
Wednesday, April 9th, 2025 Today, Judge James Boasberg has canceled a Tuesday afternoon hearing on the Trump administration's use of the Alien Enemies Act to deport alleged migrant gang members without due process, after the U.S. Supreme Court ruled Monday evening that the administration could resume carrying out such deportations; the Supreme Court paused a ruling to reinstate over 16000 probationary federal workers; Senator Brian Schatz has put a hold on over 300 trump nominees; Elon Musk and Pete Navarro get in a tariff fight; Governor Greg Abbott delays a the special election for Sylvester Turner’s House seat until November; the DHS has revoked legal status for migrants who entered the US using Biden’s CBP One app; a Trump appointed judge has reinstated the Associated Press to the White House press pool, a judge has awarded $6.6M to Ken Paxton whistleblowers; the New Mexico governor has signed the turquoise alert bill for when Native Americans go missing; Elon Musk rage quits ...
Loading summary
Allison Gill
MSW Media. Hello and welcome to the Daily beans for Wednesday, April 9, 2025. Today, Judge James Boasberg has canceled the Tuesday afternoon hearing on the Trump administration's use of the Alien Enemies act to deport alleged migrant gang members without due process after the US Supreme Court ruled Monday night that the administration could resume carrying out such deportations. And the Supreme Court paused a ruling to reinstate over 16,000 probationary federal workers. Senator Brian Schatz has put a hold on over 300 Trump nominees. Elon Musk and Pete Navarro getting a tariff for fight. Governor Greg Abbott is delaying the special election for Sylvester Turner's House seat until Nov. 4. The DHS has revoked legal status for migrants who entered the US using Biden's CBP1 app. A Trump appointed judge has reinstated the Associated Press to the White House press pool. A Judge has awarded $6.6 million to Ken Paxton, whistleblowers. The New Mexico governor has signed the Turquoise Alert bill for when Native Americans go missing. And Elon Musk Rage quits a live stream after being rel. Relentlessly mocked by gamers. I'm Allison Gill.
Dana Goldberg
And I'm Dana Goldberg.
Allison Gill
Hey, my friend. Happy taint of the week.
Dana Goldberg
Happy taint of the week to you, dear. How are you?
Allison Gill
I'm all right. We've got more good news stories than bad news stories today. So what on the, on the. Yeah. Oh, my God. News. Right like this. This news sucks. We have more good news stories which I'm very happy about. Also, I'm going to be doing a special B block on the Supreme Court decision that came down. Remember the end of the very end of the good news where we got that sort of alert that the Supreme Court did something shitty again. I'm going to break that down in the B block today. And also in the B block, new lawsuit filed by the ACLU in the Southern District of New York to follow up on what the Supreme Court did. So some good. Kind of like half and half. All right, we have a lot to get to. Let's hit the hot notes. Hot notes. All right. From the Times. The Supreme Court Tuesday blocked a ruling from a federal judge in California that had ordered the Trump administration to rehire thousands of fired federal workers who had been on probationary status. The court's brief order said the non profit groups that had sued to challenge the dismissals had not suffered the sort of injury that gave them standing to sue. We've seen this before. The practical consequences of the ruling may be limited as another trial judge's ruling requiring the reinstatement of many of the same workers still remains in place. Justice Sonia Sotomayor dissented, but she gave no reasons. And Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson said the court should not have ruled on such an important issue in the context of an emergency application, which she also talked about in her dissent. That I'll go over in the B block in Monday night's ruling about the Alien Enemies act. And my gosh, like, Supreme Court needs to just stop acting on, you know, these impulse.
Dana Goldberg
I mean, that's what it feels like.
Allison Gill
Yeah, there you go. I mean, we've seen this, though. We've seen some lower courts dismiss cases brought by, like, federal workers unions, saying you may have indirect harm as a union, but we need the individual workers to sue because they have the direct irreparable harm and impact. But yeah, I mean, here we are trying to do our best to navigate the fire hose of bullshit executive orders coming down, and you and I both know that it is improper to use a reduction in force and call it firing probationary employees without using the law, laws that are following the law requiring what, you know, what you have to do when you want to do a reduction in force. So hopefully that other lawsuit will survive.
Dana Goldberg
I hope that it does. This one's from The Texas Tribune. Governor Greg Abbott has set. Yep. November 4th as a special election date to fill the congressional seat left vacant by former Rep. Sylvester Turner's death, a timeline that leaves a solidly Democratic seat vacant for at least seven months as Republicans look to drive President Donald Trump's agenda through a narrowly divided Congress. Turner, a former Houston mayor and Democratic state lawmaker, died March 5, two months into his first term representing Texas's 18th congressional district. State law does not specify a deadline for the governor to order a special election, which is really fucking dangerous, especially because it's Abbott. With Turner's seat vacant, the House breaks down to 220 Republicans and 213 Democrats, allowing the GOP to win a majority on the floor even with three defections from their ranks. If Turner's seat were filled, likely by a Democrat, the GOP could withstand only two defections. And I think there's a lot of defections over there. Democrats, including U.S. rep. Hakeem Jeffries, the Democratic minority leader, pressured Abbott to call a special election, threatening to sue if Republican governor continued to hold off on scheduling the contest. So I hope they push back really hard on this and throw everything they can at Governor Abbott to actually do the right thing and hold a special election. They know that is a very blue area in Texas. And it has been that way for a little while. You know, I remember a couple of elections ago, they elected 19 female judges in one election in Houston. Black female judges. Not just female judges, Black female judges. They know that that seat is going to go blue and they need to do it sooner than later.
Allison Gill
Yeah. And Representative Hakeem Jeffries, Minority Leader Jeffries, don't threaten to sue. Sue. The constituents in this district are being taxed without representation for the majority of this year.
Dana Goldberg
Well said.
Allison Gill
And so I would like to see you. Instead of weighing a lawsuit or considering a lawsuit or threatening a lawsuit, I would like to see the lawsuit. So everybody give. If Hakeem Jeffries is your representative, give him a call and tell him, yeah, do sue. Sue. Please file your lawsuit. Next up from the Associated Press, migrants who were temporarily allowed to live in the United States by using Joe Biden's online appointment app. App have been told to leave the country immediately, according to officials. It was unclear how many beneficiaries would be affected, but more than 900,000 people were allowed in the country using the CBP1 app since January of 2023. They were generally allowed to remain in the United States for two years with authorization to work under a presidential authority called parole. And this is good because they pay taxes and now the IRS is going to use that information to find them and they're using Joe Biden's app to do the same thing. Authorities confirmed termination notices were sent to CBP1 beneficiaries, but didn't say how many. They were urged to voluntarily self deport using the same app they entered on, which has been renamed CBP Home. Oh, dear. Yeah. Frightening. Terrifying.
Dana Goldberg
I mean, we saw this coming. They're going to do every single thing that they can. I don't necessarily understand that these people are paying more taxes than the President of the United States at the moment. It's just really unfortunate. I don't.
Allison Gill
Also, taxation without representation.
Dana Goldberg
They can't vote 100%. No, they can't vote. That's another thing. And they know this. Republicans know this. They are not voting in these fucking elections. They know the federal law. Stop pretending like you're passing laws or bills saying, oh, these people can't vote in the next election. No shit, they already can't vote in the next election.
Allison Gill
Yep.
Dana Goldberg
Deep breath, deep breath. And Allison, by the way, speaking of the Associated Press, some good news finally from Politico. A federal judge has ordered the Associated Press restored to the White House press pool after President Donald Trump banned the wire Service for refusing to adopt his renaming of the Gulf of Mexico as the Gulf of America.
Allison Gill
That's its birth name.
Dana Goldberg
I know it was named the Gulf of Mexico at birth, but they seem to be able to use the new names very quickly. It's amazing how they can just shift like that.
Allison Gill
Weird.
Dana Goldberg
I know. The ruling from U.S. district Judge Trevor McFadden, a Trump, by the way. Yep. Trevor. Huh? I'm telling you, a broken clock is right. Twice a day, Trevor McFadden is requiring the White House to return the AP's access to the Oval Office, Air Force One and other limited spaces whenever those spaces are made available to other journalists in the White House press pool. And I quote, under the First Amendment, the government opens its doors to some journalists, be it to the Oval Office, the East Room, or elsewhere. It cannot then shut those doors to other journalists because of their viewpoints. The Constitution requires no less from McFucking Fadden.
Allison Gill
Wow.
Dana Goldberg
I know.
Allison Gill
I've never seen a Trump judge argue that vociferously for any amendment other than the Second Amendment.
Dana Goldberg
That's true. That is true.
Allison Gill
Wow. All right. Good job, Trevor.
Dana Goldberg
I mean, I think when they start saying we're going to go after the federal judges, some people like this, or, you know, are like, whoa, whoa, whoa, whoa, whoa.
Allison Gill
Yeah, precisely. All right, next up, unsurprisingly, rich people don't like Trump's tariffs. I know. Here's Senator Kennedy on CNN when asked if Trump owns this economy. Listen to me, boy. Pay attention when I'm talking to you. That boy's about as sharp as a bowling ball. Oh, okay. I'm sorry. I'm sorry. That. That is the wrong clip. Let me ask, is it.
Dana Goldberg
Is it the wrong clip?
Allison Gill
Do. Do we. Do we have the clip? Do we have the clip of Senator Kennedy?
C
It's been pain, but it may turn out well, it may not. If it doesn't turn out well, I think the President will recalibrate to that point.
Dana Goldberg
Do you think it's Donald Trump's economy now?
C
Oh, I think it is. There's no question. I think once he decided to. To. To. To add the tariffs, clearly, I mean, he will be held responsible, as he should, whether it turns out good or it turns out badly.
Dana Goldberg
Is there a point at which you would consider supporting taking tariff authority back into Congressional hands? There have been some efforts in the Senate to do that.
C
Well, if I finally concluded that what the President is proposing is not going to work, or if the treatment is worse than the disease, sure. And I'm going to look at Senator Grassley's bill very closely, but I'm not there yet.
Allison Gill
Okay, so that was, that was Senator Kennedy saying that. Yep. Donald Trump owns his good or bad. You know, I mean, I think he went to prep school in Oxford, but he's got that nice down home southern accent that he's been putting on for a while. Have you ever seen those side by side videos of him, how he used to talk and him, how he talks now?
Dana Goldberg
Huh?
Allison Gill
Yeah. Wow.
Dana Goldberg
I guess he just needed to adopt deep, a deeper. I gotta, I gotta connect with the people. He's ridiculous. There's a related story to this, by the way, and it's from the Times. Elon Musk slammed President Trump's top trade advisor as, and I quote, dumber than a sack of bricks on Tuesday.
Allison Gill
Dumber than a sack of bricks.
Dana Goldberg
Exposing a remarkable rift in the President's inner circle over the wide ranging tariffs that have upended the global economy and tanked the stock market. As most of us have felt, the feud between Mr. Musk and Peter Navarro, who has been the architect of many of Mr. Trump's trade plans, has been simmering for days as the administration's new tariffs have caused huge losses across global financial markets. But it's very specific to Musk. The squabble escalated on Monday when Mr. Navarro said on CNBC that Mr. Musk was not a, quote, car manufacturer, but a car assembler because Tesla, Mr. Musk's electric vehicle company, relied on parts from around the world. Mr. Musk fired back on Tuesday, calling Mr. Navarro a moron and dumber than a sack of bricks in a post on Twitter. And that's, as we know, the social media app that Elong has destroyed. Later in the day, Mr. Musk doubled down posting that he wanted to, quote, apologize to Brics. Sorry. I mean, listen, I know the guy is despicable 99% of the time, but every once in a while when they go after their own, it makes me giggle. And I quote, that was so unfair to bricks, said Elon. He used a slur, by the way, to refer to Mr. Navarro. Calling him, and I quote, a content warning here, by the way, for everyone. This is shitty language and it's not my language and I actually have a really hard time even saying this, but Elon called Navarro Peter Retardo.
Allison Gill
Wow.
Dana Goldberg
Yes.
Allison Gill
53 year old man, ladies and gentlemen. 53 year old man.
Dana Goldberg
Yeah, the cracks are indeed grown.
Allison Gill
Ass man. More good news from Axios. Democrats are starting to listen to us, Dana. Senator Brian Schatz is expanding his holds on Trump's nominees to include an additional 50 names, along with a batch of bipartisan foreign affairs bills. That brings the total number of Trump nominees that Shatz has ground to a halt to more than 300, intensifying his protest of what he calls the White House's lawlessness. These fresh holds include former Rep. Anthony Desposito, a Republican from New York, Trump's pick for the Labor Department inspector general, and Scott Kupor, tapped to lead the Office of Personnel Management. The new holds span nominees at more than a dozen Trump administration agencies and departments. Schatz has already placed holds on all State Department nominees as well. Shatz also is blocking nine bipartisan bills that recently cleared the Senate Foreign Relations Committee in protest of what he characterized as the committee's lax oversight of the Trump administration. So good, good trouble. Thank you, Senator Schatz. We also, you know, we've talked about Senator Gallego blocking VA nominees. We've talked about Senator Schiff slowing down the Ed Martin nomination for U.S. attorney in the District of Columbia. So thank you to these senators for blocking these. We should have been doing this the whole time.
Dana Goldberg
Absolutely. And I've got more good news coming out of the Associated Press. And I'm so proud of this because this is my home state. New Mexico Governor Michelle Lujan Grisham signed legislation Monday creating a turquoise alert for when Native Americans go missing in the state. This is so important because it has been overlooked historically. This is historic when it's, and I'm talking across this country, when it's not a little white girl or a little white boy, oftentimes, and I'm not saying always, but oftentimes it gets less press and less coverage. This is huge. The effort, which had overwhelming support among all the lawmakers, responds to a troubling number of disappeared appearances and killings in Indian country. The, quote turquoise alert system, taking its name obviously from the blue green mineral, will allow law enforcement to quickly share information. It's going to function much like an Amber Alert or a silver alert that highlights the disappearance of children or the elderly. Cell phone alerts will be issued when law enforcement finds evidence of imminent danger to a disappearance of a Native American. The legislation wasn't just a policy achievement, but a victory for every Native American mother, daughter, sister and aunt, as I said, who has ever been impacted by violence. This is what Tiffany Giron said. She's the executive director of the Coalition to Stop Violence Against Native Women. Historically, their disappearances have gone un investigated. They've been ignored. This is a big deal. And I am so proud of the Governor of my home state.
Allison Gill
I love this, and I love your home state. Thank you, New Mexico. And this is just. This is brilliant. We need this everywhere. I didn't know that there were Silver Alerts. Now I'm. Now I'm ready. Oh, really? In case. Yeah, I didn't know that.
Dana Goldberg
Silver Alerts, Amber Alerts, they call it silver. When oftentimes an elderly person wanders. Wanders away from their homes, wanders outside of an assisted living where somehow they were able to get out. And that's what they call them, Silver Alerts.
Allison Gill
That's so great.
Dana Goldberg
Yeah.
Allison Gill
All right, next up from the Associated Press district court judge on Friday. This is so great. Awarded $6.6 million combined to four whistleblowers in their lawsuit against Texas Attorney General fuckface Ken Paxton. These. These whistleblowers were fired shortly after they reported him to the FBI, quote, by a preponderance of the evidence. Travis County Judge Katherine Mozzie said in her judgment, the plaintiffs proved liability, damages and attorneys fees in their complaint against the Attorney General's office. Quote, because the office of the Attorney General violated the Texas Whistleblower act by firing and otherwise retaliating against the plaintiff for in good faith reporting violations of law by Ken Paxton and the oag. The court hereby renders judgment for the plaintiffs. The court found that the four Paxton aides were fired in retaliation for reporting allegations that he was using his office to accept bribes from member the Austin real estate developer who employed a woman with whom he was having an extramarital affair. That's cool for Republicans to do. By the way, Totes Paxton has denied accepting bribes or misusing his office to help Nate Paul, but didn't to deny the extramarital affair. So good.
Dana Goldberg
Paxton's been a piece of shit for a while, by the way.
Allison Gill
He's still under indictment anyway.
Dana Goldberg
Or was that move he wasn't even able to run?
Allison Gill
Yeah. So that guy. 6.6 million. Suck it.
Dana Goldberg
Yep. All right, moving on. This one's from UPI unions representing libraries, librarians and federal workers. They sued the Trump administration on Monday to stop its dismantling of the Institute of Museum and Library Services as they accused the federal government of usurping Congress's power, which they've been doing since he got, I'm quote, unquote, elected. The IMLS is a little known independent agency of the federal government. And what it does is it offers grants to libraries and museums across the country. It also conducts research and develops policies. Congress, which created the agency in 1996, appropriated 294.8 million to IMLs through September 30. Last month, President Donald Trump signed an executive order calling the IMLs, as well as a handful of other independent agencies unnecessary and directed it to be eliminated to the maximum extent. A lawsuit filed Monday by Democracy Forward on behalf of the American Library association and the American Federation of State, county and Municipal Employees accused the Trump administration of governmental overreach. Of course they did, because they are saying the the imls was created by Congress, which is the only entity that can lawfully dismantle it. I have to wonder. Congress is getting really fucking tired of not being able to do the job that they were elected by. Or are the Republicans so happy that they don't have to do shit because the President of the United States keeps overstepping his power and taking their jobs away from them? I think it's, I don't know. It's a toss up. It's a toss up.
Allison Gill
It's the latter. The Republicans are there to break the government and they don't like to work. They're allergic to it, even though, you know, they're firing tons of federal workers who work their asses off to to serve their country. All right, finally, from the Daily Beast, Elon Musk rage quit a live stream of the video game path of Exile 2 on Saturday night after repeatedly dying while also being ruthlessly cyberbullied in the chat. Path of Exile 2 is one of Musk's favorite games, so much so that he once claimed to be one of the world's top players in an attempt to boost his gamer credit before later backtracking and admitting that he had been secretly paying people to level up his account and make him appear more talented at the game than he is.
Dana Goldberg
This is what's fascinated about Elon, and I don't mean to interrupt the middle of the story, but we know that Trump bullshits about his his golf ability, but he would never backtrack the fact that Elon somehow admits that he was paying people to actually make him look better at the game. That's what is fascinating to me about this.
Allison Gill
This guy, right? Yeah. Nevertheless, while attempting to show off Starlink's in flight WI fi capabilities while on board his private jet over the weekend, man of the people as he is, Musk streamed himself playing some Path of Exile two on the hardest difficulty, which was broadcast live on Twitter.
Dana Goldberg
That's where he made his fatal mistake.
Allison Gill
The Doge Chief was predictably terrible at the game, kept dying, but that was the least of his problems. Less than Five minutes into the live stream, the insults began. And for the next hour and a half, Musk sat in stony faced silence and blasted techno music while dozens of users blasted him. And here to read some of the things that folks had to say about Elon Musk in that live stream is my friend Andy Merrill. You might know him as the voice of Brack from Space Ghost coast to coast and Cartoon Planet. Brack, take it away.
D
Elon is a pedophile. Elon Musk. Musk gets pathetic. You have no friends and you will die alone. You will always feel insecure and it will never go away. Please jerk off, Mr. Trump. So he dies of a heart attack. Elon, how is it possible to look this dumb and ugly? Why is your Tesla company falling apart? What happened, buddy? Oh, he's so stupid.
Dana Goldberg
Well, buddy, I listen. I mean, you put yourself out there on a public live stream. You. How can you not expect this to happen Now?
Allison Gill
As aside from muting a couple of the loudest trolls, after almost an hour of sustained abuse, Musk did little to stop the army of trolls from relentlessly mocking him. Eventually, he vanished when his wi FI connection abruptly cut out and he ended the stream. Or maybe Starlink just stopped working, which by the way, that stream, he later deleted it from Twitter, but it was swiftly re uploaded onto YouTube so you.
Dana Goldberg
Can catch it there. Oh my God.
Allison Gill
Thank you so much to my good friend Andy, voice of Brack, for. For that dramatic reading of the insults. All right, it's time for some good trouble. What are you guys doing? Okay, everybody, I happen to have for you the ICE tip line, which by the way gets taken down pretty frequently for having too many calls that are coming in. And I also have the ICE online tip form which we will link in the show notes. Please call and write to report Elon Musk having overstayed his student visa.
Dana Goldberg
Yes, please.
Allison Gill
The ICE tip line is 866-347-2423. That's 866-347-2423. And the online form can be found at ice.govWebform tip hyphen form Again, link in the show notes. Please do not use your real details like your name, your number or your address or your email address when you're submitting your complaints. And go ahead, have at it. Report some stuff to the line.
Dana Goldberg
Good trouble, people.
Allison Gill
All right, everybody, we'll be right back with the Supreme Court update I promised. If you've already read my substack@military road.com on this subject, please feel free to skip ahead to the good news, but know that there's an update with a new lawsuit filed by the ACLU on Tuesday afternoon at the end of the B block. And then stick around for the good news. We'll be right back. We'll be right back. Hey, everybody. Welcome back. All right, so Judge James Boasberg has canceled the Tuesday afternoon hearing on the Trump administration's use of the Alien Enemies act to deport allegedly Trend Gang members without due process because the Supreme Court ruled Monday night that the administration could resume carrying out such deportations. And I wrote this for my substack mullershirote.com please feel free to subscribe. It is free to subscribe. So it's called the Corrupt Supreme Court strikes Again. The Supreme Court took six months to decide immunity, but just six days to effectively strip the rest of us of due process. I know, I know I sound like I'm being overly dramatic, given the Supreme Court did just tell the Trump administration that they can't deport people under the Alien Enemies act proclamation without due process. But is it really due process? Today, the Supreme Court responded to an emergency motion filed by the Trump regime by vacating Judge Boasberg's temporary restraining orders that expanded the class of defendants deported under the Alien Enemies act and to return them to the United States. United States, pending the outcome of the case on the merits. If you've been following my videos and posts, you'll recall that the Trump regime signed an Alien Enemies act proclamation in the dark of Night on March 14 and kept it a secret as they rounded up people they allege belonged to the Trende Aragua gang, put them on planes before a court could stop them, and deported them to El Salvador. Lawyers representing five of the detainees filed a lawsuit in the early early morning hours of March 15, resulting in Judge Boasberg holding an emergency hearing which resulted in order to turn the planes around, bring the deportees back to the United States, and to stop deporting anyone else under the AEA. That's the Alien Enemies act proclamation for 14 days temporary restraining order. The Trump administration blatantly defied that order, and today the Supreme Court rewarded them for that defiance. Not only was the contempt not addressed in the ruling from the high court, but also absent was a resolution to the question of whether the Alien Enemies act is appropriate at all, given we're not at war and any semblance of judicial review. On their conclusion that habeas claims are the only remedy for due process concerns, the five male justices have issued a glib quote four paragraph per Curiam opinion discarding the district court's order based solely on a new legal pronouncement that one might have thought would require significant deliberation. That's what Justice Kataji Brown Jackson said in her dissent. She also pointed out that, quote, surely the question whether such government action is consistent with our Constitution and laws warrants considerable thought and attention from the judiciary. Now this is a common theme in Justice Sotomayor's dissent as well, with whom Justices Kagan and Jackson join and with whom Justice Barrett joins in part. The dissent goes on to say critically, even the majority today agrees and the federal government now admits that individuals subject to removal under the Alien Enemies act are entitled to adequate notice and judicial review before they can be removed. That should have been the end of the matter. Yet with, quote, bare bones briefing, no argument, and scarce time for reflection, the court announces that legal challenges to an individual's removal under the Alien Enemies act must be brought in habeas petitions in the district where they are detained. The court's legal conclusion is suspect. The court intervenes anyway, granting the government extraordinary relief and vacating the district court's order on that basis alone. It does so without mention of the grave harm plaintiffs will face if they're erroneously removed to El Salvador or regard for the government's attempts to subvert the judicial process through this litigation. Because the Court should not reward the government's efforts to erode the rule of law with discretionary equitable relief, I respectfully dissent. And of course this court relies on habeas in the district where the migrants are detained, which is going to be largely in the conservative 5th District, which will almost always side with the Trump administration's determination. That is not due process, ladies and gentlemen. They and them. That's an illegal outcome in search of a bullshit process. This short notice emergency docket opinion bereft of thoughtful briefing or oral argument is especially disturbing to me given the six month delay enjoyed by Donald Trump while waiting to be crowned king that ultimately pushed the criminal proceedings against him well past the election. But this case hadn't even reached the preliminary injunction stage. And even though temporary restraining orders are usually not appealable, the Supreme Court spent all of six days to create a new rule for the ages while throwing the rest of us under the bus. They have decided that while people deported under the Alien Enemies act proclamation are entitled to due process, they've relegated that to habeas claims filed in the jurisdiction of their detention. Even Judge Boasberg didn't hear arguments about what due process would look like because he conceded it would require a lot of briefing and considerable argument, but not for the Supreme Court. Without a scintilla of briefing, they decided habeas is the proper and only remedy, justice Sotomayor said. Against the backdrop of the US Government's unprecedented deportation of dozens of immigrants to a foreign prison without due process, a majority of this court sees fit to vacate the district court's order. The reason, apparently, is that the majority thinks the plaintiff's claims should have been styled as habeas actions and filed in the districts of their detention. In reaching that result, the majority flouts well established limits on its jurisdiction, creates new law on the emergency docket, and elides the serious threat our intervention poses to the lives of individual detainees, she continues. As an initial matter, the majority's assertion that plaintiffs claims sound and habeas is in tension with this court's understanding of habeas corpus as at its core an avenue for a person in custody to attack the legality of that custody and to secure release from illegal custody. The plaintiffs in this case sued not to challenge their custody or detention, but to protect themselves from summary deportation pursuant to the proclamation. Indeed, because all of the plaintiffs were already in immigration detention under other statutes when the government subjected them to the proclamation, they have repeatedly emphasized throughout this litigation that they do not seek release from custody and are not contesting the validity of their confinement or seeking to shorten its duration. And I'll pause here for a second to let you know that's what habeas does. It's to challenge your detention, your custody, she says. Against that backdrop, there's every reason to question the majority's hurried conclusion that habeas relief supplies the exclusive means to challenge removal under the Alien Enemies Act. At the very least, the question is a thorny one, and this emergency application was not the place to resolve it. Meanwhile, she says, funneling plaintiffs claims into individual habeas actions across the nation risks exposing them to severe and irreparable harm. Rather than seeking to enjoin implementation of the president's proclamation against all Venezuelan nationals in immigration detention, detainees scattered across the country must each obtain counsel and file habeas petitions on their own accord, all without knowing whether they will remain in detention where they were arrested or be secretly transferred to an alternative location. That requirement may have life or death consequences. Individuals who are unable to secure counsel or who cannot timely appeal an adverse judgment rendered by a habeas court face the prospect of removal directly into the perilous conditions of El Salvador's seacote, where detainees suffer egregious human rights abuses. The other thing missing, by the way, in IN is any instruction on what to do with those who've already been deported to SECO without due process. Is the government supposed to give them notice? Return them to Texas? Grant them habeas hearings there? Who makes sure that gets done? Who enforces that? Who ensures they aren't using their weird point based system based on tattoos that ICE got from a white dude named Pete in the UK in 2016? Who does any of this? Steve Vladek wrote in his substack called one first quote. There's good case law to the effect that venue for habeas petition filed by someone outside the United States is proper in D.C. so lawyers can presumably try to file a habeas petition in D.C. on behalf of the individuals already removed to El Salvador. One that will depend upon how Abrego Garcia is resolved. But even if the Supreme Court sides with the lower courts there and holds that federal courts can order the federal government to take steps to bring these folks back if their removals were unlawful by vacating Boasberg's temporary restraining orders, the majority has made that review that much more difficult and potentially ineffective. So now, well, it appears that each person already in Cekote has to find a lawyer, file a habeas petition, which costs money. Maybe in D.C. if they can't afford counsel, will one be appointed for them? The entire purpose of a class action is addressed in Justice Sotomayor's dissent, saying one great advantage of class action treatment is the opportunity to save the enormous transaction costs of piecemeal litigation. That's a quote from Ortiz v. Fireboard Corp. This ruling is garbage, but given this extremist court, it should not come as a surprise to anyone. So you can find that@meloshirote.com There are links in it to the ruling and the dissents, along with a link to one first by Steve Fladek, that particular post that I was quoting. So with that being said in response, the American Civil Liberties Union and New York Civil Liberties Union, in partnership with the Legal Aid Society, whose clients are plaintiffs in this litigation, they filed an emergency lawsuit Tuesday morning in federal court in the Southern District of New York to again halt removals under the Alien Enemies act for people within that court's judicial district. The action follows last night's U.S. supreme Court decision lifting a nationwide temporary restraining order in a challenge to Trump's invocation of the Alien enemies Act, a 1798 wartime act that the administration is trying to use to bypass immigration law in its ruling, the Supreme Court also ordered that people targeted for removal under the act are entitled to challenge their removals and must have meaningful notice and opportunity to do so. Judge Hellerstein, a Clinton appointee, has been assigned this case. It's in New York. The plaintiffs are in New York. They're being detained in New York, and they face the threat of deportation to El Salvador as they are Venezuelans being targeted under the Alien Enemies Act. So Judge Hellerstein. Hellerstein has set a restraining order hearing for this morning, Wednesday at 10am Eastern. So we're back on a fast track and we're going to follow this like we followed the Bozberg proceedings. So I appreciate you subscribing to my substack. It's free. All my stuff is free. As you know, if you can kick in money, awesome. If not, no big deal. I don't, I don't believe in paywalls, so. All right, everybody, we have the good news to get to, so stick around. We'll be right back. Everybody. Welcome back. It's time for the good news. Who likes good news? Everyone. Then good news, everyone. And if you have any good news, confessions, corrections, you want to give us a shout out to yourself or maybe a small business in your area that could use a boost, or your small business or a loved one, like a parent or a child or a spouse or a partner, you can do that. Or a shout out to a government program. Perhaps you've been helped or a loved one has been helped by Medicare, Medicaid, the PACT act, the Affordable Care act, subsidies, of course, always student debt relief. We love those stories. Any, any government program that's helped you out and if you can think of one. The only Republican government program I can think of is EMTALA. That was passed back in the 80s. If you were helped by EMTALA, let us know. We don't, we aren't about which party passed the, passed the program. But please send in those government programs because right now they're just dismantling, like all of it. So, yeah, we want to hear that good news. And all you got to do to get your good news read on the air is pay your pod pet tax, which means attach either a photo of your pet, an adoptable pet in your area. If you don't have a pet, any animal photo really will do. Bird watching photos, we're doing that for the foreseeable future, which are photos of actual birds. We have a lot of birders and myself included now. Brand new birder who listen to the daily beans or you and your family and friends flipping the bird to Trump and Musk Properties. If you don't have any of that, you can send us your baby photos. We love baby photos. In fact, you should just include your baby photo even if you have any of the other photos, because we want to see them. All right, send it all to dailybeanspod.com click on contact. First up anonymous pronoun she and her Greetings beans of my eye. Love you, your swearing, your tender hearts, your tough reporting, and for being there every freaking day for us. I had to share that. I'm so proud of my hubby, Dave. When we met 49 years ago, he was a confirmed Republican and for years we canceled each other's votes out. But over time he saw the light and migrated to registering as a Democrat and has never looked back. Still, he has never paid a lot of attention to politics or the latest. But I would share things I learned from reading and listening to wise experts. He started complimenting me on being so well informed and thanking me for keeping him informed. Lately, he has started listening and reading on his own and last week he asked me if I would find the information on our local marches in Medford, Oregon on Saturday.
Dana Goldberg
Amazing.
Allison Gill
Awesome. I couldn't go because I was sitting for our granddaughter, but that didn't stop him. He donned his Question Authority T shirt and he happily went off with some advice I passed on from Andrea Pitzer. I love her that these marches and protests aren't necessarily going to create change in the government, but that they might impact local attitudes. So he took that to heart and as each vehicle drove by, he pointed to the occupants and said, we're doing this for you. He came back beaming. Here he is in the protest wear and one of his favorite protest signs carried by another participant and also a picture of our doodle. Truman Capoodle after listening to too many political podcasts. Look at this handsome fellow.
Dana Goldberg
I love this.
Allison Gill
Hands off Social Security Question Authority. That mustache is magnificent.
Dana Goldberg
Yeah, sir.
Allison Gill
And look at this. Feed them to the penguins. That's a great sign of it. And the purple hair is amazing. And look at this doodle. Oh my God. Truman. Cool. Truman Capoodle.
Dana Goldberg
I love it. I love it. Thank you for this and the evolution of your hubby. Well done Dave. Well done. This one is from Anonymous. Pronouns he and him Dear Allison and Dana. After enough bad days lately, we had some good ones this past weekend. On Saturday, my wife and I attended the Hands Off March in Chicago. It was great seeing all the people and all the creative signs. Great to see some resistance in the face of recent horribleness. The best part of the day though was afterward when we walked over to the gallery where the School of the Art Institute it's SAIC was hosting an exhibit of the works of the seniors who were graduating in the spring. Our niece is one of the soon to be graduates and had one of her works displayed. Our niece has had a pretty difficult couple of years. She was living with us to make her commute to school a little better and shortly after starting at saic, her mother, my wife's sister, passed away suddenly and unexpectedly. After taking some time off to tend to her mental health, she restarted her program a couple of years later. Oh my God. Her dad died in an accident. Although she was not close to her dad, her mom and he split when she was just an infant. It was still a shock. Despite these challenges, she put herself together and will be getting her degree in the spring. She's doing well and is in a relationship with a wonderful trans woman. We could not be any prouder of her. This submission is fantastic.
Allison Gill
I know. I love this.
Dana Goldberg
The exhibit of the works of the graduating seniors were amazing. So much creativity, inspiration, using a wide variety of media. Painting, sculpture, printing, electronics, textiles. That's just to name a few. My mind was truly blown. It was also amazing to see so many of her fellow students at the exhibit. They were as creative, strange and beautiful as you might expect a group of art students to be. The exhibit is running, by the way, Saturday, April 12th. That's my birthday, April 12th at 33 East Washington in Chicago. It's running all the way through April 12th. Next Saturday as Pod Pet Tax. I'm including a picture of our niece's exhibit, a series of risograph prints entitled Queer Bodies. Don't ask me what a risograph print is. I just know how amazing they look. Also include is a couple of photographs of our two boys, Ollie and Pip. The first is a find the cat of the boys in their typical heart shaped cuddle position. Also included is a picture of them so can see how cute they are. We adopted them from a shelter a year and a half ago and they have been a constant source of amusement since. Thanks for all the good works you do. Podcast is a staple to me. Look at this beautiful Queer Bodies thing. This is amazing.
Allison Gill
Now I want to learn more about Risograph.
Dana Goldberg
Yeah.
Allison Gill
Oh the cats are hiding.
Dana Goldberg
That's amazing. Oh they're cute. Look at that face.
Allison Gill
Oh my goodness. Yep, they are beautiful. Definitely man cat faces. If you're new to the daily beans. I have this uncanny ability to tell man cats, they just have man cat faces. I don't know, I can't explain it, but these are beautiful babies. Thank you so much for that and what a wonderful submission. And the art is just gorgeous, Dana. Oh my God.
Dana Goldberg
It really is.
Allison Gill
All right, next up from Daniel, pronouns he and him. Hello, champions. I love that intro. I want to give a shout out to all those who attended protests over the weekend. As a Canadian. Oh, we love you, Daniel. Our emotional support Canadian. It was really impressive to see Americans stand up and make their voices heard. We see you. And that's exactly the kind of thing the rest of the world is looking for. This regime has a fundamental lack of understanding of what it means to be an American. The notion that power is with the people is foundational to the American identity. And while it is going to take a lot of fight, I know in my heart that this is a fight that righteous America will win. Thank you, Daniel. I also have a request for all the listeners. The majority of the media submits takes that think Canadians are upset because of tariffs. That is false. We are upset because of the threats to our sovereignty. Whenever you hear someone say it's tariffs, please correct them for pod pet tariff. I mean tax. Hey, we should start calling them pod pet tariffs.
Dana Goldberg
I love that.
Allison Gill
Yeah. I submit my kitten, Duke Floofington inky bottom the third, better known as Mr. Floof or just Mister. He's an unverified Turkish van, a cat with a single coat of fur. So petting him is like petting a bunny. He's so soft. Our family mantra in these troubled times has become pet the kitty. Pet the kitty. Pet the kitty. Feel better, so feel free to share. First of all, the ice cream truck. The cat in the ice cream truck is fantastic. Look at the beautiful face.
Dana Goldberg
Adorable.
Allison Gill
And the sploot and the majestic tail on this baby.
Dana Goldberg
That is a good one. Good sploot.
Allison Gill
Thanks, Daniel, and thanks for, for your support. We, we wish it got more media coverage than it is getting but you know, the oligarchs are one of the media companies too, so.
Dana Goldberg
Absolutely. Here is the tiniest submission. This is from Diane Pronoun. She and her sharing my favorite sign from the hands off March in Atlanta and it says, does this ass make my country look small? And it's a picture of Trump and.
Allison Gill
It'S the picture of Trump with his.
Dana Goldberg
Hair all oh my God. The wind takes away that ferret that's on the top of his head.
Allison Gill
That's a great sign. I saw a lot of good takes on that one. Thank you, Diane. That's a reminder to anybody have a favorite sign from the protests that are going on or went on this past weekend or will be going on. Please send in your favorite protest signs. We love them, along with all the other photos that you send. Thank you so much for your good news. Please shower us with your good news. Submissions want all the good news we can handle. And like I said, if you pay your puppet tax, we'll read it on the air. Thank you so much. Send it to dailybeanspod.com click on Contact. Dana, do you have any final thoughts for today?
Dana Goldberg
Not today.
Allison Gill
All right, everybody, we'll be back in your ears tomorrow. Until then, please take care of yourselves. Take care of each other, take care of the planet, take care of your mental health, take care of your family. I almost said vote blue over Q. I know, right?
Dana Goldberg
We'll get there soon enough.
Allison Gill
We will. We will. I've been AG and I've been DG and them's the Beans. The Daily Beans is written and executive produced by Alison Gill with additional research and reporting by Dana Goldberg. Sound design and editing is by Desiree McFarlane with art and web design by Joelle Reader with Moxie Design Studios. Music for the Daily Beans is written and performed by they Might Be Giants and the show is a proud member of the MSW Media Network, a collection of creator owned podcasts dedicated to news, politics and justice. For more information Please visit msw media.com msw media.
The Daily Beans: Episode Summary – "The Supreme Court Strikes Again"
Release Date: April 9, 2025
Hosted by Allison Gill and Dana Goldberg
Produced by MSW Media
In this episode of The Daily Beans, hosts Allison Gill and Dana Goldberg dive deep into a series of significant political and social developments. The episode, titled "The Supreme Court Strikes Again," navigates through recent Supreme Court rulings, political maneuvers, immigration policies, media freedoms, legal victories, and notable controversies, all delivered with the podcast's signature blend of progressive insight and snark.
Timestamp: 00:00 – 04:24
The episode kicks off with a discussion on two pivotal Supreme Court decisions:
Blocking the Reinstatement of Federal Workers:
Alien Enemies Act and Deportations:
Analysis: The hosts critique the Supreme Court’s rapid decision-making process, highlighting concerns over due process and the erosion of checks and balances. They emphasize the potential dangers of bypassing thorough judicial review, especially concerning immigration and employment rights.
Timestamp: 14:49 – 19:43
Senator Brian Schatz has significantly intensified his opposition to the Trump administration by placing holds on over 300 of President Trump’s nominees. This strategic move is aimed at halting the administration's agenda within a narrowly divided Congress.
Impact on Congress:
Notable Example:
Notable Quote: Allison Gill commends Senator Schatz at [14:49], “So good, good trouble. Thank you, Senator Schatz.”
Analysis: The discussion underscores the strategic blockade of Trump’s nominees as a form of political resistance, aiming to curb what the Democrats view as overreach by the Trump administration. The hosts express hope that these holds will pressure Republican leadership to reconsider their stance.
Timestamp: 04:24 – 06:21
Governor Greg Abbott has postponed the special election to fill the vacant congressional seat left by the late Rep. Sylvester Turner until November 4.
Political Implications:
Notable Quote: Dana Goldberg highlights the detrimental impact at [04:24], “With Turner's seat vacant, the House breaks down to 220 Republicans and 213 Democrats, allowing the GOP to win a majority on the floor even with three defections from their ranks.”
Analysis: The hosts express concern over the political maneuvering, suggesting that delaying the special election is a tactic to maintain Republican control in a tightly contested House. They advocate for immediate action to schedule the election to restore proper representation.
Timestamp: 06:21 – 07:35
The Department of Homeland Security (DHS) has revoked the legal status of migrants who entered the United States using President Biden's CBP1 app, which had been facilitating the entry of over 900,000 individuals since January 2023.
Details:
Notable Quote: Allison Gill summarizes the situation at [07:35], “... incentivize these people to self deport.”
Analysis: The hosts highlight the precarious situation migrants find themselves in, emphasizing the arbitrary revocation of their status and the ensuing hardships. They criticize the lack of clarity regarding the number affected and the process for voluntary deportation.
Timestamp: 08:05 – 09:37
A Trump-appointed judge, Trevor McFadden, has ordered the Associated Press (AP) back into the White House press pool after President Trump had excluded the wire service for refusing to comply with his renaming of the Gulf of Mexico.
Details:
Notable Quote: Dana Goldberg emphasizes the constitutional aspect at [08:37], “... the Constitution requires no less from McFucking Fadden.”
Analysis: The hosts applaud the judicial reinforcement of press freedoms, underscoring the importance of non-discriminatory access for all media outlets. They view this as a victory against executive overreach and a defense of the First Amendment.
Timestamp: 16:46 – 18:10
A district court judge has awarded $6.6 million to four whistleblowers in a lawsuit against Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton. The whistleblowers were terminated after reporting alleged misconduct by Paxton.
Details:
Notable Quote: Allison Gill sarcastically remarks at [18:10], “So that guy. 6.6 million. Suck it.”
Analysis: The hosts celebrate this legal triumph as a significant step in holding corrupt officials accountable. They highlight the importance of protecting whistleblowers and maintaining integrity within governmental institutions.
Timestamp: 19:43 – 16:19
New Mexico Governor Michelle Lujan Grisham has enacted the Turquoise Alert bill, a critical measure aimed at addressing the alarming number of missing Native Americans in the state.
Details:
Notable Quote: Dana Goldberg praises the legislation at [15:00], “This is historic... for every Native American mother, daughter, sister and aunt.”
Analysis: The hosts commend the legislation as a long-overdue and essential tool for protecting Native American communities. They emphasize its role in increasing visibility and response to disappearances that have historically been neglected.
Timestamp: 10:04 – 23:28
Elon Musk finds himself embroiled in controversy following his public downfall during a live-streamed gaming session and ongoing conflicts with Trump administration advisor Peter Navarro over tariffs.
Conflict with Peter Navarro:
Live Stream Incident:
Notable Quotes:
Analysis: The hosts dissect Musk’s public struggles, highlighting the intense scrutiny and backlash he faces both online and within political circles. They critique his behavior and the broader implications of executive influence on business and personal conduct.
Timestamp: 39:33 – 46:51
Transitioning from heavy topics, Allison and Dana share uplifting stories and listener submissions, celebrating personal victories, community activism, and resilience.
Listener Stories:
Notable Quote: Allison Gill expresses admiration at [39:33], “Thank you so much for that and what a wonderful submission.”
Community Highlights:
Analysis: This segment provides a refreshing balance to the episode, reinforcing the podcast’s commitment to uplifting its audience. By sharing personal stories and celebrating community efforts, the hosts foster a sense of connection and hope amidst challenging times.
In "The Supreme Court Strikes Again," The Daily Beans delivers a comprehensive analysis of pivotal political and social issues, interwoven with moments of levity and community celebration. Hosts Allison Gill and Dana Goldberg adeptly navigate complex topics, providing insightful commentary while maintaining an engaging and relatable dialogue. This episode underscores the podcast’s dedication to progressive news coverage, advocacy, and fostering a supportive listener community.
Notable Quotes with Timestamps:
For more in-depth analysis and updates, subscribe to the Daily Beans and visit mswmedia.com.