Podcast Summary: The Binge Crimes – "Night Shift II: Nurse H"
Podcast Information:
- Title: The Binge Crimes: Lady Mafia
- Series: Night Shift I
- Episode: 2. Nurse H
- Host/Author: Sony Music Entertainment / Campside Media
- Release Date: September 9, 2024
- Description: Dive into the enigmatic world of SaraKing, also known as the “Female Bernie Madoff” and “Anna Delvey of the OC,” as veteran reporter Michele McPhee unravels her rise and dramatic fall. Transitioning into The Binge Crimes, this series continues to deliver gripping true crime narratives, featuring stories from serial killer nurses to psychic scammers.
Introduction to the Mystery at Columbia VA Hospital
The episode opens with Jake Adelstein setting the stage for listeners, highlighting the true crime investigation surrounding a series of mysterious deaths at the Columbia VA Hospital in 1992. The narrative centers on the sudden rise of suspicions toward a nurse, dubbed "Nurse H," who is implicated in potentially being a serial killer.
The Catalyst: Linda McGarry's Urgent Request (00:39 - 03:07)
In August 1992, Gordon Christensen, a young epidemiologist at the Columbia VA Hospital, is approached by Linda McGarry, the head of the Quality Improvement (QI) department. Linda is alarmed by rumors circulating on the hospital floors about an "angel of death," a nurse suspected of mercy killing patients to alleviate their suffering.
- Gordon Christensen (01:33): “She told me that the subject we were going to talk about could ruin my career, which was alarming... I had no idea what she was gonna ask me about.”
Linda presents Gordon with a yellow pad containing patient names and dates of their deaths following code blue calls. She tasks him with designing a study to investigate these alarming trends, aiming to uncover if a particular nurse was responsible.
- Gordon Christensen (02:57): “This is what I was supposed to do. This was one of my responsibilities. So I was willing to do it.”
In-Depth Analysis: Unveiling Nurse H (08:05 - 12:16)
Gordon meticulously analyzes three years of death data across all hospital wards, anonymizing nurse identities by labeling them as Nurse A, Nurse B, etc., to avoid bias. His findings are startling:
- Gordon Christensen (10:46): “And I went through and made the calculations. And there was one person who stood way out beyond everybody else.”
His analysis pinpoints Nurse H (Richard Williams) as the sole individual with a death rate ten times higher than his peers, making it statistically improbable that he was innocent.
- Gordon Christensen (11:05): “So I told her that the study had confirmed there was someone who was associated with these deaths. And she asked me who it was, and I said it was Nurse H."
Internal Conflict: Formation of the Ad Hoc Investigation Board (14:37 - 21:25)
With the data in hand, Dr. Jan Swaney, Gordon’s father and the chief medical examiner, confronts Gordon about the implications of the findings.
- Dr. Jan Swaney (14:37): “He came to me and said, this guy is murdering people. And I said I wouldn't use the word murder yet... Maybe he's taking care of the sickest people.”
Despite the gravity, the VA administration opts to form an internal ad hoc board instead of immediately involving the FBI. The board comprises Gary Baker (administrator), Dr. Jan Swaney, and Lee Miller (a retired nurse turned sign language teacher).
The Accusation: Dr. Al Kalani's Confrontation (17:22 - 19:11)
A week before Gordon completes his analysis, Dr. Muhanad Al Kalani, a new intern from Jordan, publicly accuses Nurse Williams of killing patients.
- Dr. Al Kalani (Voice Actor for Richard Williams, 19:11): “Why are you killing my patients?”
This accusation sends shockwaves through the hospital, escalating the situation and complicating the investigation. Nurse Williams paradoxically reports his own accusation to higher-ups, claiming he was being wrongly accused.
- Richard Williams (26:13): “I have never had anything like this happen. This has been a blow to my ego. I just can't believe that people think that I am killing people.”
Discrepancies and Defense: Contrasting Perspectives (27:34 - 34:56)
The ad hoc board delves into the confrontation between Dr. Al Kalani and Nurse Williams. While Dr. Al Kalani insists his accusation was a joke, Lee Miller remains skeptical.
- Lee Miller (33:56): “I believe he was absolutely serious.”
Jake Adelstein and his reporting partner Shoko explore the motivations behind Williams' actions, pondering whether he sought to clear his name or manipulate the investigation.
- Jake Adelstein (28:35): “If I were wrongly accused of something this horrible, of killing people, I would be furious...”
Gordon Christensen (34:56): “The cat was out of the bag. Richard Williams knew that he was exposed.”
Unresolved Tensions and Ongoing Investigation (34:40 - End)
As the internal investigation grapples with conflicting testimonies, Nurse Williams continues his duties, maintaining a facade of calm professionalism. The board faces challenges in reconciling Dr. Al Kalani's contradictory statements and Williams' evasiveness.
- Lee Miller (34:40): “Think his goal was to keep the investigation reined in.”
The episode concludes on a note of suspense, highlighting the unresolved nature of the case and setting the stage for further exploration in subsequent episodes.
Notable Quotes with Timestamps:
- Gordon Christensen (01:33): “She told me that the subject we were going to talk about could ruin my career, which was alarming... I had no idea what she was gonna ask me about.”
- Gordon Christensen (02:57): “This is what I was supposed to do. This was one of my responsibilities. So I was willing to do it.”
- Gordon Christensen (10:46): “And I went through and made the calculations. And there was one person who stood way out beyond everybody else.”
- Gordon Christensen (11:05): “So I told her that the study had confirmed there was someone who was associated with these deaths. And she asked me who it was, and I said it was Nurse H."
- Dr. Jan Swaney (14:37): “He came to me and said, this guy is murdering people. And I said I wouldn't use the word murder yet... Maybe he's taking care of the sickest people.”
- Richard Williams (26:13): “I have never had anything like this happen. This has been a blow to my ego. I just can't believe that people think that I am killing people.”
- Lee Miller (33:56): “I believe he was absolutely serious.”
- Gordon Christensen (34:56): “The cat was out of the bag. Richard Williams knew that he was exposed.”
Conclusion
"Night Shift II: Nurse H" presents a compelling exploration of suspicion, professional integrity, and the complexities of internal investigations within a medical facility. Through meticulous data analysis and fraught interpersonal dynamics, the episode delves into whether Nurse Richard Williams was genuinely a mercy killer or an innocent professional ensnared in a web of accusations. As the narrative unfolds, it invites listeners to ponder the thin line between perceived malice and systemic flaws, leaving them eager for the resolution in future episodes.
Subscribe to The Binge Crimes: Ensure you never miss an episode by subscribing to The Binge Crimes on Apple Podcasts or visiting GetTheBinge.com. Feed your true crime obsession with ad-free, binge-access to all episodes.