The Commentary Magazine Podcast: "It's Howard Stern's World"
Release Date: August 6, 2025

Introduction

In the August 6, 2025 episode of The Commentary Magazine Podcast titled "It's Howard Stern's World," host John Podhoretz engages a panel of esteemed commentators to dissect the profound impact of Howard Stern on American culture and media. The discussion intertwines Stern's legacy with contemporary political figures, notably drawing parallels between Stern's persona and that of former President Donald Trump. The episode delves into themes of authenticity, media evolution, and the shifting cultural landscape from the audacious 1990s to today's more subdued environment.

Panel Introduction and Opening Remarks

John Podhoretz opens the episode by highlighting the educational philosophy of St. John's College, emphasizing the importance of studying the great books of Western Civilization to foster independent thinking and democratic values. He introduces the panelists:

• Abe Greenwald, Executive Editor
• Seth Mandel, Senior Editor
• Matthew Continetti, Washington Commentary Columnist

Podhoretz sets the stage for a "mailbag" segment, encouraging listeners to submit concise questions for future episodes.

Howard Stern's Influence and Evolution

The conversation swiftly moves to Howard Stern, a central figure in the discussion. Podhoretz reflects on Stern's transformative journey in the radio industry, noting his ability to captivate audiences with an edgy, transgressive style:

"[09:10] John Podhoretz: ...he kind of broke through as a cultural figure who transformed the medium of radio."

Seth Mandel praises Stern's talent for making everyone around him fascinating, from celebrity guests to staff members, creating an addictive and immersive broadcasting environment. This unique ability to engage a diverse audience is highlighted as a cornerstone of Stern's enduring influence.

Parallels Between Howard Stern and Donald Trump

A significant portion of the discussion draws parallels between Howard Stern and Donald Trump, particularly in their approach to media and public persona. Mandel observes:

"[14:08] Seth Mandel: ...he's a proto-Trumpian figure who managed to attract a broad audience by embodying the frustrations and desires of the common man."

Podhoretz elaborates on how Stern's confrontational style and willingness to insult rivals set a precedent that Trump later mirrored in political discourse:

"[15:32] Seth Mandel: ...he would attack others fiercely, much like Trump does in his rhetoric."

The panelists agree that Stern's "everyman" appeal and his ability to resonate with a broad audience laid the groundwork for political figures like Trump to harness similar traits for mass appeal.

The Transformation of Howard Stern's Career

The transition of Stern from a shock jock to a more mainstream media figure is a focal point. Podhoretz discusses Stern's move to Sirius XM and how it allowed him greater creative freedom:

"[35:04] Seth Mandel: ...he took his career to Sirius XM, which provided him a platform free from FCC regulations."

This shift not only solidified Stern's legacy but also mirrored larger trends in media consumption, where subscription-based models began to dominate. The panel notes that this move marked a point where Stern could evolve his personal brand without compromising due to external pressures.

Cultural Shifts: The 1990s vs. Today

An unnamed speaker contrasts the overtly sexual culture of the 1990s with today's more restrained societal norms. Reflecting on Stern's era, they remark:

"[27:05] Unnamed Speaker: ...the 90s were a decade of sex-drenched media, with shows like Stern pushing boundaries in ways that are less common today."

The panel discusses how the sexual openness of the past has given way to a "new chastity and androgyny," citing a renewed prudishness in modern entertainment and social interactions. This shift is seen as both a response to and a consequence of evolving cultural values.

Authenticity in Media and Politics

A central theme of the episode is the concept of authenticity versus inauthenticity, especially in the realm of politics. The panel references Lionel Trilling's ideas on sincerity and authenticity, debating how public figures either embody genuine traits or mask their true selves:

"[65:44] Unnamed Speaker: ...authenticity can only survive the national stage, but inauthenticity cannot."

Podhoretz ties this to contemporary figures like Bernie Sanders and Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (AOC), contrasting them with Trump:

"[62:49] John Podhoretz: ...Bernie Sanders is admired for his authenticity, even by detractors, whereas AOC's reluctance to engage in traditional media interviews hampers her perceived authenticity."

The discussion underscores the importance of perceived genuineness in garnering public support and the challenges faced by modern politicians in maintaining an authentic image.

Comparative Analysis with Other Media Figures

The panel draws comparisons between Howard Stern and other influential media personalities such as John McLaughlin and Rush Limbaugh. Seth Mandel highlights:

"[23:15] Seth Mandel: ...Unlike McLaughlin, Rush Limbaugh remained a dominant force until his passing, illustrating the varying degrees of lasting impact among media figures."

Andrew Dice Clay is also discussed as an example of a media figure who transitioned from controversial stand-up to respected dramatic roles, contrasting with Stern's shift towards a more subdued persona.

Concluding Insights and Future Implications

As the episode draws to a close, the panelists reflect on the legacy of Howard Stern and its implications for future media and political landscapes. Podhoretz muses on the unpredictability of political figures emerging with mass appeal, emphasizing the ongoing relevance of authenticity and genuine connection with audiences.

"[67:03] Unnamed Speaker: ...authenticity is what makes figures like Trump connect so readily with the public, and this will continue to shape political dynamics in the years to come."

The episode concludes with a recommendation for Chuck Klosterman's book "The 90s," which encapsulates the tumultuous and transformative nature of that decade, further contextualizing Stern's era within broader cultural shifts.

Notable Quotes

• John Podhoretz [09:10]: "He kind of broke through as a cultural figure who transformed the medium of radio."

• Seth Mandel [14:08]: "...he's a proto-Trumpian figure who managed to attract a broad audience by embodying the frustrations and desires of the common man."

• Seth Mandel [23:15]: "...Unlike McLaughlin, Rush Limbaugh remained a dominant force until his passing, illustrating the varying degrees of lasting impact among media figures."

• Unnamed Speaker [65:44]: "...authenticity can only survive the national stage, but inauthenticity cannot."

Conclusion

The "It's Howard Stern's World" episode offers a comprehensive analysis of Howard Stern's enduring influence on American media and culture. By drawing insightful parallels with political figures like Donald Trump and exploring themes of authenticity and cultural evolution, the panel provides a nuanced understanding of Stern's legacy and its implications for the future of media and politics. For listeners seeking an in-depth exploration of these dynamics, this episode serves as a valuable resource.