The Deck Podcast Episode Summary
Title: Jonathan Garcia-Valladares (7 of Diamonds, Arizona)
Host: audiochuck
Release Date: July 30, 2025
Introduction
In this gripping episode of The Deck, hosted by audiochuck, listeners are taken deep into the tragic and unresolved case of Jonathan Garcia-Valladares, a 13-year-old boy from Phoenix, Arizona. The podcast aims to shed light on some of the coldest cases across the nation by collaborating with investigators and family members, hoping to inspire actionable leads from the audience.
Case Background
Jonathan Garcia-Valladares was a promising young student with aspirations of becoming a surgeon. He excelled academically, was an active chess player, a member of the choir, and had recently joined his middle school's football team. Jonathan had just moved into the Camelback East Village neighborhood with his family, believing it to be a safe and supportive environment.
Notable Quote:
"He was kind of nailing it... He was about to finish eighth grade and had his sights set on a special charter high school that focused on the sciences." [02:30]
Discovery of the Crime
On the morning of November 7, 2010, Tim Stevens, a Navy search and rescue veteran and Jonathan’s neighbor, was awakened by sounds resembling gunshots and firecrackers. Reacting swiftly, Tim rushed outside with his dog to investigate, only to discover Jonathan lifeless on his porch, severely injured by multiple gunshot wounds.
Notable Quotes:
"Someone could be in serious danger." – Tim Stevens [03:45]
"Here’s the problem." – Tim Stevens regarding police actions [05:43]
Immediate Aftermath and Police Response
Police were initially cautious, suspecting an active shooter scenario due to multiple gunshot reports. Detective Dominic Rostenberg, who took over the case in 2015, described the chaotic scene and the challenges faced by the responding officers.
Notable Quote:
"We need you out of this area." – Officer directing Tim Stevens [06:15]
"He shot several times in the head. We have limited forensic evidence. We have no video, we had no cell phone data." – Detective Rostenberg [09:02]
Investigation Process
The investigation faced numerous obstacles:
- Limited Evidence: No clear motive, lack of video surveillance, or substantial forensic evidence made the case tough.
- Witness Reports: Approximately ten witnesses reported hearing gunshots, and one saw a man fleeing the scene, though no solid leads emerged.
- Forensic Challenges: Initial DNA tests revealed mixed profiles in Jonathan's pockets, but the technology at the time couldn't fully analyze the minor contributor's DNA.
Notable Quote:
"There was stippling on his left hand... It’s indicative of close range." – Detective Rostenberg [17:49]
Community and Family Impact
Jonathan's family, especially his mother Ruth, were devastated by his sudden and unexplained death. The community, including teachers like Jason Bourne, remembered Jonathan as a bright and friendly student with no known conflicts or fears.
Notable Quotes:
"He was just a sweet, innocent boy, 13 years old, his whole life ahead of him just wiped out for no reason." – Detective Rostenberg [12:45]
"He was definitely one who thought about the future. He had dreams, he was very, very friendly." – Jason Bourne [28:05]
Advances in the Investigation
In 2020, with advancements in DNA technology and new lab equipment, Detective Rostenberg was hopeful that the mixed DNA profiles could now be separated and analyzed, potentially identifying Jonathan's shooter. Despite the progress, results were pending as of April 2025, with Detective Rostenberg remaining optimistic for new breakthroughs.
Notable Quote:
"I am at least optimistic that... somebody's going to have to explain why their DNA is in a 13-year-old boy's pockets after he was robbed and shot." – Detective Rostenberg [26:47]
Community Remembrance and Ongoing Efforts
Jonathan's memory lives on in his school and neighborhood. Classmates honor him by keeping his seat empty during graduations, wearing his number at football games, and including him in school poems and tributes. Detective Rostenberg continues to advocate for justice, emphasizing the importance of community support and technological advancements in solving cold cases.
Notable Quotes:
"He really kind of shaped... He really connected with them." – Tim Stevens [29:39]
"I have Jonathan's photograph or a newspaper article at my desk that I look at every day... It just stuck with me." – Detective Rostenberg [30:34]
Call to Action
The episode concludes with a heartfelt plea for anyone with information to come forward. Detective Rostenberg provides multiple avenues for tips, including phone numbers and the Silent Witness program, encouraging the community and listeners to aid in bringing justice to Jonathan's family.
Notable Quote:
"If you know anything about the murder of Jonathan Garcia Valladares... it's time to come forward." – Ashley Flowers [31:09]
Supporting Efforts
The host also highlights Season of Justice, a nonprofit aimed at bridging the gap in resources for solving cold cases. Support from listeners and advertisers plays a crucial role in funding advanced investigative techniques and assisting law enforcement in their pursuit of justice.
Notable Quote:
"Even a couple of bucks goes a long way if our large community comes together." – Ashley Flowers [23:30]
Conclusion
This episode of The Deck not only recounts the heartbreaking loss of a young life but also underscores the persistent efforts of law enforcement and community members in seeking answers. It serves as a poignant reminder of the impact of unresolved cases and the collective responsibility to aid in uncovering the truth.
For More Information and to Submit Tips:
- Phoenix Police Department:
- Day: 602-495-5883
- Night: 602-262-6141
- Silent Witness Program:
- Phone: 480-948-6377
- Website: Silent Witness
Support Season of Justice:
- Visit seasonofjustice.org
- Donations are tax-deductible and greatly appreciated.
The Deck is produced by audiochuck with theme music by Ryan Lewis. For more details and to engage with the community, visit thedeckpodcast.com.