interesting, but there's just, there is a floor of productivity there when you have Patrick Mahomes to where it's not.
- [60:55]
Robert Mayes
It is.
- [60:56]
Dave
It's not as interesting to me as trying to imagine what McVeigh wants and how he identifies it and what it looks like. I mean, just look at how wildly different and entertaining. Like, first of all, the golf Rams were wildly entertaining and then they pivoted from that to a different, arguably, not arguably, much more entertaining team. And so to imagine how McVay pivots from that and who he thinks is the guy to move forward with after Stafford is very, very interesting to me.
- [61:28]
Robert Mayes
Why I think this is so compelling is that I could see arguments for different types of quarterbacks like Stafford, Stafford and I and I, we don't have to do the whole Jared goff, Sean, Sean McVeigh thing. Again. I think that Jared Goff has developed into a very good quarterback. I think that they scapegoated Jared Goff a little bit and blame things on him that I think were endemic issues with the offense, a lot of different stuff and was involved there. But there's no denying that they were able to enter a different sort of drop back world with Matthew Stafford than they were able to access with Jared Goff from 27, from 2018 to 2020. I wonder though, does he look at Matthew Stafford and say, that's just a different beast. Like, I'm not going to get that sort of quarterback, a guy who's been in the league for 10 years and can do all of these things. Because the reasons that Jimmy is an attractive backup to Sean McVeigh are very different than the reasons that Matthew Stafford is like the right person to make the rest of the offense sing. And so is there a world where knowing you're working with a young player that you're going to have to build up, does he go for more of a pocket based. I think he's like. I think that like what Brock Purdy does for the Niners is that the type of quarterback that the Rams are actually going to seek out, where it's like I can play the position through you because I know I'm not going to get a Matthew Stafford type player. I could see that world, I could see him wanting a player like that as like the successor to what they have. Right.
- [62:58]
Derek
Well, and also I think that's interesting because Purdy is an athlete and like they're. Before they made the trade for Matthew Stafford, Sean McVeigh was flirting with some of these guys who could move around a little bit. The John Wolfers, the Bryce Perkins, like guys who could kind of move around and do stuff. And obviously he's never committed to that, any of those guys as like a long term starter. But like, I wonder if post Stafford he kind of does. Like you're saying Stafford was its own thing. That was kind of lightning in a bottle. It was such a rare circumstance for Detroit to want to trade a guy like that that I'm going to now go kind of reset the slate a little bit. I'm going to go see if I can do this entirely new pivot. Go get me a guy who can run around a little bit and see what that does for the offense.
- [63:38]
Dave
I'm just looking over the NFL standings, like looking at each team and trying to imagine their quarterback in LA in a couple of years, which I don't know. Yeah, like is. Is the guy in the league right now? Is it a young player? Like, you want to hear the meanest.
- [63:54]
Robert Mayes
Answer that I'd have for you? You? Yes, yes, he is in the league right now. It's Joe Burrow.
- [64:00]
Dave
I mean that's so part of me, part of me wonders and it's like so much easier said than done. But after the experience that he's had with Stafford, I just don't think I buy that McVeigh wants to do that. Like I think like McVeigh is like, yes, I enjoy having a ready made product get me that. I don't want to have to worry about drafting a guy and loving him up and building up his confidence and suffering through his back bad habits and all that.
- [64:26]
Robert Mayes
Yeah, I want $10 million. Like it. You don't necessarily have access to the next Matthew Stafford because you want one.
- [64:33]
Dave
I said it was easier said than done, but you know, it. It's happened in Cincinnati before. Just saying, hey, I mean, are you kidding? Like, I'll support Joe Burrow wherever he goes and if he's playing with Sean McVeigh, I don't know, man. I might have to like, just full fledged jump on the Rams bandwagon. That would be so cool.
- [64:52]
Jennifer
Cool.
- [64:53]
Robert Mayes
To be clear, I don't think it's mean to you. I think it's mean to Bengals fans. It is.
- [64:59]
Dave
I will. Okay. Having just said that, the, the way that people are just jumping to the Joe Burrow Bengals divorce right now is pretty ridiculous. Like, come on, we can, we can try to fix this for at least another year or two.
- [65:13]
Robert Mayes
Yeah, I want to be clear. I'm kidding. Okay. That's. It's mean and far fetched. Like, I don't think that's actually going to happen. I'm not predicting that it's going to.
- [65:20]
Dave
Happen, but not in 2026, but maybe the 2029 Athletic Football Show.
- [65:25]
Robert Mayes
If you, if you don't think that the Rams would have their designs on being the destination for Joe Burrow if it eventually goes south in Cincinnati, I'll tell you right now, I assume they do. I haven't talked to anybody there about it. They're not tampering with Joe Burrow. I want to be clear about this.
- [65:40]
Dave
I thought it was very real possibility that he would land in L. A or that Dak would land in L. A if he didn't resign with the Cowboys. Like, I absolutely expect the Rams to try to live in that veteran quarterback world whenever Stafford goes.
- [65:58]
Robert Mayes
Well, we'll see when we get there. For now, that is all we've got from today's mailbag. We will be doing a lot of these over the course of the off season. Next week we'll be back at the combine, so we will not have one, but the next, the week after that we will. And we'll be having them consistently throughout the entire off season. So. So whether it's in the discord, which again, we took a ton of questions on the Discord today, so please go sign up for the Discord if you have not. It's a great way to get yourself included in the mailbag and athletic football showmail.com just keep sending the questions in. Like, we'll go through all of them each time when we look at them. So if you've got one on your mind. You don't have to wait for me to solicit the questions. Athletic football show@gmail.com. one last reminder, we only have one more show coming to you guys this week. As you guys are listening to this, I will be in Peru, Dave will be in Italy and Derek will be here doing the show. So we're doing a little bit time travel right here. But we will be back. Starting next week we're gonna have five shows coming. Your guys away from the combine very much. Looking forward to that. But we have one more show on the docket for today or for this week so please be on the lookout for that one and then be we will be back with our regularly scheduled programming next week. For now, that's all we got. Appreciate you guys listening. We'll talk to you very soon.
- [67:12]
Jennifer
Soon. If you're listening to this, you're ready. Ready to join the Industrial Intelligence generation. A generation defined not by age, but by a shared mindset to connect teams, accelerate efficiency and drive innovation. Using the power of Aviva software to reshape industries, turning real time insights into real world growth. Discover our stories@industrialintelligence.com join Generation I. We all have moments where we could have done better. Like cutting your own hair.
- [68:00]
Robert Mayes
Yikes.
- [68:00]
Jennifer
Or forgetting sunscreen so now you look like a tomato out coach could have done better. Same goes for where you invest. Level up and invest smarter with Schwab. Get market insights, education and human help when you need it. Learn more@schwab.com hey, it's Olivia from Ollie. I gotta tell you, I saw when you asked AI about probiotics. No judgment, but I think Ollie can help. Probiotics are the good bacteria that support your digestive and immune system. Just two gummies and a day to bring balance to your gut. So save the AI for drafting that reply to your ex. That's going to take guts. Go to olly.com to learn more. These statements have not been evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration. This product is not intended to diagnose, treat, cure or prevent any disease.