The David Pakman Show

Episode: Trump throws away his presidency and MAGAs cheer
Date: December 18, 2025
Host: David Pakman

Episode Overview

In this incisive episode, David Pakman breaks down the chaos of Donald Trump's latest actions and rhetoric, focusing on Trump’s public suggestion of war for oil in Venezuela, fact-challenged economic claims, the unraveling of his administration with key figures leaving, and the right-wing media’s response. Pakman exposes the contradictions and fantasy economics fueling Trump’s presidency while dissecting Trump’s shambolic national address and the sycophantic praise from his media allies. The episode is a thorough, sharp, and sometimes biting tour through recent events, illuminating both substance and spectacle at the heart of Trump world.

Key Discussion Points & Insights

1. Trump’s Call for War over Venezuela’s Oil

Timestamps: 00:44 – 09:08

• Bold statement: Trump openly claims the US "might do a war for oil" in Venezuela, breaking political norms by stating economic motivations without couching them in democracy or human rights justifications.
  • Memorable quote (Trump): “Getting land, oil rights. Whatever we had, they took it away... We want it back. They took our oil rights ... There’s a lot of oil there, as you know. They threw our companies out, and we want it back.” [03:52]
• Pakman’s analysis: This is a jarring contradiction to Trump’s prior "anti-war" branding and his criticism of George W. Bush’s Iraq invasion.
• Speculation on motivation: Pakman questions whether oil is the real motive or if it's about regime change, noting U.S. history of failed interventions in Latin America.
  • Pakman: “As an Argentinian, I know ... the history of the United States getting involved in Latin American regime change to know it's a terrible idea, it doesn't work out well.” [06:41]
• Relevance today: Given record U.S. oil production, Pakman questions the logic of needing Venezuelan oil—highlighting contradictions in Trump’s justifications.

2. Trump’s Economic Fantasy: The $18 Trillion Tariffs Claim

Timestamps: 09:17 – 18:00

• Trump’s claim: Repeatedly asserts his tariffs have generated $18 trillion—an amount Pakman calls “mathematically impossible.”
• Pakman’s fact-check: The actual tariff revenue is laughably less ($236 billion annually; would take centuries to reach $18 trillion).
  • Pakman: “To raise $18 trillion in a single year through tariffs, imports would all need to be taxed around 600%. If you did that, it would be economic disaster. Imports would collapse.” [13:42]
• Loyalty test theory: Pakman suggests these absurd claims function as loyalty tests in a cult-like regime—if you repeat the lie, you signal allegiance.
• Deeper concern: The administration and much of the media ecosystem parrot these unchallenged numbers to the base.

3. Trump’s Disastrous National Address

Timestamps: 18:00 – 28:40

• Purpose of address: Trump addresses the nation at 9pm, expected to mark a pivotal policy moment but instead delivers a rambling, grievance-filled tirade.
• Unfounded economic claims: Trump blames Biden for inflation, makes further wild statements about prices, and promises “military bonuses” supposedly funded by tariff revenue.
• Pakman’s reaction: Describes the speech as “an unforced error of brutal proportions,” questioning Trump’s emotional composure and cognitive state.
  • Pakman: “Sometimes I watch a Trump speech and I wonder, is Trump suffering from dementia? ... Is Trump on drugs? ... Is Trump kind of dumb? This speech doesn't clear up any of these questions...” [18:48]

4. Extreme Xenophobia and Economic Lies

Timestamps: 20:16 – 32:57

• Xenophobic rhetoric: Trump levels a “Nazi style” rant blaming migrants for economic ills, echoing classic dehumanizing language.
  • Trump: "This is the worst thing that, frankly, in my opinion, the worst thing that the Biden administration did ... the invasion at the border..." [20:16]
• Debunking major lies:
  • Claims of “cutting drug prices by 600%,” which Pakman clarifies is “not mathematically possible.”
  • Promise of “no tax on Social Security”—not actually in any current legislation.
  • $18 trillion in foreign investment claims—misconstrued from soft, non-binding “commitments” at best, not real funds delivered.

5. The Chaos in the Trump Administration: Bongino’s Exit and Fox Propaganda

Timestamps: 34:15 – 45:05

• Bongino resigns as FBI Deputy Director: Resignation described as a sign of unraveling; Pakman ridicules the revolving door and “incompetence” of Trump’s handpicked team.
  • Pakman: "A low rent conspiracy podcaster like Dan Bongino is not likely to work out as your deputy FBI director." [36:01]
• Culture of hypocrisy: Criticizes MAGA culture for abandoning principles when inconvenient, comparing it to cult and authoritarian patterns.
• Fox News’ contradictions: Kayleigh McEnany and others push selective data to paint Trump as hugely popular—even when contradicted by other Fox hosts and broader polling data.
  • Kayleigh McEnany: "President Trump, far more popular than President Obama at this point in his presidency." [44:15]

6. The White House Ballroom Boondoggle

Timestamps: 49:41 – 57:30

• Cost explosion: Trump’s White House ballroom plan doubles in cost to $400M while he demolishes parts of the historic East Wing, skips preservation reviews, and fires the architect warning of infeasibility.
• Fundraising and transparency concerns: Pakman raises red flags over secretive high-dollar fundraising for a sitting president’s pet project on public land.
• Legal and historic jeopardy: Demolition rush possibly preemptive to court injunctions.
  • Pakman: “He bulldozes the White House and norms. He ignores experts, which he does in every aspect of his presidency. And he basically dares anybody to stop him.” [52:53]

7. Right-Wing Cheerleading for Trump’s Meltdown

Timestamps: 57:30 – 61:53

• Media sycophancy: Sean Hannity, Deborah Lee, and Newt Gingrich lavish praise on Trump’s “discipline” and “power,” ignoring the obvious disarray and incoherence.
  • Hannity: “I don’t think Joe Biden would be capable of that speech.” [57:46]
  • Deborah Lee: “Donald Trump was so kind. He was so calm ... one of the most powerful and just engaging speeches he’s given in a very long time.” [58:51]
  • Gingrich: “...a 19 minute disciplined speech that covered that many facts was worthy of Ronald Reagan ... it set the table for the entire debate over the next year.” [61:01]
• Pakman’s response: Notes the absurdity and, with dark humor, points out that comparing Trump to Reagan is ironic, given Reagan’s own cognitive decline during office.

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

• Pakman on loyalty tests (Trump's absurd economic claims):
  "These are common in cults and authoritarian regimes. Everyone is expected to nod along to something they know isn't true. ... Leader says something absurd, you show loyalty by repeating it uncritically." [14:50]

• Pakman on Trump’s Venezuela war posturing:
  "The anti war president and winner of the inaugural FIFA Peace Prize is going to start a new war, especially for oil." [07:34]

• Pakman on MAGA contradictions:
  "The philosophy and the principles matter only when they are politically convenient ... endless black hole philosophical debates with people who ... abandon [their principles] like a bad habit as soon as they're inconvenient." [41:09]

• Pakman on Trump’s national address:
  "Whatever Donald Trump was hoping to accomplish with this national address, he failed to do it. Unless he was trying to make the country think that he's unhinged and clueless, in which case I would rate it an A. Plus plus plus plus plus." [18:24]

• Pakman on the White House ballroom project:
  "Trump demolishes, skips required reviews, costs double, architect fired, active lawsuit. All about branding and cronyism. He ignores experts and dares anyone to stop him." [52:53]

Segment Timestamps for Quick Reference

• War for oil in Venezuela: 00:44 – 09:08
• Tariffs and “$18 trillion” fantasy: 09:17 – 18:00
• Trump’s national address breakdown: 18:00 – 28:40
• Debunking economic and xenophobic claims: 20:16 – 32:57
• Bongino/FBI, MAGA culture, Fox News summation: 34:15 – 49:05
• White House Ballroom scandal: 49:41 – 57:30
• Right-wing media commentary round-up: 57:30 – 61:53

Conclusion & Takeaway

David Pakman’s episode delivers a scorching analysis of Trump’s action-packed but disastrous week: from the surreal calls for war and made-up economic boasting to administrative breakdown and echo-chambered media applause. Pakman demonstrates, through layered debunking and contextual political insight, how the Trump presidency continues to be marked less by policy and more by spectacle, fantasy, and a relentless test of partisan loyalty. This is essential listening for anyone weary of fact-free politics and skeptical of the media fog surrounding the Trump White House.

For more episodes and to support the show, visit: David Pakman Show Gear Store
Subscribe: substack.davidpakman.com