Episode Title: Neocon Trump?
Podcast: The Commentary Magazine Podcast
Host/Author: Commentary Magazine
Release Date: November 12, 2024
Introduction
In the episode titled "Neocon Trump?", hosts John Podhoretz, Christine Rosen, Seth Mandel, Matthew Continetti, and Abe Greenwald engage in an in-depth discussion about former President Donald Trump's potential foreign policy direction. The conversation delves into recent cabinet appointments, the influence of neoconservatism, the dynamics of the Jewish vote, and critiques of the current Democratic administration.
1. Trump’s Foreign Policy Appointments
Overview: The episode opens with John Podhoretz highlighting Trump's recent cabinet appointments: Elise Stefanik as the U.N. Ambassador, Representative Mike Waltz as National Security Advisor, and Marco Rubio as Secretary of State. These choices signal a strategic direction for Trump's foreign policy.
Key Points:
- Pro-Israel Stance: The appointments suggest a strong support for Israel and a commitment to combating antisemitism.
- Hawkish Approach Toward China: Indications of a tougher stance on China, recognizing the Chinese Communist Party as a significant threat.
- America-First in Ukraine Aid: A shift towards prioritizing American interests over continued aid to Ukraine, potentially seeking a settlement between Russia and Ukraine.
Notable Quote:
Seth Mandel [03:27]: "It shows a Trump foreign policy that's going to be very pro Israel… tougher toward China..."
2. Implications for Ukraine and Israel
Overview: John Podhoretz expresses concerns for supporters of the war in Ukraine, noting that the current administration's stance may diverge from strong continued support. He references a recent speech by Mike Waltz that underscores this ambivalence.
Key Points:
- Mixed Signals on Ukraine: Waltz's speech indicates frustration with the Biden administration's undefined goals in Ukraine.
- Potential Shift in Policy: A possible move towards reducing aid and seeking a settlement, despite the complexities involved.
Notable Quote:
John Podhoretz [06:10]: "Ukraine is not really in our national interest. Ukraine is, you know, Zelensky is corrupt."
3. Neoconservative vs. Jacksonian Foreign Policy
Overview: The panel explores whether Trump's appointments align more with traditional neoconservatism or a newer, more nationalist "Jacksonian" approach to foreign policy.
Key Points:
- Jacksonian Foreign Policy: Characterized by nationalism, a focus on American interests, and a willingness to use force without engaging in nation-building.
- Neoconservative Attributes: Historically associated with promoting democracy and interventionist policies, though the panel notes the term's evolving nature.
Notable Quote:
Christine Rosen [10:20]: “That’s what's actually happening here, which is that a lot of the people who talk about this stuff, especially online... are building their entire ideological worldview out of this one thing that happened.”
4. Loyalty and Administration’s Effectiveness
Overview: The discussion shifts to Trump's approach to staffing his administration, emphasizing personal loyalty over traditional qualifications or ideological alignment.
Key Points:
- Enhanced Management: Compared to Trump's first term, the current administration appears more managed and strategically assembled.
- Loyalty Over Expertise: Appointments are driven by loyalty to Trump, potentially leading to a more cohesive but insular administration.
Notable Quote:
Seth Mandel [21:42]: "They thought they knew more than he did."
5. The Jewish Vote and Antisemitism
Overview: John Podhoretz and Christine Rosen analyze the significant shift in the Jewish vote towards Trump, particularly in pivotal states like Pennsylvania, and its implications for cabinet appointments.
Key Points:
- Voting Shifts: Exit polls indicate an increase in Jewish support for Trump, contributing to his electoral success.
- Transactional Approach: Trump’s appointments reflect a transactional relationship with the Jewish community, prioritizing support in key areas.
Notable Quote:
John Podhoretz [39:36]: "An Orthodox Union exit poll showed the Jewish vote in Pennsylvania being 48, 41 for Kamala."
6. Rubio’s Appointment and Western Hemisphere Focus
Overview: Seth Mandel discusses Marco Rubio’s appointment as Secretary of State, highlighting a renewed focus on Latin America and issues such as Venezuela and Cuba.
Key Points:
- Latin America Emphasis: Rubio’s background suggests a strategic pivot towards addressing challenges in the Western Hemisphere.
- American Exceptionalism: Maintaining a belief in American leadership and exceptionalism in foreign policies.
Notable Quote:
Seth Mandel [42:10]: "He has moved toward Trump on almost everything, but he has retained a view of American exceptionalism."
7. Critique of the Biden Administration
Overview: The panel critiques the Biden administration’s foreign policy, contrasting it with Trump’s approach and highlighting perceived failures that Trump aims to rectify.
Key Points:
- Prolonged Conflicts: Biden’s policies have, in the panel’s view, extended conflicts in Ukraine and the Middle East.
- Need for De-escalation: Emphasizing classic war strategies aimed at de-escalation and resolving prolonged engagements.
Notable Quote:
John Podhoretz [29:33]: "Deescalate is a classic war strategy."
8. Democratic Response and Fundraising Criticisms
Overview: Matthew Continetti and others critique the Democratic Party’s fundraising practices, particularly focusing on Vice President Kamala Harris’s fundraising efforts and alleged financial mismanagement.
Key Points:
- Excessive Fundraising: Criticism of Kamala Harris raising exorbitant amounts of money ($1 billion in three months) and questionable expenditure.
- Potential Campaign Finance Issues: Allegations of grift and misuse of funds, drawing parallels to past political finance scandals.
Notable Quote:
Seth Mandel [57:35]: "We could have similar stories, potentially similar hearings for a losing campaign."
9. Recommendations and Conclusions
Overview: The episode concludes with recommendations for non-political content, specifically the documentary "The Last of the Sea Women," providing listeners with a respite from the intense political discourse.
Key Points:
- Documentary Recommendation: A beautifully filmed exploration of South Korean women divers, offering a meaningful break from political discussions.
- Global Interests: Highlighting the podcast’s diverse interests and coverage of global issues beyond American politics.
Notable Quote:
Matthew Continetti [63:04]: "We contain multitudes."
Conclusion
The "Neocon Trump?" episode provides a comprehensive analysis of Donald Trump's potential foreign policy trajectory, influenced by recent cabinet appointments and shifting political dynamics. The discussion underscores the complexities of neoconservatism, the strategic importance of the Jewish vote, and critiques of both the current Republican and Democratic administrations. By intertwining political strategy with social dynamics, the podcast offers listeners a nuanced perspective on the future of American foreign policy under Trump's influence.
Notable Quotes Summary:
- Seth Mandel [03:27]: "It shows a Trump foreign policy that's going to be very pro Israel… tougher toward China..."
- John Podhoretz [06:10]: "Ukraine is not really in our national interest. Ukraine is, you know, Zelensky is corrupt."
- Christine Rosen [10:20]: “That’s what's actually happening here... building their entire ideological worldview out of this one thing that happened.”
- Seth Mandel [21:42]: "They thought they knew more than he did."
- John Podhoretz [39:36]: "An Orthodox Union exit poll showed the Jewish vote in Pennsylvania being 48, 41 for Kamala."
- Seth Mandel [42:10]: "He has moved toward Trump on almost everything, but he has retained a view of American exceptionalism."
- John Podhoretz [29:33]: "Deescalate is a classic war strategy."
- Seth Mandel [57:35]: "We could have similar stories, potentially similar hearings for a losing campaign."
- Matthew Continetti [63:04]: "We contain multitudes."
Listeners are encouraged to watch the Commentary Magazine Podcast on YouTube for a visual perspective and subscribe to support future episodes.