Ben Shapiro (13:28)
Okay, so kind of awesome, right? Kind of awesome. And listen, if you live in a red state, your wife or your girlfriend probably knows how to shoot. My wife's actually a shockingly good shot. Like, that's great. There's nothing wrong. Not only is there nothing wrong with that, there's something kind of great about that. So the backlash to Sydney Sweeney for being a pretty blonde white girl with blue eyes who can shoot a gun and isn't a registered Democrat is the reason that Donald Trump is president, not her being that thing. The backlash to her being that thing, which is in fact combined with a left wing perspective that says the actual realities of life must be Cynthia Erivo as Jesus Christ and Sydney Sweeney as Nazi. If that's going to be the juxtaposition Democrats, you guys are going to lose until the end of time. This is a giant fail. Donald Trump was asked about Sydney Sweeney as registered Republican. Here's what he had to say. She's a registered Republican. Oh, now I love her ad. Is that right? Is Sydney Sweeney. You'd be surprised at how many people are Republicans. That's what I wouldn't have known. But I'm glad you told me that. If Sydney Sweeney is a registered Republican, I think her ad is fantastic. You gotta love that from President Trump. But that is really, truly one of the big emotional undercurrents of the last 20 years in our politics. The left deciding that everything that was traditionally American was bad, colonialist, racist and terrible. And the right deciding and the rest of America deciding, no, actually you're just wrong. You're just wrong. There are things we can all agree on or should be able to agree on. Like beautiful women are more beautiful than not beautiful women. Or being a registered Republican does not mean that you are a bad person. Or maybe Jesus Christ should not be played on the stage of the Hollywood bowl by a self described clear queer, bisexual black woman. Like, maybe that's just a dumb piece of casting and an insulting piece of casting. Right? That backlash, I think explains so much of our current moment. And if the left continues along these lines, they will continue to backlash their way into minority status, politically speaking. Alrighty. Coming up, Jim Acosta, you remember him from cnn. He is now in the business of apparently interviewing slain teenagers. They're like the AI versions of them. What does that say about journalism? Plus, Zaran Momdani continues his takeover of the Democratic Party. First, can the Fed take the right action at the right time or are we going to be looking at a potential economic slowdown? What does that mean for your savings? I don't know about you, but I diversify with gold through Birch Gold Group. I do it for peace of mind, knowing that if the bottom falls out, I have something tangible I can depend on. And Birch Gold makes it incredibly easy for you to diversify into gold as well. If you have an IRA or old 401k, you can convert that into a tax sheltered IRA in physical gold, or you can just buy some gold and keep it in your safe. I recently re upped on my gold purchases from Birch Gold to make the process super simple. I called them up, I asked my questions, got the information, and now I have gold in my safe. First get educated. Birch Gold will send you a free info kit on gold. Just text Lord Ben to the number 989-898. Again, text BEN to 9,898 98 consider diversifying a portion of your savings into gold. That way, if the Fed doesn't stay ahead of the curve for the country, as they have not historically, at least, you can stay ahead for yourself. A lot of uncertainty out there. A good bet against uncertainty is precious metals. That has been true for literally all of human history. Go check out Birch Gold right now. Text BEN to 9,898 98 to get started. Also Facts do not care about your feelings. And here is one fact that is really, really not going to care about your feelings. Death. I know. Bad fact. But also, here's another fact. Nearly half of American adults would face financial hardship within six months if they lost their primary income. Policy Genius makes finding life insurance simple, helping you secure real coverage so your loved ones have the financial safety net they need when it matters most. With Policy Genius, you can find life insurance policies starting at just 276 bucks a year for a million dollars in coverage. It's an easy way to protect the people you love and feel good about the future. My wife and I, we care about our family, so we have great life insurance, but it can be very complicated. Many people are trying to find life insurance via word of mouth or something. Well, Policy Genius regularizes all of it. Policy Genius is the country's leading online insurance marketplace and helps you compare quotes from America's top insurers in just a few clicks to find your lowest price. Their team of licensed agents walks you through the entire process step by step, handling paperwork, advocating for you while clearly laying out all your options. Coverage, amounts, prices, terms with no guesswork. With thousands of five star reviews on Google and trustpilot, Policy Genius has earned customers trust by helping them find the best policy fit for their needs. Don't wait for a crisis to realize you're unprotected. Head on over to policygenius.com Shapiro to compare top rated life insurance policies. Get your lowest quote and make a smart move in under 10 minutes. That's policygenius.com Shapiro okay. Meanwhile, in in what is one of the more astonishing media stories I think I've ever seen, Jim Acosta. You remember Jim Acosta. I used to say About Jim Acosta. When he was on cnn, he was the White House reporter. I used to say, find you a person who loves you, like Jim Acosta loves Jim Acosta. Jim Acosta is the most self absorbed pseudo journalist in modern American history. My favorite picture of Jim Acosta is one that he actually posted on his own Instagram and it was a picture of him reading his book while looking in the mirror. It was like Jim Acosta in one photo. Well, now he has created a conversation. And I say created because he has. It's a created conversation that he did with an avatar of one Joaquin Oliver, who's One of the 17 people who was killed in the Parkland shooting back in 2018. So according to Acosta, he went to the family and he said, I want to essentially load everything that you know or have about this, this kid who was killed. Again, this is not a real image of this person. This is an AI image of this person because it is now 2025. And so this person was killed seven years ago. So apparently Oliver's parents created an AI version of their son, and then his father, Manuel Oliver invited him to be the first reporter to interview the avatar. And Acosta went along with this. So why is this important? First of all, you know, a few years back, I. I believe it actually, it was many years back. Now, back in like 2012, I was at the Republican National Convention, the one where Mitt Romney was the nominee. And it was in Florida. And I was walking Radio Row, it's where all the various radio hosts were set up. One of the radio hosts who was set up on Radio Row was Sam Donaldson, who was then, I believe, doing a radio show for ABC News. And it was a very left wing radio show. Like Sam Donaldson had, had made all of his biases perfectly, apparently. And I was, I actually walked up to Sam Donaldson to get a quote from him. I was writing for Breitbart at the time. I went up to Sam Donaldson and I said, you know, I have a question for you. You are obviously a left wing person, right? You obviously don't like Mitt Romney. You obviously like Barack Obama. He said, yes. And I said, well, were you lying then or are you lying now? Meaning when you are a, quote unquote, an objective journalist, did you hold those same beliefs? And he said, well, yes, I held those same beliefs. And I said, well, so you weren't objective, you were. You were a left wing hack masquerading as a journalist, as an objective journalist. Because Sam Donaldson, of course, during the 1980s had been one of the big bet noirs of Ronald Reagan. And he said, do you think you're better than I am? And I said, well, yeah, because I'm honest about who I am. I'm very honest about my conservative biases. Whereas you hid them for years, pretending that you were an objective journalist when in reality you were always this thing. The Sam Donaldson who is doing a show on ABC News with all of his biases out front and center is the same Sam Donaldson who is masquerading as an objective news journalist back in the 1980s. Well, the same thing is true about Jim Acosta. So the same Jim Acosta who's perfectly willing to, quote, unquote, manufacture news by doing an interview with a person who does not exist and is a fictional embodiment of a person who is killed, which is just ghoulish in every possible respect. That is the same guy who is the White House correspondent for CNN for years, the self righteous White House correspondent for years questioning Donald Trump and talking about journalistic integrity and the importance of the fourth estate and all the rest of this kind of stuff. Now here he was interviewing a person who again, does not exist. And there's so many problems with this. I mean, obviously there is the sort of bizarre ghoulishness of interviewing an AI mockup of a dead person, especially a person who died as a teenager. And then there's also the reality, which is that people are not embedded in amber. And so suggesting that, for example, Joaquin Oliver would have believed everything today that he believed back when he was tragically murdered. I mean, we don't know that for. I mean, we don't know anything for a fact. This is all basically manufactured. And Jim Acosta was happy to promote this, which I think demonstrates the great commitment to journalistic integrity of people like Jim Acosta. Here is Jim Acosta talking to again, the avatar of Joaquin, not Joaquin Oliver who was killed back in 2018. The avatar of Joaquin Oliver, asking him to tell him about himself. I would like to know more about you. Can you tell us about yourself? What did you like to do? I'm all about love, laughter and living life to the fullest. I cherish my family and friends and always try to spread joy wherever I go. Though my life was cut short, I want to keep inspiring others to connect and add, advocate for change. Joaquin, tell everybody a little bit about yourself, like what's your favorite sport? I love basketball. It's such a fun way to connect with friends and show off some skills. Plus, there's nothing like the thrill of a good game. So obviously that's a machine. And I mean the, the cadences are that of a machine. It's not even naturalistic really. But Jim Acosta went on from here to ask about gun control and, and the. Again, it's an AI avatar of a. Of a teenager who was killed. And this, this is Jim Acosta's idea of journalism, apparently. Joaquin, it's Jim Acosta. I was wondering if you could tell me what happened to you. I appreciate your curiosity. I was taken from this world too soon due to gun violence. While at school. It's important to talk about these issues so we can create a safer future for everyone. What would you like to know more about Wakin? I would like to know what your solution would be for gun violence. Great question. I believe in a mix of stronger gun control laws, mental health support and community engagement. We need to create safe spaces for conversations and connections, making sure everyone feels seen and heard. It's about building a culture of kindness and understanding. What do you think about that? I think that's a great idea, Joaquin. We definitely need more of that. I'm so glad you think so. More kindness and understanding can truly make a difference. Together we can create a world where everyone feels safe and supported. Anything else on your mind? I mean, first of all, the AI needs tremendous work. I mean, the voice actually changes between answers. But beyond that, it says more about Jim Acosta than it does about the AI or even about the parents. Again, you can't blame grieving parents for doing things like this. That are grieving parents, God forbid anybody's in their shoes. But you can't blame Jim Acosta because this is not even remotely journalism. It's not even remotely journalism. And it doesn't even have the sort of historic curiosity factor of loading a bunch of clips, a bunch of writings of Napoleon into a computer and then talking to Napoleon or something. It's just, it's. But again, it shows the, the nature of the kind of people like Jim. Jim Acosta was a quote unquote, well respected journalist for years and years and years on cnn. And it seems to me in the same way that Sam Donaldson, his later life revealed what he was originally in the 80s. Jim Acosta again revealing exactly what he was while he was covering events at the White House. All right, coming up, Elizabeth Warren is standing shoulder to shoulder with Zoran Mandani. As the New York Post puts it, African American with Native American. We'll get to that in a moment. First, you know how most kids vitamins out there are Basically kind of just candy with a vitamin label. They're loaded with two teaspoons of sugar, artificial ingredients kids really don't need. This is where Haya comes in. They've created an amazing chewable vitamin that kids actually love. Zero sugar, but still totally delicious. Even the pickiest eaters would approve. What really impresses me was learning about their ingredient list. They packed in 12 organic fruits and veggies plus 15 essential vitamins and minerals with talking vitamin D, B, 12C, zinc and more. All the good stuff kids need for healthy growth. And they've thought of everything. It's non gmo, vegan, allergen free and thoroughly tested for safety. Are you tired of battling with your kids to eat their greens? Haya now has Kids Daily Greens plus Superfoods, a chocolate flavored greens powder designed specifically for kids. Packed with more than 55 whole food ingredients to support brain powered development and digestion. Just scoop, shake and sip with milk or any non dairy beverage for a delicious and nutritious boost your kids will actually enjoy. They even send stickers with your first order so your kids can decorate the bottle and make it their own. We've worked out a special deal with Haya for their bestselling children's vitamin. Receive 50% off your first order. To claim this deal, you have to go to hyahealth.com Shapiro the deal's not available on the regular website. Go to H I Y A H E a l t h.com Shapiro get your kids the full body nourishment they need to grow into healthy adults. Also feeling overwhelmed by the back taxes? Well, you're not alone. Maybe you missed that April deadline or your financial records are still all over the place. Whatever the situation, don't put it off any longer. The IRS isn't getting any friendlier and those penalties, well, they pile up really quickly. We're talking 5% every month you don't file. Maxing out at 25% and that adds up quickly. Here's the thing, you don't have to handle this alone. Tax Network USA specializes in exactly these situations. They've worked with thousands of Americans, employees, small business owners, people who haven't filed in years, messy books. They've literally seen it all and they know how to sort it out. What sets them apart is their direct access to IRS programs that most people don't even know exist. Plus they have expert negotiators who actually know how to get results. They'll start with a free consultation to assess your situation. If you qualify, they may be able to reduce or even eliminate what you owe. More importantly, they can protect you from the really scary stuff like wage garnishments and bank levies. The bottom line? Don't wait for that next IRS letter to show up in your mailbox. The sooner you act, the more options you will have. Call 800-958-1000 or visit tnusa.com Shapiro to talk to a real expert at Tax Network USA. Take the pressure off. Let Tax Network USA handle your tax issues. Meanwhile, in the markets, the market did bounce back very strong yesterday. So there was a, a dump in the markets after that not particularly good jobs report that came out on Friday. Well, according to the Wall Street Journal, stocks rose on Monday with major US indices climbing 1% or more and everything from utilities to meme stocks rallying markets, of course, were buffeted late last week. The Dow Industrials rose 585 points or 1.3%, snapping a five session losing streak. People don't want to wait too long because again, there is so much uncertainty in terms of what is happening right now. And I think that a lot of people believe that the Federal Reserve is about to cut those interest rates at the next quarterly meeting. That because the economy is clearly slowing, because hiring is slowing, because of all of that, the Federal Reserve's excuses for not cutting the interest rates, those are about to go away. And meanwhile, obviously it's going to need to happen because meanwhile there are some fairly serious problems in the trade sector that continue to percolate. China, for example, is choking off our supply of critical minerals for Western defense. If you've been wondering why President Trump is putting off the TikTok ban or for sale, the reason is because he's afraid of pissing off the Chinese. As I said at the very beginning of this tariff war, I'm very much in favor of tariffing the living hell out of the Chinese government, which is in fact a nefarious government spreading evil pretty much wherever it can put its tentacles, everywhere from Latin America to Africa to the Middle East. The Chinese government does not like America. They're not interested in a, in a unipolar world in which American freedoms are the governing fact of the world. Instead, they would like a multipolar world where they have their entire sphere of domination in the eastern Pacific as well as stretching out via the Belt and Road program across continent. If we were going to do a tariff war with China, however, there are a bunch of preconditions that you needed to do. Like for example, you needed to make sure that supply chains of rare earth minerals had been secured. Before you declare a trade war on China, you need to make sure that we have solid trade relationships with all of the nations surrounding China. We offer them not just sticks, but carrots, right? Ensure that they stay in our camp. Well, China right now is flexing its muscle with regard to those rare earth minerals. According to the Wall street Journal, China is limiting the flow of critical minerals to western defense manufacturers, Delaying production and forcing companies to scour the world for stockpiles of the minerals needed to make everything from bullets to jet fighters. Earlier this year, as u. S. China trade tensions soared, Beijing tightened the controls it placed on the export of rare earths. While Beijing allowed them to start flowing after the Trump administration agreed in June to a series of trade concessions, China is maintaining a lock on critical minerals for defensive purposes. China supplies around 90% of of the world's rare earths and dominates the production of many other critical minerals. So, you know, before you declare a trade war on China or really attempt to shut the box on them, what you really need to do is make sure that all the other places you would get rare earth minerals, you have secured deals with them, you have supplies that are forthcoming, that all just supply chains have been lined up. So I asked our friends and sponsors at Comet, which is perplexity's new web browser, which countries other than China can best supply the rare earth minerals the United States requires. And common answers other than China. The country's best positioned to supply the rare earth minerals required by the United States include Malaysia, which accounts for about 13% of recent U.S. rare earth imports and is a significant global processor Japan, which supplies around 6% with advanced refining infrastructure Estonia, which provides 5% primarily through specialized facilities processing imported ores. Australia, Myanmar, India, Russia, Vietnam and Madagascar. And then there are other countries like Brazil, Canada, Greenland, South Africa, Thailand and Zambia, which have notable rare earth deposits and are increasingly viewed as strategically important sources as the United States seeks to reduce its dependence on China. Now, I also asked comet, so what are our tariff rates on those various countries? On Malaysia, the answer is 19%. On Japan, it is 10%. Estonia is either 10% or maybe 15%. Myanmar is 40%. Other countries like India, Brazil, the EU nations, so India is somewhere between 20 and 25%. Brazil is now all the way up to 50%. Again, that one's justifiable as a piece of leverage against the Lula government, which is increasingly authoritarian and dictatorial. However, the point here is this. If you wish to box China in, you must cut deals with all the Other countries that actually are capable of providing the replacement materials that we need to harden your own supply lines before cutting off your nose to spite your face would be the basic policy principle here. And this is also one of the reasons why the United States should be warming its relations with India. I mentioned that India is one of the sources of possible rare earth minerals. Well, India says that it is not going to stop buying and reselling Russian oil despite an announcement by President Trump that he would substantially increase the 25% tariffs he imposed on Indian goods because of the practice. Now, again, President Trump usually has a very good relationship with Modi, who is the leader of India. And so the sort of ramping up of tensions with India, that seems to me not to be a particularly useful policy. One Indian official said the government had not given any direction to oil companies to cut back imports from Russia after President Trump announced a 25% tariff on India last week, along with the threat of an additional unspecified penalty for purchasing Russian oil. Now, again, the best way of preventing this would be to absolutely flood the Indian energy market would be to provide, if you actually want to cut Russia out of the picture as an energy supplier to India, we should be shipping en masse lng to India or working with our allies in the Middle east, like Saudi, to make sure that India gets energy supplies that are not contingent on Russia. India is now struggling, according to the New York Times, to make sense of the sudden pressure on from President Trump on an issue it considered settled. Some officials and analysts saw the threat of an additional penalty as a manifestation of President Trump's frustration with the lack of progress on Ukraine. And again, I agree with President Trump that any financial support for Russia is, in fact a problem for the end of the war in Ukraine. That, of course, is true, but it can't just be sticks. It also has to be carrots. And drawing into a closer relationship with India to provide a bulwark against China, to provide a bulwark, by the way, against radical Islamism, which is being promoted by places like Pakistan, which is a sort of hav's American ally. Pakistan and Qatar are very similar this way. They're sort of havesy American allies. They do some work with us, but they do a lot of work with terrorists and terrorist regimes as well. Now, building up our system of alliances with both carrots and sticks would be a particularly useful thing at this point in time. Now, meanwhile, on the domestic front, the controversy continues over Texas redistricting. California right now is threatening to redistrict in response to Texas redistricting its congressional districts. It's gerrymandering, I've pointed out before, but it's true. California constitution only redistricts every 10 years. So they just did a redistricting. They had like an independent board that they put up put together and it's by the California constitution as of 2020. Theoretically, they're really not supposed to have inter intra decades changes willy nilly to the congressional district. So really it should wait until 2030. Gavin Newsom is now attempting to break the constitution of his own state. Texas has no such provisions. And of course, as I've said, gerrymandering applies across the board. It happens in Illinois, it happens in Texas, it happens in California, it happens in New York, it happens in Florida. It happens literally everywhere. It is the way that congressional districts are drawn. Well, Democrats are fleeing the state and then pretending that they are acting out of some sort of massive political courage. So yesterday the Texas House passed a motion to arrest those absent Democrats. Now that arrest doesn't mean they spend time in jail. It just means that they're prevented from leaving the state. So they actually have to come to the legislature and do their jobs. Here's the Texas House. In six days, the motion prevails. The sergeant in arms and any officers appointed by her are directed to send for all absentees whose attendance is not excused for the purposes of securing and maintaining their attendance under warrants of arrest if necessary, until further order of the house. Now again, those are civil arrest warrants. It's kind of like if the, if the Congress of the United States would arrest someone for violation of, of some sort of order by Congress, you know, it's a civil arrest warrant. These people aren't going to spend time in jail. Democrats, of course, are not in the state. And so it is not as though you're going to see Texas authorities sort of parachute into Chicago to pick up various legislators. They've done this routine before. They always end up coming back because at a certain point their constituents tire of them absconding and not doing their jobs. What it really is is providing a way for Democrats to grandstand. So Governor Kathy Hochul of New York, who again is only in this particular position because Andrew Cuomo killed all the old people and grabbed ass. He ran out of old people and they kicked him out for the, for the ass grabbage. Anyway, Kathy Hochul, she says that the GOP is leading a legal insurrection, which again is kind of wild. It's just called gerrymandering, folks. It has been a feature of American Politics for well over 200 years. I cannot stand by and let this happen. While Donald Trump and his co conspirator Greg Abbott erode our democracy and Reagan swift toward authoritarianism. Now, what Texas and Republican states are doing at the direction of Donald Trump, I say, is nothing short of a legal insurrection against our Capitol. Legal, meaning they're using the legal process does not mean it's legal and it must be stopped. Now, again, the idea that Republicans are supposed to leave Chekhov's gun on the shelf while Democrats fire it continuously is ridiculous. Redistricting is a thing that happens everywhere. And if New York wants to do it, then I suppose New York could do it. If they redistrict, theoretically, they could make disappear perhaps three more seats. But Democrats already hold 19 of the 26 seats in New York. There are only seven seats that Republicans hold. And so you know, that's going to have to withstand court challenge if she does. But listen to the language here. Kathy Ogle says we're at war. We're at war. Do you really believe so? First of all, I hate this language. I truly despise this language. This language that we are at war with each other in the United States. No, we're. No, we're not. Will you stop? Seriously? We're not on the verge of civil war. We're not on the verge of Americans picking up guns and shooting each other. This sort of language, this sort of we are going to war language from politicians who have never held a gun in their lives. Truthfully, when you're not talking about actual war with, like, an armed enemy, it's the luxury of spoiled rich people, which is what a lot of our politicians are. Here's Kathy Hochul talking War. War. It's war. Here we go. History will judge us and how we respond to this moment. But here in New York, we will not stand on the sidelines with the timid souls on the sidelines who don't care, will not invest their. Their heart and soul into this battle. This is a war. We are at war. And that's why the gloves are off. And I say bring it on. Oh, it's a war. Bring it on. Bring it. Give me a break. There's nothing to bring on. You'll do something. A court will rule, and that'll be it. Meanwhile, I do love when people say that they're not doing something they are clearly doing so. Texas State Representative Gene Wu, Democrat, he again showed up not in Texas, and he says, we're not here to play games. You are literally there to Play games. That is why you are there. Here we go. We're not here to play political games. We are here to demand, to demand an end to this corrupt process. We asked them to stop hiding things from the public. We asked them to stop doing things behind closed doors. We asked them to stop attacking Texas communities. They refused because their loyalty and fealty to Donald Trump overrides all other interests. Okay, he's in Chicago right now in one of the most gerrymandered states in America, run by J.B. pritzker, who must be lowered into the state capitol each morning by Crane, who, who says that he's on Team Fight. That is also tiresome. I've been on Team Fight since I first got elected in 2018. I really believe, you know, we have to make choices right now about whether you're going to be on Team Fight or Team Cave. And the Republicans are using every, frankly, everything, whether it's cheating, breaking the law, you know, trying to do things that I think are non traditional. And we Democrats can't live by the old rules. We've got to live by the rules, but we've also got to react and fight, fight. I love when JB Pritzker, the scion of a billionaire family, pretends to be a hard nosed man of the people. It's very entertaining. Hakeem Jeffries, the House minority leader, he says Republicans are running scared, which is weird since literally Democrats are running scared from their own states and their state legislatures. This moment does require, you know, an extraordinary response because this is an extraordinary act that Republicans have been ordered to undertake to try to gerrymander the Texas congressional map as part of an effort to rig the midterm elections. Wolf, that's what this is all about, because Donald Trump, House Republicans and the Texas Republican Party, they're all running scared because they have failed the American people. Republicans are running scared, literally Democrats are running out of the state screaming. Governor Greg Abbott, he says, listen, the fleeing Democrats, they could face charges. So very simply, it would be bribery. If any lawmaker took money to perform or to refuse to perform an act in the legislature. And the reports are these legislators have been both they sought money and they offered money to skip the vote, to leave the legislature, to take a legislative act, that would be bribery. And so the facts will have to come out. But I think based upon comments made by legislators themselves, they face a possibility of facing bribery charges, which is a second degree felony in the state of Texas. Is. So he is suggesting, of course, that there may actually be some form of criminal Prosecution of these folks who are leaving the state. Be fascinating to see how far he carries that. Well, meanwhile, as the Democrats are fleeing states like Texas in order to prevent redistricting, they are also moving solidly behind Zoran Mamdani. And that of course includes faux Native American Elizabeth Warren. So Elizabeth Warren, who failed dramatically as you recall, running for president and then said that she was 1 1024th Native American in order to defend her career. Long lie that she was in fact a Native American. Well, now she's out there endorsing Zoran Mamdani. So here we have a Ugandan American and a Native American, as the New York Post has pointed out on its cover today, coming together to talk about how America sucks. Here is Elizabeth Warren endorsing Zoran Mamdani's message. When someone stands up and says, I.