Bill Kristol (3:45)

No, that's a fair note of caution. I point out, as you know, that, I mean, it's easy to get disengaged people. The more engaged people you have, I mean, almost by definition, right. They know more people have spillover effects, so to speak.

Tim Miller (3:56)

I guess the Black Lives Matter parade demographics and the no Kings parade demographics were notably different. I think we should, we should just be able to acknowledge that that is a thing and you know, and think about that.

Bill Kristol (4:09)

But you need both. And I think I was struck by a few things. I mean, the spirit, at least here in Northern Virginia, was high. A combination of anger and genuine indignation, obviously at what Trump has and said almost about what he's done to the country. This is Northern Virginia, lots of government workers, lots of people who involved, semi involved in politics and so forth, but also kind of an upbeat spirit. I mean, given that it was a kind of a grim week with the mobilization in Los Angeles of the troops and Trump's speech on Tuesday and the kind of what was then the soon to happen military parade and then a war breaking out. People were upbeat and people were really happy to see each other. It was a. I mean, it's McLean, Virginia. I'm not going to pretend it's a wildly diverse crowd for McLean. It was somewhat diverse. It was diverse in the sense that there were several ex Republicans there whom I knew, one or two of whom few of whom knew of, of me. But I mean, some who I actually know. And I was slightly surprised to see a couple of them there. They were not never Trumpers last time. They're not close friends, so I'm not intimately involved in their, you know, trajectories politically, but I would say they were Trump maybe adjacent or sort of acquiescent or neutral as late as 2020 or something. And they were there. And then there were plenty of liberals and upper middle class types and so forth. Kind of a nice combination though, as I say, of being angry about what Trump is doing to the country and a sense of humor. There was this couple of witty handmade, you know, posters, placards. I like the one woman had who she was like we were laughing about it. If only Kamala had one, we'd be at brunch now, you know, which is a very, very McLean specific, I believe, or at least upscale suburbs specific.

Tim Miller (5:51)

Yeah, I guess that speaks to my point about the.

Bill Kristol (5:52)

It very much speaks to your point, but it's also a certain amount of self. I say it puts a self, you know, mocking or irony in it. And I think people understand they need the broadest possible coalition. That part I found incidentally. I was on various calls of people, some of whom organizing this, these, these helping organize and organizing these, the no Kings rallies. And there's a lot of concern beforehand about this coalition's very, you know, get in arguments or fights. I really saw none of that, at least here. And I didn't hear about it from anyone I talked to at different events.

Tim Miller (6:23)

The ideological breadth is important and I think was reflected true everywhere. I mean, we had, you know, what felt like probably what would be the equivalent of the New Orleans DSA folks speaking as well as, you know, never Trumper types, you know, Republican types, Southern kind of suburban, former Republican types for sure. And everybody is aligned, I think, about what the message is.

Bill Kristol (6:48)

And I felt this, I mean, again, we'll get discounted. Obviously we know what side we're on.

Tim Miller (6:53)

Sure.

Bill Kristol (6:54)

I felt the feeling was patriotic, I mean, partly because there were a lot of American flags, but people really were felt they were defending American values, American principles, American history, almost against Trump Particularly this, probably a little stronger here in Northern Virginia, but a fair number of ex military, military vets there, active duty, probably wouldn't identify themselves as such. So I don't know about that. But a lot of vets settled obviously in this area. Again, the patriotism I thought was authentic and I guess I thought generally that reading it all about it all Saturday night and Sunday yesterday, I feel like it conveyed a kind of. I feel like that was the more patriotic of the two events Saturday. Now I'm so biased. I don't trust my judgment that everyone agrees with this, but. But I maybe think a little more than 49% of the country would have that perception. Just from looking at the events, looking at the actually the people and millions of people waving American flags against soldiers, looking kind of unhappy to be walking down Constitution Avenue with Trump up there trying to make it look like it was a big deal and kind of lame, don't you think? I didn't watch the parade.

Tim Miller (7:59)

Did you actually watch military parade sponsored by Coinbase? You don't think that was. That had the, the American traditions on its side? I agree with that. I thought I saw a funny post from like some far left person who is trying to be critical of the no Kings parade and they posted that like they went to their local one and there were so many American flags they thought it was a Trump rally. And I was like, great, good. That's a good critique.

Bill Kristol (8:21)

The best thing I've heard all day. That's great. I hadn't seen that.

Tim Miller (8:23)

That's true. Yeah. So no, there definitely is a spirit and I think that ties into the immigration element and it ties into kind of what the country's about. And I think the overlap between that and the anti ice parades naturally lends to kind of something about the American spirit and pluralism the way that what the country's supposed to be. So I agree with you. That was nice. Some of my friends, kids had some of the best signs, but I don't want to out them. Some of the guillotine theme sign from a child really, really jumped out to me. You know, we're inspiring the youthful imagination. The military parade, so to speak. It was really sad and this is not a bit or like hyperbole. I was prepared, I guess maybe it was on the next level. Last week we were talking about this. I was like, I'm kind of prepared for anything. I'm prepared for a total Mussolini style thing where Trump comes out in a costume like that being the one end. I wasn't thinking that was likely. But I was like that was on the most extreme on one end to on the other end, it being just a total zero flop and be shambolic to anything in between. And it was really the latter. I mean it was pathetic and like the videos of, you know, kind of the silent crowd with the wheels squeaking on the tanks and I can't get in the mind of the military folks who participated, but it just didn't really feel like. Seemed like everybody's heart was in it out there and you know, people holding up the drones like because they didn't want to perform them. It just, it didn't feel impressive. If any, if anything it made me kind of sad. Like I was worried that it was going to make me a little scared, but it made me kind of sad about the state of the country and this sort of like there's the obviously the split screen with the no kings protest, but I was struck thinking about the split screen with what's happening in the Middle east and you have like Israel using these precision strikes to take out the Iranian National Guard. And here we have this kind of pathetic parade that like people, nobody's even the people there don't look like they're enjoying that much. That didn't look particularly impressive at the end. I almost was kind of like, if you're going to do it, I wish it was a little bit more fashy. Like I just like it looked weak and embarrassing and sad. That was my main takeaway from it.

Bill Kristol (10:46)

Yeah, I felt bad for the people in the military dragoon into participating, ranging from the most junior enlisted guys to the some of the senior officers. They all looked equally from a little clip I saw at least they look not very happy to be there. And I've talked to people ranging from Seth Moulton, the conversation. Thanks. Yesterday on YouTube and a Marine veteran, four tours in Iraq. It's Michael Wood, our friend, another Marine veteran who's in Texas, went to his local no things but then no kings but to other. Lots of other people directly and indirectly who are talking to people in the military currently on active duty. And they, they did report again, it's slightly self selected here obviously, but they reported just general unhappiness in the military, either unhappiness or just not interested in it. If they, if they were far from D.C. and didn't get dragooned into participating, you know, they were, this was not a big moment for them. I mean in that respect Trump's, in some ways this is part of a more serious effort by Trump to politicize and corrupt the military, which I think it is. You know, this apart from just the idiotic self aggrandizement and giving himself a big birthday party and the performative side of it. But insofar as it's part of an agenda, I can't believe it worked. And I would say maybe a little bit of a backlash. I wonder if you're a normal, you know, sergeant or major or one star general and you think, God, is that what we want? You know, I mean, of course we'll go along with orders. Of course we're part of the military. We're not going to, you know, launch some kind of military rebellion, nor should they. But I don't know, I felt to the degree he wants to politicize the military in his direction, I wonder if it had, if it had a bit of a reverse effect and maybe firmed up a sense that we shouldn't be doing that. And I thought also General Kaine's testimony on the Hill this week, which didn't get much attention, I don't think Hegseth got more because he was so clownish in certain ways. Kaine, I didn't see enough to make a firm judgment of this. Well, certainly the clips I saw, Kaine was pretty firm in rejecting politicization and not confirming that there was an invasion going on in a kind of mild way. He didn't go to MAGA land. I didn't see enough of it to know how much more there was of that or how. But I got the general sense that he probably quietly went out of his way not to seem like Pete Hegsest sidekick and best buddy.

Tim Miller (12:57)

Yeah, I guess one more point on this, the thing that is mildly encouraging, I guess it just kind of depends on what your, what your prior worries or assumptions were, whether this is going to be an encouraging observation. But the Fox coverage of it seems so like forced. You can just tell in politics or in anything. You can tell when the side that's trying to cheerlead for something is really stretching. And I watched Brett Baer kind of chastise people about how this was really about the Army. And some people tried to make this about President Trump's birthday. And it's like you watch the Fox coverage they showed Trump over and over again. It was about Trump and it felt really strained, the efforts to try to make it into something bigger than it just was. And my worry last week, a lot of people shared this with Trump at Fort Bragg and watching everybody cheer him on and, you know, especially before we learned that they had really screened people for coming there. There's this worry of like, man, if you're concerned about an authoritarian takeover, like the military going along with a campaign rally and then holding a birthday parade for the president are two pretty concerning data points. And I think now we can look back on the week and think, well, Trump still has aspirations in this direction, but it's not. It doesn't feel like people are as gung ho about it as I might have been concerned about. And so I think that's my minor silver lining in the whole thing.

Bill Kristol (14:28)

No, I think that's very much the case. I mean, Hegseth has, on the other hand, I mean, Hegseth's Secretary of Defense, and he's fired eight generals and God knows what the promotion board's gonna do.

Tim Miller (14:35)

Tons of things to be worried about.

Bill Kristol (14:37)

Plenty of things to be worried about. The authoritarian agenda is alive and well, sadly, because Trump is president and controls the executive branch and Congress. But, yeah, I think I was. Yeah, I'm where you are. I mean, if you'd asked me when we talked a week ago, I was worried this week would be a week of decline towards authoritarianism. And I don't think it was. And I think if anything, it might have been a bit of a couple of healthy steps away from it.

Tim Miller (15:03)

Yeah, pushback, I agree with that. Just on balance, military parades, guys getting fired from their job for speaking the truth. There's a lot of uncertainty out there in the world, world. And so when that's the case, it's good to look for things you can control and take back control of. And one of those things is by getting yourself some life insurance. With today's sponsor, SELECTquote. For over 40 years, SELECTquote has been one of the most trusted brokers in insurance, helping More than 2 million Americans secure over $700 billion in coverage. Their mission is simple. To find you the right insurance policy for your unique needs. Unlike other one size fits all life insurance companies, Selectquotes licensed agents work for you in as little as 15 minutes. They'll compare policies from top rated carriers to find you the best fit for your health and your budget. And they work for you for free. No medical exam. No problem. They partner with providers offering same day coverage up to $2 million without needing to visit the doctor. Have high blood pressure, diabetes, heart disease. Select Quote partners with policies designed for many pre existing health conditions, including those so you can get the protection you deserve. Life insurance is never cheaper than it is today. Select Quote they shop, you save. So get the right life insurance for you for less and save more than 50%@SelectQuote.com Bulwark save more than 50% on term life insurance@SelectQuote.com Bulwark today to get started. That's SelectQuote.com Bulwark okay. Plenty of other things to still be worried about deciding which one to talk about first. I guess let's do is because it's on the topic, let's do the ICE and the kind of military raids because this is something where Trump sent out a bleep, basically saying those conversations about how we want to dial it back at farms and hotels, ignore that ICE officers are ordered to do all in their power to deliver the single largest mass deportation program in history. And we're going to do it in the democratic cities in Los Angeles, Chicago, New York and others where these folks live. And as someone I was talking to, Terry, that really struck him just about this notion about the militarization of our cities, sending these ICE thugs in to Democratic areas to really wreak havoc on these communities. And I think that this is maybe the inverse of what we were just talking about. There was maybe a moment where some, I didn't really think this, but some were saying that because that Trump was tacoing a little bit on this on immigration because of the pushback from Big Ag, his hotel buddies. But to me I think that was rhetorical and like he's not and this is going to continue to level up and might be a really dangerous inflection point.

Bill Kristol (17:52)

I'm not sure it's entirely rhetorical. I basically agree with you. And the ICE thing remains horrible and horrifying. I mean I do think they've changed the orders for ice. At least there was some reporting of this that not to go into the fields and you know, chase and arrest the detain and deport the agriculture workers the way they were doing and parts of California. I think on the late middle of that last week there was video of that. Yeah. Hotel workers, I don't know how you know exactly ahead of time who hotel workers. But anyway they maybe if you say you're a hotel worker, they say okay, you know, at least they don't bust.

Tim Miller (18:22)

They won't raid the hotels.

Bill Kristol (18:23)

They won't raid.

Tim Miller (18:24)

I do think it's safe. They're not going to be raiding the Four Seasons. I don't think the Four Seasons.

Bill Kristol (18:27)

Yeah, that was there wasn't a whole lot of that going on anyway. But you're right since the they try not to just inconvenience too many rich people, basically, and who might be Trump, especially if they're in areas where they're a Trump supporter. So, and I do think the tacoing, the fact that he had to put out that stupid tweet, probably changed policy a little bit. Now he's invited and sadly, now that he said the hotels are in the ag, we shouldn't bother them. I mean, everyone who's obviously knows Trump and is in the construction business saying, hey, you know what, we have problems too. Maybe you could stop hiring people who are assembling to work in construction jobs at the Home Depot shopping center, you know, and so I think it opens the door to a little bit sort of like tariffs. It opens the door a little bit to kind of pressuring Trump. Once you see it works a little bit in one case, there'll be a little more of it. It's sort of takes away a little bit that kind of mass deportation. No matter what. It's a matter of firm principle. It's obviously for Trump. It's all, who knows what it is for Trump. I mean, it's a mixture of bigotry and some sense that this is what he campaigned on. But he doesn't really want inconvenience his rich buddies. He's very different. I think Trump is different from Stephen Miller in this respect, who probably would be happy to inconvenience all the rich buddies. So we'll see what happens in practice. And it's still awful to have what's happening, and a lot of awful stuff will continue to happen. Does another thing. The fact that we've sort of forgotten that Andre has been in detention in el Salvador for 90 days and totally innocent man hasn't had a chance to call his family. I mean, so there's huge amounts to be indignant and outraged and very concerned about how to minimize that. But I guess I'm slightly more optimistic maybe than you that a little chink appeared there in the armor of mass deportation.

Tim Miller (20:02)

I think it'll be interesting to see how it plays out because my, my counterpoint to that, and we'll see, is that we're not yet an authoritarian country, actually. So Trump's diktots then get kind of filtered through the system, you know, and every. And people within the system have their own incentives. And I'm just like, I'm here in Louisiana and I was talking to folks this weekend. I've got lawyer friends I've been talking to and politician friends in town. And, you know, if you are the U.S. attorney for one of the districts here in Louisiana, you're the governor, you're the Attorney general. Your incentives are to get your deportation numbers up. You don't want to seem like you're the weak link here. And so, yeah, at the same time, you also don't want to bug your donors. Right. So there are these cross pressures, right. And the U.S. attorneys and the ICE officials and whoever oversees the LA area and the Chicago area, that is where there's going to be total wheels off. And you know, they want to maximize the number of detentions, but the incentives across all these other places are too as well. And so unless they're giving like very clear stand down orders, I don't know. I just, I think it's going to get worse before it gets better. I guess that's why that's my thing.

Bill Kristol (21:19)

It's terrible. I mean, the mass deportation thing, I, of course, I was never for it or in any way well disposed to it. But it in practice is more. Because they pushed it so hard. I suppose maybe one should have expected it, but it's just more appalling even than I thought. I mean, in terms of what it's, what it signals how people are behaving, the ICE agents, the counter attack, when someone points out that what are they doing here? You know, some of the people they're picking up are innocent, some of them are American citizens and they're treating everyone in a kind of such a bad way, unnecessarily, kind of cruel and brutal way. And the counterattack is just, that's great. You know, they deserve it. They're here illegally, they're all illegal. I mean, it's really grotesque. So that part of it, I'm very much on the kind of both alarmed and disgusted side. And as you say, that part's not. Most of that's not stopping. Maybe there are some signs that there isn't quite as much support for it as Trump thought. One poster this morning or the last couple of days asked one of these interesting questions. It's not 100% reliable in terms of as much as a real poll because it's qualitative a little bit. And you have to divide the sample to two and all this. But it's sort of are you happier with the Democrats message on the economy, we're responsive to it, or on immigration? I mean, which are you sort of. And they're about, they were the same. The poll was like 42, 56 approval of Trump. So if you're inclined to disapprove of Trump, there's as much disapproval on immigration or deportation, at least as there is on the economy, perhaps. And so I think that will encourage Democrats in a good way to focus on that. Incidentally, I did find that at our no things event, at least here in Northern Virginia, there was a lot of just talking to people, a lot of talk about immigration much more than about the economy, which is okay for now. Tariffs, you know, all that other. I mean, it is a real issue, I think, at least for the people who don't like Trump, that questions, you know, swing voters and then Trump supporters. But I think even amongst swing voters and some Trump supporters, I think the deportation stuff is just, I hope it's just a bridge too far. I don't know.

Tim Miller (23:21)

We couldn't be more aligned on that part of it. The whole notion of people only talk about their bills at the kitchen table, this totally ridiculous thing I can't even take. Okay, I want to talk about Minnesota. Just the horrible assassination attempts for anybody that missed it. There was a state House Democratic leader Melissa Hortman was killed as well as her husband Mark. State Senator John Hoffman and his wife Yvette were wounded. The suspect is a guy named Vance Bolter. His roommate says he voted for President Trump was against abortion. Old friend said similar. And this guy went to their houses dressed as a police officer with a car that had like fake sirens on, I guess real sirens with fake police sirens on it, and assassinated them in their homes. And he was finally caught just a few hours ago, which is good. He'd been on the loose. He had a list of other Democrats he was going to target and other left wing groups, organizations. So I don't know. I have a few thoughts on it. But Bill, I guess. What's your top takeaway?

Bill Kristol (24:30)

It's obviously horrible and should be denounced and the good news is it was denounced by Republicans and Democrats pretty much. I wouldn't qualify it. I think it was denounced enough. I hope it was denounced enough by everyone and is appalling to everyone. But you had a point. You really noticed and looked more closely than I did at the immediate. The degree to which the MAGA right was willing to spin this on social media based on either fake or fragmentary accounts of who the guy was as a left wing Marxist shooting endorsed by people as serious as your great buddy Senator Mike Lee and, and Elon Musk. And I mean, that really is the degree of irresponsibility and cavalier disregard for the truth and just wanting to establish your narrative, even knowing that it could well be totally falsified as it has been 24 hours later. I don't know. You thought a lot about that and you spoke eloquently about that.

Tim Miller (25:27)

Yeah, I have. I just, I gotta tell you, I've been discouraged by pretty much all of it. I like, I mean, assassinations. I like there's a moment in the country where this was, this happened like people got assassinated politically, you know, before I was born, not too long before I was born, but there was a spate of it and then some other, you know, kind of assassination attempts. And we had the Gabby Giffords issue and then Steve Scalise at the baseball field. So, like it happens. But an actual murder of a politician, like, you know, you would think that that would just call for an immediate outpouring from all leaders. That is just. No, like we have to be opposed to this. We have to demonstrate how much we are all kind of in this together. In a messy democracy, no matter what our views are, you would expect this overwhelming response and it's just not what happens, you know, I mean, Trump put out a statement about it, but then was asked if he's going to see Tim Walz who was very emotional at this, Governor Walz, who knew, you know, the victims and he kind of was dismissive of that and then attacked walls and made fun of them. And on that video you mentioned, I talked about, Senator Mike Lee has been on a tweeting spree about how this guy is a Marxist based on nothing. Bernie Moreno, senator from Ohio, posted the degree to which the extreme left has become radical, violent and intolerant as well, stunning and terrifying. Elon Musk tweeted, the are so this is not like I'm not just picking random like crazy magas off the Internet, like US Senators, richest man in the world, like very prominent right wing media figures, like immediately spun up a total fake narrative that the assassin was left wing as part of an effort to radicalize people more against the left, right. I mean, in a moment where somebody had, we don't exactly know what radicalized this guy, but where somebody felt was radicalized enough to go kill Democrats, to take that moment to try to radicalize people more against folks on the left is just unbelievably like unconscionable and irresponsible and crazy. And so like that part of it was as to me, very horrifying and I think augurs poorly for the future. And then the other thing I did talk about the video is I just kind of hate this. I hate that after one of these things, everybody immediately like retreats to like is this murder going to help my team or not? Like it's a deeply unhealthy way to think about all of this no matter what your political alliance is. And all you have to do is just look at social media to see that that's a pretty broad sentiment for people that are political posters at least. So anyway, across the board I was just, I felt like it was all pretty disheartening.

Bill Kristol (28:18)

I totally agree. But I would just add maybe a little more partisan than you or something like that. But I'm not partisan. I mean it was clear within two hours. I'm going to say it was, was certainly very, very clear who, what side this guy was coming from. Sure doesn't mean you blame the other side. He's maybe he's crazy, maybe he had mental breakdown. I mean I just saying. But his actual affiliations, the actual list of people he was going after, it was an anti democratic or anti left if you want to call it that, anti, you know, assassination. I mean and that doesn't mean that everyone their assassinations from both sides and one individual in a country of 330 million, etc. Etc. Still, if you are on that side, you have a particular responsibility to denounce it in my opinion. And even a few people might have said, gee, to the degree that he seems to be a guy who, you know, kind of agreed with us on some things, who was strongly pro life, who was a Christian minister who denounced the left, denounced gay people. I think in this speech in Africa that we got video of. Again, this video came out pretty quickly. I don't know if anyone has even gone to that next step, which is the right thing to do and the decent thing to do and which people have done in the past. If someone quote on their side went over the line to horrific violence, you sort of felt a special need to say, you know, I just want to say that we in the responsible and in the huge majority of the responsible community on this side denounce it. So not only didn't they do that, of course, as you said, they spun up this, these fake conspiracy theories and fake biographies basically of the guy and then stuck with them for hours, maybe for a day, I don't know. That's that last Mike Lee tweet was not just minutes, I don't believe after the shooting. It's totally irresponsible to do it minutes after the shooting when you don't know. It's even worse to do it hours afterwards when you kind of do know. And the degree to which he's pinned.

Tim Miller (30:05)

It to the top of his feed. That was his response to the pushback. He's like, you can choose a particular tweet and like, and make sure it stays at the top, no matter.

Bill Kristol (30:12)

Is that right? I mean, this is a US Senator and one who once was thought to be a little eccentric maybe, but kind of mild mannered and responsible. Utah, you know, and all this, I mean, in that respect, just the incredible irresponsibility and viciousness really of parts of the right, I think. And then the social media question and how they are organized to really push this stuff out immediately and really echo each other in a way that the left is often jealous of because it could be politically quite effective, but also is humanly so corrosive.

Tim Miller (30:47)

So corrosive. Right, because it's like true facts don't matter, true reality doesn't matter. And you train people to believe that. That. And so then what happens? Like when you train all of your followers to think the reality of the situation is irrelevant. Every event is part of this imaginary war that we have with our domestic political foes. And we can say or do anything we want to rationalize, anything that hurts them like that. That's basically that what is underpinning their. Their behavior. And that takes you to a deeply dark place.

Bill Kristol (31:20)

Yeah. The imaginary war becomes a real killing and it doesn't even cause. Well, maybe it caused some people who are not posting and some people who are not United States senators to rethink. But again, these are United States senators. I want to come back. You did not pick in your. When you discussed this in the video. And we're not focusing now on random people obviously online who are idiots and who say totally irresponsible things and who want to get followers. Revdev. We're talking about United States senators and Elon Musk, who is a totally irresponsible human, but also was the closest advisor to the President of the United States for the first three months of his administration.

Tim Miller (31:52)

Yeah. Just one more thing on Mike Lee. Again, there are only two options here. Either he's so mentally ill and deranged that he's convinced himself that this person is a Marxist, I guess, and that Tim Walls is responsible for the death of his friends. Like either he's so mentally ill that he. That he believes that or he knows it's a lie and he's advancing it. To what end? Because he wants to get retweets or because he wants the left to be punished, or he thinks that is a path to more power to more political power. And either one of those options makes him totally unacceptable as a person in public trust. You cannot have somebody in a place of public responsibility who's like either that, like mentally ill or that sociopathic. I guess it's just a different type of mental illness but like that confused about reality or that willing to lie about dead fellow politicians. I just, you know, for some social media purpose and it's, it's really beyond the pale.

Bill Kristol (33:07)

Yeah.

Tim Miller (33:09)

Okay. Andrew Eggert wrote this and he guilt ripped me this morning in your newsletter. And so I do want to mention it. John Hoffman's wife Yvette jumped on their daughter and protected her during the attack and saved their kid. I mean, and Yvette is also probably going to survive, it seems like, but it was shot eight times or something. So. You know, in these moments you talk about how fucking awful Mike Lee is, but maybe a word for Yvette Hoffman, one last thing is kind of related, but Edward Isaac Devore posted this. I mentioned this on video. I just want to mention it one more time because it cuts against my earlier point about the silver lining. In the last week, Marines were deployed in American city. The president called for the governor of the state to be arrested. The speaker of the House has called for that governor to be tarted, feathered, A senator has been pinned and handcuffed to the ground, and two state legislators have been shot in their homes. I mean, that is a pretty alarming week in the grand scheme of things. And just because the parade was sad doesn't mean that that trend is not concerning.

Bill Kristol (34:10)

And that was recent or one of the most recent Trump tweets that long one that I think you've already quoted a bit from, I mean, is pretty amazing. It's a flat out statement that we're going into blue cities and they're very badly governed by Democrats. And that's where I want ICE to focus. So, I mean, that's pretty astonishing, isn't it, that law enforcement is now dictated by the city, by the what kind of government, what kind of politics these cities have. Not where the highest crime making this up, but not where the highest crime rates of undocumented immigrants are. Not where the highest disturbances are. You know that you can imagine real metrics that might lead ICE to go focus on city A rather than city B, obviously. Right. Numbers and numbers of criminals and stuff. We're not, we're beyond pretending that's the case. It's just these are states that are run by cities that are run by Democrats. And I'm going to go focus on them, even though the people elected in those cities and states don't want them doing this, incidentally. Right. So I mean, the war of red America against blue America. I was texting with Ron Brownstoot who's been very obsessed with this. And you've had him on and I've had him on over the weekend, but obsessed in a correct way. The kind of degree to which Trump thinks of himself as the president of red America on a crusade much more against blue America than against any foreign. And dictators obviously are enemies. I've kind of never quite believed you could pull that off in this country of ours where so many people, you know, move around or know people who were different from them and so forth. And there are blue cities and red states and red areas and blue states. And I've always kind of assumed that would, I don't know, mitigate that attempt to create basically a civil war. But I that part. They are just Trump and Miller, but all of them and Mike Lee and Bernie Moreno and all these guys are just, they're just 100% invested in that. Don't you think? On board for that?

Tim Miller (36:05)

Yeah, it's not really even close. Like the degree to which they consider the domestic foes the real foes of the country over the foreign foes. I mean, like I wouldn't even know who they would say is the second most dangerous threat to the country. They might give lip service to China, but they don't actually do anything about it. Which kind of relates to the last topic I want to get to, which was Israel and Iran. The Israel attacks from inside Iran have made me start to rethink some of the China threat a little bit. And Ukraine's attacks from inside Russia. Anyway, maybe a topic for another day with you or a China expert, but there are just two elements of this I want to talk about. One, just the actual nature of the attacks and the success at least short term. And then I want to talk about our domestic political side of it. But do you have any thoughts about the. Just what we've seen over the last few days, just from the war side, it's pretty extraordinary.

Bill Kristol (36:58)

I mean the as with the Hezbollah attacks a year ago when they had a long term plan to penetrate, create a fake company that sold the pagers, Tesla, which then blew up and so forth. I mean that plus Iran. And it's related, of course, because they couldn't have. One reason they were deterred from this level of activity against Iran was that they thought that Hezbollah would come down you rain tens of thousands of rockets down on them from sanctuaries in Lebanon to some degree in Syria, which are mostly gone now. So it's very impressive. I'm not a fan of Netanyahu, and I think the Gaza war has been a lot of critical things one can legitimately say about that. But this just the imagination, the competence of the execution of this attack has been awfully impressive. And look, if it degrades Iran's nuclear program even for a couple of years, that's good. And it could lead to more. And it's. I am not. I know we're all supposed to be scared of saying the word regime change and all that, but I'm not. And we. I hope the people of Iran could take advantage of this moment. They've tried in 2009, they tried in 2022. We're losing here some of our new friends, you know, who might be watching this, this podcast and as part of the. Part of the board coalition.

Tim Miller (38:07)

I don't. I don't. There are people that do not want the Iranians to be free.

Bill Kristol (38:11)

They deserve to be free just like everyone else, you know, and they want to be free. I mean, unlike some of these other countries where it's fair to say, oh, well, do the people even want to. You know, maybe they like the kind of government, dictatorial and intolerant and abusive government they have. There's just a lot of evidence the Iranian people don't want that. And I hope Israel can create the circumstances and maybe we could help a little bit, too, where that might come to fruition.

Tim Miller (38:31)

I hope we're not losing anybody. The Iranians deserve to be free. That's a pretty, I think, universal sentiment. The Trump thing. I just had one, one point on this that I just wanted to get your take on. It's a. You hate to hand it to Trump on anything, but, like, his total incoherence on all this has really worked in his benefit. And that's not political advice you ever usually give to politicians, is you should try to be as incoherent as possible and then let everybody on all sides give you credit for things. But for some reason, it works for him. Michael Shearer called him and asked him about Tucker's criticism, because Tucker's really been the one that has been criticizing him. And Trump basically says that getting rid of Iranian nukes is America first, and whatever he says is America first. And then he dropped the call from Scheer to take a happy birthday call from Putin, which was some thick irony there. She was defending the notion of America, of him representing America first, he's like, I'm sorry, sir, I got a really quick take a happy birthday call from Vladimir Putin. But watching the response, you have the kind of neocon remaining wing, the militaristic wing of maga, the Ben Shapiro, Scott Jennings, Erik Erikson, they all are congratulating Trump on the strategic brilliance of, like, pretending to be against the Israel attacks while really, really letting them do it. Meanwhile, you have like, the Breitbarts and the nationalist side of them giving Trump credit for, like, opposing escalation and not being as hot on going to war as all the others want. And like, at least for now, he's getting away with it. It probably won't work if the war escalates significantly, but I don't know. Do you have any thoughts on how he manages to pull that off?

Bill Kristol (40:12)

I mean, one reason he's getting away with it is that the Israeli government is helping him get away with it by correctly, from their point of view. I mean, they cannot, they want Trump on board. And if he gets, wants to take a little credit he doesn't deserve, probably for helping out or kind of quietly encouraging Netanyahu to do it or giving him a yellow light, my impression is if thing had gone very badly, the attack on Thursday night, Friday morning, Trump would be saying, I warned them not to do it. I mean, this is what happens when you don't listen to me. They should have stayed at the peace table. You know, he was willing to go both ways. It's very Trump like, and in a certain way, once I think the Israelis realized that they could flatter him, they certainly went all out doing it. And people who talk to the Israeli government, I believe, have been echoing that. And people who are pro Israel just feel like, you know what, it's, you know, what? If it makes Trump more likely to do the right thing, we'll say excessively nice things about Trump. I think the war within, let's call it the Republican Party more broadly, but somewhat in MAGA world too, is pretty interesting. I hadn't realized how this sounds stupid for me to say, but how much being anti neocon was so central to some part of maga. I thought, of course they were anti neocon, don't get me wrong, for many reasons and many meetings of neocon there. But, you know, I still thought immigration. There are other issues. The first, second, third. The neocon stuff's sort of a cute, you know, like an additional little thing. They, you know, bug, they have to itch, they have to Scratch. I think it's more central than I realized, and it's gone pretty deep into MAGA, and it's deep in the Trump administration. J.D. vance, Rich Colby, the number three person of defense, Colby's deputies, the National Security Council, senior director for the Middle east, as I say, Vance himself. Tulsi. Obviously, there are a lot of people in the Trump administration who are really, really are going to try to flatter Trump by saying he was strong, but he's kept us out of the war. That's his achievement. Right. And then, of course, there's some others in the administration, not unfortunately, as many as there might have been, but actually here I'd say the Republicans on the Hill are more inclined to flatter him the other way. I was told last night that a couple of very senior Republican senators pretty close to Trump had a conversation in the last 48 hours in which they explicitly discussed how do we help. They want the US to help Israel, basically, and they would like the US Even to finish the job if it can be done on fordow and on the nuclear stuff. Obviously, it depends on the risks and rewards and so forth, but they're inclined, they don't want to rule that out. And they had an explicit discussion of how do we get Trump to at least be open to this and override Vance and people who are going to object. And so I said to the person who's telling me this story, well, will they publicly? Will I hear from them? No, their sense is privately flatter Trump, tell him this could help him, his reputation even more if he very carefully and cleverly at the last minute weighs in. You know, so it's all about flattering Trump on all sides, which means you can't trust anyone. No one is telling you the truth. I mean, no one is telling you what they really believe at this point because they're all maneuvering in MAGA world and even Republican world, you know, to handle Trump, which again, is. I don't criticize them for it. If I were a senator, I might be doing the same thing. If you really think the outcome's important.

Tim Miller (43:12)

I don't know, I probably would just say what I think if I was a senator, but maybe that's why I'm not a senator.

Bill Kristol (43:16)

There's some case in general that's a healthier politics. I will agree with that. But, you know, at a moment of great crisis, maybe you, you think, I don't know. Anyway, I'm struck by how much this one person I was talking to was just matter of factly told me this and said he wasn't like telling me some big. We're just chatting. And he said, you happen to know about this one conversation in this. This is the way it works. I mean, this is what it is like to be in Trump's Republican Party. You never say what you believe. I mean, some people say what they believe, especially the lunatics, but an awful lot of other people just take it for granted that they have to maneuver and flatter. And as you say, I mean, in any one instance, you can see why maybe it's they do it and why maybe conceivably it's even the right thing to do. But of course, as a general mode of politics, it's deeply corrupting and bad for the country.

Tim Miller (44:03)

Indeed. Yeah. No, my last thought on that is like, also, the anti neocon sentiment is particularly strong among the younger magas and the people that are influential online. And so that's another reason for that crowd that you're talking about, those senders, to not speak out. Right. Because it could have a backlash effect. And when I go to the TPUSA thing, my favorite question to ask the random MAGA youth is, what is it about Trump you like the best? What are the issues that you care about the most to get you here? And almost all of them say no wars. Almost all of them. It's a very different kind of mindset than back in my day. So what the impact of that will be, we'll see. But that is their political reality. Okay, Bill Kristol, thank you so much. We'll see you back here next Monday. And everybody else, do stick around for Terry Moran. This is exciting, Terry, because I'm welcoming you to the Bulwark Podcast live on Substack. This is the first attempt at this for us, so hopefully it goes well. For folks that don't know you, I assume everybody here knows you, but you were senior national correspondent for ABC News up till about two seconds ago. Previously chief foreign correspondent, chief White House correspondent, co anchor of Nightline, and now you're a free man. How's that feeling?

Terry Moran (45:34)

Oh, well, it's. Somebody said somebody used the word skiting, which is a combination of scary and exciting.

Tim Miller (45:41)

Okay.

Terry Moran (45:41)

Which I'll buy. I would say it's exhilarating and daunting and scary, but, yeah, exhilarating. You know, I was at the point in my career, 65 years old in a. In a business that just as a matter of demographic fact is dying. I was having less impact in abc. ABC having less impact on the. In the world. I'm like, well, what's next? Because I have these inappropriately young children and so court substack and a lot of all these new spaces. And now that I'm here on an accelerated timetable, it's a brave new world. And for all the things that come with job loss, there is a great deal of excitement and joy in my heart, genuinely.

Tim Miller (46:27)

All right, well, this is my first hard hitting question. You look great for 65. What's your skin care regimen? Are you moisturizing?

Terry Moran (46:34)

Well, I will say this. So I met my wife in 2006, and I'd never put anything. I just washed with bar soap. And I didn't for like, what is problem? Because she's up on all that. And so, yeah, I would use a little moisturizer or whatever.

Tim Miller (46:51)

It's working. Okay, let's get to business. So the tweet that started it all for folks who missed it. I just want to read a little bit from it. The thing about Stephen Miller is he's not the brains behind Trumpism. It's not brains, it's bile. Miller is a man who is richly endowed with the capacity for hatred. He's a world class hater. You can see this just by looking at him, because you can see that his hatreds are his spiritual nourishment. What prompted that? What was behind it?

Terry Moran (47:19)

One thing I can say is that it wasn't a drunk tweet. Everybody assumes it was because it was after midnight, and it wasn't. I had been thinking during the course of the day on and off, thinking about the country, right as we all are ruminating, whatever. And I was out for a long walk with the dog, and something kind of came to me. And I thought, because I was thinking about that guy, like, what is it and what is it in this moment? And there was something there. And I thought, all right, well, so I came back. We had a family dinner. We then watched a family movie. We watched Ocean's Eleven. And I can't blame that because that's such an excellent caper movie. And then put the kids to bed. We were up for a little while. And it was not a rock and roll wild night. It was a normal family night. And then got on the bed and I thought, what was that? And I typed it out and I looked at it and I thought, that's true. And I hit send.

Tim Miller (48:20)

You gotta forgive people who think that it might have been a drunk tweet. I mean, are you usually popping off at midnight? Is it a concern you're thinking about Stephen Miller? At midnight. I mean, I guess maybe it says something about the state of the country that you're thinking about Stephen Miller at midnight?

Terry Moran (48:35)

I believe so. It was more the moment that we're in, which he represents in such a vivid and, to me, quite disturbing way. I will say this. I looked at it, I thought, okay, what is that? And I thought, that's a description of the public man that I'm describing him.

Bill Kristol (48:55)

Yeah.

Tim Miller (48:55)

I mean, there's no lies detected from my side of things, but I'm an opinion podcaster, and you do gotta admit, like, you went a little hard in the paint there was that talking about how his hatreds are his spiritual nourishment. So, you know, I guess it does leave people to wonder, like, were you and Stephen Moore fighting? Like, was there something. Was there a news story that prompted it? Like, was it something out of your Trump interview? I mean, given, like, your background as a newsman, obviously you had a perspective. But that's. That's hot. That's hot material.

Terry Moran (49:26)

It's way hot. And I wish I had a better story, Tim. It was something that was in my heart and mind, and I would say I used very strong language deliberately because he. I felt. And it wasn't any. You see him all the time doing the same, spitting venom and lies into our debate, degrading our public discourse, debasing it, and using the power of the White House and what he's been given to grind us down in that. In that bio. That's very disturbing to me. I'm actually not that liberal. I'm like a lot of people. Some conserved, some liberal. But there was something about that and what it represented about that movement and Trump himself that I felt, to describe it accurately, needed that language.

Tim Miller (50:17)

Yeah, it's interesting. It does feel like it was something that was weighing on you. I don't have it in front of me. But maybe a week before that, you'd send kind of a long tweet about immigration. And it wasn't a lefty tweet, really. It started with a comment about how we need to be able to have self government and have our borders. Here it is. It's like people have a right to say who comes into our country and at what pace they're admitted. That's not racism. It's self government. By turning migration into a moral demand, a matter of right rather than policy, advocates have ignited a backlash. I know this was you, like, a week before. Then you go on to talk about how we are seeing a bunch of people who are being racist in the way and in the ways that they are treating immigration. So like there's something about this issue that has been obviously noodling in your head for a while.

Terry Moran (51:05)

Yeah, yeah. I would say that I'm a member of the most despised political tribe in America. I'm a proud centrist. What I mean by that is I guess I'm old. And the viciousness and the intolerance that you feel when we argue politics. Somebody asked me the other day in connection with all this, so what are your politics? And I said, well, I guess I'm a Hubert Humphrey Democrat. I mean, I'm old enough to remember him and get practical things done that people need in a decent way and stand up up for what's right. And that is my politics. So someone liked Stephen Miller. In my judgment and in my observation, which is what reporters do is degrading all that and is a danger. And that's what was in my heart.

Tim Miller (52:01)

I don't feel this way. But I used to be a Republican. So I want to steel man the Republican argument for a second with you, which is I think that some of my old friends over there, our former friends, maybe better, better put, would say, look, he just admitted it. Terry Moran just admitted he was a Democrat. He was hiding it his whole life. He was a Hubert Humphrey Democrat. And like one night it just, the mask came off, you know, and this is the problem with the media. What would you say to that?

Terry Moran (52:28)

I have at it, you know, but my own feeling is you don't sacrifice your citizenship as a journalism and your job is not to be objective. There is no Mount Olympus of objectivity where a Mandarin class of wise people have no feelings about their society. We're all in this together. What you have to be is fair and accurate. And I would refer to the interview with the President that I did or a lot of my work. And I would also say that this, while very hot, is an observation, a description that is accurate and true.

Tim Miller (53:05)

Yeah. And we got 10 years evidence. You know, it's the 10 year anniversary today of the escalator. Did you know that?

Terry Moran (53:09)

Did not know that. One of the most significant moments in American history. No question about it.

Tim Miller (53:13)

Ten years. What. What were you thinking about it back then, that day? Do you remember?

Terry Moran (53:18)

You know, it was a sideshow to me at that point. But I quickly came to understand I was actually in London because I was the foreign chief foreign correspondent. And as soon as I started hearing what he was talking about, about I told colleagues who didn't believe me, I told I Teach in the summer. I said, he's going to win in 2016. Because I did not understand what Hillary Clinton was saying to me in terms of what she wanted to do with that power. If you had taken a poll a week before the election, what does Donald Trump stand for? 95% of Americans are going towards something. Build a wall, China, whatever. What does Hillary Clinton stand for more? I think harder to get a hold of that. And, you know, I think that was kind of an issue, but I also felt like he was onto something.

Tim Miller (54:02)

Yeah, that bile and that hatred, though, goes back to that very speech. You know, I mean, it's like the rapists and the murderers, the cantaloupe legs and the grievances. Right. I mean, it's not a lot has changed there over the decade. I mean, your observation. We've got a decade of evidence, I guess, about your observations about Stephen Miller and the Trump movement.

Terry Moran (54:23)

Well, I would say this, I agree, yes, that that's part of the sale. That's part of the revving up of the resentment and all of that. And you saw it also in Britain and in other places where Trump is a nationalist. The night he was elected, I was on ABC News as we were covering the election, and I said, trump's not a Republican. He's a Democrat. He's a nationalist. We haven't seen one in a long time. And he's now basically reframing the political debate, which he's now successfully done. The Republican Party is a nationalist party, and I do think that part of that is going to be hard to get out of our system once it gets there. It's, and I don't mean a patriot, I mean a nationalist. Hey, one thing about them, they're sending their rape, they're sending rapists and murders. I covered a mock election in a little town in the middle of Pennsylvania as part of the story. And it was school election, and the teachers were kind of gathered around watching the kids vote. Trump won overwhelmingly. And the teacher said, yeah, you guys in the media, you saw that thing and all you said was, yeah, he's sending the rapist. I said, well, yeah, that was kind of bad. He said, I bet you don't remember what he said next. And I said, all right, what do you say next? And they said, they're sending the drugs. He said, the guy said, you go into any one of these classrooms, you ask, ask how many kids have a loved one or somebody they know who's been in drug addiction. And I did it. And we put it on Nightline. Because every hand in that classroom went up.

Tim Miller (55:50)

I want to get into a couple other news things for you. Just a few more things on the tweet that changed your life. So were you expecting the next morning, Obviously, it leads to you leaving abc. I'm sure there's some limitations of what you can talk about. But what were those conversations like the next morning? Were you kind of expecting that it was over? Were you bullworthing it? Were you Jerry Maguiring this or were you kind of upset set that there was even an issue because you felt it was so accurate?

Terry Moran (56:16)

Yeah, well, the Bulworth reference, I have to say, I hate that movie. But the Jerry Maguire. No, I wasn't Jerry Maguiring it either. I don't want to go into all the gory details about what happened, but it was. I was rocked, clearly, and full of fear. Okay. And I realized that this was going to be a very serious situation and had to stand up and deal with it. And activity is one of the best things to assuage fear. But also, I thought about it in my own conscience first. And I thought, as I tell you, I wrote it because I thought it was true. And at the end of the day, when all the bad stuff has happened, my children will know that whatever it means, it means that.

Tim Miller (57:04)

Did you feel like you should have been able to stay there stuff within the context of what you run?

Terry Moran (57:08)

I don't know. That's a bureaucratic thing. I don't know. You know, actually it wasn't bureaucratic. It was their calculation and had the, the Stephanopoulos press. I, I shouldn't get too close to the line. From my perspective, it looked like a business decision and I, I became bad business. It feels like.

Tim Miller (57:24)

Yeah, I understand those limitations. But just one more thing on that. It is worth seeing what happened to you in that context. Right. Like there was a settlement with Trump over the Stephanopoulos thing, which to me was pretty borderline. We're seeing this in some of the other areas 60 minutes we've seen folks have to walk away from. So what do you make of just the broader environment around you having to leave? With regards to the media's response to Trump 2.0, that's a huge challenge because.

Terry Moran (57:53)

These media companies are part of bigger companies that have major business interests. And Trump has demonstrated with law firms, with universities, with companies that he will bring all the power he can. Rhetorical. And the power that is the people's to destroy them if they don't kowtow to him. That is the story in Industry after industry. The media is no different. And that has to be the calculation in the calculation of. And I'm not talking about any particular person of any executive. And we can't live like that. That. So, you know, one of the great things about where we are right now, Tim, is that we are free to speak our minds here in a way that. That people in other ways aren't. I'm not dislagging anybody. I want.

Tim Miller (58:42)

Sure. Did I. Were you worried after the settlement. Were you worried after the settlement that things might be going away, that that concerns you?

Terry Moran (58:49)

I should have been, but no, I wasn't. I was kind of known at abc, as somebody put it, and I think I know who it was. Somebody who I don't think enjoyed my explorations of the issues and such, that he's always had a very high opinion of his opinions, which is nasty when somebody's been fired. But fair comment, I suppose. But no, I didn't think anything like that was.

Tim Miller (59:15)

Yeah, I mean, you got the Trump interview in the meantime time, like in between that.

Terry Moran (59:20)

That was accidental.

Tim Miller (59:21)

It was.

Terry Moran (59:22)

There were factors like the settlement, like the debate, like other things. I was kind of low man on the totem pole and some of the others were kind of knocked off.

Bill Kristol (59:31)

So.

Tim Miller (59:33)

It was accidental that it was you. You mean, like you were kind of the default choice, that's what you're saying? Yeah, yeah.

Terry Moran (59:38)

Which I was. I had that last. Of all the things I've done at ABC News. I've been in 86 countries and lots of elections and conflict zones. I've had a wonderful career. There's.

Tim Miller (59:48)

I love a lot.

Terry Moran (59:49)

I love most of my colleagues who were there and have tremendous respect for the work they do under difficult circumstances. But it was clear that I was not the first choice there, and I had three days to prepare, and that was the most fun I've ever had.

Tim Miller (60:05)

All right, I want to get to the interview. Right. Next. But just really quick, have you seen Pelly's commencement? I assume you have since he left 60 Minutes.

Terry Moran (60:11)

Yeah.

Tim Miller (60:11)

Yeah. I mean, like quite powerful stuff. It is. Your departure from ABC is within that context. Right. You have somebody leaving 60 minutes and giving a commencement who is basically warning that we have real threats to democracy, to freedom of speech, to the free press, to diversity. And what did you make of his remarks?

Terry Moran (60:31)

I thought Scott was absolutely spot on. I'm now in a position where I can help in that good work, and that fills my joy as well. We can all put our shoulder to the wheel because I do think thinks he's right. This is a moment of danger, and I'm happy to be able to help if I can.

Tim Miller (60:51)

All right, back to the Trump interview. I have many thoughts on it. I've now watched the Zapruder film three or four times through. What was going through your head when he starts arguing with you about how Kilmar Gregor Garcia actually did have the letters MS.13 tattooed on his hand?

Terry Moran (61:11)

I couldn't believe he went there. And also. So we were in the Oval Office and we had a time limit, so I had a couple of issues to get to. And then I couldn't let it slide. And so I said no. So no, not right. No Photoshop. And it was like a dog with a bone. Okay. It was like he was nuts about it. And I'm thinking. And so I'm a little freelancing at this point. This is not something I had attended to grill on him. To grill him on and had fact checked everything. But I. I'm kind of know that in the photographs when he's in El Salvador, they're not there and da da, da them. I don't know. I'm not an expert in tattoos, all that stuff. And he kept at it so much. So he was very angry at the end of the interview, and we were supposed to do a rose garden walk. And he said, not after that interview. You know, it was a bad feeling. And he stormed out. And of course, then I said, okay, that's good. Good, good day's work. And of course, we were going to put an hour in prime time, so we were short, so we had to get him back. And I. The. There was executives who went. And Susie Wiles, chief of staff, went back. And then he managed to come back and he said, look, I'm. I'm just gonna sit at this desk. You're gonna stand there, I'm gonna point some things out, and then that's it. No rub for me.

Tim Miller (62:28)

Oh. So that was. Cause it ended up being at the beginning when he's showing you the photos of my favorite. One part of that exchange is you asked him why he has the James Monroe photo up there. And he's like, well, the Monroe Doctrine. And you're like, well, what was it about the Monroe Doctrine? And he's like, very important. It was very important. So I was like, I'm not. I think it leaves some questions about his familiarity with what the Monroe document actually was. So my nitpick of you. I know you're doing it live. I have to live through all this. I rewatch My shit now. And it's like, it's harder than it looks. But, you know, at one point you're like, he's adamant that it's like it said Ms. 13. And you go, agree to disagree. I want to move on to something else. And he would not let you stop. Then he continued, and you're giving him agree to disagree, which is maybe wrong. And it's kind of like if Trump was saying, the moon is made of cheese, and you're like, agree to disagree. Let's move on. And then he's like, no, the moon is made of cheese, Terry.

Terry Moran (63:29)

Well, and the last thing I said in that. That's fair. And I've seen people who said I should have gotten up on my. My soapbox and say, how dare you, Mr. President. First, I don't do theater. And second, I felt the facts had been well established for anyone who to look at them. And third, the last thing I said was, it's contested.

Tim Miller (63:49)

Yeah.

Terry Moran (63:50)

So, yeah, the agreed to discrete thing was an error. I agree.

Tim Miller (63:53)

But he was adamant. That's the funny part. And, like, you had him. But he really thought it. Right. I mean, like, there's no way to interpret that other than that he really thought that the MS.13 was on his fingers.

Terry Moran (64:03)

Yes.

Tim Miller (64:04)

Not only.

Terry Moran (64:04)

So back in the. His hold or wherever he went, because we were in the Oval, he apparently told Stephen Chung, go get the photograph. I'm going out there. I'm going out there, I'm going to show him. And A, that shows he's got terrible staff work who are too afraid of him to tell him the truth. B, that he was still fixated on.

Bill Kristol (64:26)

Yeah.

Tim Miller (64:26)

And that he's, like, extremely gullible. And also shows. I just. I mean, truth is truth. It wasn't a convincing tattoo, really, on the fingers.

Terry Moran (64:38)

It wasn't. But he has demonstrated the capacity to bend reality, to bend truth for tens of millions of Americans simply through sheer force of will.

Tim Miller (64:47)

Another thing, when I was rewatching the interview this morning, that struck me was there's this. There's a section on his meeting with Zelensky that happened in. In Vatican City. And you were talking about how striking it was and, like, how there's this historic photo, you know, moving photo maybe, or historic between the two of them in the Vatican. And there's that somber photo that people have of Trump leaning forward and staring at him. And I just watched that with, like, a month's difference. And it really is striking how that actually was nothing, you know, like Trump. Like Trump is very. You said you don't do theater. Trump does theater. Like, he was happy for that to be theater. Like him and Zelenskyy having this serious meeting in Vatican City. But. But unfortunately, it's changed nothing, Right? And I guess we had over the weekend that Trump got a happy birthday call from Putin and nothing has changed.

Terry Moran (65:44)

Well, has nothing changed, though, Tim? Because it's like he's disappointed and I think he's still going to abandon Ukraine. Trump's fairly bent on that, but I do feel that he thought he could just wave his bending reality wand and get. Make peace there. And the reason I did kind of lay it on a little thick, this moving photo, this historic photo, whatever it was, was to get them to open up a little bit about it.

Tim Miller (66:13)

Yeah, no, I wasn't really criticism in that moment. It felt that way. You know, there was like a moment of, okay, well, gosh, we've got a new Pope. They're meeting there in the Vatican. And, you know, his fake reality about what Russia wants is, you know, crumbling, right? And, you know, we had, it had been a month prior that they had had the shouting match, you know, the kids, you know, food fight in the West Wing. Right. And maybe this is a sign of progress, and it's kind of like this guy is not movable. You know, I don't. I. I guess my point is the majesty of the Vatican and the reality of Putin's behavior, like, directionally hasn't really changed where Trump's posture is on all this.

Terry Moran (66:55)

He came into office bent on abandoning Ukraine. He has, as far as he has this kind of thing, he's one of the world historical figures. Henry Kissinger, just before he died, saw it. He said, Trump is one of those figures that history brings forward who marks the end of one era. Right. And I thought, that's Trump. How much he has a grand theory, I don't know. But he does, as far as he does, sees great power politics as the world. You get Ukraine, we get Greenland and Canada or whatever, and that's the way he sees the world. Like Risk.

Tim Miller (67:31)

Was there anything else that struck you from the interview and you mentioned earlier, you got more and more mad over time. I do think it said something about. Says something about his personality, right. That he comes in his tone at the beginning of the interview like he's malleable, right? Like, if you had just kind of sucked up to him and just said, sir, look at all this progress on the border, and, you know, whatever, like. And Henry Kissinger said, you marked the end of history, he would have went along with you throughout it. The dramatic change of his temperament, I think is pretty noteworthy because a lot of politicians you've interviewed probably keep it a lot cooler than that, even when challenged.

Terry Moran (68:07)

Yes, I'd say a couple things about that. First, I did say that the accomplishment on the border is staggering and a judgment on Democrats. The fact that arrests at the border order are down to close to zero, basically simply because obviously there's cruelty, I believe there's the actions in courts have found to be illegal. But simply saying we will enforce our laws and you will be arrested. That it was, it's the force of that more than any individual arrest and the terror campaign that it amounts to against people who are here, you know, without the authority of law. But it really is the credibility that was lacking, whether in a vicious way or a virtuous way. There was no credibility to our border. So I gave him that. I said, you know, it's amazing. The other thing I'd say is that I tried to be as respectful as I could. He's the President of the United States. People in the Constitution put him there and he deserves respect in that regard. And I just don't think he brooks anything but praise. And that I couldn't, obviously I wasn't going to do.

Tim Miller (69:18)

Right. And that's the striking thing to me. It's like, it's not like you went in there with Trump, like going at him in the hardest possible way or being rude or whatever, but he just is unable to handle the slightest amount of pushback. I mean, that is a noteworthy trait when you consider, you know, he's gonna have to make some high stakes decisions here on the next. Over the next three and a half years.

Terry Moran (69:42)

Over the next three and a half years. That's it. Yeah. No, he's a, he's a piece of work, as we all know. And I just will also say this, you know, just kind of batting it back and forth with him for that amount of time. You're looking into someone's eyes, you know, what do you see? I saw, he's mean. He can lash out at any moment. You can feel that. And I think there's also, so obviously he's a, you see him on the golf course, he's enjoys people and he's a sociable person. But I. What, I don't think, I don't think.

Tim Miller (70:13)

He'S that tough if he can't handle you. You mean, he's not that tough.

Terry Moran (70:17)

At one point I, he said something like, you know, because I asked the question, you know, do you have 100% confidence in headsets? And he said, stupid question. I don't have 100 confidence in anything. I don't have 100% confidence this interview is going to. Even is going to. Whatever. We're going to finish the interview of you. And I just said, no, we will. And he just said, all right, go on. He just gave that up. I just felt like. And I didn't really even intend to back him down, but he did. He's never mentioned me. I have a name built for Trump tweet, and I've heard it since I was in third grade. Terry Moron. I'm kind of. I was waiting for the Everybody. And everybody. Everybody says it, thinks they invented it. Right. I've been hearing it my whole life, and he hasn't whispered anything about. Not even about this. He hasn't even dunked on me for this. Not that he. Not that he had not want him to. I don't. But I don't know what that means.

Tim Miller (71:10)

It's the weirdest part of the whole Trump phenomenon. I mean, you said, you know, you said you were kind of on to it. You saw the appeal of the nationalism and really to Brexit at the beginning. But something I can't really grasp is that to me, he's just obviously weak. Right. And that he's not. He's not the traditional, you know, kind of tough man and the John Wayne, you know, kind of. Which is obviously fake, but like, you know, like this sort of strong, silent type that, you know, conservatives and folks have traditionally held up as being what it means to be a tough, strong guy. Like, he's the opposite of that. He's like a whiny child. And it is interesting to me that, that, that that myth of him as a tough guy persists.

Terry Moran (71:55)

Yeah.

Tim Miller (71:56)

What do you think that is?

Terry Moran (71:57)

That's a great point. Although there's one moment when he rose from the ground after being shot at that was tough. And told him. Told him, I gotta stand up. And he had enough of a sense of his own Persona in front of the country to do that. I'm not gonna take that away from him, but I guess that's a fair point. Point. But I. But I hear what you're saying, which is that, you know, my dad was. I was thinking of my father yesterday, and he was in World War II. He joined right after Pearl harbor, ended up in the airborne paratrooper in the Pacific on the islands, you know, Philippines, Okinawa, and then the occupation of Japan. Never much talked about it. He hated Braggarts. He hated blowhards because men of that generation, and by tradition, Americans, we used to, like, think those guys. Bullies, all those. And now he is, you know, the leader of the biggest and most important political movement certainly of my lifetime, if not, you know, one of the biggest in history.

Tim Miller (73:01)

Yeah. Wild. You are right about the Butler thing. I know. It almost feels like it's fake. It almost makes me think we're living in a simulation. What happened in Butler, to be honest, just one more thing I just was thinking about right now, like, thinking about the interview you had with. With him and the Ms. Thirteen fingers and his, like, his ability to kind of suspend disbelief when it benefits him. You did ask about the other thing that I'm obsessed with, which is the Venezuelans that we have now kidnapped and sent to El Salvador without any due process. And you asked him about that, and you. You did push him on it about how, like, we don't know, some of these people might not be bad people. Right. And. And he kind of had the same response to you that he did on the finger. He's like, no, Terry, he's like, we know these people are bad. I do think that he's convinced himself of that. Right. And to me, that presents an opportunity in the same way that the fingers did. The bubble can be punctured. The dis. Reality bubble can be punctured. That does happen with Trump from time to time. It didn't happen on the 2020 election, but it's happened on. Grego Garcia was able to come back. His buddies in the hotel industry now aren't going to have deportations. There are certain ways that the stuff can, and I don't know you make of that. His response to you on the Venezuela issue.

Terry Moran (74:15)

You know what? I hear what you're saying to me, and I agree. I left a trick on the table there, if you will. Right. I did. And it was the way we figure it out, if they're bad guys is through due process. And you know what? You get large majorities of Americans who agree with that he will be stopped. But he needed to be pressed on that because it's circular. How do you know? Well, I know know, and that's easily punctured. And I did leave that trick on the table.

Tim Miller (74:42)

I'd say, yeah, on this. He did a. He did a bleat over the weekend on his feed. I want to get your reaction to, because it's related to sort of all these issues ICE officers are here with. He's come up with an old English word He likes now herewith, ICE officers are herewith ordered by notice of this truth to do all in their power to achieve the very important goal of delivering the single largest mass deportation program in history. In order to achieve this, we must expand efforts to detain and deport illegal aliens in la, Chicago, New York, where millions upon millions of them reside, and other such cities which are the core of the Democratic power center, where they use illegal aliens to expand their voter base. I wonder what you made of that.

Terry Moran (75:22)

That's the real thing. We're there. He wants to send troops into the homes, homelands of the strongholds, political strongholds, of his opponents and punish them for objecting to his policies and trying to stop him from exercising the authorities of the office that he has in this way. And I think that we're there. We're there. This is a threat to send troops into the cities run by Democrats so he can do what he wants there. And I also get a feeling, is.

Tim Miller (76:03)

The there in that sentence authoritarianism? What is the there?

Terry Moran (76:07)

Yeah, where we're there at the crisis of our free government. If a president of the United States is saying, I'm sending troops into cities in part for political reasons, because my political opponents are in power there and I want the troops there in defiance of the black letter of the law, I think it's safe to say we can't turn our eyes from it anymore. This is an attempt at changing the nature of the American democracy. Right. And they do so with lies. Let me just raise Stephen Miller once again. When the Supreme Court said that the government must facilitate the return of Grego Garcia, Guillermo Gregor Garcia to the United States, Stephen Miller came out and said with his venomous demeanor, the Supreme Court, nine to nothing, upheld the president's right to what the Supreme Court says. No court can tell you how much money to spend, what flight they have to be on, by what date. But the order is law and you must facilitate it. You must do it under this order. And he spit on that with his lie that the Supreme Court upheld the president's position nine to nothing, that kind of lie and then this kind of decree. What would you call that if you saw that in another country? What would you call it?

Tim Miller (77:31)

Yeah, I mean, it's a path to urbanism for sure. It's a crackdown on due process. And so, you know, we can come up with other words. You want authoritarianism, light urbanism. You know, we can debate that, academics can debate that, but I think the true facts are there. To me, Terry, it's like. And I see, Stephen, in this post from Trump, it is in addition to everything you said, it is him ensuring that there is no misunderstanding about his statements from last week about how maybe trips should, maybe the ice agents should chill out on the farms and the hotels. Right. And I think that there was a concern that there was a misread of that, and he wants to reassure everybody that, no, my top priority is we are going to deport these people. We are going to deport these people no matter what, no matter whether they've committed crimes or not. Like, we want to have the biggest deportation in history, and we're going to come into your towns and to your businesses and do it. And I think that was the point.

Terry Moran (78:37)

It was the point. But combine those two social media posts and statements, and what you get is we're going to come into their towns and their cities. And if you, you are on my side, I can do a deal with you. But if you stand up to me, then I will send the troops into, into your, your towns and cities. And that is not just organism. Look at the godfather of all this is Putin. Right. Kgb, but never forget, was a lawyer. Right. And I think he, if you look at how, because I covered. I've been in Russia since 1999, probably, I don't know, 12, 15 times. And I have seen and have felt, and my friends and colleagues there have felt the civic space shrink more and more. And in Poland as well, dear friend, in Poland, when the law and justice government there was trying to destroy the judiciary. And I asked my friend and colleague Tomikrowski, I said, we were late one night at the bureau in London, and I said, what does it feel like? How do ordinary people do? And he said this. He said, your life gets smaller. You don't put your head up over the parapet. You don't look at it. You go to the cafe, you have the best life. You can think how many people are already leading that life in the United States and may be soon.

Tim Miller (79:55)

And you see that happening here, not just among immigrants, but also among the broader population or right now, you're saying that that's kind of limited to the, that's kind of the first step is the immigrant class.

Terry Moran (80:07)

Well, whatever one decides about the journalistic ethics of my post. Right. And I'll let that conversation continue. I'm happy to. I think it's an important conversation at this moment, and people can make up their minds one way or the other. I'm proof that you don't want to get in the way of this, of this administration, not that I want to make it about me. Let me, Let me withdraw that. But say a lot of people, a lot of people, people are watching what they say and where they say it.

Tim Miller (80:36)

And just from your experience in Russia, like, how much of a parallel are you seeing? Well, all right, I mean, look, obviously, I mean, like, we're at a different level now, but it's been a long arc from Gorbachev to now. It's like, do you see our. Do you see us on that trajectory somewhere?

Terry Moran (80:53)

I would have to say, we're such a different country. The instruments of oppression were at hand in Russia and their civil institutions were not. We have a robust system and it'll withstand a lot. But the idea that one person defines the national interest, one person defines what's good about the country, what's not. One person defines who's a good guy, who's a bad guy. One person exercises the power that they have in those ways. Yeah, it's similar, but what I feel is the experience of, of that space shrinking. Right, for people. And I don't think it'll work. I mean, I could be wrong, but the good guys are gonna win. And as I said in one of the first substacks, what a joy it is to be an American and alive at this moment in our history. This is a privilege that we have right now to speak out and use our voices and to say no. Those no Kings protest were a moment. Right. Gotta build on it, but it was a moment.

Tim Miller (82:00)

All right. So that takes us to the last thing. So you are free now. You're free man. Just you. You and your substack, your subscribers, you can go check them out on Terry Maria substack, you know, at least until the ICE troops come into Frederick, Maryland. You're a free man. What do you want to do? What are you wanting to pop off on? I mean, it could go a lot of different directions. Are you going to be. Let all those opinions out? You've been stifling. Are you going to do interviews? What do you think is the most value valuable thing for you to be doing right now?

Terry Moran (82:26)

Yes, all the above and more. Look, I'd like to do some more of what I was doing at abc. Look, the great thing about ABC and all those legacy media organizations, and they are great in their way, and I, as I say, I've got nothing to say against them. I had a wonderful career. We're working out some details at the end. But the great thing is the resources that they can bring around the world. I don't have those resources at this point, but I'd like to keep doing reporting as I did. And I'll tell you the first place I want to go. I want to go to Springfield, Ohio. Go back to Springfield, Ohio, where I spent a week or so twice during the campaign. And I want to go back to the Haitian community that was there and their neighbors, now that they are being, you know, sent out, sent back to Haiti, and what that's going to do to the town. And not just the Haitian people there, but the town had come to depend on them, that the town had. Was falling flat, and now it had risen. The mayor wanted them there, Governor DeWine wanted them there. And now that's going to be a radical and cruel change. And so that kind of thing I'll do. But interviews, I hope. Newsmaker interviews. And I love, by the way, I love the bulwark, and it's why I wanted to be with you. It's absolutely thrilling to be in these new spaces. I don't have a great idea what the brand is going to be, but if there is such a thing. But I'm keen to find out.

Tim Miller (83:47)

I'm obsessed with that Springfield story, too. So that's great. Check in. Let's do a check in when you get out there. I would love to do that. And final thing, do you see a beer summit coming for you and Stephen Miller, or are you planning to meet in his cave somewhere or any thoughts on that?

Terry Moran (84:04)

I'm going to emphasize I was describing the public, man. I don't by my nature want people to feel bad from something I said or wrote or did.

Tim Miller (84:14)

But sometimes that's the difference between you and me, Terry. We found the one area of disagreement.

Terry Moran (84:20)

But you gotta tell the truth, right? That's the job. You gotta tell the truth. So I don't see a beer summit. In fact, I see probably maybe a couple of cop cars pulling up. And then I need a lawyer.

Tim Miller (84:32)

Good luck out there, man. I really appreciate you doing this. I'm excited to watch what you're gonna be doing going forward and let's check in from time to time. How about about that?

Terry Moran (84:41)

That's great. Thanks, Tim.

Tim Miller (84:42)

All right. Good luck, brother. We'll see you soon.

Unknown (84:44)

Take this job and shove it. I ain't working here no more. My woman died and left and took all of the reasons I was working for. You better not try to stand in my way when I walk out the door. Take this job and shove it I ain't working here no more.

Terry Moran (85:21)

I've been.

Unknown (85:22)

Working in this factory pretty close to 15 years. I seen some of my best friends wear my Standing in a pool of tears I seen a lot of kin folks dying Had a lot of bills to pay? Lord, I'd give the shirt right off in my bag if I had the guts to say take this job and shove it? I ain't a working hair no more? My woman got left and took all of the reasons I was working for? You better not try to stand in my way when I walk out the door? Take this job and shove it I ain't working here no more.

Tim Miller (86:25)

The Bulwark Podcast is produced by Katie Cooper, with audio engineering and editing by Jason Brown.