Summary of "A Love Letter to Camp Mystic" by The New York Times' The Daily
Introduction
In the July 8, 2025 episode of The Daily titled "A Love Letter to Camp Mystic," host Michael Barbaro delves into the profound impact of Camp Mystic, a century-old all-girls Christian summer camp in central Texas, which tragically became the epicenter of devastating flooding. The episode centers around the personal narratives of Erin Paisan, a former camper, who shares her memories and the emotional toll of the recent tragedy that claimed over 127 lives at the camp.
Erin Paisan’s Connection to Camp Mystic
Erin Paisan begins by recounting her inaugural experience at Camp Mystic in 1975 when she was just ten years old. "My first year at Mystic was 1975, when I was 10 and my mom sent me for five weeks" [00:56]. Although Erin attended the camp for six summers, she emphasizes that her time there was deeply meaningful despite fewer visits compared to other campers.
The Allure and Culture of Camp Mystic
Erin describes the enchanting environment that initially drew her to the camp. "When we were down there picking him up, we went across a bridge that crosses the waterfront of Camp Mystic. And all these girls were out on the riverfront splashing and playing, and it was just so beautiful" [02:15]. Camp Mystic was renowned for its picturesque riverfront, expansive fields, and a sense of community that fostered genuine connections among campers.
The camaraderie among the girls was a cornerstone of the camp's culture. Erin reflects, "It was a level playing field... it was a very, very safe space" [05:02]. Without the usual social hierarchies present in schools, campers could simply be themselves, free from external judgments. This environment allowed for authentic friendships and personal growth.
Memorable Experiences and Camp Activities
Erin fondly recalls various activities that characterized her summers at Camp Mystic. From playful shenanigans like yanking pants down in line for the dining hall to adventurous water activities, the camp offered a blend of fun and freedom. "We rolled around in the mud and we threw mud at each other and, you know, just" [06:52].
The river played a pivotal role in the camp's daily life, serving both as a source of joy and, later, as a harbinger of disaster. "The river is like a character because if you had an 8 o'clock swim class, you were dreading going in that river because it was frigging cold" [08:30]. Despite its allure, the river's unpredictable nature would later contribute to the camp's tragedy.
Historical Flooding at Camp Mystic
Erin shares her harrowing experience during the 1978 flood, offering a glimpse into the camp's vulnerability to natural disasters. "I have a privileged childhood. But, you know, just because you're privileged doesn't mean that things are always going well at home" [05:47]. The suddenness of the flood left campers and staff scrambling for safety. "We were all told that we were gonna be moved up to a cabin called Angel's Attic" [14:02].
Despite the severity of the 1978 flood, Erin believes that the recent disaster pales in comparison. "Understand that the flood of '78 was nothing. It just doesn't. That pales in comparison to what just happened" [15:31]. This perspective underscores the unprecedented scale of the 2025 flood.
The 2025 Flood and Its Aftermath
The recent flood on July 4th resulted in catastrophic loss of life at Camp Mystic. Erin grapples with the emotional weight of witnessing this tragedy through social media and personal connections. "Yesterday, I just fell apart. Yesterday was the day that I just broke" [15:42]. The images of two young friends, Lila Bonner and Eloise Peck, clinging to each other amidst the chaos, epitomize the heartbreaking loss [16:41].
Erin's emotional response is intertwined with her enduring bond to the camp. "You could have my two daughters on this call who know that when I die, my ashes are to be spread at Camp Mystic" [04:51]. The camp's significance transcends mere memories, embodying a sanctuary of safety and sisterhood for countless women.
Community and Official Reactions
In the wake of the disaster, hundreds of Camp Mystic alumni and supporters gathered in Dallas to mourn. Texas Lieutenant Governor Dan Patrick criticized the lack of flood warning systems, asserting, "Had we had sirens along this area up and down, that would have blown very loudly. It's possible that that would have saved some of these lives" [23:06]. The state government is now pledging to implement a siren system by the following summer to prevent future tragedies.
Erin reflects on the challenges of flood prevention at Camp Mystic, "The flood rose so fast in the middle of the night that you couldn't see. Nobody could see or predict it was gonna rise that fast" [18:04]. Despite discussions about installing warning systems, Erin remains skeptical about their efficacy given the camp's remote location and the rapid onset of the floodwaters.
Looking Forward: The Future of Camp Mystic
The devastation has cast doubt on the camp's future, with many questioning whether it can or should reopen. Erin expresses hope for the camp's revival but recognizes the immense investment required to safeguard it against future floods. "I would love to see Camp Mystic come back, but I don't think... Maybe this was a wake-up call for the community that the money needs to be invested in something" [20:16].
Enduring Legacy and Healing
Despite the tragedy, Erin clings to the positive memories and the solace Camp Mystic continues to provide. "I choose to hold on to the beautiful moments there when you could hear the... voices of all these girls singing softly together" [21:00]. The camp remains a symbol of resilience and the enduring bonds formed among its campers.
Conclusion
"A Love Letter to Camp Mystic" poignantly captures the essence of a beloved summer retreat and the profound loss endured by its community. Through Erin Paisan's heartfelt reflections, the episode underscores the importance of safety measures, community support, and the enduring power of cherished memories in the face of tragedy.