The Deck Podcast: Luther Meshell (9 of Hearts, Louisiana) – Detailed Summary

Episode Release Date: June 25, 2025
Host: audiochuck

Introduction: Unsolved Mystery of Luther Meshell

In this gripping episode of The Deck, host audiochuck delves into the haunting case of Luther Meshell, designated as the Nine of Hearts from Louisiana. The episode meticulously unpacks the mysterious circumstances surrounding Luther's death in 1991, exploring the intricate details that have left his family seeking justice for over three decades.

The Night of Luther’s Death

[07:30]
On a tranquil spring evening in 1991, Luther Meshell's life was abruptly ended under perplexing circumstances. Luther's teenage son, Alan, discovered him dead on the bedroom floor beside his overturned wheelchair and a knife. The scene was baffling: the front door was locked from the inside, and there were no indications of forced entry.

Key Quote:
Ashley Flowers: "Police believe his killer could have been someone he knew and trusted."
(Timestamp: 07:30)

Discovery and Initial Investigation

[04:13] - [06:45]
Tammy Michel, Luther's daughter, recounts the terrifying moment she learned of her father's condition. Upon arriving at his home, Tammy and Alan found Luther in distress, initially mistaking the dark substance on him for hair dye. However, the grim reality set in when they realized it was blood, indicating multiple stab wounds. The broken phone line revealed the perpetrator's attempt to sever communication, leaving the family without immediate help.

Notable Quote:
Tammy Michel: "And so they had cut the phone line, and they had cut the phone line to where he couldn't even call."
(Timestamp: 06:26)

Crime Scene Insights

[08:01] - [10:12]
Corporal Christopher Bordelon of the Shreveport Police Department provides critical insights into the crime scene. The living room was eerily adorned with remnants from Luther's recent 50th birthday party, suggesting the killer did not intend to steal extensively, pointing away from robbery as the primary motive. The presence of defensive injuries on Luther hinted at a violent confrontation with someone familiar.

Key Quote:
Corporal Christopher Bordelon: "The injuries sustained by Mr. Michel are consistent to someone standing over him and stabbing in a downward angle."
(Timestamp: 09:26)

Potential Suspects and Motives

[10:29] - [15:10]
Investigators swiftly turned their attention to Luther's personal relationships. Luther was separated from his second wife, Pearly Alvarez, and had a tumultuous relationship marked by alcohol-fueled conflicts. A threatening call from Luther to Tammy, mentioning Pearly wielding a knife, raised suspicions. Pearly's subsequent statements and lack of a matching fingerprint at the crime scene further complicated the investigation.

Notable Quote:
Tammy Michel: "Whoever it was either knew my dad really well, or he was ambushed."
(Timestamp: 15:10)

Evidence and Leads

[21:01] - [23:15]
Luther's car, a blue-green 1970s Oldsmobile Delta 88, was found abandoned miles away with signs of tampering, including a missing battery and a flat tire. Despite extensive searches, the keys were never recovered, suggesting the assailant had prior access or retrieved them from Luther's residence. The lack of forced entry and minimal theft pointed towards a personal vendetta rather than opportunistic crime.

Key Quote:
Corporal Christopher Bordelon: "The keys were not present with the vehicle, which is somewhat significant because the person had to get the keys from the residents in order to take this vehicle."
(Timestamp: 21:01)

Parallel Cases and Serial Killer Theories

[27:25] - [29:56]
A retired detective involved in Luther's case highlighted similarities with other unsolved murders in Shreveport, notably the case of Louis Woodrow Pleasance (Woody). Both victims were brutally stabbed in their apartments, and their cars were subsequently stolen and abandoned. These parallels fueled suspicions of a serial killer operating in the region during that period, possibly targeting individuals within the LGBTQ community.

Notable Quote:
Retired Detective: "Early case investigators had been exploring the theory that Luther may have been killed by a serial killer."
(Timestamp: 27:25)

Family's Pursuit for Justice

[31:33] - [35:26]
Tammy Michel's relentless pursuit for answers underscores the emotional toll of unresolved justice. Over three decades, she has tirelessly advocated for her father's case, navigating media interviews, public campaigns, and personal anguish. Her commitment remains unwavering, driven by the desire to see the perpetrator confronted and her father's memory honored.

Key Quote:
Tammy Michel: "I'll die talking about it. I will die talking about it."
(Timestamp: 31:33)

Current Investigative Efforts and Hope for Resolution

[33:19] - [35:39]
Despite the passage of time, there remains a glimmer of hope for Luther's family. The Shreveport Police Department, acknowledging advancements in forensic technology, has expressed willingness to re-examine existing evidence. Although challenges persist due to potential degradation of critical evidence, renewed efforts aim to bring closure to Luther's loved ones.

Notable Quote:
Corporal Christopher Bordelon: "We're gonna do everything we can to try to get you any kind of closure possible."
(Timestamp: 34:21)

Conclusion: A Call for Public Assistance

The episode concludes with an earnest plea for public assistance. Luther Meshell's case remains unsolved, but the collective memory of the community and advancements in investigative techniques offer a path forward. Listeners are encouraged to come forward with any information that might shed light on Luther's mysterious death, providing a chance to finally deliver justice to those who have long awaited it.

Call to Action:
"Anyone with information on who is responsible for the death of Luther Michelle is urged to contact the Shreveport Police Department. Call 318-673-7300 and ask for someone in Investigations."

Final Thoughts

The Deck masterfully intertwines investigative journalism with empathetic storytelling, highlighting the enduring pain of unsolved crimes and the relentless quest for truth. Luther Meshell's case serves as a poignant reminder of the complexities involved in criminal investigations and the profound impact unresolved cases have on families and communities.

For More Information:

Visit thedeckpodcast.com to learn more about Luther Meshell's case and other advocacy work undertaken by The Deck.