Kyle Seidel (5 of Diamonds, Connecticut)

Summary

Podcast Summary: The Deck – Episode: Kyle Seidel (5 of Diamonds, Connecticut)
Host: audiochuck
Release Date: April 2, 2025

---

Introduction

In this gripping episode of The Deck, host Ashley Flowers delves into the harrowing case of Kyle Seidel, a 34-year-old Connecticut man whose life was abruptly taken the night before Christmas in 2012. Utilizing the unique approach of replacing traditional playing cards with the faces of missing and murdered individuals, The Deck aims to reignite public interest and uncover new leads in cold cases through engagement with inmates. This episode showcases the relentless pursuit of justice by investigators and the profound impact on Kyle's family.

The Night of the Murder

August 2012, the evening before Christmas, was supposed to be a joyful time for Kyle Seidel and his family in Waterford, Connecticut. Kyle, a dock laborer at the Essex Island Marina, had attended his company’s holiday party and later stopped by a dive bar with a friend. Upon returning home around 7:30 PM, he promptly switched into "dad mode," greeting his wife, Kate, and their three young children. He agreed to pick up Chinese takeout for dinner, a routine request that would turn tragic.

Quote:
"It should have been a quick trip," Ashley Flowers explains, highlighting that the restaurant was only ten minutes away.

However, Kyle never made it home.

The Murder and Initial Investigation

Kyle was found in the parking lot of a local bowling alley, having been shot by an unidentified assailant. Detectives arrived swiftly but were met with a scene offering few clues. The only items recovered were Kyle’s wallet, containing $40 in cash, an open pocket knife he often carried, and a bullet casings mismatch.

Quote:
Detective Ray Carroll notes, "He had at least a second to try to defend himself, you know, but no DNA on that other than Kyle's." ([07:30])

Despite thorough searches, including interviews with over a dozen people and surveillance footage reviews, investigators found no witnesses or solid leads. The absence of shell casings and the potential for environmental factors like wind complicated evidence collection.

Theories and Family Insights

As the investigation stalled, Kyle's family grappled with possible motives. Detective Carroll mentioned a prevalent theory of road rage, suggesting Kyle might have been involved in a roadside altercation. However, this theory was contested by Kyle's mother, Darlene, who emphasized his aversion to road aggression.

Quote:
Darlene Seidel passionately counters, "He was the type of guy... if there was a family out there that ran out of gas and it was raining, he'd stop and make sure he'd go and get him gas." ([17:07])

Another theory posited that Kyle might have stopped to assist someone in distress, but investigators found this unlikely due to the dark and poorly lit parking lot conditions.

Emergence of Suspects: Mike and Ron

In 2014, the investigation took a new turn when a deck of playing cards featuring Kyle was distributed in Connecticut prisons. A prisoner identified as Mike claimed responsibility for the murder. Further scrutiny revealed connections between Mike and another inmate, Ron, who was known as Mike's enforcer.

Quote:
"We just want to stress to anybody that was close to Kyle... any small bit of evidence or leads can be very important to this case," Ellen Pompeo asserts, emphasizing the need for credible information. ([43:32])

Despite Mike’s initial admission, his alibi and subsequent denials, alongside Ron’s uncooperative stance, hindered immediate prosecution. Efforts to build a case through narcotics charges eventually led to Mike's incarceration in 2015, but his refusal to discuss the murder left the case unresolved.

Complications in the Investigation

The case faced significant delays, partially due to the overwhelming attention following the Sandy Hook school shooting just a week prior. Resources were stretched thin, delaying progress on Kyle’s case, which was subsequently handed over to the state police cold case unit.

Community and Family Efforts

Kyle's family remained steadfast in their quest for answers. They offered a $25,000 reward for information leading to the resolution of the case, but initial tips lacked credibility. The turning point came when Amanda, a woman with a dubious criminal background, claimed to witness Mike and Ron at the scene. However, inconsistencies in her account prevented the information from being admissible in court.

Quote:
"It's tough because when these people came forward with so many years after the fact... it's been so long that they get their dates mixed up," Ellen Pompeo explains the challenges with witness reliability. ([39:45])

Advancements and Ongoing Efforts

In 2021 and 2022, detectives revisited the case, focusing on DNA evidence. Although no matches were found linking Mike and Ron to the DNA mixtures on Kyle's clothing, investigators remained convinced of their involvement based on circumstantial evidence and cell phone activity.

Detective Carroll appeals to the public for any additional information, emphasizing that even seemingly insignificant details could be pivotal in solving Kyle's murder.

Quote:
Detective Ray Carroll urges, "I think just if people are listening to this, then they will hopefully think about coming forward with any little bit of information that could help connect Kyle somehow to these people..." ([42:53])

Impact on the Family

The Seidel family's life was irrevocably altered by Kyle's murder. Kate, Kyle’s wife, struggles with the absence of her husband during her children’s formative years. The emotional toll is profound, as Kyle's parents eventually relocated to Florida to escape the painful reminders in Waterford.

Quote:
Kate shares, "Navigating her own grief while helping three young children understand that their dad wasn't coming home was a devastating task." ([44:16])

Kyle’s mother, Darlene, remains actively involved, regularly communicating with detectives and maintaining an online memorial space dedicated to seeking justice for her son.

Conclusion and Call to Action

Despite years passing without a definitive resolution, the hope remains that new information will surface to bring closure to Kyle Seidel’s family. The Deck emphasizes the importance of community involvement and the critical role of public tips in solving cold cases.

Quote:
Detective Carroll emphasizes, "We believe we've definitely developed probable cause. We just need that little extra information that would place Kyle in the area with those suspects." ([42:53])

Listeners are encouraged to contact the Waterford Police Department with any information that might aid in resolving Kyle's case, reinforcing the podcast’s mission to leverage community engagement in pursuit of justice.

---

Closing Thoughts

This episode of The Deck not only recounts the tragic story of Kyle Seidel but also highlights the broader challenges faced in solving cold cases. Through detailed narrative and emotional testimonies, audiochuck underscores the enduring impact of such crimes on families and communities, advocating for continued vigilance and support in the quest for truth and accountability.

Transcript

[Ashley Flowers]

Hi everyone. Ashley Flowers here. If you love diving into mysteries and exploring the unexplained, but sometimes wonder if the answers lie just beyond the edge of what we know, your next listen should be so Supernatural. Every week I handpick the most bizarre, mind bending mysteries for my friends Rasha and Yvette to look into. From eerie disappearances to encounters that defy exploitation, Rasha and Yvette dive deep into every possibility paranormal, scientific and everything in between. So if you're ready to explore the unknown, then join us on so supernatural. Over 100 episodes are available now and new stories are explored every Friday. Listen to so Supernatural now wherever you listen to podcasts, what if you could turn your curiosity for true crime into a degree at Southern New Hampshire University? You can. Southern New Hampshire University offers over 200 degrees you can earn completely online, including subjects like forensic psychology, criminology and crime analysis. And with low online tuition, Southern New Hampshire University makes earning your degree affordable, flexible and achievable. Find your degree at snhu. Edu Decline. That's snhu. Edu Dec Parents when you visit California Childhood Rules if you don't remember how awesome childhood is, just ask yourself, what would kids do? Let childhood rule your family vacation. Start planning your trip to the ultimate [e-mail] don't miss Good American Family. We have a little girl here for adoption. She has dwarfism.

[Ellen Pompeo]

Starring Ellen Pompeo and Mark Duplass.

[Mark Duplass]

Something is off. She's just a little girl.

[Ashley Flowers]

You think she's faking? She has adult teeth. There are signs of puberty. Inspired by the shocking stories that tore a family apart. I don't know what's going on. How old are you? You should get a lawyer. You have no idea how those people hurt this girl. The Hulu Original Series Good American Family New episodes Wednesdays streaming on Hulu. Our card this week is Kyle Seidel, the five of diamonds from Connecticut. Kyle Seidel should have only been gone for about 20 minutes when he went to pick up Chinese takeout for his wife and their kids just a few days before Christmas in 2012. But something happened that night that changed the course of his fate. Instead of the Chinese restaurant, Kyle was found in the parking lot of a local bowling alley, shot by a mystery assailant with an even more mysterious motive. And detectives are hoping that you can help them crack this case. I'm Ashley Flowers and this is the deck. It was the Friday night before Christmas in 2012 and 34 year old Kyle Seidel was A little late getting home from work. He'd been to his company holiday party and then stopped off at a dive bar with a friend. But the minute he walked through the door of his Waterford, Connecticut, home at about 7:30pm he switched into dad mode, greeting his wife, Kate, and their three young kids and agreeing to go pick up Chinese food for dinner. Kyle had just gotten his holiday bonus from his job as a laborer building docks at the Essex Island Marina. It was about $600 added to his paycheck, and he usually handed his checks right over to Kate to pay the bills. While at the party, Kyle's bosses usually also handed out some extra cash for the holidays. And I don't know exactly how much more Kyle got in cash, but on this particular night, he held onto at least 40 bucks to pay for takeout from their regular spot, the Lucky Inn. Now, this should have been a quick trip. The restaurant was only about 10 minutes away. So as time started to tick by, Kate started to wonder what was taking him so long. Now, she pushed aside her concern at first, telling herself maybe the restaurant was just really busy on a Friday night before the holidays. But then her phone buzzed with a text from her sister, sharing news that was spreading fast through the small town. Someone had been shot at the local bowling alley. Now, Kyle never really went to the bowling alley or the bar connected to it, but Kate knew that he would have driven right past it on his way to pick up the food. And she instantly just felt sick to her stomach. So right away, she started trying to call Kyle. But his phone just rang and rang and rang until it went to voicemail and phones were ringing over at the Waterford's 911 dispatch center. Around that time, too, it was about 8:20pm When 911 dispatchers got back to back calls from people at the bowling alley saying a man was lying on the ground in the parking lot, bleeding from his chest. Here's Waterford Detective Ray Carroll.

[Detective Ray Carroll]

A third caller, a male who identified himself as a corrections officer, stated, looks like he's got a bullet hole to his chest. He moved his head for a second. His car is running, the door is open. He's on the ground. Looks like he might have gotten into an altercation and got shot.

[Ashley Flowers]

When first responders arrived at the scene a few minutes after those calls came in, the injured man was barely conscious.

[Ellen Pompeo]

The sergeant asked the male, who did this? He asked again, who shot you? The male did not answer. The male's jaw quivered as if he was trying to speak, but he was unable to do.

[Ashley Flowers]

So investigators located the man's wallet and ran his tags to identify him. It was indeed Kyle, though Kate wouldn't know that yet. While she waited anxiously at home, hoping he would just pull into the driveway any minute, Paramedics loaded Kyle onto an ambulance and rushed him to the hospital. Just as investigators would continue to process the scene, starting with Kyle's car.

[Ellen Pompeo]

So, based on the positioning of the vehicle, it was parked at an angle, so not totally within one parking spot. And the door was open, engine running, headlights on. So it seemed like he'd either pulled in quickly or needed to exit his vehicle fairly quickly.

[Ashley Flowers]

Now, they didn't find anything of note in the car except for the $40 in cash that Kyle had taken with him to pay for the dinner that he never picked up. Outside of the car, investigators didn't notice any damage, like bullet holes or shattered glass. The only thing left behind was a small, open pocket knife on the ground near the car, one that, they would come to learn Kyle carried with him often. And all of this led police to believe that Kaya was actually outside of his vehicle when he'd been shot. And he must have known that he was in danger.

[Detective Ray Carroll]

He had at least a second to try to defend himself, you know, but no DNA on that other than Kyle's, so that never got used. Basically, Kyle was never close enough to the person who shot him that he was able to use the knife on him.

[Ashley Flowers]

And aside from the knife, nothing else was found, not even shell casings. But there could have been multiple reasons for that. I mean, the wind was roaring that night, dropping the temperature into the low 30s. And police said a shell casing literally could have just been blown away. Or maybe the shooter picked up the casings before fleeing. Or potentially they used a revolver, which doesn't expel its casings at all. All in all, investigators didn't have much to work with.

[Ellen Pompeo]

So the most difficult part of the case is that there was no real evidence that we were able to get from anybody else. The only evidence we collected was from the victim, including his knife that was open near the rear tire of the car. Nothing was collected that would say that somebody else was there.

[Ashley Flowers]

Police talked to more than a dozen people at the scene, interviewed local business owners, and took down the license plates of every car parked in the parking lot. But none of it led to useful information. Police didn't really report any accounts of anyone seeing Kyle pull into the lot or hearing any arguing. There were no witness accounts of any vehicles speeding away from the scene. And by the way, they weren't even sure that their killer was in a car. I mean, it's just as likely at this point that they could have been on foot. And any hope that Kyle himself might be able to identify his assailant was dashed that same night when he succumbed to his injuries. He was pronounced dead at 8:45pm about this same time, Kate was at home trying to calm herself down so she could focus on finding Kyle. She took their son Jesse upstairs and put him to sleep in his crib. And then she went into her and Kyle's bedroom and dialed his number one last time. She listened to the phone ring and ring again, and just then she saw headlights outside of her bedroom window. She looked out to see a truck pulling into her driveway and this ominous feeling just washed over her.

[Mark Duplass]

Are your kids struggling with homework? IXL is an online learning program that covers math, language arts, science and social studies with interactive practice problems for kids from Pre K to 12th grade. Using advanced algorithms, IXL's questions adjust to the right level of difficulty for each different student as they practice, whether it's on the computer or using the app on a phone or tablet. Memberships start at only 9.95amonth. And listen, I don't have kiddos, but I do have a lot of friends who do and I feel like there is a constant concern about resources outside the classroom. They want to make sure their kids are learning at the pace that they need to or that they have the resources that they need to do so. And every time they bring it up to me, I think about I make an impact on your child's learning. Get IXL now and the DEC listeners can get an exclusive 20% off IXL membership when they sign up today at ixl.com dec Visit ixl.com dec to get the most effective learning program out there at the best price. Vacation season is nearly upon us this year. Treat yourself to the luxe upgrades you deserve with Quince's high quality travel essentials at fair prices like lightweight European linen styles from $30, washable silk tops and comfy lounge sets. Pair it with premium luggage options and stylish tote bags to carry it all. The best part? All Quint's Items are priced 50 to 80% less than similar brands because they partner directly with top factories, cutting out the cost of the middleman and passing the savings on to us. I've specifically been super impressed with their leather goods. I love a leather jacket and I started searching for a brown option which I feel like are really hard to find and I couldn't find any until I started looking at quints. Every time I wear my jacket, I always get a compliment. For your next trip, treat yourself to luxe upgrades you deserve from quinte. Go to quince.comdeck for 365 day returns plus free shipping on your order. That's Q-U-I-N-C-E.com deck to get free shipping and 365 day returns. Quince.com deck.

[Ashley Flowers]

Kate recognized the truck pulling into her drive. It was her sister Christy's. When Kristi, Kristi's husband, and their friend piled out of the truck, Kate just knew this wasn't just a bad feeling she was having. This was bad. Though no one had been notified by police, word spreads fast in a small town where everyone knows one another. Kristi had a friend who worked at the local emergency room, and that friend told her that Kyle had been shot. So Kristi stayed behind with the kids while Kate jumped into the truck with Kristi's husband and his friend and headed straight to the er. But by the time she got there, Kyle was already gone. And Kate was left with a million questions like why was he in that parking lot to begin with? I mean, that's a question police were asking her, too, but she had no answers. She told them about the holiday party that he'd gone to, the plan to pick up Chinese for dinner. And she knew that he'd been drinking at the party earlier that day. And Kyle's brother Jeremy confirmed that his brother had sounded like he'd been drinking when he talked to him on the phone about an hour before he been shot. But no one could think of any reason why he would have stopped at the bowling alley.

[Detective Ray Carroll]

That's when the detectives and the investigator started asking her about use of drugs or anything like that. Keith said that Kyle occasionally smoked marijuana and formerly used coke when he was younger. She estimated that he smoked marijuana twice a week.

[Ashley Flowers]

He still bought weed from a local guy, but Kate said that she didn't know his name and she really didn't think Kyle had been planning to meet up with him or anyone on his way to grab food. Kate also told us that Kyle had weed at home so he wouldn't have been out buying anymore. And when they talked to his mom, Darlene, she added this he had all.

[Darlene Seidel]

Afternoons because he had, you know, had his Christmas party. I guess he had visited some friends, you know, after the party, so he had plenty of time alone if he was thinking about doing anything, you know, why would he do it when you go to get takeout. The last thing he would ever do if he wanted to do takeout was to make a detour, let it get cold, and have to reheat it.

[Ashley Flowers]

As Kyle's family struggled to make sense of how he ended up in that bowling alley parking lot, they arrived at one possible theory.

[Detective Ray Carroll]

The first kind of motive we had came from a family member of Kyle's who just said, you know, a gut feeling. I think maybe someone cut him off or he cut someone else off. And it was like a road rage incident that occurred. And that kind of goes along with the way the car is parked.

[Ashley Flowers]

Detectives took this theory seriously. I mean, they were already in the process of scouring the area for security footage to see if the shooting or the moments leading up to it were captured on camera. But they didn't have any luck. Most of the local businesses had cameras that either weren't working or weren't pointing in the right direction. There was one camera from a nearby ATM that had a motion activated camera. Now, it didn't show Kyle pulling into the bowling alley, but at one point, it did show Kyle's car in the parking lot, which could have been helpful for investigators. Except whenever the camera was motion activated by a car pulling up to the atmosphere, the car getting cash would block the view of the rest of the scene. So investigators couldn't see much, and they weren't able to gather any evidence from that footage. Now, there was a glimmer of hope when detectives reviewing surveillance footage from a gas station spotted a car registered to someone with a violent criminal history driving by the bowling alley that same night. But that person had a solid alibi for the time of Kyle's killing and was cleared of any involvement in his death. Though this road rage theory seemed to be prominent among family, it never made sense to his mom, Darlene, who told our reporter Taylor, that Kyle wasn't prone to road rage. In fact, he was really scared of other people being aggressive on the road.

[Darlene Seidel]

When he was a teenager, he drove truck for an ionic lumber. After he graduated, he did for a while, and he says, mom, I'm going to get killed on the road. He said, you don't believe how angry these people are. You're in a truck and they pull right in front of you, like you can stop on a dime, you know? So he wouldn't have played into road rage. In my heart, he would have avoided.

[Ashley Flowers]

It if another driver had gotten mad at him for something on the road. Darlene thought that Kyle probably would have pulled off the road to Avoid them, maybe into a parking lot. But in her mind, it was more likely that he stopped to help someone.

[Darlene Seidel]

He was the type of guy, if there was a family out there that ran out of gas and it was raining, he'd stop and make sure he'd go and get him gas. You know, the scenario I play in my mind is if a guy was either hurting a girl or a kid just before Christmas, he'd throw his hands up at a light and say, like, what are you doing? You know, because that wasn't his thing. He could have known the person and there was an issue going on, and he would pull in and say, what the heck? Kyle had good morals like that. So if he saw something like that, he would have stepped in. Those are the two scenarios I can come up with. Either road rage or he saw when he was going by somebody he knew was in trouble.

[Ashley Flowers]

Detectives considered the theory that he stopped to help someone, too, but ultimately they dismissed it because it was unlikely that he could have even spotted someone in distress.

[Detective Ray Carroll]

You would barely be able to see anything in that parking lot. You couldn't barely make out the family bowl because you have the lights on the businesses that are on Route 1 that kind of drown out the background and make it seem even darker to the eye. So you're not seeing anything back there.

[Ashley Flowers]

That made them wonder if it wasn't road rage and he hadn't seen someone in distress. Maybe the stop was pre planned.

[Detective Ray Carroll]

Well, we had theories that because he had just gotten a bonus from the Christmas party, that maybe he was going out to buy some harder drugs than marijuana just to celebrate if he was into that kind of thing. Again, they're just trying to go through Kyle's life and find anything that can give us a reason why he was there and if he was going to meet someone or not.

[Ashley Flowers]

So they turned to Kyle's phone, hoping if it was a planned meetup, they would find evidence of it being arranged. But sure enough, just like his family suggested, there weren't any messages about anything like that. And tox screens later done at an autopsy would confirm that there were no illegal drugs or. Or even prescription painkillers in his system. Just alcohol, though. Quite a lot of it. Kyle's BAC at the time of his death was 0.18%, which is more than double the legal limit in Connecticut. But there was one message on his phone that did stand out. One suggesting that maybe he had been trying to buy something else. Learn naturally. Speak confidently. Rosetta Stone helps you absorb a language the way you learned your first through real world context and conversation. No memorization, just practical skills you can use right away. Available on mobile and desktop, Rosetta Stone is designed to fully immerse you in your chosen language for a more natural and effective learning experience. Italian, German, Korean, Chinese with 30 years of experience, millions of users and 25 languages offered, Rosetta Stone is the Go To Language Learning solution. Perfect your pronunciation with built in True Accent speech recognition technology providing real time feedback and this is where I'll give you my little life update. So my husband and I applied for residency in Portugal. We're not like moving or anything. I'm still going to be living in Indianapolis most of the time. French is out, I've started leaning in hard to Portuguese. And honestly, this is what is so great about Rosetta stone. They had 25 languages and when life changed on a dime, so could I The Deck listeners can grab Rosetta Stone's lifetime membership for 50% off. That's unlimited access to 25 language courses for life. Just visit rosettastone.comdeck to get started and claim your 50% off today. That's rosettastone.com deck to start learning do.

[Mark Duplass]

You say data or data however you say it? It's time to for your monthly data plan with Mint Mobile, say goodbye to your overpriced wireless plans, jaw dropping monthly bills and unexpected overages. All Mint Mobile plans come with high speed data or data, your choice, and unlimited talk and text delivered on the nation's largest 5G network. Plus you can use your own phone with any Mint Mobile plan and bring your phone number along with all of your existing contacts. Ditch overpriced wireless and get three months of premium wireless service from Mint Mobile for 15 bucks a month. No matter how you say it, don't overpay for it. Shop data plans@mint mobile.com deck that's mintmobile.com deck upfront payment of $45 for three month five gigabyte plan required equivalent to $15 a month new customer offer for first three months only, then full price plan options available, tax and fees extra. See Mint Mobile for details.

[Ashley Flowers]

The medical examiner had recovered a bullet from Kyle's body, a.45 caliber, and that stood out to police because of a text message that Kyle sent to his friend the day before he was murdered.

[Detective Ray Carroll]

Kyle said that he was going to buy a.45 caliber pistol and that's what started leading us down that road. Was he meeting someone to buy a gun? And then the deal just went bad.

[Ashley Flowers]

Detectives talked to the friend who Kyle had texted about the gun. And unfortunately, kyle hadn't said anything more about who or where he was planning to buy it from. Apparently, kyle told his friend that he had a pistol permit, so his friend just assumed that he would be buying it from a store. But detectives learned that kyle didn't have a pistol permit, so there was a chance that he was planning to buy a pistol off the books. Now, detectives checked Kyle's incoming and outgoing calls, Texts, Social media messages, but they didn't find anything to indicate that he'd communicated with anyone about an illegal gun purchase. And there were no calls or texts to any unknown numbers, either. Detectives also checked phone records for kate, Jeremy, and one of kyle's close friends. One thing they were looking for Was to see if any of them had exchanged messages with anyone about buying any drugs or a gun, like maybe someone else had set up a meeting for kyle. But there was nothing. Kyle's mom, darlene, told our reporter that kyle had been in the process of getting his pistol permit with his dad. Now, she insisted that kyle was doing everything by the book, and he had a specific reason that he wanted a gun, Though not one that you would probably ever guess.

[Darlene Seidel]

He wanted to go shark fishing. And if you're gonna go off montauk stock fishing, you, soon have some kind of gun. The shark gets in the boat, or it comes up the whole nine yards. So he and his dad both went together. They went to the pistol permit classes. They got the letters, they got everything they needed. And they had decided the day after christmas, when things quieted, they were going to take their paperwork down to the police station and find out what they had to do to file it and get their pistol permit.

[Ashley Flowers]

Darlene said that kyle's dream was to spend more time on the water, and she and her husband had just bought a boat for kyle that he was.

[Darlene Seidel]

Making payments on that was like his dream boat. He was the man with a plan, you know, pay it off in four years with his income tax. He had it all planned. It was the perfect boat for fishing and a family, because that was his passion. He fed his family a lot with his fish since he was a little boy. I have pictures of him fishing.

[Ashley Flowers]

Darlene said kyle had gone to a local gun shop About a week before his murder and had called her afterwards to get her advice about which pistol to buy. He specifically said that he wouldn't be able to get it until he submitted his permit application and got it approved, which they were expecting to happen shortly after the holiday.

[Darlene Seidel]

Kyle really wasn't a rule breaker. He wouldn't need a gun so badly. He would all of a sudden have to buy one.

[Ashley Flowers]

Detective Carroll said police in Waterford never received a pistol permit application from Kyle. That doesn't mean that he wasn't gathering the paperwork he needed to submit that application. Kyle's brother Jeremy, said Kyle hadn't mentioned anything to him about planning to meet up with anyone to buy a gun. And he really doesn't think Kyle would be spending money on something like that right before the holidays, even if he had just gotten his bonus. He said that Kyle had spent a ton on Christmas presents already that year, and the brothers were planning to go shopping for their wives the very next day. Kyle also didn't have much cash on him. He had that 40 bucks for food, and investigators found $23 in the wallet in his back pocket. I mean, his wife Kate said that he never really had much cash on him. And even if he'd gotten a cash bonus that day, Kyle's mom said that as far as she knows from having a husband and two sons who have done a lot of manual labor at marinas and on the water like Kyle did, he probably would have gotten, like, 50 bucks or so. Detectives still weren't completely convinced that Kyle hadn't planned to meet someone for something out in that parking lot. And since sifting through so many pages of Kyle's phone records hadn't gotten them any closer to a lead, they tried another avenue for information.

[Detective Ray Carroll]

They tried to get a search warrant for a cell tower dump. So they just wanted to get everybody's phone that was in the area that night and start picking through it. But the court denied it, wouldn't allow it.

[Ashley Flowers]

So they had to do things the old fashioned way, hit the streets, talk to anyone who knew Kyle, anyone who might have known why he was in that parking lot that night. And they learned a little more about that night after talking to a friend named Travis. Travis said that Kyle had actually stopped by his place after leaving the bar but before going home. And he tried to get Travis to go out with him, but Travis said no. Now, this was interesting, but it didn't give police a new lead to follow because Kyle wasn't trying to get Travis to go somewhere specific. And Kyle clearly decided to just go home himself to be with his family. I mean, why else would he have offered to go get dinner? And in case you're wondering, yes, detectives checked Travis's alibi for the night, and it was rock solid. So there just wasn't much for investigators to work with. Complicating Matters was that when Kyle was killed, law enforcement was already overwhelmed by another tragedy that had pulled the focus of the nation and put a spotlight on Connecticut and its investigators. The Sandy Hook mass shooting. Just a week before Kyle's murder, 20 children and six educators had been killed in an elementary school just an hour and a half away from where Kyle was shot. And that investigation was massive, Pulling resources from across the state. Kyle's family still worries that all those factors could have played a role in the direction Kyle's case went in. Because eventually his case was turned over to the state police cold case unit in hopes of getting more leads. There was a reward put out for information on Kyle's case, and it was plastered on posters that his family put up around town. But even still, nothing happened. That is, until police put Kyle's case on a deck of playing cards in 2014 and passed those decks out to Connecticut prisons.

[Ellen Pompeo]

Someone had come forward after seeing the picture and saying that a man that will identify as Mike was playing cards and said, that is my work. As if to say he's the one who killed Kyle Seidel. Then we started looking into him. There was no clear alibi for him that night.

[Ashley Flowers]

But here's the twist. When Mike claimed to take credit for Kyle's murder, one of his buddies, who was also incarcerated at the time, got mad.

[Ellen Pompeo]

We heard that there was some arguments made by another person that were called Ron, saying that Mike didn't do it, I did it. So we started looking at both of those people and we saw that there is a connection between those two people. Outside of prison, they were known to hang out together.

[Ashley Flowers]

Just to be clear, Mike and Ron are not these guys real names. Police insisted on using pseudonyms to protect their investigation. Now, they said Ron was known to act as Mike's muscle, For lack of a better term.

[Ellen Pompeo]

Mike and Ron both have extensive criminal histories. Mike's was mostly narcotics related sale counts, things of that nature. And Ron has a more violent criminal history. Also has drug offenses, but shootings and things of that nature.

[Ashley Flowers]

And it wasn't long before someone else came forward to report that Mike had confessed to the crime.

[Ellen Pompeo]

We had a family member of Mike's come forward and say that Mike admitted it to him, that he had killed Kyle Seidel and that he had come over to a house that night and was acting very nervous and said he had to get out of town and went into a neighboring town later that night.

[Ashley Flowers]

Apparently, this family member had come into possession of a phone that used to belong to Mike. And on that Phone were photos of mike holding various guns. And he decided to go to a cop that he knew and trusted to show him the photos and talk about kyle's case. Detective carroll said that as promising as these tips were at first, the people they were getting these accounts from Just weren't credible. The informant's supposed account of the shooting Ultimately didn't add up. When investigators dug in, he told police that there were other witnesses to mike's confession. But according to parole and probation records, the people he said were there when mike confessed couldn't have been. But police did still believe that there could be a kernel of truth in there, so they didn't want to let up just yet. Mike was incarcerated when that tip from the cold case deck came in. Now, he was released from prison sometime in 2014 or 2015, but he wouldn't be out for long, because while there just wasn't enough solid evidence for detectives to charge Mike with kyle's murder, There were other crimes, Namely drug dealing, that they could maybe bring him in for.

[Ellen Pompeo]

We had a task force officer try to build a narcotics case on him to get him locked up in hopes that if he was in prison, maybe other witnesses would come forward. They would feel safe knowing that he was already locked up, and he wouldn't be able to serve any kind of retribution on him. So that did work out. Mike got arrested on the narcotics charge in late 2015, and that's when we talked to him. He just cried a lot, but said nothing about the homicide, Just denied any ever being at the bowling alley, Denied knowing kyle, Denied ever being involved in any kind of violence. He basically just denied and said he didn't know what we were talking about.

[Ashley Flowers]

And detectives attempt to interview ron Failed to elicit any information at all.

[Ellen Pompeo]

He basically came in the room, sat down. As soon as we started talking to him, he said, I'm all set. I don't want to talk, and left.

[Ashley Flowers]

So detectives kept looking for more evidence to connect these guys to the scene. First, they turned back to cell phone records. A court had denied their first request for a cell tower dump, But a second request was approved. The data from that tower dump showed that mike and ron were in the area of the shooting at the time it happened. But unfortunately, cell tower data doesn't provide an exact location. It just identifies the tower. Particular phones are pulling their data from at any given point. And it turned out that mike and ron Both lived near the same cell tower that serviced the bowling alley. So both men could have just been at home. The interesting thing that they did get from the records, though, was activity along with location. The records also showed the numbers of phone calls that both Mike and Ron made immediately after Kyle was shot. And there was a flurry of them, including a few calls that seemed really suspicious.

[Ellen Pompeo]

Yeah. So the tower dump that we executed came back with a lot of information. We got a lot of phone calls from Mike to his girlfriend, other family members, other friends. We also got Ron's information. He made several phone calls. Notably, he called the hospital emergency room. Ron's calls to the Lawrence Memorial emergency room seemed like something you would do to cover your tracks or to see what the status is of Kyle to see if he had died or if he was still alive.

[Ashley Flowers]

The combination of tips about Mike and Ron and their cell phone activity certainly made detectives feel that they were on the path to arresting the men for Kyle's murder. But they still needed more evidence to clinch the charges, the weapon, a witness, anything. And in 2018, it seemed like they got exactly what they needed. Someone claiming to be an eyewitness to the murder who was willing to talk to them. Today is as good an excuse as any to gift yourself that piece of jewelry you've always wanted. Who says you need a reason? Find pieces that make you feel [e-mail] at Blue Nile, you'll find thousands of independently graded diamonds and fine jewelry pieces at prices below your expectations. Peace of mind comes with every Blue Nile purchase, thanks to some of the highest quality standards in the jewelry industry. And buyer's remorse is no more because Blue nile also offers 30 day returns and a diamond price match guarantee. And I know there can be fear with making big purchases like diamonds online. Maybe that's just the elder millennial in me and all you gen zers like don't blink an eye. But it was a big deal for me to pull the trigger and buy a diamond online. Except once I did and saw what an amazing diamond ring I got, I have gone back and bought a ton of more from Blue Nile. Experience the ease and convenience of shopping Blue Nile, the original online jeweler. Go to bluenile.com today. That's blue nile.com Stop allergy season in its tracks with big savings from Goodrx. Seasonal allergy medication starts at just $15, so you and your family can kick those itchy eyes, stuffy noses, and scratchy throats straight to the curb. Check Goodrx before every trip to the pharmacy. To save up to 80% on both brand name and generic medications. Goodrx is free and easy to use. Just search for your prescription on the website or app, compare prices and get a free coupon to show your pharmacist. Use Goodrx to save at over 70,000 local pharmacies nationwide, including Walmart, Walgreens, CVS, Publix, Kroger and many more. Remember, Goodrx works with or without insurance and could beat your insurance copay price. Don't let allergies slow you down. Save big on allergy medications this season with GoodRx. Go to GoodRx.com Dec that's GoodRx.com Dec the tip that came in was from a woman named Amanda who said that she knew Ron and Mike.

[Ellen Pompeo]

Amanda said that she was actually with Mike and Ron the night that Kyle Seidel was shot. Amanda says they pulled into the family bull. She wasn't sure what was going on, why they were there, but Mike and Ron both got out of the car, which in her experience meant that they were probably going to rob somebody because if it was just a drug deal, then only one of them would have got out of the car. And so she witnessed the shooting. Mike and Ron got back in the car and then they left.

[Ashley Flowers]

Now, Amanda is not this witness's real name, and her account wasn't the thing that was going to seal the deal either.

[Ellen Pompeo]

She has a lengthy criminal history, and a lot of that criminal history has to do with deception. So whether it's fraud, defrauding people, she was supposed to be trusted by larcenies and things of that nature, it doesn't make her a great witness. So while her information is great and we can use some of that as investigative leads, the court is not confident that they could bring this case to trial based on her testimony alone.

[Ashley Flowers]

They kept running into similar credibility issues as they followed new leads. At one point, detectives had gotten a family member of Mike's to agree to record a conversation with Mike. But apparently that didn't pan out because Mike didn't trust that relative anymore. Maybe he found out that he'd gone to the cops previously. Now, another woman we'll call Julie also contacted investigators about Mike.

[Ellen Pompeo]

Julie came forward and said that she took Mike to a small chop shop to actually get rid of the murder weapon used in the Seidel homicide. But based on Julie's statements of when and where it occurred, those things couldn't.

[Ashley Flowers]

Have happened, detective Carroll said. It's hard to tell whether some of these stories have been inaccurate due to people being dishonest or just because they waited so long to give their tips to police. The flip side of that though, is the $25,000 reward that's up for grabs could also be motivating people to just make things up.

[Ellen Pompeo]

It's tough because when these people came forward with so many years after the fact that even if they are telling the truth or trying to tell the most accurate story they can, it's been so long that they get their dates mixed up. But that's part of the reason, probably, why the court's looking at it, that they can't take it to trial, because the defense attorney is going to tear their stores apart.

[Ashley Flowers]

In 2021 and 2022. Police tried to see if they could link Mike and Ron to the crime scene using DNA. Back in the early days of the investigation, when they were exploring all possibilities, they had Kyle's clothes tested for possible touch DNA. And they did find some unknown DNA mixtures on his clothing, including near the chest area of his sweatshirt. So they got search warrants for Mike and Ron's DNA and compared it to the unidentified DNA mixtures found on Kyle's clothing, But there was no match. Now, detectives say that that doesn't rule them out as suspects, since the shooter may have never even touched Kyle. But it doesn't help their case against Mike and Ron either. And while investigators feel pretty confident that Mike and Ron are their guys, they have other questions that they're still hoping to answer.

[Ellen Pompeo]

One possible theory is that Kyle, with a history of some drug use, was going to the bowling alley to purchase drugs. Since he had a recent Christmas bonus from work. And since he wasn't a regular user, he might have been hooked up with these guys, Mike and Ron. And because he was possibly a first time buyer, they just robbed him of his money. The second theory is based on Mike and Ron's history with guns and having guns, Is that Kyle was looking to purchase a gun. And a text from. Just a couple days before the homicide, Kyle texted his one of his friends, saying he was gonna buy a.45 pistol. And that's the caliber of the weapon that was used to shoot Kyle.

[Ashley Flowers]

It's worth noting that while much of the investigation has revolved around Mike and Ron, Police did their due diligence and considered members of Kyle's own family at the start. And detectives told us that they don't consider any of them a suspect in his death. They found no sign of a life insurance policy in Kyle's name, so there was really no financial motivation for him to be killed. And Kate and Jeremy allowed police to look through their phones. Kyle's mom and brother say that he and Kate had dealt with relationship struggles in the past, but had worked on their relationship and were in a good place as a couple. Darlene says that she remains as close to Kate as if she were her own daughter. And both she and Jeremy believe that Kate and Kyle's marriage would have lasted for the long haul if they'd been given a chance. And detectives are still trying to figure out why they didn't get that chance. But to figure out the motive in Kyle's murder, they need people who knew Kyle, who or know Mike and Ron to come forward.

[Detective Ray Carroll]

I think just if people are listening to this, then they will hopefully think about coming forward with any little bit of information that could help connect Kyle somehow to these people or even just connect these people to that area. It would be great to have a reason why they were both there at the same time. We believe we've definitely developed probable cause. We just need just that little extra information that would place Kyle in the area with those suspects.

[Ashley Flowers]

For some reason, detectives think it is possible that someone who knew and loved Kyle hasn't shared everything they know.

[Ellen Pompeo]

We just want to stress to anybody that was close to Kyle, friends and family that might be either looking out for his reputation or their own reputation, that any small bit of evidence or leads can be very important to this case. We interviewed, you know, lots of people that were close to Kyle, one of which, when we interviewed them, it felt like they were holding back and weren't telling us everything, just based on their emotional response. And we asked to have that person be part of a polygraph. They agreed, but then shortly afterwards, contacted us and said that they did not want to take the polygraph.

[Ashley Flowers]

Detective Carroll also spoke directly to anyone who might be afraid that they could get in trouble for coming forward with information.

[Ellen Pompeo]

They're not going to be looked at in a bad light. And solving his homicide is a lot more important than Kyle either wanting to buy an illegal gun or buying some drugs. None of that matters at this point. It's just trying to help the family out and solve this homicide.

[Ashley Flowers]

Kyle's wife Kate, wrote in an email to our reporter that watching their children, Samantha, Maya, and Jessie, grow up without Kyle there to celebrate and support their milestones has been a heartbreaking experience. I mean, Kyle missed seeing Samantha graduate high school. Maya got her first job. Jesse learned how to ride a dirt bike. I mean, they were just 8, 6, and 2 when their father was taken from them. And Kate said that Kyle was her best friend. And navigating her own grief while helping three young children understand that their dad wasn't coming home. When she herself didn't understand what happened was a devastating task. At Kyle's funeral, Kate said that she waited until everyone else had left the room and told her husband, I've got this. I will need your help along the way, but I've got this. And over the years, that's what she and her kids have said to each other when their grief feels unbearable. When times get hard, they look at each other and say, I've got this. Kate told us that she heard rumors over the years about suspects in the case. And based on what she's pieced together, she doesn't believe the suspects are people that she or Kyle knew or even ever met. She believes, like Darlene and Jeremy do, that Kyle encountered his killer in some sort of random run in. She said healing is impossible without answers about what happened to Kyle. Here is our reporter reading part of Kate's statement to us.

[Mark Duplass]

To have someone held accountable and locked up would mean so much to us. It's so hard knowing the killer is still out there just living his day to day life while Kyle got a life sentence. My kids and I have to live with this heartache for the rest of our lives. We are learning how to move forward and take Kyle along with us in our hearts.

[Ashley Flowers]

Kyle's parents, Darlene and Rick, moved to Florida a few years after the murder because being in Waterford carried too many reminders of what happened to Kyle. But they carry his memory with them in a visible way. Before Kyle died, she and Rick got matching tattoos to memorialize their shared love for Chevy cars and trucks. And since Kyle's death, Darlene has gotten a full tattoo sleeve with images that represent her love for him, a rendering of his beloved boat, a sunset over the water, a fishing lure, and a broken heart. Darlene thinks about her son every day and regularly checks in with detectives to find out whether Mike and Ron are in or out of prison. As of this recording, Mike was out on parole and Ron was incarcerated. Darlene also regularly checks a Facebook group called justice for Kyle where she writes messages to her son, posts photos, and provides updates on the case, ending every.

[Darlene Seidel]

Message the same and I always sign it. I will love you forever and always, Mom.

[Ashley Flowers]

She writes to Kyle's killer on there too, expressing her pain and her rage.

[Darlene Seidel]

I really despise him, you know, or her for doing what they did. This person has his right maybe to come and go. Maybe he's in jail, I don't know. But he can still do things. He still has the opportunity if he has children to take them for ice cream or see him at Christmas. To me, that's not there.

[Ashley Flowers]

Detectives are looking for any information about Kyle's life that might help them understand what happened. So anyone with any information is asked to contact the Waterford Police Department tip line at 860-437-8080. Or you can call Waterford detectives directly at 860-442-0645 or 860-442-9451. The deck is an Audio Chuck production with theme music by Ryan Lewis. To learn more about the Deck and our advocacy work, visit thedeckpodcast.com so what do you think Chuck? Do you approve.

[Detective Ray Carroll]

Jack in the Box's.

[Ashley Flowers]

New banana French toast sticks starting at.

[Detective Ray Carroll]

$2.99 are the same French toast sticks.

[Ashley Flowers]

You love now, banana flavored and served with chocolate dipping sauce. So good. And another way Jack gives you so much more. Hi everyone. Ashley Flowers here. If you're like me, diving into true crime is about more than just the details of a case. It is also about giving a voice to the victims and understanding the lives behind the headlines. And this is what host Kylie Lowe does each week on her podcast, Dark Down East. Every Thursday, Kylie dives into New England's most gripping mysteries, uncovering stories in a way you won't hear anywhere else. And she digs through archives, connects with families, and shines a light on the voices that deserve to be heard. From cold cases to moments of long awaited justice, Dark down east is the perfect blend of investigations and honoring the stories behind them. You can find Dark down east now wherever you're listening.