The Best Idea Yet — Episode 47: ⚾️ New York Yankees: Rise of the Bronx Bombers
Main Theme / Purpose (00:16–03:32)
This episode uncovers the untold business story behind the New York Yankees: from their humble and chaotic beginnings in the early 1900s to their emergence as a global brand and the most decorated franchise in major American sports. Hosts Nick Martell and Jack Crivici-Kramer explore how shrewd investments, key transformations, bold personalities, and viral brand moments helped the Yankees move from near obscurity to international icons. Along the way, they reveal what entrepreneurs and business leaders can learn from the Yankees’ playbook—especially about talent, brand rivalry, and reinvention.
1. The Yankees as a Global Phenomenon (00:16–02:22)
- Ubiquity of Yankees Gear: Nick shares that on a recent trip to Paris, he counted 18 Yankees caps in a single day—even though most people didn’t know anything about the team.
- “The Yankees hat is everywhere in the world.” – Jack (00:47)
- “Their home is the Bronx, but their market is the world.” – Nick (02:17)
- Symbolism: Many non-Americans interpret the NY logo as a symbol for America itself, highlighting the cap’s appeal beyond baseball.
2. The Early Years—Birth, Corruption, and the New York Market (05:20–13:58)
The Move to New York (05:20–10:06)
- Origins: The Yankees’ origins are unorthodox––not even beginning in New York, but as the Baltimore Orioles, a failed franchise beset by debt.
- Shady Investors: A corrupt police commissioner (Big Bill Devery) and a gambling hall owner (Frank J. Farrell) purchase the team and move it north.
- “Sounds like a setup for an episode of Boardwalk Empire.” – Jack (06:50)
- Ban Johnson’s Vision: The American League's founder, Ban Johnson, is determined to establish an AL team in the nation’s biggest (and already NL-dominated) city.
Turf Wars and Political Machinations (09:55–13:09)
- Opposition from Giants: Giants’ owner Andrew Friedman—who controls the city’s rapidly developing subway system—uses his influence to block the newcomers from securing land for a stadium.
- “New York City Transit is all above ground at this point… It’s basically a mess of electric cable cars fighting for space.” – Nick (11:11)
- Beating the System: The Yankees’ owners outmaneuver Friedman to secure Hilltop Park for their new “Highlanders” team—a nod to its Manhattan altitude.
How the Yankees Name Was Born (13:09–13:58)
-
Initially called the “Highlanders,” the team becomes the “Yankees” thanks to sportswriters needing a shorter, catchier name for their columns.
- “Yankees just kind of emerges out of convenience. But it sticks.” – Nick (13:48)
3. The Babe Ruth Inflection Point (14:14–29:59)
The Legend of Babe Ruth (16:29–19:35)
- Early Life: Ruth was a misfit kid from Baltimore, sent to a reform school where he discovers baseball.
- First Break: Signed as a minor by Jack Dunn, Ruth becomes “Dunn’s new Babe”—thus his famous nickname.
Ruth Revolutionizes the Game (19:35–21:01)
- As both a pitcher and a batter for the Boston Red Sox, Ruth propels the team to World Series glory—a dual-threat unmatched until Shohei Ohtani a century later.
The Trade that Changed History (22:24–27:14)
- Salary Disputes: Ruth’s talent brings both record performance and “problem child” behavior, leading to conflict with the Red Sox brass.
- The Sale: On Jan 5, 1920, Boston sells Ruth to the Yankees for $100,000—a move that becomes “the most expensive mistake in sports history.”
- “Underpaying top talent doesn’t save you money. It funds your competition.” – Jack (40:14)
- Immediate Impact: Ruth shatters home run records, attendance doubles, and the team finances a new stadium—the first “House That Ruth Built.”
- “From a purely financial standpoint, Babe Ruth was the single greatest investment the Yankees ever made.” – Jack (27:24)
Notable Quote
“The Babe is Shohei Ohtani 100 years before Shohei Ohtani.” – Nick (20:51)
The Curse of the Bambino & Cultural Context
- Red Sox Drought: The Red Sox don’t win another World Series for 86 years after the Ruth trade.
- Brand Rivalry Born: The Yankees–Red Sox rivalry becomes a defining American sports feud.
4. Yankees as a Media and Business Empire—The Steinbrenner Era (30:08–39:46)
Transition to Corporate Ownership and the Arrival of George Steinbrenner (31:12–32:50)
- CBS Years: The team flounders under corporate ownership as CBS shifts focus to the booming NFL.
- Steinbrenner’s Takeover: Buys the Yankees for just $10 million in 1973 ($1 million less than CBS paid).
The Boss: Controversy, Free Agency, and Marketing (33:42–36:54)
- Hands-on Leadership: Steinbrenner brings strict grooming policies and an aggressive business style likened to a startup founder.
- Free Agency Era: Initially skeptical, Steinbrenner soon leverages New York’s market power to outspend rivals in signing talent, spending $1.8 billion in free agent deals.
- “Thanks to their massive New York media market, the Yankees have deep pockets… so Steinbrenner makes big signing moves that other teams can’t afford.” – Jack (36:09)
Notable Quote
“Steinbrenner is running the team in full on founder mode.” – Jack (31:21)
Business Innovations & Modern Brand (38:40–39:46)
-
YES Network Launch: In 2002, creates the first full-time regional HD sports network, changing how live sports is watched and sold.
-
Franchise Value: Yankees surpass $8 billion in value, outpacing all other MLB teams.
-
“Jay-Z famously said, ‘I made the Yankee hat more famous than a Yankee can.’ But we’d argue the Yankees themselves made it pretty famous, too.” – Jack (39:27)
5. Key Business Insights—Lessons from the Yankees (40:07–41:59)
Talent as the Ultimate Asset
- Investing in star talent pays exponential dividends; underpaying stars only boosts competitors.
- “Underpaying top talent doesn’t save you money. What it really does is fund your competitors.” – Jack (40:53)
Brand Rivalry as a Growth Engine
- Rivalries create passion, loyalty, and repeat business—not just in sports, but across CPG and entertainment.
- “Brand rivalries are a cheat code for your business.” – Nick (41:01)
- Examples: Crest vs Colgate, Marvel vs DC, Kendrick vs Drake.
- “The Kendrick vs Drake rivalry not only drove millions of downloads…it’s the beef that keeps on giving.” – Jack (41:40)
6. Iconic Brand Moments & “Best Facts Yet” (42:10–44:11)
The NY Logo & Tiffany’s (42:15–42:58)
- The Yankees interlocking “NY” was designed by jeweler Louis Tiffany for the NYPD, later adopted by the team—likely due to co-owner Police Chief Big Bill Devery.
The “Subway Series” and NYC Rivalries (43:07–44:11)
- Fourteen World Series have featured two NYC teams; the unique “Subway Series” pits crosstown rivals and is a signature New York phenomenon.
- In 2000, the Mets and Yankees played a doubleheader in both the Bronx and Queens in one day—final score was the same in each: Yankees 4, Mets 2.
7. Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments
- “When you give people a chance to root for the home team, they will show up with their wallets.” – Nick (41:01)
- “No press release, no official declaration. Society just collectively agrees the Yankees nickname is forever.” – Jack (13:58)
- “Without the Babe, the Yankees don’t become the Yankees.” – Jack (40:29)
- “Call Steinbrenner a kitty cat, because this guy always lands on his feet.” – Jack (37:52)
8. Episode Takeaways & Relevance for Listeners
- For Entrepreneurs & Businesses: Invest in elite talent and embrace rivalry to supercharge your brand. The Yankees’ focus on big names and building a mythos around conflict drove both on-field results and cultural dominance.
- For Brand Strategists: Spontaneous viral symbols (like the Yankees cap) can transcend their industry and become icons—often through global exposure and strong, simple branding.
Timestamps for Key Segments
- 00:16–02:22: The Yankees as a worldwide icon
- 05:20–13:58: The corruption, turf wars, and unlikely birth of the team in NYC
- 16:29–27:14: The rise of Babe Ruth and the franchise-altering trade
- 31:12–39:46: The business transformation under George Steinbrenner
- 40:07–41:59: Core business lessons—talent and rivalries
- 42:10–44:11: Brand iconography: Tiffany’s, the Subway Series, and surprising facts
In short:
The Yankees’ meteoric rise stemmed from bold leadership, seismic talent acquisitions, viral branding, and the will to turn even their villains (and failures) into folklore. Their story provides a masterclass on how to build a dynasty—on the field and in business.