Podcast Summary: The Binge Crimes: Finding Mom's Killer Episode 2: "The Stories We Tell" Release Date: March 10, 2025
Host/Author: Sony Music Entertainment

Introduction

In the second episode of The Binge Crimes: Finding Mom's Killer, listeners delve deeper into the haunting mystery surrounding the disappearance of Noreen Boyle. This episode, titled "The Stories We Tell," unveils the intricate web of family secrets, personal struggles, and a young boy's relentless quest for the truth.

Family Background

Collier Landry Boyle, an 11-year-old boy, grows up in an affluent family in Mansfield, Ohio. His father, Jack Boyle, is portrayed as a devoted Navy pilot and a respected physician, while his mother, Noreen, is the heart of the family, deeply involved in cultural and social activities.

Notable Quote:
"I mean, my mother was my whole world. The sun rose and set with her. You know, I just loved being around my mom."
— Collier Landry Boyle [10:03]

Childhood Memories and Parental Dynamics

Collier's childhood appears idyllic, filled with nurturing experiences and cherished memories. However, underlying tensions begin to surface as Collier observes his father's increasing absence and mysterious behavior.

Notable Quote:
"My father would have this temper that you could just set off at the drop of a hat. And there was no telling what would set him off."
— Collier Landry Boyle [24:27]

The Catalyst: A Father's Secret

A pivotal moment occurs during a family outing when young Collier witnesses his father, Jack, in a compromising situation with a woman named Sherry. This event plants the seeds of doubt and suspicion in Collier's young mind.

Notable Quote:
"I see my father making out with Sherry. I mean, I just, I'm standing there in the parking lot just kind of looking at them like, what is."
— Collier Landry Boyle [26:00]

Noreen's Disappearance

Six months after the unsettling incident with Sherry, Noreen Boyle mysteriously disappears. While Jack publicly laments that Noreen has abandoned the family, Collier senses that something far more sinister is at play.

A Young Detective Emerges

Determined to uncover the truth behind his mother's disappearance, Collier forms an unlikely alliance with Lieutenant Dave Messmore, a seasoned homicide cop. Their partnership becomes the cornerstone of the investigation.

Notable Quote:
"Every day that I go to school, I'm trying to, like, check in with Dave."
— Collier Landry Boyle [07:29]

Unveiling Jack Boyle's True Nature

As Lieutenant Messmore delves deeper, a disturbing picture of Jack Boyle emerges. Contrary to the heroic tales told by Jack, Messmore uncovers evidence of Jack's infidelity, aggressive behavior, and deceitful nature.

Notable Quote:
"He's pretty much a philanderer. The more I talked to, the worse it got."
— Lieutenant Dave Messmore [31:12]

Further investigations reveal that Jack fabricated his heroic Vietnam War story, never having served as a Navy pilot. This revelation shakes the foundation of Collier's perception of his father.

Notable Quote:
"He never set foot on a boat. He couldn't fly. His whole life is a L."
— Lieutenant Dave Messmore [32:57]

Sherry Campbell's Involvement

Sherry Campbell, initially introduced as one of Jack's patients, becomes a central figure in the mystery. Her relationship with Jack appears to be more than professional, raising suspicions about her role in Noreen's disappearance.

Notable Quote:
"I see this ring and it's unmistakable because it is identical to a ring that my father had given my mother."
— Collier Landry Boyle [26:15]

The Turning Point

Collier's discoveries lead him to question the authenticity of his family's narrative. As he pieces together the inconsistencies, the bond between Collier and Lieutenant Messmore strengthens, propelling the investigation forward.

Climactic Revelations

While the transcript provided ends before the episode's conclusion, the podcast description hints at a shocking revelation where Collier and Messmore unveil the true culprit behind Noreen's disappearance—a figure intimately connected to Collier's life.

Conclusion

The Stories We Tell intricately weaves personal trauma with investigative prowess, showcasing a young boy's unwavering determination to seek justice for his missing mother. This episode sets the stage for further unraveling of the Boyle family's dark secrets, promising listeners a gripping continuation of Collier's quest.

Production Credits

• Host: Steve Fishman
• Senior Producer: Drew Nellis
• Producer & Production Coordinator: Austin Smith
• Story Editor: Emil Klein
• Fact-Checked by: Ryan Alderman
• Sound Design: Scott Somerville
• Lawyers: Davis Wright Tremaine (Sony Music Entertainment)
• Executive Producer: Jonathan Hirsch
• Special Thanks: Emily Racik, Steve Ackerman, Catherine St. Louis, Sammy Allison, Fisher Stevens, Rhea, Julian, Dan Bopkoff (WME), Evan Krasik, Marisa Hurwitz, Ben Davis, Carl Hunnel (Richland Source), and Collier Landry for sharing his story.

Note: This summary excludes advertisement segments and focuses solely on the narrative content of the episode, incorporating notable quotes to enhance the storytelling.