The Boostly Podcast: When an OTA Bans You – A Host’s Story of Resilience and Reinvention

Episode Information:

• Title: When an OTA Bans You: A Host’s Story of Resilience and Reinvention
• Host: Mark Simpson
• Guest: Elam King
• Release Date: October 21, 2024

Introduction

In this compelling episode of The Boostly Podcast, host Mark Simpson welcomes Elam King, a seasoned short-term rental entrepreneur, to share his harrowing yet inspiring journey of resilience after being banned from Airbnb. This episode delves deep into the challenges Elam faced, the strategic moves he made to sustain his business, and the profound lessons he learned along the way.

Guest Introduction: Elam King

Mark introduces Elam King, clarifying the pronunciation of his name and setting the stage for a candid discussion about his tumultuous experience with Airbnb. Elam shares his initial success in the hospitality industry, running over 20 properties and generating more than a million dollars in annual revenue in Lancaster, Pennsylvania’s Amish Country.

Elam King [03:36]: "Sometimes there's a macro narrative going on that might have nothing to do with what you see on the surface."

Elam's Background and Business Growth

Elam recounts his entry into the real estate and short-term rental business seven years prior. Starting with a seven-bedroom house in Lancaster, he creatively converted the property into three separate apartments, allowing him to cover costs and generate profit. This initial success spurred further ventures, including rental arbitrage and property management for other owners.

Elam King [08:24]: "We sold our first property almost a year ago and made a really handsome profit."

Elam’s vision extended beyond mere accommodation; he aspired to create a hospitality brand that "ignites people's souls," aiming to provide transformative experiences for guests dealing with personal challenges.

Elam King [05:52]: "Our goal was to give people an experience of a lifetime... helping them come to grips with their inner selves."

The Incident: Airbnb’s Shadow Ban and Account Suspension

The crux of the episode centers around the devastating event on March 19th when Elam’s Airbnb listings were suspended following a report he made about a guest involved in sex trafficking. Instead of receiving support for his responsible action, Elam found his listings shadow-banned, preventing new reservations and eventually leading to the suspension of his entire account.

Elam King [13:01]: "They suspended our entire account. It's like, is there some kind of correlation here?"

Mark empathizes with Elam, highlighting the frustration many hosts feel when faced with arbitrary actions by large OTAs (Online Travel Agencies) like Airbnb.

Emotional Impact and Struggles with Airbnb Support

Elam describes the emotional turmoil caused by Airbnb’s lack of transparent communication and ineffective customer support. Despite his attempts to resolve the issue through numerous calls and involving his attorney, Enrico Schaefer, Elam faced continuous setbacks, including mass cancellations valued at approximately $200,000.

Elam King [19:20]: "I buried my baby... It felt like trying to fight tooth and nail to save the company."

The guest recounts instances of being labeled unjustly, such as being called a "thief" and a "fraudster" by his marketing manager, exacerbating the strain on his business and personal well-being.

Strategic Response: Shifting to Direct Bookings and Diversification

In the wake of Airbnb’s actions, Elam swiftly pivoted towards building a direct booking channel. Leveraging his existing database, he reached out directly to former guests to secure bookings outside of Airbnb’s platform. This proactive approach helped mitigate some of the financial losses, although the damage from canceled reservations was substantial.

Elam King [21:23]: "I just literally went and called a bunch of people up, and some of them booked."

Elam emphasizes the importance of diversification, advising other hosts to not rely solely on one OTA. He encourages leveraging multiple platforms like VRBO and Booking.com, while also establishing robust direct booking systems to maintain control over bookings and guest relationships.

Elam King [40:07]: "Direct bookings are crucial. Diversify among the different OTAs."

Insights and Lessons Learned

Elam shares critical insights from his ordeal, highlighting the vulnerabilities of depending on large OTAs and the necessity of having alternative revenue streams. He points out Airbnb’s arbitrary power and advises hosts to build and maintain their own booking channels to ensure business continuity.

Elam King [40:07]: "Airbnb wants to have a reason to kick anyone off the platform at any given time."

Moreover, Elam reflects on the broader systemic issues within the short-term rental industry, questioning the fairness and transparency of OTA policies.

Reinvention and Future Plans

Facing insurmountable challenges, Elam decides to close his short-term rental business, viewing it as an end to a meaningful chapter in his life. Instead of retreating, he plans to channel his experience into new ventures such as coaching, consulting, and potentially starting a bookkeeping firm tailored for fellow hosts.

Elam King [47:31]: "I'm starting to get really excited about other people's visions and helping them fulfill it."

He expresses optimism about the future, viewing his current struggles as a catalyst for personal and professional growth, inspired by his Christian faith and a renewed sense of purpose.

Elam King [45:45]: "God is using this to redirect... I'm excited about the next chapter."

Conclusion: Key Takeaways

Mark and Elam conclude the episode with profound reflections on adversity, emphasizing the importance of resilience, diversification, and proactive strategies in the face of unforeseen challenges. Elam’s story serves as a powerful reminder for hosts to build sustainable businesses that are not solely dependent on any single platform.

Mark Simpson [52:35]: "Make sure you're building your business on your land. Diversify among the different OTAs."

Elam leaves listeners with an empowering message about the transformative power of action and the importance of moving forward despite setbacks.

Elam King [53:34]: "The next step and what's going to make me successful is whether I take action or don't take action."

Final Thoughts

This episode of The Boostly Podcast offers invaluable lessons for short-term rental hosts and entrepreneurs alike. Elam King’s journey underscores the critical need for business diversification, the establishment of direct booking channels, and the cultivation of resilience in the face of adversity. His candid storytelling and strategic insights provide a roadmap for others navigating similar challenges in the hospitality industry.

Follow Elam King on Facebook: Elam Z. King

Stay Connected with Boostly Podcast:

• Website: boostly.co.uk/youtube
• YouTube Channel: Boostly

Note: This summary excludes non-content segments such as advertisements, sponsorship messages, and introductory sections to maintain focus on the core discussion and insights shared by the guest.