The Bulwark Podcast: Bill Kristol on "Fake Nicey-Nicey Sht"**
Episode Title: Bill Kristol: Fake Nicey-Nicey Sh**t
Release Date: December 16, 2024
Host: Tim Miller
Guest: Bill Kristol
Introduction
In this episode of The Bulwark Podcast, host Tim Miller engages in a candid and insightful discussion with political commentator Bill Kristol. Titled "Fake Nicey-Nicey Sh**t," the conversation delves into the ramifications of corporate capitulation in the face of political pressure, the evolving dynamics within the Republican Party, and the broader implications for American democracy.
ABC News' Defamation Settlement with Donald Trump
The episode opens with a critical examination of ABC News' recent $15 million settlement in a defamation lawsuit filed by Donald Trump. Tim Miller highlights the controversy surrounding the network's reporting, where George Stephanopoulos reportedly referred to Trump as being "adjudicated for sexual assault" during a civil suit verdict.
Notable Quote:
"This kind of, as you say, preemptive capitulation is just terrible."
— Bill Kristol [02:30]
Kristol criticizes ABC News for what he perceives as a premature and unnecessary settlement, arguing that it sets a dangerous precedent. He expresses concerns about the intimidation effect such lawsuits may have on media outlets and individuals who wish to hold powerful figures accountable.
Impact on Free Speech: Kristol emphasizes that the settlement could create a chilling effect, discouraging honest discourse and investigative journalism. He warns that corporate giants like Disney, with vast legal resources, capitulating in such cases may embolden figures like Trump to leverage the legal system as a tool for intimidation.
Corporate Capitulation and Its Consequences
The conversation shifts to the broader theme of corporate capitulation. Tim Miller and Bill Kristol discuss how major corporations are seemingly tucking their tails in the face of political pressure, prioritizing survival over transparency and accountability.
Notable Quote:
"The chilling effect element of this is really staggering."
— Tim Miller [05:27]
Kristol draws parallels to actions taken by authoritarian figures like Viktor Orban in Hungary, highlighting the potential for widespread suppression of dissent if corporations continue to bow to political demands. He underscores the importance of maintaining a free press that does not fear government retribution.
Mitt Romney's Endorsement and the Republican Party's Future
A significant portion of the episode is dedicated to Mitt Romney's recent endorsement remarks, where he aligns himself with the MAGA wing of the Republican Party. This marks a departure from his previous stance and raises questions about the party's direction.
Notable Exchange:
Jake Tapper: "You could not have less respect for somebody than long ago."
Mitt Romney: "MAGA is the Republican Party and Donald Trump is the Republican Party today." [11:35-12:20]
Tim Miller expresses frustration over Romney's shift, feeling that it undermines earlier criticisms of Trump and J.D. Vance. Kristol agrees, labeling the endorsement as a capitulation that invalidates past arguments against Trump's leadership and the ideologies he represents.
Democratic Party's Internal Dynamics and Oversight Committee Leadership
The discussion transitions to the Democratic Party's internal struggles, particularly regarding leadership within oversight committees. Tim Miller brings up Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (AOC) potentially spearheading the committee, juxtaposed with more traditional figures like Gerry Connolly.
Notable Quote:
"My instinct is to think, why not do AOC?"
— Bill Kristol [31:13]
Kristol shows tentative support for AOC leading the oversight committee, believing her aggressive stance could be beneficial in challenging the Trump administration. However, he acknowledges potential reservations among moderates who may be uncomfortable with her dynamic approach.
Tim Miller shares similar sentiments, advocating for a more assertive Democratic oversight presence to counteract the current administration's tactics. Both agree that while AOC brings passion and visibility, there are concerns about balancing her boldness with effective governance.
Bernie Sanders on the Rise of Oligarchy
The podcast also features a segment discussing Bernie Sanders' remarks on the growing oligarchic tendencies within American society. Sanders warns of the concentration of wealth and power among billionaires, drawing parallels to oligarchical systems in other countries.
Notable Quote:
"I don't think it's quite the same in both parties and I think honestly it's the political power side of it that's most scary."
— Bill Kristol [27:33]
Kristol concurs with Sanders, highlighting the Democratic Party's acknowledgment of wealth inequality as a pressing issue. He contrasts this with the Republican approach, which he views as more aligned with oligarchical and authoritarian tendencies, particularly through alliances with figures like Elon Musk and Donald Trump.
Final Thoughts and Broader Implications
As the episode wraps up, Tim Miller and Bill Kristol reflect on the state of American politics. They express concern over the apparent alignment of major corporations and political figures with authoritarian practices, fearing significant long-term damage to democratic institutions and societal norms.
Notable Quote:
"We're going down. We're going down."
— Bill Kristol [33:53]
Kristol emphasizes the urgent need for vigilance and proactive measures to safeguard democratic principles against the encroaching influence of oligarchic power structures. The conversation serves as a clarion call for both the media and political institutions to resist capitulation and uphold the values of free speech and accountability.
Conclusion
In "Fake Nicey-Nicey Sh**t," Bill Kristol provides a sobering analysis of the intersection between corporate behavior, political pressure, and the erosion of democratic safeguards. Through thoughtful dialogue, the episode underscores the challenges facing liberal democracy and the imperative to confront and counteract authoritarian tendencies within both major political parties and corporate entities.
Note: Advertisements, musical interludes, and non-content sections from the transcript have been omitted to focus on the substantive discussions between Tim Miller and Bill Kristol.