The Binge Crimes: The Arsonist Next Door
Episode 4: The Bait
Release Date: May 22, 2025

Introduction

In Episode 4, titled "The Bait," of "The Binge Crimes: The Arsonist Next Door," reporter James Hibbard delves deeper into the harrowing investigation of a series of arson attacks in Phoenix. This episode intricately weaves together the relentless pursuit by law enforcement and the personal struggles faced by those involved in unraveling the mystery behind the fires that threatened the city.

The Exclusive Interview that Ignited the Investigation

The episode opens in January 2001 with James Hibbard, a 28-year-old reporter, achieving a significant breakthrough by securing an exclusive interview with the presumed arsonist responsible for the Phoenix fire spree. This interview, published in the Phoenix New Times, paves the way for both acclaim and controversy.

James Hibbard [01:22]: "The headline was Exclusive Interview with the Preserve's Arsonist."

However, this success breeds tension as the task force, led by Lieutenant Rob Handy, feels sidelined by Hibbard's achievement.

Special Agent Ken Williams [02:26]: "We looked into James quite a bit... we saw James as facilitating and promoting criminal activity."

Faced with pressure from authorities offering a $76,000 reward to divulge his source, Hibbard grapples with a moral dilemma: accept the reward and potentially compromise his journalistic integrity or protect his source and endure the consequences.

Rising Tensions: Task Force vs. Journalism

Hibbard's decision to uphold his journalistic principles doesn't sit well with the task force. Special Agent Ken Williams expresses frustration over Hibbard's non-cooperation, viewing it as an obstruction to their investigation.

Special Agent Ken Williams [02:43]: "We looked into everything we could about him."

This strain extends beyond Hibbard, affecting the entire Phoenix New Times, which becomes a target of suspicion. The tension escalates when the Arizona Republic publishes an editorial accusing Hibbard of prolonging the arson investigation.

James Hibbard [05:01]: "Rival newspaper, the Arizona Republic published an editorial that said, if you meet with an egocentric firestarter, you become part of his gang."

The mounting pressure takes a psychological toll on Hibbard, highlighting the personal sacrifices intertwined with his professional pursuits.

Strategizing the Trap

As the investigation stalls, the task force considers innovative methods to lure the arsonist. Special Agent Ken Williams recounts their brainstorming sessions aimed at setting a trap.

Special Agent Ken Williams [14:46]: "We started penciling it out on a whiteboard. How does this look? What can we do?"

The plan involves staging a fake construction site near the Lee Benson fire location, believing this area holds personal significance for the arsonist. A neighbor aids by offering an undeveloped lot for the setup. Surveillance cameras are installed to monitor the site meticulously.

James Hibbard [15:13]: "In the aftermath of James Hibbard's interview with CSP's line about that second Lee Benson fire being personal, they know exactly where to set this thing up."

The Failed Trap and Renewed Resolve

The first attempt to catch the arsonist falters due to technical glitches, allowing the suspect to evade capture.

Special Agent Ken Williams [18:11]: "There was an IT related issue with the cameras. Something was amiss."

Devastated by the missed opportunity, Lieutenant Rob Handy channels his frustration into refining their strategy. The team perseveres, adjusting the camera angles and enhancing the bait to entice the arsonist back to the staged construction site.

James Hibbard [14:29]: "So what do you do when you can't find the needle in the haystack? Well, you could try making the needle come to you by setting a trap."

The Breakthrough: Mark Sands’ Arrest

After weeks of intensified surveillance and strategic adjustments, the task force spots the suspect approaching the baited site. Rookie Officer Kerry Miyaso plays a pivotal role in identifying and apprehending the individual.

Kerry Miyaso [22:07]: "I see this subject walk towards the sign, and I'm like, john, you see that? And he goes, yeah."

The suspect, Mark Sands, is arrested at the scene, bringing a semblance of closure after a year of relentless pursuit.

James Hibbard [27:16]: "The man who wrote on the sign has been arrested in the shipping container. Kerry and her partner John are ecstatic."

However, the excitement is short-lived as doubts emerge about Sands' true identity as the arsonist.

Warren Jerrems [27:49]: "You've put so much time and effort and work... but you don't know for sure is it really him and is it only him?"

Revelations and Cliffhanger

In a dramatic turn, Special Agent Ken Williams conducts an interrogation with Sands, uncovering inconsistencies in his story. Despite initial hopes, the evidence doesn't conclusively tie Sands to the arson crimes.

Mark Sands [31:35]: "I did it under the guise that I was part of that group."

As the investigation seemingly reaches a dead end, personal connections and unforeseen twists hint at deeper layers of deceit and betrayal within the community.

The episode concludes with a shocking revelation: Mark Sands is in fact a close friend of Lieutenant Rob Handy, throwing the investigation into disarray and setting the stage for the next episode.

James Hibbard [36:33]: "Mark Sands, his running buddy and hiking partner... It turned out that I was the serpent in an unsuspecting place."

Conclusion

"The Bait" masterfully encapsulates the complexities of balancing ethical journalism with the pressures of law enforcement. Through vivid storytelling and character development, the episode not only advances the narrative of the arsonist investigation but also delves into the personal conflicts and moral quandaries faced by those striving to unveil the truth.

Notable Quotes:

• James Hibbard [05:01]: "Rival newspaper... if you meet with an egocentric firestarter, you become part of his gang."
• Special Agent Ken Williams [14:46]: "We started penciling it out on a whiteboard. How does this look? What can we do?"
• Kerry Miyaso [22:07]: "I see this subject walk towards the sign, and I'm like, john, you see that? And he goes, yeah."
• James Hibbard [36:33]: "Mark Sands... It turned out that I was the serpent in an unsuspecting place."

Key Takeaways

• Ethical Dilemmas: The episode highlights the challenging decisions journalists must make when their professional responsibilities clash with personal morals.

• Law Enforcement Challenges: It showcases the intricate and often frustrating nature of criminal investigations, emphasizing the importance of strategic planning and adaptability.

• Personal Stakes: The intertwining of personal relationships within professional investigations adds depth to the narrative, underscoring how personal biases and connections can influence outcomes.

Stay tuned for the next episode of "The Arsonist Next Door" to uncover the ensuing fallout from the shocking revelations surrounding Mark Sands and the domino effect it triggers within the community and the investigation team.

For more gripping true crime stories, subscribe to The Binge and explore the full series on your preferred podcast platform.