Podcast Summary: "The Interview": Chuck Schumer on Democrats, Antisemitism and His Shutdown Retreat

Title: The Daily
Host/Author: The New York Times
Episode: 'The Interview': Chuck Schumer on Democrats, Antisemitism and His Shutdown Retreat
Release Date: March 16, 2025
Duration: Approximately 54 minutes

Introduction

In this episode of The Daily, journalist Lulu Garcia Navarro engages in an in-depth conversation with Senator Chuck Schumer of New York. The discussion spans a range of critical topics, including Schumer’s perspectives on rising antisemitism, the Democratic Party’s messaging strategies, recent controversial voting decisions, and the internal dynamics within his party. The interview delves into Schumer’s new book, Antisemitism in a Warning, and examines his recent vote with Republicans on a federal spending bill, which has sparked significant backlash within the Democratic caucus.

Antisemitism in America

Timestamp: 02:20 - 05:47

Senator Schumer opens the discussion by reflecting on the historical context of antisemitism in America. He shares personal anecdotes from his upbringing in Brooklyn, highlighting moments of both acceptance and discrimination. Schumer emphasizes a marked increase in overt antisemitic incidents following October 7th, attributing this surge to broader political and social tensions.

Chuck Schumer [02:20]: "October 7th changed it all. And all of a sudden, antisemitism explodes in ways we've never seen."

This unsettling rise in antisemitism motivated Schumer to pen his book, aiming to shed light on both historical and contemporary prejudices against Jewish communities in the United States.

Jewish-American Identity and the Democratic Party

Timestamp: 05:47 - 09:19

Schumer discusses the intrinsic relationship between American Jews and the Democratic Party, asserting that this alliance remains strong despite recent political shifts. He underscores the fragility of Jewish success in America, rooted in a history of survival and resilience against persecution.

Chuck Schumer [06:10]: "The Jewish values and the American values are a very good mix and potent combination and have yielded a lot of success for the Jewish people."

He also touches upon the evolving perception of Jewish identity within the political landscape, asserting that authentic representation is crucial for maintaining trust and support within the Jewish-American community.

Democratic Messaging and Authenticity

Timestamp: 09:19 - 12:25

The conversation shifts to the Democratic Party’s current messaging strategies. Schumer argues that Democrats are not suffering from an authenticity problem but rather from a failure to effectively communicate their longstanding support for working-class Americans. He criticizes past assumptions that legislative successes alone would suffice in garnering public support.

Chuck Schumer [10:03]: "Donald Trump is making the middle class pay for tax cuts for billionaires."

Schumer emphasizes the need for the party to adapt its communication methods, particularly leveraging social media and influencer engagement to better convey their policies and achievements to the public.

Recent Political Decisions: The Federal Spending Bill Vote

Timestamp: 30:43 - 47:03

A pivotal moment in the interview centers on Schumer’s unexpected decision to join Republicans in passing a federal spending bill, which averted a government shutdown but ignited fury within his own party. He explains that this choice was a strategic move to prevent the more devastating consequences of a shutdown orchestrated by Republican leader Mitch McConnell and influenced by figures like Donald Trump and Elon Musk.

Chuck Schumer [44:44]: "A shutdown would shut down all government agencies and it would solely be up to Trump and Doge and Musk what to open again because they could determine what was essential."

Schumer defends his decision by highlighting the catastrophic impact a shutdown would have on essential services, arguing that the immediate harm outweighed partisan disagreements. He acknowledges the division this caused within the Democratic Party but maintains that avoiding a shutdown was paramount for the nation's well-being.

Aftermath of the Vote: Divisions Within the Democratic Party

Timestamp: 43:09 - 52:04

Following his vote with Republicans, Schumer addresses the ensuing backlash from prominent Democrats, including Nancy Pelosi and Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez. While he defends his decision as necessary to prevent a shutdown, he recognizes the strained relationships this has caused within the party.

Chuck Schumer [48:11]: "We have mutual respect in our caucus and we are all united, no matter how people voted on this vote, to continue fighting Trump."

Schumer reassures listeners that despite the disagreements, the Democratic caucus remains unified in their broader mission to counteract Trump’s influence. He emphasizes ongoing efforts to engage with Republican districts and rally support against policies perceived as favoring the wealthy elite.

Leadership and Future Prospects

Timestamp: 47:03 - 51:38

The interview explores Schumer’s role as a leader within the Democratic Party amidst the internal conflict. He likens his leadership to that of an orchestra conductor, coordinating diverse talents and ensuring cohesive action towards common goals.

Chuck Schumer [17:13]: "We have a unique opportunity now... to regain the ear of the working people and middle class people."

Discussing potential challenges to his leadership, including rumors of a primary challenge by Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, Schumer remains confident in his approach and commitment to the party’s objectives. He expresses a focus on diminishing Trump’s popularity as a strategic priority for the coming years.

Views on Trump and Democratic Strategy

Timestamp: 38:50 - 42:21

Schumer articulates his staunch opposition to Donald Trump, framing him as a threat to democratic norms and the integrity of American institutions. He outlines a strategy centered on reducing Trump’s influence through persistent legislative and public relations efforts.

Chuck Schumer [40:23]: "Donald Trump will screw up... we'll keep at it until he goes below 40."

He highlights the importance of judicial support in upholding democratic principles and expresses hope that Republican senators dissatisfied with Trump will oppose his attempts to undermine democracy.

Regional Politics: New York State and Upcoming Elections

Timestamp: 32:04 - 35:34

Addressing the political climate in New York, Schumer discusses recent election results where Trump improved his performance, citing public concerns over crime and safety as primary factors influencing voter behavior.

Chuck Schumer [34:12]: "I think that influenced New Yorkers. New Yorkers are willing to put up with a lot to live in New York, but they want to be safe."

He emphasizes the importance of addressing safety concerns to regain voter support and outlines ongoing efforts at the city and state levels to reduce crime as a means to appeal to disenfranchised voters.

Controversial Figures and Party Dynamics

Timestamp: 35:53 - 50:31

The discussion briefly touches on controversial Democratic figures like Mayor Eric Adams and former Governor Andrew Cuomo. Schumer refrains from commenting directly on Adams but critiques Cuomo's actions and the broader implications for Democratic politics in New York.

When questioned about potential leadership challenges and allegations of mismanagement within the party, Schumer maintains that internal respect and a shared commitment to combating Trump underpin the Democratic caucus’s cohesion.

Chuck Schumer [50:41]: "I believe that my hard work against Trump will pay off."

Conclusion

The interview concludes with Schumer reiterating his dedication to leading the Democratic Party through turbulent political waters, emphasizing unity against common threats and a relentless pursuit of policies benefiting the working and middle classes. He remains optimistic about the party’s direction and its ability to adapt to contemporary challenges.

Notable Quotes

• Chuck Schumer [02:20]: "October 7th changed it all. And all of a sudden, antisemitism explodes in ways we've never seen."
• Chuck Schumer [06:10]: "The Jewish values and the American values are a very good mix and potent combination and have yielded a lot of success for the Jewish people."
• Chuck Schumer [10:03]: "Donald Trump is making the middle class pay for tax cuts for billionaires."
• Chuck Schumer [44:44]: "A shutdown would shut down all government agencies and it would solely be up to Trump and Doge and Musk what to open again because they could determine what was essential."
• Chuck Schumer [48:11]: "We have mutual respect in our caucus and we are all united, no matter how people voted on this vote, to continue fighting Trump."
• Chuck Schumer [40:23]: "Donald Trump will screw up... we'll keep at it until he goes below 40."
• Chuck Schumer [34:12]: "I think that influenced New Yorkers. New Yorkers are willing to put up with a lot to live in New York, but they want to be safe."
• Chuck Schumer [50:41]: "I believe that my hard work against Trump will pay off."

Closing Remarks

This episode offers a comprehensive look into Senator Chuck Schumer’s current challenges and strategies within the Democratic Party. From addressing the rise in antisemitism to navigating internal party conflicts, Schumer provides candid insights into his leadership approach and the broader political landscape. Listeners gain an understanding of the complexities facing American politics today and the delicate balance leaders must maintain to uphold democratic values while managing party unity.

For full access to this and other insightful episodes, subscribe to The New York Times podcasts at nytimes.com/podcasts or on platforms like Apple Podcasts and Spotify.