
Being a 13-year-old kid can be tough, to say the least. But it seemed as if Jonathan Garcia-Valladares had it figured out. He was an overachieving student. He was a chess player. And on a crisp fall day in 2010, Jonathan was trying to get in shape for the football team, a sport he’d just joined. But on that day, his short life would come to an end. In the 15 years since, law enforcement is still trying to uncover why, and, most importantly… who would do this to an innocent young kid who had his entire life ahead of him.
Loading summary
Ashley Flowers
If you're like me, you're always looking for the next true crime case to dive into, and you've pretty much listened to it all. But what if I told you there is even more waiting for you in the Crime Junkie Fan Club? The Crime Junkie Fan Club features exclusive content you won't hear anywhere else, and early ad free episodes of the one true crime podcast, Crime Junkie. So if you're ready to dive deeper into even more mysteries, join the Crime Junkie Fan club today. Visit crimejunkiepodcast.comfanclub to learn more and join. That's crimejunkiepodcast.com fanclub. What if you could turn your curiosity for true crime into a degree at Southern New Hampshire University? You can. Southern New Hampshire University offers over 200 degrees you can earn completely online, including subjects like forensic psychology, criminology and crime analysis. And with low online tuition, Southern New Hampshire University makes earning your degree affordable, flexible, and achievable. Find your degree at Snhu. Edu Dec. That's Snhu. Edu Dec. This is a true story. It happened right here in my town. One night 17 kids woke up, got out of bed, walked into the dark and they never came back.
Dominic Rostenberg
From the director of Barbarian A lot.
Ashley Flowers
Of people die in a lot of weird ways. You're not gonna find it in the news because the police covered everything.
Dominic Rostenberg
Lola Onokus Dave.
Ashley Flowers
This is where the story really starts.
Dominic Rostenberg
Weapons Rated R Under 17 not admitted.
Ashley Flowers
Without parent Life is full of plot twists, but like any good mystery, having the right people to help makes a difference. Think of a State Farm agent like your sidekick, there to help you in your search for coverage. And with so many options, it's nice knowing you have help finding what fits for you. Go online@statefarm.com or use the award winning app to get help from one of their local agents. Like a good neighbor, State Farm is there. Our card this week is Jonathan Garcia Valladares, the seven of diamonds from Arizona. Being a 13 year old is hard for most people, but for Jonathan, it seemed like he was close to nailing it. He was about to finish eighth grade and had his sights set on a special charter high school that focused on the sciences. He wanted to be a surgeon when he grew up and it wouldn't have been a stretch. Jonathan was an excellent student, top of his class. He was the kind of kid who wanted to do his very best at everything, including the school football team that he had just joined. Although somehow one of the very first runs he took to get in shape for that football team was the exact thing that cut his dreams short. I'm Ashley Flowers, and this is the deck.
Tim Stevens
Phoenix 91 1, where what happened? Someone that was shot in front of.
Ashley Flowers
My house is laying in the street, not moving.
Tim Stevens
Did you see who shot him? Yeah. No, no, it's 26th Street.
Ashley Flowers
Hurry. Those are the sounds that startled Tim Stevens awake in the early hours on November 7, 2010. His immediate reaction, Firecrackers. But no, he thought, who sets off firecrackers in November? And then it hit him. Someone could be in serious danger. And here's the thing. Tim was a Navy search and rescue veteran. He had been trained to respond in times of trouble.
Jason Bourne
I mean, I think that's sort of my. Even still, if there's an accident, I usually instinctively, I move towards the accident instead of away from it, you know, or whatever, to see if I can help. First few minutes of being awake, I've got my dog in my arm. I'm probably in my bare feet or flip flops at the very most.
Ashley Flowers
Even if Tim had been trained for this sort of emergency, it was the last thing he expected to happen on that crisp fall morning in Phoenix. Tim, who worked as a systems engineer for IBM, had moved to the Camelback East Village neighborhood only a few days ago. He had a bunch of work done on the place and finally got to spend his first weekend in the newly remodeled home. He was looking forward to sleeping in. The weather was perfect, so Tim and his wife had all of the windows flung open, enjoying the breeze when he heard the noises and grabbed his small dog that he took everywhere. And then he rushed out of the house.
Jason Bourne
I come around the corner, there's some commotion going on that I can't quite remember exactly, but there were some people on the porch that I remember. And then to see that child sitting there lifeless, sitting in a pool of blood.
Ashley Flowers
The scene was shocking and also strange. Tim remembered that something felt off. And then it clicked. Where were the cops?
Jason Bourne
I just. I went towards the boy to check him out. I just thought he might still be alive. And I checked his vitals, and he had no pulse whatsoever. And by then, there was a cop down the street. He was at the very end of the street. And I stood up and I'm like, here's where the problem is.
Ashley Flowers
The officer frantically waved Tim towards him, away from what was clearly becoming a crime scene and towards the officer's car.
Jason Bourne
And he didn't say anything. He just said, we need you out of this area.
Ashley Flowers
Tim got in the police car, but he was still confused. Why was everyone hanging back?
Jason Bourne
It just was odd to me that they didn't sort of rush in.
Ashley Flowers
I guess there's a reason the cops weren't rushing to the victim. By this time, several Neighbors had called 911 reporting the same thing. Gunshots. More specifically, multiple gunshots. The police responded quickly, and they had absolutely no idea what they were walking into. But two words came to mind. Active shooter. Police moved toward the victim cautiously, each behind their own shield. That protects against gunfire. Detective Dominic Rostenberg explained what was found at the scene.
Dominic Rostenberg
As I approach, I could see that it's a younger Hispanic male. He didn't have any identification on him. He was dressed in athletic attire, running shoes, red running shorts, a hoodie. He was unresponsive. He was bleeding profusely from the head. It was later learned that he was shot four times. Two in the left cheek and two at the earth.
Ashley Flowers
Police eventually realized that there was no active shooter in the area, but instead just a teenager who had been shot in the head four times without even knowing who this boy was. Yet he was pronounced dead at the scene. And in short order, police rushed to cordon off the immediate area so that they could begin an investigation.
Dominic Rostenberg
So the police contacting witness, certainly making sure the shooter or if shooters are still in the area. So we're still using caution. Once we realize that the scene is safe, then we start preserving the scene, which is hanging crime scene tape, contacting witnesses, separating them so they don't contaminate their testimonies, kind of holding the area, preserving evidence.
Ashley Flowers
A report shows that police spoke to about 10 witnesses who heard the gunshots from their homes and a few who even reported seeing the victim. One witness called in saying that he saw a man walking from the crime scene. The guy didn't appear to be in a hurry, and the witness tried to follow the man but lost him. And police never knew if it was someone involved or another potential witness who might have information. And then there was this account. One witness said that he'd been woken up by his wife who heard the gunshots. And the couple reported hearing two people. One that sounded like a woman's voice saying, get in the car, followed by what was described as a man's voice that said, get in the effing car. They reported hearing the car peel away at a high speed. But they nor any of the other witnesses police would end up speaking to actually saw those two people, and that was it. No one else heard or saw anything useful.
Dominic Rostenberg
We have a young victim. He shot several times in the head. We have limited forensic evidence. We have no video, we had no cell phone data. The investigators immediately recognized that this is a tough case.
Ashley Flowers
By the time the sun was high in the desert sky, Phoenix Police Department at least had one lead. A call had come in that ID'd their victim.
Anna Sega Nicolasi
If your dog could talk, they'd beg for Ollie. The full body tail wag, the excited little hops, the big goofy grin. That's the Ollie effect. Ollie delivers clean, fresh nutrition in five drool worthy flavors even for the pickiest eaters. Made in US Kitchens with the highest quality human grade ingredients. No fillers, no preservatives, just real food. Just fill out Ollie's 30 second quiz and they'll create a customized meal plan based on your pup's weight, activity level and other health info. Healthier food means a happier pup, more energy, shinier coats, better poops, and more excitement at mealtime. Dogs deserve the best and that means fresh, healthy food. Head to ollie.com deck tell them all about your dog and use Code deck to get 60% off your welcome kit when you subscribe today. Plus, they offer a happiness guarantee on the first box so if you're not completely satisfied, you'll get your money back. That's O L L I e.com deck and enter code deck to get 60% off your first box.
Ashley Flowers
Summer is in full swing. Whether you're traveling, taking the kids to summer camp or heading to the pool, we' looking for ways to stay healthy and save money this summer. With Goodrx you can save up to 80% on prescriptions for you and your family pets too. Check GoodRx before every trip to the pharmacy for big savings on both brand and generic medications. GoodRx is free and easy to use. Just search for your prescription on the website or app, compare prices and get a free coupon to show your pharmacist. You can use GoodRx to save at over 70,000 local pharmacies nationwide. And now you can enroll in GoodRx rewards and earn points every time you use a coupon at the pharmacy. Remember, GoodRx is not insurance, but works whether you have insurance or not and could even beat your insurance copay. Price Save at the pharmacy this summer with goodrx go to goodrx.com deck that's goodrx.com deck A woman named Ruth, who lived about a fourth of a mile from where the shooting happened, called police that morning to report her 13 year old son missing. She said that he had gone out for a jog that Morning in the Camelback East Village neighborhood. But he'd never come home and they couldn't find him. When they went looking for him along his jogging route. She began to describe her son. His dark curly hair, dark eyes. She said that he would have been wearing glasses, red gym shorts, a white T shirt topped with a navy blue zip up hoodie. And that's when they started to piece it all together.
Dominic Rostenberg
Detectives responded out to her house and spoke to her and they were able to determine based on the physical description and the clothing worn, that that was her son Jonathan, who was deceased at the scene.
Ashley Flowers
This is the worst possible news that any parent could get. And Ruth was hearing that she had just lost her oldest son months after the family had moved to what she believed would be a safe neighborhood. But why? Why would someone choose to murder a 13 year old kid? It's a question even his mom was asking because she and her son were very close and she never saw or heard anything from Jonathan that could have foreshadowed his death.
Dominic Rostenberg
I remember when I, you know, speaking to Vallartis, she just explained how close they were and she gave me an example of how she got her hair done. She had a hair appointment and her son actually went into the office at the school just to call her to see how her hair turned out. It just shows you how sweet he was and how much he cared about his family. Just to ask his mom, I bet you look so beautiful. I can't wait to see your hair when I come home. It was just so sad to hear that. He's just a sweet, innocent boy, 13 years old, his whole life ahead of him just be wiped out for no reason whatsoever. It's horrible. It's just a tragic situation.
Ashley Flowers
A typical weekend in the Valladares home might look something like the night before Jonathan's murder. Ruth told the Washington Post that she and her family had gone to the movie theater to see the animated movie Megamind. And afterwards, she and Jonathan playfully debated the color of suit that he would wear to his middle school graduation. He wanted to wear green. Jonathan Garcia Valladares was an A student. He was a chess player. He was in choir. And when he grew up, he wanted to be a surgeon. He had just joined his middle school's football team and he had a loving family. Here is one of Jonathan's former middle school teachers. His name is Jason Bourne. And yes, that's his real name.
Tim Stevens
You know, obviously it's a city with certain crimes, so there were gangs in that neighborhood. We got to know the parents really really well. And the parents were really just hard working parents that wanted the best for our kids.
Ashley Flowers
He remembered that even though Jonathan's family had just moved there in the last few months, he was finding his place at Larry c. Kennedy.
Tim Stevens
He was pretty new to us, but he fit in really well. He was a part of the football team that was kind of eighth graders. It's a big deal for them to be on the football team. And so he was a part of that. I know he was in kind of a higher academic grouping. So a lot of his friends, a lot of the kids that he really would have connected with, kids who were higher achievers.
Ashley Flowers
And because Jonathan was such a high achiever, he wanted to do well in this new sport that he'd just taken up. So that's why he started jogging. One of the very first runs he went on was the one that would be his last. Investigators set out to learn more about Jonathan Outside of the accolades that his mom and teacher had volunteered. They spoke to a schoolmate of Jonathan's who said that he had heard a rumor that Jonathan was killed during an attempted robbery. That schoolmate also told police about an incident unrelated to Jonathan where he witnessed a kid in the middle of an argument take off his shirt, yell, southside posse, and walk away. Now, the Southside posse was a gang that was active in the area. And while authorities knew that Jonathan didn't have ties to any gangs and he didn't have a criminal record, they did wonder, could his death have been gang related? But the thing is, there was no one police could find who had any conflict with Jonathan. He hadn't made any mention to family or friends that he was scared of anyone or even that he had an issue with another person, like a school bully. And his family life was good. Ruth and her husband, Jonathan's stepdad, Isaac, were both vetted, and they were fully cooperative with law enforcement and were cleared of any involvement in the shooting. And it should be noted that Jonathan's birth father died a few years prior. So as authorities grappled with why someone would target Jonathan, they wondered if maybe he wasn't targeted at all. Maybe this was just a random act of violence or a crime of opportunity. But even that idea made little sense to detectives. Detective Rostenberg described the area to us specifically as a middle class neighborhood. He said that a shooting taking place there was very rare. And here's Tim again, the neighbor who tried to save Jonathan.
Jason Bourne
I just bought this house. I just moved into this house two days, and now there's a dead Boy that was shot, you know, two doors down, like, what the hell's going on here? Well, and everybody told me, like, this is nothing. Nothing like this has ever happened before. This is very unusual, but even still, I'd been in the house three days.
Ashley Flowers
You know, Detective Rostenberg told us there were no child abductions in the area at the time and that Jonathan was found fully dressed with no signs of sexual assault. He didn't even have any injuries to suggest there had been a struggle, like if someone were trying to get him in a car or something. He was shot and fell to the ground as his shooter fled the area. Random crimes in this neighborhood might not have been common, but that's what this was looking like. Though there was a little more that the autopsy provided.
Dominic Rostenberg
There was stippling on his left hand, the back of his left hand. So basically, stippling is the pattern of gunshot residue. So we believe Jonathan maybe had his left hand up, covering his face as he was shot. It's also indicative of close range, of him being shot from close range. Two of the bullets entered his left cheek, and two of the bullets were in close proximity to his left ear.
Ashley Flowers
That's so sad that he must have been, like, trying to protect himself.
Dominic Rostenberg
Yeah, he must have been just like this.
Ashley Flowers
This information told investigators that the shooter was two or three feet, maybe even closer range to Jonathan when he was shot with.22 caliber bullets. Interestingly, even though Jonathan was shot four times, six 22 caliber bullet casings were recovered when they did a sweep of the scene. Meaning that at least two shots missed, probably forced the shooter to get closer and closer, close enough that they may have even touched Jonathan. The pockets being turned out. Was that something that was noticed right away?
Jason Bourne
Yeah.
Dominic Rostenberg
When detectives get out there, we're trained to look for things like that. We're certainly always looking, you know, to determine a motive. So when you see. That's not typically how somebody would wear their pants, obviously. So when you see that, not necessarily that it's a robbery, but it can be indicative of a robbery or robbery attempt.
Ashley Flowers
We know that Jonathan didn't leave the house with much. He didn't have a wallet or a phone or really anything of value. So those pockets were probably empty before the shooter turned them inside out. Despite interviewing more people and attempting to test what little evidence they had for touch DNA and even making pleas to the public for information, Jonathan's case stalled before it ever gained any real traction. It wasn't until Detective Rostenberg got assigned to the case in 2015 that things started to pick up again, and right away he honed in on something important. Even though the shooter hadn't taken anything with them when they'd reached into Jonathan's pockets, they did leave something behind, something that maybe now could be the key to cracking this case wide open.
Anna Sega Nicolasi
Whether your child is trying to catch up, stay sharp or get a head start for the fall, IXL can make learning a seamless part of summer. IXL is an online learning platform that helps kids truly understand what they're learning, whether they're brushing up on math or diving into social studies. Used in 96 of the top 100 school districts in the U.S. is a great tool to keep learning going. My nieces and nephew are loving ixl. Not only are they in control of the topics they're learning, but the interactive challenges and awards makes it feel like a game, an extremely educational game. So they're getting the best of both worlds. Make an impact on your child's learning. Get IXL now and the Deck listeners can get an exclusive 20% off IXL membership when they sign up today at ixl.com deck Visit ixl.com deck to get the most effective learning program out there at the best price. Summer's here and the only thing that should be heating up is the grill. So don't get scorched by your wireless bill. Whether you're road tripping, beach lounging or pool floating, your wireless bill shouldn't be what slows you down. And for a limited time, Mint mobile is offering three months of unlimited premium wireless service for 15 bucks a month on the nation's largest 5G network. Say buh bye to your overpriced wireless plans. Jaw dropping monthly bills and unexpected overages, Mint Mobile is here to rescue you. All plans come with high speed data and unlimited talk and text delivered on the Nation's largest largest 5G network. Ditch overpriced wireless and get three months of unlimited service from Mint Mobile for 15 bucks a month. This year. Skip breaking a sweat and breaking the bank. Get this new customer offer and your 3 month unlimited wireless plan for just 15 bucks a month at mintmobile.comdeck that's mintmobile.com deck upfront payment of $45 required equivalent to $15 a month limited time new customer offer for first 3 months only. Speeds may slow above 35 gigabytes on unlimited plan taxes and fees extra CMIT mobile for details.
Dominic Rostenberg
So when I got involved in 2015 and part of my review process is again like searching like who would want to hurt Jonathan So that's when going through the crime scene photos and the evidence, I again confirmed that it appeared that Jonathan's pants short pockets have been pulled out. They had previously been tested for DNA, but, you know, the technology that we had in 2010 is obviously different from the technology that we have now. So I identified that while speaking with the lab, our crime lab, that there appear to be mixed profiles in Jonathan's pockets. So I'm cautiously optimistic, if you will, that, you know, with additional testing and advancements in DNA technology, that may eventually actually lead to something.
Ashley Flowers
When Detective Rostenberg talked about a mixed profile, what he means is that there were two DNA profiles together, one of which they deemed major and one minor. The major profile belonged to Jonathan, but at the time, the technology wasn't good enough to separate out the minor one to make any determinations about the contributor. Now, Jonathan's DNA being in there makes sense, of course, right? Like, those were Jonathan's shorts. But the other profile, that one was more likely than not their killers. And that is what they need to identify. Since 2015, Detective Rostenberg had played the waiting game, checking back every couple of years to see if the technology was better. And those years may as well have been a lifetime in terms of technology. So it took about five years. But in 2020, the Phoenix Police Department's labs got new equipment outfitted with new technology that could actually separate those mixed profiles. Now, it was still going to have to be a bit of a waiting game because there was a backlog of cases, and Detective Rosenberg had been waiting for another couple of years. But finally, on April 4, 2025, after our team started digging into this case, the lab request was sent back, and those mixed samples are being processed as I speak. DNA backlogs are a real issue for law enforcement departments across the country. Phoenix currently has approximately 2,300 unsolved homicide cases dating back to the 70s. Even so, Detective Rosenberg said that he is optimistic that the results will come back in the next few months. And our team made him aware of Season of Justice in case he has any more cases in need of advanced or expert expedited testing. For those of you new to the deck or me or audio Chuck, Season of Justice is a nonprofit I founded back in 2020 when I saw a gap in the system. So often, the only thing standing in the way of a case getting solved or not is money. Sending things to an outside lab is expensive. And forget the newer stuff like investigative genetic genealogy. Science moves a whole lot faster than law and departments of don't have that budgeted. And even if they did, for how many cases, with the support of our crime junkie fan club and the advertisers on our shows like this one, we can help bridge that gap. So this is my friendly reminder to listen to and support the advertisers on this show because they help us fund nonprofits like Season of Justice. SOJ is separate from our media organization and it's run by a board of directors. And the grant process is the easiest thing ever. I literally had a retired detective help design it because I didn't want red tape and paperwork getting in the way of solving cold cases. So all that to say we gave that information to Detective Rostenberg. But I want to make sure that all of you know the ins and outs of that organization as well, because I know a lot of people in law enforcement and a lot of people who know people in law enforcement listen to this show. So be sure to spread the word. The website is seasonofjustice.org and if you're so inclined, you can even make a tax deductible donation on the website as well. Even a couple of bucks goes a long way if our large community comes together. I'm going to put the link in the show notes. In all that time that Detective Rostenberg has been waiting for the technology to advance and for this to get tested, no tips have come into the silent witness program or to Detective Rostenberg. So for now, we're playing the waiting game. Detective Rostenberg is hopeful that those pockets are going to lead to a suspect. That, and he's hopeful that someone hearing this may come forward.
Dominic Rostenberg
I am at least optimistic that, you know, with this new testing that we're going to get something good. And somebody's going to have to explain why their DNA is in a 13 year old boy's pockets after he may have been robbed and shot several times in the head.
Anna Sega Nicolasi
Absolutely.
Ashley Flowers
Yeah.
Anna Sega Nicolasi
And this is something that I would.
Ashley Flowers
Assume is like exactly what you hope to have in a cold case. It's something that you can kind of like hold on to as technology evolves.
Dominic Rostenberg
Absolutely. And that's one of the great things, you know, great part of this job is just because even, you know, 10 years ago, five years ago, even, you know, you go back 20 years and it's just moving in the right direction. It's just getting better and better and better, especially DNA. The way we collect DNA, the way we process DNA, the results we're getting from DNA, fingerprints, ballistics.
Ashley Flowers
Our reporters, Taylor and Annie tried Getting in touch with Jonathan's parents, they tried contacting those who attended his funeral and wrote on his obituary wall as well. They texted and called every number, but so far we haven't heard back. And it feels as if not only Jonathan is gone, but everyone else around him. But this doesn't mean that he's forgotten. Jason Jonathan's teacher vividly remembered the last time he spoke with Jonathan. The 8th grader was already planning what he was going to study the next.
Tim Stevens
Year he had applied for. It was a charter school that was kind of focused on biology, if I remember correct. It was a science oriented school. So he would talk about kind of the dreams of furthering his education and getting into career. Looking back, I remember the last time I saw him, I had to sign something for him or give him a letter. It might have been a letter of recommendation for this biology school, but he and his friend had come by after school to pick up this letter. And he kind of made a joke of, someday you'll see my name, I'll be famous, I'll remember you, Mr. Bourne. And it's kind of chilling when you kind of think back, but that was the last time I saw him. That was the last thing he said. He was definitely one who thought about the future. He had dreams, he was very, very friendly. The kids, they really connected with him.
Ashley Flowers
And even though he was new to the school, Jonathan's classmates made a point to remember him.
Tim Stevens
He came up often. Kids would kind of mention him in poems that they had written of war. And we would talk about prepping for the promotion, kind of always remembering him. The football season continued and a number of students kind of made it a point to go to every game. And they wore his number either on their cheek face painting or wrote it on their T shirts. So he really kind of shaped.
Ashley Flowers
Jonathan's classmates kept a seat empty for him at the eighth grade graduation, the one where he wanted to wear green. Tim Stevens, the neighbor who found Jonathan just yards from his new home, still lives in that same house. He's been there for about 15 years and he's become friends with his neighbors and none of them have forgotten about this case. Tim said that it's just a part of the fabric now of their community.
Jason Bourne
It's always there, it's always accompanied with, you know, when I think of my first stepping into this house, which I love this house, I love everything about it. And I've been playing with and building and remodeling and landscaping this house for 15 years, I do love, but my very first week was a tough one. You know, sobering, very sobering moment in.
Ashley Flowers
This case haunts Detective Rostenberg.
Dominic Rostenberg
I have Jonathan's photograph or a newspaper article at my desk that I look at every day and it just thankful when I go home and see my kids at this could have easily have been one of my kids. He's exercising. He wants to get in shape for the football team. He had no gang ties, no issues with anyone, no unpaid debts. He was doing great in school and he just leaves his home to go for a quick short job to get in shape for the football team. And he shot four times in the head. It's just the brutality of it, the viciousness of it, it just stuck with me.
Ashley Flowers
If you know anything about the murder of Jonathan Garcia Valladares in Phoenix, Arizona on November 7, 2010, it's time to come forward. You can contact Detective Rostenberg or anyone at the Phoenix Police Department Department during the day at 602-495-5883. And at night you can call 602-262-6141. And if you want to remain anonymous, you can put your tip in through silent witness at 480-948-6377. There's also a toll free line, a text number and the website where you can submit tips as well. And we're going to have all of that information in the show Notes the Deck is an Audio Chuck production with theme music by Ryan Lewis. To learn more about the Deck and our advocacy work, visit thedeckpodcast.com so what do you think, Chuck? Do you approve?
Jason Bourne
Possibility means you have a chance.
Dominic Rostenberg
Passion opens the door to all possibilities.
Anna Sega Nicolasi
When I feel like anything's possible, I feel kind of giddy.
Ashley Flowers
I want to be an astronaut, an artist, an actress, to visit another country.
Jason Bourne
All I need is a backpack and.
Dominic Rostenberg
A pair of shoes and I'll find.
Ashley Flowers
A way I'm able to do anything I set my mind to. I've never felt like more things are possible than right now. In the right shoes, anything's possible. DSW Countless shoes at bragworthy prices. Imagine the possibilities.
Anna Sega Nicolasi
Behind every homicide case is a process.
Ashley Flowers
An investigation, and people seeking answers. And it takes more than reading the headlines to get to the true heart of these stories. I'm Anna Sega Nicolasi, a former New York City homicide prosecutor. And I'm Scott Weinberger, investigative journalist and former deputy sheriff. Each week on our podcast Anatomy of Murder, we dissect real homicide cases from the perspective of those who have lived them. Investigators, prosecutors, and the people impacted most. We dive into not just what happened.
Jason Bourne
But why it happened.
Ashley Flowers
Focusing on the facts, process the decisions.
Jason Bourne
That shaped each case and the pursuit.
Ashley Flowers
Of justice, giving you a deeper understanding of how each case unfolds.
Jason Bourne
Listen to Anatomy of Murder, available wherever.
Ashley Flowers
You get your podcasts.
The Deck Podcast Episode Summary
Title: Jonathan Garcia-Valladares (7 of Diamonds, Arizona)
Host: audiochuck
Release Date: July 30, 2025
In this gripping episode of The Deck, hosted by audiochuck, listeners are taken deep into the tragic and unresolved case of Jonathan Garcia-Valladares, a 13-year-old boy from Phoenix, Arizona. The podcast aims to shed light on some of the coldest cases across the nation by collaborating with investigators and family members, hoping to inspire actionable leads from the audience.
Jonathan Garcia-Valladares was a promising young student with aspirations of becoming a surgeon. He excelled academically, was an active chess player, a member of the choir, and had recently joined his middle school's football team. Jonathan had just moved into the Camelback East Village neighborhood with his family, believing it to be a safe and supportive environment.
Notable Quote:
"He was kind of nailing it... He was about to finish eighth grade and had his sights set on a special charter high school that focused on the sciences." [02:30]
On the morning of November 7, 2010, Tim Stevens, a Navy search and rescue veteran and Jonathan’s neighbor, was awakened by sounds resembling gunshots and firecrackers. Reacting swiftly, Tim rushed outside with his dog to investigate, only to discover Jonathan lifeless on his porch, severely injured by multiple gunshot wounds.
Notable Quotes:
"Someone could be in serious danger." – Tim Stevens [03:45]
"Here’s the problem." – Tim Stevens regarding police actions [05:43]
Police were initially cautious, suspecting an active shooter scenario due to multiple gunshot reports. Detective Dominic Rostenberg, who took over the case in 2015, described the chaotic scene and the challenges faced by the responding officers.
Notable Quote:
"We need you out of this area." – Officer directing Tim Stevens [06:15]
"He shot several times in the head. We have limited forensic evidence. We have no video, we had no cell phone data." – Detective Rostenberg [09:02]
The investigation faced numerous obstacles:
Notable Quote:
"There was stippling on his left hand... It’s indicative of close range." – Detective Rostenberg [17:49]
Jonathan's family, especially his mother Ruth, were devastated by his sudden and unexplained death. The community, including teachers like Jason Bourne, remembered Jonathan as a bright and friendly student with no known conflicts or fears.
Notable Quotes:
"He was just a sweet, innocent boy, 13 years old, his whole life ahead of him just wiped out for no reason." – Detective Rostenberg [12:45]
"He was definitely one who thought about the future. He had dreams, he was very, very friendly." – Jason Bourne [28:05]
In 2020, with advancements in DNA technology and new lab equipment, Detective Rostenberg was hopeful that the mixed DNA profiles could now be separated and analyzed, potentially identifying Jonathan's shooter. Despite the progress, results were pending as of April 2025, with Detective Rostenberg remaining optimistic for new breakthroughs.
Notable Quote:
"I am at least optimistic that... somebody's going to have to explain why their DNA is in a 13-year-old boy's pockets after he was robbed and shot." – Detective Rostenberg [26:47]
Jonathan's memory lives on in his school and neighborhood. Classmates honor him by keeping his seat empty during graduations, wearing his number at football games, and including him in school poems and tributes. Detective Rostenberg continues to advocate for justice, emphasizing the importance of community support and technological advancements in solving cold cases.
Notable Quotes:
"He really kind of shaped... He really connected with them." – Tim Stevens [29:39]
"I have Jonathan's photograph or a newspaper article at my desk that I look at every day... It just stuck with me." – Detective Rostenberg [30:34]
The episode concludes with a heartfelt plea for anyone with information to come forward. Detective Rostenberg provides multiple avenues for tips, including phone numbers and the Silent Witness program, encouraging the community and listeners to aid in bringing justice to Jonathan's family.
Notable Quote:
"If you know anything about the murder of Jonathan Garcia Valladares... it's time to come forward." – Ashley Flowers [31:09]
The host also highlights Season of Justice, a nonprofit aimed at bridging the gap in resources for solving cold cases. Support from listeners and advertisers plays a crucial role in funding advanced investigative techniques and assisting law enforcement in their pursuit of justice.
Notable Quote:
"Even a couple of bucks goes a long way if our large community comes together." – Ashley Flowers [23:30]
This episode of The Deck not only recounts the heartbreaking loss of a young life but also underscores the persistent efforts of law enforcement and community members in seeking answers. It serves as a poignant reminder of the impact of unresolved cases and the collective responsibility to aid in uncovering the truth.
For More Information and to Submit Tips:
Support Season of Justice:
The Deck is produced by audiochuck with theme music by Ryan Lewis. For more details and to engage with the community, visit thedeckpodcast.com.