Postgame Show: The Mario Chalmers HOF Debate (feat. JuJu Gotti)

Summary

The Dan Le Batard Show with Stugotz

Episode: Postgame Show – The Mario Chalmers HOF Debate (feat. JuJu Gotti)
Date: August 25, 2025

---

Episode Overview

Recorded at the Elser Hotel in Downtown Miami, this Postgame Show features Dan Le Batard, Stugotz, their regular cast, and guest JuJu Gotti. The episode is a lively blend of sports banter and irreverent debate, highlighted by a spirited discussion about Mario Chalmers’ Hall of Fame credentials following his Big Three championship, and a rundown of college football's greatest players of the 21st century. Classic Le Batard Show chaos, quick wit, and unique perspectives are on full display.

---

Key Discussion Points & Insights

1. Run Lines, Spread Picks & Gambling Hijinks

[01:18–02:48]

• The crew discusses betting picks for upcoming baseball games.
• Roy picks the Kansas City Royals to beat the White Sox by more than a run:
  • “Kansas City’s playing the worst team in the American League in the Chicago White Sox...” (Roy, 00:50)
• Billy opts for the Marlins plus one and a half against the Braves, analyzing pitcher stats:
  • “Spencer Strider’s had a bit of a rough go as of late... Edward Cabrera, Braves are hitting .109 against him.” (Billy, 01:42)
• The group humorously bickers over the semantics of run lines vs. favorites/underdogs:
  • “You guys aren’t doing this right with the run lines and favorites and dogs.” (Analyst 1, 02:26)
  • “It’s against the spread.” (Co-host 1, 02:30)
  • “It’s a spread—the run lines are spreading it.” (Analyst 2, 02:44)

2. Bleacher Report’s Top 3 College Football Players of the 21st Century

[02:49–04:54]

• JuJu Gotti introduces Bleacher Report’s list, and the crew debates the picks.
• Countdown:
  • #3: Reggie Bush
    • “Welcome back into the good graces, Reggie Bush. It’s been a long time coming and you deserve it.” (JuJu, 03:16)
  • #2: Cam Newton
    • “Controversial. Hey, I salute to the championship they won in Auburn though I’ve never been an Auburn fan…” (JuJu, 03:24)
    • Dan (Analyst 1) draws parallels to coaches who succeeded thanks to star players:
      • “Gene Chizik goes the way of Larry Coker. Guy who wins championship because of players and then disappears from the face of the earth.” (04:05)
  • #1: Tim Tebow
    • “According to Bleacher Report, it’s your Timothy Tebow.” (JuJu, 04:05)
• Vince Young’s absence is noted:
  • “Vince Young really getting slighted in all of these.” (Dan, 04:16)
• The group jokes about God and player rankings relating to jersey number 55 and Ed Reed:
  • “55 would have been like emphasizing God.” (Co-host 2, 04:34)
• JuJu closes out by tipping his hat to Florida’s recruiting:
  • “Florida had both of them. Florida had Tim Tebow and Cam Newton. So salute to the recruitment center over there in Florida.” (JuJu, 04:47)

3. Mario Chalmers’ Hall of Fame Debate

[04:54–05:32]

• The show pivots to Mario Chalmers and Michael Beasley winning the Big Three championship.
• Dan asks the earnest (but tongue-in-cheek) question:
  • “I know this is going to come off as a joke, but sincerely, is Mario Chalmers Hall of Famer?”
    • Lists Chalmers’ resume: High school, college, Europe, NBA, Big Three championships, and the iconic NCAA title shot:
      • “He won in high school, he won with a shot in college, he won in Europe, he won in the NBA, and he hit the game-winning shot in the Big Three. He should be in the Hall of Fame.”
• The room bursts into laughter at the audacity of the claim:
  • “No, no, no.” (Analyst 2, 05:31)
  • “Sha feels.” (Co-host 1, 05:32)

---

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

• “Welcome back into the good graces, Reggie Bush.” — JuJu Gotti (03:16)
• “Gene Chizik goes the way of Larry Coker. Guy who wins championship because of players and then disappears from the face of the earth.” — Dan Le Batard (04:05)
• “I know this is going to come off as a joke, but sincerely, is Mario Chalmers Hall of Famer?” — Dan Le Batard (05:08)
• “He won in high school, he won with a shot in college, he won in Europe, he won in the NBA, and he hit the game-winning shot in the Big Three. He should be in the Hall of Fame.” — Dan Le Batard (05:17)
• “Sha feels.” — Co-host 1, responding to the Chalmers debate (05:32)

---

Timestamps for Important Segments

• Run Lines & Picks: 01:18–02:48
• Top Three College Football Players Debate: 02:49–04:54
• Mario Chalmers Hall of Fame Discussion: 04:54–05:32

---

Tone and Style

The episode is marked by signature Le Batard Show irreverence—mixing serious sports analysis with inside jokes, mock-serious debate, and playful banter. JuJu Gotti’s cameo provides fresh energy and humor, while the hosts deftly keep the conversation moving between sports history and their own wild hypotheticals.

---

This summary captures both the substance and the delightfully chaotic spirit of the show, guiding listeners through the main debates and laughs of the “Mario Chalmers HOF Debate” episode.

Transcript

[Host]

New season, new chaos in college football. Let's go.

[Co-host 1]

Big stage, big opportunity.

[Host]

This Labor Day weekend. The wildness lives on ABC, ESPN and the all new ESPN app.

[Co-host 1]

What a way to start.

[Host]

Featuring top 10 teams like Clemson, Notre Dame, Alabama and LSU. And Bill Belichick's debut at North Carolina.

[Analyst 1]

It's so special when these teams collide.

[Host]

Don't miss a lineup filled with electric matchups. Welcome back to College Football Kickoff Week, presented by Modelo. Labor day weekend on ESPN and ABC. Also available to stream on the all new ESPN Apple.

[Co-host 2]

Against the Spread is presented by DraftKings. DraftKings. The Crown is yours. Roy, what do you got?

[Analyst 2]

Royals at White Sox tonight. Noah Cameron versus Shane Smith. Kansas City's playing the worst team in the American League in the Chicago White Sox, who have lost the last 13 Monday night games versus team in their own division, Kansas City. This is a big game for them. Three games out of the wild card spot in the American League. So go with them. They are the favorites at a run and a half against the spread.

[Host]

Still.

[Analyst 1]

So you're saying winning by more than a run?

[Analyst 2]

Correct. The Royals will win by more than a run.

[Analyst 1]

That is some real expertise we got there. I saw that ESPN had a list of the top 100 players of all time in college football. Was his top 100. Bleacher Report has now made it just the top three.

[Co-host 2]

Stan, Billy has one against the spread.

[Analyst 3]

All right, I'm gonna take the Marlins plus one and a half against the Braves tonight. Marlins road or home? Dogs against the Braves, Spencer Strider versus Edward Cabrera. Spencer Strider's had a bit of a rough go as of late. 7 earn runs, 8 earn run, fiverr runs, last three starts. Doesn't have a ton of numbers against these Marlins. Edward Cabrera, Braves are hitting 109 against him. He's had two bad starts in a row. But if you go back to earlier August, Ezra Cabrera dominated the Braves 5. 1 win, 8 innings pitched, 11 strikeouts, 1 earned run in that game. Now they're coming down to Miami. And again the Marlins are one and a half run dogs at home. I'm gonna take the Marlins plus one and a half.

[Analyst 1]

You guys aren't doing this right with the run lines and favorites and dogs.

[Co-host 1]

It's against the spread.

[Analyst 3]

What do you mean? How would you do it?

[Analyst 1]

No, if you bet them to win by a run and a half, sp. It's not just because you name it as favorites and underdogs on the run line.

[Co-host 1]

Yeah, but that's a spread.

[Analyst 2]

It's a Spread the run lines are spreading it. It's not the money line, it's the run.

[Analyst 3]

Go on.

[Analyst 1]

Juju is here. He's got the top three college football players of all time according to Bleacher report. And is Tebow going to get in there? Is he going to, Is he against. Is he going to be again in the top three? What is Bleacher report saying?

[Guest (Juju)]

Yes sir, it's the actually of this century right here. Not of all time but this century. Number three, Reggie Bush. I mean.

[Analyst 1]

Oh, I'm sorry, you wanted some fanfare there, didn't you?

[Guest (Juju)]

It's all good.

[Analyst 2]

Whoops.

[Guest (Juju)]

Against the spray cat daddy. Yes sir. Well, yeah, welcome back into the good graces, Reggie Bush. We it's been a long time coming and you deserve it. Number two was Cam Newton. Controversial. Controversial. Hey, I salute to the championship they won in Auburn though I've never been an Auburn fan so I, I couldn't necessarily get too much into Cam Newton beef or love or anything. Just you know, salute to Cam.

[Analyst 1]

That was a pretty good backfield that that Auburn team had going undefeated. And then Gene Chiszek goes the way of Larry Coker. Guy who wins championship because of players and then disappears from the face of the earth.

[Guest (Juju)]

Right. And the number one player this according to Bleacher report is your Timothy Tebow.

[Analyst 1]

Vince Young really getting slighted in all of these. These memories of guy in huddle with a bunch of other first round picks. Tebow gets to win that one for all time, huh?

[Guest 2]

Was he fourth? Vince Young? We don't know. Right.

[Analyst 1]

Well Vince young just falls 55 says.

[Analyst 2]

Oh my God, oh my God.

[Co-host 2]

55 would have been like emphasizing God.

[Guest 2]

Where was Ed Reed? He had to be up there.

[Analyst 1]

You're not going to go to a whole lot of non quarterbacks on the list.

[Guest 2]

I bet it made it that kind of thing.

[Guest (Juju)]

Florida had both of them. Florida had Tim Tebow and Camden. So salute to the recruitment center over there in Florida.

[Analyst 1]

I wanted to get to a couple of other things that we didn't get to today. Mario Chalmers and Michael Beasley win the big three championship. That is an all time wonderful lineup to have two of your three players be Chalmers and Beasley.

[Co-host 1]

I know this is going to come off as a joke, but sincerely as Mario Chalmers, hall of Famer and Sincerely Ed Reed. 6 that's awesome. Mario Chalmers has won in high school, he won with a shot in college, he won in Europe, he won in the NBA and he hit the game winning shot in the big three. He should be in the hall of fame. No, no, no.

[Analyst 2]

Oh, man.

[Co-host 1]

Sha feels.