The Bill Simmons Podcast: NBA Playoffs Mega-Preview & Awards Picks (April 18, 2025)

In this episode of The Bill Simmons Podcast, hosted by Bill Simmons of The Ringer, Bill is joined by regular contributors Rob Mahoney, Chris Ryan, and guest Brian Windhorst. The primary focus centers on an extensive preview of the NBA Playoffs, alongside insightful discussions on Bill’s NBA Awards picks. Skipping over the numerous advertisements and intros, the conversation delves deep into strategic analyses of key playoff matchups and the merits of various players vying for season awards.

NBA Playoff Series Preview

1. Rockets vs. Warriors: A Clash of Titans

Timestamp: [04:04] – [17:35]

Rob Mahoney introduces his enthusiasm for the Rockets-Warriors series, highlighting the intense animosity and high stakes. "I just think it has all the juice you could ask for, all the animosity," remarks Chris Ryan at [04:04], emphasizing the electric atmosphere surrounding this matchup.

The discussion navigates through the Warriors' precarious lineup issues, particularly focusing on Jonathan Kuminga's role and the potential impact of injuries to Steph Curry and Klay Thompson. Rob elaborates at [04:27], "I'm excited to watch this very, you know, version of the warriors, but the Rockets do seem like they were built in a lab to screw with them."

Bill Simmons voices his concerns about the Warriors' reliance on key players, stating at [06:51], "I have to pick anything else. I have to worry about them. This is way more than a recency bias." The trio debates the potential outcomes, considering factors like defensive strategies and offensive rebounds, with Rob predicting a tightly contested series where "it feels like a real Clash of the Titans." at [08:10].

2. Pacers vs. Bucks: Damian Lillard’s Return

Timestamp: [17:35] – [25:14]

The Pacers-Bucks series garners significant attention with Damian Lillard rejoining the fray. Bill Simmons expresses his optimism for the Pacers' performance, despite skepticism from others. "I think Dame is playing this Buck series, and the Bucks-Pacers series is a stealth most fun possibility for Round one," he notes at [17:35].

Chris Ryan underscores Giannis Antetokounmpo's dominance, debating why many overlook the Pacers’ potential. At [19:11], Rob Mahoney adds, "I think they're stronger than you think, and they can throw some haymakers at Cleveland." The analysis extends to the Pacers' defensive improvements and the strategic advantages they hold, with Bill concluding, "I can't figure this series out, but I'm leaning towards the Pacers," at [22:26].

3. Nuggets vs. Clippers: A Shift in Favor

Timestamp: [25:14] – [34:17]

The Nuggets-Clippers matchup experiences a notable shift in betting lines, with the Clippers now favored. Bill discusses the implications of this change, considering the Clippers' comprehensive roster and coaching strategies. "I think the Clippers are winning this series. As great as Jokic is," he asserts at [33:51].

Chris Ryan elaborates on Denver's potential vulnerabilities, particularly their depth and reliance on Jamal Murray. "Their bench is weak, and Jokic is going to have to carry them through," he states at [27:44]. The conversation critiques Denver's defensive rebounding and the Clippers' offensive versatility, painting a picture of a dynamic and unpredictable series outcome.

4. Lakers vs. Wolves: Underdogs Rising

Timestamp: [34:17] – [43:59]

In the Lakers-Wolves series, Bill expresses skepticism about the Vegas odds favoring the Lakers heavily. "Minnesota being a plus 156 underdog and the Lakers being almost 2 to 1 seems awful to me," he critiques at [43:55].

Rob Mahoney and Chris Ryan provide counterpoints, assessing the Wolves' resilience and strategic gameplay. "I would be more bullish on that than most," Rob mentions at [38:15], suggesting that the Wolves possess untapped potential and tenacity. The discussion underscores the unpredictability of playoff performances and the fine margins that could tip the balance in favor of the Wolves.

5. Pistons vs. Knicks: A Battle of Resolve

Timestamp: [43:59] – [57:56]

The Pistons-Knicks series is dissected with a focus on defensive strategies and player performances. Bill criticizes the Pistons for their end-of-game decision-making, stating, "They have to protect the boards and Ezekiel will end up being the one guarding Luka," at [55:14].

Chris Ryan praises the Knicks' layered offensive threats and Rudy Gobert's impact, noting at [40:39], "I think he will make an impact on it." The conversation highlights the tactical nuances each team brings to the table, with Bill emphasizing the Knicks' defensive robustness as a cornerstone for their potential upset against the Pistons.

NBA Awards Picks

1. Coach of the Year

Timestamp: [56:02] – [57:33]

Bill Simmons nominates Rick Bickerstaff of the Heat as Coach of the Year, giving him the top spot. "Mark Dagnault, number one," he declares, commending his leadership and tactical acumen in steering the team through injuries and maintaining an elite defensive effort.

Chris Ryan counters with "Atkinson 1. Emo Doka 2. Bickerstaff 3," acknowledging Bickerstaff's strategic prowess but placing Anthony Atkinson first for his impactful coaching style.

2. Defensive Player of the Year

Timestamp: [61:14] – [63:00]

Bill highlights Draymond Green as his choice for Defensive Player of the Year, citing his multifaceted defensive contributions. "Draymond Green," he states firmly, emphasizing his ability to guard multiple positions and disrupt opposing offenses.

Rob Mahoney and Chris Ryan support this pick, noting Green’s defensive versatility and leadership on the court. "Draymond Green deserves it," Rob concurs at [62:06].

3. Clutch Player of the Year

Timestamp: [57:33] – [58:28]

Bill singles out Jalen Brunson as the Clutch Player of the Year, praising his consistent performance in high-pressure moments. "Jalen Brunson," he asserts, highlighting his crucial baskets and leadership in tight games.

Rob and Chris discuss the validity of this award, with Chris questioning its overall significance while still recognizing Brunson’s impactful play in clutch situations.

4. Sixth Man of the Year

Timestamp: [58:28] – [61:37]

Bill chooses Malik Beasley from the Pistons as his Sixth Man of the Year, commending his offensive contributions off the bench. "Malik Beasley first," he proclaims, noting his ability to maintain team momentum with high-scoring performances.

Chris Ryan reflects on Beasley’s versatility and Huskey's role, agreeing with the selection based on his offensive prowess and defensive reliability.

5. Athlete of the Year

Timestamp: [61:37] – [67:25]

Bill nominates Lou Dort for Athlete of the Year, lauding his defensive intensity and game-changing plays. "Lou Dort," he declares, emphasizing his impact on the court and ability to elevate his team's performance.

Chris and Rob debate alternative candidates, with Chris suggesting that Dort's defensive prowess and consistent performance make him a standout choice. They conclude that Dort’s efforts merit the top spot in this category.

6. Most Improved Player

Timestamp: [67:25] – [71:04]

Bill awards Shai Gilgeous-Alexander of the Thunder as Most Improved Player, recognizing his leap in performance and leadership. "Shai Gilgeous-Alexander," he names, pointing to his increased scoring, playmaking, and defensive contributions as pivotal to his team's success.

Chris and Rob support this selection, noting Shai's all-around improvement and significant role in the Thunder’s defensive strategies.

Discussion on All-NBA Teams and Voting Integrity

Timestamp: [83:00] – [100:00]

Bill Simmons and his guests engage in a critical analysis of the All-NBA Teams voting process, highlighting concerns about fairness and potential biases. Bill expresses skepticism about the public nature of votes, "The players and the media had to check on that. The players, first off, they vote for All Star, and half of them don't take it seriously." at [160:07].

Rob Mahoney concurs, remarking on the challenges of maintaining integrity in award selections when faced with fan biases and media influences. "Players don't trust the owners. The owners don't trust the players. The players can't be trusted to pick the other players," he states at [161:55], underscoring the complexities and potential conflicts inherent in the voting system.

Bill suggests that the All-NBA voting should be reevaluated to enhance accountability and reduce biases, proposing that "people should hold us accountable," at [162:00]. The conversation underscores the need for a more transparent and fair voting mechanism to ensure that genuine performance is recognized over popularity or narrative-driven choices.

Final Thoughts and Anecdotes

Timestamp: [101:44] – End

The latter part of the podcast shifts towards personal anecdotes and lighter conversations. Bill reminisces about past interactions with players and memorable moments from playoff coverage. Brian Windhorst shares behind-the-scenes stories from international tournaments and highlights the cultural differences in basketball playstyles.

Bill and his guests discuss the evolution of media coverage, player interactions, and the personal impacts of trades and game outcomes. "I was upset that I'd seen him for the third time," Brian reflects on Luka Doncic's disciplinary issues, emphasizing the importance of professional conduct on and off the court.

The episode concludes with light-hearted banter about upcoming content, future podcast segments, and mutual appreciation among the hosts and guests. Bill wraps up by encouraging listeners to engage with Celtic City on Max and teasing future episodes focused on playoff action.

Notable Quotes

• Chris Ryan [04:04]: "It's Rockets Warriors. I just think it has all the juice you could ask for, all the animosity."

• Bill Simmons [06:51]: "Is this a classic small ball, big ball kind of matchup. I'm way more worried about them than I was two weeks ago. Is that recency bias or what do you think it is?"

• Rob Mahoney [08:10]: "You can tell me at the end of this series that this was like a version of like the early great Thunder teams that came out and just ripped the spurs apart."

• Bill Simmons [17:35]: "What’s CR, who is the guy? There's going to be three games in this series with three minutes left and now I have to match baskets with Curry and Butler. Who's it going to be?"

• Chris Ryan [40:39]: "Anthony Antetokounmpo is one of the best playoff performers in modern NBA, if not overall NBA."

• Bill Simmons [57:33]: "Jalen Brunson 2. I couldn't believe how easy this was for me because I actually watch basketball. Jokic is the number one clutch player of the year."

• Brian Windhorst [61:14]: "I think Shai has got to be there. I think he's got to be their second team in the."

• Bill Simmons [67:25]: "Shai Gilgeous-Alexander," he names, pointing to his increased scoring, playmaking, and defensive contributions as pivotal to his team's success.

• Bill Simmons [162:00]: "Hold us accountable."

This episode offers a comprehensive and engaging analysis of the NBA Playoffs, enriched by expert opinions and strategic insights from seasoned analysts. Bill Simmons and his guests provide a balanced view of the upcoming series while critically evaluating the integrity of NBA awards, making it a valuable resource for both dedicated fans and casual listeners.