The Dan Le Batard Show with Stugotz

Local Hour: How Did We Get Here?

Date: September 19, 2025
Podcast Hosts: Dan Le Batard, Stugotz (not present), Billy Gil, Jonathan Zaslow, Roy Cummings
Location: The Elser Hotel, Downtown Miami

Episode Overview

This Local Hour episode is a quintessential dive into the psyche of Miami sports fandom, bouncing between earnest confessions, analytical breakdowns, and affectionate mockery of the region’s teams—particularly the Miami Dolphins. The hosts dissect the team's latest struggles, the infamous Zach Seiler roughing penalty, Tua Tagovailoa’s status as a franchise quarterback, Tyreek Hill’s performance, and even detour into Florida Panthers and Miami Hurricanes territory. The episode is punctuated by self-aware humor and the group’s unique blend of pessimism and hope.

Key Discussion Points & Insights

1. Miami Dolphins: Frustration and Fatal Flaws

Timestamp: 01:01 – 29:40

• Fan Perspective & Emotional Toll:

  • Zaslow admits he morphs into an irrational Dolphins fan during games, in contrast to his more reasoned approach with the Panthers or Heat.
    • “I don’t like what the Dolphins do to me.” – Roy Cummings (01:41)
  • Zaslow and the others riff on the emotional scars left by decades of Dolphins' letdowns, likening fandom to unnecessary suffering.

• Dolphins-Bills Game Analysis:

  • The crew analyzes the Dolphins’ 10-point loss to the Bills, lamenting how even Miami’s “best possible game” isn’t enough against elite teams.
    • “That is the best game that team can play...and they lose by 10 points against the Bills.” – Jonathan Zaslow (05:01)
  • Miami's offense was shockingly anemic: both QBs averaged only 1.4 air yards per completion—a stat so pitiful it becomes a running joke.
    • “Guess as low as you want to guess...1.4 yards per completion.” – Jonathan Zaslow (07:32)

• On Tua Tagovailoa:

  • Consensus grows that Tua is not a franchise QB, with several citing his lack of growth and inability to win close games against strong opponents.
    • “I don’t think this guy’s good. It’s six years in. I think I’m ready to make a judgment call.” – Dan Le Batard (11:03)
    • “He seems to have regressed...even every long pass he’s had to Tyreek [Hill] has either been under thrown or the defenders are right there.” – Billy Gil (11:21)
  • Criticism softens when Zaslow points to breakdowns on the offensive line leading to hurried, panicked throws from Tua—a sign the issues run deeper than quarterback alone.
    • “He was getting rid of the ball in two seconds because he had to, and that’s how the mistake got made.” – Jonathan Zaslow (18:33)

• On Play Calling & Strategy:

  • The offense’s heavy reliance on screen passes and swing routes is mocked—particularly considering Tua's $55 million/year contract.
    • “You pay the quarterback...and like that’s the offense. How did we get here?” – Roy Cummings (21:50)
  • The hosts highlight how previously explosive players—Tyreek Hill and Jaylen Waddle—have become nearly invisible, pinned in place by predictable play design and defensive scheming.

2. The Zach Seiler Penalty & Defensive Woes

Timestamp: 14:06 – 15:13, 22:27 – 23:20

• The infamous roughing the punter penalty by Zach Seiler comes under scrutiny. The crew is hesitant to single him out, instead framing his hustle as a tragic overreach amid a team that’s constantly scrambling to cover for its flaws.

  • “I'm not going to criticize one of their best and most solid players...” – Jonathan Zaslow (14:15)

• There's resignation that Miami's defense, not offense, might doom the season:

  • "I believe it's going to be the defense. I don't believe they're going to be able—The second half is the first time they've stopped anybody all season." – Jonathan Zaslow (10:00)

3. The Bigger Picture: Coaching, Ownership, and Future

Timestamp: 29:11 – 31:29

• Steven Ross allegedly wants to keep head coach Mike McDaniel barring a fan revolt or clear quit by the team. The group muses over how legal drama (i.e., Brian Flores's racial discrimination lawsuit) could affect looming decisions about firing personnel.

  • “[Ross] said like reportedly the only way he'd consider firing Mike McDaniel is if the fans stop showing up to the building or the team looks like they check out.” – Dan Le Batard (29:11)

• The Brian Flores lawsuit is briefly addressed as a complicating factor.

  • “Is it easy to fire your black GM and biracial head coach while claiming you are not involved in discrimination?” – Billy Gil (31:13)

4. Notable Stats: Dolphins' Record vs. Good Teams

Timestamp: 33:36 – 34:14

• Zaslow depressingly lists a series of damning statistical trends:
  • Tua is 2–14 away from home against winning teams (33:36)
  • Dolphins have lost 14 of their last 17 and 8 straight to teams over .500
    • “Winning teams are not something that they can beat.” – Jonathan Zaslow (34:02)

5. Panthers, Hurricanes, and South Florida Sports Crossover

Timestamp: 38:00 – 41:48

• On College GameDay’s guest picker: The crew debates whether Matthew Tkachuk, the Florida Panthers star, is a “lame” or “perfect” selection, with Dan arguing for Tkachuk’s historic, LeBron-like impact on South Florida sports.
  • “Matthew Tkachuk is tied with LeBron James...in terms of immediate impact.” – Dan Le Batard (38:07)
• Nostalgic and satirical takes on blockbusters like LeBron's “trade,” with Dan cheekily calling it:
  • “Acquiring LeBron was a bad trade because you actually gave up assets and he didn’t extend.” – Dan Le Batard (39:13)

6. Humor, Snark, and Self-Awareness

All segments interspersed

• The group repeatedly mocks their own past takes (e.g., Zaslow calling Panthers coach Paul Maurice a “murderer of fun”), celebrates being “big enough to admit when they're wrong,” and gleefully nitpicks each other’s arguments.
• Roasting their own suffering, they joke about why they even bother and the masochism of Dolphins fandom.
• Zaslow receives tongue-in-cheek “credit” for saving the Panthers’ season after returning from vacation, with Dan deadpanning, “I think you should be the game day picker instead of Matthew Tkachuk because you saved the season!” (43:41)

7. Offbeat South Florida News

Timestamp: 30:35 – 41:48

• Le Batard brings up a bizarre, real-life Miami crime headline:
  • “Witness in long delayed University of Miami murder case is not dead.”
  • The group riffs on the surrealism of Miami criminal investigations and uses it to pivot to College GameDay in town.

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

• “I don’t like being that guy...I don’t like what the Dolphins do to me.” – Roy Cummings (01:41)
• “I have no problem admitting when I’m wrong.” – Roy Cummings (03:17)
• “That is...the best game that team can play...and they lose by 10 points against the Bills.” – Jonathan Zaslow (05:01)
• “Guess as low as you want to guess...1.4 yards per completion.” – Jonathan Zaslow (07:32)
• “I don’t think this guy’s good. It’s six years in. I think I’m ready to make a judgment call.” – Dan Le Batard (11:03)
• “How did we get here? That was crazy.” – Dan Le Batard (21:09)
• “You pay the quarterback...and like that’s the offense. How did we get here?” – Roy Cummings (21:50)
• “He seems to have regressed...the two of them are not what they were clearly two years ago.” – Billy Gil (11:21)
• “Tua is now two and 14 away from home against winning teams, which is the second worst mark for any quarterback in the last decade.” – Jonathan Zaslow (33:36)
• “Matthew Tkachuk is tied with LeBron James...in terms of immediate impact.” – Dan Le Batard (38:07)
• “Acquiring LeBron was a bad trade because you actually gave up assets and he didn’t extend.” – Dan Le Batard (39:13)

Timestamps for Important Segments

• 01:41 – Roy Cummings on being “that guy” Dolphins fans relate to.
• 05:01 – Fatal flaw of Dolphins and ceiling debate.
• 07:32 – Shocking air yards stat.
• 11:03 – 12:13 – Tua’s inability to be a franchise QB.
• 14:06 – Zach Seiler penalty discussion and defensive struggles.
• 21:09 – 22:01 – “How did we get here?”: On the Dolphins’ stagnant offense.
• 29:11 – 31:29 – Coaching/ownership drama, Brian Flores lawsuit implications.
• 33:36 – Dolphins' poor record against winning teams.
• 38:07 – 41:48 – Matthew Tkachuk’s Miami impact, LeBron as a “bad trade.”
• 43:41 – Zaslow’s “credit” for saving the Panthers; self-aware humor.

Tone & Style

True to form, the show is a mix of passionate ranting, self-mockery, and sharp sports analysis—rich with in-jokes for fellow Miami fans and a willingness to put the city’s sports pain under a microscope. The tone flies from resignedly glum to absurdly hopeful in seconds. Even the bleakest stats are delivered with a glint of gallows humor.

This summary focuses solely on content; all ad reads and promos are omitted.