
It's pretty common to hear copywriters recommend that you study old sales pages and even sales emails, but what about old magazine ads? The kind that are printed on paper in actual periodicals? Today, where so much advertising happens online or in your...
Loading summary
Kira Hug
Copywriters seem to revere old books by Eugene Schwartz and Vic Schwab. But what about old ads? This is the Copywriter Club podcast. If you've been a copywriter for more than a few weeks, you've probably probably heard other, more experienced copywriters mention books like Breakthrough Advertising by Eugene Schwartz or How to Write a Good Advertisement by Victor Schwab, or Tested Advertising Methods by John Caples. They make up a large part of the official canon of copywriting. In fact, David Ogilvy once said that no one should be allowed to write a single word of copy unless they had finished reading Caples book seven times. Of course, there are new books that ought to be added to that canon. Books by Joe Sugarman, Ann Handley, and Melbourne Matthew Dix. And in addition to books, there are a lot of copywriters who like to study old sales pages. They create swipe files full of them. I do this. Actually. My swipe file has more than a thousand different sales pages that I've collected over the last decade. Some copywriters even suggest that you handwrite sales pages as part of your learning. I don't go that far, but I do think that you can learn a lot by studying the persuasion techniques that copywriters have used in their work. But what about ads? One page ads with an image, a headline, maybe a few lines of copy. Are they worth studying? And what can we learn from them? My guest on this episode is Lewis Falkard. Lewis has made a bit of a name for himself by picking old print ads from advertising award books and analyzing them and then writing about whether they're effective or not. Lewis's breakdowns are more than interested in reading. They're mini lessons on copywriting, attention getting and persuasion. He told me why he does it and how it's impacted his business in this interview. So stick around to hear what Louis had to say. As you might expect, this episode is brought to you by the Copywriter Underground. I've mentioned that we've been rebuilding the content vault and adding a ton of additional workshops to it. Workshops taught by expert copywriters like Paris Lampropoulos, Joanna Wieb, Stefan Georgi, Jack Ford, Shanti Zak, Laura Belgray, and dozens of others. And it's not just copywriters. We've got marketing experts teaching about how to build funnels, how to market using tools like LinkedIn or Pinterest, how to put yourself in the right mindset to succeed, and so much more. And that's just the workshops. There are dozens of templates a Community of like minded writers holding each other accountable and monthly coaching with me in addition to weekly copy critiques, reviews. It's time that you joined us inside. You can learn more@the copywriterclub.com TCU and now my interview with Lewis Folkard. Louis, welcome to the podcast. I would love to hear your story and how you became a copywriter.
Lewis Falkard
Okay. Well, I mean I guess a lot of copywriters say very similar things in the sense that I feel like I've always had an interest in people and, and communications. I mean some of the earlier non fiction books that I read were kind of about human psychology and communications. I think there was how to and Friends and Influence People and another one by Brian Tracy I believe. But I was young and sort of just enjoyed learning about how the human mind works and how we can kind of translate that or how not to say how we can but how that translates into behavior. But yeah, the career into copywriting and marketing started I guess alongside uni. I graduated with a degree in materials engineering and had every intention of following that path. And I don't know really, I don't know how or what the, the kind of compelling idea was to, to leave and to start marketing, but it kind of happened. And of course mate had a small business online selling vintage jewelry and yeah, I sort of helped him out as best I could and end up discovering copywriting and haven't really looked back since. To be fair, it sort of scratched itches that I didn't realize I had. I've kind of always been more sort of mathsy, so to speak. Numbers, binary answers, right or wrong. You know, this either works or it doesn't. And heading into copywriting in this kind of world was like, well actually two opposing ideas can both be true. And it's kind of challenged me in ways that I never really understood. But I really enjoy those kind of challenges. There's obviously loads of paradoxes in human behavior, especially consumer behavior.
Kira Hug
So a lot of copywriters come from different backgrounds. You're the first person I've talked to. It doesn't mean you're the first copywriter that's had a materials engineering background, but that is a big jump. Engineering to selling jewelry as your first client. But marketing copywriting. Are there skills that you learned in materials engineering as an engineer that are strictly applicable to what you do as a copywriter?
Lewis Falkard
That's a good question. I think a lot of materials engineering is like looking at components that have broken and you then have to kind of find out why they've broken and how you can not help so they don't break in the future, basically. So reverse engineering. Those kind of concepts I think have always stuck with me. That's something that kind of pulled me into that in the first place. Um, and it's definitely something I do now, especially with like rewriting old ads and sort of looking at how they work. Um, it's kind of sort of leaned into that a lot more and understanding how some of the best performing pieces of copy work. It's then helped me sort of reverse engineer and apply those to my own pieces, I guess.
Kira Hug
So you started working for your friend selling vintage jewelry. How did you turn that now into a business? Like, you got the first thing done probably for not a lot of money, I'm guessing, but yeah, for free. So, yeah, how do you leverage free project into now landing clients and doing the kind of work that you want to do?
Lewis Falkard
Okay, so. Well, I kind of did it on the side. So I did follow the materials engineering path for probably around six months after graduating. And I was sort of doing this on the side and helping out in the evenings as best I could. And yeah, he's running ads on Facebook and Instagram. And I sort of wanted to find out how can I help these ads perform better. There's probably no surprise. First client, you, you're kind of a. You're a bit like a deer in headlights. You don't know what's. What's going on and everything. And yeah, that's where I ended up finding copyright, in particular Joe Sugarman's copywriting handbook. And yeah, I sort of stuck at the job for a little while. And I guess it's kind of the case of a lot of things when you go on to a path that you're kind of in control of. You're like your own sort of freelance. You're in charge of what you earn effectively. It seemed a lot more kind of fulfilling and inspiring and exciting. So I ended up leaving that job. Wasn't because I didn't like the job, but it's just. It was more stimulating doing my own thing. And yeah, I remember the first day that I sort of left and woke up and was like, well, what do I do today? Kind of thing. Like, how is this going to work? How am I going to get money from this kind of thing? And yeah, I ended up actually led into again at the ads that I still look at now. It was like, well, I need to kind of keep learning. I'm certainly no. No copywriter at the minute and just Kept reading books, and then I sort of found old pieces of direct mail and sort of thought, oh, that technique looks familiar. I've seen that somewhere else. And that kind of spurred on the idea to, well, why don't I sort of look at these in more detail and throw myself into the shoes of these copywriters and see why they're saying and doing what they're doing to effectively help me do the same thing? And it's a practice that I've continued to do since.
Kira Hug
And were you cold pitching clients? Were you reaching out to friends and family? I mean, this is really the big challenge for a lot of copywriters. How do you find the clients?
Lewis Falkard
I was in some ways fortunate and in some ways unfortunate. There was a couple of local networking events that I went to. I met a few people, and a few months after that, sort of nothing directly happened, like, immediately after that event. And then Covid happened, and everybody started to look to move things online. And I was sort of positioning myself as like an ads copywriter. And when everyone was sort of like, well, I need to find someone who can help me bring my business online. And I happened to be there with a few touch points. I met a few other people and a local agency, and that sort of gave me the first level of experience I needed. And it's kind of grown from there, really. A few agencies and. Yeah.
Kira Hug
How does that work? Working with the agencies? Again, this is something that we talk about a lot in our programs, that agencies can be great clients. You know, obviously you make the connection, but, like, what does the workflow feel like? You know, are you asking them for work from time to time? Are they just dropping things in your lap? What is that whole process?
Lewis Falkard
Yeah, I mean, it does depend on the agency. Different agencies run. Run it differently. The one that I worked with the closest was that, okay, we had projects come through, and do you want to work on it? Yes or no. And then a brief came through, and that was basically how it worked. So I kind of got to miss out on all the. The onboarding, which in some ways was nice. But I feel like that experience could have been helpful at the start because there's lots to learn, like, later on. But it was also handy that I could just kind of get given a brief, do the work, and get paid for it. And at the start, I just needed to get. Get experience under my belt and learn the ropes, really, and that definitely helped.
Kira Hug
So your first project was free as you moved into agencies, Help me understand how your income has grown over time?
Lewis Falkard
I Mean, I do less work for agencies now. I definitely do more independent, but that's just, I guess having kind of roots in one place and being able to kind of build more of a foundation to build a business. From at the start, I was kind of naive to how I thought it'd be a lot easier than what it was, put it that way. And that was definitely a wake up call again. That first day was thinking, oh, right, okay, I don't have anything to do today. I also don't have any money coming in. How am I going to do this? And I did cold pitch as well. I tried a lot of things. And you certainly expose weaknesses when you're, when you're cold pitching, because it needs to be. It's a very difficult thing to do and especially with no experience. I'd love to look back on some of those early emails to see what they look like now. And yeah, just kind of building a base and agencies have been really helpful as like an extra step up. So when things have been tough, they're like another source of income basically. So yeah, can be helpful.
Kira Hug
So one of the ways that you got on my radar is your newsletter and the breakdowns that you do there. It might be interesting to do a breakdown of some of those earlier pitches that you were sending out. You break down old ads and, and basically talk about like what works, what doesn't work, and your thinking around them. And I would love to hear the origin of how that came about, why you started sharing those thoughts. And then maybe we can talk a little bit about what you. The process of actually breaking down ads to understand how they're, how they're working or not working.
Lewis Falkard
No, of course. So it started off very, very early when I had very little copyrighting experience. It was like, well, a lot of copywriters sort of preach writing or rewriting old direct mail pieces and I did that. But I really wanted to sort of throw myself in it further, I guess, and to really understand, okay, well what does this line actually do? It's all well and good writing and having a similar style to say, Gary Halbert or Richard Foster, but you kind of need to understand like the why behind it as well as that. So yeah, with a little bit of sort of copyright books again. Joe Sugarman's copywriting handbook was definitely the one that taught me a lot of these different techniques that are going on and I started to spot them in other pieces and I'm thinking, oh, I could actually like look at that. I had like a leaflet come through the Door and thought, oh, they're saying that because that does that for example. And just even basic things of like, well, we've had 8,000 reviews. Well, that actually performs a function there that's not there just for the sake of it. And obviously when you're, when you're new, you don't realize these things. And I sort of pieced it all together and have kind of developed from there really.
Kira Hug
So maybe we can take a look at it. I don't know if a specific example comes to mind, but let's walk through that process with an ad and you start at the top, look at the headline, how the images work together. Let's, let's kind of go through the process.
Lewis Falkard
Yeah. So I think it was probably three years ago I met a copywriter, a well known copywriter over here, Lawrence Bloom, and he was in a lot of the annuals that I get the ads from. So that was a great, a great touch point for me. But I have probably close to 40 old advertising annuals stored away that I literally flick through and think, oh, that one actually looks quite interesting. That one grabs my attention. And that is the first, the first thing they do is find one that grabs my attention and then I sort of try and dissect it. And I've probably got enough ads in those books to last me the next 10 years, I reckon. But there's no like immediate or performance based things. It's done more from like a creative point of like, well, sometimes the timing could be right. You might see this ad and think, today it doesn't do much for me. But in two weeks time when you're working on a similar brief, it could be like a stepping stone to something that helps you. And these breakdowns now, so more of a function of that, of like, well, these are inspiration. There's nothing necessarily that these are the best performing ones. These are ones that obviously somewhat respectable because they're in the annuals themselves. But it's more as like a creative stepping stone, I guess is the best way to put it.
Kira Hug
So do you have a favorite ad that as you've gone through these you're like, wow, this, this one is just tops.
Lewis Falkard
Oh, the one I always mention is Richard Foster did one for Sainsbury's, which is a supermarket over here. And he did it an olive of all things. And it's just the cadence and the rhythm of how he writes was just something so menial as an olive. And it flowed so well like a story. And I thought, you know, if someone could do this for an olive. Well, what can they do with something that's actually genuinely quite exciting? Yeah, it's definitely one that stands out.
Kira Hug
And then you do the breakdowns, but obviously you're learning from them. At some point you started sharing these as well.
Lewis Falkard
Yeah, that was a mere coincidence. I think I just thought, you know, I'll just post it on LinkedIn. As again, desperate for work at the very start, I think I looked at a smoothie bottle first, was how it started, and was like, well, they had about six or seven lines of copy on that and thought, well, this, each line or each sentence had like a function that at least it looked like to me. And I shared it online and it did for relative speaking, it did quite well. It went quite far. And I thought, well, why don't I try these with another one? And that was way before I got these annuals as well. And the annuals sort of just ignited that excitement for it and have carried on, carried on looking at them.
Kira Hug
So obviously you've been sharing them not just on LinkedIn but you started an email list. How has that grown and what's the impact that that's had on your business?
Lewis Falkard
It's, it's still growing, for sure. It's something that I've, I've kind of done for, as selfish as it sounds, my own interests than for generating business. It's more that I want to help, help excite other creatives and see, you know, like, the work that's come before us has helped shape and more of the industry that we work in and I don't want to kind of lose sight of that. Yeah, there's, there's just like we as humans haven't changed that much. And the drivers behind these ads are still relevant today. They still tick the same kind of evolutionary desires and tap into those. And I just wanted to be a great, a way of showing, you know, all these things have come before us. They're not, they're not useless. I think many other industries, like film, music, they all look back to see what's come before them and to learn from those that have again, shaped and molded their industry. Whereas in marketing, we're very quick to dismiss, I think, like looking for the next silver bullet. And it's, I think it's important to look back to see what's, what's come before us.
Kira Hug
So as you've done that, have you compiled the list or have you, you know, you've got like, hey, these are the persuasion techniques or the headline techniques, the hooks that seem to be working have you, have you kind of figured out like, okay, these are the formulas and you. And maybe you start there. Or is it just really more of just kind of an artistic exercise?
Lewis Falkard
I mean, this is probably more the engineering side, the math side of it. I have a very large spreadsheet of all the books and ads that I've looked at and I've kind of segmented them all out into different techniques. Okay, was this for headlines? Is this for boosting credibility? Is this for, you know, like smoothing transition between a headline to the first line of the copy? I've got that and I use that and I often refer back to that to kind of, kind of get the ball rolling. But yeah, the first ads, the first ones I look at are more just a gut instinct and then I sort of look to dig more because there's normally more going on than what meets the eye initially. And I guess that's what makes a good ad a good ad, is that we don't realize that it's sort of a sales pitch that doesn't feel like a sales pitch. And I first. First is always gut feeling. Well, this is interesting. And I'm like, well, why is it interesting? And then I sort of start probing and looking back at other ads and techniques and they was like stepping stones. They just keep building out. So ye, the documents that plan these end up getting quite long and it's quite difficult to cut out what doesn't go in and what does go in. Again, it's the same as all copywriting, isn't it, in that sense? So yeah, there's a big extensive spreadsheet that maybe, I don't know, I might turn into something that's actually useful, but it's just my eyes only and it's quite a mess.
Kira Hug
But yeah, I'm curious, I'd love to see it. But I wonder, like, are there. What are the techniques that you see happening over and over and over that are just clearly like, these are the table sticks, the basics that every ad really ought to have.
Lewis Falkard
That. That is a good question. I mean there's normally some form of storytelling and it's kind of the old cliche that story, story sells. And but how those stories come across, they differ between the ads and some of them, again, some of the ones I look at, I guess for the listeners, like, are not always copy heavy. Sometimes they are just an image and headline. Sometimes they are copyrighted, a lot of very heavy body copy. And I guess there's something that we can use for our longer forms of writing because the Images. Our brains process images a lot faster than what they do. Words. And a long piece of copy isn't usually just words. There is normally some kind of imagery that goes with it or media. And I like to look at visual metaphors, so I've tried to include those in longer form pieces of copy where I can. But obviously you, like, you can't over complicate it too much and sort of throw too much the reader. So how you present that is normally a bit of a challenge. But, yeah, I'd say a lot of the ads I looked at have some kind of visual metaphor. They do a lot of work by pulling in symbols from other areas. One that comes to mind. I actually wrote a post for LinkedIn yesterday that's coming in the next few weeks, and it was just a picture of a happy baby for cow and gate baby food. I'm not sure if you guys have that over the pond, at least.
Kira Hug
I'm not familiar with that brand, but baby food for sure.
Lewis Falkard
Yeah. And it was just a means of having. Having a picture of a happy baby on the front with like, it was. The red hand was very like symbolic of the brand between a cow and a gate in the imagery. It was like a sort of a dad holding. Holding a baby in the field. And happy baby does a lot of work without us really thinking about it. There's so much that goes on sort of subconsciously that helps us process and evokes a lot of emotion without really having to say anything at all. And we can use those same techniques in our copy to deliver more. More pack for less punch, I guess.
Kira Hug
Yeah, I think that's a really important point. I have a ton of old advertising annuals as well, you know, from the 80s and 90s. And as I look through them, oftentimes just for inspiration or, you know, just to make my. Put myself maybe in a more creative mind. One of the things that I have realized is so much of the work back then was in this golden age of magazines when visuals were really important. Copy was sort of shrinking in ads. And the challenge for a lot of copywriters is we're hired to write words, not necessarily ads. You know, most magazines, so many magazines are defunct now and. And that kind of art has shrunk. It's still there in places. But as far as applying these kinds of ideas into, you know, blog posts or emails or. So much of the content that we're asked to create today, as a copywriter, what do you see is the best way to do that?
Lewis Falkard
I remember reading a Book probably a couple years ago by Orlando Wood and it was sort of discussed the different ways that different sides of the brain have kind of dominated in different sort of phases of history and how that kind of looks in arts. And something that we see a lot today is in kind of a quote, kind of like left brain society, so to speak, is that everything is very short term and kind of spoon fed that a lot of the better ads from way back when were they sort of trusted the reader to figure them out a bit more. And I feel like that applies to all copywriting is that we, we make it too simple and too obvious. It's kind of a sign of the times, I guess in some ways. But we can just put more trust into our reader to figure out what we mean. We don't have to state every little detail. We can let their minds figure things out. And our brains generally enjoy doing that as well. And so if those positive associations come from thinking and solving a sort of a problem, so to speak, then those associations sort of stick with who they're getting them from. And that helps come to mind sooner which then helps advertising and copywriting in the future. So there's like a long term effect of letting our reader do a bit of work basically.
Kira Hug
Yeah, I really like that. I've noticed you've mentioned that a few times. In fact, I've got a swipe file where I've collected what I call puzzle ads. It's where you're basically forced to complete the connection between the headline or the Image 1 series that I remember. You're probably too young to remember these live. They probably are in your annuals is Silk Cut cigarettes, which was a brand in the uk had an outdoor campaign where there was always some combination between a sharp object and this purple, this beautiful purple silk. And I remember seeing them all over Scotland when I was there in the 80s and I just kind of fell in love with these ads that were just, it was, it was intended to make your brain have to think about what was being advertised because it was not clear. And as the campaign builds, you know, obviously every time you see this purple silk with, you know, a pair of scissors or a knife or you know, something, you started to see this, the silk cut. And it's the kind of. It stuck with me. And there are other campaigns that do something similar. Absolute Vodka in the, in the 90s ran. They're basically puzzle ads where you kind of had to figure out what was the bottle and you know, what was the connection to the thing. But I think I'VE seen one.
Lewis Falkard
It was like an X ray, but I wasn't, I think. And it was.
Kira Hug
Yeah, there's all kinds. Well, there's all kinds, right. So, you know, they would have one that would say like absolute Manhattan. And it would be a photograph looking down, you know, at New York City and Central park was shaped as an absolute bottle. And which, you know, it's not, but you would look at it like, oh, familiar image tweaked a little bit to, you know, advertise this, this cool brand. So that's a little harder to pull off in a blog post or an email. But there are probably ways to create these kinds of puzzles and connections and help our readers think a little bit so that, you know, like you said, they're spending a little mental energy and it makes the work more memorable and more effective.
Lewis Falkard
It's definitely, it's a, it's a tough balance to get right because if you make it look too complex, then no one's going to even bother attempting it. But if you make it too simple, it's kind of insulting that it's just kind of boring and not, not entertaining and engaging to look at. And if we're putting ourselves in front of all these people in all these different ways, the least we can do is make it somewhat enjoyable to like, to read. And yeah, there's obviously there's loads of different ways that we can do it. And yeah, I just, they always put a smile on my face. Seeing something that, you know, just the two or three seconds of thought you think it's normally the product that then like completes the message as well, is kind of the, the missing piece. But that's again, it's a sign again of more Left brain advertising is that there's no, no kind of thought. You need to be able to prove it and there's too many reasons for something not to work. Whereas more Right Brain, which is more like sort of dialogue based. And there wasn't much about the product in a product ad, for example, that was something that, you know, you trusted the reader to fill out that, okay, the actual answer to this is the brand that we're advertising here. Whereas now it seems too risky.
Kira Hug
But yeah, so if you've as you've spent so much time looking at these ads, dissecting them, trying to figure out what works, how has that impacted the work that you do for your clients?
Lewis Falkard
It's really helped me sell work for one.
Kira Hug
What do you mean by that? How does that work?
Lewis Falkard
For example, if I've written a website, it's a lot easier for me to justify each line because I know what techniques I'm using here and why that's being used on this page, here in this position, on this page. And obviously everything should earn its right, but it's sometimes difficult to kind of justify everything. But these having the techniques and seeing it in different formats have really helped. They've also helped me critique other people's work. So in different, sort of, like, groups that I'm in, if we're sharing different pieces of work, it's easy to sort of pinpoint and say, well, have you thought about doing this technique to add credibility here instead of the one you've used, for example? So there's different ways like that. And obviously then I feel like a lot of the creative decisions that we use, like, obviously we have constraints to work with, is undeniably some science behind what we do, or a lot of science. But there is a little bit of wiggle room for some creative work. And a lot of these decisions that we make come from our unconscious. And the more that we can kind of draw attention to those in different ways, whether we study, whether we write them, we then kind of give our subconscious that ability to kind of use them in our work. And they come out sometimes naturally, or sometimes we have to kind of like, actually apply them and go back and intentionally insert them sometimes, and depends what we're working with. But it has helped for sure.
Kira Hug
So I'd love to shift our conversation a little bit and just hear more about how you work. You know, what does your typical day look like? Like when you get up and. And start thinking about a project or working on a project, you know, what is that? How does that all come together?
Lewis Falkard
Okay, so for the last three. Three years or so, I have just been living out of a backpack, traveling the world with my girlfriend. So my days do vary quite a bit. I usually depending on which side of the world all my clients have always stayed in in the uk. So sometimes that involves me working in the evening, sometimes it involves me working in the mornings, depending on where I am. But yeah, I normally keep my evenings aside where I can. I tend to prefer to work in the mornings and just sort of do the. To eat the big frog first, I think, as the saying goes, and to do the heaviest, most kind of demanding task and then save emails and calls for afternoons as best I can.
Kira Hug
And I mean, traveling and working is a challenge. It's one of those things. I think a lot of people who work for themselves think, oh, I can do this. So that, That I can travel. A lot of us don't travel. It's something that I've. I've done with my family a bit. Talk about some more of the challenges of that because it's not just as easy as saying, well, I'm going to work late or I'm going to work early. In my experience, you know, my family and I, we lived in Europe for seven or eight months while I was working. And the balance between everybody else wanting to go do something, me having to get work done, it was not an easy thing to strike.
Lewis Falkard
I know it's. Yeah, it's definitely posed its challenges. I've quite enjoyed working from different places and seeing how different places kind of inspire different trails of thought. And, yeah, it's been interesting to observe how people act in different places and scenarios and it's definitely granted me that opportunity. But the lack of routine has been very challenging. So sometimes it's a matter of squeezing work into an evening. If I've got a flight and I'm changing time zones, for example, I know I'm not going to be able to do much the next few days. And just settling into that took a little bit of time, but it's. It's been. It's been exciting, but it is definitely difficult. And, yeah, trying to find times where you have to sort of think on tap rather than like, plan when you're going to have your times and you don't know when that's going to be. If you've got an hour before a flight. Okay, well, it's. What can I do that's not too demanding here and saving. And it forces you to sort of manage your time a lot better, I think is the best way to put it.
Kira Hug
What are your favorite places where you've been?
Lewis Falkard
Probably Thailand, I think. Takes. Takes the top. The top draw.
Kira Hug
And why is that?
Lewis Falkard
The food, the beaches, the people. It's just. Yeah, it's lovely. Good coffee shops and there's always good places to work. So I think that takes. Takes the biscuit. But I'm back home now, so.
Kira Hug
Well, and when I reached out to you, I know you were in Australia then. What. What are some of the other places you've been?
Lewis Falkard
So we did, I guess, Mexico, Colombia. We've been in and around Southeast Asia from like, Thailand, Vietnam, Cambodia.
Kira Hug
That's amazing.
Lewis Falkard
Yeah, there's. Yeah, Australia. We've done, obviously, a lot of places in Europe as well. It's a lot closer for us, so.
Kira Hug
And were you carrying your annuals with you or like, how are you finding.
Lewis Falkard
A suitcase packed full of them? Yeah, exactly.
Kira Hug
That's heavy stuff.
Lewis Falkard
That was a lot of preparation. So I took enough pictures of the annuals before I went and I've got an album that's got close to a thousand pictures of different ads in there that I kind of pull from. And when I need to find another one for the next newsletter or however in advance I'm doing, I'll go through and see I get this one. It's really taken my fancy here, but yeah, I had to really think about what information I was going to need because I can't just flick back through them books and find the bits. So there's a lot of note taken that goes involved into that. But I've got them, I've got them with me now.
Kira Hug
Yeah. Okay, that makes sense. So now that you're back home, at least temporarily, are you. Are you looking at your business differently? Do you do some. Anything differently because you're in the home base or is it more of the same?
Lewis Falkard
I mean, I've only been back about a month, but I definitely have the desire to. It's one. I can do the same thing. I can follow a fixed routine, which is nice, and I can actually go and meet some of these clients in person, which I've not been able to do. So I'm hoping it's going to have positive impact. That same sense that, you know, I can sort of. I can solidify the relationship a bit better than what I can via email and video call and also just the kind of to go out and speak to local people and attend more in person events that I've not been able to do. So there's. It's happening slowly, but again, I've only been back a few weeks to kind of make the most of that.
Kira Hug
So where do you see your business going from from now and, you know, in the coming years?
Lewis Falkard
I would like just to keep doing what I'm doing, really. I really enjoy. And ever since I started it, I've enjoyed it and I still enjoy it to this day. Obviously it'd be, I mean, to say, work fewer hours. I don't know. I mean, I think the best thing about being freelancers, you can pick and choose how and when you want to work. If you want to do more, you can. If you want to do less, you can. Obviously it comes with its risks and challenges, of course, but I'm really content with how things are and don't want to change too much, really, as sort of naive as that sounds, but that makes sense.
Kira Hug
So if you could go back in time, you know, to Lewis, who is maybe, you know, just coming out of uni materials engineering, you know, working on that first client, what kind of advice would you give him in order to help him make progress or do things differently, you know, have success faster or something like that?
Lewis Falkard
Well, it's all kind of come in waves, so I think I would tell myself that when things are good, they probably won't stay this way. If you've got lots of projects coming through all at once, there's going to be periods where these projects do not continue even if you think they're going to continue. So keep planting seeds for the future and don't put that off. Just keep doing that consistently. That's been a lesson that's been quite difficult over the years and especially when I've been other parts of the world and sort of really relying on people finding me via online somewhere or another, is that just to keep going. Don't stop with planting seeds because you need to keep, keep nurturing them as you go along.
Kira Hug
Obviously what you're posting on LinkedIn, that's planting seeds. What are the ways do you plant seeds in order to connect with clients?
Lewis Falkard
I'm in a few different sort of groups of copywriters and business owners that I sort of now attend to as well. They were online but I'm now able to go out and see them in person. And I mean, I mean just doing things that I quite enjoy, quite enjoy doing. And you never know who you meet or who that that person knows. There's been a lot of relationships and clients that have come from sort of word of mouth referrals that very, very slim off chances. And now I kind of have this idea that you know, well, you never know who you're going to meet and who you're going to talk to just to try and spike up conversations in day to day about, in coffee shops. You never know who, who that person might know. And that's proved pretty, pretty positive.
Kira Hug
So yeah, that's I think a really critical piece of advice that I think a lot of people need to hear over and over and over is, you know, these relationships matter. Striking up conversations matters, creating friendships matters. And I know a lot of people shy away from networking that the concept that you're out there looking for work or asking for work, but when it comes right down to it, people work with the people they like and the people that they know. And the more we can get out there, the better it is for all of our businesses.
Lewis Falkard
100%. And yeah, it's been, again, a tough lesson to learn over the months, over the years that, you know, you really don't know who you're talking to. And sometimes the least expecting ones can be the ones that provide the most, whether it's on LinkedIn, whether it's in person, you know, you just have these conversations and they're opportunities to learn about people as well, which obviously is a very big part of what we do. And yeah, if you kind of see it as a game and a bit of fun, you can have a good time doing it. And I do.
Kira Hug
Any other advice that you would offer copywriters looking to grow their businesses and do some of the things that you're.
Lewis Falkard
Doing, again, plant the seeds and just be consistent that these things, I was naive thinking, you know, within six months I'll have all these clients and all these different things to do and it takes a lot longer than what you think you're going to take. I don't want to dishearten people, but the reality is that, yeah, these things do take time and anything that comes quickly normally goes quickly. So if it's a slow builder, you're normally in a safer position in the long run. So prepare for the future. And yeah, just keep, keep planting those seeds.
Kira Hug
Amazing. Louis, if people want to see your creative breakdowns, you know, be on your list or, you know, find wherever it is that you're posting, where should they go?
Lewis Falkard
So my website is LewisFolkard.co.uk. that's L E W I S F O L k a r d.co.uk. and yeah, the newsletter is on there as well if you wish to, wish to sign up to that. If not, I've got all the past ones on on my blog for you to look through. So they're all there.
Kira Hug
We'll link to it in the show notes. We'll also link to the olive, the breakdown that you have of the olive. I, I remember when that one came out and you're right, it is, it's interesting. If a copywriter can wax poetic about a single olive, you know that they can write. So we'll link to that so people can find it. I, I really appreciate you taking some time this morning to talk to me.
Lewis Falkard
Perfect. Thank you very much. I appreciate it.
Kira Hug
Yeah. Thanks, Lewis. Thanks to Louis Folkard for sharing his story, details about his newsletter and how he breaks down older ads. Breakdowns are tremendously useful. Seeing how other copywriters think about copy, copy written by them or even by others, that helps us see techniques so that we can find them in other copy that we read later, or even copy that we write ourselves. In fact, having an experienced copywriter look at your work and make suggestions about how to improve it is perhaps the best way to see things that you miss, and ultimately it makes you a better writer. Lewis mentioned that we as humans haven't changed all that much over the past centuries, let alone decades, so we can learn a lot by looking back at what has come before, and Lewis didn't mention this. But one of the reasons that I like to look back at old ads is that it puts me in a different frame of mind for thinking about headlines and hooks. There's something about studying clever ideas that helps you flex your own clever muscle and can make your headlines more intriguing. These kinds of reviews are something that we do a lot of in the Copywriter Underground. I even broke down one of my all time favorite sales pages by Gary Bensivenga showing how Gary uses more than a dozen different persuasion techniques. I think there's 18 or 19 of them that he uses in a single sales page. I've also broken down web pages, sales pages, social media posts, emails for different members of the Copywriter Underground. You can see them all inside the Copywriter Underground. If you're not already a member, you can jump in at thecopywriterclub.com TCU that's the end of this episode of the Copywriter Club podcast. If you like what you heard, please share it with someone you know. Or if you don't know another writer or a freelancer who you can share it with, visit Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever it is that you listen to your favorite podcasts and leave a five star review of the show. I really appreciate it. I promise when you share it, your friends will appreciate it too. Thanks as always for listening. See you next week.
Podcast Title: The Copywriter Club Podcast
Episode: #435: Analyzing Old Ads for Fun and Profit with Lewis Falkard
Release Date: February 18, 2025
Hosts: Kira Hug and Rob Marsh
Guest: Lewis Falkard
Description: Ideas and habits worth stealing from top copywriters.
In this episode of The Copywriter Club Podcast, hosts Kira Hug and Rob Marsh delve into the niche yet insightful practice of analyzing old advertisements with their guest, Lewis Falkard. The discussion centers on how dissecting vintage ads can enhance modern copywriting techniques, providing both inspiration and practical strategies for copywriters seeking to refine their craft.
Lewis Falkard shares his unconventional journey into copywriting. Originally a materials engineering graduate, Lewis was drawn to the field through assisting his friend’s vintage jewelry business online. His fascination with human psychology and communication, influenced by early readings like How to Win Friends and Influence People and works by Brian Tracy, naturally transitioned him from engineering to the persuasive art of copywriting.
Notable Quote (03:05):
"I've always had an interest in people and communications... understanding how the human mind works and how that translates into behavior." – Lewis Falkard
Lewis elaborates on how his engineering background, particularly skills in reverse engineering and problem-solving, seamlessly translated into dissecting and understanding successful advertising copy. This analytical approach enabled him to break down effective ads and apply similar strategies to his own work.
Notable Quote (05:08):
"Materials engineering is like looking at components that have broken and finding out why they've broken... reverse engineering those concepts has always stuck with me and pulled me into copywriting." – Lewis Falkard
Lewis discusses his passion for old print ads, particularly those featured in advertising award books. By analyzing these ads, he uncovers the underlying persuasion techniques and storytelling methods that made them effective. This practice not only serves as a learning tool but also inspires his creative process.
Key Points:
Notable Quote (12:15):
"There's normally some form of storytelling... a good ad is a sales pitch that doesn't feel like a sales pitch." – Lewis Falkard
By systematically analyzing old ads, Lewis has enhanced his ability to justify creative decisions and critique others' work effectively. This analytical foundation has been instrumental in selling his services and improving his copywriting quality.
Notable Quote (25:40):
"Having the techniques and seeing them in different formats has really helped me sell work for one." – Lewis Falkard
Lewis shares his experience transitioning from freelancing to collaborating with agencies. Initially relying on local networking and cold pitching, the shift to agency work provided him with a steady flow of projects, though he now leans more towards independent work to build a sustainable business foundation.
Notable Quote (08:59):
"We had projects come through, and I'd decide to work on them based on the brief. It helped me gain experience and get paid for it without extensive onboarding." – Lewis Falkard
Lewis began sharing his ad breakdowns on platforms like LinkedIn, which unexpectedly garnered significant engagement. His newsletter serves both as a personal exploration of copywriting techniques and a resource for fellow creatives to understand the efficacy behind classic ads.
Notable Quote (15:21):
"I want to help excite other creatives and show how past work has shaped our industry." – Lewis Falkard
For the past three years, Lewis has been a digital nomad, balancing work with globe-trotting adventures alongside his girlfriend. This lifestyle has introduced challenges like maintaining a routine and managing time across different time zones, but it has also provided diverse inspirations for his copywriting.
Notable Quote (27:20):
"The lack of routine has been very challenging, but working from different places inspires different trails of thought." – Lewis Falkard
Currently based at home, Lewis aims to leverage his fixed routine to deepen client relationships and expand his network through in-person interactions. He expresses a desire to continue his current path, enjoying the flexibility that freelance work offers while preparing for sustainable, long-term growth.
Notable Quote (31:10):
"I can solidify relationships better in person and attend more events, which should positively impact my business." – Lewis Falkard
Lewis emphasizes the importance of consistency and relationship-building in growing a copywriting business. He advises emerging copywriters to continuously plant seeds for future opportunities, understanding that client acquisition often takes longer than expected. Building a network through genuine interactions can lead to unexpected and valuable collaborations.
Notable Quote (32:47):
"When things are good, they probably won't stay this way. Keep planting seeds for the future and don't put that off." – Lewis Falkard
Lewis Falkard's approach to analyzing old advertisements offers a compelling blueprint for copywriters seeking to enhance their persuasive abilities. By dissecting and understanding the elements that make classic ads successful, Lewis not only refines his own craft but also provides valuable insights to the copywriting community. His journey from engineering to copywriting underscores the power of transferable skills and the importance of continuous learning and adaptation in the ever-evolving field of marketing.
Additional Resources:
If you found this summary helpful, consider sharing it with fellow copywriters or freelancers who could benefit from Lewis Falkard’s insights on analyzing old ads to boost modern copywriting strategies.