Episode Summary: Roger "Unkle Rog" McCall (2 of Spades, New York)

Podcast Information:

• Title: The Deck
• Host/Author: audiochuck
• Episode: Roger "Unkle Rog" McCall (2 of Spades, New York)
• Release Date: July 9, 2025

Introduction

In this poignant episode of The Deck, host audiochuck unpacks the heartbreaking case of Roger "Unkle Rog" McCall, a beloved radio personality and property co-owner from Rochester, New York. Through detailed narratives and interviews with key individuals, the episode seeks to shed light on the mysteries surrounding Roger's unsolved murder on December 12, 2003, and urges listeners to come forward with any information that might finally bring justice to Roger and his family.

The Night of the Incident

On the evening of December 12, 2003, Roger McCall was tragically gunned down in Rochester. The episode begins by setting the scene with a chilling 911 call made by Roger's son, Jason McCall. The call captures the frantic atmosphere as Jason tries to assist his father amidst gunfire and confusion.

Notable Quote:

• "I think it might be my father. I think he said Roger and it sounded like my father." — Jason McCall [05:07]

Initial Investigation Challenges

Upon arrival, first responders found Roger lying in his driveway, struggling to stay conscious. Nearby, investigators discovered a PlayStation game and Roger's own .45 caliber gun, suggesting he was prepared for protection. However, no immediate suspect or clear motive emerged, complicating the investigation.

Notable Quote:

• "He was actually, at some point during the confrontation, able to draw the weapon. He got the weapon out, but never got a shot off." — Investigator Gary Goletta [07:02]

Witness Accounts and Suspect Identification

A key witness, referred to as Kate, provided crucial information. She witnessed Roger collecting rent at her residence and later observed two men fleeing the scene in a white car, displaying suspicious behavior. Kate identified one of the men as Ori and the other as Sam, both known in the neighborhood for petty crimes but not directly linked to homicide.

Notable Quote:

• "She theorized someone that knew his routine might have attacked the victim." — Investigator Gary Goletta [11:26]

Additionally, Michael, Kate's husband, emerged as a person of interest due to his criminal background and the vague descriptions fitting Roger's shooter, but lacked a clear motive.

Notable Quote:

• "He was still on our radar just because of his criminal background." — Investigator Gary Goletta [20:19]

Investigative Hurdles

The investigation faced significant obstacles, including a heavy snowfall that erased potential footprints and the loss of ballistic evidence. Efforts with a K9 unit yielded minimal results, and initial suspects did not match all the details provided by Roger and witnesses.

Notable Quote:

• "In between the time that the incident happened and the time that first responders arrived, we experienced what's known as a burst of lake effect snow..." — Investigator Gary Goletta [08:47]

Breakthrough After Five Years

Five years post-murder, an informant named Dan stepped forward with new allegations implicating Michael in Roger's death. Dan claimed to have witnessed Michael firing the gun, aligning with previous evidence and offering a motive rooted in personal animosity. Despite Dan’s prior credibility issues, certain details in his statement provided new leads.

Notable Quote:

• "I realize I should have come forward a long time ago, but I was scared." — Dan [23:28]

Legal and Procedural Challenges

Despite Dan's testimony, law enforcement faced difficulties in building a prosecutable case due to the time elapsed and inconsistencies in witness statements. Michael maintained his innocence, and without concrete evidence, the case remained unresolved.

Notable Quote:

• "You got nothing, and he's not going to willfully talk to you." — Investigator Gary Goletta [27:03]

Community and Personal Impact

Roger McCall was not just a public figure but a pillar in his community, supporting local artists and assisting tenants. His untimely death left a void, and his family's pain underscores the ongoing need for closure and justice.

Notable Quote:

• "In a 2003 article in the Democrat Chronicle, Denise described Roger as, 'the kindest, sweetest, most generous, loving man I have ever known.'" — Ashley Flowers [28:55]

Call to Action

The Deck urges anyone with information about Roger McCall's murder to come forward, emphasizing the ongoing impact of the case on his family and community. Listeners are encouraged to contact Rochester Crime Stoppers anonymously to aid in the pursuit of justice.

Notable Quote:

• "Whether it was a robbery or something, something more personal than that. If you can provide any insight... please reach out." — Ashley Flowers [30:23]

Conclusion

This episode of The Deck masterfully intertwines personal stories with investigative details, highlighting the complexities of cold cases and the enduring quest for justice. Roger McCall's story serves as a poignant reminder of the human element behind every unsolved crime and the vital role of community involvement in solving such mysteries.

Note: For more information or to contribute to the case, visit Rochester Crime Stoppers or contact them at 585-423-9300.