The Best Idea Yet: Heinz Ketchup – The King of Condiments | Episode 33 Summary

Released May 27, 2025 by Wondery

Introduction

In Episode 33 of The Best Idea Yet, hosts Nick Martell and Jack Crivici-Kramer delve deep into the flavorful history of Heinz Ketchup, exploring how this iconic condiment became a household staple. From its humble beginnings to its dominance in the global market, the episode uncovers the untold stories, bold innovations, and strategic risks that propelled Heinz to the forefront of the food industry.

Origins of Heinz: From Horseradish to Ketchup

[04:37] The story begins in 1869 Pittsburgh, where a young Henry J. Heinz, at just 25 years old, introduces his first product: pure horseradish. Unlike competitors who used fillers like wood chips and leaves, Heinz promises a pure, unadulterated product in clear glass bottles, setting the stage for his commitment to quality and transparency.

Henry Heinz (Narration): "There's nothing to hide in his clear glass bottles." [05:05]

Driven by his mother's strong moral values, Henry seeks to revolutionize the adulterated food market by offering products that are both convenient and healthy. Recognizing the potential of housewives seeking time-saving yet safe food options, Henry partners with L. Clarence Noble, and together they establish Heinz, Noble & Co. Incorporated in Pittsburgh.

Facing Adversity: The Long Depression and Bankruptcy

[11:15] Just as Heinz begins to flourish, the Long Depression of the 1870s hits, severely impacting sales and causing Henry to overextend his company by purchasing entire harvests of cucumbers and cabbages. This overextension leads to unsold inventory and financial strain.

Henry Heinz (Diary Entry - [14:02]): "A man is nowhere without money. It is hard to lose trade money, friends and reputation, and even parents in trouble."

Bankruptcy ensues in 1875, forcing Henry to lay off hundreds of employees and auction off assets. Facing public shame and personal despair, Henry's family steps in to save the company, injecting $86,000 (equivalent to today’s money) to help rebuild.

Rebuilding with Integrity: Innovations and Ethical Practices

[16:27] Determined to avoid past mistakes, Henry commits to avoiding debt and overseeing every aspect of the business. He adopts vertical integration, ensuring control from soil to customer, and instills a strict moral code, symbolized by a notebook labeled "mo" (moral obligations).

Henry's dedication to quality leads to significant innovations:

• Vertical Integration: Controlling every stage of production to maintain quality.
• Advanced Inventory Control: Implementing first-in, first-out methods to prevent spoilage.
• Commitment to Cleanliness: Providing employee changing rooms, clean uniforms, and even on-site manicures to ensure product purity.

Breakthrough in Ketchup: Branding and Marketing Genius

[26:19] While traveling through New York, Henry is inspired by a billboard advertising "21 styles of shoes," leading him to adopt the number 57 as a branding symbol for Heinz. This specificity not only differentiates his product but also evokes curiosity and trust.

Henry Heinz (Reflective - [27:21]): "Five is his lucky number and seven is his wife's lucky number. That's good enough for Henry."

The "57 Varieties" slogan becomes a cornerstone of Heinz's branding, enhancing brand recognition and consumer trust. Henry pioneers several marketing strategies:

• Electric Billboards: Designing New York’s first electric billboard to display the 57 varieties.
• National Advertising Campaigns: Placing a "57" sign on a San Francisco hillside visible from trains.
• Heinz Exhibit in Atlantic City: Creating a free museum attraction that boosts sales by 30% in its first year.

These efforts cement Heinz’s status as a leading ketchup producer, outpacing competitors and establishing a loyal customer base.

Regulatory Challenges and Industry Impact

[35:46] As issues like exploding ketchup bottles due to fermentation emerge, Henry is motivated to develop a preservative-free ketchup. Inspired by Dr. Harvey Wiley’s Poison Squad, which tested food preservatives on volunteers, Henry recognizes the impending regulatory shifts and the growing public demand for pure foods.

Facing skepticism from competitors, Henry takes a bold step:

• Preservative-Free Formula: Creating ketchup without benzoates or harmful chemicals, relying instead on high-quality tomatoes and natural preservation methods.
• Aggressive Marketing: Launching attack ads that discredit competitors' use of preservatives, even fabricating threats of government confiscation to sway public opinion.

Though President Theodore Roosevelt later validates his approach by deeming benzoates safe in limited quantities, Heinz’s early adoption of pure ingredients garners consumer trust and positions the brand ahead of regulatory changes.

Heinz’s Dominance and Lasting Legacy

[38:21] By 1906, with the passage of the Pure Food and Drug Act, Heinz becomes the largest ketchup producer in the U.S., outstripping competitors who are forced to adopt similar preservative-free practices. Henry’s commitment to quality, transparency, and innovative marketing ensures that Heinz ketchup remains the preferred choice for consumers.

Jack Crivici-Kramer: "It's not necessarily about being better. It's about being different... by also being better."

Despite Henry Heinz's passing in 1919, his legacy endures as Heinz continues to dominate the ketchup market, with over 197 million Americans using Heinz ketchup in 2020.

Takeaways and Reflections

Jack Crivici-Kramer: "It's not necessarily about being better. It's about being different... from going with the K spelling of ketchup to the 57 variety slogan to the pursuit of higher quality ingredients, Henry succeeded by choosing options that were different and that set him apart by also being better."

Nick Martell: "Investors are living in a world five years ahead. Henry Heinz was building for the world he believed would eventually come, not the world that he was currently living in."

The episode emphasizes the importance of differentiation, ethical practices, and forward-thinking strategies in building a lasting brand. Henry Heinz's story is a testament to resilience, innovation, and the power of maintaining core values amidst adversity.

Notable Quotes

• Henry Heinz (Diary Entry): "A man is nowhere without money. It is hard to lose trade money, friends and reputation, and even parents in trouble." [14:42]

• Jack Crivici-Kramer: "It's not necessarily about being better. It's about being different." [41:03]

• Nick Martell: "Investors are living in a world five years ahead." [41:35]

Fun Facts

• Heinz Remix Machine: In 2024, Heinz introduced a remix machine allowing customers to customize their ketchup flavors, leading to innovative products like pickle-flavored ketchup.

• Mars Edition Ketchup: Heinz developed a ketchup variant mimicking Mars-like growing conditions to showcase long-term food production possibilities on the planet.

Conclusion

Episode 33 of The Best Idea Yet masterfully chronicles the rise of Heinz Ketchup, highlighting how Henry Heinz's unwavering dedication to quality, ethical business practices, and innovative marketing transformed a simple condiment into a global phenomenon. This episode not only celebrates the legacy of Heinz but also offers valuable lessons in branding, resilience, and strategic foresight for entrepreneurs and business enthusiasts alike.

Follow The Best Idea Yet on the Wondery App or your preferred podcast platform to explore more stories behind the products you love.