The Benny Show: "PANIC: James Comey Indictment IMMINENT, Faces Years in PRISON | Letitia James, John Bolton Next..."
Date: September 25, 2025
Host: Benny Johnson
Guests: Mike Davis, Rudy Giuliani, Tricia McLaughlin, Rep. Jimmy Patronis
Episode Overview
This high-energy episode centers on imminent indictments against former FBI Director James Comey, New York Attorney General Letitia James, and former National Security Advisor John Bolton. Benny Johnson, known for unfiltered conservative commentary, dives into allegations of perjury, classified document mishandling, and mortgage fraud among top political figures. The host is joined in rapid-fire succession by guest experts who provide legal analysis, government insight, and reaction to recent violent acts against law enforcement and conservative leaders.
Main Themes & Topics
- Imminent Indictment of James Comey
- Alleged perjury before Congress
- Leaks and mishandling of classified material
- Parallel Investigations into Letitia James & John Bolton
- Mortgage fraud & property misrepresentation (James)
- Discovery of classified documents (Bolton)
- Weaponization of Government & Double Standard in Law Enforcement
- Recent Left-wing Political Violence and Government Response
- Copycat attacks, overt political radicalization, and the need for stronger legislative response
- Republican Strategy and Reform in Congress
- Upcoming legislative action to designate groups like Antifa as terrorist organizations
Detailed Segment Breakdown
1. Opening & Set-Up (00:01–03:40)
- Benny introduces the day's breaking news: James Comey's anticipated indictment, followed by Letitia James and John Bolton.
- Confirms reports of classified documents found at Bolton's home.
- Teases expert guest panel: Mike Davis, Rudy Giuliani, Tricia McLaughlin, Rep. Jimmy Patronis.
2. James Comey: Lies, Leaks, and Looming Indictment (03:40–21:09)
Comey’s Contradictory Statements & Bragging
- Benny contrasts Comey's denial of spying on Trump under oath with Comey's later public admission of sending agents to the White House (07:45).
- Memorable Clip:
- “Let’s just send a couple guys over.” — James Comey recounting sending agents to interview Flynn, on stage with Nicole Wallace (07:45)
- Benny’s Take:
- “So this is entrapment... These are just like the reason I talk about my IQ here is that if you’re honest, you don’t have to remember all your lies.” (08:36)
- Memorable Clip:
Evidence & Legal Fragility
- MSNBC and CNBC report indictment forthcoming for Comey in the Eastern District of Virginia for lying to Congress (11:45).
- Benny outlines past DOJ investigations into Comey’s leaks, calling out the reluctance to prosecute.
- “Imagine if you’re a 98-year-old granny who even looked at the Capitol on January 6th… But the inspector general finds out James Comey criminally leaks and they’re like, ‘Yeah, but just don’t do it again.’” (16:34)
Comey’s Congressional Testimony Under Scrutiny
- Clip of Comey denying under oath that he authorized leaks, despite claims from Andrew McCabe (19:26).
- Key Quote:
- “I can only speak to my testimony. I stand by what the testimony you summarized that I gave in May of 2017.” — James Comey (19:26)
- Key Quote:
3. Legal Consequences for Comey (21:09–27:25)
- Benny and guests walk through relevant statutes: perjury, obstruction of Congress, false statements.
- Maximum penalties: up to five years in prison & $250,000 fines.
- Host questions Comey's public persona as “a serious man” warning of Trump as a “danger” to American institutions (25:45).
- Comey on a Second Trump Term:
- “Trump is coming for [the FBI and Justice Department] … and that should worry every American. This election matters because of a reason like that... You must vote for him [Biden]...” — James Comey (26:02–26:25)
- Comey on a Second Trump Term:
4. Letitia James & John Bolton: Next in the Crosshairs (33:39–40:35)
Letitia James
- Accused of mortgage fraud and lying about residency for property purchases to obtain better rates (35:39).
- Benny presents documentation, asserts the hypocrisy in James prosecuting Trump for alleged property value inflation.
John Bolton
- Reports confirm seizure of classified documents from his home; comparison drawn to Mar-a-Lago raid (38:54).
5. Expert Analysis: Mike Davis on Lawfare, Justice, and Retaliation (40:35–56:53)
-
Mike Davis predicts indictments for James and Comey, citing clear legal violations.
- Notable Quote:
- "It's time to put Big Tish's fat ass in prison, like I said, right after the election." — Mike Davis (44:55)
- Notable Quote:
-
Davis explains the difference between Trump’s property cases and James’s, noting direct documentary evidence in the latter.
Crossfire Hurricane, Deep State, and Conspiracy Charges
-
Davis connects current indictments to the weaponization of intelligence agencies against Trump.
-
Notes five-year statutes of limitations—urgency for prosecutors.
-
Suggests possible further charges for conspiracy under 18 USC §241 (54:54).
-
Davis’s Blunt Message to Comey:
- “Lawyer up, Big Jim. And we are going to be making the six foot six prison jumpsuits as we speak…” (52:29)
-
Advocates equal application of espionage statutes for Bolton, mirroring the treatment of Trump (53:27).
6. America’s Mayor Weighs In: Rudy Giuliani on RICO and Political Violence (59:25–77:25)
Personal Reflections & Faith
- Opens with a discussion about friendship, faith, and adversity in public life (61:16–63:52).
Using RICO to Combat Left-wing Violence
-
Giuliani urges expanded use of RICO (Racketeer Influenced and Corrupt Organizations Act) against left-wing groups like Antifa and BLM (66:45).
- “Every time I prosecuted them, I would put together two or three of their crimes. I'd charge RICO and go get a restraining order on all their bank accounts..." (66:45)
-
Calls for DOJ and US Attorneys to be trained in RICO’s application to combat organized political violence (69:24).
-
Criticizes government for ignoring evidence implicating leftist involvement in high-profile political violence (71:09).
Justice for Comey and James: Never Too Late
- Giuliani: “Never too late... The really big crimes, though, the one I'm really interested in is James Cardinal Comey...” (72:54)
- Draws on history with FISA court, calls Comey’s actions a “horrible thing... and he did it four times. Can't be a mistake... gets close to treason.” (75:25–76:27)
7. Department of Homeland Security on Left-Wing Terror: Tricia McLaughlin (80:24–96:42)
- McLaughlin confirms new details on a copycat shooting at ICE, inspired by online rhetoric and previous violence against conservative leaders (like Charlie Kirk):
- “...He was wishing for terror and to bring terror to ICE agents… directly inspired by your friend… Charlie Kirk.” (80:24)
- Describes nationwide pattern: organized, professionalized left-wing riots and attacks (93:15).
- Highlights government effort to designate Antifa as a terrorist organization, bolster ICE recruitment, and prosecute organizers and funders.
- Asserts: “We won't stop. We won't be deterred. We will find you, and you will be arrested and prosecuted to the fullest extent of the law.” (95:45)
8. Congress Responds: Rep. Jimmy Patronis on Reform and Security (99:45–108:03)
- Patronis describes surprising collegiality in Congress, but underscores deadlock on addressing left-wing violence (100:56–103:37).
- Discusses upcoming executive order designating Antifa as terrorist group, legislation to follow (102:18).
- Expresses frustration at Democratic reluctance to denounce violence; shares emotional reflection on the cost and purpose of public service.
Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments
-
Benny Johnson (on Comey):
- "James Comey's lies getting him in trouble... If you're honest, you don't have to remember all your lies." (08:36)
-
James Comey (contradicting himself):
- "Let’s just send a couple guys over." (07:45)
-
Mike Davis:
- "Lawyer up, Big Jim. And we are going to be making the six foot six prison jumpsuits as we speak because this guy is a snake." (52:29)
-
Rudy Giuliani:
- "RICO should have been used a lot by us... It's exactly what it's for. The Democrats have set up businesses of crime." (64:33)
-
Tricia McLaughlin:
- "We won't stop. We won't be deterred. We will find you and you will be arrested and we will prosecute you to the fullest extent of the law." (95:45)
-
Rep. Jimmy Patronis:
- "[The President’s] only by the hand of God is even alive ... other people died through the actions of that assailant. That’s a reality that seems like it’s totally been forgotten and just dismissed.” (104:15)
Important Timestamps
- Allegation Setup & Guest Overview: 00:01–03:40
- Comey Testimonies Analyzed: 06:07, 07:45, 19:26
- Legal Statutes Read: 21:09–23:35
- Media & DOJ Reactions: 11:45, 16:34
- Mike Davis Interview: 40:35–56:53
- Giuliani on RICO: 66:45–69:24
- Tricia McLaughlin on ICE Shooting: 80:24–96:42
- Rep. Patronis on Congress and Security: 99:45–108:03
Tone & Style
- Bold, direct, unapologetically partisan; Benny and guests speak in brash, often sardonic, language.
- Frequent use of humor, sarcasm, and nicknames (“Big Tish”) to skewer political rivals.
- References to faith and traditional values interspersed with policy analysis.
- Frequent invocation of “lawfare,” “weaponization,” and “double standard.”
For Listeners New to the Show
- The episode is a rapid-fire, combative analysis of ongoing legal cases against prominent anti-Trump figures.
- Utilizes extensive evidence (clips, documents, witness statements) to build a parallel narrative to mainstream reporting.
- Guests, especially Mike Davis and Rudy Giuliani, bring legal heft and historical context to the core themes of government corruption and selective enforcement.
- The episode is shaped around both recent breaking news and a broader ideological battle over justice, political violence, and the future of the American right.
Summary
This episode of The Benny Show unleashes a barrage against James Comey, Letitia James, and John Bolton amid breaking news of pending indictments and renewed calls for accountability. Benny Johnson, with his signature blend of outrage and humor, deconstructs Comey’s conflicting testimony and connects it to years of what the host calls "lawfare" against Donald Trump. Mike Davis and Rudy Giuliani provide aggressive legal analysis, celebrating what they see as overdue justice and retribution, while Tricia McLaughlin and Rep. Jimmy Patronis lay out government responses to political violence. Throughout, the show hammers themes of hypocrisy, selective law enforcement, and a call for conservatives to fight just as hard, both legally and in the court of public opinion.