
Parents try everything to influence their children. But new research suggests that brothers and sisters have their own profound impact. Susan Dominus, a staff writer for The New York Times Magazine, discusses the surprising ways that our brothers and sisters shape our lives.
Loading summary
Capital One Ad
This message comes from Capital One. Your business requires commercial banking solutions that prioritize your long term success with Capital One. Get a full suite of financial products and services tailored to meet your needs today and goals for tomorrow. Learn more@capitalone.com Commercial Member FDIC.
Michael Balbaro
From the.
Susan Dominus
New York Times, I'm Michael Balbaro. This is the Daily Much of our understanding of what makes us who we are revolves around the role of our parents. Today, my colleague Susan Dominus on the unseen but surprisingly powerful ways that our lives are shaped by our siblings. It's Tuesday, May 13th. Hi Sue.
Hi Michael.
Michael Balbaro
It is really nice to see you.
Susan Dominus
It's so nice to see you too.
Michael Balbaro
I want to jump in and I want to have you tell the story of how it is you became so interested in the subject of his siblings.
Susan Dominus
So I think it started when I was a young child and my parents used to go away pretty often and travel for work. And when they did, I would stay with really close family friends. And you may know that when you stay with a family, you really get to know them and their culture in a way that's different from your own family. You can really see all these big differences in one family I stayed with, the kids would do these very elaborate math problems like at the table, you.
Michael Balbaro
Know, at the dinner table.
Susan Dominus
At the dinner table. One the father would say, so Daniel, a plane is leaving Chicago traveling this many miles an hour, and another one is leaving New York. What time would they cross paths in? Wherever, you know.
Michael Balbaro
Oh my God. What are you thinking when that question.
Susan Dominus
Comes across as well? I loved it. It was like a show for me. I just loved it until they asked me that question one day and I burst into tears.
Michael Balbaro
But is it safe to say that was not the dinner table dynamic at your house?
Susan Dominus
No, my father's very proud of the one rule we had at the table, which was that you had to chew with your mouth closed. And that was firmly enforced. But I became what I think of as kind of a family oper. I got very interested in how family cultures differed and how it affected the kids in those families and their outcomes and who they were likely to become. And fast forward, I become a journalist. Perhaps not surprisingly, a lot of what I cover as a now adult familyologist is family dynamics. I did a lot of reporting that involves twins and nature and nurture. And I really got interested in doing even more research into this topic. I ended up undertaking a book which was going to be about the nature of families of high achieving siblings. And I went into the book Fully expecting that I was gonna hear these stories about parents who had these extraordinary ways of doing things, and they inspired and motivated their kids. And instead, what I found was that although parents matter, certainly the parenting effect is actually probably smaller than we think. These decisions that loving parents really agonize over, like whether to have a chore wheel or whether to co sleep, those things probably matter less than we think. And what I found, as I reported and researched, was that sibling effects are more profound than have been realized. And they really do matter for kids in ways that I think researchers are just only now starting to appreciate.
Michael Balbaro
Mm. So tell us what you end up concluding about the sibling effect from your book, the Family Dynamic, which ends up very much being a study of the dynamics of siblings.
Susan Dominus
Well, I think that there is a kind of duality to how these things work. And what I really found is that the parents. Sort of the way I think of it is parents can kind of launch this arrow of ambition and striving into the air, but the people who focus that arrow and who help it land somewhere, maybe someplace suitable, very often, those are the siblings.
Michael Balbaro
That's a lovely metaphor.
Susan Dominus
Thank you.
Michael Balbaro
Michael, I wonder if you can illustrate how it actually works that siblings influence the direction of that arrow.
Susan Dominus
Yeah, I was curious about that myself. How did that work? And one way that I got at it was by going deep with a couple of families and really spending time with them, really understanding the sibling dynamics and how they recalled their childhoods and these really influential moments. So one of the families that let me into their lives was the Groff family. This is a family of three siblings. Lauren Groff is this much lauded, influential novelist. Her sister, Sarah True, is an Olympic triathlete turned ironman champion. I know. And then they have a third sibling who they also know. He's the really impressive one, Adam. And he is a serial healthcare entrepreneur who's done extremely well doing good with innovative healthcare solutions.
Michael Balbaro
Okay, and what do you find from the graphs?
Susan Dominus
You know, the graphs embodied very neatly a concept that's known as differentiation. This is the idea that kids are trying to find a niche as they're growing up. And so if one sibling is doing one thing, whether it's conscious or not, another sibling might go in a different direction or their parents might even push them in a different direction. So you can see where this ended up in the graphs in that they all have careers that are wildly different. Wildly different.
Michael Balbaro
And what do you come to understand about how. And this seems important. Consciously or unconsciously, the Groff siblings exerted a Differentiating force on each other. Cause that seems like it would be not something you would necessarily ever consciously intend to do.
Susan Dominus
I think it happens all kinds of ways, actually. But the person who's most explicit about it was Sarah, who's the youngest of the three siblings. And Sarah had these two older siblings who were very, very academic. And she felt that if she couldn't keep up with them, that was on her, she said. And that her desire to keep up with them was all about her relationship to them, much less her parents. So first of all, that was interesting to me. It wasn't about pleasing her parents, it was about keeping up with her siblings and being worthy in their eyes, I think. But she also felt that she couldn't keep up with them academically. And she says that she thinks she made a conscious choice to go into sports all year because that was a domain where she knew she could excel. But even more than that, she knew that Lauren wasn't that interested in it. And so, you know, so she felt.
Michael Balbaro
Like the lane was free.
Susan Dominus
The lane was free. And this effort that Sarah has to, you know, find her own lane really comes to head when she's 14 years old and she tells her parents that she wants to swim the length of the nine mile lake that's right outside of their home. And the family all sort of, you know, they're dreading this. They don't think she's gonna be able to do it, but they're like, okay, let's go, dad. Rose brother's in the sailboat with him too. And not only does she swim the length of the lake, but she actually broke the town record for men and for women.
Michael Balbaro
Wow.
Susan Dominus
And that record still stands. And they all agree that that was a really defining moment for Sarah. And I think she kind of came into her own and realized, ah, this is who I am and what I'm gonna keep doing. And ran with it and swam with it and became this incredible triath. And it's really interesting because there's a lot of research actually that suggests that younger siblings are overrepresented in sports. So there is this finding that comes up over and over again that the oldest sibling is indeed the most cognitively strong, does the best in school, gets the best grades, they have this little cognitive edge.
Michael Balbaro
Just explain that because everyone listening is gonna wanna understand why that is.
Susan Dominus
Well, there's different theories about it, but the one that rings the most true to me, I'll just say, is that when you're an only child, you know, your parents just shower, you with a level of attention and cognitive enrichment.
Michael Balbaro
And they have more of that attention.
Susan Dominus
They have literally more hours in the day to spend on that first child than they do when the second and the third come along. By the way, I should emphasize that these effects are small and they are also on average. So it does, it does not mean that this is necessarily true for your family, dear listener, or dear youngest child, of which I am one. But it does mean that on average, this is what we see. And so when you have an oldest child typically being the most academically strong, then you see this differentiation, which is that younger children are sometimes more drawn to sports or they compete a little bit harder in sports in order to define their niche and find their way and have space where they can excel. And then you actually do see in some research that younger children are overrepresented in elite sports.
Michael Balbaro
It's fascinating. And clearly that seems to be what happened with the youngest of the Groff siblings. What about the middle Groff child? What was her experience? Lauren.
Susan Dominus
So what I see in Lauren is something that's a little bit different, which is you can see in Lauren, and she's actually also quite self aware about this, how a sense of competition with her brother was really fueling her. I don't think her brother was even aware that there was a competition, but she felt like she wanted to prove something to him. At one point she felt, she told me, that a huge part of what motivated her to write big books, feminist literature, was the frustration that she felt with this all knowing older brother.
Michael Balbaro
Wow. So what's important about the Grofs, it would seem, is that you have this academically strong and much more than he would seem to know, emotionally towering figure. And the two younger siblings respond in these complicated ways that it sounds like they're conscious of. They seem to know it's happening, and as a result they end up and very high achieving, but extremely different lines of work.
Susan Dominus
That's beautifully summed up. Thank you, Michael. Yes.
Michael Balbaro
Well, what about the Groff's parents, in your understanding of the family, how did they launch that, to use your phrase, arrow of ambition, that the sibling, especially Adam, the older brother, ultimately influences the course of.
Susan Dominus
You know, both of the Groff parents had come from very hardscrabble backgrounds and gotten college degrees and their father had become a doctor and was able to provide this really lovely life for his. But I think it was very important to them that their children be tough, that their children be hardworking in part because of where they had come from. So they even have this term in the family, which is gruffiness, which is a certain kind of, like, hard work and, like, brute force getting things done. Lauren once said to me that in her family, work was holy, and I think that is the launching of the arrow.
Michael Balbaro
Do these siblings get along? I mean, does differentiation mean ultimately difficulty?
Susan Dominus
Oh, I sometimes think it's the differentiation that allows them to be close because the competition isn't happening.
Michael Balbaro
That's really interesting.
Susan Dominus
Yeah. And in fact, they are very, very close. You know, Sarah moved to New Hampshire to be closer to Adam. At one point in her training, Sarah's been very open about mental health struggles that she's gone through. She's a mental health advocate. And Sarah says that Lauren was somebody who would just stay on the phone with her sometimes, being there for her, even if they were very, very quiet.
Sue, the Grofs are a family with a fair amount of resources.
Michael Balbaro
Right.
Susan Dominus
So how much do your findings, especially around differentiation, apply to families without those resources? Does that mean that there is inherently less competition, less enrichment, less differentiation?
Yeah, there is some research that suggests that you see differentiation in families that have the resources to shuttle kids around to different kinds of lessons, and there's a lot of room for individualization in those families. In less advantaged families, you don't have quite so much differentiation. But there is an equally powerful force that does shape the siblings. And I really saw this at work in a family that I got to know very well, called the Chens.
We'll be right back.
Capital One Ad
Hey, finance folks. You're under a lot of pressure to save money, but the best finance leaders focus on more than that. Brex knows you want to drive growth, change the game, and win. So that's exactly what Brex will help you do. Brex offers the world's smartest corporate card banking, expense management, and travel, all on one AI powered platform. See why 30,000 companies across every stage of growth, use brex@brex.com grow brex.com grow.
Strawberry Me Ad
This podcast is supported by Strawberry Me. Unlike any class, book or podcast, Strawberry Me career coaching gives you something truly unique. A professional partner who's 100% focused on your success. It's not just advice. It's like therapy for your career. Your coach will ask the right questions, helping you uncover hidden strengths, break through obstacles, and move forward with confidence. If you're ready to unlock your full potential, visit Strawberry Methedaily to claim your $50 credit. That's strawberry Methedaily.
Michael Balbaro
So, sue, tell us about the Chen family and the dynamic between the siblings in that family that was at play.
Susan Dominus
So the Chens were family that had immigrated from China, and their parents ran a Chinese restaurant. They were incredibly hardworking and worked very, very long hours, and they just weren't around as much as parents ideally hoped to be. So the siblings were extremely close, and they spent a lot of time together, and they really influenced each other very strongly. And what you see in this family is a phenomenon that's called the spillover effect. The spillover effect is just a reflection of the fact that when one sibling does well, then the younger siblings tend to do well as well. And for many years, it's been difficult to know whether that's because of genetic overlap or is there something in the environment apart from how the siblings are influencing each other. But there's a really interesting study that was conducted just a few years ago that is sort of what we call a semi natural experiment. This researcher at Yale found that when children are kind of on the old side for their grade, depending on where their birthday is, we know that those kids tend to do better academically than kids who are very young for their grade.
Michael Balbaro
Right.
Susan Dominus
So she looked at the younger siblings of those kids who happened to be doing better in school because of this developmental advantage. And what she found was, for the younger siblings of those kids, didn't matter whether those kids, these younger siblings were old for their grade, young for their grade, they did better than expected.
Michael Balbaro
Hmm.
Susan Dominus
And so you really see here that is the sibling effect. It's not something that's happening at home. It's not genetic. It's just affected by the good luck that an older sibling had in being a little bit old for the grade.
Michael Balbaro
And what does the spillover effect look like? How does it operate within the Chen family?
Susan Dominus
So there's four Chen siblings. The oldest is Elizabeth, then comes Yi, then Gong, and then a fourth sibling who is much younger than the older ones. His name is Devon. When they arrived in the United States, Elizabeth was put into a grade that was two years below her age because they were so worried about her English skills that they wanted to give her a chance. Not only did they give her a chance, but I think they really gave her a boost because she was gonna catch up with the English pretty quickly. And then she had all these other advantages, you know, like self control and just being more developmentally farther along. And teachers really respond to that. And then school becomes a really comfortable place. And that was a place where she excelled. And then because she did excel in school, she. To help her siblings excel, she would tell them which APs to take. And she would help them with their homework. And all of the siblings played instruments and she was very important in helping them practice. And they all were coaching each other. That was true in a way for sports as well. So E, the oldest of the brothers was a very accomplished wrestler, but it's not that gang then chose some other sport. He didn't go in a different direction. He too became a wrestler. And so he benefited from his brothers. And they were kind of consolidating forces. There's like this symbiosis. And you know, you see these kinds of so called spillover effects. They influence each other in very collaborative ways.
Michael Balbaro
And it sounds like in this collaboration you're describing, the Chen siblings are building off one another, each one hoping that the next will do at least as well, if not better than they did either academically or athletically. That you're saying is the spillover effect. And it really does feel quite different than the more competitive tinged idea of differentiation.
Susan Dominus
I mean, this certainly looks like one mechanism of the sibling spillover effect. It's the opposite of competition. It's working together and influencing each other and making each other in some ways more similar, which to them was about making each other better, basically. You really see it in their youngest sibling, Devin. They had all gone off to college themselves or maybe were even out of college by the time he was applying to schools. And they actually felt a little bad that he wasn't benefiting from what they had provided for each other when they all lived in the same home at the same time.
Michael Balbaro
There wasn't enough spill left to spill over him.
Susan Dominus
Yeah, exactly. And so they would, you know, conference call with him. And they actually formed a reading group to make sure that he was reading, they were picking books for to make sure that he was keeping up with that. And then when it came time for him to apply to college, they actually divided up the tasks. One of them took over SAT prep, and one helped him with his essays, and one helped him keep on top of applications and staying organized. And this is one mechanism of how the spillover effect works. It's Devin presumably wanting to live up to his siblings academic success, but it's them also really sharing their resources with him.
Michael Balbaro
Where does Devin end up going to college? Which of course makes me want to know what happens to all four of the Chen siblings in terms of their career.
Susan Dominus
So all four of the Chens were in fact valedictorians, and Devin ended up going to Dartmouth. And I'll spare you the colleges, they're all terrific, but there's more to life than college. I know you're like, no, there is nothing more to life than college. What I like about the careers they all chose that I find very moving is that they all chose careers that sort of would have helped their own parents when they were struggling in their first years in America. So Elizabeth became a doctor who works with a sizable Chinese population. You know, I think their parents rarely went to the doctor. I'm sure if there had been Chinese doctors in the area, they would have been more comfortable. Yi actually was one of the first hires at this mega restaurant software business called Toast. It's like the Amazon of restaurant software. And Gong ended up working at this very high power AI English language instruction startup. And then Devin works in Amazon. He's a software engineer. Devin likes to say that of the four siblings, he's the one who works to live where his siblings, he thinks all live to work. So in my time with his family, I was struck by how proud of each other they all were, how protective of each other they all were. And now, of course, they're having children of their own. It's really beautiful to watch that happen. And they're all really intent on the cousins being really close.
Michael Balbaro
I mean, that's a remarkably beautiful story. I wonder if spillover effects on siblings are always as constructive and positive as they were with the Chens.
Susan Dominus
Now, that's a really important question, because spillover effects, of course, can in fact, work the other way. We know that siblings influence each other, and that means that if a sibling's grades are suffering because of some outside force, that's also gonna have an effect on their younger siblings. So. So the concern is that if you're in a disadvantaged family, there might be some trauma, right, that affects the older sibling. Adverse childhood events, we call them. So if there is something traumatic that happens, I'm a junior in high school, maybe my grades suffer. Okay? My little sister is a freshman in high school. Her grades suffer as a result of the same trauma. But also because the junior in high school's grades have suffered, that too, has a negative effect on that younger sibling. So it's this one, two punch. And so what that tells us is that you have families that are more likely to suffer some kind of disruption like this than the grades suffer. And we know that income later in life is very closely tied to grades and test scores in high school. So these kinds of sibling effects actually do have really profound policy implications.
Michael Balbaro
What do you mean by policy implications?
Susan Dominus
Well, just when we think about Are we going to invest in interventions? It actually turns out that if you can raise the academic performance of an older sibling, that investment in that intervention is all the more worthwhile because it's gonna have ripple effects on the whole family, or more specifically, the younger sibling. And so you're not just affecting, let's say, the economic, you know, earnings of the older sibling down the road, but the younger one, too. You're getting so much more bang for your buck with an effective intervention than really has been previously realized.
Michael Balbaro
I'm not trying to be facetious, but this almost sounds biblical. If the eldest child is invested in properly and this spillover effect happens, that seems quite important and potentially achievable.
Susan Dominus
I did say the oldest child, but I think it's possible that sibling effects can work in multiple directions.
Michael Balbaro
And does that mean that younger siblings can spill over to older siblings?
Susan Dominus
Yes, that is what that means.
Michael Balbaro
Hmm. So now that we've talked through these two distinct but seemingly related forces of the spillover effect and differentiation between siblings, I wonder what you have found in your reporting on how controllable any of this is. Parents like to think, and you hinted at this earlier, that they exert some level of influence over this kind of thing. Can they? Do they? Or is it ultimately out of their control?
Susan Dominus
You know, I think that parents think they have more control than they actually do over so much. And trying to really change one child is kind of like checkers. And then the idea that you're gonna try to actually manipulate some complicated interaction over many years among multiple siblings, like, to me, that's just like playing chess with a blindfold on. So, you know, there's some common sense things that I think parents aspire to, which is not to compare too much. And if they have the resources to let children, you know, pick their own passions and foster them. But I also think that some of the things that drive sibling relationships, such as competition and rivalry, you can manage it, but you can't necessarily control it.
Michael Balbaro
I don't think we can end this conversation without asking you about your own siblings and your relationship to them, with them. Is it a story of spillover? Is it a story of differentiation? Is it a story of something else entirely?
Susan Dominus
I think in terms of personality, there's some differentiation there, but it's also, I think, this idea of the arrow being launched and the sibling helping it land somewhere. I really see that in my own family because my parents definitely valued hard work. That was a huge value in our household. But my brother was the person who came to me when I was 14 and said, why don't you join the high school newspaper? He was at college at the time. And I said, we don't have one anymore. That it disbanded. And my brother then launched into a big lecture about the decline of democracy without a free press. And it was pathetic. And he kind of rallied me to try to restart the high school newspaper. Wow. And I was a pretty passive kid. I spent most of my time reading in a room. But my brother knew me well enough to know. He knew before I knew that I would love doing journalism. And I think if my parents had suggested, I would have rolled my eyes and thought it was something they thought I should put on my application. But also, God bless my parents, they were really laid back people. They weren't the kind of people who were paying that much attention, you know. And so it was my brother who was paying attention and who knew the school environment. He knew me. He knew what high schools were supposed to have. And somehow his belief that I could do it. I actually did go out and do it. I'm not saying it was a great high school newspaper. It was not, but it was. I loved doing it. And from the second the first article started trickling in, I just was like, oh, this is what I want to do. And so it was a really fateful conversation that we had that day. And I definitely am grateful to my brother for it.
Michael Balbaro
I mean, let's just be explicit about how fateful.
Susan Dominus
Oh, yeah. I mean, I found my vocation because. Because my brother told me to do it.
Michael Balbaro
Told me to do it.
Susan Dominus
He didn't just tell me to do it. He kind of bullied me into doing it. Like, I didn't want him to come home from the next vacation and be like, why didn't you start a high school newspaper? You know? And then start lecturing me all, I didn't want to disappoint my brother.
Michael Balbaro
And of course, there's something kind of poetic about this. If your oldest sibling hadn't pushed you to create that newspaper and become a journalist, you would never go on to write a book about siblings.
Susan Dominus
That's true. And I think it is because I've been very lucky in that way that I've also been really drawn to the subject.
Michael Balbaro
And on that note. Cause I'm not talking about my family.
Susan Dominus
Oh, damn.
Michael Balbaro
Sue.
Susan Dominus
Yes.
Michael Balbaro
Thank you very much.
Susan Dominus
I had a question for you, Michael. One last question tomorrow, okay?
Michael Balbaro
On the Daily. Thank you, Sue. I appreciate it.
Susan Dominus
Oh, just my pleasure. Thank you for having me.
We'll be right back.
Capital One Ad
Hey, finance folks. You're under a lot of pressure to save money, but the best finance leaders focus on more than that. Brex knows you want to drive growth, change the game and win. So that's exactly what Brex will help you do. Brex offers the world's smartest corporate card banking, expense management and Travel all on one AI powered platform. See why 30,000 companies across every stage of growth use Brex@brex.com grow brex.com grow I'm Judson Jones.
Judson Jones
I'm a reporter and meteorologist at the New York Times. For about two decades I've been covering extreme weather, which is getting worse because of climate change, and it's becoming more important to get timely and accurate weather information. That's why we send these customized newsletters letting you know up to three days in advance about extreme weather that could impact you or a place you care about. At the Times, you can be confident that everything we publish is based off the most accurate scientific embedded information available to us. Because we want you to be able to make real time decisions about how to go about your life. This is the kind of work that makes subscribing to the New York Times so valuable. Valuable. And it's how you can support fact based independent journalism. So if you'd like to subscribe, go to nytimes.com subscribe.
Susan Dominus
Here'S what else you need to know today. On Monday, the stock market soared and thousands of American businesses businesses celebrated as the United States and China agreed to drastically reduce their tariffs against one another for the next three months. Starting tomorrow, the US will reduce its tariffs on Chinese imports from 145% to 30%. China in turn, will lower its tariffs on American goods from 125% to just just 10%. Negotiators from both countries will now seek to reach a permanent trade deal, but few believe that either country will ever return to the sky high tariffs of the past month. As a result, The S&P 500 rose 3.3%, the Dow Jones Industrial Average surged nearly 2.8%, and the Nasdaq stack climbed nearly 4.4%. Officially entering a bull market. Today's episode was produced by Asta Chaturvedi and Ricky Novetsky with help from Claire Teneschetto. It was edited by Michael Benoit and Mark George. Contains original music by Marian Lozano and Dan Powell and was engineered by Chris Wood. Our theme music is by Jim Brunberg and Ben Landsberg of Wonder Lake. That's it for the Daily. I'm Michael Balbaro.
Michael Balbaro
See you tomorrow.
Summary of "The Secret Power of Siblings" Episode of The Daily
Release Date: May 13, 2025
Host: Michael Barbaro
Guest: Susan Dominus, Journalist and Author
In this insightful episode of The Daily, host Michael Barbaro engages in a profound conversation with Susan Dominus, a seasoned journalist and author, about the often-overlooked influence of siblings in shaping our lives. Dominus delves into her extensive research on family dynamics, particularly focusing on how siblings play a pivotal role in personal development, surpassing even parental influence in certain aspects.
[01:20] Susan Dominus:
“I became what I think of as kind of a familyologist. I got very interested in how family cultures differed and how it affected the kids in those families and their outcomes and who they were likely to become.”
Dominus shares her childhood experiences, highlighting how time spent away from her parents with family friends exposed her to diverse family cultures. This early exposure piqued her interest in family dynamics, leading her to explore the roles siblings play in personal development. Her journalistic endeavors evolved into an academic pursuit, culminating in her book that challenges the conventional emphasis on parenting by illuminating the profound impact siblings have on each other.
One of the primary case studies Dominus examines is the Groff family, consisting of three high-achieving siblings:
[03:58] Susan Dominus:
“I think that there is a kind of duality to how these things work. The parents can kind of launch this arrow of ambition and striving into the air, but the people who focus that arrow and help it land somewhere, maybe someplace suitable, very often, those are the siblings.”
Dominus introduces the concept of differentiation, where siblings consciously or unconsciously carve out distinct paths to establish their unique identities. In the Groff household, Adam's academic prowess set a high standard, prompting his younger siblings to pursue excellence in different fields to find their niches. This differentiation fosters a healthy competition that drives each sibling to excel individually while maintaining close familial bonds.
Notable Quote:
[06:01] Susan Dominus:
“I think it was very important to them that their children be tough, that their children be hardworking... 'Work was holy,' Lauren once said.”
Through Differentiation, the Groff siblings pursued vastly different careers—Adam in healthcare entrepreneurship, Sarah in sports, and Lauren in literature—demonstrating how sibling dynamics can encourage diverse achievements without fostering resentment.
Contrasting the Groffs' differentiation, Dominus explores the spillover effect within the Chen family, an immigrant household running a Chinese restaurant:
[15:36] Susan Dominus:
“The spillover effect is just a reflection of the fact that when one sibling does well, then the younger siblings tend to do well as well.”
In the Chen family, the success of the eldest sibling, Elizabeth, a doctor serving the Chinese community, created a supportive environment that enabled her siblings to thrive academically and professionally. Elizabeth’s achievements and guidance played a crucial role in her younger siblings’ successes, illustrating how positive influences can cascade through sibling relationships, fostering collective advancement rather than individual competition.
Notable Quote:
[17:24] Susan Dominus:
“It's the opposite of competition. It's working together and influencing each other and making each other in some ways more similar, which to them was about making each other better.”
The Chen siblings not only supported each other’s academic and professional endeavors but also chose career paths that contributed to their family's well-being, reinforcing a collaborative dynamic that contrasts with the competitive differentiation seen in the Groff family.
Dominus emphasizes the broader societal and policy implications of understanding sibling dynamics:
[21:13] Michael Barbaro:
“What do you mean by policy implications?”
[21:15] Susan Dominus:
“If you can raise the academic performance of an older sibling, that investment in that intervention is all the more worthwhile because it's gonna have ripple effects on the whole family.”
Effective interventions aimed at improving the outcomes for one sibling can have amplified benefits for the entire family unit. By enhancing the academic or professional success of one child, policymakers can foster an environment where these positive effects spill over, promoting overall family advancement and reducing socioeconomic disparities.
In a heartfelt conclusion, Dominus shares her personal experience with her siblings, illustrating how sibling influence extends into one's own life choices and career path.
[23:10] Susan Dominus:
“I found my vocation because my brother told me to do it. He kind of bullied me into doing it.”
Dominus recounts how her brother's encouragement led her to revive her high school newspaper, igniting her passion for journalism. This personal anecdote underscores the profound and often subconscious ways siblings can shape each other’s destinies.
Susan Dominus’s exploration into sibling dynamics reveals the nuanced and powerful roles that brothers and sisters play in our lives. Through the lenses of differentiation and spillover effects, she illustrates how siblings can be both collaborators and competitors, driving each other toward excellence in unique and supportive ways. This episode underscores the importance of recognizing and fostering positive sibling relationships as a cornerstone for individual and familial success.
Notable Quote to End:
[25:47] Michael Barbaro:
“And if your oldest sibling hadn't pushed you to create that newspaper and become a journalist, you would never go on to write a book about siblings.”
Dominus’s work not only sheds light on the complexities of sibling relationships but also celebrates the unseen bonds that propel each of us toward our full potential.
Produced by Asta Chaturvedi and Ricky Novetsky, with contributions from Claire Teneschetto. Edited by Michael Benoit and Mark George. Music by Marian Lozano, Dan Powell, Jim Brunberg, and Ben Landsberg of Wonder Lake.
For a deeper dive into the powerful dynamics of sibling relationships and their impact on personal and familial success, tune into this episode of The Daily.