Transcript
A (0:07)
Welcome everybody. Hope you had a good weekend. A terrible weekend in Michigan for some. A Trump supporting Marine veteran opened fire in a Mormon church in Michigan. And there's the human tragedy of this. There's the reality that MAGA world is losing control of their left wing violence narrative that they've been pushing since the killing of Charlie Kirk. I'm going to talk about both aspects of this. We're going to talk about media coverage. There's so this, this is in the midst of a horrible tragic event of another damn shooting in the United States. There are a lot of stories, a story about violence, a story about media coverage. So we're going to get into it here. As I mentioned, this shooting did take place a Mormon church. At least four were killed as of this moment. At least eight were wounded as of this moment. The perpetrator is known to be 40 year old male, Thomas Sanford, I guess I should say white male. And this is one of these things where it's not that we say that for any particular reason of stigma or prejudice, but because these shootings are often analyzed through the lens of identity. And I guess it's sort of correct for me to say 40 year old white male Thomas Sanford, Marine veteran, rammed into the church's front door with his pickup truck before he started shooting and later set the building on fire. He was ultimately killed in a gunfight with two police officers within 10 minutes of the start of this tragic event. Now, we don't yet know the motive for this spit specific shooting. We are learning a lot about the shooter's right wing beliefs. There was a Trump Pence poster hanging on his fence just above a red stop sign. We're going to get back to the stop sign in a moment. Some say, oh, the stop sign meant he wants to stop Trump AKA he is anti Trump. Every bit of information we have at this point contradicts that and indicates this was a very clearly ardently procedure. Trump individual social media posts are filled with MAGA and typical right wing content. This includes Pro Turning Point USA and pro Charlie Kirk content. Stuff about stay away from the vaccine, stuff about Trump being a great golfer I guess is what it seems to be in the bottom right there. The shooter had been seen wearing a Trump 2020 campaign shirt in camouflage designed with the make liberals cry again line. That's from a picture posted to social media in 2019. We also know about two petitions signed by the shooter. One for the petition to repeal the pandemic powers of Democratic Governor Gretchen Whitmer and another one to to outlaw abortion In Michigan. Now we are going to hear all of the usual things that we hear when the shooter is right wing. This was not a gun issue. This was not a political issue. This was a lone nutjob crazy guy. We are going to hear because he attacked a church. This is anti Christian motivation. Interesting, by the way, that depending on whether it's convenient or not, evangelicals and Protestants and other Christians will or won't acknowledge that Mormons are Christian. This is a whole other thing where, listen, Mormons are followers of Jesus. As a non Christian, they're certainly Christian in the general sense. But much like with the Amish, when convenient versus not convenient, you will hear these are Christians versus these are not. Ok, we will get back to that as well. They are going to, I mean, listen, we'll probably hear, forget about the fact that he was wearing a Trump shirt, forget about the fact that he had a Trump sign. Forget about the fact that his social media was riddled with pro Trump stuff. His wife's ex boss's sister's cousin's hairdresser once said, trans people are human too. So therefore this is left wing violence. Right. We're not there yet, but I would not be surprised if we get to that. They're going to pull out their proverbial sharpies and make this what they need it to be and make this what they want it to be. Now there's another issue here that I think is important to talk about. We're going to get there. Trump is already reacting to this. Caroline Levitt is trying to do a cleanup on aisle five. We are seeing reports about political violence misrepresented and okay, there's another issue here that I think is important to mention. Aside from the fact that the shooter was obviously a pro Trump MAGA guy, former military becoming shooters, this is another, you know, we can categorize these in a lot of different ways. Are the political motivations left wing or right wing? Okay, well, they're primarily right wing. That's what the overarching data tells us. Aside from any, you know, Charlie Kirk was killed. This guy went to a church. Let's zoom out. Overwhelmingly, political violence in the United States is right wing. Fine. What about gender? Well, we can look at that too. We can say overwhelmingly. Are these shooters male or are they female? They're mostly male. Fine. Age? They are disproportionately under 30. This guy happened to be 40. Race. They are disproportionately white. Okay. The other important aspect to this that is not getting a lot of attention is former Military and becoming shooters. The violence project, which is this, they use a database of mass shootings dating back to 1966. They estimate that 26% of mass shooters had military experience. Now, I think I should have looked up percentage of population with military service to, to contextualize that. So 6% of the adult population are veterans, 26% of mass shooters are veterans. So that's an aspect to this that I think needs to be considered. And if you look at other sources, you see similar numbers sort of in the 25 to 30% range of mass shooters are individuals with background in the military. So that's another aspect to this that I think needs to be considered. The big stories are at the top, of course. More death, more violence, more tragedy, more carnage. Disgusting. Next, we continue to deal with the widespread availability of guns. Next, the political background of these shooters continues to lean significantly to the right. No one incident changes that. The Charlie Kirk killing, this incident, the dozens and dozens of incidents that that have happened since. Some politically motivated, some not. But we are going to have to deal with each of these aspects. And the first thing we're going to look at is how did Donald Trump react to the this news? Donald Trump was essentially silenced in his narrative about left wing violence by this pro Trump, pro maga, anti abortion, anti vax, anti COVID lockdowns to the extent that lockdowns took place, shooting up a Mormon church in Michigan. Now, even though Donald Trump was unable to make the case that this is a left winger because he was a Trump supporter, at the end of the day, Donald Trump still includes in his Truth social post a sort of little breadcrumb which he would be glad if it directed some people in the direction of this was a left wing shooter. Let me read for you the Truth social post that Donald Trump made. Quote, I have been briefed on the horrendous shooting that took place at the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints in Grand Blanc, Michigan. The FBI was immediately on scene and will be leading the federal investigation and providing full support to state and local officials. The suspect is dead, but there is still a lot to learn. This appears to be yet another. This is a key line. This appears to be yet another targeted attack on Christians in the United States. The Trump administration will keep the public posted as we always do. In the meantime, pray for the victims and their families. This epidemic of violence in our country must end immediately. Notice that there is no overt partizanship. Now there is some implied partizanship. Let's just compartmentalize that for A moment because it's critical importance. If we want to think critically about how they react, how do we react? We say whatever the political motivation, whatever the impetus or catalyst for a shooting, we are against it. We can sort out the motive. We can later make an assessment about is the predominant political violence in the United States from the left or from the right. When Charlie Kirk was killed, on the assumption it was probably someone who disagreed with Charlie Kirk, whatever their motivations, they are condemnable. We denounce it in instantly, within minutes of the shooting, I had a video up denouncing it. But the right functions a little bit differently. After Charlie Kirk was killed, Donald Trump was out there. Liberal scum this and left wing perpetrators that. And on TRIFA and all of this different stuff. But this time it's, we are going to keep everybody posted. We must pray for the victims and their families. The violence must stop. No partisanship. We've just got to stop the violence. But. But Donald Trump does include. This is a targeted attack on Christians in the United States of America. There's a few interesting layers to that. Number one, the entire Christian persecution complex in the United States with the right wing is pathetic stuff. Pathetic stuff. And in fact, if you look instances where individuals are targeted based on religion, you know what the most prevalent one is? It's Judaism. When you look at religiously oriented violence where people are targeted based on their religion, in the United States, overwhelmingly it is Jews that are being targeted. Now, sometimes they don't get Jews, right? And so this is one of the sick things. Think back to Glenn Miller, that guy I interviewed who went up and tried to kill Jews in, I believe it was Kansas. And this, it's so weird to use these phrases. He accidentally killed Christians. He was targeting Jews. Okay. But there's another aspect to this, which is they are trying to make you believe anyone who attacks a church must be a left winger. And so although Trump knows he can't go out there and go liberal scum like he did last time, you can't do it because the evidence isn't there. This was a Trump supporter. Trump signed Trump shirt. Trump posts all of it. He goes, oh, the Christian persecution. One other thing I want to mention, since when are Mormons considered Christian for the average Protestant? And this is another story. You know, I've mentioned before when I spent some time in rural, some people say rural, I don't really like that. When I went to rural Indiana and I hung out with some evangelical Christians, there's a lot of Amish in this part of Indiana. You know, you pass neighborhoods that you can see, notably, there's no power lines, they don't have electricity. You pass the buggies on the roads and, you know, you, you, you see the Amish shops where you can buy jams, jellies, and marmalades of different kinds. And so I asked one of these evangelical Christians playing stupid, right? I'm just a dumb Jew asking questions, right? Hey, are Amish or Christian, right? And they go, well, not. This was the evangelicals. Not, not really, no. We really kind of see them as a cult. The analogy to Mormons is depending on whether it's convenient. If you go to your average Protestant, if you go to your average evangelical, they might say Mormons are Christian in the sense that at the end of the day they follow Jesus, right? But you will, when it's not convenient, they will go, no, we kind of see them, you know, they, the Joseph Smith stuff, it's really their own thing here because they want to play up the Christian persecution complex. Of course, this was targeted at Christians, even though many Christians do not consider Mormons to be Christian in a serious manner. So Trump can't do the liberal scum thing because he knows they're not, but he's still doing what he can. All right, let's now zoom out and talk about political violence. When your followers don't have any idea what's going on, it is easy to lie to them. Donald Trump is panicking because no matter how many times he says it, we have the data, we have the receipts. Most political violence in the United States for decades has been right wing. I don't care what the political orientation or catalyst is for violence. I'm against it. If you commit, commit an act of violence, you are wrong. I want you persecuted, prosecuted, rather prosecuted to the fullest extent of the law and punished in accordance with what due process would indicate. But we have to acknowledge where the lion's share of the violence is coming from. The new one that they are going with is in 2025. There has been more left wing political violence than, than ever. Now, this is painfully stupid if you examine the facts, which we're going to do. But Donald Trump is probably assuming that his followers aren't smart enough to fact check, aren't astute enough to know the difference. And I hate to admit it, but Donald Trump may be right. Axios is actually helping Donald Trump to pull this off. Let's explore Axios. Put out an article called Study Left Wing terrorism climbs to 30 year high. And at the top of the article, there is a chart which has left and right wing domestic terrorism by year. The yellow bars are left wing, the gray bars are right wing. Okay? An arrow points to 2025, and there's a larger yellow bar than a gray bar, meaning more left wing terror, domestic terror, political violence in 2025 than right wing. Now let's be serious here. I want to be serious for a moment. Let's actually think through this like adults. Okay? Superficially, you can visually see there were larger yellow bars for left wing terror for sure in 2020 and 2022 than in 2025. So we already should be saying, wait a second, record left wing terror. There was more in 2020. There was more in 2022. Still a minority, still mostly right wings. But it's true that only partway through the year, we have some more left wing terror this year than in some years. But the second question is, where is the data from? Well, the data is from csis. That's a good source. We often cite the CSIS data on domestic terror. If you go to the underlying report from csis, you find a different chart and you see that under left wing terror attack and plots, and as a percentage of all attacks and plots, you do see a spike. But this measures something completely different. What this is measuring is the percentage of attacks this year that are from the left. And by the way, the data only goes through July 4th. Fourth, that was three months ago. We had this terrible right wing attack over the weekend at the Mormon church in Michigan. Now, why do we care about seven months in 2025 when the real story of this study is that like every other study, it confirms, if we put up the original chart again, most domestic terror in the United States is right wing. In every single year, the right wing domestic terror blows out of the water. The left wing domestic terrorist. Now, there's another problem with this editorialization of the report that MAGA is doing, which is that CSIS is careful to note left wing violence, even when it happens on average, is less lethal, it's less organized, it's smaller in scale, and it kills fewer people. It's less deadly, sadly. Is the average MAGA going to see the headline from Axios and do this sort of analysis? I think not. But it does tell us a lot about how desperate they are that they uncritically push this article when the underlying report says the opposite. If you appreciate this type of analysis, please make sure to like this video on YouTube, make sure to share this video on YouTube and make sure that you're subscribed to the YouTube channel YouTube.com/the David Pakman Show. I don't have a cat myself, but many friends and family do and lately they have all been talking about Smalls. So when Smalls came on as a sponsor I wanted to learn more. Smalls is a fresh take on cat food because their recipes are protein packed, made with ingredients you would actually recognize from your own fridge. No preservatives, nothing artificial. Real food made for cats. That's why cats.com and Forbes both named it Best Overall cat food. Friend of mine recently mentioned their cat seems excited when the Smalls boxes show up. They tried putting it side by side with the old food. The cat went straight for Smalls, which is a pretty good sign For a limited time. My audience gets 60% off your first smalls order plus free shipping. Just go to smalls.com and and use the code PACMAN. The link is in the description. A pending Supreme Court case could strip our fourth Amendment rights and allow immigration agents to come into our homes for any reason. No probable cause needed. All while Republicans try to twist things so that you think this is all great for America. This should be the biggest story in the US right now, but but it's almost impossible to keep up with the millions of moves that Trump is making every single day. That's why Ground News exists. Ground News is an app and website that exposes the blind spots and spin before it takes control of our opinions. Ground News is the smarter, more reliable way to stay informed when MAGA is banking on us getting distracted. I'm partnering up with Ground News to give you 40% off the same vantage plan that I use so you'll pay only five bucks a month for all of their premium features. Just go to Ground News slash Pacman or use the code Pacman in the app when you sign up. The link is in the description or scan the QR code. The David Pakman show is an independent audience supported program. Tomorrow, the last day of September we are doing a one day membership drive. The goal here is more new members on a single day than we've ever had before. I need your help building this is not just about numbers. This is about building a media ecosystem that is better than what corporate media is getting us and obviously more important than what the right wing ecosystem is providing. It will be three years, three months and three weeks left of Trump's presidency. Tomorrow we that'll be the theme of our one day membership drive and I hope that you will participate in it. All you need to do to be notified tomorrow how to sign up at this huge membership discount price is get on my free newsletter substack.david pakman.com it costs nothing and tomorrow you'll be notified of how to take advantage of this great membership special. And if you can't wait. If you want to get today's bonus show, it's easy. Just sign up now at Join Pacman Caroline Levitt is Donald Trump's White House Press Secretary. She is willing to lie to no end. She is willing to say anything she needs to say in order to defend MAGA and defend Trump and defend the right wing. And this morning Caroline Levitt appeared on Fox News and she was asked about the Michigan shooting. The Michigan shooting in which a Trump T shirt wearing Trump lawn sign having anti vax, anti abortion Trump supporter shot up a Mormon church. All political violence is unacceptable. Of course it just so happens this was a right winger and Caroline Levitt is going with the it was an attack on Christians line that Donald Trump floated on his Truth social. Important to remember that they only consider Mormons Christian when convenient. This is absolutely one of those times.
