wavePod

Get Wave AI

Charlie's Global Fight for Free Speech with Dr. James Orr - The Charlie Kirk Show | Wave AI Podcast Notes

Back to The Charlie Kirk Show

Charlie's Global Fight for Free Speech with Dr. James Orr

The Charlie Kirk Show

Wed Sep 24 2025

Summary

Podcast Summary: The Charlie Kirk Show — "Charlie's Global Fight for Free Speech with Dr. James Orr"

Date: September 24, 2025
Host: Andrew Colvett (executive producer, Standing in for Charlie Kirk)
Guests: Tom Homan (former ICE director), Dr. James Orr (University of Cambridge), Blake Neff (producer)

MAIN THEME & PURPOSE

This poignant episode is shaped by the assassination of Charlie Kirk, founder of Turning Point USA and the podcast’s original host. The episode serves as both a tribute to Charlie’s legacy and a forceful conversation about contemporary threats to free speech, political violence, and the state of Western civilization, with special focus on the UK and US. Dr. James Orr, a scholar and friend of Charlie, joins alongside producers and other prominent guests to discuss Charlie’s global impact, the rising climate of political extremism, and the enduring importance of faith and moral clarity in public life.

KEY DISCUSSION POINTS & INSIGHTS

1. Opening: A Nation in Mourning & the Reality of Political Violence

[00:48] Andrew Colvett opens, acknowledging Charlie Kirk’s assassination and the latest in a string of targeted attacks on ICE agents in Texas.
[01:34] Tom Homan relays how an ICE facility in Dallas was shot at, making it the third such attack against immigration officials in Texas. A bullet had an anti-ICE slogan: “It was clearly a targeted attack.”

Notable Quote:

“Assaults on ICE officers are up over 1,000%. ... If hate-filled rhetoric doesn’t decrease, it’s going to end in bloodshed, someone’s going to die. I was called a fear monger. Unfortunately, I was right.” — Tom Homan [03:30]
There is condemnation of rising violent targeting of law enforcement and border personnel, attributed to inflamed political rhetoric on the left.

2. Political Rhetoric and Divergent Attitudes Toward Violence

[05:48] Andrew presents a poll: 30% of US liberals aged 18-39 agree that violence is sometimes justified for political goals. The contrast is drawn with conservatives, who poll as the most peaceful group.
[07:09] Homan criticizes universities for fomenting extremism and blames mainstream media for a hostile narrative: “There’s groups that hate President Trump more than they love their communities or have any common sense. ... It’s just out of control.”
Tom Homan shares personal impact: “I have a 24/7 security detail because of threats. I don’t live with my family. But I’m not going away.” [08:46]

3. Remembering Charlie Kirk: Scholar, Friend, Prophetic Voice

[12:03] Dr. James Orr reminisces about Charlie’s insatiable curiosity and thirst for spiritual and intellectual growth:

“In all my years teaching at Oxford and Cambridge, I’ve never met someone with that thirst for knowledge, for intellectual formation, spiritual wisdom…” [12:03]
Charlie’s humility and aspiration to understand philosophy and bring it to a wider audience are highlighted through anecdotes of their last days together.

4. Charlie’s Impact in the UK: Challenging the Zeitgeist

[15:15 - 17:54] Discussion of Charlie’s visit to Oxbridge and his attempts to “wake up” British youth and leadership. Charlie is framed as a “modern prophet,” calling both Americans and Brits to remember their national character.
[19:44] Dr. Orr reflects: “If one side is so quick to resort to lawfare, warfare, or violence…where does that leave liberalism?”
[20:32] Dr. Orr describes the grief among students after Charlie’s death, the spontaneous London vigil outside Downing Street, and the outpouring of love and admiration in the UK that followed his assassination.

5. UK Response, Media Narratives, and the Power of Peaceful Assembly

[21:58] Vigils and marches in support of Charlie are recounted, notable for their scale and peacefulness despite establishment/media anxiety.
[24:22] Comparable peacefulness at the Arizona memorial is described: “The whole event came and went without one arrest. ... Even the Super Bowl would have had someone get drunk and, like, punch a guy.” — Blake Neff [24:25]

6. Charlie’s Legacy: Spiritual and Cultural Turning Point

[25:20] Dr. Orr observes new conversations about faith, family, and national identity sweeping the UK:

“He’s unleashed something extraordinary. ... Conversations I simply, you know, was just very, very difficult to have before...something shifted.” [25:20]
A newfound openness about political and spiritual renewal is attributed to Charlie’s death and message.

7. University Intolerance and Threats to Free Speech

[27:14] Oxford Union’s president-elect is exposed for celebrating Charlie’s assassination in private messages (“Charlie Kirk got shot. Let’s effing go. Scoreboard.”) [28:08]
- This draws condemnation and a campaign for his removal.
- “Language like that, it lays down the enabling conditions…for violence.” — Dr. James Orr [31:00]
Andrew calls for students to take a principled stand: “That is not okay… For somebody to represent your school that would celebrate his death is shocking.” [30:00]

8. Media Culture, Contrition, and Fake Apologies

[44:00] Segment examining Jimmy Kimmel’s non-apology for initially blaming MAGA for the assassination.
Kimmel’s words dissected:

“It was never my intention to make light of the murder ... Nor was it my intention to blame any specific group…” — Jimmy Kimmel [44:00]
Dr. Orr explains the difference between real contrition and equivocation:

“Repentance…means a complete transformation of one’s mind, one’s intellect, one’s heart. It expresses itself in actions… not just defensive statements.” [45:31]

9. Free Speech in Britain: Law, Immigration, and Fear

[55:03] Dr. Orr describes the shift in British society — the move from a high-trust to a fragmented society, and how rapid demographic change has led to speech-policing:

“The police, you know, they are policing tweets, not streets. And it's…getting worse.” [57:08]
Discussion about the "Orwellian" category of “non-crime hate incidents,” database tracking, and hopes that a Nigel Farage government would prioritize free speech.

10. Political Violence: Bothsidesism, Data, and the Real Divide

[74:18] Blake Neff debunks media claims that right-wing violence eclipses left-wing violence, exposing flaws and biases in databases and how left-wing violence (e.g., 2020 riots) is often undercounted or ignored for convictions.
[80:23] Dr. Orr argues the true test is in crisis response:

“The true character of a political movement comes out in moments of crisis and of tragedy. The contrast is as clear as day between May 2020…and Charlie's death.” [80:23]

11. Faith, Revival, and the Future of the West

[61:29 - 62:11] Dr. Orr:

“The West is built out of Christianity…all our moral reflexes, even our atheism…is driven by a Christian impulse.” [61:29]
[64:01] Anecdotes about revival: Youth belief in God tripling in the UK; “something is stirring.”

12. Charlie as Salt and Light

[67:56] Clip of Charlie Kirk on Christian duty:

“Jesus called us to be salt and light. ... They don’t conform, they don’t affirm, they transform what they come in contact with.” [67:56]
Dr. Orr praises Charlie’s authentic, unflinching moral clarity and rhetorical power.

13. Charlie’s Enduring Legacy

[84:02] Dr. Orr:

“We need to bottle some Kirk Juice and bring it back to the mother country. But I think there’s going to be a lot of Kirk Juice in Britain now. ... It’s been unleashed.” [84:02]
Charlie’s death is described as a spark for spiritual and cultural renewal across Europe.

NOTABLE QUOTES

Tom Homan: “Assaults on ICE officers are up over 1,000%. ... The rhetoric is causing some of this violence. ... I have a 24/7 security detail because of threats.”
Dr. James Orr: “Never met anyone like him…you’re going to learn so much from each other. … He was prepping, prepping, prepping.”
Andrew Colvett: “Charlie was a modern prophet…calling our leaders to repent, calling our citizens to remember themselves.”
Blake Neff: “[The data] is a total sham. ... The reality is, when tragedy hits, look at who riots and who prays.”
Charlie Kirk (archival): “Are you transforming the environment you come in contact with? ... We must challenge people to be greater, to reach higher, to be biblical, to be Christlike.” [67:56]

TIMESTAMPS FOR IMPORTANT SEGMENTS

[01:34] Tom Homan details ICE attacks in Texas
[03:30] Homan on rising rhetoric and violence
[07:09] Homan on “not the country I grew up in”…media and colleges blamed
[08:46] Homan shares his own security/family situation
[12:03] Dr. Orr’s tribute to Charlie’s character and intellect
[17:54] Orr & Colvett recall Oxbridge debates, Charlie’s warmth, and groupthink
[19:44] Free speech battles and aftermath of assassination on UK campus culture
[24:22] Outpouring of peaceful mourners in US and UK
[25:20] Is Charlie’s death a political/religious turning point?
[27:14] Scandal at the Oxford Union, calls for condemnation
[44:00] Jimmy Kimmel’s apology analyzed
[55:03] Dr. Orr on UK hate speech laws and societal change
[74:18] Blake Neff debunks violence statistics
[80:23] Dr. Orr on how movements react in crisis
[84:02] Dr. Orr on Charlie’s legacy: “Kirk Juice…unleashed.”

FLOW & OVERALL TONE

The episode is reverent and reflective, balancing grief and righteous anger with a deeper ambition: to honor Charlie Kirk’s legacy and to examine the pressures, both political and spiritual, facing modern Western democracies. The language is unapologetically conservative, earnest, and intellectual, often infused with religious references and a sense of high moral urgency.

CONCLUSION

The episode mourns the loss of Charlie Kirk while issuing a clarion call for the preservation of free speech, for public moral clarity, and for a revival of faith in modern civic life. Listeners are left with an emphatic sense of Charlie’s unique legacy—both as a fallen voice and a catalyst for renewed engagement with the foundational values of Western civilization.

Loading summary...

Transcript

Tom Homan (0:00)

Satan.

Andrew Colvett (0:48)

Everybody, welcome to the Charlie Kirk Show. This is Andrew Colvett, executive producer of this show. And that empty chair reminds us of Charlie's legacy, his memory, and the fact that political violence took his life. An assassination did. And this morning we awoke to more news of political violence targeted at ICE in Texas. And to start off the show. And we had a whole show planned, but I thought it was important that we do this simply. It hits very close to home for this team, I can tell you. And so I wanted to have border czar Tom Homan kick off the top of the show with us. So borders are. Homan, thank you for joining us. What can you tell us about what happened in Texas?

Tom Homan (1:34)

Well, this morning, a lone gunman was targeting a nice facility in Dallas, Texas. It's where aliens are processed either for removal or transfer to a facility. And again, it's the third shooting that's occurred in Texas against immigration officials. And we had a shooter show up at a Border Patrol facility and open fire trying to kill Border Patrol agents. He was killed by agents. Then we had a group of people show up with weapons at an ICE detention facility in Alvarado, Texas, and try to kill ICE agents. And they did shoot one officer, a local police officer who's also responding to the scene. And now we have this today where a lone gunman stood at perch and opened up on ICE during a transportation transfer. And we know we have at least two dead and officers are uninjured. And it later was announced by Kash Patel that one of the bullets had an anti ICE slogan on the bullet. So this was clearly a targeted attack against ice.

Andrew Colvett (2:38)

Well, borders are. I just know that Charlie, this is his show, he was such a supporter of yours and was worried for our brave men and women in law enforcement that were doing what the voters had voted for very, very clearly to remove illegal aliens from this country. And we've seen these stats that the targetings on the increase that assaults against ICE officers, are we still seeing a ramp up? I mean, this instance is awful. Thank God no law enforcement were harmed or injured. But, you know, our prayers are with the families of the detainees that have lost their lives. But are we seeing this continue to ramp up across the country? Are we still seeing it go up? Are we seeing any calming down of the violence and the attacks against ICE officers?

Tom Homan (3:30)

First of all, you're right. I had many discussions with Charlie and he always ended the discussion to be safe and that ICE officers should be safe because the rhetoric has continued to increase. Assaults on ICE officers are up over 1,000%. And no, the rhetoric hasn't stopped. And I said months ago, months ago that if the HAPO rhetoric didn't decrease, it's going to end in bloodshed, someone's going to die. And of course I was called a fear monger. The left says I was making irresponsible comments. Unfortunately I was right. And just this past weekend we saw protests turn criminal in Chicago and in Boston. I mean in Chicago, the ICE facility is under attack. Portland, in Portland, Oregon, the ICE facility there has been under attack for months. So you know, no, it hasn't not slowed down either has the hateful rhetoric from some up on Hill, some are congressional representatives and other people who are in a position where that small fraction, I would say on the left, not everybody on the left is a bad person, most of them aren't. But there's that fraction that listens to this rhetoric and they feel empowered to take action against ice. If you've got a member of Congress comparing ICE to the secret police, which is a direct affiliation with the Nazis or calling straight out Nazis to terrorists or Governor Newsom just recently said the secret. I mean he just passed legislation about secret police. I mean, bottom line is that rhetoric is causing some of this violence. I've been calling people to stop the hateful rhetoric because more are going to be hurt. As a matter of fact, when we talked about the person that was shot at the Elboral city and we talked about the gunman that was killed at the border patrol city, I said at that time there's going to be more if the rhetoric doesn't stop. I've seen this game before, I've seen this story before and I just hate to see it right now. I hope between what happened to our officers across the country, what happened to Charlie and what's happened today, I mean, at what point do people just stop the hate? You can disagree what ICE does, but taking those toward actions, it's unbelievable. There's no excuse for it.

Dr. James Orr (12:03)

Well, Andrew, thank you. It's just so good to be with you. Despite the circumstances. And gosh, what a. What a surreal few days it's been. What an extraordinary achievement you guys pulled off. I was so thrilled to have. Being able to make it to the stadium on Sunday for that, that extraordinary day. And just so many thoughts going through my mind. But, you know, I've been teaching undergraduates, graduate students at Oxford and Cambridge on and off for 15, 16 years, and I can say, you know, hand on heart, I have never come across a young person with that. That thirst for knowledge, that thirst for intellectual formation, spiritual wisdom. You know, I spent weeks trying to. Trying to get him to call me James, but it was always Dr. Orr. So this is sort of extraordinary respect and humility that he had. And you're right, that last afternoon, just before I was getting off to the airport, I think that morning, a car was supposed to pick me up to take me to his apartment. And Mikey, Charlie's chief of staff, rang me and said, I've cancelled the car. I said, how am I gonna get to Charlie's apartment? He said, no, no, he wants to come and pick you up from the hotel so that he can have more time with you. And, you know, we had. We had a day together. We had a wonderful morning and went into his apartment and, yeah, two, three hours of just philosophy, just grilling me on. It's with that big, big whiteboard. He wanted me to, you know, map out moral philosophy help. He was just prepping, prepping, prepping. What if I get this question? What if I get that question? It was just extraordinary and absorbing it all, taking notes, grilling me, yes, I understand that point, but how do I make it accessible? And there was always this sense of this, the audience that he wanted to reach and not be in conflict with. Not to sort of dunk on them at all, but to inform them, to educate them, to enlighten them, just extraordinary. And then got back to London, getting texts from him, Bible verses from him, and then a text on, oh, that, that lecture by Jean Paul Sartre you mentioned on existentialism in 1946. Can you send me a copy? And can you explain to me that point is, okay, let's do it? And did that. And then on the first. My last text from him was on 1st September, saying, Can you send me a lecture on natural law? And. And God help me, I never got back to him. It was. Yeah, it was. It was a busy week. And I thought, I've got to sit down and do this properly. And. And then, you know, by the time things had calmed down, It. It had happened and yeah, I never met anyone like him. And, you know, you meet people who, you know that there's just. You're gonna be friends for, for years and years and years and you're going to learn so much from each other. And we had. We had great plans. He was so excited about Britain. He loved it so much. Was staring now this photo of Winston Churchill and was so excited about what was happening on the right in, In Britain and wanted to know exactly what all the kind of, all the polling dynamics were and how he could help. Extraordinary.

Dr. James Orr (45:31)

Yeah, I mean, look, I could hear some contrition in his, in his voice as he's clearly emotional. Whether the emotions is being driven by what had happened to him, you know, the fact that his career looked like it was on the precipice, I don't know. I mean, I think, you know, true contrition expresses itself in actions. And, you know, I detected sort of a hint of a politician's apology there. Just deeply, deeply sorry that that offense has been caused. But you know, repentance, you know, the Greek, the New Testament is metanoia, which means a complete transformation of one's mind, of one's intellect, one's understanding, one's heart. And you know, the Latin translation I think is pinetameni, which is kind of not just repentance, but do penance. And there's a lot of debate about that in the Reformation about, you know, his sort of repentance is something not just of the heart, but you've got to do it, you've got to do stuff that shows this kind of the outward working, the outward expression of inner contrition within one's heart. And I don't know, look, I don't have a window into men's souls. I don't have a window into Jimmy Kimmel's soul. I just hope that this incident, this whole sorry saga has made the left, has made the kind of American liberals think a lot harder about the language that they're using and just being aware that spinning the kind of conspiracy theories that are completely fact free, as seems to be the case with this extraordinary charge that the killer was motivated by was part of the MAGA movement, just simply absurd, not a shred of evidence for it. I just hope that this will give them pause for thought and it'll just slow things down. And yeah, I mean, there cannot be civilization discourse if it's, you know, if one side is constantly paying the consequences for, you know, indiscreet speech or violent rhetoric and the other side effectively gets a free pass and that seems to be what's. What's happening just not just in America, but all across the landscape of Western, Western culture, Western politics.

Andrew Colvett (52:43)

But that, that this, this is the distinction and I think it's really important for us to remain morally very clear on this. I, what I was trying to say was that celebrating the vicious murder of our friend is vile, it's ugly, it's nasty, 100%. And it is in the, it is from the same demonic spirit that I think somebody would, you know, this incitement legal. So I'm talking. There's two distinctions. There's almost like the demonic spirit that I would call it versus the legal standard. And I'm not conflating the two. I'm saying, so, you know, if you're going to celebrate that, certainly maybe you didn't break a law, but you are participating in the same demonism. And I would just say I have not fully internalized that other than to say that may you live a life so remarkable, so courageous and so true that the demons celebrate when you die. And may your enemies, your enemies celebrate because that means you have done something, you have been so extraordinary that you live rent free in their heads. And they know not, they don't know anything else to do other than to say, you know, thank goodness that extraordinarily effective person is off the board. But, you know, in Soren Kierkegaard's words, that's really just the beginning when a martyr dies. And so Dr. Orr, Charlie was a free speech absolutist and one of the themes of his trip to the UK was about this issue of free speech. We've heard that in the UK 30 arrests are made a day for people criticizing immigration. Basically just this sea of humanity. And, you know, we have a ton of immigration into this country, which is one of, you know, my pet projects is to limit that. But we also have a country that's much larger and you, it sort of can absorb the visceral feel or the visual feel of it can absorb It a little bit differently than the UK, which is, remind me, what are you, 60, 80 million? I can't remember. So if you have a couple million migrants come into the uk, I mean, it's instantly very visible. It's very, it impacts the daily life of a lot of Britons. Really quickly tell us about the state of free speech in your country. Did this hundred thousand person march push back against that? Was that a theme of it? Explain.

Dr. James Orr (81:49)

And that came across, I thought, in Larian's beautiful tribute to him in the stadium. And I've never, never seen Larry, you know, deeply kind of moved like that. He's always very good at keeping it together. But I. It was just such an extraordinary testimony. I think he mentioned at one point that, you know, he said to. He said to Charlie, you know, you got to learn, and it's going to take suffering. It's a great bit of wisdom from Aeschylus, Agamemnon, Pathemata, Mathemata. You have sufferings, learnings. And that idea that's. Larry's just instills that in his. In his. In his cohorts at Hillsdale. And then just Charlie goes off and does all 31 Hillsdale courses available, then, you know, comes back, comes back for more and just extraordinary. And I think, you know, it's hard to. Hard, you know, hard to replace somebody with that. That kind of package of powers and skills and abilities and aptitudes, and you can't replace him. But I felt on Sunday, you know, something had shifted and that although he could not be replaced, there was something. Something stirring, something that is. Something that is. That is peaceful. Something that is, you know, that it. That is kind of recovering the ancient. The ancient vision for the west, of hope, of faith, of love, the great, you know, the great trinity of theological virtues. And it was just extraordinary to witness that. And there's a kind of envy. I remember that that last show we did that, or that was aired as his last show, we recorded it back in August. And I think I opened it by saying, I don't normally like watching things. I do, but I wanted to watch that because I wanted to be reminded of. Of him and of our time together. And I think I just started by saying, look, you know, young people are always saying, we want to change the world. And I tend to think that the world would be a much better place if you're young people trying to change it. But in. But in Charlie's case, I said, you know, you really are changing the world. You are really shifting. Shifting things in extraordinary ways. I think I said at one point, we need to. We need to bottle some Kirk Juice and bring it back. To bring it back to the mother country. And. But I think. I think there's going to be a lot of Kirk Juice in Britain now.