PTFO - We Fact-Checked Stephen A.'s LeBron and Kobe Story — and Polled 1,000+ Voters on His Presidential Campaign

Summary

Podcast Summary: PTFO - We Fact-Checked Stephen A.'s LeBron and Kobe Story — and Polled 1,000+ Voters on His Presidential Campaign

Host and Panelists:

• Pablo Torre
• Tim Miller
• Wyatt Cenac

Release Date: April 4, 2025

---

1. Introduction

In this episode of "The Dan Le Batard Show with Stugotz," host Pablo Torre, alongside co-hosts Tim Miller and Wyatt Cenac, delves into the contentious feud between sports commentator Stephen A. Smith and NBA superstar LeBron James. The episode centers on fact-checking Stephen A.'s claims regarding LeBron's attendance at Kobe Bryant's memorial service and explores the surprising results of a recent poll suggesting Stephen A. Smith’s viability as a presidential candidate.

---

2. Fact-Checking Stephen A.'s LeBron and Kobe Story

The discussion kicks off with Pablo Torre addressing Stephen A. Smith's public apology to LeBron James concerning claims about LeBron's absence at Kobe Bryant's memorial service.

• Stephen A. Smith's Claim:

  "I never really discussed why you were not at Kobe Bryant's memorial service."
  (01:21)

• Fact-Check Findings:

  • Multiple reputable sources, including the Washington Post, Los Angeles Times, and Entertainment Tonight, confirm LeBron James was present at the memorial.
  • LeBron James requested not to be filmed during the service, leading to misconceptions about his attendance.
  • High-level insiders from the Lakers organization, including owner Jeanie Buss, corroborate that LeBron was not visible during the event.

• Notable Quote:

  "There's no way he was there. If he was, he was Casper the Ghost." – Jeanie Buss, Lakers Owner
  (07:40)

Despite Stephen A.'s assertions, the investigation reveals that LeBron James was indeed present but chose to remain off-camera, a detail that Stephen A. later acknowledged as a misstatement.

---

3. Polling Over Stephen A.'s Presidential Campaign

Transitioning from sports controversies to political aspirations, the panel examines a recent Rasmussen poll surveying over 1,000 likely American voters about Stephen A. Smith's potential presidential run.

• Poll Highlights:

  • Voter Support:
    • Stephen A. Smith: 34%
    • Hillary Clinton (2016): 36%
    • Joe Biden (2024): 27%
  • Head-to-Head Matchups:
    • Kamala Harris vs. Stephen A. Smith (2028 Democratic Primary):
      • Kamala Harris: 45%
      • Stephen A. Smith: 24%
    • Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez vs. Stephen A. Smith:
      • AOC: 32%
      • Stephen A.: 28%

• Notable Quotes:

  "I'm spiritually with you, but I don't know. My shadow self is tingling." – Wyatt Cenac
  (18:06)

  "Stephen A. just wants attention." – Tim Miller
  (17:12)

The polling data suggests that while Stephen A. Smith garners significant attention, his viability as a serious presidential candidate is questionable, especially when compared to established political figures.

---

4. Analysis of Polling Data and Potential Viability

The panel scrutinizes the implications of the polling results, discussing Stephen A.'s strengths and weaknesses in a hypothetical presidential campaign.

• Strengths:

  • Name Recognition: High visibility from media presence.
  • Moderate Support: Solid backing among specific voter demographics.

• Weaknesses:

  • Political Experience: Lack of substantial political background.
  • Perceived Seriousness: Viewed by some as seeking attention rather than genuine political reform.

• Comparative Insights:

  • Stephen A. vs. J.D. Vance:

    "He is not the best metacharacter... Stephen A. Smith right now." – Wyatt Cenac
    (28:31)

  • Stephen A. as an Independent vs. Major Party Candidates:

    "He's not a spoiler; he's taking equally from both JD Vance and Kamala Harris."
    (35:34)

The analysis concludes that while Stephen A. has notable support, his lack of political infrastructure and perceived motivations may hinder a successful campaign.

---

5. Discussion on Democratic Party's Direction and Candidate Needs

Pablo Torre, Tim Miller, and Wyatt Cenac engage in a broader conversation about the Democratic Party's current challenges and the qualities needed in a candidate to lead effectively.

• Key Points:

  • Leaderless Persona: The party struggles with defining a clear and charismatic leader.
  • Candidate Attributes: Emphasis on effective communication skills, akin to past successful candidates like Obama, is highlighted as crucial.
  • Voter Demographics: The importance of appealing to a broad base, especially white voters, is discussed in the context of recent election trends.

• Notable Quote:

  "Maybe, we just need to accept that talking is a pretty key part of the job and that the Democrats should probably orient themselves to finding somebody who's really, really good at talking." – Wyatt Cenac
  (33:17)

The panel suggests that the Democratic Party might benefit from a candidate who excels in communication and can unite diverse voter groups, rather than relying solely on media personalities like Stephen A.

---

6. Conclusions and Takeaways

In wrapping up, the hosts reflect on the implications of their findings and discussions.

• Fact-Check Outcome:

  • LeBron James was indeed present at Kobe Bryant's memorial service but chose to remain off-camera, contrary to Stephen A.'s initial claims.

• Polling Insights:

  • Stephen A. Smith holds notable support but faces significant challenges in translating media presence into political viability.
  • The Democratic Party may need to seek candidates with stronger political credentials and genuine reform agendas to resonate with voters.

• Final Notable Quote:

  "What did we find out today, guys?" – Pablo Torre

  "Stephen A. Smith is a viable minor candidate for the Democratic nominee in 2028, but maybe not as viable as he thinks." – Wyatt Cenac
  (50:08)

The episode concludes with an acknowledgment of the complexities surrounding media figures in politics and the ongoing search for effective leadership within the Democratic Party.

---

Conclusion:

This episode provides an in-depth examination of Stephen A. Smith's interactions with LeBron James, the realities of his presence at Kobe Bryant's memorial, and a critical analysis of his potential as a presidential candidate based on recent polling data. Additionally, it offers valuable insights into the Democratic Party's current leadership challenges and the attributes needed for future candidates to successfully navigate the political landscape.

Transcript

[Pablo Torre]

Pablo. I'm Pablo Torre. And this episode of Pablo Torre Finds out is brought to you by Remy Martin. 1738 Accord Royale. Exceptionally smooth cognac for all your game day festivities. Please drink responsibly, because today we're going to find out what this sound is.

[Tim Miller]

If that name had been Pikachu, do you think it would have also gotten.

[Pablo Torre]

2% right after this ad?

[Wyatt Cenac]

You're listening to Giraffe Kings Network.

[Pablo Torre]

We have paperwork in front of us. Tim Miller w reuniting. Not an expert panel, but almost like an exploratory committee.

[Wyatt Cenac]

Yeah, an exploratory committee.

[Pablo Torre]

That's a term of art in politics, isn't it, Tim?

[Tim Miller]

Yeah.

[Wyatt Cenac]

Oh, yeah. I've been on a couple of those.

[Pablo Torre]

You have?

[Wyatt Cenac]

For Jeb and John Huntsman. More often than not, it's a candidate that is like, I want to see if the water's warm for me and Wyatt.

[Pablo Torre]

I do want to just estab the following question. Have you been following this feud between Stephen a. Smith and LeBron James?

[Tim Miller]

A little bit.

[Wyatt Cenac]

I have a Twitter level of knowledge about this.

[Tim Miller]

I have a Mastodon level knowledge. Is that more or less?

[Wyatt Cenac]

Less, I think.

[Pablo Torre]

Okay, well, we can just watch this.

[Stephen A. Smith]

I am pleading with LeBron James as a father, stop this. Stop this. We all know that Bronny James is in the NBA because of his dad. And I turn around, and he's right here in my face. He said, yo, you gotta stop talking about my son. You gotta stop with my son. That's my son. That's my son. And I was like, what? I thought it was weak. I thought it was some bullshit.

[LeBron James]

He's, like, on a Taylor Swift.

[Wyatt Cenac]

Yeah.

[LeBron James]

Tour run right now.

[Wyatt Cenac]

Oh, yeah, yeah. We're watching it. We're awesome.

[LeBron James]

He's gonna be smiling from ear to ear when he hears me talking about him. Oh, my God. He's gonna get home and grab some ice cream out of the freezer and sit in his chair and his tighty whities on the couch.

[Pablo Torre]

Which led to Stephen A. Smith going on first take and escalating all of this by saying this.

[Stephen A. Smith]

I suggest that he be happy with the things that I haven't brought up. I never brought up really? And never really discussed why you were not at Kobe Bryant's memorial service. I never really.

[Pablo Torre]

And so this is where I need to start today before we get into our packet of research, because the question that is embedded in what Stephen A's take was there was obviously explosive. It got aggregated. There's a community note over on X and the community note said, this quote, this is incorrect. LeBron was in attendance. According to the Washington Post, the Los Angeles Times, and Entertainment Tonight, they all list James is among the attendees at the memorial. LeBron James requested to not be film at the memorial. And Stephen A. Smith during the show apologized on air and also on Twitter, saying that he misspoke.

[Wyatt Cenac]

Can I just ask, what is even that theory? Like, why would this be a slight? Like, what are people upset about? Yeah, I guess that's the part I don't get that part. Why is this the thing that merits a cover up? What would be the failure of LeBron here that people would be upset about?

[Tim Miller]

And also, if he didn't go to this funeral, what's the big deal, right? Like, he's like, yeah, why? Like, why does he have to attend every basketball funeral?

[Pablo Torre]

This was kind of a state funeral in the world of politics. Have you ever been to a state funeral of any kind?

[Wyatt Cenac]

No. I mean, I've been to, I guess the viewing in the Rotunda, but I've never got to, like, go to the A list funeral. You know, maybe one of these days. But that is a big deal. I mean, Mark Leibovitz's book, like, starts at the McCain funeral and it's like all the who's sitting next to who. So there is a lot of, you know, political drama around these sorts of events.

[Pablo Torre]

Yeah. Have you ever been to an A list funeral, Wyatt?

[Tim Miller]

No, I just go to the after parties.

[Pablo Torre]

Yeah, this A list service. To be very clear, LeBron's attendance at the memorial service turned out to be a subject, according to a high level source that is close to the Lakers quote, a topic that people throughout the Lakers organization, top to bottom, have been grousing about for years. LeBron James to put us back in January of 2020. Right. So the tragedy happens. And LeBron James in public, he really did take the lead on being a spokesperson. He spoke up in a team meeting, reportedly saying, quote, God gave me wide shoulders for a reason. He got a tattoo of Kobe Bryant, the Mamba posted on Instagram. And then before the Lakers first home game, after the crash, he tossed his notes aside and gave a speech at center court.

[LeBron James]

Now I got something written down. You know, they asked me to kind of stay on course or whatever the case may be. But Laker Nation, man, I would be selling y'all short if I read off this. So I'm gonna go straight from the heart.

[Pablo Torre]

And then he even dunked like Kobe Bryant. And he equated the dunk to the Marlon Wayans classic the sixth man by saying quote, Kobe came down, put himself in my body and gave me that dunk on that break. And he even referenced the upcoming memorial himself. And so what I wanted to do is just take a fact based approach to this question, Tim and Wyatt. And so what we did here at Pablo Torre finds out was talk to eight sources who are directly familiar with this situation to get to the bottom of a Myst been hiding allegedly in plain sight.

[Wyatt Cenac]

I'm fascinated. It's there's waiting with baited breath to see what's the result.

[Tim Miller]

I just want to know why Byron Scott told you all this or Nick Van Axle.

[Pablo Torre]

So this memorial service, it was Lakers executives, the producers of the Grammy awards, it was Vanessa Bryant, Kobe's widow, Gigi's mother. All of these people in this planning group creating a live televised memorial at Staples center in the arena itself that was intended again to be both very personal but also incomparable in how a list and exclusive and produced the whole spectacle was going to be. It was February 24, 2020, which happens to have been the day my daughter was born. So Violet came into the world. I missed all of this.

[Wyatt Cenac]

And so you didn't have the memorial on in the office?

[Pablo Torre]

Second screen. Yeah, it was the view of my wife's birth canal and then Michael Jordan crying.

[Wyatt Cenac]

Yeah, that would have been good Instagram.

[Pablo Torre]

And I'm just investigating these claims to be very, very clear on a purely factual basis. Like I, I'm not here to talk about motives, but claim number one, there's a video of Diana Tausi who spoke at the Memorial Yukon basketball star, one of the great women's basketball players ever and she told a joke while complimenting 11 year old Gigi Bryant and her level of skill. And it sounded like this. I mean, who has a Turner fade away jumper at 11? LeBron barely got it today.

[Wyatt Cenac]

It's a roast.

[Pablo Torre]

Which is a pretty good joke. A pretty, a pretty bold joke from the goat. And she does, by the way, gesture off screen left. But what we did, of course was look at multiple angles of the broadcast of that very direction at various points in the broadcast. And no LeBron James. You see Pau Gasol.

[Wyatt Cenac]

James Worthy.

[Pablo Torre]

James Worthy. That's right.

[Tim Miller]

James Worthy.

[Wyatt Cenac]

Your source who's that is not Kuz.

[Pablo Torre]

Is wearing the big glasses, the big sunglasses.

[Tim Miller]

Is he also wearing those super long sleeves?

[Pablo Torre]

I like to think that his black tie was super long sleeves as well.

[Wyatt Cenac]

Like this is a common tactic, you know, a rhetorical, rhetorical tactic. You're gesturing at somebody I don't think there's anything to go with there.

[Pablo Torre]

No visible LeBron at all in the photography. And then what I did was confirm with multiple sources that Diana Taurasi never saw LeBron James at the memorial that day. So she, this person held up as the proof, did not see LeBron that day. So claim number two that LeBron James was there, but he chose to be left off camera. And what we did was we talked to a lead producer on the memorial, a longtime award show producer named Ron Basile. Ron Basile helped coordinate everything from Beyonce's 6:40am sound check to Michael Jordan's eulogy. And the producer told us when we asked him about any directive from LeBron James about having him on camera, quote, the off camera thing is, end quote. And so I want to be careful here. But he wasn't stage left, he wasn't off camera. And we can further tell you that according to two additional independent high level sources involved in the planning of this whole event who were in attendance, what they tell us here at Pablo Torre finds out is that they did not see LeBron in the building. They don't know of a single person who did see him in the building. And one of the people who did not see LeBron at all that day was in fact Lakers owner Jeannie Buss. So as one of the sources who spent that morning in the event's VIP areas says of LeBron, quote, There's no way he was there. If he was there, he was Casper the Ghost, end quote. My personal belief, by the way, is that I don't care how anyone chooses to grieve at all. Yeah, but LeBron James, the face of the Lakers who got the tattoo, gave the speech at center court, threw away his notes, was the face of mourning for this person. What LeBron did not do was what LeBron himself had chosen to do in the weeks before. LeBron did not take center stage at all. And multiple high level sources told us that LeBron was not invited to speak at Kobe's memorial. We had a third source involved in the planning of this. Go back to an early wish list of speakers and performers. This was shared between the Lakers, Vanessa Bryant, event producers, and as this third source puts it, quote, he's not on the list. Vanessa's on all these emails. It wasn't just the Lakers. It was a family thing. There was a lot of emotion. The word LeBron isn't even in here. We did reach out to LeBron's camp and they did not comment, which is totally fair. They also Wanted to make clear that they're not talking about anything that has to do with Stephen a. Smith. But LeBron's agent, Rich Paul, told Stephen A. Smith himself at the time that LeBron was, quote, in his own space. A very carefully worded answer for was LeBron at the memorial service. Then LeBron was asked for comment at Lakers practice by ESPN's David Menamon the day after the memorial. And LeBron's answer is conveniently on tape.

[Wyatt Cenac]

Did you attend the ceremony?

[LeBron James]

Like I said, man, it was just. I respect your question for sure. Very emotional, very emotional day. Very tough day for myself, my family, for everyone involved. One thing I can, one thing I can come out of saying, how, how strong and how bold, how powerful Vanessa is to stand up there the way she did, to give the speech, the way, the way she gave that speech, I commend her. My heart is with their family still with his three daughters that's still here, his wife, with his mom and dad, sister. It was just very difficult day, obviously, celebration, but it's a difficult day for all of us. I appreciate it.

[Pablo Torre]

So in that answer, you heard what.

[Wyatt Cenac]

That he wasn't there. The guy, the, the white guy in the corner with the cell phone that was taping it, he's. His face kind of reflected everything, which was kind of like, I, I don't, I don't think you're actually answering, like, why are you talking about this? Like, what is your non answer? So I, I don't know, but it seems like it would be a no to me.

[Tim Miller]

Yeah, that didn't.

[Wyatt Cenac]

Was there not a follow up question?

[Pablo Torre]

That's where it was left for roughly five years until I realized that this would be a thing that no one had actually followed up on satisfactorily. And by the way, what I want to make very clear is that I don't think that LeBron was obligated to do anything. There is stuff under the surface here that I can't fully definitively say.

[Wyatt Cenac]

Vanessa Bryant is the key source here, so I don't know who your sources are, but it is notable that in his answer he goes rightly into a very lavish compliment of her.

[Tim Miller]

He was like a person and it was a great celebration.

[Wyatt Cenac]

Kind of feels like that'd be the point person to untangle this. You know, Pavel, I don't know if you know this. When Trump won the first time and I went to a place of dark depression where I was like, I should quit politics through a friend I interviewed with the Lakers to be their flack is that.

[Pablo Torre]

Right.

[Wyatt Cenac]

And, yeah, and I had an interview with them and with Jeannie and them. It was very pleasant. It just wasn't really a fit for a variety of reasons. But, like, I'm, I'm hearing this whole story and, like, imagining that alternate life for me. I'm, like, trying to spin this on. I'm like, I'm like, who am I spinning for right now? Jeannie or Lebron or Kobe's legacy? And Pablo's like, you know, I'm happy to be on this side of the mic, I guess, and to not be a Lakers flack trying to navigate the Kremlinology of the Kobe funeral.

[Pablo Torre]

It is. It's genuine. It is Kremlinology. It is. What are people not saying but clearly feeling? What are the power dynamics and incentives at play? And why won't Tim Miller return my calls?

[Wyatt Cenac]

Why would you just answer this? Was he there?

[Pablo Torre]

All of which is to say that when I'm trying to get the answer to that question. We were also conducting a legitimate political poll about whether one of the people involved in this would be a legitimate candidate for president of the United States.

[Tim Miller]

Hey, I mean, I'm not looking forward to where this is going.

[Pablo Torre]

The finals for March Mania are here. And the only thing for sure is that it's the last time to bet on college basketball this season. So get in on all the action expected and unexpected with DraftKings sportsbook. With live betting, exclusive content, promos and parlays, DraftKings is the ultimate college basketball destination for March. And if it's your first time, got something special just for you. New DraftKings customers bet $5 to get $150 in bonus bets instantly. And there have been, yeah, so few Cinderella stories this year. I know. But one of them is bound to happen. And so why not use the bonus bets on the underdogs? You can bet the unexpected with DraftKings Sportsbook. Download the DraftKings Sportsbook app and use code Pablo. That is code Pablo. For new customers to get $150 in bonus bets when you bet just five bucks only on DraftKings, the crown is yours.

[Unknown]

Gambling problem, call 1-800-GAMBLER in New York. Call 877-8-HOPENY or text hopeny467-369 in Connecticut. For problem gambling, call 888-789-7777 or visit ccpg.org Please play responsibly on behalf of Boothill Casino and resort in Kansas, 21 and over. Age and eligibility varies by jurisdiction. Void. In Ontario, new customers only. Bonus bets expire 168 hours after issuance for additional terms and responsible gaming resources, see dkng.

[Pablo Torre]

These packets in front of us are the results of a truly exhaustive attempt relative to the just pure speculation that is surrounded whether Stephen A. Smith is actually going to do the thing that he's been talking about for months now and actually run for president.

[Tim Miller]

No.

[Stephen A. Smith]

And you know, I'm half joking, but I. I kind of mean it. I mean, I have no desire to be a congressional figure or a senator, but if you came to me and you told me I had a legitimate shot to win the Presidency of the United States of America, I would definitely consider it. But I. Here's the problem.

[Wyatt Cenac]

So you wanna break through the line.

[Stephen A. Smith]

Oh, that's right. I'm a moderate. I'm a centrist, and I'm the kind of person that. Do I believe that if I committed myself to knowing politics the way you and others know it, do I believe I could win a Democratic nomination? Hell yes. Particularly the state of affairs that exist. I think it would be a cakewalk. I think I'd take them all out. I really, really believe that. I really think I could take them.

[Pablo Torre]

Welcome to the exploratory committee. Wyatt Zenaki. Didn't know you were joining it. But that's also bull.

[Tim Miller]

Like, everything he's saying is bull. There's just like, he's like, oh, if I put the time in, I could totally run for president. He might as well say, like, if I put six months in, I could totally fight Mike Tyson. Like, there's like, all he's doing is just talking. There's nothing serious. He is the most unserious human being who just likes the attention. And that is what you are giving him with this. Congratulations, Pablo. You just fell into the trap. The egomaniac wants people to talk about him and you just did it. And you tricked me and Tim into taking part of this. And I want no part of it, Pablo. I don't want it because he doesn't want this. He just wants attention.

[Wyatt Cenac]

I'm kind of intrigued. On the other hand.

[Pablo Torre]

Damn it, Tim. Damn it.

[Tim Miller]

I thought you were with me.

[Wyatt Cenac]

I'm spiritually with you, but I don't know. My shadow self is tingling.

[Tim Miller]

Don't let the shadow emerge.

[Wyatt Cenac]

My shadow self is tingling.

[Pablo Torre]

I find it hard to disagree with wise fundamental points, but I also deeply value him as an important part of the exploratory committee.

[Wyatt Cenac]

Yeah, same.

[Pablo Torre]

Which is like the guy who's going.

[Tim Miller]

To actually a hostage in the exploratory committee.

[Pablo Torre]

The Hostage slash opposition opinionist who's going to establish that the research that we are presenting should be viewed with a healthy dose of what Wyatt, I believe, expressed as bull.

[Tim Miller]

Is there any way, like, running the red team.

[Wyatt Cenac]

We have a red team project. Like, you pretend like you're on the other side, and so we'll have you on the exploratory committee pretending like you're Hostel, but really you're just kind of testing out the ways for Stephen A. To. To, you know, defeat his haters.

[Tim Miller]

Sure. To help me do this, is there any way we could get, like, some rope to tie me to this chair so that to Anyone watching on YouTube they can see I wanted no part of this? I'm clearly a hostage in this conversation.

[Pablo Torre]

All we have are two bottles of Remy Martin and a hat.

[Wyatt Cenac]

So, yeah, I'll take some.

[Tim Miller]

This.

[Pablo Torre]

We might need to. We might need to dip into the reserves early. But the thing that kickstarted this whole enterprise truly, is that there was this single throwaway question in a McLaughlin poll in January that went viral immediately because it gave Stephen A. Smith, Wyatt's Anax favorite person, a 2% chance as a wild card against the field of 15 other potential candidates for the 2028 Democratic primary. And Stephen A. Goes on Hannity, and he says he had no business being on that list.

[Tim Miller]

He did not.

[Pablo Torre]

And so we wanted to actually fact check this. Like, okay, that's one throwaway line in a poll. What if we committed actual time to trying to do an exclusive? Pablo Torre finds out first of its kind, political poll.

[Tim Miller]

Before you go into this, though, can I just ask a question?

[Pablo Torre]

Yes.

[Tim Miller]

So there was a poll where they had 15 names, or was it 16.

[Pablo Torre]

15 other potential candidates.

[Tim Miller]

So they had all of these names and Stephen A. Smith's name is on there.

[Wyatt Cenac]

Yeah.

[Tim Miller]

And he gets 2%. If that name had been Pikachu, do you think it would have also gotten 2%? Like, it wasn't like, I don't. I just feel like the fact that you're putting the name on the list legitimizes the name in a way that at least a few people will be like, well, I'll check that box. Sure.

[Pablo Torre]

To Wyatt's point, polling as an instrument, flawed, limited. Right. There's an epistemological question of, like, chicken or egg? Is this real because you asked about it, or is this real because someone felt away about it when you asked them about it? So all of that is a very useful, both qualitative and quantitative context for the fact that we commissioned a legitimate survey with Rasmussen of 1021 likely American voters with dozens of questions connected over two days online and by phone. Basic demographics of the survey, 52 women, 33 Democratic, 35 Republican, 32% unaffiliated. And Rasmussen, Tim, you know, again, it's a public opinion firm. That is a thing. It's a real thing.

[Wyatt Cenac]

Rasmussen is a legitimate polling operation.

[Pablo Torre]

Can we dive into these cross tabs?

[Wyatt Cenac]

Let's do it.

[Pablo Torre]

Chart number one. We asked a survey of 1021 likely American voters. Who would you consider a stronger Democratic candidate for president? Hillary Clinton in 2016 got 36%. Stephen A. Smith in 2028 got 34%. Not sure. Coming in strong with 30%.

[Wyatt Cenac]

I would assume that most of the people that took the poll were familiar with the fact that Hillary Clinton lost in 2016. So they have that kind of base bias here when they're trying to answer this question. Well, you know, so even if Stephen A. Smith had a 2% chance of winning, you would think, well, that would be better than the 0% chance that Hillary ended up with. So I'm not fully. My brain isn't fully blown by this quite yet.

[Tim Miller]

Yeah. Who would you consider the stronger candidate? The person who, you know, lost in the past or the person who in the future. Who knows what could happen on that.

[Pablo Torre]

Note, chart number two, same question, except Joe Biden in 2024.

[Wyatt Cenac]

Yeah.

[Pablo Torre]

Coming in at 27%. Stephen A. Smith in 2028 coming in at 36%.

[Wyatt Cenac]

It's an article out this morning from where Joe Biden's first chief of staff, Ron Klain, is quoted where he gives some backstory and the debate prep for the debate that ruined America. And he gives some anecdotes about how Joe Biden left debate prep to go to the pool and fell asleep and how he couldn't remember things and how he was focused mostly on how he didn't think that, why people weren't happier that leaders of Germany and France thought that he was doing a good job, why that wasn't resonating more. So, I don't know. I mean, I'm kind of surprised that Joe Biden got 27% there. I guess I would say that's maybe not a great sign for Stephen A. Smith's potential campaign, that he's only coming in at nine points ahead of the.

[Pablo Torre]

Guy who went, who went to the pool before the debate.

[Tim Miller]

Again, I'm with Tim on this chart.

[Pablo Torre]

Number three, narrowing the poll now to 654 likely Democratic primary voters. Margin of error now up to 4%. If the 2028 Democratic primary were held today, who would you vote for? Kamala Harris coming in at 45%. Stephen A. Smith coming in at 24%. Other 17% wouldn't vote, 6% not sure, 9%. And so this is a head to head matchup between Kamala Harris.

[Wyatt Cenac]

Why would you answer that question? As a recipient of this poll? You got a phone call, somebody on the other line, Rasmussen, Wyatt, Smack. Who would you vote for in Kamal Harris or Stephen A. Smith? What would you have said?

[Tim Miller]

If it's just those two, I would have said Kamala Harris. But I feel like the other thing that feels mushy here is not sure is 9%. Other is 17%. Not sure and other are basically the same thing. So let's just call that 26%. So it's Kamala 45, other 26%, Stephen 24%. Because we don't know who other is. Other could be anybody. It could be Pikachu. So this again feels flawed to me. He's coming in third behind, oh, chart number four.

[Pablo Torre]

Another head to head in the primary. Alexandria Ocasio, Cortez, 32%. Stephen A. Smith, 28%. Other 18% wouldn't vote, 7% not sure, 15%.

[Tim Miller]

The other not sure collective, 33%. So let's just call it what it is. He's still coming in third.

[Wyatt Cenac]

A little discouraging for aoc, that's that.

[Pablo Torre]

This is where in the cross tabs I was like, okay, this is getting a little dark.

[Tim Miller]

But that also doesn't surprise me where I think AOC would be a good candidate. I feel like if you're talking about the people who are involved in this poll, I would imagine there are probably a number of more centrist Democrats who also view AOC in the same way that I feel like probably many centrist Republicans and then far right Republicans see her as being too left of their ideals and policies. And so I could see where she would come in at a lower number just, just solely based on their perception of her without her actually being able to go and lay out what her campaign would look like and what her goals would be.

[Pablo Torre]

But AOC just in the cross tabs of this, did have a net favorable rating from the people polled. So not simply people who are predisposed to not like the left, but moderates who actually did see value in her. Although in this case, 32 to 28 is right at the margin of error of 4%. Which again is where my brain was like, okay, well what about to Wyatt's point though, about a more, let's say, deliberately moderate positioned candidate like Gavin Newsom. Chart 5, head to head Gavin Newsom, 31% Stephen A. 28.

[Wyatt Cenac]

This is bad news for Gavin Newsom. I think if you're looking at this, I mean he's, him and Stephen are competitors across multiple vectors. Now they're both podcast hosts.

[Pablo Torre]

Yes.

[Wyatt Cenac]

They are both potential presidential candidates. And you would think that Gavin would have a little bit more space between him and Stephen A. You know, in this situation, governor of California has some experience, people are basically like either seem fine. So I don't know if that's good for Stephen A. Or it seems like it's not great for Gavin.

[Tim Miller]

I think still though, great for other. Not sure. He's yeah, coming in at 35%.

[Pablo Torre]

Chart number six though. This is, I think something like a bigger reveal. This is a head to head matchup for the White House. Okay, 2028 presidential election. In a legit political poll, the Rasmussen reports, Pablo Torre finds out survey more than a thousand likely American voters with a margin of error of 3%. If the 2028 presidential election were held today, who would you vote for? J.D. vance, 38%. Stephen A. Smith, 34%. And as a person who worked in politics, Tim, this result indicates what to you?

[Wyatt Cenac]

Well, it indicates that there's about a third of the country that would literally respond in favor of anybody over JD Vance, formerly JD Hamill, formerly JD Bowman.

[Pablo Torre]

Did a lot of separate names.

[Wyatt Cenac]

He's changed his name several times, which I think is a sign of sociopathy.

[Tim Miller]

Stephen A. Smith, was it check cashing?

[Pablo Torre]

Unlikely.

[Wyatt Cenac]

I don't think it was related to check cashing. Has Stephen A. Smith has multiple names or is his birth name Stephen A. Smith?

[Pablo Torre]

I believe he has been Stephen A. Smith for decades now.

[Wyatt Cenac]

I think this stands out a little bit less as encouraging for Stephen A. Smith and more as discouraging for Vance. I mean, Trump just got 49%. Right. So he's 11% below that.

[Tim Miller]

Right.

[Wyatt Cenac]

And I think that leads us to, you know, something that is pretty obvious, which is that, you know, he has less appeal than Donald Trump to certain, to certain groups of people.

[Tim Miller]

People aren't that excited by a potato face with a beard. Like if you just put a beard on a potato, that's J.D. vance.

[Pablo Torre]

But what if that potato also loved to post?

[Wyatt Cenac]

Really loved to post.

[Pablo Torre]

It's like arguing with people on X all the time.

[Wyatt Cenac]

Do you have any mixed feelings about J.D. vance over that? Because I gotta tell you, I really dislike him at a Deep level, like, in my core, I find him to be probably the most unappealing person in all of public life. But he's a poster. And as a poster, I do feel like I have some kinship with him that I'm grappling with.

[Pablo Torre]

It is disturbing to be on and constantly refreshing the platform that JD Vance in a somewhere out there sort of scenario is also scrolling and refreshing at the same exact time. Yeah, that's worrisome to me. But I think the point, the takeaway point is, what if it was Trump without any of the charisma? And also he wasn't funny. And also he wasn't even vaguely entertaining. I think truly, like, part of the appeal of Stephen A. Just to now get into why some might be at all energized, I think there is the part of it that is like, we are on a desert island, like in a cartoon, and you see something and you're like, that's a steak. And it's not a steak, it's a coconut. But you're so hungry that you're like, that looks like the greatest meal I've ever had. And there is just like that dysmorphia around who and what Stephen A. Is actually. And then there is the added desperation and hunger for someone to just get.

[Wyatt Cenac]

Into a debate, to own these guys.

[Pablo Torre]

And just go after them in the way that we impotently watched the guy who went to the pool passed out go to bed instead of getting in the ring.

[Wyatt Cenac]

Yeah.

[Pablo Torre]

And I think we just want a champion who will go into a televised debate and take some big swings.

[Wyatt Cenac]

I agree with this. And this was where I disagreed with your earlier statement. We kind of got distracted. But you said something like, you know, like, the only thing he can do is talk or that. Like that. There's. That getting ready for the presidency is just figuring out how to talk. And it's more than that. Are we sure? Maybe that's not true, actually. Maybe ability to post and talk and to own JD Vance to his potato beard face is really all we're looking for right now.

[Tim Miller]

But is that truly satisfying? I feel like. Would that truly be satisfying? Because I just think about. There were moments where, like, I remember during the Obama administration where Obama went to the House and do you remember this?

[Wyatt Cenac]

Yeah, sure.

[Tim Miller]

And he just kind of was like, I'll take all your questions. And it was this thing where, like, people just threw questions at him. And at that time, people were like, nobody's ever done this before. Like, he just went and he was like, there. And he was on top of it, and he got his points in. He got in some zingers, and it was like, all right, great. And he did that. And a week later, nobody cared. And it just felt like, oh, that get. That was oxygen for just a brief little moment. Is that what we want?

[Wyatt Cenac]

What we want versus what we deserve? I think is it. Are two different questions or what we. Commissioner Gordon might need, but, like, is it more than talking? I mean, obviously, the presidency is more than talking, but the better. The more appealing talker. Maybe not. The better talker has, like, basically won every time. Except for the COVID election recently. Obama was a very good talker.

[Tim Miller]

Sure.

[Wyatt Cenac]

The Democrats have put up the last three times. Kamala Harris, who had some skills talking, but also some demerits and deficits. She was not particularly strong, speaking off the cuff.

[Tim Miller]

But could she have gotten better?

[Wyatt Cenac]

Like, had she had more time? Yeah, maybe.

[Tim Miller]

Because I also feel like that's the one weird thing, that when we're looking at this, we're looking at it with an asterisk of. Okay, yeah. You ran a shortened campaign and still, like, it was close in the popular vote for sure.

[Wyatt Cenac]

Joe Biden couldn't talk at all and literally couldn't speak. So that wasn't great. Hillary not exactly a dynamic talker, really. We'll put it back to my people. Jeb. And I love Jeb, like, personally.

[Pablo Torre]

You put the exclamation point.

[Wyatt Cenac]

I did. I didn't, actually, but, you know, I emotionally put it in there. Howard Dean did it.

[Tim Miller]

Jeb.

[Wyatt Cenac]

But, like, he was a terrible talker. And. And, you know, I do think we convince ourselves because there's this thing that, like, we want to believe it's about more than that. You know, we want to think. We want to, you know, pull people's higher angels, think about people's better angels, and, like, think about all of the serious problems that the country faces. And we need a person of depth. And it's kind of like, I don't think the people really want a person of depth unless they're a good talker. Like, maybe we just need to accept that talking is a pretty key part of the job and that the Democrats should probably orient themselves to finding somebody who's really, really good at talking, and then all the other skills are kind of secondary.

[Tim Miller]

Yeah, I mean, I will. I will see that. That, yes, there is an element of it that feels like, as president, you are America's spokesmodel. Right. And.

[Wyatt Cenac]

And so with that in mind, America's next top spokesmodel.

[Tim Miller]

Yeah. You like you are, you are Vanna White, just turning the letters on democracy. And with that in mind, though, I think that's also there is that part of it that is both domestically and internationally. Could Stephen A. Smith actually, like, would he just be seen as a joke to everyone outside of the US when he has to go overseas and actually interact with foreign chancellors and other foreign presidents? Are they just going to be like.

[Wyatt Cenac]

We have a weekend Fox host running the military right now?

[Tim Miller]

Yeah. And I don't think anybody takes that guy seriously.

[Wyatt Cenac]

Yeah, I know, but it seems like Stephen A. Would be an upgrade. I don't know, but he's not the best meta Fredrickson of Denmark would be thrilled to see Stephen A. Smith right now.

[Pablo Torre]

I, I do just want to express as somebody who's worked with Stephen A. Smith and has been in sports for a very long time, it is insane how plausible all of this conversation is. It is very disturbing to me truly, that the people of our country, Wyatt, might want to just buy a vowel. And the vowel is a. Stephen a. Winning by 28% in this head to head matchup with J.D. vance among black voters, winning by 12% among moderates, losing by only 2% among independents. And I'll just speed through chart number seven, which is that if Stephen A. Were to run as an independent in a three way matchup, now we're looking at a bit of a problem for Mr. A. Smith. J.D. vance, Republican, 40. Kamala Harris, Democrat, 37. Stephen A. Smith, Independent, 11%. And the head pollster at Rasmussen, Mark Mitchell, tells us that, quote, he's not a spoiler is what we're learning from these numbers. He was taking equally from both JD Vance and Kamala Harris. Again, speaking to the more moderate, centrist style candidate.

[Wyatt Cenac]

I would look at this as really bad news for Kamala, actually, because you notice JD Vance number went up when we added Kamala to the picture. So people, when it was just JD Versus Stephen A. People were like, I'd like to learn a little bit more. But then when there are 2% of the people that are like, once Kamala is even a possibility, they're like, no, it JD Vanced Potato beard.

[Tim Miller]

So here's my question. I feel like his name comes up and these other names come up because there is this conversation of like, the Democratic Party is in turmoil. What is the direction of the party? But I'm curious, when has there ever been a clear direction of the party? Like, when has it ever been strong? Because I don't feel like it really has, like When I, when you look back in history, it's like, okay, even when Obama was running Obama, like, it wasn't like Obama was saying things that other candidates weren't saying. It's to your point, he was saying them better. Like at that time, he wasn't running on same sex marriage. Like same sex marriage happened much later. But prior to that, he was very much openly against same sex marriage just to woo voters. And whether he believed that in his real life or not, he was just very charmingly playing it down the middle as closely as possible. And to me, that raises a question of both parties seem to always be playing it as safely down the middle as they can until Trump to just kind of like win over some very specific demographic.

[Wyatt Cenac]

And I think you're unintentionally making the case for Stephen A. Smith right now. You're coming. You're coming. No, I'm not.

[Pablo Torre]

Are we writing all this down?

[Wyatt Cenac]

I think you're kind of unintentionally making the case for it because I agree, like the policy part of this is, you know, you can kind of co opt a bunch of things that are already out there. What people don't like about the Democratic Party right now is it feels leaderless and listless and, and it doesn't feel like there's a fight. It's not really like there are a couple of specific policies. Like people were pretty unhappy with crime rising during COVID but that's coming down anyway right now. Right. Like, there are a couple of policy things, but a lot of it is vibes. And if you look at the Democrats who've had the most success, they haven't come out of sports journalism, but in your history, Kennedy, Clinton, Obama, they all did, they all did kind of break the mold from before and they were very charismatic and this was, and all of those were kind of in a. Before Internet time. Right. So, you know, I think that the traits that were required then are even required, like on steroids now. Sure. And so I don't, again, like Stephen A. Smith. I don't know. We're about to get into the other kinds of names that they throw out there. But to me it's like, is there a way that the Democrats could, could put a front man up there that like, really doesn't change a whole lot, but makes people feel like a lot has changed? It's like, oh man, he's fresh, but she's new. They're fresh. They don't have the baggage of Hillary and Biden.

[Pablo Torre]

I mean, why, to your point, he's Stephen A. Is not actually even a Democrat. Like, he would be wearing sort of like the label.

[Wyatt Cenac]

Right.

[Pablo Torre]

Which would be a fundamental change in the product. Because discernibly, Stephen A. Is the guy who goes on like Hannity's show and talks. He's the guy who's friends with Bill O'Reilly. He's the guy on First Take arguing with LeBron James.

[Tim Miller]

Right.

[Pablo Torre]

He's not actually a Democrat in really any discernible political way, even if the Venn diagram might have them. Again, as the centrist with some overlap of both parties.

[Wyatt Cenac]

That's a weakness.

[Tim Miller]

Well, and I guess, I guess for me, the question is how much is this a Democratic candidate and how much is this focusing energy in different ways? Because again, thinking about like any of those moments in history where we have seen like great change within civil rights, whether that was in the 60s, whether that was same sex marriage, those things weren't coming internally from the White House. Those were external pressures from organizers from like state legislation, from judges, from things like that that were pushing those things forward. And then they eventually would get to a president's desk. But it wasn't a thing that like some president was leading the charge on these things. And so I just wonder on some level how much of this is, you know, that energy that we're looking for the party. Is it something that we're looking from a candidate or is it more. When you think about those moments in time, those movements were people outside of direct politics who were trying to push for change and were able to mobilize people not only in, you know, raising awareness, but mobilizing people to then get out and become a voting bloc that then those politicians had to actually respond to.

[Wyatt Cenac]

So I think here's the fundamental disconnect with the, with what you're arguing, okay, that you are looking for earnest, genuine change reform in the country. And what, what this exercise is, you idiot, is trying to figure out who can be a vessel for that change by flapping their jaws successfully enough to put J.D. vance, like back in that girl's bathroom where he hung out in high school with no friends. All right? Like, that's what the people are looking for, somebody to put J.D. in a corner. And then after that, once you found that person, then maybe the goody two shoes people like you and activists out there in the world could like, kind of provide them some sort of positive, you know, positive vision to execute upon.

[Tim Miller]

I just wonder if that's even when you're talking about somebody like Stephen A. Smith and you're and the metric now is comparing somebody to Trump. Like yeah, then it's, who's to say that like a Stephen A. Smith is going to then want to do those things?

[Pablo Torre]

I mean I just gotta remind us all that we're talking about Stephen Colin, Stephen A. Smith.

[Wyatt Cenac]

I don't know how did I end up on the Pro Stephen A. Smith. I don't know how this thing, call me sas.

[Pablo Torre]

It's, it's. I will end this segment by pointing out that according to the pollster who worked with us on these, on these cross tabs on this data, he looked at the top line numbers and said, quote, based on what I see in these numbers, he should run, end quote.

[Wyatt Cenac]

The one thing that is missing from the Stephen A. He is trying to do this like I'm a common sense independent guy and like he's not like doing that. I'm really going to take the fight to the bad guys. Like if Stephen A. Wanted to do this, like we need first take Stephen A. Owning J.D. the way he owns Skip, you know, like, and that's not what he's giving us.

[Pablo Torre]

No, he is actively trying to be the guy who is the reasonable person and is actually not political. Yeah, like he's sort of angling for that lane right down the middle is what I can tell.

[Wyatt Cenac]

Your boy Kang wrote about this.

[Pablo Torre]

Yeah, Jay Caspian. Kang was the person, by the way, that Wyatt should really be mad at.

[Tim Miller]

Yeah, I am mad at Jay, but I also know this is what Jay does. Jay just loves to drop cherry bombs in the toilet.

[Pablo Torre]

New Yorker.

[Wyatt Cenac]

Yes, I wrote down what he wrote because I thought it was really smart. He was like, he thinks the Democrats need a hostile takeover and new candidates who stand far outside the establishment's tepid choices. The policy positions of these candidates, I believe, do not matter as long as they're within reason. Which means that everything from full bore leftist economic populism to staunch performative centrism is on the table as long as they fight the Trump. Like that's his point. That is what the people are demanding out there. Somebody who is not tepid and limp and has been in Washington forever.

[Pablo Torre]

People are tired of being dunked on 50 times in a row and are like, can we get someone else to do that to them, please?

[Wyatt Cenac]

Yeah, so Jay's point's like, give me an AOC that'll take him down. Give me somebody that's in the middle that'll take him down. Like what we need is somebody that can actually compete against them and out meme them and own them. And that might say something really horrible about our society.

[Pablo Torre]

It does, to be clear.

[Wyatt Cenac]

Yeah, sure. But I do think that it is channeling a real feeling out there, particularly among Democratic voters.

[Pablo Torre]

No question.

[Wyatt Cenac]

It's like not very ideological at all. And so this is, I think, Stephen's biggest failure, which is like, if he's gonna do this, he's gotta be first. Take guy.

[Tim Miller]

Just looking at demographically how people voted, when you look at it by race, overwhelmingly non white people vote for Democratic ideas and Democratic policies. White people vote overwhelmingly for Republican ideas and Republican policies. And if you look at all the last elections, and I think it's like the last 30 years of elections, it breaks down where if the Republican candidate gets 55% of the white vote, they lose. If they get 56, they win. If the Democratic candidate gets 43% of the white vote, they win. 42, they lose. And that's how it's broken down in the last five elections. I believe McCain got 55%. Obama got 43%. Biden, when he won, got 43%. Trump got 55%. This last time, Trump got 56%. Kamala Harris got 42%. And to me, it feels like that is the thing to look at is like, what is it about that 1% that it seems like both parties just seem to be playing for that 1%. And when I, when I hear people talk about their sort of disappointment and disillusionment with the Democratic Party, it might be in part because it feels as though Democratic Party has just sort of assumed that every other race is going to overwhelmingly vote for Democratic ideas and Democratic policies, and they have just chosen to get into this battle for this 1%. Is it a thing where then you can bring in a Stephen A. Smith and it's like, okay, all of a sudden, yeah, now you're gonna have to like, can you both figure out what this 1% that these two parties have decided that they're gonna fight over? Are you the person who's going to be able to argue that and are you the person who's going to be able to instill confidence in all of the other voters that have. That are going to be okay with the fact that in this public thing you are not addressing their concerns while you continue to have this fight for this 1%?

[Wyatt Cenac]

I don't know what the first take demo is, but maybe.

[Pablo Torre]

Yeah.

[Tim Miller]

Yeah.

[Pablo Torre]

I, I mean, what I can tell you though is that if there is a bit of a compromise solution for the exploratory committee to consider, it would be okay. What if we get a real Democratic candidate, top of the ticket. And what if Stephen A. Smith did the thing that he is loathe to do in any sector of his life and be the vice president, be the secondary figure? And so we did ask our sample of over a thousand likely American voters who would be the best 2028 Democratic candidate for vice president. And the results were as Wyatt is already having his head in his hands. Mark Cuban, 14%.

[Tim Miller]

No.

[Pablo Torre]

Stephen A. Smith, 12%.

[Tim Miller]

No.

[Pablo Torre]

Dwayne Johnson, 12%.

[Tim Miller]

No.

[Pablo Torre]

Matthew McConaughey, 10%.

[Wyatt Cenac]

All right.

[Tim Miller]

No.

[Pablo Torre]

John Stewart, 9%. Oprah Winfrey, 7%. Pablo Torre, 1%.

[Tim Miller]

No.

[Pablo Torre]

Not sure. 35.

[Tim Miller]

Yes. Oh, God.

[Wyatt Cenac]

Mark Cuban. Yeah.

[Pablo Torre]

By the way, he did such a.

[Tim Miller]

Great job with the Mavericks.

[Pablo Torre]

We should say that when we reached.

[Wyatt Cenac]

Out, wasn't Nico wasn't one of the ideas.

[Pablo Torre]

Well, he did hire Nico Harrison. I do want to say also there.

[Tim Miller]

Was all that sexual harassment stuff.

[Pablo Torre]

Well, we did reach out to Mark Cuban for comment on the fact that he pulled at 14 and Stephen A. Smith pulled at 12%. And he wrote back in an email as this is want quote, I need to reconsider my life if I only beat STEPHEN A. By 2%.

[Tim Miller]

No, you don't, Mark Cuban. You don't stay the out of politics.

[Mark Cuban]

At the Home Depot. Spring Black Friday is here, and we've got 14 days of deals to transform your space. So what are you working on? How about a quick and stylish patio furniture update? And what's outdoor dining without a shiny new grill? Find a wide selection of grills under $300, like the next Grill 4 burner for only $229 at the home Depot. Then add a little ambiance with string lights. Shop 14 days of deals during Spring Black Friday now through April 16th at the home Depot.

[Pablo Torre]

At the end of every episode of Pablatore, finds out a show about finding stuff out and also torturing Wyatt's an act and making him question his friendship with me. What did we find out today, guys?

[Wyatt Cenac]

I found out that Stephen A. Smith is a viable minor candidate for the Democratic nominee in 2028, but maybe not as viable as he thinks. And I found out that LeBron James was right in his argument with Stephen A. Smith about whether he should be talking about his son because you shouldn't be talking about somebody's son. And I found out the LeBron James might not have been right about his presence at Kobe Bryant's funeral.

[Pablo Torre]

Yeah. Yeah, Wyatt, what did you find out today?

[Tim Miller]

I found out there's not enough Remy Martin to have done this podcast today. I'm taking both those bottles and whatever else you got, but that's still not going to be enough. I you're both delightful people.

[Pablo Torre]

What I really found out today is that Widen is the new campaign manager for Other Not sure other not sure.

[Tim Miller]

2028 put it on a T shirt.

[Pablo Torre]

Thank you both for doing this. Pablo Torre Finds out is produced by Walter Abaroma, Ryan Cortez, Sam Dawig, Juan Galindo, Patrick Kim, neely Loman, Rob McRae, Rachel Miller, Howard Carl Scott, Matt Sullivan, Claire Taylor, Chris Tominiello, and Juliet Warren. Our studio engineering by RG Systems. Our sound design by NGW Post. Our theme song, as always, is by John Bravo. We will talk to you next.