The Chairish Podcast: Episode Summary Title: Modern Living in Historic Homes: Renovations that Last
Release Date: October 8, 2024
Host: Michael Boudreau
Guests:

• Timothy Corrigan: Interior Designer specializing in historic architecture
• Robert O'Byrne: Writer and Lecturer on Fine and Decorative Arts

Introduction: The Allure and Challenge of Historic Homes

In the October 8, 2024 episode of The Chairish Podcast, host Michael Boudreau delves into the complexities of renovating historic homes to meet modern living standards without compromising their historical integrity. Joined by interior design expert Timothy Corrigan and esteemed author Robert O'Byrne, the conversation centers on balancing preservation with contemporary needs in various architectural masterpieces, from French chateaus to Irish country houses.

The Appeal of Historic Homes to Modern Buyers

Robert O'Byrne initiates the discussion by addressing the continued interest of international buyers in Irish historic properties. “People coming from abroad see the particular qualities of Irish architecture over the centuries that perhaps those of us who are too close to it might not necessarily catch for ourselves” (03:50). This perspective highlights a universal phenomenon where outsiders appreciate the charm of places that natives might overlook.

Timothy Corrigan expands on this by explaining the financial attractiveness of purchasing old country houses in France. “The cost per square foot to buy one of these old country houses in France is literally a fraction of the cost of anything else of any other property” (05:04). Despite the high initial investment in restoration, the low entry cost makes these properties appealing as long-term investments.

Navigating the Challenges of Renovation

Renovating historic homes presents unique challenges, particularly in integrating modern amenities. Timothy Corrigan shares his experience upgrading the American ambassador's residence in Paris, emphasizing non-invasive methods: “We actually used the fireplace ducts to put all the ducting” (08:02). This approach allowed for the installation of central air conditioning without disturbing the original structure, demonstrating that modernization and preservation can coexist.

However, Robert O'Byrne points out the stringent EU regulations that complicate renovations. “EU legislation... is very much about trying to improve environmental issues. And obviously old-fashioned things like fusing systems... are very much out of fashion now” (06:44). These regulations often require significant upgrades that can be financially burdensome, as government assistance typically covers only a fraction of the costs.

Cultural Differences in Restoration Practices

The conversation shifts to the availability and quality of artisans necessary for restoration projects. Robert O'Byrne notes a positive trend in Ireland, where a new generation of artisans is emerging, skilled in traditional crafts: “There's a number of different courses available where you can learn traditional craft skills” (26:39). In contrast, Timothy Corrigan describes challenges in France, where artisans often price themselves as artists, making their services expensive and less accessible: “They often price themselves out of the market” (27:16).

The Role of Color in Historic Interiors

A significant portion of the discussion revolves around the use of color in historic homes. Contrary to common misconceptions, Robert O'Byrne explains that historic interiors were often vibrant: “They have bright colored rooms very much thought in terms of let's put color on the walls and everything” (22:25). Timothy Corrigan shares a personal anecdote about a misstep in color selection, illustrating the importance of context in design: “I took a color reader... and I took it into the rooms and surreptitiously got the exact color... it was neon yellow. It was so horrible” (24:35). This story underscores that while bold colors are historically accurate, their application must consider the surrounding environment and lighting.

Balancing Modern Needs with Historical Integrity

Timothy Corrigan and Robert O'Byrne discuss the delicate balance between meeting contemporary living standards and preserving historical elements. Corrigan emphasizes respectful updates: “When it comes to the shell, I think it's important to appropriately update the structure of the house for the needs of today and be respectful of it” (17:40). They agree that modern amenities like kitchens and bathrooms are essential, but must be integrated in a way that maintains the property's character.

Client Relationships and Ethical Restoration

The guests highlight the importance of working with clients who are committed and understanding of the renovation process. Robert O'Byrne describes such clients as “crazy, but happily so” (10:21), indicating their passion and determination to see projects through despite the challenges. Ethical restoration often requires setting boundaries with clients to prevent “desecration” of historic properties. For instance, Corrigan recounts a project where adjacent alterations were necessary but managed without compromising the building’s authenticity: “We did a listed house in London... I was a little resistant... but we were able to maintain all the original architecture” (31:37).

The Impact of Social Media and Awareness

Social media platforms like Instagram and Pinterest play a dual role in the restoration of historic homes. While they can spread unrealistic expectations, they also serve as educational tools, increasing awareness and appreciation for historical properties. Robert O'Byrne notes, “Pinterest... are indirect educational tools that people have become much more aware of, of what the past has to offer” (35:08). Sharing restoration journeys online fosters a community of support and inspiration, making the arduous process more manageable and rewarding.

Training and Availability of Artisans

Robert O'Byrne and Timothy Corrigan discuss the availability of skilled artisans necessary for restoration. In Ireland, the emergence of trained artisans has alleviated some challenges, whereas in France, particularly in rural areas, finding specialized labor remains difficult. Corrigan shares his efforts to bring in craftsmen from different regions to complete projects, highlighting the logistical hurdles: “I had to bring some people in from the south of France to do some plaster work” (28:48).

Conclusion: Preserving History for Future Generations

The episode concludes with reflections on the profound personal and cultural rewards of restoring historic homes. Timothy Corrigan expresses that restoration is life-transforming, offering deep satisfaction beyond the frustrations: “It will be so much more rewarding than you ever possibly thought it would be” (12:13). Robert O'Byrne adds that owners become part of a continuum, embedding their stories into the fabric of these historic structures: “You are part of a long history... and you are actually embroidering that particular piece of tapestry yourself” (24:24).

Ultimately, both guests advocate for the preservation of historic homes as living entities that bridge the past and present, fostering a richer, more diverse architectural landscape for future generations.

Notable Quotes:

• Robert O'Byrne on Foreign Buyers: “People coming from abroad see the particular qualities of Irish architecture over the centuries that perhaps those of us who are too close to it might not necessarily catch for ourselves” (03:50).

• Timothy Corrigan on Renovation Costs: “The cost per square foot to buy one of these old country houses in France is literally a fraction of the cost of anything else of any other property” (05:04).

• Timothy Corrigan on Air Conditioning Installation: “We actually used the fireplace ducts to put all the ducting... so now you actually can run air conditioning throughout all the structure” (08:02).

• Robert O'Byrne on Client Determination: “I'd probably describe them as crazy, but happily so” (10:21).

• Timothy Corrigan on Color Misstep: “I took a color reader... and I took it into the rooms... it was neon yellow. It was so horrible” (24:35).

• Robert O'Byrne on Irish Color Trends: “Mariga decided that strong colors were the way to go... bright yellow walls or green” (22:42).

For more insights and inspiration, listeners are encouraged to explore Robert O'Byrne’s book The Irish Country House: A New Vision and Timothy Corrigan’s At Home in Inspiration and Style in Town and Country. These resources provide deeper dives into the art and challenges of restoring historic homes.